Diagnostic Yield, Morbidity, and Mortality of Intraventricular Neuroendoscopic Biopsy: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Simultaneous Single-Trajectory Endoscopic Biopsy and Third Ventriculostomy in Pineal Region Tumors: A Systematic Review and Single Arm Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

To assess the efficacy and surgical outcomes of the simultaneous single-trajectory endoscopic biopsy and third ventriculostomy (ETV) in pineal region tumors.

METHODS

A systematic review and meta-analysis adhering to Cochrane Standards and PRISMA framework were conducted. PubMed, Embase, and Web Of Science databases were searched until December 2023. Outcomes included rate of histopathologic diagnosis success, ETV success, complications, required VPS, and mortality.

RESULTS

Seventeen studies (N = 388) met inclusion criteria. Histopathologic diagnosis success rate was 90% for general population (95% CI: 86%-95%; I2 = 42%) and 94% for pediatric patients (95% CI: 89%-98%; I2 = 19%). ETV Success rate was 93% (95% CI: 88%-97%; I2 = 60%). An estimated risk of postoperative ETV complications was found to be 16% for the general population (95% CI: 5%-28%; I2 = 90%) and 5% for pediatric patients (95% CI: 0%-13%; I2 = 51%). The risk of requiring VPS was estimated as 2% (95% CI: 0%-4%; I2 = 39%) and for the pediatric population it was 7% (95% CI: 0%-16%; I2 = 69%). Mortality risk was found to be 1% (95% CI: 0%-3%; I2 = 0%).

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous endoscopic biopsy and ETV demonstrated high diagnostic and therapeutic success rates. The procedure's safety profile, with low mortality and complications, supports its role in treating hydrocephalus associated to pineal region tumors. Subgroup analyses revealed higher diagnostic success rates and required VPS in the pediatric population, whilst it had lower complication rates.

Intraventricular Tumors: Surgical Considerations in Lateral and Third Ventricular Tumors

Management of lateral and third ventricular tumors has been a challenge for neurosurgeons. Advances in imaging and pathology have helped in a better understanding of the treatment options. Technical refinement of microsurgical technique and addition of endoscopy has enabled more radical excision of tumors, when indicated, and added more safety.A proper understanding of the pathology at various ages and treatment options is continuously evolving. Many pediatric tumors are amenable to conservative surgical methods with effective complementary treatments. However, radical surgery is required in many adults as the main treatment and for many benign tumors. Various intraventricular lesions encountered and their surgical management is reviewed here for their efficacy, safety, and outcome, encompassing changes in our practice over the last 20 years.

[Microsurgical ventriculostomy of the third ventricle with access through a burrhole in the treatment of midly located deep-seated brain tumors]

BACKGROUND

Currently, endoscopic third ventriculostomy and simultaneous biopsy of deep midline brain tumors are a generally accepted option in neurooncology. Nevertheless, effectiveness of this surgery and diagnostic accuracy of biopsy are not without drawbacks. An alternative to endoscopic surgery may be simultaneous microsurgical third ventriculostomy and biopsy of deep midline tumors.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate effectiveness and safety of burr hole microsurgical third ventriculostomy in the treatment of deep midline brain tumors.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We used transcortical (25 cases) and transcallosal (8 cases) approaches for microsurgical third ventriculostomy.

RESULTS

Initially scheduled biopsy was performed in 19 cases, partial resection in 6 cases, subtotal resection in 4 cases and total resection in 4 cases. All patients underwent microsurgical third ventriculostomy. In 12 cases, stenting of stoma was performed in addition to ventriculostomy. Biopsy was informative in all cases. Postoperative follow-up period ranged from 3 to 44 months (mean 29 months). There was no postoperative hydrocephalus and need for shunting procedure.

CONCLUSION

Burr hole microsurgery may be an alternative to endoscopic surgery for the treatment of pineal, periaqueductal and third ventricular tumors.

