Responses of mesophilic anaerobic sludge microbiota to thermophilic conditions: Implications for start-up and operation of thermophilic THP-AD systems

A cyclic shift-temperature operation method to train microbial communities of mesophilic anaerobic digestion

Temperature is the critical factor affecting the efficiency and cost of anaerobic digestion (AD). The current work develops a shift-temperature AD (STAD) between 35 °C and 55 °C, intending to optimise microbial community and promote substrate conversion. The experimental results showed that severe inhibition of biogas production occurred when the temperature was firstly increased stepwise from 35 °C to 50 °C, whereas no inhibition was observed at the second warming cycle. When the organic load rate was increased to 6.37 g VS/L/d, the biogas yield of the STAD reached about 400 mL/g VS, nearly double that of the constant-temperature AD (CTAD). STAD promoted the proliferation of Methanosarcina (up to 57.32 %), while severely suppressed hydrogenophilic methanogens. However, when the temperature was shifted to 35 °C, most suppressed species recovered quickly and the excess propionic acid was quickly consumed. Metagenomic analysis showed that STAD also promoted gene enrichment related to pathways metabolism, membrane functions, and methyl-based methanogenesis.

Total ammonia nitrogen inhibits medium-chain fatty acid biosynthesis by disrupting hydrolysis, acidification, chain elongation, substrate transmembrane transport and ATP synthesis processes

This study used 16S rRNA gene sequencing and metatranscriptomic analysis to comprehensively illustrate how ammonia stress influenced medium-chain fatty acids (MCFA) biosynthesis. MCFA synthesis was inhibited at total ammonia nitrogen (TAN) concentrations above 1000 mg N/L. TAN stress hindered organic hydrolysis, acidification, and volatile fatty acids elongation. Chain-elongating bacteria (e.g., Clostridium_sensu_stricto_12, Clostridium_sensu_stricto_1, Caproiciproducens) abundance remained unchanged, but their activity decreased, partially due to the increased reactive oxygen species. Metatranscriptomic analysis revealed reduced activity of enzymes critical for MCFA production under TAN stress. Fatty acid biosynthesis pathway rather than reverse β-oxidation pathway primarily contributed to MCFA production, and was inhibited under TAN stress. Functional populations likely survived TAN stress through osmoprotectant generation and potassium uptake regulation to maintain osmotic pressure, with NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase potentially compensating for ATP loss. This study enhances understanding of MCFA biosynthesis under TAN stress, aiding MCFA production system stability and efficiency improvement.

Extracellular-proton-transfer driving high energy-conserving methanogenesis in anaerobic digestion

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is a promising technology to realize the conversion from organic matters to methane, which is highly mediated by syntrophic microbial community via mutualistic interactions. However, small energy available in methanogenic conversion usually limits the metabolic activity. To adapt such energy-limited environment, efficient energy conservation is critical to support active physiological functions of anaerobic consortia for methanogenic metabolism. In this study, the contribution of extracellular proton transfer (EPT) enhancement to achieving energy-conserving methanogenesis in AD was explored. Proton-conductive medium (PCM) was applied to construct efficient proton transport pathway, and a large number of protons from extracellular water were found available to upregulate methanogenesis in AD, as indicated by the increase in the content of 2H (D) in methane molecules (over 40.7%), among which CO2-reduction-to-CH4 was effectively enhanced. The increases of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) concentration (+54.1%) and gene expression activities related to ATPase (+100.0%) and proton pump (+580.1%) revealed that enhanced EPT by PCM promoted transmembrane proton motive force generation to facilitate ATP synthesis. Based on genome-centric metatranscriptomic analyses, MAG14, MAG63 and MAG61 with high energy conservation activity displayed most pronounced positive response to the EPT enhancement. In these core MAGs, the metabolic pathway reconstruction and the key genes activity identification further proved that EPT enhancement-driven efficient ATP synthesis stimulated the cross-feeding of carbon and proton/electron to facilitate microbial mutualism, thereby resulting in the high energy-conserving methanogenesis. Overall, our work provides new insights into how EPT enhancement drives high energy-conserving methanogenesis, expanding our understanding of the ecological role of EPT in AD.

