Renal Oncocytoma: An Algorithm for Diagnosis and Management

Clear cell likelihood score may improve diagnosis and management of renal masses

The detection of solid renal masses has increased over time due to incidental findings during imaging studies conducted for unrelated medical conditions. Approximately 20% of lesions measuring less than 4 cm are benign and 80% are malignant. Clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) is the most frequent among renal carcinomas, responsible for 65-80% of cases. The increased detection of renal masses facilitates early diagnosis and treatment. However, it also leads to more invasive interventions, which result in higher morbidity and costs. Currently, only histological analysis can offer an accurate diagnosis. Surgical nephron loss significantly elevates morbidity and mortality rates. Active surveillance represents a conservative management approach for patients diagnosed with a solid renal mass that is endorsed by both American Urological Association and the European Society for Medical Oncology. However, active surveillance is used in a minority of patients and varies across institutions. The lack of clinical studies using a standardized approach to incidentally detected small renal masses precludes the widespread use of active surveillance. Hence, there is an urgent need for better patient selection, distinguishing those who require surgery from those suitable for active surveillance. The clear cell likelihood score (ccLS) represents a novel MRI tool for assessing the probability of a renal mass being a ccRCC. In this study, we present a comprehensive review of renal masses and their evaluation using the ccLS to facilitate shared decision between urologists and patients.

Renal Oncocytoma: A Systematic Review of Its Metastatic Features

Oncocytomas are referred to as benign kidney neoplasms. They primarily affect adults, with patients over 70 years old being the most affected. Renal oncocytomas (ROs) are frequently detected by excision, biopsy, or scan. Hematuria, flank pain, and a palpable mass are the traditional trio of symptoms. Oncocytomas appear as well-circumscribed, tan or mahogany-coloured masses with a central scar that is stellate. Histological features include well-circumscribed lesions, bland cytology, eosinophilic cytoplasm, regular nuclei with prominent central nucleoli, and nested architecture. ROs are rarely linked to an aggressive clinical course and have an excellent prognosis. There is proof that the disease can spread to the liver and bones. Some literature has also reported oncocytoma metastases to the lung and liver. This systematic review of the literature examines and evaluates the malignant potential of oncocytoma. The purpose of the study was to determine whether ROs can be diagnosed as a benign condition or if malignancy needs to be considered and investigated. Seventeen studies were analysed which had a total of 412 ROs. Four patients (one percent) died as a result of their illness. There was evidence of disease progression in every patient who passed away from their illness. Six patients (1.5%) experienced disease progression in total. Three hundred and seventeen patients (80%) underwent radical nephrectomy, while 81 patients (20%) underwent partial nephrectomy. Liver, bone, lung, lymphadenopathy, and local recurrence were among the metastasis sites. Perinephric fat invasion, renal sinus fat invasion, renal capsular invasion, and vascular invasion are characteristics of metastatic behavior that have been found. Despite this, the small number of patients who experienced disease progression and/or death as a result of ROs implies that aggressive malignant behavior is not always correlated with the presence of metastatic features or disease. Oncocytomas should be viewed as having a low potential for malignancy rather than as benign. Individuals who exhibit aggressive characteristics, such as vascular invasion and/or perinephric fat invasion, have an atypically good prognosis. Despite advancements in imaging and immunochemical techniques, it is indisputable that ROs, which were first classified as renal tumours in 1976, continue to pose a diagnostic challenge for multidisciplinary teams. There is considerable variation in practice across the globe due to difficulties in confirming ROs, especially when it comes to metastatic disease. There is even more variation in the management of follow-up care that follows. This will remain the MDT's current state until randomised controlled trials, long-term results, and a better comprehension of the behavior of this tumour are obtained.

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Comparing Biopsy in Advance of Ablation with Concurrent Biopsy and Ablation for Small Renal Masses Measuring 1-3 cm

PURPOSE

To analyze the cost effectiveness of performing a renal mass biopsy in advance of ablation or concurrently with a percutaneous ablation procedure for the management of small renal masses (SRMs).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A decision-analytic model was developed with a cohort of 65-year-old male patients with an incidental, unilateral 1-3 cm SRM. A decision tree modeled the first year of clinical intervention, after which patients entered a Markov model with a lifetime horizon. Patients were assumed to be treated in accordance with established clinical practice guidelines, including surveillance, repeat ablation for recurrence, and systemic therapy for metastasis. Healthcare cost and utility values were determined from published literature or local hospital estimates, discounted at 1.5%. Total lifetime costs were calculated from the perspective of a Canadian healthcare payer and converted to 2022 Canadian dollars (C$). The primary outcome was incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) at a willingness-to-pay threshold of C$50,000 per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained. The secondary outcome was ICER at a willingness-to-pay threshold of C$50,000 per life year (LY) gained.

