Stigma experienced by patients with epilepsy: A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative studies

Determination of stigma and attitude in relatives of patients with epilepsy

PURPOSE

This study was conducted to determine stigma and attitudes in the relatives of patients with epilepsy and the factors affecting them.

METHODS

This descriptive and cross-sectional study was conducted with 173 relatives of patients with epilepsy who were admitted to the neurology outpatient clinic of a university hospital in Van Province, eastern Turkey, between April and December 2021. Individual information forms, the Epilepsy Stigma Scale Patient's Relative, and the Epilepsy Attitude Scale were used to collect the data.

RESULTS

The mean stigma score was 54.58 (standard deviation [SD] = 10.96), and the mean attitude score was 53.05 (SD = 8.14). A negative and significant correlation was found between stigma score and attitude score (r = -0.457, p < 0.001). It was found that stigma and attitude scores differed significantly in terms of education, hiding epilepsy, and the idea that epilepsy is related to spiritual thoughts (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

As a result of this study, it was found that the relatives of patients with epilepsy were generally moderately stigmatized (64.8 %) and had moderate attitudes toward epilepsy. As the stigma increased in the participants, it was determined that they showed more negative attitudes toward epilepsy. The results indicated that relatives of patients with epilepsy who had one or more seizures per month experienced more stigma, and relatives of patients with epilepsy who did not take their medication regularly exhibited a more negative attitude toward epilepsy.

A multicultural comparative study of self-stigma in epilepsy: Differences across four cultures

OBJECTIVE

Epilepsy is a neurological disorder characterized by recurrent seizures, exhibiting variance in prevalence and treatment availability across diverse geopolitical contexts and cultural milieus. The stigma associated with epilepsy is a significant global issue affecting the quality of life (QOL) of people with epilepsy (PWE). This study aims to examine the relationship between self-stigma and depressive symptoms in PWE, with a particular emphasis on understanding the manifestations of these across different cultural contexts. We aim to enhance the provision of customized care to diverse cultural settings, fostering the adoption of healthier lifestyles for PWE.

METHODS

We recruited PWE who received treatment at specialized medical facilities for epilepsy in Japan, Malaysia (Chinese, Malay), and Turkey from February to October 2023. The Epilepsy Self-Stigma Scales (ESSS), Neurological Disorders Depression Inventory for Epilepsy (NDDI-E), and Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7 (GAD-7) in local languages were used to assess self-stigma, depressive symptoms, and anxiety.

RESULTS

The ESSS total scores were significantly higher among the Turkish and Japanese cohorts (F [3, 406] = 6.57, p < 0.001, η2 = 0.05). In addition, the self-stigma observed moderate positive correlations for depressive symptoms (rs = 0.41-0.50, Ps < 0.001) and anxiety (rs = 0.42-0.44, Ps < 0.001). The ANCOVA findings suggested that the notable variations in self-stigma, as found in the one-way ANOVA conducted across four cultures, were reduced when taking into consideration depressed symptoms. Our finding highlights the potential influence of mental health factors over cultural factors concerning self-stigma.

SIGNIFICANCE

The manifestation of self-stigmatization within epilepsy exhibits distinctions across diverse cultural cohorts, regardless of the demographic and clinical variation, yet demonstrates a significant correlation with psychological factors. In subsequent research endeavors, we should comprehensively investigate these subtle differences, their potential impact on patient care, and the development of supportive approaches.

PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY

This cross-cultural study reveals significant variations in self-stigma among people with epilepsy across different cultural contexts, with Turkish and Japanese cohorts showing higher levels. Self-stigma demonstrated moderate positive correlations with depressive symptoms and anxiety across all cultures. Notably, differences in self-stigma were reduced when accounting for depressive symptoms, suggesting that mental health factors may have a stronger influence than cultural factors. These findings underscore the importance of considering both cultural and psychological aspects in developing targeted interventions to address self-stigma in epilepsy care.

Living with epilepsy in adolescence and young adulthood transitioning from pediatric to adult hospital services: A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative studies

BACKGROUND

Transition is characterized by developing greater self-identity and growing independence, but adolescents dealing with chronic illnesses encounter health-related and situational changes during transition. Despite the many suggestions made in recent years, the shift from pediatric to adult care continues to pose difficulties for adolescents and young adults with epilepsy (AWE). The holistic perspective of AWE's experiences and needs during transition is not as well understood.

