A Chemically Defined Feeder-free System for the Establishment and Maintenance of the Human Naive Pluripotent State

Single-cell 3D genome structure reveals distinct human pluripotent states

BACKGROUND

Pluripotent states of embryonic stem cells (ESCs) with distinct transcriptional profiles affect ESC differentiative capacity and therapeutic potential. Although single-cell RNA sequencing has revealed additional subpopulations and specific features of naive and primed human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs), the underlying mechanisms that regulate their specific transcription and that control their pluripotent states remain elusive.

RESULTS

By single-cell analysis of high-resolution, three-dimensional (3D) genomic structure, we herein demonstrate that remodeling of genomic structure is highly associated with the pluripotent states of human ESCs (hESCs). The naive pluripotent state is featured with specialized 3D genomic structures and clear chromatin compartmentalization that is distinct from the primed state. The naive pluripotent state is achieved by remodeling the active euchromatin compartment and reducing chromatin interactions at the nuclear center. This unique genomic organization is linked to enhanced chromatin accessibility on enhancers and elevated expression levels of naive pluripotent genes localized to this region. In contradistinction, the primed state exhibits intermingled genomic organization. Moreover, active euchromatin and primed pluripotent genes are distributed at the nuclear periphery, while repressive heterochromatin is densely concentrated at the nuclear center, reducing chromatin accessibility and the transcription of naive genes.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data provide insights into the chromatin structure of ESCs in their naive and primed states, and we identify specific patterns of modifications in transcription and chromatin structure that might explain the genes that are differentially expressed between naive and primed hESCs. Thus, the inversion or relocation of heterochromatin to euchromatin via compartmentalization is related to the regulation of chromatin accessibility, thereby defining pluripotent states and cellular identity.

Comprehensive assessment of mRNA isoform detection methods for long-read sequencing data

The advancement of Long-Read Sequencing (LRS) techniques has significantly increased the length of sequencing to several kilobases, thereby facilitating the identification of alternative splicing events and isoform expressions. Recently, numerous computational tools for isoform detection using long-read sequencing data have been developed. Nevertheless, there remains a deficiency in comparative studies that systemically evaluate the performance of these tools, which are implemented with different algorithms, under various simulations that encompass potential influencing factors. In this study, we conducted a benchmark analysis of thirteen methods implemented in nine tools capable of identifying isoform structures from long-read RNA-seq data. We evaluated their performances using simulated data, which represented diverse sequencing platforms generated by an in-house simulator, RNA sequins (sequencing spike-ins) data, as well as experimental data. Our findings demonstrate IsoQuant as a highly effective tool for isoform detection with LRS, with Bambu and StringTie2 also exhibiting strong performance. These results offer valuable guidance for future research on alternative splicing analysis and the ongoing improvement of tools for isoform detection using LRS data.

Resistance to Naïve and Formative Pluripotency Conversion in RSeT Human Embryonic Stem Cells

One of the most important properties of human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) is related to their primed and naïve pluripotent states. Our previous meta-analysis indicates the existence of heterogeneous pluripotent states derived from diverse naïve protocols. In this study, we have characterized a commercial medium (RSeT)-based pluripotent state under various growth conditions. Notably, RSeT hESCs can circumvent hypoxic growth conditions as required by naïve hESCs, in which some RSeT cells (e.g., H1 cells) exhibit much lower single cell plating efficiency, having altered or much retarded cell growth under both normoxia and hypoxia. Evidently, hPSCs lack many transcriptomic hallmarks of naïve and formative pluripotency (a phase between naive and primed states). Integrative transcriptome analysis suggests our primed and RSeT hESCs are close to the early stage of post-implantation embryos, similar to the previously reported primary hESCs and early hESC cultures. Moreover, RSeT hESCs did not express naïve surface markers such as CD75, SUSD2, and CD130 at a significant level. Biochemically, RSeT hESCs exhibit a differential dependency of FGF2 and co-independency of both Janus kinase (JAK) and TGFβ signaling in a cell-line-specific manner. Thus, RSeT hESCs represent a previously unrecognized pluripotent state downstream of formative pluripotency. Our data suggest that human naïve pluripotent potentials may be restricted in RSeT medium. Hence, this study provides new insights into pluripotent state transitions in vitro.