Results of the treatment of pineal tumors in children: the Lyon experience

INTRODUCTION

Pineal tumors are rare and their incidence is of 1% among all pediatric tumors of the central nervous system. Patient survival depends on the histology, the extension of the surgical removal, and the efficacy of the complementary treatment (chemotherapy and cranio-spinal irradiation), as well as the age of the patient.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this study, we analyzed 151 pediatric patients treated for pineal tumors from 1997 to 2020 in Lyon, France. All patients were recorded in the French Register of Pineal tumors, which has been centralized and maintained in Lyon since 2010.

RESULTS

Our analysis shows that benign tumors have an overall positive prognosis with total surgical removal. Concerning pineal parenchymal tumors, pinealoblastomas have a poor prognosis , especially in children less than three years old. A new pathological classification system allows for a better stratification of patient risk within different groups of patients with pineal tumors. It is also important to note that the identification of DICER 1 syndrome in families with pinealoblastomas warrant further medical investigation. Patients with Germ Cell Tumors have more favorable outcomes, with a global survival rate of 87 % and a pure germinoma survival rate of almost 97%. When analyzing the prognosis of pineal gland gliomas, otherwise known as tectal plate gliomas, pilocytic astrocytomas had a promising prognosis. Otherwise, prognosis of other tectal plate gliomas are related to the grade of malignancy and the efficacy of complementary treatment. Lastly, papillary tumors need a complete removal for the best chance of survival, and Atypical teratoid/ rabdoid tumors (AT/TR) still have a bad prognosis, regardless of surgical resection.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results show that, with regards to pediatric pineal region tumors, there are still areas in prognostic indicators that need to be improved. Similarly, these pathologies need to be treated via a multidisciplinary approach to improve a patient's survival rate and their quality of life.

Neuroendoscopy in the management of pineal region tumours in children

INTRODUCTION

Pineal region tumours (PRTs) are more common in children and represent a wide variety of lesions. The practise of a radiation test dose is obsolete and a biochemical/histological diagnosis is recommended before further therapy. Many patients present with hydrocephalus. Advances in neuroendoscopic techniques have allowed safe and effective management of this obstructive hydrocephalus with an opportunity to sample cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and obtain tissue for histopathology. Definitive surgery is required in less than a third. Endoscopic visualisation and assistance is increasingly used for radical resection, where indicated.

METHODOLOGY

Our experience of endoscopic surgery for paediatric PRTs from 2002 to 2021 is presented. All patients underwent MRI with contrast. Serum tumour markers were checked. If negative, endoscopic biopsy and endoscopic third ventriculostomy (ETV) were performed; and CSF collected for tumour markers and abnormal cells. For radical surgery, endoscope-assisted microsurgery procedures were performed to minimise retraction, visualise the extent of resection and confirm haemostasis.

RESULTS

M:F ratio was 2:1. The median age of presentation was 11 years. Raised ICP (88.88%) was the commonest mode of presentation. Nineteen patients had pineal tumours, one had a suprasellar and pineal tumour, one had disseminated disease, while six had tectal tumours. The ETB diagnosis rate was 95.45%, accuracy rate was 83.3% and ETV success rate was 86.96%.

CONCLUSION

Neuroendoscopy has revolutionised the management of paediatric PRTs. It is a safe and effective procedure with good diagnostic yield and allows successful concurrent CSF diversion, thereby avoiding major surgeries and shunt implantation. It is also helpful in radical resection of lesions, where indicated.

Hemorrhagic Complications After Brain Tumor Biopsy: Risk-Reduction Strategies Based on Safer Biopsy Targets and Techniques

OBJECTIVE

Brain tumor biopsies are essential for pathologic diagnosis. However, hemorrhagic complications after biopsies may occur, leading to suboptimal outcomes. This study aimed to evaluate the associated factors of hemorrhagic complications after brain tumor biopsies and propose countermeasures.

