Phosphosulindac is efficacious in an improved concanavalin A-based rabbit model of chronic dry eye disease

Animal Models in Eye Research: Focus on Corneal Pathologies

The eye is a complex sensory organ that enables visual perception of the world. The dysfunction of any of these tissues can impair vision. Conduction studies on laboratory animals are essential to ensure the safety of therapeutic products directly applied or injected into the eye to treat ocular diseases before eventually proceeding to clinical trials. Among these tissues, the cornea has unique homeostatic and regenerative mechanisms for maintaining transparency and refraction of external light, which are essential for vision. However, being the outermost tissue of the eye and directly exposed to the external environment, the cornea is particularly susceptible to injury and diseases. This review highlights the evidence for selecting appropriate animals to better understand and treat corneal diseases, which rank as the fifth leading cause of blindness worldwide. The development of reliable and human-relevant animal models is, therefore, a valuable research tool for understanding and translating fundamental mechanistic findings, as well as for assessing therapeutic potential in humans. First, this review emphasizes the unique characteristics of animal models used in ocular research. Subsequently, it discusses current animal models associated with human corneal pathologies, their utility in understanding ocular disease mechanisms, and their role as translational models for patients.

Evaluating the Efficacy of Polyglycolic Acid-Loading Tetrandrine Nanoparticles in the Treatment of Dry Eye

INTRODUCTION

Dry eye disease (DED) is a multifactor-induced disease accompanied by increased osmolarity of the tear film and inflammation of the ocular surface. Traditional anti-inflammation agent corticosteroids applied in DED treatment could result in high intraocular pressure, especially in long-term treatment. Therefore, we explored a nano drug that aimed to block the formation pathway of DED which had anti-inflammatory, sustained release, and good biocompatibility characteristics in this study.

METHODS

We prepared a novel nanomedicine (Tet-ATS@PLGA) by the thin film dispersion-hydration ultrasonic method and detected its nanostructure, particle size, and zeta potential. Flow cytometry was used to detect the cell survival rate of each group after 24 h of drug treatment on inflammed Statens Seruminstitut Rabbit Corneal (SIRC) cells. Observed and recorded corneal epithelial staining, tear film rupture time, and Schirmer test to detect tear secretion on the ocular surface of rabbits. The corneal epithelial thickness, morphology, and number of bulbar conjunctival goblet cells were recorded by H&E staining. Finally, we detected the expression of VEGF, IL-1β, PGE2, and TNF-α by cellular immunofluorescence staining and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA).

RESULTS

The encapsulation efficiency and drug loading of Tet-ATS@PLGA were 79.85% and 32.47%, respectively. At eye surface temperature, Tet can easily release from Tet-ATS@PLGA while that it was difficult to release at storage temperature and room temperature. After 2 weeks medication, Tet-ATS@PLGA can effectively improve the tear film rupture time and tear secretion time in a DED model (p <0.05). Compared with the normal group (62.34 ± 4.86 mm), the thickness of corneal epithelium in ATS (29.47 ± 3.21 mm), Tet-ATS (46.23 ± 2.87 mm), and Tet-ATS@PLGA (55.76 ± 3.95 mm) gradually increased. Furthermore, the flow cytometry indicated that Tet-ATS@PLGA can effectively promote the apoptosis of inflammatory SIRC cells, and the cellular immunofluorescence and ELISA experiments showed that the expression intensity of inflammatory factors such as VEGF, IL-1β, PGE2, and TNF-α decreased in this process. Interestingly, Tet also had the effect of reducing intraocular pressure.

CONCLUSION

Tet-ATS@PLGA can effectively promote the apoptosis of inflammatory corneal epithelial cells, thus inhibiting the expression of inflammatory factors to block the formation of DED and improve the secretion of tear on the ocular surface.

