Assessment of the robustness of a serendipitous zinc binding fold: mutagenesis and protein grafting

Non-native fold of the putative VPS39 zinc finger domain

Background: The multi-subunit homotypic fusion and vacuole protein sorting (HOPS) membrane-tethering complex is involved in regulating the fusion of late endosomes and autophagosomes with lysosomes in eukaryotes. The C-terminal regions of several HOPS components have been shown to be required for correct complex assembly, including the C-terminal really interesting new gene (RING) zinc finger domains of HOPS components VPS18 and VPS41. We sought to structurally characterise the putative C-terminal zinc finger domain of VPS39, which we hypothesised may be important for binding of VPS39 to cellular partners or to other HOPS components.

Methods: We recombinantly expressed, purified and solved the crystal structure of the proposed zinc-binding region of VPS39.

Results: In the structure, this region forms an anti-parallel β-hairpin that is incorporated into a homotetrameric eight-stranded β-barrel. However, the fold is stabilised by coordination of zinc ions by residues from the purification tag and an intramolecular disulphide bond between two predicted zinc ligands.

Conclusions: We solved the structure of the VPS39 C-terminal domain adopting a non-native fold. Our work highlights the risk of non-native folds when purifying small zinc-containing domains with hexahistidine tags. However, the non-native structure we observe may have implications for rational protein design.

Non-native fold of the putative VPS39 zinc finger domain

Background: The multi-subunit homotypic fusion and vacuole protein sorting (HOPS) membrane-tethering complex is involved in regulating the fusion of late endosomes and autophagosomes with lysosomes in eukaryotes. The C-terminal regions of several HOPS components have been shown to be required for correct complex assembly, including the C-terminal really interesting new gene (RING) zinc finger domains of HOPS components VPS18 and VPS41. We sought to structurally characterise the putative C-terminal zinc finger domain of VPS39, which we hypothesised may be important for binding of VPS39 to cellular partners or to other HOPS components. Methods: We recombinantly expressed, purified and solved the crystal structure of the proposed zinc-binding region of VPS39. Results: In the structure, this region forms an anti-parallel β-hairpin that is incorporated into a homotetrameric eight-stranded β-barrel. However, the fold is stabilised by coordination of zinc ions by residues from the purification tag and an intramolecular disulphide bond between two predicted zinc ligands. Conclusions: We solved the structure of the VPS39 C-terminal domain adopting a non-native fold. Our work highlights the risk of non-native folds when purifying small zinc-containing domains with hexahistidine tags. However, the non-native structure we observe may have implications for rational protein design.

Deciphering metal ion preference and primary coordination sphere robustness of a designed zinc finger with high-resolution mass spectrometry

Small zinc finger (ZnF) motifs are promising molecular scaffolds for protein design owing to their structural robustness and versatility. Moreover, their characterization provides important insights into protein folding in general. ZnF motifs usually possess an exceptional specificity and high affinity towards Zn(II) ion to drive folding. While the Zn(II) ion is canonically coordinated by two cysteine and two histidine residues, many other coordination spheres also exist in small ZnFs, all having four amino acid ligands. Here we used high-resolution mass spectrometry to study metal ion binding specificity and primary coordination sphere robustness of a designed zinc finger, named MM1. Based on the results, MM1 possesses high specificity for zinc with sub-micromolar binding affinity. Surprisingly, MM1 retains metal ion binding affinity even in the presence of selective alanine mutations of the primary zinc coordinating amino acid residues.

A strong 13C chemical shift signature provides the coordination mode of histidines in zinc-binding proteins

Zinc is the second most abundant metal ion incorporated in proteins, and is in many cases a crucial component of protein three-dimensional structures. Zinc ions are frequently coordinated by cysteine and histidine residues. Whereas cysteines bind to zinc via their unique S(γ) atom, histidines can coordinate zinc with two different coordination modes, either N(δ1) or N(ε2) is coordinating the zinc ion. The determination of this coordination mode is crucial for the accurate structure determination of a histidine-containing zinc-binding site by NMR. NMR chemical shifts contain a vast amount of information on local electronic and structural environments and surprisingly their utilization for the determination of the coordination mode of zinc-ligated histidines has been limited so far to (15)N nuclei. In the present report, we observed that the (13)C chemical shifts of aromatic carbons in zinc-ligated histidines represent a reliable signature of their coordination mode. Using a statistical analysis of (13)C chemical shifts, we show that (13)C(δ2) chemical shift is sensitive to the histidine coordination mode and that the chemical shift difference δ{(13)C(ε1)} - δ{(13)C(δ2)} provides a reference-independent marker of this coordination mode. The present approach allows the direct determination of the coordination mode of zinc-ligated histidines even with non-isotopically enriched protein samples and without any prior structural information.