METHODS

We retrospectively collected data on 208 consecutive patients with brain tumors (malignant lymphoma or glioma) who underwent a biopsy from 2011-2020. We evaluated factors and microbleeds (MBs) in the tumor plus relative cerebral/tumoral blood flow (rCBF) at the biopsy site on preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

RESULTS

Postoperative all and symptomatic hemorrhage occurred in 21.6% and 9.6% of patients. In univariate analysis, a needle biopsy was significantly associated with the risk of all and symptomatic hemorrhages compared to techniques that allow adequate hemostatic manipulation (i.e., open and endoscopic biopsies). Multivariate analyses revealed that a needle biopsy and gliomas of World Health Organization (WHO) grade III/IV were significantly associated with postoperative all and symptomatic hemorrhages. Multiple lesions were also an independent risk factor for symptomatic hemorrhages. On preoperative MRI, abundant MBs in the tumor and MBs at the biopsy sites, in addition to high rCBF, were significantly associated with postoperative all and symptomatic hemorrhages.

CONCLUSIONS

We recommend the following measures to prevent hemorrhagic complications: consider biopsy techniques that allow adequate hemostatic manipulation preferentially; perform more careful hemostasis in cases of suspected gliomas of WHO grade III/IV, multiple lesions, and abundant MBs in the tumors; and, if there are multiple candidate biopsy sites, select areas with lower rCBF and no MBs as a biopsy target.

Outcome of endoscopic transcortical intraventricular biopsy of isolated thickened pituitary stalk lesions in children

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the efficacy and safety of endoscopic transcortical intraventricular biopsy in pediatric patients with isolated thickened pituitary stalk lesions.

METHODS

From 1994 to 2018, 16 pediatric patients (8 males and 8 females) underwent endoscopic transcortical intraventricular biopsy at a single institution to establish an accurate pathological diagnosis for appropriate treatment strategies.

RESULTS

Preoperatively, the median diameter of the pituitary stalks was 5.31 ± 1.67 mm (range 3.86-9.17 mm). Overall, the diagnostic yield at endoscopic intraventricular biopsy was 93.8%. Histopathological diagnosis included germinoma (n = 10, 62.5%), Langerhans cell histiocytosis (n = 4, 25%), pilocytic astrocytoma (n = 1, 6.3%), and pituicytoma (n = 1, 6.3%). Two patients developed new diabetes insipidus after the procedure, and 3 patients had new postoperative hypothyroidism. There were no postoperative neurological deficits in this series.

CONCLUSIONS

Neuroendoscopic biopsy via the transcortical intraventricular corridor was shown to be safe and to aid in a reliable histopathological diagnosis in the management of isolated pituitary stalk lesions in pediatric patients. It can be considered a minimally invasive alternative to open biopsy via transcranial or endonasal corridors.

Cytologic Features of Ventricular Tumors of the Central Nervous System: A Review with Emphasis on Diff-Quik Stained Smears

BACKGROUND

Neoplasms from the ventricular system share a common location but have highly variable histogenesis. Many are slowly growing tumors that behave in a benign fashion. They can be classified as primary and secondary tumors. The most common primary tumors are ependymomas, subependymomas, subependymal giant cell astrocytomas, central neurocytomas, choroid plexus tumors, meningiomas, germinomas, pineal parenchymal tumors, papillary tumors of the pineal region, chordoid gliomas, rosette-forming glioneuronal tumors of the fourth ventricle, and craniopharyngiomas. Pilocytic astrocytomas, medulloblastomas, and atypical teratoid/rhabdoid tumors often show secondary involvement of the ventricular system.

