Xenotransplantation in immunodeficient mice to study ovarian follicular development in domestic animals

Prospective solutions to ovarian reserve damage during the ovarian tissue cryopreservation and transplantation procedure

Birth rates continue to decline as more women experience fertility issues. Assisted reproductive technologies are available for patients seeking fertility treatment, including cryopreservation techniques. Cryopreservation can be performed on gametes, embryos, or gonadal tissue and can be used for patients who desire to delay in vitro fertilization treatment. This review focuses on ovarian tissue cryopreservation, the freezing of ovarian cortex containing immature follicles. Ovarian tissue cryopreservation is the only available treatment for the restoration of ovarian function in patients who undergo gonadotoxic treatments, and its wide adoption has led to its recent designation as "no longer experimental" by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Ovarian tissue cryopreservation and subsequent transplantation can restore native endocrine function and can support the possibility of pregnancy and live birth for the patient. Importantly, there are multiple steps in the procedure that put the ovarian reserve at risk of damage. The graft is highly susceptible to ischemic reperfusion injury and mass primordial follicle growth activation, resulting in a "burnout" phenomenon. In this review, we summarize current efforts to combat the loss of primordial follicles in grafts through improvements in freeze and thaw protocols, transplantation techniques, and pharmacologic adjuvant treatments. We conducted a review of the literature, with emphasis on emergent research in the last 5 years. Regarding freeze and thaw protocols, we discuss the widely accepted slow freezing approach and newer vitrification protocols. Discussion of improved transplantation techniques includes consideration of the transplantation location of the ovarian tissue and the importance of graft sites in promoting neovascularization. Finally, we discuss pharmacologic treatments being studied to improve tissue performance postgraft. Of note, there is significant research into the efficacy of adjuvants used to reduce ischemic injury, improve neovascularization, and inhibit hyperactivation of primordial follicle growth activations. Although the "experimental" label has been removed from ovarian tissue cryopreservation and subsequent transplantation, there is a significant need for further research to better understand sources of ovarian reserve damage to improve outcomes. Future research directions are provided as we consider how to reach the most hopeful results for women globally.

Medical Grade Honey as a Promising Treatment to Improve Ovarian Tissue Transplantation

Ovarian tissue cryopreservation is a female fertility preservation technique that presents major challenges for the maintenance of follicular viability after transplantation. The aim of this study was to evaluate and compare the application of L-Mesitran Soft®, a product containing 40% medical grade honey (MGH), with other strategies to improve ovarian grafts' viability. For this purpose, bovine ovarian tissue was vitrified, warmed and randomly assigned to culture groups: (1) control, (2) MGH 0.2% in vitro, (3) MGH in vivo (direct application in the xenotransplantation), (4) vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF 50 ng/mL) and (5) vitamin D (100 Nm), during a 48 h period. A sixth group (6) of fragments was thawed on transplantation day and was not cultured. The tissue was xenotransplanted into immunodeficient (Rowett nude homozygous) ovariectomized rats. Grafts were analyzed 48 h after culture, and 7 and 28 days after transplantation. The tissue was subjected to histological and immunohistochemical analysis. Treatments using MGH showed the highest angiogenic and cell proliferation stimulation, with cellular apoptosis, within a healthy cellular turnover pathway. In conclusion, MGH should be considered as a potentially effective and less expensive strategy to improve ovarian tissue transplantation.

Hormonal Stimulation of Human Ovarian Xenografts in Mice: Studying Folliculogenesis, Activation, and Oocyte Maturation

Ovarian tissue cryopreservation and banking provides a fertility preservation option for patients who cannot undergo oocyte retrieval; it is quickly becoming a critical component of assisted reproductive technology programs across the world. While the transplantation of cryopreserved ovarian tissue has resulted in over 130 live births, the field has ample room for technological improvements. Specifically, the functional timeline of grafted tissue and each patient's probability of achieving pregnancy is largely unpredictable due to patient-to-patient variability in ovarian reserve, lack of a reliable method for quantifying follicle numbers within tissue fragments, potential risk of reintroduction of cancer cells harbored in ovarian tissues, and an inability to control follicle activation rates. This review focuses on one of the most common physiological techniques used to study human ovarian tissue transplantation, xenotransplantation of human ovarian tissue to mice and endeavors to inform future studies by discussing the elements of the xenotransplantation model, challenges unique to the use of human ovarian tissue, and novel tissue engineering techniques currently under investigation.

