Umbilical cord accidents and legal implications

Fetal movement during delivery can lead to damage to the umbilical vessels and endanger the life of the fetus

INTRODUCTION

Fetal umbilical cord hematoma has a low incidence but high mortality, and its cause during delivery is often unclear. We report an autopsy case in which it was concluded that umbilical cord hematoma resulted from fetal movements during childbirth.

CASE PRESENTATION AND AUTOPSY FINDINGS

A 27-year-old primigravida at 39 + 2 weeks gestation with normal antenatal visits suffered a fetal heart rate decrease during active labor. Bedside ultrasound revealed fetal death in utero 22 min later. Forensic pathologists found that the umbilical vessels were torn and bleeding on almost the same plane, and the hematoma compressed both umbilical arteries, which is the cause of fetal stillness in utero. A total of 32 cases were reported, including 6 umbilical cord ruptures and 26 umbilical cord hematomas. The cause of hematoma was unknown in 77 % of cases, while dysplasia was present in 56.25 % of umbilical cords.

DISCUSSION

This case indicates that fetal movements may cause umbilical cord vessel injury, particularly when oxytocin is used to induce labor. When fetal heart sounds decrease for no apparent reason, the possibility of cord injury should be considered, and cesarean delivery should be performed as soon as possible. Therefore, rigorous fetal heart tracing during active delivery is necessary.

Clinical Significance of the Large Fetal Vessel Lesions in Placental Fetal Vascular Malperfusion

Fetal vascular malperfusion (FVM) is an important pattern of placental injury. Although the significance of distal villous FVM (clusters of sclerotic and/or mineralized chorionic villi) is well documented, the clinical significance of proximal (large vessel) lesions of FVM is less clear, which is the aim of this retrospective analysis. To evaluate the clinical significance and placental associations of single and coexisting categories of lesions of large vessel FVM, 24 clinical and 44 placental phenotypes of 804 consecutive placentas with at least 1 lesion of proximal vessel FVM from the second half of pregnancy, divided according to the type or category of the individual FVM lesion (fetal vascular ectasia, fetal vascular thrombi, intramural fibrin deposition, and stem vessel obliteration): 689, 341, 286, and 267 placentas, respectively (first analysis) and single or coexisting large fetal vessel lesions (1, 2, 3, and 4 coexisting categories of lesions: 276, 321, 162, and 45 placentas, respectively) were statistically compared (analysis of variance, χ2, univariate analysis). Because of multiple comparisons, Bonferroni-corrected P < .001 was used as a threshold of statistical significance. In this population of high-risk pregnancies dominated by fetal congenital anomalies, single individual or 1 to 2 coexisting categories of lesions of the large vessel FVM, including fetal vascular thrombi, did not consistently correlate with clinical or placental variables and were not prognostically useful, but the coexistence of 3 or 4 lesions was associated with the most advanced gestational age, fetal congenital anomalies, distal villous FVM, particularly high-grade, chorangioma or chorangiomatosis, hypercoiled umbilical cord, perivascular stem edema, and marginate or vallate placenta. Therefore, the finding of multiple lesions of the large vessel FVM not only merits a diligent search for the distal villous lesions including the CD34 immunostaining, but also justifies putting the large vessel (global) FVM on the final placental diagnosis line, which in the case of up to only 2 lesions may not be justified.

Cesarean section per se is not a risk factor for non-anatomical placenta creta

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether mild forms of placenta creta (MPC) are more common in placentas delivered by cesarean section for non-anatomical indications than in placentas from vaginal deliveries.

METHODS

This is a retrospective clinical study in which MPC was diagnosed histologically by the presence of myometrial fibers in the decidua basalis or parietalis or in direct contact with the Rohr fibrinoid or chorionic villi. After excluding 111 cases at high risk for anatomical PC, placentas from 830 consecutive cesarean deliveries (group 1) were retrospectively statistically compared with 907 placentas from vaginal deliveries (group 2).

RESULTS

Statistically significant differences were found in six independent clinical and seven placental phenotypes. More frequently, pre-eclampsia, abnormal fetal heart rate tracing and umbilical artery Dopplers, hypercoiled umbilical cord, diffuse postuterine pattern of chronic hypoxic placental injury, and clusters of avascular or mineralized chorionic villi were found in group 1, while preterm delivery, induction of labor, and histological patterns related to stillbirth were observed in group 2.

CONCLUSION

MPC diagnosed in placentas from cesarean sections performed for non-anatomical indications is not statistically significantly more common than in those after vaginal delivery. Therefore, MPC may feature similar diagnostic correlations and portend a similar prognosis for future pregnancies.

CD34 immunostain increases the sensitivity of placental diagnosis of fetal vascular malperfusion in stillbirth

INTRODUCTION

Postmortem regressive placental changes of stillbirth may obscure the pre-existing placental histomorphology. The objective is to find out whether the use of CD34 immunostain can increase the sensitivity of placental examination in the diagnosis of fetal vascular malperfusion (FVM).

METHODS

Twenty six independent clinical and 46 placental variables of 46 placentas from stillbirths were statistically compared to those of 92 placentas from livebirths. One histologically most unremarkable section per case was stained using double E-cadherin/CD34 immunostain (ECCD34). Clusters of avascular/hypovascular chorionic villi on hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining system and/or CD34 immunostaining, the latter also including endothelial CD34 positive debris in the villous stroma, were regarded as evidence of FVM.

RESULTS

The gestational age and cesarean section rate were statistically significantly lower and the induction of labor and mild erythroblastosis of fetal blood was higher, but the frequencies of clinical and placental features of umbilical cord compromise were not statistically significant between stillbirths and livebirths, respectively. By using H&E stain, 9 (19.6%) of stillbirths and 30 (32.6%) of livebirths showed clusters of avascular villi on H&E. By CD34, the rates of FVM increased to 23 (50%) and 34 (40%), respectively. The increase was statistically significant for stillbirths only (Chi square = 9.4, p = 0.002). By CD34, new clusters of hypovascular chorionic villi or villi with endothelial fragmentation were found in 23 stillbirth cases (50%) as opposed to livebirths (29 cases, 31.5%)(Chi square = 9.4, p = 0.002).

DISCUSSION

When compared with H&E stain, the CD34 increases sensitivity and/or upgrades FVM in placental examination in stillbirths but not in livebirths.