Metabolic Quadrivalency in RSeT Human Embryonic Stem Cells

One of the most important properties of human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) is related to their pluripotent states. In our recent study, we identified a previously unrecognized pluripotent state induced by RSeT medium. This state makes primed hESCs resistant to conversion to naïve pluripotent state. In this study, we have further characterized the metabolic features in these RSeT hESCs, including metabolic gene expression, metabolomic analysis, and various functional assays. The commonly reported metabolic modes include glycolysis or both glycolysis and oxidative phosphorylation (i.e., metabolic bivalency) in pluripotent stem cells. However, besides the presence of metabolic bivalency, RSeT hESCs exhibited a unique metabolome with additional fatty acid oxidation and imbalanced nucleotide metabolism. This metabolic quadrivalency is linked to hESC growth independent of oxygen tension and restricted capacity for naïve reprogramming in these cells. Thus, this study provides new insights into pluripotent state transitions and metabolic stress-associated hPSC growth in vitro.

Learning Towards Maturation of Defined Feeder-free Pluripotency Culture Systems: Lessons from Conventional Feeder-based Systems

Pluripotent stem cells (PSCs) are widely recognized as one of the most promising types of stem cells for applications in regenerative medicine, tissue engineering, disease modeling, and drug screening. This is due to their unique ability to differentiate into cells from all three germ layers and their capacity for indefinite self-renewal. Initially, PSCs were cultured using animal feeder cells, but these systems presented several limitations, particularly in terms of Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) regulations. As a result, feeder-free systems were introduced as a safer alternative. However, the precise mechanisms by which feeder cells support pluripotency are not fully understood. More importantly, it has been observed that some aspects of the need for feeder cells like the optimal density and cell type can vary depending on conditions such as the developmental stage of the PSCs, phases of the culture protocol, the method used in culture for induction of pluripotency, and intrinsic variability of PSCs. Thus, gaining a better understanding of the divergent roles and necessity of feeder cells in various conditions would lead to the development of condition-specific defined feeder-free systems that resolve the failure of current feeder-free systems in some conditions. Therefore, this review aims to explore considerable feeder-related issues that can lead to the development of condition-specific feeder-free systems.

Discordance between chromatin accessibility and transcriptional activity during the human primed-to-naïve pluripotency transition process

Naïve pluripotent state can be obtained by several strategies from various types of cells, in which the cell fate roadmap as well as key biological events involved in the journey have been described in detail. Here, we carefully explored the chromatin accessibility dynamics during the primed-to-naïve transition by adopting a dual fluorescent reporter system and the assay for transposase-accessible chromatin (ATAC)-seq. Our results revealed critical chromatin remodeling events and highlight the discordance between chromatin accessibility and transcriptional activity. We further demonstrate that the differential epigenetic modifications and transcription factor (TF) activities may play a critical role in regulating gene expression, and account for the observed variations in gene expression despite similar chromatin landscapes.

Induction and application of human naive pluripotency

Over the past few decades, many attempts have been made to capture different states of pluripotency in vitro. Naive and primed pluripotent stem cells, corresponding to the pluripotency states of pre- and post-implantation epiblasts, respectively, have been well characterized in mice and can be interconverted in vitro. Here, we summarize the recently reported strategies to generate human naive pluripotent stem cells in vitro. We discuss their applications in studies of regulatory mechanisms involved in early developmental processes, including identification of molecular features, X chromosome inactivation modeling, transposable elements regulation, metabolic characteristics, and cell fate regulation, as well as potential for extraembryonic differentiation and blastoid construction for embryogenesis modeling. We further discuss the naive pluripotency-related research, including 8C-like cell establishment and disease modeling. We also highlight limitations of current naive pluripotency studies, such as imperfect culture conditions and inadequate responsiveness to differentiation signals.

Chemical conversion of human conventional PSCs to TSCs following transient naive gene activation

In human embryos, naive pluripotent cells of the inner cell mass (ICM) generate epiblast, primitive endoderm and trophectoderm (TE) lineages, whence trophoblast cells derive. In vitro, naive pluripotent stem cells (PSCs) retain this potential and efficiently generate trophoblast stem cells (TSCs), while conventional PSCs form TSCs at low efficiency. Transient histone deacetylase and MEK inhibition combined with LIF stimulation is used to chemically reset conventional to naive PSCs. Here, we report that chemical resetting induces the expression of both naive and TSC markers and of placental imprinted genes. A modified chemical resetting protocol allows for the fast and efficient conversion of conventional PSCs into TSCs, entailing shutdown of pluripotency genes and full activation of the trophoblast master regulators, without induction of amnion markers. Chemical resetting generates a plastic intermediate state, characterised by co-expression of naive and TSC markers, after which cells steer towards one of the two fates in response to the signalling environment. The efficiency and rapidity of our system will be useful to study cell fate transitions and to generate models of placental disorders.