RESULTS

Concurrent biopsy and ablation resulted in a gain of 16.4 quality-adjusted days, at an incremental cost of $386, with an ICER of C$8,494/QALY. The concurrent strategy was the dominant strategy for a prevalence of benign mass of <5%. Sequential biopsy and ablation was only cost-effective when LYs were not quality-adjusted and ablation cost was >C$4,300 or benign mass prevalence was >28%.

CONCLUSIONS

Concurrent biopsy and ablation is cost-effective relative to pretreatment diagnostic biopsy for management of incidental SRMs.

Renal mass biopsy - a practical and clinicopathologically relevant approach to diagnosis

Advancements in imaging modalities have increased the frequency of renal mass discovery. Imaging has typically been considered sufficient to guide management for a large proportion of these tumours, but renal mass biopsies (RMBs) have an increasing role in determining malignancy and can be a valuable tool for preventing unnecessary surgery in patients with benign tumours. A structured approach should be used to help to navigate the expanding repertoire of renal tumours, many of which are molecularly defined. In terms of tumour subtyping, the pathologist's strategy should focus on stratifying patients into clinically different prognostic groups according to our current knowledge of tumour behaviour, including benign, low-grade or indolent, intermediate malignant or highly aggressive. Crucial pathological features and morphological mimicry of tumours can alter the tumour's prognostic group. Thus, pathologists and urologists can use RMB to select patients with tumours at a reduced risk of progression, which can be safely managed with active surveillance within a tailored imaging schedule, versus tumours for which ablation or surgical intervention is indicated. RMB is also crucial in the oncological setting to distinguish between different high-grade tumours and guide tailored management strategies.

Exploratory Analysis of the Role of Radiomic Features in the Differentiation of Oncocytoma and Chromophobe RCC in the Nephrographic CT Phase

In diagnostic imaging, distinguishing chromophobe renal cell carcinomas (chRCCs) from renal oncocytomas (ROs) is challenging, since they both present similar radiological characteristics. Radiomics has the potential to help in the differentiation between chRCCs and ROs by extracting quantitative imaging. This is a preliminary study of the role of radiomic features in the differentiation of chRCCs and ROs using machine learning models. In this retrospective work, 38 subjects were involved: 19 diagnosed with chRCCs and 19 with ROs. The CT nephrographic contrast phase was selected in each case. Three-dimensional segmentations of the lesions were performed and the radiomic features were extracted. To assess the reliability of the features, the intraclass correlation coefficient was calculated from the segmentations performed by three radiologists with different degrees of expertise. The selection of features was based on the criteria of excellent intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), high correlation, and statistical significance. Three machine learning models were elaborated: support vector machine (SVM), random forest (RF), and logistic regression (LR). From 105 extracted features, 41 presented an excellent ICC and 6 were not highly correlated with each other. Only two features showed significant differences according to histological type and machine learning models were developed with them. LR was the better model, in particular, with an 83% precision.

Oncocytoma on renal mass biopsy: is it still the same histology when surgery is performed? Results from UroCCR-104 study

PURPOSE

To describe clinical features of patients with oncocytoma on renal biopsy (RMB), correlation with final histology on surgically treated patients, and predictive factors of discrepancy between RMB and final histology.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study conducted in the framework of the UroCCR project (NCT03293563). All tumors with oncocytoma on RMB were selected and all pathological reports were reviewed. Patients with the RMB simultaneously performed with a focal treatment, synchronous bilateral tumors and ambiguous RMB report were excluded. Discrepancy between RMB and definitive histology was evaluated using a uni- and multivariable logistic regression analyses model.

RESULTS

Overall, 119 tumors with oncocytoma on RMB, from 15 centers, were included. Of those, 54 (45.4%) had upfront surgery and 65 (54.6%) had active surveillance (AS). In renal masses with initial active surveillance, with a median follow-up of 28 months, 23 (19.3%) underwent surgery, 4 (3.4%) received focal treatment and 38 (31.9%) remained on AS. On final pathology, only 51 of the 75 surgically treated tumors (68.0%) had oncocytoma, while 24 presented malignant tumors (mainly chromophobe carcinoma (19.2%), and hybrid oncocytic/chromophobe tumor (HOCT) (6.8%)) leading to a discrepancy of 32.0% between RMB and final pathology. The only predictive factor of a discrepancy between RMB and definitive histology was a biopsy done outside of the center (Odds ratio: 3.22 [95%-confidence interval: 1.08-9.61], p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

Despite the increase of RMB in more and more centers, histologic discrepancy between RMB and definitive histology remains significant. This information should be discussed with patients and taken into consideration before treatment decision.

