The role of REM sleep without atonia in the diagnosis of REM sleep behavior disorder: past errors and new challenges

REM Sleep Behavior Disorder and Its Possible Prodromes in General Population: Prevalence, Polysomnography Findings, and Associated Factors

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the prevalence of REM sleep behavior disorder (RBD) and its possible prodromal conditions, isolated dream enactment behavior (DEB) and isolated REM without atonia (RWA), in a general population sample, and the factors associated with diagnosis and symptom frequency.

METHODS

From a population-based prospective cohort in Korea, 1,075 participants (age 60.1 ± 7.0 years; range 50-80 years; men 53.7%) completed the RBD screening questionnaire (RBDSQ), a structured telephone interview for the presence and characteristics of repeated DEB, and home polysomnography (PSG). RWA was measured on submentalis EMG, including 30-second epoch-based tonic and phasic activity as well as 3-second mini-epoch-based phasic and any EMG activities. Based on the presence of repeated DEB and any EMG activity of ≥22.3%, we categorized the participants into no RBD, isolated RWA, isolated DEB, and RBD groups.

RESULTS

RBD was diagnosed in 20 participants, isolated RWA in 133 participants, and isolated DEB in 48 participants. Sex and DEB frequency-adjusted prevalence of RBD was 1.4% (95% CI 1.0%-1.8%), isolated RWA was 12.5% (95% CI 11.3%-13.6%), and isolated DEB was 3.4% (95% CI 2.7%-4.1%). Total RBDSQ score was higher in the RBD and isolated DEB groups than in the isolated RWA and no RBD group (median 5 [interquartile range (IQR) 4-6] for RBD, median 4 [IQR 3-6] for isolated DEB, median 2 [IQR 1-3] for isolated RWA, and median 2 [IQR 1-4] for no RBD groups, p < 0.001). RBDSQ score of ≥5 had good specificity but poor positive predictive value (PPV) for RBD (specificity 84.1% and PPV 7.7%) and its prodromal conditions (specificity 85.2% and PPV 29.1%). Among the RWA parameters, any EMG activity showed the best association with the RBD and its possible prodromes (area under the curve, 0.917). Three-second mini-epoch-based EMG activity and phasic EMG activity were correlated with the frequency of DEB (standardized Jonckheere-Terpstra statistic [std. J-T static] for trend = 0.488, p < 0.001, and std. J-T static = 3.265, p = 0.001, respectively).

DISCUSSION

This study provides prevalence estimates of RBD and its possible prodromal conditions based on a structured telephone interview and RWA measurement on PSG from the general population.

REM Sleep without atonia correlates with abnormal vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials in isolated REM sleep behavior disorder

STUDY OBJECTIVES

The neurophysiological hallmark of REM sleep behavior disorder (RBD) is loss of atonia during REM sleep. Indeed, signs and symptoms of neurodegeneration can occur after years, even decades, from its beginning. This study aimed to measure neurophysiological alterations of the brainstem that potentially correlate with the severity of atonia loss, and determining whether a prodromal neurodegenerative disorder underlines this condition when it occurs as an isolated condition (iRBD).

METHODS

Subjects with iRBD and matched healthy controls were recruited. The study included the recording of one-night polysomnography, vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs), and a [123I]-FP-CIT dopamine transporter (DAT) scan. The quantification of REM sleep without atonia (RSWA) was made according to two previously published manual methods and one automated method.

RESULTS

The rate of alteration of VEMPs and VEMP score were significantly higher in iRBD patients than controls. Moreover, VEMP score was negatively correlated with the automated REM atonia index; a marginal statistical significance was also reached for the positive correlation with the visual tonic electromyographic parameter, while the other correlations, including that with DAT-scan score were not statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

Brainstem neurophysiology in iRBD can be assessed by VEMPs and their alterations may possibly indicate an early expression of the neurodegenerative process underlying this disorder at the brainstem level, which awaits future longitudinal confirmation. The correlation between RSWA and VEMP alteration might also represent a prodromal aspect anticipating the possible evolution from iRBD to neurodegeneration, whereas DAT-scan abnormalities might represent a later step in this evolution.

Abnormal behaviors during sleep from the viewpoint of sleep epileptology: current and future perspectives on diagnosis

Abnormal behaviors during sleep (ABDS) exhibit a myriad of symptoms. Their underlying diseases are also diverse, which include NREM/REM-related parasomnias, epilepsy and mental disorders. Since ABDS may severely affect a patient’s quality of life, giving an early and accurate diagnosis of the underlying disease (by analyzing video-polysomnographic data during the manifestation of ABDS) is of great importance. However, accurate diagnosis of ABDS is rather difficult. Recently it has been suggested that the pathology of (NREM/REM-related) parasomnias and epilepsy are closely related. In order to unravel the pathophysiological substrate of ABDS, it is essential to develop a novel approach based on sleep epileptology, a field which targets the interface between sleep medicine and epileptology.