3D ECM-rich environment sustains the identity of naive human iPSCs

The establishment of in vitro naive human pluripotent stem cell cultures opened new perspectives for the study of early events in human development. The role of several transcription factors and signaling pathways have been characterized during maintenance of human naive pluripotency. However, little is known about the role exerted by the extracellular matrix (ECM) and its three-dimensional (3D) organization. Here, using an unbiased and integrated approach combining microfluidic cultures with transcriptional, proteomic, and secretome analyses, we found that naive, but not primed, hiPSC colonies are characterized by a self-organized ECM-rich microenvironment. Based on this, we developed a 3D culture system that supports robust long-term feeder-free self-renewal of naive hiPSCs and also allows direct and timely developmental morphogenesis simply by modulating the signaling environment. Our study opens new perspectives for future applications of naive hiPSCs to study critical stages of human development in 3D starting from a single cell.

Krüppel-like factor 5 rewires NANOG regulatory network to activate human naive pluripotency specific LTR7Ys and promote naive pluripotency

Endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) have been reported to participate in pre-implantation development of mammalian embryos. In early human embryogenesis, different ERV sub-families are activated in a highly stage-specific manner. How the specificity of ERV activation is achieved remains largely unknown. Here, we demonstrate the mechanism of how LTR7Ys, the human morula-blastocyst-specific HERVH long terminal repeats, are activated by the naive pluripotency transcription network. We find that KLF5 interacts with and rewires NANOG to bind and regulate LTR7Ys; in contrast, the primed-specific LTR7s are preferentially bound by NANOG in the absence of KLF5. The specific activation of LTR7Ys by KLF5 and NANOG in pluripotent stem cells contributes to human-specific naive pluripotency regulation. KLF5-LTR7Y axis also promotes the expression of trophectoderm genes and contributes to the expanded cell potential toward extra-embryonic lineage. Our study suggests that HERVs are activated by cell-state-specific transcription machinery and promote stage-specific transcription network and cell potency.

A Comparative Study of Cell Culture Conditions during Conversion from Primed to Naive Human Pluripotent Stem Cells

The successful reprogramming of human somatic cells into induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) represented a turning point in the stem cell research field, owing to their ability to differentiate into any cell type with fewer ethical issues than human embryonic stem cells (hESCs). In mice, PSCs are thought to exist in a naive state, the cell culture equivalent of the immature pre-implantation embryo, whereas in humans, PSCs are in a primed state, which is a more committed pluripotent state than a naive state. Recent studies have focused on capturing a similar cell stage in human cells. Given their earlier developmental stage and therefore lack of cell-of-origin epigenetic memory, these cells would be better candidates for further re-differentiation, use in disease modeling, regenerative medicine and drug discovery. In this study, we used primed hiPSCs and hESCs to evaluate the successful establishment and maintenance of a naive cell stage using three different naive-conversion media, both in the feeder and feeder-free cells conditions. In addition, we compared the directed differentiation capacity of primed and naive cells into the three germ layers and characterized these different cell stages with commonly used pluripotent and lineage-specific markers. Our results show that, in general, naive culture NHSM medium (in both feeder and feeder-free systems) confers greater hiPSCs and hESCs viability and the highest naive pluripotency markers expression. This medium also allows better cell differentiation cells toward endoderm and mesoderm.

Cell fate roadmap of human primed-to-naive transition reveals preimplantation cell lineage signatures

Human naive pluripotent stem cells offer a unique window into early embryogenesis studies. Recent studies have reported several strategies to obtain cells in the naive state. However, cell fate transitions and the underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. Here, by a dual fluorescent reporter system, we depict the cell fate dynamics from primed state toward naive pluripotency with ALPG activation followed by the activation of OCT4-distal enhancer. Integration of transcription profiles and the chromatin accessibility landscape reveals the appearance of primitive endoderm and trophectoderm signatures in the transitioning subpopulations, with the capacities for derivation of extra-embryonic endoderm and trophoblast stem cell lines, respectively. Furthermore, despite different fluorescent dynamics, all transitioning intermediates are capable of reaching the naive state with prolonged induction, showing their developmental plasticity and potential. Overall, our study describes a global cell roadmap toward naive pluripotency and provides hints for embryo modeling-related studies.

