Diagnostic criteria for limbal stem cell deficiency-a systematic literature review

Prevalence of limbal stem cell deficiency at an academic referral center over a two-year period

Aim

To evaluate the prevalence and clinical characteristics of limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) in the setting of a tertiary referral cornea practice at an academic center.

Patient and methods

A retrospective chart review was performed to identify all unique medical record numbers (MRNs) presenting to a single cornea specialist (JHH) at the University of Minnesota during calendar years 2019 and 2020. Records were queried and confirmed for a diagnosis of LSCD. Clinical characteristics of identified patients, including demographics, etiology of LSCD, severity of LSCD, treatment, and best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) at final follow-up, were documented.

Results

In total 1436 unique MRNs were identified over the study period. There were 61 individuals (91 eyes) diagnosed with LSCD, resulting in a prevalence of 4.25% (95% CI, 3.33-5.42). Of 91 eyes, 60 eyes were bilateral (65.9%). Among all eyes, ocular surface burns were the most common etiology (18.7%) followed by iatrogenic or medicamentosa (15.4%). There were 51 eyes (56.0%) that underwent some form of transplantation. The median BCVA at final follow-up was Snellen 20/80 (range 20/20 to no light perception).

Conclusions

The prevalence of LSCD found at a cornea subspecialty tertiary referral center in our study was much higher than previously reported prevalence rates. This may reflect referral bias and potential underdiagnosis of LSCD in practices outside of subspecialty referral centers. The high prevalence rate in our study also suggests that LSCD patients are concentrated in subspecialty referral practices, with many having high morbidity disease. This constitutes a major health burden for these practices.

Evaluating the clinical translational relevance of animal models for limbal stem cell deficiency: A systematic review

PURPOSE

Animal models are pivotal for elucidating pathophysiological mechanisms and evaluating novel therapies. This systematic review identified studies that developed or adapted animal models of limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD), assessed their reporting quality, summarized their key characteristics, and established their clinical translational relevance to human disease.

METHODS

The protocol was prospectively registered (PROSPERO CRD42020203937). Searches were conducted in PubMed, Ovid EMBASE and Web of Science in August 2020. Two authors screened citations, extracted data, assessed the reporting quality of eligible studies using the ARRIVE guidelines, and judged the clinical translational relevance of each model using a custom matrix.

RESULTS

105 studies were included. Rabbits were the most common animal species. Overall, 97% of studies recapitulated LSCD to a clinical etiology, however 62% did not provide sufficient methodological detail to enable independent reproduction of the model. Adverse events and/or exclusion of animals were infrequently (20%) reported. Approximately one-quarter of studies did not produce the intended severity of LSCD; 34% provided insufficient information to assess the fidelity of disease induction. Adjunctive diagnostic confirmation of LSCD induction was performed in 13% of studies.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first systematic review to assess the reporting quality and clinical translational relevance of animal models of LSCD. Models of LSCD have evolved over time, resulting in variable reporting of the characteristics of animals, experimental procedures and adverse events. In most studies, validation of LSCD was made using clinical tests; newer adjunctive techniques would enhance diagnostic validation. As most studies sought to evaluate novel therapies for LSCD, animal models should ideally recapitulate all features of the condition that develop in patients.

Goals and Challenges of Stem Cell-Based Therapy for Corneal Blindness Due to Limbal Deficiency

Corneal failure is a highly prevalent cause of blindness. One special cause of corneal failure occurs due to malfunction or destruction of the limbal stem cell niche, upon which the superficial cornea depends for homeostatic maintenance and wound healing. Failure of the limbal niche is referred to as limbal stem cell deficiency. As the corneal epithelial stem cell niche is easily accessible, limbal stem cell-based therapy and regenerative medicine applied to the ocular surface are among the most highly advanced forms of this novel approach to disease therapy. However, the challenges are still great, including the development of cell-based products and understanding how they work in the patient's eye. Advances are being made at the molecular, cellular, and tissue levels to alter disease processes and to reduce or eliminate blindness. Efforts must be coordinated from the most basic research to the most clinically oriented projects so that cell-based therapies can become an integrated part of the therapeutic armamentarium to fight corneal blindness. We undoubtedly are progressing along the right path because cell-based therapy for eye diseases is one of the most successful examples of global regenerative medicine.