The Antiangiogenic Effect and Ocular Pharmacology of Novel Modified Nonsteroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs in the Treatment of Oxygen-Induced Retinopathy

Purpose: To evaluate the hypothesis that 3 novel compounds, OXT-328, Q-922, and CL-717 show efficacy in the treatment of oxygen-induced retinopathy (OIR) and whether or not their route of administration is intravitreal, topical, or systemic. Methods: The OIR mouse model, characterized by an avascular area (AVA) and a neovascular area (NVA) of the retina, was used to study retinopathy of prematurity and other retinal diseases characterized by abnormal vessel growth. We measured the effect of our compounds on both the AVA and NVA in whole mounts of mouse retinal tissue. We also evaluated their ability to prevent new vessel formation in chicken chorioallantoic membranes (CAMs). Finally, we measured the in vitro uptake and biodistribution of topically applied CL-717 in human eye explants. Results: In mice with OIR, compared to controls, a single intravitreal administration of Q-922 or OXT-328 significantly reduced both AVA and NVA. CL-717 administered as eye drops over 5 days also reduced AVA and NVA, whereas OXT-328 eye drops had no effect. Q-922 given intraperitoneal (150 mg/kg/day × 5 days) reduced AVA and NVA. Remarkably, explanted human eyes bathed in CL-717 show rapid uptake and biodistribution in ocular tissues. In the chicken CAM model, all 3 compounds reduced the formation of new blood vessels by about one-third. No side effect in mice was observed, except for mild ocular surface irritation with Q-922. Conclusions: Systemic administration of Q-922 or topical administration of CL-717 holds particular promise for a simplified treatment of proliferative retinopathies without the necessity of intravitreal injections.

Current Advances in Mechanisms and Treatment of Dry Eye Disease: Toward Anti-inflammatory and Immunomodulatory Therapy and Traditional Chinese Medicine

Dry eye is currently one of the most common ocular surface disease. It can lead to ocular discomfort and even cause visual impairment, which greatly affects the work and quality of life of patients. With the increasing incidence of dry eye disease (DED) in recent years, the disease is receiving more and more attention, and has become one of the hot research fields in ophthalmology research. Recently, with the in-depth research on the etiology, pathogenesis and treatment of DED, it has been shown that defects in immune regulation is one of the main pathological mechanisms of DED. Since the non-specific and specific immune response of the ocular surface are jointly regulated, a variety of immune cells and inflammatory factors are involved in the development of DED. The conventional treatment of DED is the application of artificial tears for lubricating the ocular surface. However, for moderate-to-severe DED, treatment with anti-inflammatory drugs is necessary. In this review, the immunomodulatory mechanisms of DED and the latest research progress of its related treatments including Chinese medicine will be discussed.

Once-Daily Topical Phosphosulindac Is Efficacious in the Treatment of Dry Eye Disease: Studies in Rabbit Models of Its Main Clinical Subtypes

Purpose: Dry eye disease (DED) is classified as aqueous deficient, evaporative, or mixed. We investigated the therapeutic effect of the novel anti-inflammatory drug phosphosulindac (PS) in rabbit models of DED encompassing its pathogenesis, and its transition to chronicity.

Methods: We treated three rabbit models of DED with PS (hydrogel formulation) or vehicle topically applied 1 × /day. We induced aqueous-deficient DED (acute and chronic) by injecting Concanavalin A into lacrimal glands; evaporative DED by injecting into the upper eyelid inactivated Mycobacterium tuberculosis in complete Freund's adjuvant; and mixed DED through desiccative stress, induced by holding open the eye for 3 h. We determined corneal sensitivity, tear break-up time (TBUT), Schirmer's tear test (STT), tear osmolality, and fluorescein staining of the ocular surface.

Results: PS reversed all abnormal DED parameters. In acute DED, PS dose dependently normalized corneal sensitivity and tear osmolality; and improved TBUT, STT, and fluorescein staining. PS normalized corneal sensitivity and improved all other parameters in chronic aqueous-deficient DED. In evaporative DED, PS normalized corneal sensitivity and improved TBUT and fluorescein staining (osmolality and STT were not significantly changed in this model). In the desiccative stress model, PS improved TBUT and fluorescein staining but had no effect on STT or tear osmolality.

Conclusions: PS rapidly reversed almost all DED parameters in its three subtypes. The normalization of the suppressed corneal sensitivity suggests the possibility of marked symptomatic relief by PS. The hydrogel formulation allows once-daily dosing. PS merits further development as a potential treatment for DED.

