Defining, distinguishing and detecting the contribution of heterogeneous methylation to cancer heterogeneity

DNA methylation heterogeneity attributable to a complex tumor immune microenvironment prompts prognostic risk in glioma

Gliomas are malignant tumours of the human nervous system with different World Health Organization (WHO) classifications, glioblastoma (GBM) with higher grade and are more malignant than lower-grade glioma (LGG). To dissect how the DNA methylation heterogeneity in gliomas is influenced by the complex cellular composition of the tumour immune microenvironment, we first compared the DNA methylation profiles of purified human immune cells and bulk glioma tissue, stratifying three tumour immune microenvironmental subtypes for GBM and LGG samples from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA). We found that more intermediate methylation sites were enriched in glioma tumour tissues, and used the Proportion of sites with Intermediate Methylation (PIM) to compare intertumoral DNA methylation heterogeneity. A larger PIM score reflected stronger DNA methylation heterogeneity. Enhanced DNA methylation heterogeneity was associated with stronger immune cell infiltration, better survival rates, and slower tumour progression in glioma patients. We then created a Cell-type-associated DNA Methylation Heterogeneity Contribution (CMHC) score to explore the impact of different immune cell types on heterogeneous CpG site (CpGct) in glioma tissues. We identified eight prognosis-related CpGct to construct a risk score: the Cell-type-associated DNA Methylation Heterogeneity Risk (CMHR) score. CMHR was positively correlated with cytotoxic T-lymphocyte infiltration (CTL), and showed better predictive performance for IDH status (AUC = 0.96) and glioma histological phenotype (AUC = 0.81). Furthermore, DNA methylation alterations of eight CpGct might be related to drug treatments of gliomas. In conclusion, we indicated that DNA methylation heterogeneity is associated with a complex tumour immune microenvironment, glioma phenotype, and patient's prognosis.

Multiplex digital profiling of DNA methylation heterogeneity for sensitive and cost-effective cancer detection in low-volume liquid biopsies

Molecular alterations in cancerous tissues exhibit intercellular genetic and epigenetic heterogeneity, complicating the performance of diagnostic assays, particularly for early cancer detection. Conventional liquid biopsy methods have limited sensitivity and/or ability to assess epigenetic heterogeneity of rare epiallelic variants cost-effectively. We report an approach, named REM-DREAMing (Ratiometric-Encoded Multiplex Discrimination of Rare EpiAlleles by Melt), which leverages a digital microfluidic platform that incorporates a ratiometric fluorescence multiplex detection scheme and precise digital high-resolution melt analysis to enable low-cost, parallelized analysis of heterogeneous methylation patterns on a molecule-by-molecule basis for the detection of cancer in liquid biopsies. We applied the platform to simultaneously assess intermolecular epigenetic heterogeneity in five methylation biomarkers for improved, blood-based screening for early-stage non-small cell lung cancer. In a cohort of 48 low-volume liquid biopsy specimens from patients with indeterminant pulmonary nodules, we show that assessment of intermolecular methylation density distributions can notably improve the performance of multigene methylation biomarker panels for the early detection of cancer.

Interlaboratory consistency of SDC2 promoter methylation detection in colorectal cancer using the post-optimized materials

Fecal DNA-based Syndecan 2 (SDC2) methylation detection is a promising non-invasive strategy for early colorectal cancer (CRC) screening. In China, commercial assays for SDC2 methylation detection vary in sensitivity and specificity, yet there is no standardized external quality assessment (EQA) to ensure accuracy. This study utilized CRISPR-Cas9 and homology-directed repair (HDR) technologies to edit the SDC2 promoter in 293T cells, creating hypermethylated and heterogeneous cell lines. These cell lines were used to develop an EQA panel for SDC2 methylation. We established a 10-sample panel, encompassing a range of methylation levels, and conducted an EQA across 140 laboratories. Among 1,400 results, 0.57% were incorrect. The optimized EQA materials effectively monitor the accuracy of SDC2 methylation detection in CRC, supporting reliable and consistent clinical testing and contributing to early CRC screening and diagnosis in China.