Electron-transfer-driven spatial optimisation of anaerobic consortia for efficient methanogenesis: Neglected inductive effect of conductive materials

The inductive effect of conductive materials (CMs) on enhancing methanogenesis metabolism has been overlooked. Herein, we highlight role of CMs in inducing the spatial optimisation of methanogenic consortia by altering the Lewis acid-base (AB) interactions within microbial aggregates. In the presence of CMs and after their removal, the methane production and methane proportion in biogas significantly increase, with no significant difference between the two situations. Analyses of interactions between CMs and extracellular polymer substances (EPSs) with and without D2O reveal that CMs promote release and transfer potential of electron in EPSs, which induce and enhance the role of water molecules being primarily as proton acceptors in the hydrogen bonding between EPSs and water, thereby changing the electron-donor- and electron-acceptor-based AB interactions. Investigations of succession dynamics of microbial communities, co-occurrence networks, and metagenomics further indicate that electron transfer drives the microbial spatial optimisation for efficient methanogenesis through intensive interspecies interactions.

Microbial community assembly in engineered bioreactors

Microbial community assembly (MCA) processes that shape microbial communities in environments are being used to analyze engineered bioreactors such as activated sludge systems and anaerobic digesters. The goal of studying MCA is to be able to understand and predict the effect of design and operation procedures on bioreactor microbial composition and function. Ultimately, this can lead to bioreactors that are more efficient, resilient, or resistant to perturbations. This review summarizes the ecological theories underpinning MCA, evaluates MCA analysis methods, analyzes how these MCA-based methods are applied to engineered bioreactors, and extracts lessons from case studies. Furthermore, we suggest future directions in MCA research in engineered bioreactor systems. The review aims to provide insights and guidance to the growing number of environmental engineers who wish to design and understand bioreactors through the lens of MCA.

When polyethylene terephthalate microplastics meet Perfluorooctane sulfonate in thermophilic biogas upgrading system: Their effect on methanogenesis

Microplastics (MPs) and Perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) are two hard-biodegradable pollutants widely existing in the waste streams treated by anaerobic digestion. However, their synergistic effect on methanogenic metabolism is still unknown. This study investigated the impact of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) MPs alone and co-existing with PFOS on CO2 conversion to CH4 in a thermophilic biogas upgrading system. The results showed that either PET MPs addition alone or coexisting with PFOS improved the ultimate CH4 percentage and increased CO2 utilization rate. When Fe0 was added into the reactors with PET to enhance the interspecies electron transfer, a potential defluorination was observed with a defluorination rate of 15.88 ± 1.53%. Exposure of the reactor to PFOS of 300 μg/L could change the methanogenic pathway, resulting in a newly emerged Methanomassiliicoccus with dominance of 16%. Furthermore, under the exposure of PFOS, the number of predicted genes regulating enzymes in methanogenic steps from CO2 increased. These results suggest that the co-existence of PET MPs and PFOS will not inhibit the activity of hydrotrophic methanogenes, and a portion of PFOS may be biodegraded during the methanogenesis under Fe0 regulation.

Adaptability of sulfur-disproportionating bacteria for mine water remediation under the pressures of heavy metal ions and high sulfate content

Biological sulfide production processes mediated by sulfate/sulfur reduction have gained attention for metal removal from industrial wastewater (e.g., mine water (MW) and metallurgical wastewater) via forming insoluble metal sulfides. However, these processes often necessitate the addition of external organic compounds as electron donors, which poses a constraint on the broad application of this technology. A recent proof of concept study reported that microbial sulfur disproportionation (SD) produced sulfide with no demand for organics, which could achieve more cost-benefit MW treatment against the above-mentioned processes. However, the resistance of SD bioprocess to different metals and high sulfate content in MW remains mysterious, which may substantially affect the practical applicability of such process. In this study, the sulfur-disproportionating bacteria (SDB)-dominated consortium was enriched from a previously established SD-driven bioreactor, in which Dissulfurimicrobium sp. with a relative abundance of 39.9 % was the predominated SDB. When exposed to the real pretreated acidic MW after the pretreatment process of pH amelioration, the sulfur-disproportionating activity remained active, and metals were effectively removed from the MW. Metal tolerance assays further demonstrated that the consortium had a good tolerance to different metal ions (i.e., Pb2+, Cu2+, Ni2+, Mn2+, Zn2+), especially for Mn2+ with a concentration of approximately 20 mg/L. It suggested the robustness of Dissulfurimicrobium sp. likely due to the presence of genes encoding for the enzymes associated with metal(loid) resistance/uptake. Additionally, although high sulfate content resulted in a slight inhibition on the sulfur-disproportionating activity, the consortium still achieved sulfide production rates of 27.3 mg S/g VSS-d on average under an environmentally relevant sulfate level (i.e., 1100 mg S/L), which is comparable to those reported in sulfate reduction. Taken together, these findings imply that SDB could ensure sustainable MW treatment in a more cost-effective and organic-free way.