Effect of Exogenous Anti-Müllerian Hormone Treatment on Cryopreserved and Transplanted Mouse Ovaries

Follicle loss occurs after ovary cryopreservation and transplantation. To preserve the follicle pool of cryopreserved or grafted ovaries, anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH), which inhibits ovarian follicle recruitment, was used in a mouse model. In experiment 1, ovaries were vitrified warmed with different doses of AMH (0, 5, 15, or 45 μg/mL) supplementation. In experiment 2, AMH (0, 50, 250, and 1250 μg/mL) was injected into mice before and/or after cryopreserved ovary autotransplantation, and the recipients remained for 7 or 28 days after grafting. Ovaries were evaluated by follicle morphology, density, and apoptosis ratio. Additionally, serum follicle-stimulating hormone was measured in experiment 2. Significantly decreased follicle apoptosis were detected in AMH-treated groups when compared to the control ovaries in experiment 1, meanwhile no positive effect of exogenous AMH was found in experiment 2. Thus, we suggest AMH supplementation during ovary vitrification warming has beneficial effect on reducing follicle apoptosis.

Generation of mouse functional oocytes in rat by xeno-ectopic transplantation of primordial germ cells

Primordial germ cells (PGCs) are germ cell progenitors in the fetal genital ridge; female PGCs give rise to definitive oocytes that contribute to the next generation. Artificial PGCs have been induced in vitro from pluripotent stem cells and gonad-like tissue has been induced in vivo by cotransplantation of PGCs with PGC-free gonadal cells. To apply these technologies to human infertility treatment or conservation of rare species, PGC transplantation must be established in xenogenic animals. Here, we established a xenogeneic transplantation model by inducing ovary-like tissue from PGCs in xenogenic animals. We transplanted enzymatically dispersed PGCs with PGC-free gonadal cells under the kidney capsule of xenogenic immunodeficient animals. The transplanted cells formed ovary-like tissues under the kidney capsule. These tissues were histologically similar to the normal gonad and expressed the oocyte markers Vasa and Stella. In addition, mouse germinal vesicle-stage oocyte-like cells collected from ovary-like tissue in rats matured to metaphase II via in vitro maturation and gave rise to offspring by intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Our studies show that rat/mouse female PGCs and PGC-free gonadal cells can develop and reconstruct ovary-like tissue containing functional oocytes in an ectopic xenogenic microenvironment.

Perspectives of germ cell development in vitro in mammals

Pluripotent stem cells, such as embryonic stem cells (ESCs) and induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) are able to differentiate into all cell lineages of the embryo proper, including germ cells. This pluripotent property has a huge impact on the fields of regenerative medicine, developmental biology and reproductive engineering. Establishing the germ cell lineage from ESCs/iPSCs is the key biological subject, since it would contribute not only to dissection of the biological processes of germ cell development but also to production of unlimited numbers of functional gametes in vitro. Toward this goal, we recently established a culture system that induces functional mouse primordial germ cells (PGCs), precursors of all germ cells, from mouse ESCs/iPSCs. The successful in vitro production of PGCs arose from the study of pluripotent cell state, the signals inducing PGCs and the technology of transplantation. However, there are many obstacles to be overcome for the robust generation of mature gametes or for application of the culture system to other species, including humans and livestock. In this review, we discuss the requirements for a culture system to generate the germ cell lineage from ESCs/iPSCs.

Follicle activation and 'burn-out' contribute to post-transplantation follicle loss in ovarian tissue grafts: the effect of graft thickness

STUDY QUESTION

What are the effects of thin ovarian grafts compared with grafts of the standard thickness on follicle loss post-transplantation?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Transplantation of reduced-thickness ovarian grafts led to intense activation and 'burn-out' a short time after transplantation resulting in significant folllicle loss.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Transplantation of fresh and frozen-thawed ovarian tissue has been proved successful, but techniques vary and are not optimised, often resulting in significant follicular loss. Follicle loss is mostly related to the freezing-thawing process and to post-transplantation hypoxia.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