Characterization of the cofactor-induced folding mechanism of a zinc-binding peptide using computationally designed mutants

Metals are the most commonly encountered protein cofactors, and they play important structural and functional roles in biology. In many cases, metal binding provides a major driving force for a polypeptide chain to fold. While there are many studies on the structure, stability, and function of metal-binding proteins, there are few studies focusing on understanding the kinetic mechanism of metal-induced folding. Herein, the Zn(2+)-induced folding kinetics of a small zinc-binding protein are studied; the CH1(1) peptide is derived from the first cysteine/histidine-rich region (CH1 domain) of the protein interaction domains of the transcriptional coregulator CREB-binding protein. Computational design is used to introduce tryptophan and histidine mutations that are structurally consistent with CH1(1); these mutants are studied using stopped-flow tryptophan fluorescence experiments. The Zn(2+)-induced CH1(1) folding kinetics are consistent with two parallel pathways, where the initial binding of Zn(2+) occurs at two sites. However, the initially formed Zn(2+)-bound complexes can proceed either directly to the folded state where zinc adopts a tetrahedral coordination or to an off-pathway misligated intermediate. While elimination of those ligands responsible for misligation simplifies the folding kinetics, it also leads to a decrease in the zinc binding constant. Therefore, these results suggest why these nonnative zinc ligands in the CH1(1) motif are conserved in several distantly related organisms and why the requirement for function can lead to kinetic frustration in folding. In addition, the loop closure rate of the CH1(1) peptide is determined based on the proposed model and temperature-dependent kinetic measurements.

Statistical validation of the root-mean-square-distance, a measure of protein structural proximity

Despite its well-documented limitations, the root-mean-square-distance (rmsd) between pairs of equivalent atoms is routinely used to monitor the degree of similarity between two optimally superposed protein three-dimensional structures. A robust method for assessing the statistical significance of the difference between two rmsd values is presented here. It is based on the comparison of two protein structures through the correlation coefficient between equivalent inter-atomic distances and the subsequent application of the Fisher transformation that allows one to estimate the probability of identity between two correlation coefficient values. The relationship between the rmsd and Fisher correlation coefficient allows then to estimate the statistical significance of the difference between two rmsd values. Such a procedure is exemplified with the analysis of the possible classifications of the immunoglobulin-like domains of filamin and is compared to related estimations of structural similarity. The possibility to estimate the probability of the difference between two rmsd values can be used to optimize the protein structural classifications and comparisons, independent of the procedure used to derive the rmsds.

Dimerization of CtIP may stabilize in vivo interactions with the Retinoblastoma-pocket domain

CtIP is a tumor suppressor that interacts with Retinoblastoma protein (Rb) to regulate the G1/S-phase transition of the cell cycle. Despite its large size (897 residues) CtIP has few known structured regions. Rather it contains several linear motifs that interact with known binding partners, including an LXCXE motif that binds the pocket domain of Rb-family proteins. This LXCXE motif lies at the C-terminus of the only known structured domain, an N-terminal coiled-coil dimerization domain (DD; residues 45-160). Yeast two-hybrid (Y2H) and GST-pulldown analyses showed that CtIP requires the LXCXE motif to bind the Rb-pocket. Although isothermal titration calorimetry data indicates that the LXCXE motif is the sole determinant of binding affinity for the Rb-pocket domain (K(A) approximately 10(6)M(-1)), Y2H data indicates that the DD is required to stabilize the interaction in vivo. Thus dimerization may increase the apparent stability of the proteins and/or the lifetime of the complexes.