Referral Patterns of Patients with Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency to a Specialized Tertiary Center in the United Kingdom

INTRODUCTION

Limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) is a potentially blinding disease; hence, referral to a specialist service is becoming increasingly common. Our aim was to investigate the referral patterns and associated details.

METHODS

We conducted an audit of 100 consecutive patients with LSCD who were referred to our service from 2011 to 2018. Patient demographics, geographical location, cause of LSCD, coexisting ocular diseases, best corrected visual acuity (BCVA), and extent of LSCD were recorded. The following two subgroups were further analyzed: (1) burns and (2) other causes of LSCD.

RESULTS

Out of the 100 patients (138 eyes), 70% were male, with a mean age of 45 years (SD 19). LSCD was unilateral in 62% of the cases. The most common ocular comorbidity was glaucoma, in 21 patients (33 eyes). Burns were the most frequent cause of referral (61%). The mean BCVA of the involved eye was 1.22 (SD 0.8) LogMAR, and total LSCD was present in 75 eyes (54%). There were statistically significant age, gender and eye-involved differences between the burns group and other causes group, mean 39 (SD 17) and 53 (SD 19) years (p < 0.001); 85% were men versus 48.7%, (p = 0.001); and 82% were unilateral versus 31% (p < 0.001), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

LSCD was more common in men and usually unilateral. Overall, the main cause of LSCD was burns. There were significant differences between the burns group and other causes of LSCD group in terms of age, gender and unilateral involvement that may help to guide management decisions.

High-Resolution Optical Coherence Tomography Angiography Characteristics of Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency

This study aimed to identify the anterior segment high-resolution optical coherence tomography (HR-OCT) and HR-OCT angiography (HR-OCTA) features suggestive of limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) as confirmed by both impression cytology (IC) and in vivo confocal microscopy (IVCM). This was a single-centre prospective cross-sectional study including 24 eyes of 22 patients with clinical suspicion of LSCD based on peripheral superficial corneal vascularisation and scarring. On IC and IVCM, performed and interpreted by blinded observers, 12 eyes each were diagnosed with and without LSCD. Additionally, 10 eyes of 5 healthy volunteers with no ocular pathology were also imaged. The 136 HR-OCT/A images of these 34 eyes were analysed with respect to 12 imaging parameters; the parameters most suggestive of LSCD were identified and the sensitivity and specificity were calculated. In the LSCD group, the most common aetiology was ocular chemical burns (83%), whereas in the non-LSCD group, the most common aetiology was viral keratitis (67%). Multiple logistic regression analysis revealed that mean epithelial reflectivity, mean stromal reflectivity, and mean superficial vascular density were the parameters that were diagnostic of LSCD on HR-OCT/A (p < 0.0001). A ratio of the mean epithelial reflectivity to stromal reflectivity of >1.29 corresponded with a high sensitivity (91.7%) and specificity (98.75%); while a mean superficial vascular density score of >0.38 corresponded with a sensitivity of 97.9% and specificity of 73.8%. In conclusion, HR-OCT/A as a non-invasive imaging modality could prove to be a useful tool for confirming the diagnosis of LSCD, with potential clinical and research applications.

Recent Advances in Stem Cell Therapy for Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency: A Narrative Review

Destruction of the limbus and depletion of limbal stem cells (LSCs), the adult progenitors of the corneal epithelium, leads to limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD). LSCD is a rare, progressive ocular surface disorder which results in conjunctivalisation and neovascularisation of the corneal surface. Many strategies have been used in the treatment of LSCD, the common goal of which is to regenerate a self-renewing, transparent, and uniform epithelium on the corneal surface. The development of these techniques has frequently resulted from collaboration between stem cell translational scientists and ophthalmologists. Direct transplantation of autologous or allogeneic limbal tissue from a healthy donor eye is regarded by many as the technique of choice. Expansion of harvested LSCs in vitro allows smaller biopsies to be taken from the donor eye and is considered safer and more acceptable to patients. This technique may be utilised in unilateral cases (autologous) or bilateral cases (living related donor). Recently developed, simple limbal epithelial transplant (SLET) can be performed with equally small biopsies but does not require in vitro cell culture facilities. In the case of bilateral LSCD, where autologous limbal tissue is not available, autologous oral mucosa epithelium can be expanded in vitro and transplanted to the diseased eye. Data on long-term outcomes (over 5 years of follow-up) for many of these procedures is needed, and it remains unclear how they produce a self-renewing epithelium without recreating the vital stem cell niche. Bioengineering techniques offer the ability to re-create the physical characteristics of the stem cell niche, while induced pluripotent stem cells offer an unlimited supply of autologous LSCs. In vivo confocal microscopy and anterior segment OCT will complement impression cytology in the diagnosis, staging, and follow-up of LSCD. In this review we analyse recent advances in the pathology, diagnosis, and treatment of LSCD.

