Endoscopic versus Open Microsurgical Excision of Colloid Cysts: A Comparative Analysis and State-of-the-Art Review of Neurosurgical Techniques

Isolated entrapment of the lateral ventricle after neuroendoscopic resection of colloid cysts: single - center experience and management

BACKGROUND

A minimally invasive option of colloid cyst surgical treatment is endoscopic resection, well validated in various reports and clinical practice. A rare complication of the surgical treatment, previously reported only once in literature, is the entrapment of the lateral ventricle. In this study we aim to outline our experience in the management of this occurrence, hypothesizing possible etiopathogenetic causes.

METHODS

Among patients who underwent neuroendoscopic resection for a colloid cysts at our Institution between 2013 and 2022, cases who developed a postoperative lateral ventricle entrapment were retrospectively reviewed and included. Clinical history, imaging and treatment were reported.

RESULTS

Among 34 patients treated for a colloid cysts, two (5.9 %) patients developed an ipsilateral ventricular entrapment with dilation from two to five months after the resection. Both patients were substantially asymptomatic and neurologically intact, and therefore treated conservatively. One case underwent complete spontaneous radiological resolution one month later, and the other one has remained neurological asymptomatic at follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Isolated asymptomatic ventricular entrapment with significant dilation after endoscopic colloid cyst resection is a rare occurrence which can be plausibly caused by scar tissue at the level of the foramen of Monro. Because they can have an indolent course with spontaneous resolution, conservative treatment is a viable option, with strict radiological and clinical follow - up. Given the rarity of the occurrence, further studies with larger cohorts are warranted to confirm the etiopathogenetic hypothesis and validate the clinical management.

Use of a neuro-evacuation device for the endoscopic removal of third ventricle colloid cysts

Background

Colloid cysts are benign tumors usually located at the level of the foramen of Monro and account for approximately 1% of all intracranial tumors. Endoscopic surgical treatment represents the approach of choice for removal of these tumors and is usually preferred over transcortical or transcallosal microsurgical approaches. Our purpose is to demonstrate the feasibility of endoscopic removal of colloid cysts using a novel aspiration and fragmentation system, currently designed for evacuation of cerebral hematomas.

Methods

We performed an evaluation of the results obtained in patients with symptomatic colloid cysts of the third ventricle operated on using an endoscopic neuroevacuation system (Artemis Neuro Evacuation Device, Penumbra, Alameda, California, USA) between April 2020 and April 2022. Instrumentation and surgical technique are described in detail. All patients underwent postoperative MRI to assess the extent of cyst removal.

Results

Five patients were included in our study. The predominant symptom at onset was headache. No intraoperative complications related to the technology in use occurred. The surgical time for the cyst removal was significantly shorter than removal via a standard endoscopic technique (80 vs. 120 min). Removal was complete, both content and capsule of the cyst, in all patients. In all cases there was a complete regression of the previously complained symptoms.

Conclusion

The Artemis Neuro Evacuation Device has proved to be effective and safe in removal of colloid cysts of the third ventricle and may be proposed as a possible alternative or as a complement of the standard instruments routinely used in neuroendoscopy.

Trascallosal bilateral transforaminal resection of a solid partially calcified colloid cyst: 2D operative video

BACKGROUND

Colloid cysts are benign lesions of the roof of the third ventricle, often diagnosed incidentally; sometimes they can cause hydrocephalus due to obstruction of the foramina of Monroe. Symptomatic cysts could be resected either microsurgically (transcallosal or transcortical) or endoscopically. Although both strategies are effective and have advantages and disadvantages, there is no consensus on the choice of the optimal approach. Transcallosal resection, although more invasive than endoscopy, allows adequate bimanual manipulation of the cyst and is associated with high rates of complete resection, the use of neuronavigator and intraoperative ultrasound optimizes surgical trajectory and improves safety of the procedure with complication rates comparable to endoscopy. Endoscopy is less invasive but complete resection of solid cysts can be challenging.