Bovine ovarian tissue strips (n = 55) were prepared in two groups of conventional-thickness strips (1-2 mm) or thin strips (0.5-0.9 mm). Fresh or frozen-thawed samples were xenotransplanted into sterilized immune-deficient mice (n = 49). Non-transplanted conventional size fresh samples were used as controls (n = 6). Grafts from all study groups were recovered after 7 days for analysis.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Morphometric differential counting of follicle classes was performed by two observers. Immunohistochemistry was conducted for proliferation (Ki67), cortical fibrosis (Masson tri-chrome) and blood-vessel density (CD31). Results were expressed as the mean number of dormant or growing follicle (GF) type per section or total follicle counts per graft. Blood-vessel density was calculated per mm(2). P-values <0.05 were considered statistically significant.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

The loss of all follicle types, and most noteably of primordial follicles (PMFs), was observed 7 days post-transplantation (P < 0.05). The relatively high number of GFs and the positive Ki67 staining in all recovered grafts indicated that follicle activation was depleting the resting follicle pool. The reduced graft thickness had an adverse effect on the number of recovered follicles, especially on the resting non-GFs in the fresh, and more so in the frozen-thawed, samples (P < 0.05). Extensive stromal fibrosis and high blood-vessel density were observed in all grafts with no advantage in the thin prepared grafts.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

This study used only one species of ovaries (bovine) for xenotransplantation. The immediate post-transplantation events were not visualized directly nor were the molecules involved in follicle activation studied.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

Follicle activation and 'burn-out' appear to be important in follicle loss after transplantation. Reducing graft thickness in an attempt to improve freezing conditions and reduce post-transplantation ischemia has adverse effects on the graft follicle pool due to increased activation and loss. Agents which prevent 'burn-out' will potentially improve follicle pool survival.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This study was funded by research grants from the Israeli Science Foundation (No. 1675/10), the Israeli Jack Craps foundation and the Israel Cancer Research Fund (ICRF No. 12-3081). The authors have no competing interest to declare.

FSH prevents depletion of the resting follicle pool by promoting follicular number and morphology in fresh and cryopreserved primate ovarian tissues following xenografting

BACKGROUND

Cryopreservation and transplantation of ovarian tissue is one option for re-establishing ovarian function, but optimal conditions for graft sustainment and follicular survival are still considered experimental. The present study aims to analyze the effect of FSH treatment on the resting follicle pool in fresh and cryopreserved primate ovarian tissues following xenografting.

METHODS

Ovarian tissues from adult marmosets were grafted freshly or following cryopreservation to ovarectomized nude mice treated with FSH 25 IU twice daily post transplantation or left untreated as controls. Grafts were retrieved 2 or 4 weeks after transplantation to evaluate the number and morphological appearance of follicles.

RESULTS

Early start of FSH treatment within 1 week following transplantation partly prevents primordial follicle loss in fresh and frozen-thawed tissues, whereas after a 3 weeks time interval this effect is present only in fresh tissues. A similar positive effect of early, but not later FSH treatment on primary follicles is seen in fresh tissues compared to only marginal effects in frozen-thawed tissues. The percentage of morphologically normal follicles is generally increased in FSH treated tissues, whereas the percentage of primary follicles over all primordial and primary follicles is increased by FSH only in freshly-grafted tissues.

CONCLUSIONS

FSH treatment alleviates depletion of the resting follicle pool and promotes normal follicular morphology both in freshly and frozen-thawed grafted tissues. In previously cryopreserved tissues, applying to most of the tissues intended for clinical use in fertility preservation attempts, its positive effect on primordial follicle numbers and potential graft sustainment is dependent on an early start of treatment within one week of transplantation.

Safety of ovarian tissue autotransplantation for cancer patients

Cancer treatments can induce premature ovarian failure in almost half of young women suffering from invasive neoplasia. Cryopreservation of ovarian cortex and subsequent autotransplantation of frozen-thawed tissue have emerged as promising alternatives to conventional fertility preservation technologies. However, human ovarian tissue is generally harvested before the administration of gonadotoxic treatment and could be contaminated with malignant cells. The safety of autotransplantation of ovarian cortex remains a major concern for fertility preservation units worldwide. This paper discusses the main tools for detecting disseminated cancer cells currently available, their limitations, and clinical relevance.

Effect of graft site and gonadotrophin treatment on follicular development of canine ovarian grafts transplanted to NOD-SCID mice

PURPOSE

To investigate the effect of graft site and gonadotrophins administration on the number and survival rate of follicles of canine ovarian grafts transplanted to NOD-severe combined immune deficiency (SCID) mice.