Cell fate dynamics during human naïve pluripotency establishment remain poorly understood. Here, Bi et al. depict a high-resolution cell roadmap of the primed-to-naïve pluripotency transition, providing hints for embryo modeling-related studies.

Translational and post-translational control of human naïve versus primed pluripotency

Deciphering the regulatory network for human naive and primed pluripotency is of fundamental theoretical and applicable significance. Here, by combining quantitative proteomics, phosphoproteomics, and acetylproteomics analyses, we revealed RNA processing and translation as the most differentially regulated processes between naive and primed human embryonic stem cells (hESCs). Although glycolytic primed hESCs rely predominantly on the eukaryotic initiation factor 4E (eIF4E)-mediated cap-dependent pathway for protein translation, naive hESCs with reduced mammalian target of rapamycin complex (mTORC1) activity are more tolerant to eIF4E inhibition, and their bivalent metabolism allows for translating selective mRNAs via both eIF4E-dependent and eIF4E-independent/eIF4A2-dependent pathways to form a more compact naive proteome. Globally up-regulated proteostasis and down-regulated post-translational modifications help to further refine the naive proteome that is compatible with the more rapid cycling of naive hESCs, where CDK1 plays an indispensable coordinative role. These findings may assist in better understanding the unrestricted lineage potential of naive hESCs and in further optimizing conditions for future clinical applications

•

RNA processing and translation are most different between naive and primed hESCs

•

Glycolytic primed hESCs mainly rely on eIF4E-dependent translation

•

Bivalent metabolism in naive hESCs promotes eIF4E-independent translation

•

CDK1 is required for naive pluripotency partially by activating E-cadherin signaling

Large-scale analysis of imprinting in naive human pluripotent stem cells reveals recurrent aberrations and a potential link to FGF signaling

Genomic imprinting is a parent-of-origin dependent monoallelic expression of genes. Previous studies showed that conversion of primed human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) into naive pluripotency is accompanied by genome-wide loss of methylation that includes imprinted loci. However, the extent of aberrant biallelic expression of imprinted genes is still unknown. Here, we analyze loss of imprinting (LOI) in a large cohort of both bulk and single-cell RNA sequencing samples of naive and primed hPSCs. We show that naive hPSCs exhibit high levels of non-random LOI, with bias toward paternally methylated imprinting control regions. Importantly, we show that different protocols used for the primed to naive conversion led to different extents of LOI, tightly correlated to FGF signaling. This analysis sheds light on the process of LOI occurring during the conversion to naive pluripotency and highlights the importance of these events when modeling disease and development or when utilizing the cells for therapy.

Pluripotent stem cells for the study of early human embryology

Forty years have passed since the first pluripotent stem cells (PSCs), mouse embryonic stem cells (ESCs), were established. Since then, several PSCs have been reported, including human ESCs in 1998, mouse epiblast stem cells (EpiSCs) in 2007, induced PSCs (iPSCs) in 2006 and 2007, and naïve human PSCs in 2014. Naïve PSCs are thought to correspond to pre-implantation epiblast cells, whereas conventional (or primed) human PSCs correspond to post-implantation epiblast cells. Thus, naïve and primed PSCs are classified by their developmental stages and have stage-specific characteristics, despite sharing the common feature of pluripotency. In this review, we discuss the current status of PSCs and their use to model human peri-implantation development.