Radiogenomic markers enable risk stratification and inference of mutational pathway states in head and neck cancer

PURPOSE

Head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCCs) are a molecularly, histologically, and clinically heterogeneous set of tumors originating from the mucosal epithelium of the oral cavity, pharynx, and larynx. This heterogeneous nature of HNSCC is one of the main contributing factors to the lack of prognostic markers for personalized treatment. The aim of this study was to develop and identify multi-omics markers capable of improved risk stratification in this highly heterogeneous patient population.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, we approached this issue by establishing radiogenomics markers to identify high-risk individuals in a cohort of 127 HNSCC patients. Hybrid in vivo imaging and whole-exome sequencing were employed to identify quantitative imaging markers as well as genetic markers on pathway-level prognostic in HNSCC. We investigated the deductibility of the prognostic genetic markers using anatomical and metabolic imaging using positron emission tomography combined with computed tomography. Moreover, we used statistical and machine learning modeling to investigate whether a multi-omics approach can be used to derive prognostic markers for HNSCC.

RESULTS

Radiogenomic analysis revealed a significant influence of genetic pathway alterations on imaging markers. A highly prognostic radiogenomic marker based on cellular senescence was identified. Furthermore, the radiogenomic biomarkers designed in this study vastly outperformed the prognostic value of markers derived from genetics and imaging alone.

CONCLUSION

Using the identified markers, a clinically meaningful stratification of patients is possible, guiding the identification of high-risk patients and potentially aiding in the development of effective targeted therapies.

Epigenomic interplay in tumor heterogeneity: Potential of epidrugs as adjunct therapy

"Heterogeneity" in tumor mass has immense importance in cancer progression and therapy. The impact of tumor heterogeneity is an emerging field and not yet fully explored. Tumor heterogeneity is mainly considered as intra-tumor heterogeneity and inter-tumor heterogeneity based on their origin. Intra-tumor heterogeneity refers to the discrepancy within the same cancer mass while inter-tumor heterogeneity refers to the discrepancy between different patients having the same tumor type. Both of these heterogeneity types lead to variation in the histopathological as well as clinical properties of the cancer mass which drives disease resistance towards therapeutic approaches. Cancer stem cells (CSCs) act as pinnacle progenitors for heterogeneity development along with various other genetic and epigenetic parameters that are regulating this process. In recent times epigenetic factors are one of the most studied parameters that drive oxidative stress pathways essential during cancer progression. These epigenetic changes are modulated by various epidrugs and have an impact on tumor heterogeneity. The present review summarizes various aspects of epigenetic regulation in the tumor microenvironment, oxidative stress, and progression towards tumor heterogeneity that creates complications during cancer treatment. This review also explores the possible role of epidrugs in regulating tumor heterogeneity and personalized therapy against drug resistance.

Distinct Performance of Methylated SEPT9 in Upper and Lower Gastrointestinal Cancers and Combined Detection with Protein Markers

Background: The performance of methylated SEPT9 (mSEPT9) in lower gastrointestinal (GI) cancer (colorectal cancer) has been extensively investigated; however, its performance in upper GI cancer (esophageal cancer and gastric cancer) and the comparison with lower GI cancer have rarely been studied. Methods: A total of 1854 subjects, including 344 upper GI cancer patients, 459 lower GI cancer patients, and 1051 noncancer subjects, were recruited in this prospective cohort study. A modified single polymerase chain reaction test for detecting mSEPT9 was used for plasma detection. Results: The sensitivity of mSEPT9 for upper and lower GI cancers was 45.3% and 74.8%, and the corresponding specificities were 85.6% and 86.5%, with areas under curve (AUC) of 0.71 and 0.80, respectively. mSEPT9 exhibited lower sensitivity in stage I than stage II-IV cancer, while no difference in sensitivity was observed for different locations in upper or lower GI cancer. No difference in sensitivity was found among gross classifications, pathological classifications, and differentiation in upper GI cancer, but a higher sensitivity in infiltrative cancer and moderate and poorly differentiated cancers was observed in the lower GI. No difference in sensitivity was found between male and female in both cancers, while sensitivity increased with age for both cancers. Cancer antigen 724 (CA724) showed the highest sensitivity for upper GI cancers, and carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) showed the highest sensitivity for lower GI cancers. The combination of CA724 with mSEPT9 increased the sensitivity to 67.5% in upper GI cancers, and the combination of mSEPT9 with CEA increased the sensitivity to 85.4% in lower GI cancers, with an AUC of 0.90 and 0.95, respectively. Conclusions: mSEPT9 exhibited a higher sensitivity in lower GI cancers than upper GI cancers. The combination of mSEPT9 with protein markers significantly enhanced the detection sensitivity in both cancers.

