Biological mechanisms implicated in adverse outcomes of sex mismatched transfusions

Estimated median density identifies donor age and sex differences in red blood cell biological age

BACKGROUND

Donors possess heterogeneous red cell concentrates (RCCs) in terms of the biological age of their red blood cells (RBCs) as a direct result of various donor-dependent factors influencing rates of erythropoiesis. This study aimed to estimate the median biological age of RBCs in RCCs based on donor age and sex to investigate inherent differences in blood products' biological ages over hypothermic storage using estimated median densities (EMDs).

STUDY DESIGN

Sixty RCCs were collected from four donor groups; male and female teenagers (17-19 years old) and seniors (75+ years old). A Percoll density-based separation approach was used to quantify the EMDs indicative of biological age. EMD and mean corpuscular hemoglobin (MCHC) were compared by correlation analyses.

RESULTS

Differences in the median biological age of RCC units were observed with male donors having significantly higher EMDs compared to females (p < .001). Teen male donors possessed the highest EMDs with significantly elevated levels of biologically aged RBCs compared to both female donor groups, regardless of storage duration (p < .05). Throughout most of the 42-day storage period, senior donors, particularly senior females, demonstrated the strongest correlation between EMD and MCHC (R2 > 0.5).

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides further evidence that there are inherent differences between the biological age profiles of RBCs between blood donors of different sex and age. Our findings further highlight that biological age may contribute to RBC quality during storage and that donor characteristics need to be considered when evaluating transfusion safety and efficacy.

Towards the crux of sex-dependent variability in red cell concentrates

Donor sex can alter the RBC 'storage lesion' progression, contributing to dissimilarities in blood product quality, and thus adverse post-transfusion reactions. The mechanisms underlying the reduced sensitivity of female RBCs to storage-induced stress are partially ascribed to the differential effects of testosterone, progesterone, and estrogen on hemolytic propensity. Contributing to this is the increased proportion of more robust, biologically 'young' subpopulations of RBCs in females. Herein, we discuss the impact of sex hormones on RBCs and the relevance of these biological subpopulations to provide further insight into sex-dependent blood product variability.

The impact of biological age of red blood cell on in vitro endothelial activation markers

Introduction: Blood donor characteristics influence red blood cell transfusion outcomes. As donor sex affects the distribution of young to old RBCs in the circulation, we hypothesized that the amount of circulating young RBCs in the blood product are associated with immune suppression.

Materials and Methods: Blood samples were collected from healthy volunteers and density fractionated into young and old subpopulations. In an activated endothelial cell model, RBC adhesion to endothelium and secretion of endothelial activation markers were assessed. The impact of RBC biological age was also assessed in a T cell proliferation assay and in a whole blood stimulation assay.

Results: After Percoll fractionation, young RBCs contained more reticulocytes compared to old RBCs. Young RBCs associated with lower levels of E-selectin, ICAM-1, and vWF from activated endothelial cells compared to old RBCs. RBC subpopulations did not affect T cell proliferation or cytokine responses following whole blood stimulation.

Conclusion: Young RBCs contain more reticulocytes which are associated with lower levels of endothelial activation markers compared to old RBCs.

Donor sex, pre-donation hemoglobin, and manufacturing affect CD71+ cells in red cell concentrates

BACKGROUND

Circulating CD71⁺ red blood cells (RBCs) have been reported to play an immunomodulatory role in vivo, which may contribute to adverse donor-recipient sex-mismatched transfusion outcomes. However, it is not clear how CD71⁺ RBC quantity in red cell concentrates (RCCs) is affected by manufacturing methods and donor factors such as donor sex, donor age, pre-donation hemoglobin (Hb), venous Hb (Hb_v ) levels, and donation frequency.

METHODS

We determined CD71⁺ RBCs and Hb levels in whole blood (WB) from healthy donors (42 male/38 female). Using small-scale red cell filtration (RCF) and whole blood filtration (WBF) methods, leukoreduced RCCs were processed from WB samples (n = 6) and the CD71⁺ RBCs were determined at days 1, 7, and 28. We examined uni- and multivariate associations among CD71⁺ RBCs, donor factors, and manufacturing method.