Temporal activation of LRH-1 and RAR-γ in human pluripotent stem cells induces a functional naïve-like state

Naïve pluripotency can be established in human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) by manipulation of transcription factors, signaling pathways, or a combination thereof. However, differences exist in the molecular and functional properties of naïve hPSCs generated by different protocols, which include varying similarities with pre-implantation human embryos, differentiation potential, and maintenance of genomic integrity. We show here that short treatment with two chemical agonists (2a) of nuclear receptors, liver receptor homologue-1 (LRH-1) and retinoic acid receptor gamma (RAR-γ), along with 2i/LIF (2a2iL) induces naïve-like pluripotency in human cells during reprogramming of fibroblasts, conversion of pre-established hPSCs, and generation of new cell lines from blastocysts. 2a2iL-hPSCs match several defined criteria of naïve-like pluripotency and contribute to human-mouse interspecies chimeras. Activation of TGF-β signaling is instrumental for acquisition of naïve-like pluripotency by the 2a2iL induction procedure, and transient activation of TGF-β signaling substitutes for 2a to generate naïve-like hPSCs. We reason that 2a2iL-hPSCs are an easily attainable system to evaluate properties of naïve-like hPSCs and for various applications.

The combination of dibenzazepine and a DOT1L inhibitor enables a stable maintenance of human naïve-state pluripotency in non-hypoxic conditions

Conventional human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs), known for being in a primed state, are pivotal for both basic research and clinical applications since such cells produce various types of differentiated cells. Recent reports on PSCs shed light on the pluripotent hierarchy of stem cells and have promoted the exploration of new stem cell states along with their culture systems. Human naïve PSCs are expected to provide further knowledge of early developmental mechanisms and improvements for differentiation programmes in the regenerative therapy of conventionally primed PSCs. However, practical challenges exist in using naïve-state PSCs such as determining the conditions for hypoxic culture condition and showing limited stable cellular proliferation. Here, we have developed new leukemia inhibitory factor dependent PSCs by applying our previous work, the combination of dibenzazepine and a DOT1L inhibitor to achieve the stable culture of naïve-state PSCs. The potential of these cells to differentiate into all three germ layers was shown both in vitro and in vivo. Such new naïve-state PSCs formed dome-shaped colonies at a faster rate than conventional, primed-state human induced PSCs and could be maintained for an extended period in the absence of hypoxic culture conditions. We also identified relatively high expression levels of naïve cell markers. Thus, non-hypoxia treated, leukemia inhibitory factor-dependent PSCs are anticipated to have characteristics similar to those of naïve-like PSCs, and to enhance the utility value of PSCs. Such naïve PSCs may allow the molecular characterization of previously undefined naïve human PSCs, and to ultimately contribute to the use of human pluripotent stem cells in regenerative medicine and disease modelling.

Signal regulators of human naïve pluripotency

Pluripotent cells transiently develop during peri-implantation embryogenesis and have the capacity to convert into three embryonic lineages. Two typical states of pluripotency, naïve and primed, can be experimentally induced in vitro. The in vitro naïve state can be stabilized in response to environmental inductive cues via a unique transcriptional regulatory program. However, interference with various signaling pathways creates a spectrum of alternative pluripotent cells that display different functions and molecular expression patterns. Similarly, human naïve pluripotent cells can be placed into two main levels - intermediate and bona fide. Here, we discuss several culture conditions that have been used to establish naïve-associated gene regulatory networks in human pluripotent cells. We also describe different transcriptional patterns in various culture systems that are associated with these two levels of human naïve pluripotency.

Parsing the pluripotency continuum in humans and non-human primates for interspecies chimera generation

Pluripotency refers to the potential of single cells to form all cells and tissues of an organism. The observation that pluripotent stem cells can chimerize the embryos of evolutionarily distant species, albeit at very low efficiencies, could with further modifications, facilitate the production of human-animal interspecies chimeras. The generation of human-animal interspecies chimeras, if achieved, will enable practitioners to recapitulate pathologic human tissue formation in vivo and produce patient-specific organs inside livestock species. However, little is known about the nature of chimera-competent cellular states in primates. Here, I discuss recent advances in our understanding of the pluripotency continuum in humans and non-human primates (NHPs). Although undefined differences between humans and NHPs still justify the utility of studying human cells, the complementary use of NHP PS cells could also allow one to conduct pilot studies testing interspecies chimera generation strategies with reduced ethical concerns associated with human interspecies neurological chimerism. However, the availability of standardized, high-quality and validated NHP PS cell lines covering the spectrum of primate pluripotent states is lacking. Therefore, a clearer understanding of the primate pluripotency continuum will facilitate the complementary use of both human and NHP PS cells for testing interspecies organogenesis strategies, with the hope of one day enabling human organ generation inside livestock species.