Simplified ex-vivo drug evaluation in ocular surface cells: Culture on cellulose filters of cells obtained by impression cytology

Drug development, resource- and time-intensive, extensively employs cell-based assays to assess the efficacy and safety of candidate drugs. The widely used immortalized cell lines, experimentally convenient, have limited predictive value. In contrast, ex-vivo models more faithfully reproduce diseases but are technically challenging to establish. To address this need, we developed a simplified process for ex-vivo cell culture, demonstrating its feasibility in ocular surface cells. Conjunctival cells were harvested by impression cytology and grown on mixed cellulose ester membrane filters (MCFs). Human and rabbit conjunctival cells cultured on MCFs are 100% viable at 24 h, and 43% viable at 72 h. A gene expression study evaluating 84 genes involved in ocular inflammation demonstrated that ex-vivo culturing maintains intact the expression of two thirds of these genes in human cells. That these cells are suitable for the assessment of ocular drugs was demonstrated by studying the effect of phosphosulindac (PS), a small molecule under development for the treatment of dry eye disease, in both human and rabbit conjunctival cells. PS, for example, suppressed the expression of CXCL10, a cytokine participating in the pathogenesis of dry eye disease, in human and in rabbit conjunctival cells cultured ex-vivo by 32% and 70%, respectively. Conjunctival cells cultured ex-vivo can be transfected to evaluate mechanistic questions. We successfully transfected such cells with a plasmid expressing luciferase under the control of an IFN-γ-responsive promoter or its control plasmid. IFN-γ stimulated luciferase expression by 85% in cells with the responsive plasmid but not in controls; PS significantly suppressed this induction by 37% without affecting the control plasmid. These findings demonstrate that human and rabbit conjunctival cells cultured ex-vivo with our method are viable and maintain their biological integrity; respond to biological and pharmacological agents; and are transfectable with informative plasmids. The unique advantage of this method is to potentially accelerate the development of novel drugs for the treatment of ocular surface diseases, and to advance our understanding of ocular surface pathophysiology.

Animal models of dry eye disease: Useful, varied and evolving (Review)

Dry eye disease (DED), which is a prevalent disease that still lacks successful treatment options, remains a major challenge in ophthalmology. Multiple animal models of DED have been used to decipher its pathophysiology and to develop novel treatments. These models use mice, rats, rabbits, cats, dogs and non-human primates. Each model assesses aspects of DED by focusing on elements of the lacrimal functional unit, which controls the homeostasis of the tear film. The present review outlines representative DED animal models and assesses their contribution to the study of DED. Murine models are the most extensively used, followed by rabbit models; the latter offer the advantage of larger eyes, a favorable biochemical profile for drug studies, experimental ease and relatively low cost, contrasting with non-human primates, which, although closer to humans, are not as accessible and are expensive. No comprehensive ‘ideal’ animal model encompassing all aspects of human DED exists nor is it feasible. Investigators often choose an animal model based on their experimental needs and the following four features of a given model: The size of the eye, its biochemical composition, the available research reagents and cost. As research efforts in DED expand, more refined animal models are needed to supplement the enormous contribution made to date by existing models.

The transcriptome of rabbit conjunctiva in dry eye disease: Large-scale changes and similarity to the human dry eye

The pathophysiology of dry eye disease (DED) remains largely unknown, accounting in part for the lack of successful treatments. We explored the pathophysiology of DED using a rabbit model of chronic DED induced with 3 weekly injections of Concanavalin A into the periorbital lacrimal glands. The transcriptome of full-thickness's conjunctival tissue from rabbits with DED and from normal controls was determined using microarrays and, as needed, confirmatory real-time polymerase chain reactions. Results were subjected to bioinformatic analysis. DED induced large-scale changes in gene transcription involving 5,184 genes (22% of the total). Differentially expressed genes could be segregated into: functional modules and clusters; altered pathways; functionally linked genes; and groups of individual genes of known or suspected pathophysiological relevance to DED. A common feature of these subgroups is the breadth and magnitude of the changes that encompass ocular immunology and essentially all aspects of cell biology. Prominent changes concerned innate and adaptive immune responses; ocular surface inflammation; at least 25 significantly altered signaling pathways; a large number of chemokines; cell cycle; and apoptosis. Comparison of our findings to the limited extant transcriptomic data from DED patients associated with either Sjogren's syndrome or non-Sjogren's etiologies revealed a significant correlation between human and rabbit DED transcriptomes. Our data, establishing the large-scale transcriptomic changes of DED and their potential similarity to the human, underscore the enormous complexity of DED; establish a robust animal model of DED; will help expand our understanding of its pathophysiology; and could guide the development of successful therapeutic strategies.

