Biliary Dyskinesia: Fact or fiction?

Evaluation and Management of Biliary Dyskinesia in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review From the APSA Outcomes and Evidence-Based Committee

INTRODUCTION

The diagnosis and management of biliary dyskinesia in children and adolescents remains variable and controversial. The American Pediatric Surgical Association Outcomes and Evidence-Based Practice Committee (APSA OEBP) performed a systematic review of the literature to develop evidence-based recommendations.

METHODS

Through an iterative process, the membership of the APSA OEBP developed five a priori questions focused on diagnostic criteria, indications for cholecystectomy, short and long-term outcomes, predictors of success/benefit, and outcomes of medical management. A systematic review was conducted, and articles were selected for review following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Risk of bias was assessed using Methodologic Index for Non-Randomized Studies (MINORS) criteria. The Oxford Levels of Evidence and Grades of Recommendation were utilized.

RESULTS

The diagnostic criteria for biliary dyskinesia in children and adolescents are not clearly defined. Cholecystectomy may provide long-term partial or complete relief in some patients; however, there are no reliable predictors of symptom relief. Some patients may experience resolution of symptoms with non-operative management.

CONCLUSIONS

Pediatric biliary dyskinesia remains an ill-defined clinical entity. Pediatric-specific guidelines are necessary to better characterize the condition, guide work-up, and provide management recommendations. Prospective studies are necessary to more reliably identify patients who may benefit from cholecystectomy.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 3-4.

TYPE OF STUDY

Systematic Review of Level 3-4 Studies.

Hypokinetic Biliary Dyskinesia in a Pediatric Patient: A Case Report

The diagnosis of biliary dyskinesia (BD) in pediatric patients lacks uniformity across the literature. BD is among the most common reasons for cholecystectomy in pediatric patients. Even still, diagnostic criteria for this disorder, including symptomatology and gallbladder ejection fraction, as well as the symptomatic relief after cholecystectomy, are inconsistent across the literature for the pediatric population. We share the case of an 18-year-old female patient who presented to our clinic for cholecystectomy for a diagnosis of BD. After 10 months of seeking a diagnosis, an eventual nuclear medicine HIDA scan revealed a biliary ejection fraction of 18%, leading her to our care. The patient underwent robotic-assisted laparoscopic cholecystectomy and tolerated the procedure well, reporting a resolution of symptoms on follow-up. The diagnosis and management of BD are complicated by the combination of vague and varied symptomatology and a lack of definitive, uniform diagnostic criteria in the pediatric population. Variability in diagnostic requirements varies between sources. While some look to the interpretation of gallbladder emptying studies, others rely on surgical outcomes. To further complicate diagnosis, some patients experience symptoms that do not correlate with their gallbladder emptying studies. The controversy extends beyond diagnosis as some studies argue against cholecystectomy as a treatment for BD, as it has been shown to not always resolve symptoms. More research should be conducted to identify and establish more consistent diagnostic criteria for BD in the pediatric population, as well as to study symptomatic improvement following cholecystectomy to establish optimal treatment for these patients. Biliary dyskinesia is a relatively common but rather inconsistent diagnosis in the pediatric population, and attention should be turned toward developing uniform and consistent diagnostic criteria in order to optimally recognize, diagnose, and treat these patients, ensuring a shorter time-to-diagnosis and improved quality of life.

Biliary Dyskinesia: Current Perspectives and Future Directions

Biliary dyskinesia (BD) is a disorder characterized by functional biliary pain, the absence of gallstones on ultrasound, and the finding of a reduced gallbladder ejection fraction on a cholecystokinin-cholescintigraphic scan. Cholecystectomy remains a commonly applied treatment for BD, despite a lack of high-quality evidence supporting the practice. The following article provides an overview of the current diagnostic strategies, treatment outcomes with both surgical and nonsurgical treatment, emerging considerations related to special populations, and suggestions for addressing the identified knowledge gaps, moving forward in an effort to develop stronger, more evidence-based practice guidelines for treating this poorly understood and poorly studied condition.