Fluorine mass balance analysis of PFAS in communal waters at a wastewater plant from Austria

Temporal and spatial distribution of inorganic fluoride, total adsorbable organofluorine, PFOA and PFOS concentrations in the Hungarian section of the Danube River

The existing technologies in municipal wastewater treatment plants are ineffective in eliminating persistent fluorine-containing contaminants. At the same time, there is an increasing demand for novel organofluorine compounds, particularly in the production of lithium-ion batteries, as well as in the agrochemical and pharmaceutical sectors for more efficient ingredients. This implies that we must account for ongoing changes in the fluorine levels within riverine environments. To determine the fluorine concentration in the water phase of rivers, it is essential to measure both inorganic fluoride and total organofluorine concentrations. These analytes were measured in water samples collected monthly from twelve locations along the Hungarian section of the Danube River during the period from July to December 2023, applying ion-chromatography and combustion ion-chromatography. The concentration of inorganic fluoride ranged from 28 to 76 µg/L, with a median of 45.3 µg/L. The total adsorbable organofluorine concentrations were between 0.22 and 12.5 µg/L, with a median of 2.43 µg/L. To assess the impact of restrictions on the use of PFOA and PFOS compounds, these substances were quantified using a UHPLC-Q-TOF-MS system. A comparison of our data with previously published concentrations in the Danube River reveals a decreasing tendency, justifying the restricted use of these chemicals.

High organofluorine concentrations in municipal wastewater affect downstream drinking water supplies for millions of Americans

Wastewater receives per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from diverse consumer and industrial sources, and discharges are known to be a concern for drinking water quality. The PFAS family includes thousands of potential chemical structures containing organofluorine moieties. Exposures to a few well-studied PFAS, mainly perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAA), have been associated with increased risk of many adverse health outcomes, prompting federal drinking water regulations for six compounds in 2024. Here, we find that the six regulated PFAS (mean = 7 to 8%) and 18 measured PFAA (mean = 11 to 21%) make up only a small fraction of the extractable organofluorine (EOF) in influent and effluent from eight large municipal wastewater treatment facilities. Most of the EOF in influent (75%) and effluent (62%) consists of mono- and polyfluorinated pharmaceuticals. The treatment technology and sizes of the treatment facilities in this study are similar to those serving 70% of the US population. Despite advanced treatment technologies, the maximum EOF removal efficiency among facilities in this work was <25%. Extrapolating our measurements to other large facilities across the United States results in a nationwide EOF discharge estimate of 1.0 to 2.8 million moles F y-1. Using a national model that simulates connections between wastewater discharges and downstream drinking water intakes, we estimate that the sources of drinking water for up to 23 million Americans could be contaminated above regulatory thresholds by wastewater-derived PFAS alone. These results emphasize the importance of further curbing ongoing PFAS sources and additional evaluations of the fate and toxicity of fluorinated pharmaceuticals.

Assessment of Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity of Plasma-Treated Perfluorooctanesulfonate Containing Water Using In Vitro Bioassays

The contamination of ground and surface waters with per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) is of major concern due to their potential adverse effects on human health. The carbon-fluorine bond makes these compounds extremely stable and hardly degradable by natural processes. Therefore, methods for PFAS removal from water are desperately needed. In this context, plasma treatment of water has been proposed as an effective method with reported removal rates exceeding 90%. However, the high reactivity of plasma discharge results in the formation of many reactive species, like radicals, ozone, or even solvated electrons, which lead to a complex reaction cascade and, consequently, to the generation of a wide variety of different chemical products. The toxicological properties of these PFAS breakdown products are largely unknown. The present study focuses on a toxicological assessment of PFAS-containing plasma-treated water samples. Aqueous solutions of long-chain perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) were treated with various plasma-atmospheric regimes. Subsequently, plasma-treated water samples were subjected to in vitro bioassays. Cytotoxicity and genotoxicity were assessed with the MTS assay using human liver cells (HepG2) and the Ames MPFTM assay using Salmonella Typhimurium strains. Our results demonstrate varying cyto- and genotoxic properties of water containing PFAS breakdown products depending on the atmosphere present during plasma treatment. Based on the results of this study, the atmosphere used during plasma treatment affects the toxicological properties of the treated sample. Further studies are therefore needed to uncover the toxicological implications of the different treatment parameters, including the PFAS starting compound, the atmosphere during treatment, as well as the quantity of plasma energy applied.