METHODS

Fresh ovarian cortex slices obtained from immature bitches were grafted subcutaneously (SC), under kidney capsule (KC) or into ovarian bursa (OB) in NOD-SCID mice. Two months after surgery, the mice allocated into non-treated and treated gonadotrophins groups that injected with porcine follicle stimulating hormone during 7 days and human chorionic gonadotrophin 48 h later. Ovarian grafts were collected after 10 h of last injection and processed for histology.

RESULTS

The number of transitional and preantral follicles under KC and into OB was significantly higher in gonadotrophins-treated mice than those who received saline. Furthermore, the survival rates of primary, transitional and preantral follicles under KC and into OB grafts were significantly higher than those placed SC in the treated gonadotrophins group, and in the non-treated gonadotrophins group; the proportion of primary and preantral follicle survival was significantly higher under KC and into OB than SC grafts.

CONCLUSIONS

In canine ovarian xenografting, administration of gonadotrophin could be effective for improvement of survival of transplanted ovary. Furthermore, the grafting into OB appeared to be better than grafting under KC, which in turn is better than SC.

Assessment of canine ovaries autografted to various body sites

The influence of graft site on the survival of canine follicles and oocytes after autografting was investigated. Hemi-ovaries were autografted to three locations (quadriceps femoris muscle fascia, kidney capsule, and gastrosplenic ligament), and grafted ovaries were recovered (under anesthesia) 28 to 31 d after transplantation. The grafted hemi-ovaries were bisected: one-quarter ovary was used for histological assessment and another quarter for evaluation of oocyte viability. As controls, the remaining fresh hemi-ovaries were used to assess the viability of follicles and oocytes in non-transplanted ovaries. Most follicles in the histological sections of the grafts were classified as primordial or primary follicles. Antral follicles were not observed in the grafts, irrespective of the graft site. The percentages of viable follicles in the sections from control ovaries, and the ovaries grafted to the kidney capsule, the quadriceps femoris muscle fascia, and the gastrosplenic ligament were 17.4, 22.9, 18.3, and 32.4%, respectively. A total of 12 oocytes was recovered from the 15 hemi-ovaries grafted in five bitches, of which five (41.7%) oocytes from the ovaries grafted to the quadriceps femoris muscle fascia and the kidney capsule were cultured for assessment of meiotic competence. Three oocytes were viable but remained in the germinal vesicle stage after 72 h of maturation culture. The quadriceps femoris muscle fascia might be useful for grafting like the kidney capsule, but improvement of follicle survival and meiotic competence of oocytes in the grafts is necessary.

In vitro growth and steroidogenesis of dog follicles are influenced by the physical and hormonal microenvironment

The present study examined the influences of the physical and hormonal microenvironment on in vitro growth and steroidogenesis of dog follicles. Follicles were enzymatically isolated and individually encapsulated in 0.5% (w/v; n=17) or 1.5% (n=10) alginate and cultured with 0.5 IU/ml equine chorionic gonadotropin for 192 h. In a separate experiment, follicles were encapsulated in 0.5% alginate and cultured with 0 (n=22), 1 (n=23), 10 (n=20) or 100 (n=21) μg/ml FSH for 240 h. Follicle diameter and steroid production were assessed every 48 h in both studies. Follicles encapsulated in the 0.5% alginate grew faster (P<0.05) than those cultured in the 1.5% concentration. Oestradiol (E(2)) and progesterone (P(4)) increased consistently (P<0.05) over time, and follicles in the 1.5% alginate produced more (P<0.05) P(4) than those in the 0.5% solution. Follicles cultured in the highest FSH concentration (100 μg/ml) increased 100% in size after 240 h compared with 50 to 70% in lower dosages. E(2) concentration remained unchanged over time (P>0.05) across FSH dosages. However, P(4) increased (P<0.05) as culture progressed and with increasing FSH concentration. Results demonstrate that dog follicles cultured in alginate retain structural integrity, grow in size and are hormonally active. Lower alginate and increasing FSH concentrations promote in vitro follicle growth. However, the absence of an E(2) rise in follicles cultured in FSH alone suggests the need for LH supplementation to support theca cell differentiation and granulosa cell function.