SUMMARY

Advances in neurosurgery have facilitated access to the ventricular system increasing the number of cases in which such tumors can be biopsied. In this context, cytology has been proven to be an extremely useful diagnostic tool during intraoperative pathologic consultations. Many ventricular tumors are infrequent, and the cytologic information available is limited. In this review, we describe the cytologic features of the uncommon ventricular tumors and report on unusual findings of the more common ones. For the cytologic evaluation of brain tumors, many neuropathologists prefer formalin fixation and hematoxylin and eosin staining. In this review, we highlight the cytologic findings as seen with Diff-Quik, a very popular staining method among cytopathologists. In fact, when pathologists are unfamiliar with cytology, it is common to request the assistance of cytopathologists during the evaluation of intraoperative procedures. Key Message: Ventricular tumors of the central nervous system comprise a group of heterogeneous tumors with very different cytologic features. The cytomorphology of these tumors, including rare entities, is often very characteristic, allowing a precise recognition during intraoperative pathologic consultations. Diff-Quik is a valuable staining method that can be used alone or as a complement to hematoxylin and eosin staining. Diff-Quik allows for clear visualization of the overall architecture, cytoplasmic details, and extracellular material.

Endoscopic versus stereotactic biopsies of intracranial lesions involving the ventricles

Stereotactic biopsies of ventricular lesions may be less safe and less accurate than biopsies of superficial lesions. Accordingly, endoscopic biopsies have been increasingly used for these lesions. Except for pineal tumors, the literature lacks clear, reliable comparisons of these two methods. All 1581 adults undergoing brain tumor biopsy from 2007 to 2018 were retrospectively assessed. We selected 119 patients with intraventricular or paraventricular lesions considered suitable for both stereotactic and endoscopic biopsies. A total of 85 stereotactic and 38 endoscopic biopsies were performed. Extra procedures, including endoscopic third ventriculostomy and tumor cyst aspiration, were performed simultaneously in 5 stereotactic and 35 endoscopic cases. In 9 cases (5 stereotactic, 4 endoscopic), the biopsies were nondiagnostic (samples were nondiagnostic or the results differed from those obtained from the resected lesions). Three people died: 2 (1 stereotactic, 1 endoscopic) from delayed intraventricular bleeding and 1 (stereotactic) from brain edema. No permanent morbidity occurred. In 6 cases (all stereotactic), additional surgery was required for hydrocephalus within the first month postbiopsy. Rates of nondiagnostic biopsies, serious complications, and additional operations were not significantly different between groups. Mortality was higher after biopsy of lesions involving the ventricles, compared with intracranial lesions in any location (2.4% vs 0.3%, p = 0.016). Rates of nondiagnostic biopsies and complications were similar after endoscopic or stereotactic biopsies. Ventricular area biopsies were associated with higher mortality than biopsies in any brain area.

Visual-Controlled Endoscopic Biopsy of Paraventricular Intraparenchymal Tumors

OBJECTIVE

Frame-based stereotaxy represents the gold standard for biopsy of deep-seated lesions. Visual control of possible bleeding in these lesions is not possible. Neuroendoscopic biopsy represents an alternative procedure for tissue sampling in deep-seated intraventricular lesions. The authors present a technique for transventricular-navigated endoscopic biopsy of lesions that are located in the paraventricular region.

METHODS

Biopsy of paraventricular pathologies was performed in 6 male and 6 female patients between March 2013 and September 2018. The patient age ranged from 18 to 82 years. All patients underwent a pure endoscopic procedure over a burr hole trepanation supported by frameless navigation of the sedan probe.

RESULTS

Histologic diagnoses were established in all biopsies. In all patients, a direct control of the biopsy area was feasible, and hemostasis could be obtained. In 5 patients, endoscopic third ventriculostomy was performed first due to obstructive hydrocephalus. In 1 patient suffering from obstructive hydrocephalus, a pellucidotomy was performed. In 9 cases, the initial postoperative course was uneventful. Three patients suffered from persistent hydrocephalus and had to be treated with ventriculoperitoneal shunt insertion.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopically conducted biopsies with the aid of navigated tracking of the probe represent a possible additional technique in selected paraventricular intraparenchymal pathologies. The endoscopic approach enables the direct visualization of the intraventricular surface and its vessels. In contrast to standard stereotactic biopsy, direct visual control of hemostasis can be obtained even in paraventricular tumors.