Microbiome-functionality in anaerobic digesters: A critical review

Microbially driven anaerobic digestion (AD) processes are of immense interest due to their role in the biovalorization of biowastes into renewable energy resources. The function-versatile microbiome, interspecies syntrophic interactions, and trophic-level metabolic pathways are important microbial components of AD. However, the lack of a comprehensive understanding of the process hampers efforts to improve AD efficiency. This study presents a holistic review of research on the microbial and metabolic "black box" of AD processes. Recent research on microbiology, functional traits, and metabolic pathways in AD, as well as the responses of functional microbiota and metabolic capabilities to optimization strategies are reviewed. The diverse ecophysiological traits and cooperation/competition interactions of the functional guilds and the biomanipulation of microbial ecology to generate valuable products other than methane during AD are outlined. The results show that AD communities prioritize cooperation to improve functional redundancy, and the dominance of specific microbes can be explained by thermodynamics, resource allocation models, and metabolic division of labor during cross-feeding. In addition, the multi-omics approaches used to decipher the ecological principles of AD consortia are summarized in detail. Lastly, future microbial research and engineering applications of AD are proposed. This review presents an in-depth understanding of microbiome-functionality mechanisms of AD and provides critical guidance for the directional and efficient bioconversion of biowastes into methane and other valuable products.

Mechanistic insights into Fe3O4-modified biochar relieving inhibition from erythromycin on anaerobic digestion

Anaerobic digestion (AD) of antibiotic manufacturing wastewater to degrade residual antibiotics and produce mixture of combustible gases has been investigated actively in the past decades. However, detrimental effect of residual antibiotic to microbial activities is commonly faced in AD process, leading to the reduction of treatment efficiency and energy recovery. Herein, the present study systematically evaluated the detoxification effect and mechanism of Fe3O4-modified biochar in AD of erythromycin manufacturing wastewater. Results showed that Fe3O4-modified biochar had stimulatory effect on AD at 0.5 g/L erythromycin existence. A maximum methane yield of 327.7 ± 8.0 mL/g COD was achieved at 3.0 g/L Fe3O4-modified biochar, leading to the increase of 55.7% compared to control group. Mechanistic investigation demonstrated that different levels of Fe3O4-modified biochar could improve methane yield via different metabolic pathways involved in specific bacteria and archaea. Low levels of Fe3O4-modified biochar (i.e., 0.5-1.0 g/L) led to the enrichment of Methanothermobacter sp., strengthening the hydrogenotrophic pathway. On the contrary, high levels of Fe3O4-modified biochar (2.0-3.0 g/L) favored the proliferation of acetogens (e.g., Lentimicrobium sp.) and methanogen (Methanosarcina sp.) and their syntrophic relations played vital role on the simulated AD performance at erythromycin stress. Additionally, the addition of Fe3O4-modified biochar significantly decreased the abundance of representative antibiotic resistant genes (ARGs), benefiting the reduction of environmental risk. The results of this study verified that the application of Fe3O4-modified biochar could be an efficient approach to detoxify erythromycin on AD system, which brings high impacts and positive implications for biological antibiotic wastewater treatment.

Enhanced hydrolysis/acidogenesis and potential mechanism in thermal-alkali-biofilm synergistic pretreatment of high-solid and low-organic-content sludge

Improving the anaerobic digestion (AD) of high-solid and low-organic-content sludge is imperative for sustainable waste activated sludge (WAS) management. Here, a thermal-alkali-biofilm pretreatment (TAB) was established to treat high-solid and low-organic-content sludge and compared with thermal and thermal-alkali methods. The results showed that TAB drastically improved WAS reduction, hydrolysis/acidogenesis efficiency, and biochemical methane potential. TAB possessed the lowest sludge particle size and the highest surface charge due to the stimulated proteolysis and WAS solubilization, supported by the protease activity test and secondary substrate identification. In addition, the biofilm assistance noticeably accelerated the elimination of autochthonous bacteria in WAS (e.g., Proteobacteria) and facilitated the enrichment of specialized fermentative microorganisms (e.g., Firmicutes) along with relevant functional genes, lying molecular foundation for the enhanced hydrolysis/acidogenesis in TAB. These findings could expand the application of biofilm in the AD of WAS and provide new insight into the pretreatment strategy of high-solid and low-organic-content sludge.