Epigenetic heterogeneity in cancer

Phenotypic and functional heterogeneity is one of the hallmarks of human cancers. Tumor genotype variations among tumors within different patients are known as interpatient heterogeneity, and variability among multiple tumors of the same type arising in the same patient is referred to as intra-patient heterogeneity. Subpopulations of cancer cells with distinct phenotypic and molecular features within a tumor are called intratumor heterogeneity (ITH). Since Nowell proposed the clonal evolution of tumor cell populations in 1976, tumor heterogeneity, especially ITH, was actively studied. Research has focused on the genetic basis of cancer, particularly mutational activation of oncogenes or inactivation of tumor-suppressor genes (TSGs). The phenomenon of ITH is commonly explained by Darwinian-like clonal evolution of a single tumor. Despite the monoclonal origin of most cancers, new clones arise during tumor progression due to the continuous acquisition of mutations. It is clear that disruption of the "epigenetic machinery" plays an important role in cancer development. Aberrant epigenetic changes occur more frequently than gene mutations in human cancers. The epigenome is at the intersection of the environment and genome. Epigenetic dysregulation occurs in the earliest stage of cancer. The current trend of epigenetic therapy is to use epigenetic drugs to reverse and/or delay future resistance to cancer therapies. A majority of cancer therapies fail to achieve durable responses, which is often attributed to ITH. Epigenetic therapy may reverse drug resistance in heterogeneous cancer. Complete understanding of genetic and epigenetic heterogeneity may assist in designing combinations of targeted therapies based on molecular information extracted from individual tumors.

Multilayer microfluidic array for highly efficient sample loading and digital melt analysis of DNA methylation

Liquid biopsies contain a treasure of genetic and epigenetic biomarkers that contain information for the detection and monitoring of human disease. DNA methylation is an epigenetic modification that is critical to determining cellular phenotype and often becomes altered in many disease states. In cancer, aberrant DNA methylation contributes to carcinogenesis and can profoundly affect tumor evolution, metastatic potential, and resistance to therapeutic intervention. However, current technologies are not well-suited for quantitative assessment of DNA methylation heterogeneity, especially in challenging samples such as liquid biopsies with low DNA input and high background. We present a multilayer microfluidic device for quantitative analysis of DNA methylation by digital PCR and high resolution melt (HRM). The multilayer design facilitates high-density array digitization aimed at maximizing sample loading efficiency. The platform achieves highly parallelized digital PCR-HRM-based discrimination of rare heterogeneous DNA methylation as low as 0.0001% methylated/unmethylated molecules of a classic tumor suppressor gene, CDKN2A (p14ARF).

Digital High-Resolution Melt Platform for Rapid and Parallelized Molecule-by-Molecule Genetic Profiling

This work presents a microfluidic Digital High-Resolution Melt platform for absolute quantitation and sensitive detection of locus-specific sequence variations on a molecule-by-molecule basis. The platform provides a facile means for assessment of hundreds to thousands of single DNA copies by digitizing template molecules in a 4096 1-nL array microfluidic device and observing the sequence-dependent fluorescence changes during temperature ramping. The analytical capability of this platform is demonstrated in several applications, such as digital assay characterization, detection and assessment of DNA methylation heterogeneity, and detection of rare biomarkers at frequencies as low as 0.0005% target to background molecules.