Post-ICP Chemical Ionization MS for Total Extractable Organic Fluorine Quantitation

Total extractable organic fluorine (EOF) quantitation complements targeted analyses to ensure complete accounting of all fluorochemicals in a sample. Notably, the prevalence of perfluoroalkyl substances has increased the need for total EOF quantitation due to the myriad forms of these chemicals and the limited availability of standards for targeted analysis. Here, we evaluate postplasma chemical ionization mass spectrometry (MS), an approach developed to address the limitations of inductively coupled plasma (ICP)-MS in F analysis, for total EOF quantitation. Organofluorine-containing samples are introduced into an ICP, leading to the post-ICP formation of HF, which is then ionized to ScFNO3(H2O) n + and detected by quadrupole MS. We report optimal F detection across a wide range of ICP operating parameters, highlighting robust ion generation processes. We then compare sample introduction methods and show that a single-pass spray chamber mitigates volatility-related biases, yielding compound-independent F response factors and an instrumental detection limit of 2.2 ng of F mL-1 by using flow injections. This detection limit is 10-fold better than that offered by ICP-MS and comparable to that of combustion ion chromatography. Subsequently, we conduct total EOF quantitation of food contact paper products via methanolic extraction of 3 cm × 3 cm samples followed by 8-fold preconcentration with solid phase extraction and flow injections, achieving a detection limit of 1.2 ng F cm-2. We show that organic fluorine is detected on all 9 locally collected food contact paper products with total EOF contents of 22-363 ng F cm-2. These studies expand elemental MS capabilities in F analysis and highlight post-ICP chemical ionization MS as a facile total EOF quantitation technique.

Identification of emerging PFAS in industrial sludge from North China: Release risk assessment by the TOP assay

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) have been widely used across various industries, leading to their prevalent occurrence in sludges generated by wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Consequently, industrial sludges serve as typical reservoirs for PFAS. This study examined 46 target PFAS in sludge samples intended for brick production from nine WWTPs in North China, identifying emerging PFAS and categorizing their behaviors through high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) screening and total oxidizable precursor (TOP) assay. Forty-one PFAS were detected, with trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), perfluorooctane sulfonic acid, and hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid being the most prevalent. Twenty-nine emerging PFAS were identified, and their behaviors were categorized using TOP assay. Notably, four CF3-containing PFAS were identified, all confirmed as precursors of TFA, with a molar yield of 16.4 %-25.6 % in Milli-Q water during TOP assay validation. These findings indicate that the transformation of these precursors during sludge recycling may substantially contribute to TFA release, underscoring potential risks associated with secondary PFAS release during sludge resource utilization.

Exploring the variability of PFAS in urban sewage: a comparison of emissions in commercial versus municipal urban areas

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are recognized for their persistence and ubiquitous occurrence in different environmental compartments. Conventional wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) cannot effectively remove PFAS from wastewater, and a better understanding of the occurrence and sources of PFAS in this medium would enable effective source abatement. We compared sewage from urban areas exhibiting differentiating characteristics with respect to activities in their catchments. These included a sewer that serves primarily a municipal area, with no commercial activities involving PFAS emissions being identified, another sewer with a strong influence of commercial activities potentially related to PFAS emissions, and the influent of the whole city sewage network. The year-long monitoring campaign consisted of flow-proportional, monthly composite samples and targeted analysis of 29 PFAS compounds. Principal component analysis was used to investigate the relationships between selected PFAS and standard water quality parameters such as ammonium, a known tracer of urine and thus of typical municipal wastewater. Notable findings were seen for PFOS and 6:2 FTS, whose concentrations were most negatively correlated with ammonium. Ammonium concentration data allowed for a normalized per-person median load calculation, which resulted in loads of the observed PFAS ranging from below 0.4 up to 4.7 μg per person per day. Both the commercial area sewer and the city influent exhibited significantly higher (p < 0.05) median loads (>0.9 μg per person per day) in the case of 6:2 FTS and PFOS, compared to the municipal sewer (<0.6 μg per person per day). No statistically significant difference was found for other compounds, such as PFBA, PFHxA, PFOA, and PFHxS. We argue that this approach demonstrates that PFAS can differ in speciation and quantity within an urban wastewater setting, and consideration of both municipal and commercial activities is needed for a proper understanding of sources and emission pathways within the urban environment.