AIM

To synthesize the qualitative evidence related to AWE's experiences and needs transitioning from pediatric to adult hospital care.

METHODS

This systematic review adhered to the rigorous Joanna Briggs methodology for qualitative evidence synthesis. A comprehensive search was conducted across multiple databases, including PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, Embase, PsycINFO, and ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global, from their inception to April 2024. The findings were critically appraised and aggregated using meta-synthesis.

RESULTS

The search yielded a total of 3,985 studies, and twenty-one were included in the review. Two of the included studies were undertaken in a program where a transition clinic was established. The meta-synthesis reveals that the transition experience of AWE is more than a change from one clinic to another and is interwoven into a pattern of developmental, health-illness, situational, and organizational transition issues. Five synthesized findings were developed: 1) Feeling different from others and striving to address the impact of epilepsy in everyday life; 2) the transition from pediatric to adult care - a problematic intersection point; 3) the family's role - support or parental overprotectiveness 4) seeking knowledge and being familiar with epilepsy supported by healthcare professionals and technologies, and 5) development of independence and responsibility through involvement and support from healthcare professionals and parents.

CONCLUSION

During the transition from pediatric to adult hospital care, AWEs encounter a loss of familiarity, increased responsibility, and feelings of not belonging. Therefore, it is essential to create an environment where they can thrive beyond the limitations of their illness. Understanding, acceptance, and inclusivity should characterize this environment to support AWEs in facilitating the development of responsibility, independence, and confidence as they navigate transitions.

Assessment of stigmatization and self-esteem in patients with epilepsy

AIM

This study was conducted to examine the relationship between stigmatization and self-esteem of patients with epilepsy.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study was conducted with 216 patients at a university hospital in Van, a province in eastern Turkey. The researcher prepared the data collection tools, including a personal information form, Jacoby Stigma Scale and the Rosenberg self-esteem scale, in line with the literature. The Jacoby stigma scale was applied to assess stigma. Data analysis was performed using t-test, one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), and Tukey, LSD coefficient.

RESULTS

The mean total stigmatization score of patients with epilepsy was 21.11 ± 10.00, while the mean total self-esteem score was 20.26 ± 5.16. The study found a significant negative correlation between stigmatization and self-esteem scores (r = -0.411; p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The research study revealed that patient with epilepsy have a high perception of stigma and low selfesteem levels.

Social determinants of health and long-term conditions in people of Black African and Black Caribbean ethnicity living with HIV in London: A qualitative study

BACKGROUND

People living with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) are disproportionately impacted by socioeconomic deprivation and are at increased risk of developing other long-term conditions (LTCs). These illnesses require transformative action to tackle the adverse effects on their health. Data on lived experiences of LTCs among people living with HIV of Black African and Black Caribbean ethnicities are sparse, and how people with LTCs are impacted by social determinants of health (SDoH).

METHODS

Through a phenomenological study design this qualitative study, conducted in 2022, comprised four focus group discussions (FGDs) with 20 people of Black ethnicities living with HIV were purposively invited from a community organisation (CO) in London, including four semistructured interviews with CO staff. Following transcription, qualitative data were analysed thematically and measures to validate the findings were implemented.

RESULTS

The findings are presented in terms of the following four levels of SDoH: (1) individual determinants (such as the impact of SDoH on lifestyle modification and self-management); (2) interpersonal determinants (such as positive experiences of accessing healthcare for LTCs); (3) clinical determinants (such as care pathway barriers) and (4) systemic determinants (such as systemic barriers related to race/ethnicity).

CONCLUSIONS

It is necessary to provide ongoing and interactive education to community members who live with HIV, focusing on risks and management of LTCs. Additionally, individuals would benefit from support to navigate increasingly complex and fragmented health services. Health Service staff require cultural competence when caring for patients of Black African and Black Caribbean ethnicities with complex health and psychosocial needs.

PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION

The research team collaborated with an HIV CO in South London from the very start of the project to agree the study design and learn about the realities of their daily lived experiences. Community collaborators helped to develop the semistructured interview and FGD topic guides, and were directly involved in the data gathering, analysis and validation.

Resilience and psychosocial factors in adult with epilepsy: A longitudinal study

PURPOSE

Resilience is conceptually characterized as a dynamic process encompassing positive adaptation in the context of significant adversity. Our goal was to assess the resilience in people with epilepsy (PWE) and how it impacts longitudinally on psychosocial factors, with a particular focus on the manifestation of stigmatization-related feelings.