LogLoss-BERAF: An ensemble-based machine learning model for constructing highly accurate diagnostic sets of methylation sites accounting for heterogeneity in prostate cancer

Although modern methods of whole genome DNA methylation analysis have a wide range of applications, they are not suitable for clinical diagnostics due to their high cost and complexity and due to the large amount of sample DNA required for the analysis. Therefore, it is crucial to be able to identify a relatively small number of methylation sites that provide high precision and sensitivity for the diagnosis of pathological states. We propose an algorithm for constructing limited subsamples from high-dimensional data to form diagnostic panels. We have developed a tool that utilizes different methods of selection to find an optimal, minimum necessary combination of factors using cross-entropy loss metrics (LogLoss) to identify a subset of methylation sites. We show that the algorithm can work effectively with different genome methylation patterns using ensemble-based machine learning methods. Algorithm efficiency, precision and robustness were evaluated using five genome-wide DNA methylation datasets (totaling 626 samples), and each dataset was classified into tumor and non-tumor samples. The algorithm produced an AUC of 0.97 (95% CI: 0.94-0.99, 9 sites) for prostate adenocarcinoma and an AUC of 1.0 (from 2 to 6 sites) for urothelial bladder carcinoma, two types of kidney carcinoma and colorectal carcinoma. For prostate adenocarcinoma we showed that identified differential variability methylation patterns distinguish cluster of samples with higher recurrence rate (hazard ratio for recurrence = 0.48, 95% CI: 0.05-0.92; log-rank test, p-value < 0.03). We also identified several clusters of correlated interchangeable methylation sites that can be used for the elaboration of biological interpretation of the resulting models and for further selection of the sites most suitable for designing diagnostic panels. LogLoss-BERAF is implemented as a standalone python code and open-source code is freely available from https://github.com/bioinformatics-IBCH/logloss-beraf along with the models described in this article.

Methylation Status of Transcriptional Modulatory Genes Associated with Colorectal Cancer in Northeast China

Background/Aims

Methylation status plays a causal role in carcinogenesis in targeted tissues. However, the relationship between the DNA methylation status of multiple genes in blood leukocytes and colorectal cancer (CRC) susceptibility as well as interactions between dietary factors and CRC risks are unclear.

Methods

We performed a case-control study with 466 CRC patients and 507 cancer-free controls to investigate the association among the methylation status of individual genes, multiple CpG site methylation (MCSM), multiple CpG site heterogeneous methylation and CRC susceptibility. Peripheral blood DNA methylation levels were detected by performing methylation-sensitive high-resolution melting.

Results

Total heterogeneous methylation of CA10 and WT1 conferred a significantly higher risk of CRC (adjusted odds ratio [OR_adjusted], 5.445; 95% confidence interval [CI], 3.075 to 9.643; OR_adjusted, 1.831; 95% CI, 1.100 to 3.047; respectively). Subjects with high-level MCSM (MCSM-H) status demonstrated a higher risk of CRC (OR_adjusted, 4.318; 95% CI, 1.529 to 12.197). Additionally, interactions between the high-level intake of fruit and CRH, WT1, and MCSM on CRC were statistically significant.

Conclusions

The gene methylation status of blood leukocytes may be associated with CRC risk. MCSM-H of blood leukocytes was associated with CRC, especially in younger people. Some dietary factors may affect hypermethylation status and influence susceptibility to CRC.

Facile profiling of molecular heterogeneity by microfluidic digital melt

This work presents a digital microfluidic platform called HYPER-Melt (high-density profiling and enumeration by melt) for highly parallelized copy-by-copy DNA molecular profiling. HYPER-Melt provides a facile means of detecting and assessing sequence variations of thousands of individual DNA molecules through digitization in a nanowell microchip array, allowing amplification and interrogation of individual template molecules by detecting HRM fluorescence changes due to sequence-dependent denaturation. As a model application, HYPER-Melt is used here for the detection and assessment of intermolecular heterogeneity of DNA methylation within the promoters of classical tumor suppressor genes. The capabilities of this platform are validated through serial dilutions of mixed epialleles, with demonstrated detection limits as low as 1 methylated variant in 2 million unmethylated templates (0.00005%) of a classic tumor suppressor gene, CDKN2A (p14^ARF). The clinical potential of the platform is demonstrated using a digital assay for NDRG4, a tumor suppressor gene that is commonly methylated in colorectal cancer, in liquid biopsies of healthy and colorectal cancer patients. Overall, the platform provides the depth of information, simplicity of use, and single-molecule sensitivity necessary for rapid assessment of intermolecular variation contributing to genetic and epigenetic heterogeneity for challenging applications in embryogenesis, carcinogenesis, and rare biomarker detection.