Accumulating ammoniacal nitrogen instead of melanoidins determines the anaerobic digestibility of thermally hydrolyzed waste activated sludge

Full-scale thermal hydrolysis processes (THP) showed an increase in nutrients release and formation of melanoidins, which are considered to negatively impact methanogenesis during mesophilic anaerobic digestion (AD). In this research, fractionation of THP-sludge was performed to elucidate the distribution of nutrients and the formed melanoidins over the liquid and solid sludge matrix. Degradation of the different fractions in subsequent AD was assessed, and the results were compared with non-pre-treated waste activated sludge (WAS). Results showed that the THP-formed soluble melanoidins were partially biodegradable under AD, especially the fraction with molecular weight under 1.1 kDa, which was related to protein-like substances. The use of THP in WAS increased the non-biodegradable soluble chemical oxygen demand (sCOD) after AD, from 1.1% to 4.9% of the total COD. The total ammoniacal nitrogen (TAN) concentration only slightly increased during THP without AD. However, after AD, TAN released was 34% higher in the THP-treated WAS compared to non-treated WAS, i.e., 36.7 ± 0.7 compared to 27.4 ± 0.4 mgTANreleased/gCODsubstrate, respectively. Results from modified specific methanogenic activities (mSMAs) tests showed that the organics solubilised during THP, were not inhibitory for acetotrophic methanogens. However, after AD of THP-treated sludge and WAS, the mSMA showed that all analysed samples presented strong inhibition on methanogenesis due to the presence of TAN and associated free ammonia nitrogen (FAN). In specific methanogenic activities (SMAs) tests with incremental concentration of TAN/FAN and melanoidins, TAN/FAN induced strong inhibition on methanogens, halving the SMA at around 2.5 gTAN/L and 100 mgFAN/L. Conversely, melanoidins did not show inhibition on the methanogens. Our present results revealed that when applying THP-AD in full-scale, the increase in TAN/FAN remarkably had a greater impact on AD than the formation of melanoidins.

Insights into methanogenesis of mesophilic-psychrophilic varied anaerobic digestion of municipal sludge with antibiotic stress

Methane production through anaerobic digestion (AD) of municipal sludge is economic and eco-friendly, which is commonly affected by temperature and pollutants residues. However, little is known about methanogenesis in psychrophilic AD (PAD) with temperature variations that simulating seasonal variations and with antibiotic stress. Here, two groups of AD systems with oxytetracycline (OTC) were operated with temperature maintained at 35 °C and 15 °C or variation to explore the influence to methanogenesis. The acetic acid was noticeably accumulated in OTC groups initially (P < 0.001). Methane production was noticeably inhibited initially in PAD with OTC, but had been stimulated later at 35 °C. The dominant acetoclastic methanogens Methanosaeta gradually decreased to 15.48% and was replaced by methylotrophic Methanomethylovorans (73.43%) in PAD with OTC. Correspondingly, the abundances of functional genes related to methylotrophic methanogenesis were also higher in these groups. Besides, genes involving in methane oxidation had over 50 times higher abundances in PAD with OTC groups in the second phase. Further investigation is essential to understand the main dynamics of methanogenesis in PAD and to clear the related molecular mechanism for future methane production regulation in sludge systems.

Medium-chain fatty acid production from thermal hydrolysed sludge without external electron donor supplementation

In this study, medium-chain fatty acid (MCFA) generation from mixed sludge (including primary sludge and waste activated sludge) was investigated without additional electron donors (EDs). 0.5 g COD/L of MCFAs was produced and the in situ generated ethanol could serve as the EDs during the anaerobic fermentation of mixed sludge without thermal hydrolysis process (THP) pretreatment. THP increased the MCFA production by approximately 128% in the anaerobic fermentation. During 102 days of operation, the fermentation of THP pre-treated mixed sludge stably generated 2.9 g COD/L MCFAs. The self-generated EDs could not maximize MCFA production, and external addition of ethanol improved MCFA yield. Caproiciproducens was the dominant chain-elongating bacteria. PICRUST2 revealed that both fatty acid biosynthesis and reverse β-oxidation pathways could participate in MCFA synthesis, and ethanol addition could enhance the contribution of the reverse β-oxidation pathway. Future studies should focus on the improvement of MCFA production from THP-assisted sludge fermentation.