Central corneal basal cell density and nerve parameters in ocular surface disease and limbal stem cell deficiency: a review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To conduct a review and meta-analysis for investigating the relative reduction of central corneal basal cell density (BCD) and nerve parameters in ocular surface disease (OSD) and limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD).

METHODS

A systematic literature search using the terms ((1) "ocular surface disease" or "ocular surface disorder"; (2) "in vivo confocal microscopy"; (3) "limbal stem cell deficiency"; (4) "basal cell density" or "corneal basal cell density" or "central corneal basal cell density"; (5) "corneal nerves" or "corneal nerve parameters" or "central corneal nerve parameters") was performed. The results are presented as weighted mean difference (WMD) with corresponding 95% CI.

RESULTS

16 studies that reported the central corneal BCD and 21 studies that reported the central corneal nerve parameters in OSD (including LSCD) were included. A significant reduction in central corneal BCD was observed in patients with various OSDs (WMD=-9.50, 95% CI -14.04 to -4.97, p<0.01) as well as in patients with LSCD (WMD=-22.14, 95% CI -37.91 to -6.37, p<0.01) compared with healthy controls, however, no significant difference in BCD was observed between the two groups (WMD=-11.61, 95% CI -15.96 to -7.26, p=0.13). There was no conclusive difference in various central corneal nerve parameters between OSDs and LSCD.

CONCLUSION

Central corneal BCD and nerve parameters are reduced in LSCD, there is a similar reduction in other OSDs.

Diagnostic criteria for limbal stem cell deficiency before surgical intervention-A systematic literature review and analysis

An accurate diagnosis of limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) is the premise of an appropriate treatment; however, there is no consensus about the diagnostic criteria for LSCD. We performed a systematic literature search of the peer-reviewed articles on PubMed, Medline, and Ovid to investigate how LSCD was diagnosed before surgical intervention. The methods used to diagnose LSCD included clinical presentation, impression cytology, and in vivo confocal microscopy. Among 131 eligible studies (4054 eyes), 26 studies (459 eyes, 11.3%) did not mention the diagnostic criteria. In the remaining 105 studies, the diagnosis of LSCD was made on the basis of clinical examination alone in 2398 eyes (62.9%), and additional diagnostic tests were used in 1047 (25.8%) eyes. Impression cytology was used in 981 eyes (24.2%), in vivo confocal microscopy was used in 29 eyes (0.7%), and both impression cytology and in vivo confocal microscopy were used in 37 eyes (0.9%). Our findings suggest that only a small portion of patients underwent a diagnostic test to confirm the diagnosis of LSCD. Treating physicians should be aware of the limitations of clinical examination in diagnosing LSCD and perform a diagnostic test whenever possible before surgical intervention.

Limbal Stem Cell Transplantation: Clinical Results, Limits, and Perspectives

Limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) is a clinical condition characterized by damage of cornea limbal stem cells, which results in an impairment of corneal epithelium turnover and in an invasion of the cornea by the conjunctival epithelium. In these patients, the conjunctivalization of the cornea is associated with visual impairment and cornea transplantation has poor prognosis for recurrence of the conjunctivalization. Current treatments of LSCD are aimed at replacing the damaged corneal stem cells in order to restore a healthy corneal epithelium. The autotransplantation of limbal tissue from the healthy, fellow eye is effective in unilateral LSCD but leads to depauperation of the stem cell reservoir. In the last decades, novel techniques such as cultivated limbal epithelial transplantation (CLET) have been proposed in order to reduce the damage of the healthy fellow eye. Clinical and experimental evidence showed that CLET is effective in inducing long-term regeneration of a healthy corneal epithelium in patients with LSCD with a success rate of 70%–80%. Current limitations for the treatment of LSCD are represented by the lack of a marker able to unequivocally identify limbal stem cells and the treatment of total, bilateral LSCD which requires other sources of stem cells for ocular surface reconstruction.