Phospho-Sulindac (OXT-328) Inhibits Dry Eye Disease in Rabbits: A Dose-, Formulation- and Structure-Dependent Effect

Purpose: Inflammation of the ocular surface is central to dry eye disease (DED). The anti-inflammatory agent phospho-sulindac (PS) at a high dose was efficacious against DED in a rabbit model. We assessed the dose, formulation and structure dependence of PS's effect. Methods: In rabbits with concanavalin A-induced DED we evaluated a range of PS concentrations (0.05%-1.6%) and dosing frequencies, assessed the duration of its effect with PS in 2 solution formulations and one emulsion formulation, and compared the efficacy of PS to that of sulindac, and of the structurally similar phospho-ibuprofen amide. We determined tear breakup time (TBUT) (tear stability), Schirmer's tear test (tear production), and by esthesiometry corneal sensitivity (symptoms). We also determined the biodistribution in the eye of topically applied PS. Results: PS in a solution formulation, given as eye drops q.i.d. was efficacious starting at a dose of 0.1%. The effect was apparent after 2 days of treatment and lasted at least 8 days after the last dose. Both signs (evidenced by TBUT and Schirmer's test) and symptoms (measured by corneal sensitivity) improved significantly. The best formulation was the solution formulation; a cyclodextrin-based formulation was also successful but the emulsion formulation was not. PS and its metabolites were essentially restricted to the anterior chamber of the eye. Sulindac and phospho-ibuprofen amide had no efficacy on DED. Conclusions: PS is efficacious against DED. Its effect, encompassing signs, and symptoms, are dose, formulation, and structure dependent. PS has therapeutic promise and merits further development.

Animal models of dry eye: Their strengths and limitations for studying human dry eye disease

Dry eye disease (DED), also called the keratoconjunctivitis sicca, is one of the most common diseases in the ophthalmology clinics. While DED is not a life-threatening disease, life quality may be substantially affected by the discomfort and the complications of poor vision. As such, a large number of studies have made contributions to the investigation of the DED pathogenesis and novel treatments. DED is a multifactorial disease featured with various phenotypic consequences; therefore, animal models are valuable tools suitable for the related studies. Accordingly, selection of the animal model to recapitulate the clinical presentation of interest is important for appropriately addressing the research objective. To this end, we systemically reviewed different murine and rabbit models of DED, which are categorized into the quantitative (aqueous-deficient) type and the qualitative (evaporative) type, based on the schemes to establish. The clinical manifestations of dry eye on animal models can be induced by mechanical or surgical approaches, iatrogenic immune response, topical eye drops, blockage of neural pathway, or others. Although these models have shown promising results, each has its own limitation and cannot fully reproduce the pathophysiological mechanisms that occur in patients. Nonetheless, the animal models remain the best approximation of human DED and represent the valuable tool for the DED studies.

Diagnosis of Dry Eye Disease Using Principal Component Analysis: A Study in Animal Models of the Disease

PURPOSE

To evaluate whether principal component analysis (PCA) can assess various diagnostic tests of dry eye disease (DED), providing a simplified, more informative measure of disease status than individual clinical test parameters (ICTP).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

ICTP were analyzed using PCA in two groups of normal rabbits (Groups 1 and 2). Group 3, not truly normal, was also assessed. DED was induced in Group 1 by complete dacryoadenectomy; in Groups 2 and 3 by injection of concanavalin A. Tear break up time, tear osmolarity, Schirmer's tear test and rose bengal staining were the ICTP measured in all groups. Statistical analysis including descriptive statistics, t test, correlation coefficients and PCA was done. PCA using ICTP data from Group 1 generated axes; Group 2 and 3 were plotted over these axes.