Pitfalls of Neuroendoscopic Biopsy of Intraventricular Germ Cell Tumors

OBJECTIVE

A neuroendoscopic biopsy has become common for the diagnosis of ventricular tumors. However, its utility in patients with germ cell tumors (GCTs) has not been well discussed. We examined the usefulness and pitfalls of neuroendoscopic biopsies of intraventricular GCTs at a single institution.

METHODS

We retrospectively studied 21 consecutive patients diagnosed with GCTs by a neuroendoscopic biopsy of the ventricular region via the lateral ventricle. We examined the localization of tumors, histologic diagnoses using biopsies, surgical complications, and consistency of the diagnosis at the latest follow-up.

RESULTS

Tumor specimens were obtained from a pineal lesion (n = 20), neurohypophysial lesion (n = 5), and lateral ventricular wall lesion (n = 2). In 5 patients, the specimens were obtained from multiple areas. The initial diagnoses were pure germinoma (n = 16), immature teratoma (n = 1), yolk sac tumor (n = 1), and mixed GCT (n = 3). Six of 21 patients needed a second transcranial removal of enhanced residual lesions in the course of the treatment. A discrepancy in the histologic diagnosis between 2 surgeries occurred in 3 patients: All 3 patients had a new diagnosis of teratoma component following transcranial surgery. No postoperative mortality or permanent morbidity related to the neuroendoscopic procedures was noted.

CONCLUSION

Neuroendoscopic biopsies are safe and useful for obtaining reliable histologic diagnoses in the management of GCTs. However, for GCTs with mixed histology, biopsies are susceptible to diagnostic errors, especially missing detecting a component of teratoma.

Robot-assisted procedures in pediatric neurosurgery

OBJECTIVE

During the last 3 decades, robotic technology has rapidly spread across several surgical fields due to the continuous evolution of its versatility, stability, dexterity, and haptic properties. Neurosurgery pioneered the development of robotics, with the aim of improving the quality of several procedures requiring a high degree of accuracy and safety. Moreover, robot-guided approaches are of special interest in pediatric patients, who often have altered anatomy and challenging relationships between the diseased and eloquent structures. Nevertheless, the use of robots has been rarely reported in children. In this work, the authors describe their experience using the ROSA device (Robotized Stereotactic Assistant) in the neurosurgical management of a pediatric population.

METHODS

Between 2011 and 2016, 116 children underwent ROSA-assisted procedures for a variety of diseases (epilepsy, brain tumors, intra- or extraventricular and tumor cysts, obstructive hydrocephalus, and movement and behavioral disorders). Each patient received accurate preoperative planning of optimal trajectories, intraoperative frameless registration, surgical treatment using specific instruments held by the robotic arm, and postoperative CT or MR imaging.

RESULTS

The authors performed 128 consecutive surgeries, including implantation of 386 electrodes for stereo-electroencephalography (36 procedures), neuroendoscopy (42 procedures), stereotactic biopsy (26 procedures), pallidotomy (12 procedures), shunt placement (6 procedures), deep brain stimulation procedures (3 procedures), and stereotactic cyst aspiration (3 procedures). For each procedure, the authors analyzed and discussed accuracy, timing, and complications.

CONCLUSIONS

To the best their knowledge, the authors present the largest reported series of pediatric neurosurgical cases assisted by robotic support. The ROSA system provided improved safety and feasibility of minimally invasive approaches, thus optimizing the surgical result, while minimizing postoperative morbidity.