METHODS

We consecutively enrolled 78 adults PWE (42.5 ± 16.2 years old); among them 36 (46.1 %) were seizure-free. All subjects completed at baseline (T0) the Resilience Scale (RS-14) and questionnaires for the assessment of depressive symptoms, anxiety and quality of life: respectively, Beck Depression Inventory-II (BD-II), Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7 (GAD-7) and QOLIE-31 (Q31). All patients were followed up prospectively and re-evaluated after 6-22 months (T1; mean: 14 ± 8 months; median 14 months); at follow up they also completed the Stigma Scale of Epilepsy (SSE) for the assessment of the stigma associated with epilepsy. We correlated resilience values with all psychosocial scores at T0 and T1. Factors associated with resilient and vulnerable outcomes were identified. Finally, a multiple stepwise regression analysis was applied to identify predictors for resilience and stigma perception.

RESULTS

The results showed for the RS-14 score a significant direct correlation with the Q31 (p < 0.001) and an inverse correlation with the depressive and anxiety symptoms at both times (T0 and T1), as evaluated with BDI-II (p < 0.001) and GAD-7 (p < 0.001). Finally, we found a significant inverse correlation between RS-14 at T0 and the levels of stigmatization assessed with SSE at T1 (p =.015). Using a multiple stepwise regression analysis separately for resilience and stigma perception, depressive symptoms turned out as the best predictors for both variables. Finally, considering longitudinal evaluation we did not observe significant changes in depressive and anxious symptoms, despite a significant reduction in the total number of seizures at follow up.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study showed that depressive symptoms, anxiety and quality of life were significantly associated with resilience in PwE. Finally, as a novel finding resilience was proved to affect the perception of stigma related to epilepsy more than seizures.

A community-based awareness program improves knowledge and attitudes toward epilepsy: An interventional study

OBJECTIVE

Little interventional studies were conducted to improve knowledge, improve attitude, and eliminate stigma against patients with epilepsy. This study was conducted to investigate the effect of a community-based epilepsy awareness program (CBEAP) on knowledge, attitude, and stigma against patients with epilepsy among the Palestinian general public.

METHODS

This interventional study used a pre-post design. Knowledge and attitudes were assessed using a reliable and internally consistent questionnaire before and 1 month after receiving a CBEAP. Knowledge was assessed using a 16-item and attitudes were assessed using 13 items.

RESULTS

A total of 150 participants completed the questionnaire before the CBEAP. Of those, 136 (90.7 %) completed the CBEAP, and 129 (86.0 %) completed the questionnaire 1 month after receiving the CBEAP. The CBEAP significantly (p-value < 0.05) increased knowledge about the nature of epilepsy and seizures, triggers and treatment options, and patients with epilepsy. Similarly, the CBEAP significantly (p-value < 0.001) improved the attitudes of the participants toward epilepsy or having epilepsy, patients with epilepsy, relationships with patients with epilepsy, and working or staying with patients with epilepsy. Greater changes in knowledge and attitude scores were predicted by younger age and having a close friend or family member with epilepsy.

CONCLUSION

The CBEAP developed and implemented in this interventional study significantly increased the knowledge of the participants about epilepsy and improved their attitudes toward epilepsy and patients with epilepsy. Large-scale implementation of such interventional programs is still needed to increase knowledge and improve attitudes toward epilepsy and patients with epilepsy.

Health-related quality of life and associated factors among adult patients with epilepsy in public hospitals of Wolaita zone, southern Ethiopia. An embedded mixed method study

BACKGROUND

The socioeconomic and overall quality of life of patients with epilepsy are significantly impacted by the disease, which is one of the most prevalent chronic noncommunicable brain disorders. Less consideration has, however, been given to research in Ethiopia generally and the study setting in particular. Consequently, the purpose of this study was to assess the health-related quality of life and associated factors among adult patients with epilepsy in public hospitals in the Wolaita zone of southern Ethiopia.