ICP-MS As a Contributing Tool to Nontarget Screening (NTS) Analysis for Environmental Monitoring

Due to the increasing number of chemicals released into the environment, nontarget screening (NTS) analysis is a necessary tool for providing comprehensive chemical analysis of environmental pollutants. However, NTS workflows encounter challenges in detecting both known and unknown pollutants with common chromatography high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) methods. Identification of unknowns is hindered by limited elemental composition information, and quantification without identical reference standards is prone to errors. To address these issues, we propose the use of inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) as an element-specific detector. ICP-MS can enhance the confidence of compound identification and improve quantification in NTS due to its element-specific response and unambiguous chemical composition information. Additionally, mass balance calculations for individual elements (F, Br, Cl, etc.) enable assessment of total recovery of those elements and evaluation of NTS workflows. Despite its benefits, implementing ICP-MS in NTS analysis and environmental regulation requires overcoming certain shortcomings and challenges, which are discussed herein.

Determination of total extractable organofluorine (EOF) in food contact materials and target and non-target analysis of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances using LC-MS/MS and LC-HRMS simultaneously coupled to ICP-MS

Food contact materials (FCMs) from three countries were analysed for all extractable organofluorines (EOFs) from the materials and subsequently by target and non-target analysis for per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). The EOF varied by two orders of magnitude for FCM from UK and Saudi Arabia ranging between 2.14 and 483 ng cm-2 (0.2-48 ng g-1) showing that one quarter of all samples were above the Danish regulation for PFAS in FCM. Target PFAS showed high variability in composition and accounted for less than 1% of the EOF. Non-target PFAS screening using HPLC-ICP-MS and coupled simultaneously to HRMS showed the occurrence of organofluorines which were identified by neither LC-MS/MS nor LC-HRMS. This illustrates that the current target PFAS approaches fail to identify EOFs from FCM, which would be a problem with the new EU proposal to ban all PFAS.

A source-based framework to estimate the annual load of PFAS in municipal wastewater

Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a class of persistent chemicals, whose impact has been observed in various environmental compartments. Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are considered a major emission pathway of PFAS, specifically in the context of the aquatic environment. The goal of this study was to develop a compartmentalized, source-based load estimation model of 7 PFAS within the municipal wastewater influent. Consumer statistics, data from literature on PFAS concentrations and release during use, and specific sampling activities for environmental flows in the related city were used to estimate per capita emission loads. Model results were compared with loads obtained through the monitoring campaign at the municipal WWTP influent. A wide range of discrepancies (≈5 % to ≈90 %) between loads observed in the WWTP influent and source based model estimates was noticed. The loads less accounted by the model were associated with sulfonic acids (PFSAs), whereas for carboxylic acids (PFCAs) most of the observed loads could be reasonably explained by the model, with even an overestimation of nearly 5 % noted for PFNA. Higher heterogeneity in sources was observed in the PFCA group, with a noticeable dominance in the share of consumer products. PFSAs had less of a consumer product input (<20 %), with the rest of the modelled load being attributed to environmental inputs. A large gap of unknown loads of PFSAs indicates a need for examination of other, not yet quantified activities that can potentially explain the remainder of the observed load. Especially commercial activities are considered as potential additional sources for PFSAs. These findings signify the importance of PFAS that originate from both consumer products, as well as environmental inputs in the overall load contribution into the sewage, while identifying the need for further investigation into commercial sources of PFAS emitted into the municipal wastewater.