RESULTS

All groups had induction of DED. Correlations for all ICTP were in the correct direction and were strongest for Group 1 and weakest in Group 3. PCA clearly separated DED and normal eyes. Principal component (PC) 1, made up of nearly equal contributions from the four clinical tests, explained 73% of the variation and provided a means to separate normal from DED. PC 1 values under 0.52 can be mathematically defined as DED. Of all pairwise comparisons, PC 1 vs PC 2 and PC 1 vs PC 3 were the most informative providing excellent spatial separation and additional information regarding DED status.

CONCLUSIONS

PCA proved useful for evaluating DED providing a simpler, more comprehensive assessment than ICTP. PC 1 is a valuable, clinically relevant, and informative metric for DED status and severity having superior diagnostic value and statistical strength compared to ICTP. Spatial information on biplots of PC 1 vs PC 3 is also informative. PCA, and specifically PC 1, has the potential to serve as a biomarker for DED.

Optimization of a Rabbit Dry Eye Model Induced by Topical Instillation of Benzalkonium Chloride

Purpose

To optimize a rabbit dry eye model induced by topical instillation of benzalkonium chloride (BAC), reduce the days of instillation of the original model by increasing the concentration of BAC from 0.1% to 0.2%.

Materials and Methods

An experimental, prospective, and randomized study was performed on 10 male New Zealand white rabbits, divided into two groups, considering both eyes: 5 rabbits as control (n = 10) and 5 rabbits with 0.2% BAC treatment (n = 10). Saline solution (control) and 0.2% BAC were instilled for 5 consecutive days, twice daily. Tear secretion with and without anesthesia, tear breakup time, tear osmolarity, corneal staining, conjunctival hyperemia, density of goblet cells, height of mucin cloud, and transcript levels of IL-6 were measured before and after the treatment.

Results

After the instillation of 0.2% BAC for 5 consecutive days, there was a significant increase in tear secretion without anesthesia (P < 0.001), corneal staining (P < 0.001), conjunctival hyperemia (P < 0.001), and levels of IL-6 mRNA (P=0.005) compared to the control group. Conversely, there was a decrease in tear secretion with anesthesia (P < 0.001), tear breakup time (P=0.007), tear osmolarity (P < 0.001), density of goblet cells (P < 0.001), and height of mucin cloud (P < 0.001).

Conclusions

The topical instillation of 0.2% BAC for 5 consecutive days, twice daily, was a proper procedure to induce a rabbit dry eye model, reducing the number of days of instillation compared to the original model (14 days).

A New Rabbit Model of Chronic Dry Eye Disease Induced by Complete Surgical Dacryoadenectomy

Purpose/Aim: Dry eye disease (DED), common and suboptimally treated, is in need of novel animal models to understand its pathophysiology and assess the efficacy and other parameters of new pharmacological agents for its treatment. The more than 10 rabbit models of DED described to date have significant limitations including induction of mild disease, lack of consistency, and off-target effects when chemical agents are used for disease induction. Our aim was to develop a new model of chronic DED in rabbits that overcomes the limitations of existing models.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a complete surgical resection of all orbital lacrimal glands (LGs; dacryoadenectomy) in normal adult New Zealand White rabbits. One week after removal of the nictitating membrane, we surgically removed the orbital superior LG, followed by removal of the palpebral superior LG, and finally removal of the inferior LG. Surgery was performed under anesthesia, required about 1 h/eye, and was well-tolerated.

RESULTS

Dacryoadenectomy induced severe DED, evidenced by >90% reduction in the tear break up time test, 50% reduction in the Schirmer tear test, 10% increase in tear osmolarity, and a marked increase in the rose bengal staining score. DED was sustained and essentially unchanged for the eight weeks of observation. Sham-operated rabbits showed no such changes, with the exception of a non-significant and transient reduction in the tear break up time test, a response to ocular surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

This model of stable, chronic, predominantly aqueous-deficient DED recapitulates key clinical and histological features of human DED and is suitable for the study of ocular surface homeostasis, of the pathophysiology of DED, and of the efficacy of candidate drugs for DED treatment.