METHODS

A facility-based embedded mixed method with cross-sectional and phenomenological study designs was carried out on 423 adult patients with epilepsy from August 1 to August 30, 2022. Systematic and criterion-purposive sampling was employed for the cross-sectional and phenomenological designs, respectively, to select study participants. Quantitative data were entered into Kobo Toolbox and then exported to SPSS Version 25 for analysis. The frequency, percentage, and cross-tabulation of the different variables were then determined. Finally, the magnitude and associated factors were first analyzed using binary logistic regression and then multivariate logistic regression. P < 0.05 was chosen as the level of statistical significance. An inductive thematic approach was used for qualitative data analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 423 patients with epilepsy were included in the study, making the response rate 100%. The overall prevalence of poor quality of life among patients with epilepsy in the study area was 53 percent (95% CI: 48.24-57.76). Being single (AOR = 4.457, 95% CI: 1.149, 17.282), having poor social support (AOR = 3.741, 95% CI: 2.107, 6.643), having uncontrolled seizures (AOR = 2.154, 95% CI: 1.234, 3.759), and having a high frequency of seizures (AOR = 5.192, 95% CI: 1.574, 17.126) were significantly associated factors with quality of life. Lack of social support, a fear of drug side effects, and worry about their disease were findings from the qualitative perspective added to the perspective of the quantitative findings.

CONCLUSION

One in every two patients with epilepsy in this study had a poor quality of life. Being single, the frequency of seizures, and a lack of social support all have a significant association. Public health initiatives should continue to strive to create positive awareness of epilepsy in society in addition to managing the clinical aspect of the disease.

The impact of epilepsy on quality of life: Findings from a European survey

INTRODUCTION

Epilepsy is a serious neurological disorder affecting the quality of life (QoL) of people with this condition. A survey was conducted in five European countries (France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the UK) to understand the impact and burden of epilepsy and its treatment on the lives of people with epilepsy (PWE).

METHODS

Five hundred PWE (taking >1 antiseizure medication [ASM]) and 500 matched controls completed a 30-minute online questionnaire. The 12-Item Short Form Survey (SF-12) was used to measure QoL and the Neurological Disorders Depression Inventory for Epilepsy (NDDI-E) was used to screen for major depressive disorder (MDD) symptoms.

RESULTS

Comorbidities such as migraine, high cholesterol, osteoporosis, and Type 1 diabetes were reported more commonly in PWE, while anxiety disorders, high blood pressure, skin disorders, and mood disorders were more common in controls. However, compared to controls, a significantly higher percentage of PWE had an NDDI-E score of 15-24 (54% vs 35%; p < 0.0001), indicative of MDD symptoms. Significantly more PWE than controls were part-time employed (15% vs 11%; p = 0.03). People with epilepsy had a significantly lower total SF-12 score than controls across the physical and the mental components; compared to controls, a significantly higher proportion of PWE defined their general health as 'poor' or 'fair' and felt limited in carrying out daily and work activities. Among PWE, those taking ≥3 ASMs were more likely to experience difficulties in carrying out these activities than those on two ASMs. Ability to drive, mood, and level of self-esteem were reported as concerns for PWE.

CONCLUSION

Epilepsy has a major impact on the physical and mental health of PWE, interfering with their daily and work activities and overall QoL, and its treatment might also contribute to a lower QoL. The impact of epilepsy on mood and mental health might be under-recognized.

The experiences of adolescents and young adults with epilepsy: A systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative studies

BACKGROUND

Epilepsy is one of the most common and severe chronic neurological disorders and is associated with psychosocial problems. Several qualitative studies have investigated the experiences of adolescents and young adults with epilepsy. However, the findings were conflicting to some extent. This study examined and synthesized qualitative research data to understand the experiences of adolescents and young adults living with epilepsy, improving the development of targeted interventions and enhancing these experiences.

OBJECTIVE

To synthesize qualitative evidence about the experiences of adolescents and young adults suffering from epilepsy.

METHODS

This systematic review and qualitative evidence synthesis used the Joanna Briggs methodology for qualitative systematic reviews [1]. PubMed, PsychINFO, EMBASE, and Web of Science were searched for studies indexed until March 2022. Qualitative data were extracted, analyzed, and aggregated using meta-synthesis.

RESULTS

Seventeen studies were included in the review. Three distinct themes were identified: "impact of epilepsy," "emotions associated with epilepsy," and "self-management of epilepsy." The results show that adolescents and young adults with epilepsy develop different strategies to manage epilepsy and associated problems.

CONCLUSION

The results improved our understanding of the experiences of adolescents and young adults suffering from epilepsy. Several approaches are encouraged to improve these experiences and the quality of life, including granting more autonomy to affected children, providing individualized care and advice, improving public awareness of epilepsy to avoid stigma, and strengthening legal frameworks to safeguard the rights of affected people.