A multiport MR-compatible neuroendoscope: spanning the gap between rigid and flexible scopes

OBJECTIVE Rigid endoscopes enable minimally invasive access to the ventricular system; however, the operative field is limited to the instrument tip, necessitating rotation of the entire instrument and causing consequent tissue compression while reaching around corners. Although flexible endoscopes offer tip steerability to address this limitation, they are more difficult to control and provide fewer and smaller working channels. A middle ground between these instruments-a rigid endoscope that possesses multiple instrument ports (for example, one at the tip and one on the side)-is proposed in this article, and a prototype device is evaluated in the context of a third ventricular colloid cyst resection combined with septostomy. METHODS A prototype neuroendoscope was designed and fabricated to include 2 optical ports, one located at the instrument tip and one located laterally. Each optical port includes its own complementary metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS) chip camera, light-emitting diode (LED) illumination, and working channels. The tip port incorporates a clear silicone optical window that provides 2 additional features. First, for enhanced safety during tool insertion, instruments can be initially seen inside the window before they extend from the scope tip. Second, the compliant tip can be pressed against tissue to enable visualization even in a blood-filled field. These capabilities were tested in fresh porcine brains. The image quality of the multiport endoscope was evaluated using test targets positioned at clinically relevant distances from each imaging port, comparing it with those of clinical rigid and flexible neuroendoscopes. Human cadaver testing was used to demonstrate third ventricular colloid cyst phantom resection through the tip port and a septostomy performed through the lateral port. To extend its utility in the treatment of periventricular tumors using MR-guided laser therapy, the device was designed to be MR compatible. Its functionality and compatibility inside a 3-T clinical scanner were also tested in a brain from a freshly euthanized female pig. RESULTS Testing in porcine brains confirmed the multiport endoscope's ability to visualize tissue in a blood-filled field and to operate inside a 3-T MRI scanner. Cadaver testing confirmed the device's utility in operating through both of its ports and performing combined third ventricular colloid cyst resection and septostomy with an endoscope rotation of less than 5°. CONCLUSIONS The proposed design provides freedom in selecting both the number and orientation of imaging and instrument ports, which can be customized for each ventricular pathological entity. The lightweight, easily manipulated device can provide added steerability while reducing the potential for the serious brain distortion that happens with rigid endoscope navigation. This capability would be particularly valuable in treating hydrocephalus, both primary and secondary (due to tumors, cysts, and so forth). Magnetic resonance compatibility can aid in endoscope-assisted ventricular aqueductal plasty and stenting, the management of multiloculated complex hydrocephalus, and postinflammatory hydrocephalus in which scarring obscures the ventricular anatomy.

Endoscopic Versus Stereotactic Procedure for Pineal Tumor Biopsies: Focus on Overall Efficacy Rate

OBJECTIVE

The management of pineal region tumors depends on the histologic subtypes. Two minimally invasive techniques are available: endoscopic intraventricular biopsies and stereotactic biopsies. The recent Southampton and Lille series are the largest endoscopic and stereotactic series of pineal region tumors reporting both diagnosis rate and accuracy rate, respectively; we elaborated on these results in the light of other recent studies.

METHODS

We compared the Southampton endoscopic series with the Lille series, reflecting our 25-year experience of stereotactic biopsies, and the metadata of the literature for both approaches, as reported in the 2013 Report of the French-Speaking Society of Neurosurgery on tumors of the pineal region.

RESULTS

The results of the Southampton series match the endoscopic literature, in particular regarding the diagnosis rate (81.2%) and the perioperative morbidity (25.0%), and provide a rarely reported accuracy rate (78.6%), giving access to the overall efficacy rate (63.8%). The results of the Lille series match the stereotactic literature and show better results than endoscopic biopsies concerning the diagnosis rate (98.9%), accuracy rate (100%), resulting overall efficacy rate (98.9%), and perioperative morbidity (6.4%).

CONCLUSIONS

The Southampton and Lille series provide a unique opportunity to compare the overall efficacy rates of endoscopic and stereotactic biopsies, respectively. The stereotactic approach is safer and more effective for biopsies of pineal region tumors. To improve the safety and reliability of endoscopic biopsies, various methods have to be evaluated: alternative burr-hole strategies, use of neuronavigation, and a combination of flexible and rigid endoscopes.