Reliability and Management Outcomes Following a Percutaneous Biopsy Diagnosis of Oncocytoma: A 15-year Retrospective Analysis

Background There is uncertainty in the management of renal masses diagnosed as oncocytomas with image-guided percutaneous biopsy. Purpose To assess the reliability of a diagnosis of oncocytoma based on image-guided percutaneous renal mass biopsy and evaluate patient outcomes following different management strategies. Materials and Methods In this retrospective study, image-guided percutaneous biopsy pathology reports from April 2004 to April 2019 were searched for keywords "oncocytoma" and "oncocytic neoplasm" and compared with surgical pathology or repeat biopsy results. Patients with at least 12 months of clinical follow-up and known cause of death were grouped according to management strategies, and disease-specific survival and metastatic renal cell carcinoma (RCC)-free survival were compared. Mass growth rates were calculated with use of a normal linear mixed model. Results The database yielded 160 biopsy reports of 149 renal masses in 139 patients; 149 masses were categorized as oncocytoma (n = 107), likely oncocytoma (n = 12), oncocytic neoplasm (n = 28), and indeterminate with oncocytoma in differential (n = 2). Biopsied masses categorized as oncocytoma or likely oncocytoma were oncocytomas in 16 of 17 masses (94%) based on surgical pathology or repeat biopsy; four of eight masses (50%) categorized as oncocytic neoplasms were low-grade RCCs. Outcome analysis included 121 patients (mean age ± SD, 68 years ± 9.1; 82 men); 80 patients initially underwent active surveillance (11 were later treated), 33 underwent ablation, and eight underwent surgery. Disease-specific survival and metastatic-free survival were 100% after each management strategy (median follow-up, 86.6 months; range, 14.2-207.9 months). Mass growth rate (mean, 1.7 mm per year) showed no evidence of a significant difference among biopsy result categories (P = .37) or initial (P = .84) or final management strategies (P = .11). Conclusion Image-guided percutaneous biopsy diagnosis of renal oncocytoma was reliable. Although some masses diagnosed as oncocytic neoplasms were low-grade renal cell carcinomas (RCCs) at final diagnosis, no patients died of RCC, including those managed with active surveillance. © RSNA, 2023 See also the editorial by Lockhart in this issue.

Asymptomatic Giant Right Renal Oncocytoma: A Case Report

Renal oncocytoma is usually detected incidentally. It can be considered as a renal cell carcinoma (RCC) on preoperative imaging. They usually present as small masses and usually look like benign tumors. Giant oncocytomas are rare. A 72-year-old male patient was seen in the outpatient department for left scrotal swelling. Ultrasound (US) showed a giant mass compatible with RCC in the right kidney which was incidentally detected. Abdominal computed tomography (CT) revealed a mass with an axial diameter of 167×146 mm, compatible with RCC, a heterogeneous mass of soft tissue density with central necrosis. There was no evidence of tumor thrombus in the right renal vein or inferior vena cava. Open radical nephrectomy was performed through an anterior subcostal incision. Pathological examination revealed a 17×15 cm renal oncocytoma. The patient was discharged on the sixth day postoperatively. Clinically or radiologically, renal oncocytoma and renal cell carcinoma usually cannot be distinguished, although oncocytoma may be suspected if a central scar with fibrous extensions is seen, the so-called "spoke-wheel appearance". The treatment decision should be made according to the clinical aspects. Radical/partial nephrectomy or thermal ablation can be considered as treatment options. In this article, we review the literature on the radiological and pathological features of renal oncocytoma.

99mTc-Sestamibi SPECT/CT and histopathological features of oncocytic renal neoplasia

BACKGROUND

^99mTc-Sestamibi Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography/Computed Tomography (SPECT/CT) contributes to the non-invasive differentiation of renal oncocytoma (RO) from renal cell carcinoma (RCC) by characterising renal tumours as Sestamibi positive or Sestamibi negative regarding their ^99mTc-Sestamibi uptake compared to the non-tumoral renal parenchyma.

PURPOSE

To determine whether ^99mTc- Sestamibi uptake in renal tumour and the non-tumoral renal parenchyma measured using Standard Uptake Value (SUV) SPECT, has a beneficial role in differentiating RO from RCC.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Fifty-seven renal tumours from 52 patients were evaluated. In addition to visual evaluation of ^99mTc-Sestamibi uptake, SUV_max measurements were performed in the renal tumour and the ipsilateral non-tumoral renal parenchyma. Analysis of the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve identified an optimal cut-off value for detecting RO, based on the relative ratio of ^99mTc- Sestamibi uptake.