CASE DESCRIPTION

In Video 1, we show resection of a solid partially calcified colloid cyst using a transcallosal bilateral transforaminal approach to anterior third ventricle male, 65 years old; headache and mild memory impairment for 6 months; admitted at our emergency department because of a brief loss of consciousness. Neurologic examination was normal. Computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed a colloid cyst at the level of anterior third of the third ventricle (1.5 cm in diameter) with hypointense appearance in T2 sequences suggesting a solid calcific component. The ventricular system was enlarged. Colloid cyst risk score 3/5 (diameter >0.7 cm, headache, risk zone I) considered an intermediate-risk subgroup according to Alford et al. On this basis, we proposed the surgical treatment. We chose a transcallosal microsurgical resection. The patient gave consent for the procedure. A preoperative planning with a computer-generated 3D model is performed to simulate the approach. Craniotomy, interhemispheric dissection, and callosotomy were planned with the neuronavigator and with the aid of intraoperative ultrasound to optimize the trajectory and perform a limited and tailored callosotomy. The 1.5 cm callosotomy allows to approach both lateral ventricles, the cyst was progressively dissected working bilaterally through both foramina of Monroe without injuries of the fornices. Resection at term is complete. Postoperative MRI and CT scan confirmed complete excision without complications; the patient was discharged after a week in good neurological condition with complete regression of headache.

CONCLUSION

Microscopic transcallosal resection of the colloid cyst of the third ventricle allows for complete resection with low complication rates. The use of preoperative 3D planning and integrated neuronavigation with intraoperative ultrasound helps to reduce invasiveness.

Outcomes and complications of microscopic transcallosal colloid cyst resection: A single institution experience

Background:

Colloid cysts have always provoked the interest of neurosurgeons due to their benign histology, wide variety of clinical presentations, and differences in reported surgical outcomes. Although recent studies have reported favorable outcomes with different surgical resection approaches, the transcallosal approach remains the most popular approach to date. In this series, we report the clinical and radiological outcomes of the transcallosal approach for the resection of third ventricle colloid cysts in 12 patients.

Methods:

We present a case series of 12 patients who were radiologically diagnosed with a third ventricle colloid cyst who underwent transcallosal resection by a single surgeon in one center over a 6-year period. Clinical, radiological, and surgical data were collected, and surgical outcomes and complications were analyzed.

Results:

Of the 12 patients diagnosed with colloid cysts, 10 (83%) presented with headache, and five (41%) presented with memory disturbance. All 12 patients showed improvement or resolution of their symptoms following resection. Nine patients (75%) presented with hydrocephalus on radiology. All the patients required preoperative or intraoperative external ventricular drain insertion. Four patients (33%) experienced transient postoperative complications. None of the patients required long-term cerebrospinal fluids shunting. One (8%) of 12 patients experienced transient memory loss. No mortality was recorded during the follow-up.

Conclusion:

Transcallosal resection of colloid cysts has a favorable prognosis. It allows for complete resection of the cyst with minimal transient postoperative complications. Most patients with postoperative complications show complete resolution of symptoms, with no long-term morbidity.

Structural Brain Network Reorganization Following Anterior Callosotomy for Colloid Cysts: Connectometry and Graph Analysis Results

Introduction:

The plasticity of the neural circuits after injuries has been extensively investigated over the last decades. Transcallosal microsurgery for lesions affecting the third ventricle offers an interesting opportunity to investigate the whole-brain white matter reorganization occurring after a selective resection of the genu of the corpus callosum (CC).

Method

Diffusion MRI (dMRI) data and neuropsychological testing were collected pre- and postoperatively in six patients with colloid cysts, surgically treated with a transcallosal-transgenual approach. Longitudinal connectometry analysis on dMRI data and graph analysis on structural connectivity matrix were implemented to analyze how white matter pathways and structural network topology reorganize after surgery.

Results

Although a significant worsening in cognitive functions (e.g., executive and memory functioning) at early postoperative, a recovery to the preoperative status was observed at 6 months. Connectometry analysis, beyond the decrease of quantitative anisotropy (QA) near the resection cavity, showed an increase of QA in the body and forceps major CC subregions, as well as in the left intra-hemispheric corticocortical associative fibers. Accordingly, a reorganization of structural network topology was observed between centrality increasing in the left hemisphere nodes together with a rise in connectivity strength among mid and posterior CC subregions and cortical nodes.