Epigenetic modifications in the embryonic and induced pluripotent stem cells

Epigenetic modifications are involved in global reprogramming of the cell transcriptome. Therefore, synchronized major shifts in the expression of many genes could be achieved through epigenetic changes. The regulation of gene expression could be implemented by different epigenetic events including histone modifications, DNA methylation and chromatin remodelling. Interestingly, it has been documented that reprogramming of somatic cells to induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells is also a typical example of epigenetic modifications. Additionally, epigenetic would determine the fates of almost all cells upon differentiation of stem cells into somatic cells. Currently, generation of iPS cells through epigenetic modifications is a routine laboratory practice. Despite all our knowledge, inconsistency in the results of reprogramming and differentiation of stem cells, highlight the need for more thorough investigation into the role of epigenetic modification in generation and maintenance of stem cells. Besides, subtle differences have been observed among different iPS cells and between iPS and ES cells. Although, a handful of detailed review regarding the status of epigenetics in stem cells has been published previously, in the current review, an abstracted and rather simplified view has been presented for those who want to gain a more general overview on this subject. However, almost all key references and ground breaking studies were included, which could be further explored to gain more in depth knowledge regarding this topic. The most dominant epigenetic changes have been presented followed by the impacts of such changes on the global gene expression. Epigenetic status in iPS and ES cells were compared. In addition to including the issues related to X-chromosome reactivation in the stem cells, we have also included loss of imprinting for some genes as a major drawback in generation of iPS cells. Finally, the overall impacts of epigenetic modifications on different aspects of stem cells has been discussed, including their use in cell therapy.

Promoter methylation of tumor-related genes as a potential biomarker using blood samples for gastric cancer detection

Gene promoter methylation has been reported in gastric cancer (GC). However, the potential applications of blood-based gene promoter methylation as a noninvasive biomarker for GC detection remain to be evaluated. Hence, we performed this analysis to determine whether promoter methylation of 11 tumor-related genes could become a promising biomarker in blood samples in GC. We found that the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor 2A (p16), E-cadherin (CDH1), runt-related transcription factor 3 (RUNX3), human mutL homolog 1 (MLH1), RAS association domain family protein 1A (RASSF1A), cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor 2B (p15), adenomatous polyposis coli (APC), Glutathione S-transferase P1 (GSTP1), TP53 dependent G2 arrest mediator candidate (Reprimo), and O6-methylguanine-DNAmethyl-transferase (MGMT) promoter methylation was notably higher in blood samples of patients with GC compared with non-tumor controls. While death-associated protein kinase (DAPK) promoter methylation was not correlated with GC. Further analyses demonstrated that RUNX3, RASSF1A and Reprimo promoter methylation had a good diagnostic capacity in blood samples of GC versus non-tumor controls (RUNX3: sensitivity = 63.2% and specificity = 97.5%, RASSF1A: sensitivity = 61.5% and specificity = 96.3%, Reprimo: sensitivity = 82.0% and specificity = 89.0%). Our findings indicate that promoter methylation of the RUNX3, RASSF1A and Reprimo genes could be powerful and potential noninvasive biomarkers for the detection and diagnosis of GC in blood samples in clinical practices, especially Reprimo gene. Further well-designed (multi-center) and prospective clinical studies with large populations are needed to confirm these findings in the future.

p53 is essential for DNA methylation homeostasis in naïve embryonic stem cells, and its loss promotes clonal heterogeneity

In this study, Tovy et al. investigated p53's contributions to epigenetic regulation and stem cell biology and showed that, in naïve mouse ESCs (mESCs), p53 restricts the expression of the de novo DNA methyltransferases Dnmt3a and Dnmt3b while up-regulating Tet1 and Tet2, which promote DNA demethylation. Their findings provide insight into a new role for p53 in maintaining DNA methylation homeostasis and clonal homogeneity in ESCs.