RESULTS

Male donors had a higher CD71⁺ RBC concentration than females (p < .001), especially male donors aged 17-50 years with 1 or 2 WB donations over the previous 12 months. Donors with a Hb_v above 155 g/L had a higher CD71⁺ RBC concentration than an Hb_v level below 140 g/L (p < .05). There was a positive correlation between pre-donation Hb and CD71⁺ RBC concentration (Pearson r = 0.41). WBF RCCs had a higher total number of CD71⁺ RBCs than RCF-produced RCCs on day 1 (p < .05).

DISCUSSION

RCCs have variable numbers of CD71⁺ RBCs. This makes understanding the impact of donor factors and manufacturing methods on the immunomodulatory effect of CD71⁺ RBCs critical in exploring donor-recipient sex-mismatched transfusions.

Red Blood Cell Donor Sex Associated Effects on Morbidity and Mortality in the Extremely Preterm Newborn

Transfusion exposure increases the risk of death in critically ill patients of all ages. This was thought to relate to co-morbidities in the transfusion recipient. However, donor characteristics are increasingly recognised as critical to transfusion recipient outcome with systematic reviews suggesting blood donor sex influences transfusion recipient health. Originally focusing on plasma and platelet transfusions, retrospective studies report greater risks of adverse outcomes such as transfusion related acute lung injury in those receiving products from female donors. There is increasing awareness that exposure to red blood cells (RBCs) poses a similar risk. Recent studies focusing on transfusion related outcomes in extremely preterm newborns report conflicting data on the association between blood donor sex and outcomes. Despite a renewed focus on lower versus higher transfusion thresholds in neonatal clinical practice, this group remain a heavily transfused population, receiving on average 3-5 RBC transfusions during their primary hospital admission. Therefore, evidence supporting a role for better donor selection could have a significant impact on clinical outcomes in this high-risk population. Here, we review the emerging evidence for an association between blood donor sex and clinical outcomes in extremely preterm newborns receiving one or more transfusions.

The Effect of Sex-Mismatched Red Blood Cell Transfusion on Endothelial Cell Activation in Critically Ill Patients

BACKGROUND

Observational studies suggest that sex-mismatched transfusion is associated with increased mortality. Mechanisms driving mortality are not known but may include endothelial activation. The aim of this study is to investigate the effects of sex-mismatched red blood cell (RBC) transfusions on endothelial cell activation markers in critically ill patients.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

In patients admitted to the intensive care unit who received a single RBC unit, blood samples were drawn before (T0), 1 h after (T1), and 24 h after transfusion (T24) for analysis of soluble syndecan-1, soluble intercellular adhesion molecule-1, soluble thrombomodulin (sTM), von Willebrand factor antigen, interleukin-6 (IL-6), and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFα). Changes in the levels of these factors were compared between sex-matched and sex-mismatched groups.

RESULTS

Of 69 included patients, 32 patients were in the sex-matched and 37 patients were in the sex-mismatched group. Compared to baseline, sex-matched transfusion was associated with significant reduction in sTM level (p value = 0.03). Between-group comparison showed that levels of syndecan-1 and sTM were significantly higher in the sex-mismatched group compared to the sex-matched group at T24 (p value = 0.04 and 0.01, respectively). Also, TNFα and IL-6 levels showed a statistically marginal significant increase compared to baseline in the sex-mismatched group at T24 (p value = 0.06 and 0.05, respectively), but not in the sex-matched group.

DISCUSSION

Transfusion of a single sex-mismatched RBC unit was associated with higher syndecan-1 and sTM levels compared to transfusion of sex-matched RBC unit. These findings may suggest that sex-mismatched RBC transfusion is associated with endothelial activation.

Donor-recipient sex is associated with transfusion-related outcomes in critically ill patients

Transfusion of female RBCs to male recipients increases the risk of ICU mortality compared with female blood to female recipients.

Receiving RBCs from female donors is associated with a trend toward ARDS.