Conclusion

A structural reorganization of intra- and inter-hemispheric connective fibers and structural network topology were observed following the resection of the genu of the CC. Beyond the postoperative transient cognitive impairment, it could be argued anterior CC resection does not preclude neural plasticity and may subserve the long-term postoperative cognitive recovery.

Giant Colloid Cyst

Giant colloid cysts are defined as cysts of more than 3 cm in maximal diameter. Few cases of giant colloid cysts have been reported in the literature. We herein describe a giant colloid cyst. A 15-year-old female presented with headache, blurred vision, and episodic behavioral changes for three months. Neurological examination was limited due to agitation and confusion. Fundoscopy was notable for bilateral papilledema. Brain CT revealed a giant third-ventricular lesion, causing obstructive hydrocephalus. The patient underwent urgent ventriculoperitoneal shunt insertion initially and then cyst excision. The histopathological sections of the lesion were compatible with a colloid cyst. Five years following surgical resection, a brain MRI did not demonstrate any evidence of residual or cyst recurrence. To our knowledge, giant colloid cysts have been rarely reported and pose a management dilemma in the literature. The present article highlights the symptomatology, radiological findings, and outcome of a giant colloid cyst.

Decision-Making and Management in a Patient With Coexistent Colloid Cyst and Pituitary Macroadenoma: A Case Report

The coexistence of separate and distinct primary intracranial tumors is rare. Specifically, there are no previous reports of a colloid cyst coexisting with a pituitary macroadenoma. We present the case of a 40-year-old male with a colloid cyst associated with mild enlargement of the right lateral ventricle and a coexistent pituitary macroadenoma with compression of the optic apparatus. An endoscopic endonasal transsphenoidal surgery (EETS) for resection of the pituitary mass was performed first due to the patient’s complaints of acute visual changes. He then underwent a right frontal craniotomy for resection of the colloid cyst one month later. The patient recovered without residual deficits in vision, and he did not require ventricular shunting after removal of the colloid cyst. We aimed to discuss our decision-making process and the management of these coexistent lesions. 

Pediatric colloid cysts: a multinational, multicenter study. An IFNE-ISPN-ESPN collaboration

OBJECTIVE

Colloid cysts (CCs) are rare at all ages, and particularly among children. The current literature on pediatric CC is limited, and often included in mixed adult/pediatric series. The goal of this multinational, multicenter study was to combine forces among centers and investigate the clinical course of pediatric CCs.

METHODS

A multinational, multicenter retrospective study was performed to attain a large sample size, focusing on CC diagnosis in patients younger than 18 years of age. Collected data included clinical presentation, radiological characteristics, treatment, and outcome.

RESULTS

One hundred thirty-four children with CCs were included. Patient age at diagnosis ranged from 2.4 to 18 years (mean 12.8 ± 3.4 years, median 13.2 years, interquartile range 10.3-15.4 years; 22% were < 10 years of age). Twenty-two cases (16%) were diagnosed incidentally, including 48% of those younger than 10 years of age. Most of the other patients had symptoms related to increased intracranial pressure and hydrocephalus. The average follow-up duration for the entire group was 49.5 ± 45.8 months. Fifty-nine patients were initially followed, of whom 28 were eventually operated on at a mean of 19 ± 32 months later due to cyst growth, increasing hydrocephalus, and/or new symptoms. There was a clear correlation between larger cysts and symptomatology, acuteness of symptoms, hydrocephalus, and need for surgery. Older age was also associated with the need for surgery. One hundred three children (77%) underwent cyst resection, 60% using a purely endoscopic approach. There was 1 death related to acute hydrocephalus at presentation. Ten percent of operated patients had some form of complication, and 7.7% of operated cases required a shunt at some point during follow-up. Functional outcome was good; however, the need for immediate surgery was associated with educational limitations. Twenty operated cases (20%) experienced a recurrence of their CC at a mean of 38 ± 46 months after the primary surgery. The CC recurrence rate was 24% following endoscopic resection and 15% following open resections (p = 0.28).

CONCLUSIONS

CCs may present in all pediatric age groups, although most that are symptomatic present after the age of 10 years. Incidentally discovered cysts should be closely followed, as many may grow, leading to hydrocephalus and other new symptoms. Presentation of CC may be acute and may cause life-threatening conditions related to hydrocephalus, necessitating urgent treatment. The outcome of treated children with CCs is favorable.