DNA methylation is a key regulator of embryonic stem cell (ESC) biology, dynamically changing between naïve, primed, and differentiated states. The p53 tumor suppressor is a pivotal guardian of genomic stability, but its contributions to epigenetic regulation and stem cell biology are less explored. We report that, in naïve mouse ESCs (mESCs), p53 restricts the expression of the de novo DNA methyltransferases Dnmt3a and Dnmt3b while up-regulating Tet1 and Tet2, which promote DNA demethylation. The DNA methylation imbalance in p53-deficient (p53^−/−) mESCs is the result of augmented overall DNA methylation as well as increased methylation landscape heterogeneity. In differentiating p53^−/− mESCs, elevated methylation persists, albeit more mildly. Importantly, concomitant with DNA methylation heterogeneity, p53^−/− mESCs display increased cellular heterogeneity both in the “naïve” state and upon induced differentiation. This impact of p53 loss on 5-methylcytosine (5mC) heterogeneity was also evident in human ESCs and mouse embryos in vivo. Hence, p53 helps maintain DNA methylation homeostasis and clonal homogeneity, a function that may contribute to its tumor suppressor activity.

Gene heterogeneity in metastasis of colorectal cancer to the lung

Colorectal cancer (CRC) as a heterogeneous disease, is one of the most common and serious cancers with high metastases and mortality. Lung is one of the most common sites of CRC metastases with high heterogeneity between cells, pathways, or molecules. The present review will focus on potential roles of gene heterogeneity in KRAS pathway in the development of CRC metastasis to lung and clinical therapies, which would lead to better understanding of the metastatic control and benefit to the treatment of metastases. KRAS is the central relay for pathways originating at the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) family. KRAS mutation exists in about 40% CRC, associated with higher cumulative incidence of CRC lung metastasis, and acts as an independent predictor of metastasis to lung. Mutations in KRAS can lead to poor response of patients to panitumumab, and inferior progression-free survival. However, most patients with KRAS wild-type tumors still do not respond, which indicates other mutations. Phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate 3-kinase catalytic subunit alpha (PIK3CA) mutation was associated with lung metastases in metastatic colorectal cancer. PIK3CA mutation in exon 20 was found to be correlated with patient survival in the metastatic setting after the treatment with cetuximab and chemotherapy. The heterogeneity of KRAS pathway was found in the phosphatase and tensin homologue deleted on chromosome ten loss, disheveled binding antagonist of beta catenin 2 overexpression and increased dual-specificity protein phosphatase 4 expression of CRC lung metastasis.

Systems heterogeneity: An integrative way to understand cancer heterogeneity

The concept of systems heterogeneity was firstly coined and explained in the Special Issue, as a new alternative to understand the importance and complexity of heterogeneity in cancer. Systems heterogeneity can offer a full image of heterogeneity at multi-dimensional functions and multi-omics by integrating gene or protein expression, epigenetics, sequencing, phosphorylation, transcription, pathway, or interaction. The Special Issue starts with the roles of epigenetics in the initiation and development of cancer heterogeneity through the interaction between permanent genetic mutations and dynamic epigenetic alterations. Cell heterogeneity was defined as the difference in biological function and phenotypes between cells in the same organ/tissue or in different organs, as well as various challenges, as exampled in telocytes. The single cell heterogeneity has the value of identifying diagnostic biomarkers and therapeutic targets and clinical potential of single cell systems heterogeneity in clinical oncology. A number of signaling pathways and factors contribute to the development of systems heterogeneity. Proteomic heterogeneity can change the strategy and thinking of drug discovery and development by understanding the interactions between proteins or proteins with drugs in order to optimize drug efficacy and safety. The association of cancer heterogeneity with cancer cell evolution and metastasis was also overviewed as a new alternative for diagnostic biomarkers and therapeutic targets in clinical application.