RESULTS

Semiquantitative evaluation of ^99mTc-Sestamibi uptake did not improve the performance of ^99mTc- Sestamibi SPECT/CT in detecting RO. ^99mTc- Sestamibi SPECT/CT identifies a group of mostly indolent Sestamibi-positive tumours with low malignant potential containing RO, Low-Grade Oncocytic Tumours, Hybrid Oncocytic Tumours, and a subset of chromophobe RCCs.

CONCLUSION

The imaging limitations for accurate differentiation of Sestamibi-positive renal tumours mirror the recognised diagnostic complexities of the histopathologic evaluation of oncocytic neoplasia. Patients with Sestamibi-positive renal tumours could be better suited for biopsy and follow-up, according to the current active surveillance protocols.

Benefit and Harm of Active Surveillance for Biopsy-proven Renal Oncocytoma: A Systematic Review and Pooled Analysis

Context

Active surveillance (AS) of biopsy-proven renal oncocytomas may reduce overtreatment. However, on biopsy, the risk of misdiagnosis owing principally to entities with peculiar hybrids and overlap morphology, and phenotypes argues for early intervention.

Objective

To assess the benefit and harm of AS in biopsy-proven renal oncocytoma.

Evidence acquisition

A systematic review was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA). We systematically searched PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases from September 26 up to October 2021, for studies that analyzed the outcomes of AS in patients with biopsy-proven renal oncocytoma.

Evidence synthesis

A total of ten studies with 633 patients met our inclusion criteria and were included for analysis. After a median follow-up of 34.5 mo (95% confidence interval [CI] 30.6–38.4), the overall definitive treatment rate from AS to definitive treatment was 17.3% (n = 75/433, six studies). The pooled pathological agreement between the initial renal mass biopsy and the surgical pathology report was 91.1%. The main indications for surgery during follow-up were rapid tumor growth and patient request. The pooled median growth rate was 1.55 mm/yr (95% CI 0.9–2.2). No metastasis or death related to renal oncocytoma was reported.

Conclusions

Annual tumor growth of biopsy-proven renal oncocytoma is low. AS is oncologically safe, with favorable compliance of patients. Crossover to definitive treatment revealed a strong concordance between biopsy and final pathology. Further studies on the long-term outcomes of AS are needed.

Patient summary

In this study, we examined the benefit and harm of active surveillance (AS) in biopsy-proven oncocytoma. Based on the available data, AS appears oncologically safe and may represent a promising alternative to immediate treatment. Patients should be included in AS decision discussions.

Eosinophilic Vacuolated Tumor of Kidney: Clinical Perspective of a New Pathologic Emerging Entity

The eosinophilic vacuolated tumor (EVT) of the kidney is a newly identified and pathological emerging entity. In this case report, EVT diagnosed due to a partial nephrectomy performed for a suspicious kidney mass in a 47-year-old patient is presented. A review of the literature and this case indicates that EVT, also called high-grade oncocytoma, does not show clinically aggressive behavior. However, in case of clinical suspicion, tumors with this oncocytic morphology should be treated with nephron-sparing treatment methods, considering that they may be hybrid malignancies.

High-Resolution Ultrasonography of Renal Oncocytoma Presenting with Symptomatic Hematuria and Urinary Bladder Clot Retention-A Rare Occurrence

Renal oncocytomas are asymptomatic, benign tumors often encountered incidentally on various imaging modalities. Renal oncocytomas comprise 5–7% of primary renal neoplasms and are derived from cells of the distal renal tubule. We present a case report of renal oncocytoma in a 22-year-old male having right-sided flank pain and symptomatic gross hematuria with a giant urinary bladder clot retention. The tumor was excised, and the patient underwent laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. Typical features of renal oncocytoma were observed upon histopathological examination of the resected specimen. The patient was catheterized, and bladder irrigation with clot retraction was performed.

Combining contrast-enhanced ultrasound, CT perfusion and 99mTc-Sestamibi SPECT/CT to guide diagnosis in a case of solid renal tumour

Definitive, pre-operative differentiation of solid renal lesions by ultrasound, contrast-enhanced multiphasic CT or MRI examinations is often not possible. An increasing amount of literature indicates the added value of ^99mTc-Sestamibi SPECT/CT, CT perfusion and contrast-enhanced ultrasound in the pre-operative characterisation of solid renal tumours. This case report presents the diagnostic approach of a solid renal tumour that turned out to be a hybrid oncocytic chromophobe tumour in a patient with Stage 3 renal failure by combining the three aforementioned modern examination techniques.