Semi-automated Detection of Polysomnographic REM Sleep without Atonia (RSWA) in REM Sleep Behavioral Disorder

We aimed at evaluating semi-automatic detection and quantification of polysomnographic REM sleep without atonia (RSWA). As basic requirements, we defined lower time demand, the possibility of comparison of several evaluations and ease of examination for neurologists. We focused on well-known primary processing of surface electromyographic signals and selected recordings that were free of technical artifacts that could compromise automated signal detection. Thus we created a comprehensive method consisting of several modules (data preprocessing, signal filtration, envelopes creation, detection of ECG QRS complexes, iterative RSWA detection, detection evaluation and interactive visualization). The original dataset consisted of 7 individual polysomnography (PSG) recordings of individual human adult subjects with REM sleep behavior disorder (RBD). RSWA detection was performed with three different methods for envelope creation (envelope by moving average filter, envelope by Savitzky-Golay filtration and peaks interpolation). Best RSWA detection was achieved using the envelope by moving average filter (average precision 64.24±12.34 % and recall 91.63±10.07 %). The lowest precision was 42.86 % with 100 % recall.

REM sleep behaviour disorder

Rapid eye movement (REM) sleep behaviour disorder (RBD) is a parasomnia that is characterized by loss of muscle atonia during REM sleep (known as REM sleep without atonia, or RSWA) and abnormal behaviours occurring during REM sleep, often as dream enactments that can cause injury. RBD is categorized as either idiopathic RBD or symptomatic (also known as secondary) RBD; the latter is associated with antidepressant use or with neurological diseases, especially α-synucleinopathies (such as Parkinson disease, dementia with Lewy bodies and multiple system atrophy) but also narcolepsy type 1. A clinical history of dream enactment or complex motor behaviours together with the presence of muscle activity during REM sleep confirmed by video polysomnography are mandatory for a definite RBD diagnosis. Management involves clonazepam and/or melatonin and counselling and aims to suppress unpleasant dreams and behaviours and improve bedpartner quality of life. RSWA and RBD are now recognized as manifestations of an α-synucleinopathy; most older adults with idiopathic RBD will eventually develop an overt neurodegenerative syndrome. In the future, studies will likely evaluate neuroprotective therapies in patients with idiopathic RBD to prevent or delay α-synucleinopathy-related motor and cognitive decline.

Sleep Disorders in Neurologic Practice: A Case-based Approach

Sleep disorders are common in neurology practice, but are often undiagnosed and untreated. Specific patient cohorts, such as older adults, patients residing in nursing homes, and patients with underlying chronic neurologic and psychiatric disorders, are at particular risk. If these sleep problems are not properly evaluated and managed the patient may experience exacerbation of the underlying neurologic disorder. This article highlights some of the key sleep disorders relevant to practicing neurologists, emphasizing hypersomnolence, insomnia, and sleep-related movement disorders in the setting of neurologic disorders to enhance the tools available for evaluation, and discusses management strategies.

Sodium oxybate for idiopathic REM sleep behavior disorder: a report on two patients

BACKGROUND

REM-sleep behavior disorder (RBD) therapy is based on small to medium-sized case series, as no large controlled clinical trials have been performed. The most used and widely recognized effective drugs are clonazepam and melatonin, with anecdotal reports on the potential benefit of other drug classes.

METHODS

We report on two patients suffering from idiopathic RBD presenting with almost nightly complex and violent episodes, refractory to conventional drugs. Both patients, after informed consent, were treated off-label with sodium oxybate in add-on therapy. We followed up the patients in order to assess treatment efficacy by means of clinical interview, visual analog scales (VAS) for frequency and severity, Clinical Global Impression (CGI) improvement scale and efficacy index, video-polysomnography and at-home actigraphy.

RESULTS

Sodium oxybate intake was well tolerated and effective in reducing the number and intensity of RBD episodes; patients reported no new traumatic episodes. Results were confirmed by bed-partner reports, VAS, CGI improvement scale and efficacy index, and at-home actigraphic monitoring, the latter showing a trend of improvement in nocturnal sleep quality and reduction in motor activity, compared to the baseline. Nevertheless, video-polysomnography did not show a clear beneficial effect on sleep-related electromyographic parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

Our cases suggest that sodium oxybate can be an effective add-on option for the treatment of idiopathic RBD refractory to conventional therapies. The lack of improvement of polysomnographic parameters suggests caution in considering only polysomnographic data as endpoints in the assessment of the efficacy of therapies for RBD, and that long-term home-based assessment seems a promising tool.

REM Sleep Behavioral Events and Dreaming

STUDY OBJECTIVES

To clarify whether motor behaviors and/ or vocalizations during REM sleep, which do not yet fulfill diagnostic criteria for REM sleep behavior disorder (RBD) and were defined as REM sleep behavioral events (RBEs), correspond to dream enactments.

METHODS

13 subjects (10 patients with Parkinson disease [PD] and 3 healthy controls) originally identified with RBE in a prospective study (DeNoPa cohort) were reinvestigated 2 years later with 2 nights of video-supported polysomnography (vPSG). The first night was used for sleep parameter analysis. During the 2nd night, subjects were awakened and questioned for dream recall and dream content when purposeful motor behaviors and/or vocalizations became evident during REM sleep. REM sleep without atonia (RWA) was analyzed on chin EMG and the cutoff set at 18.2% as specific for RBD.

RESULTS

At the time of this investigation 9 of 13 subjects with previous RBE were identified with RBD based upon clinical and EMG criteria. All recalled vivid dreams, and 7 subjects were able to describe dream content in detail. Four of 13 subjects with RBE showed RWA values below cutoff values for RBD. Three of these 4 subjects recalled having non-threatening dreams, and 2 (of these 3) were able to describe these dreams in detail.

CONCLUSION

RBE with RWA below the RBD defining criteria correlate to dreaming in this selected cohort. There is evidence that RBEs are a precursor to RBD.