1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium Chloride Affects Anaerobic Digestion through Altering Organics Transformation, Cell Viability, and Microbial Community

1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride (BmimCl), an imidazolium-based ionic liquid, is considered the representative emerging persistent aquatic pollutant, and its environmental toxicity has attracted a growing concern. However, most of the investigations focused on monocultures or a single organism, with little information available on the complex syntrophic consortium that dominates the complex and successional biochemical processes, such as anaerobic digestion. In this study, the effect of BmimCl at environmentally relevant levels on glucose anaerobic digestion was therefore investigated in several laboratory-scale mesophilic anaerobic digesters to provide such support. Experimental results showed that BmimCl at 1-20 mg/L inhibited the methane production rate by 3.50-31.03%, and 20 mg/L BmimCl inhibited butyrate, hydrogen, and acetate biotransformation by 14.29%, 36.36%, and 11.57%, respectively. Toxicological mechanism studies revealed that extracellular polymeric substances (EPSs) adsorbed and accumulated BmimCl through carboxyl, amino, and hydroxyl groups, which destroyed the EPSs' conformational structure, thereby leading to the inactivation of microbial cells. MiSeq sequencing data indicated that the abundance of Clostridium_sensu_stricto_1, Bacteroides, and Methanothrix decreased by 6.01%, 7.02%, and 18.45%, respectively, in response to 20 mg/L BmimCl. Molecular ecological network analysis showed that compared with the control, the lower network complexity, fewer keystone taxa, and fewer associations among microbial taxa were found in the BmimCl-present digester, indicating the reduced stability of the microbial community.

Contrasting archaeal and bacterial community assembly processes and the importance of rare taxa along a depth gradient in shallow coastal sediments

Marine microbial communities assemble along a sediment depth gradient and are responsible for processing organic matter. Composition of the microbial community along the depth is affected by various biotic and abiotic factors, e.g., the change of redox gradient, the availability of organic matter, and the interactions of different taxa. The community structure is also subjected to some random changes caused by stochastic processes of birth, death, immigration and emigration. However, the high-resolution shifts of microbial community and mechanisms of the vertical assembly processes in marine sediments remain poorly described. Archaeal and bacterial communities were analyzed based on 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing and metagenomes in the Bohai Sea sediment samples. The archaeal community was dominated by Thaumarchaeota with increased alpha diversity along depth. Proteobacteria was the dominant bacterial group with decreased alpha diversity as depth increased. Sampling sites and depths collectively affected the beta-diversity for both archaeal and bacterial communities. The dominant mechanism determining archaeal community assembly was determinism, which was mostly contributed by homogeneous selection, i.e., consistent selection pressures in different locations or depths. In contrast, bacterial community assembly was dominated by stochasticity. Co-occurrence networks among different taxa and key functional genes revealed a tight community with low modularity in the bottom sediment, and disproportionately more interactions among low abundant ASVs. This suggests a significant contribution to community stabilization by rare taxa, and suggests that the bottom layer, rather than surface sediments may represent a hotspot for benthic microbial interactions.

Genome-centric metagenomics analysis revealed the metabolic function of abundant microbial communities in thermal hydrolysis-assisted thermophilic anaerobic digesters under propionate stress

The ecological roles of microbial communities and how they interact with each other in thermal hydrolysis process (THP) assisted thermophilic anaerobic digestion (THP-AD) reactors remain largely unknown, especially under propionate stress. Two thermophilic THP-AD reactors had methane yield of 240-248 mL/g VS_added, but accumulated approximately 2000 mg/L propionate. Genome-centric metagenomics analysis showed that 68 metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) were recovered, 32 MAGs of which were substantially enriched. Firmicutes spp. dominated the enriched microbial community, including hydrolytic/fermentative bacteria and syntrophs. Methanogenic activities were mainly mediated by Methanosarcina sp. and Methanothermobacter spp. In addition to hydrogenotrophic methanogens, Thermodesulfovibrio sp. could also be a vital H₂ scavenger, contributing to maintaining low H₂ partial pressure in the bioreactors. The remarkable accumulation of propionate could be likely attributed to the weak syntrophic propionate-oxidizing activity or its absence. These findings advanced our knowledge about the mutualistic symbiosis of carbon metabolism in thermophilic THP-AD reactors.