The Role of Limbal Epithelial Stem Cells in Regulating Corneal (Lymph)angiogenic Privilege and the Micromilieu of the Limbal Niche following UV Exposure

The cornea is a clear structure, void of blood, and lymphatic vessels, functioning as our window to the world. Limbal epithelial stem cells, occupying the area between avascular cornea and vascularized conjunctiva, have been implicated in tissue border maintenance, preventing conjunctivalisation and propagation of blood and lymphatic vessels into the cornea. Defects in limbal epithelial stem cells are linked to corneal neovascularisation, including lymphangiogenesis, chronic inflammation, conjunctivalisation, epithelial abnormalities including the presence of goblet cells, breaks in Bowman's membrane, persistent epithelial defects and ulceration, ocular surface squamous neoplasia, lipid keratopathy, pain, discomfort, and compromised vision. It has been postulated that pterygium is an example of focal limbal deficiency. Previous reports showing changes occurring in limbal epithelium during pterygium pathogenesis suggest that there is a link to stem cell damage. In this light, pterygium can serve as a model disease of UV-induced stem cell damage also characterised by corneal blood and lymphangiogenesis. This review focuses on the role of corneal and limbal epithelial cells and the stem cell niche in maintaining corneal avascularity and corneal immune privilege and how this may be deregulated following UV exposure. We present an overview of the PUBMED literature in the field as well as recent work from our laboratories.

An Amplifying Cascade of Contact Lens-Related End-of-Day Hyperaemia and Dryness Symptoms

End-of-day (EOD) symptoms of dryness are too often the cause of poor soft contact lens (SCL) tolerance and abandonment of wear. This review examines an amplifying cascade model for these symptoms, which involve thin tear layers on contact lens (CL) front surfaces being susceptible to evaporation-related short tear breakup (TBU) times. Susceptibility to faster tear loss by evaporation may be exacerbated by other forms of tear instability, such as lipid and mucin deficiencies as well as lens surface soiling. Bulbar and palpebral conjunctival hyperaemia and associated faster evaporation of warmer pre-conjunctival tears could also contribute to evaporative dry eye EOD symptoms. In CL wearers, a cascade of increasing hyperaemia toward the end of day, associated increasing tear temperature and evaporative loss, shortened TBU times (TBUTs) and increased osmolarity, all elevate the risk of higher symptom levels according to progressive amplification of this cascade. Chronic wound healing responses to SCL wear, perhaps related to limbal conjunctival trauma, stem cell deficiency and persistent epitheliopathy, as well as one or more immune responses, may contribute directly or indirectly to inflammation and the amplifying evaporative dryness cascade. A diurnal cycle that culminates in EOD symptoms appears to involve a process of recovery from causal mechanisms after lens removal, which allows lenses to be worn comfortably, at least initially the next day. Possible recovery processes are discussed in this review as are procedures that may help de-amplify an inflammatory, evaporative dryness cascade and alleviate EOD symptoms. Evidence of an accrual of adverse responses over long periods of more or less successful lens wear indicate an incremental failure to recover from EOD hyperaemia. Such incremental failure could help explain how SCL wear too often needs to be abandoned after many years of comfortable wear.

Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency-Demography and Underlying Causes

PURPOSE

To determine the demographic features of patients affected by limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD), and to identify the underlying causes of LSCD.

DESIGN

Retrospective, multicenter case series.

SETTING

Two large tertiary care ophthalmology hospitals.

SUBJECTS

Patients with a diagnosis of LSCD presenting from January 1, 2005 to December 31, 2014.

METHODS

Records of patients with a clinical diagnosis of LSCD were reviewed. Demographic details and clinical features at presentation, as well as the underlying cause of LSCD (if identified), were noted. Descriptive statistical analysis and chart preparation were done. Main outcome measures were type of LSCD (unilateral or bilateral), age and sex of patients, extent of LSCD (clock hours of limbus involved), and underlying cause of LSCD.

RESULTS

We found 1331 patients with LSCD in the 10-year period under study. Unilateral LSCD was more common (791 patients) than bilateral LSCD (540 patients). Out of 1331 patients, 875 (65.74%) were male. The median age of patients was 24 years. Extent of LSCD could be determined in 1849 eyes, of which 1239 eyes (67.00%) had total LSCD. The underlying cause of LSCD could be identified in 1512 eyes. In cases of unilateral LSCD, ocular surface burns was the commonest identifiable cause (83.73%). The leading identifiable causes of bilateral LSCD were ocular surface burns (29.95%), allergic conjunctivitis (29.48%), Stevens-Johnson syndrome (SJS) or toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN) (23.11%), aniridia (9.43%), and mucous membrane pemphigoid (3.54%). Lime ("chuna") injury was responsible for ocular surface burns in 352 out of 567 cases in which the agent was identified (62.08%).