Transfusion of red blood cells (RBCs) from female donors has been associated with increased risk of mortality. This study aims to investigate the associations between donor-recipient sex and posttransfusion mortality and morbidity in critically ill patients who received RBC transfusions from either male-only donors or from female-only donors (unisex-transfusion cases). Survival analysis was used to compare 4 groups: female-to-female, female-to-male, male-to-female, and male-to-male transfusion. Multivariate logistic model was used to evaluate the association between donor sex and intensive care unit (ICU) mortality. Associations between transfusion and acute kidney injury (AKI), acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), and nosocomial infections were assessed. Of the 6992 patients included in the original cohort study, 403 patients received unisex-transfusion. Survival analysis and the logistic model showed that transfusion of female RBCs to male patients was associated with an increased ICU mortality compared with transfusion of female RBCs to female patients (odds ratio, 2.43; 95% confidence interval, 1.02-5.77; P < .05). There was a trend toward increased ARDS in patients receiving RBC from female donors compared with those receiving blood from males (P = .06), whereas AKI was higher in donor-recipient sex-matched transfusion groups compared with sex-mismatched groups (P = .05). This was an exploratory study with potential uncontrolled confounders that limits broad generalization of the findings. Results warrant further studies investigating biological mechanisms underlying the association between donor sex with adverse outcomes as well as studies on the benefit of matching of blood between donor and recipient.

Storage of red blood cell concentrates: Clinical impact

The storage of red blood cells for transfusion purposes induces modifications of biochemical and biological properties. Moreover, these modifications are modulated by the donors' characteristics and the cell processing. These ex vivo alterations were suspected to decrease the transfusion efficiency and even to induce adverse events. This short article will review the red blood cells storage lesions and the clinical data related to them. In particular, the questions regarding the donors and recipients sex will be discussed.

Sex- and Gender-Related Factors in Blood Product Transfusions

Blood products are indicated for a plethora of conditions in several settings, with a variety of products available for transfusion, from highly processed specific components to whole blood. Matching the donor product to the recipient is crucial in avoiding serious transfusion reactions, with the extent of matching depending on the physiological need, setting, and product. There are important factors related to sex and gender differences in donated blood products, adverse reactions to those products, interplay with underlying pathology, as well as sociocultural differences in the collection. This article will review key sex- and gender-specific research related to the use of blood products with an emphasis on the acute care setting.

Donor-dependent aging of young and old red blood cell subpopulations: Metabolic and functional heterogeneity

BACKGROUND

Characteristics of red blood cells (RBCs) are influenced by donor variability. This study assessed quality and metabolomic variables of RBC subpopulations of varied biologic age in red blood cell concentrates (RCCs) from male and female donors to evaluate their contribution to the storage lesion.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Red blood cell concentrates from healthy male (n = 6) and female (n = 4) donors were Percoll separated into less dense ("young", Y-RCCs) and dense ("old", O-RCCs) subpopulations, which were assessed weekly for 28 days for changes in hemolysis, mean cell volume (MCV), hemoglobin concentration (MCHC), hemoglobin autofluorescence (HGB), morphology index (MI), oxygen affinity (p50), rigidity, intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS), calcium ([Ca²⁺ ]), and mass spectrometry-based metabolomics.

RESULTS

Young RCCs having disc-to-discoid morphology showed higher MCV and MI, but lower MCHC, HGB, and rigidity than O-RCCs, having discoid-to-spheroid shape. By Day 14, Y-RCCs retained lower hemolysis and rigidity and higher p50 compared to O-RCCs. Donor sex analyses indicated that females had higher MCV, HGB, ROS, and [Ca²⁺ ] and lower hemolysis than male RBCs, in addition to having a decreased rate of change in hemolysis by Day 28. Metabolic profiling indicated a significant sex-related signature across all groups with increased markers of high membrane lipid remodeling and antioxidant capacity in Y-RCCs, whereas O-RCCs had increased markers of oxidative stress and decreased coping capability.

CONCLUSION

The structural, functional, and metabolic dissimilarities of Y-RCCs and O-RCCs from female and male donors demonstrate RCC heterogeneity, where RBCs from females contribute less to the storage lesion and age slower than males.