CONCLUSIONS

In our study, unilateral LSCD was more common than bilateral LSCD. Young male subjects were commonly affected, with a majority of eyes suffering from total LSCD. Overall, ocular surface burns are the leading cause of LSCD. Unilateral and bilateral LSCD had a markedly different distribution of causes, necessitating different approaches to management.

Boston keratoprosthesis type 1 for limbal stem cell deficiency after severe chemical corneal injury: A systematic review

PURPOSE

To systematically review the published literature on outcomes of Boston keratoprosthesis type 1 for the treatment of limbal stem cell deficiency secondary to severe chemical corneal injury.

METHODS

Literature searches were conducted in MEDLINE (Ovid), Embase, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Central Register. The main outcome measures assessed were the proportion of eyes with best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) ≥ 20/200 and the proportion retaining their original keratoprosthesis, both at the last recorded visit.

RESULTS

We identified 9 reports in which outcomes of Boston keratoprosthesis type I implantation after severe chemical injury could be determined, encompassing a total of 106 eyes of 100 patients. There were no randomized controlled studies. The median pre-operative BCVA was hand motion. Vision improved to ≥20/200 in 99/106 (93.4%) eyes after implantation. With a mean follow-up of 24.99 ± 14 months, 68/106 (64.1%) eyes retained BCVA ≥ 20/200 at the last examination. Therefore, 68/99 (68.7%) of those who improved to > 20/200 maintained at least this acuity. The originally implanted device was retained in 88/99 (88.9%) recipients for whom retention was reported. The mean time to failure was 22.36 ± 17.2 months. Glaucomatous optic neuropathy was the most common cause for BCVA <20/200 in eyes that retained the keratoprosthesis (18/27, 66.7%)..

CONCLUSIONS

Implantation of a Boston keratoprosthesis type I in eyes with corneal blindness after severe chemical ocular injury leads to functional vision in the majority of recipients. Evidence was limited by variability in outcome reporting and an absence of controlled studies..

The diagnosis of limbal stem cell deficiency

Limbal stem cells (LSCs) maintain the normal homeostasis and wound healing of corneal epithelium. Limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) is a pathologic condition that results from the dysfunction and/or an insufficient quantity of LSCs. The diagnosis of LSCD has been made mainly based on medical history and clinical signs, which often are not specific to LSCD. Methods to stage the severity of LSCD have been lacking. With the application of newly developed ocular imaging modalities and molecular methods as diagnostic tools, standardized quantitative criteria for the staging of LSCD can be established. Because of these recent advancements, effective patient-specific therapy for different stages of LSCD may be feasible.

Keratolimbal allograft for limbal stem cell deficiency after severe corneal chemical injury: a systematic review

Purpose

To review the published literature on outcomes of keratolimbal allograft (KLAL) for the surgical treatment of limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) and corneal blindness after severe corneal chemical injury.

Methods

Literature searches were conducted in the following electronic databases: MEDLINE, EMBASE, Science Citation Index, CINAHL, LILACS and the Cochrane Library. Standard systematic review methodology was applied. The main outcome measure was the proportion of eyes with best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) ≥20/200 at last follow-up. Other measures of allograft success were also collected.

Results

We identified six reports in which KLAL outcomes in the eyes after chemical injury could be distinguished. There were no randomised controlled studies. The outcomes of KLAL in 36 eyes of 33 patients were analysed. One study with seven eyes did not specify KLAL follow-up specific to chemical injury. Median postoperative follow-up for the other 29 eyes in 26 patients was 42 months (range 6.2–114 months). In the same 29 eyes, 69% (20/29) had BCVA ≥20/200 at the last follow-up examination. Eighty-nine per cent of all eyes (32/36) underwent penetrating keratoplasty simultaneous or subsequent to KLAL.

Conclusions

The number of studies where outcomes of KLAL in eyes with severe corneal chemical injury could be discerned was limited, and variability was observed in outcome reporting. The quality of evidence to support the use of KLAL in LSCD in severe chemical corneal burns was low. Standardisation and longer follow-up are needed to better define evidence-based best practice when contemplating surgical intervention for blindness after corneal chemical injury.

PROSPERO registration number

CRD42017054733.