Perceived stigma and self-esteem for children with epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

The study was conducted to determine the sense of stigma and self-esteem in children with epilepsy.

METHODS

The study has a descriptive-correlational design.The research group included 150 children aged 9 to 15 who presented to a hospital in eastern Turkey, the Pediatric Neurology Clinic and Polyclinic, between January and June 2021, and were admitted to a pediatric clinic associated with the epilepsy polyclinic. A personal information form, a child perceptions scale (CPS), and the Coopersmith Self-Esteem Inventory (CSEI) were used to collect the data.

RESULTS

Children scored an average of 3.31 ± 1.10 on the CPS and an average of 37.33 ± 27.78 on the CSEI. A statistically significant, high-level, and negative relationship was found between CSEI and CPS scores (p < 0.05). As the CSEI score increases, the CPS score drops. A statistically significant model was obtained from the regression analysis (F = 246.816; p = 0.000; R2 = 0.791; SH = 17.07). The CSEI score significantly predicts the CPS score.

CONCLUSION

The research study revealed that children with epilepsy have a high perception of stigma and low self-esteem levels, and that children's perceptions of being stigmatized are influenced by their educational status, their parents' educational status, their income level, their family type variables, and their self-esteem. The study determined that children's self-esteem decreased as their perception of stigma increased.

Mental health and quality of life in patients with craniofacial movement disorders: A cross-sectional study

Background

Facial appearance and expressions influence social interaction. Hemifacial spasm (HFS), blepharospasm (BPS), and blepharospasm-oromandibular dystonia (BOD) are common forms of craniofacial movement disorders. Few studies have focused on the mental burden and quality of life (QoL) in patients with craniofacial movement disorders. Therefore, this study investigated mental health and QoL in these patients.

Methods

This cross-sectional study included 90 patients with craniofacial movement disorders (HFS, BPS, and BOD; 30 patients per group) and 30 healthy individuals without craniofacial movement disorders (control group) recruited from October 2019 to November 2020. All participants underwent QoL and mental health evaluations for depression, anxiety, and stigma using the 36-item Short Form Health Survey (SF-36), Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale (HAMA), Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression-24 (HAMD-24) and a questionnaire related to stigma.

Results

Depression was diagnosed in 37 (41.11%) patients, whereas 30 patients (33.33%) had anxiety. HAMA scores were significantly higher in the BPS and BOD groups than in the control group. Nineteen patients (21.11%) experienced stigma and SF-36 scores were lower in various dimensions in the movement disorders groups compared to healthy controls. The role-physical and social function scores were significantly lower in the movement disorders groups than in the control group all p < 0.05. The vitality scores of the BPS group and mental health scores of the BPS and BOD groups were significantly lower than those of the control group. Correlation analysis showed that the eight dimensions of SF-36 correlated with education level, disease duration, HAMD score, and HAMA score (all p < 0.05). Regression analysis demonstrated that the HAMD score correlated with general health, vitality, social function, role-emotional, and mental health (all p < 0.05). The HAMA score correlated with body pain after adjusting for education level and disease duration.

Conclusion

This study highlights the significant frequency of mental symptoms, including depression, anxiety, and stigma, which lower QoL in patients with craniofacial movement disorders.

Perceived epilepsy-related stigma is linked to the socioeconomic status of the residence

Purpose

Epilepsy is one of the most common neurological disorders with high costs for the healthcare systems and great suffering for patients. Beyond seizures, psychosocial comorbidities can have detrimental effects on the well-being of people with epilepsy. One source of social stress and reduced quality of life is epilepsy-related stigma that often occurs, e.g., due to public misconceptions or myths. Stigma has individual biological, psychological and social correlates. Moreover, environmental factors like living in remote areas are associated with stigma. However, little is known about the link between the social structure of the residence and stigma in epilepsy. Thus, we investigated the association between the structural socioeconomic status (SES) and perceived stigma in an urban epilepsy population.

Methods

This prospective, cross-sectional study examined 226 adult in-patients with epilepsy from Berlin. Multiple regression analyses were performed to check the relationship between structural SES and stigma controlling for individual-level demographic, clinical, psychological and social factors. Continuous social indices (SI) of the districts and neighborhoods ("SI district" and "SI neighborhood") of Berlin were used to measure different levels of structural SES. Non-linear relationships are tested by grouping the SI in quartiles.

Results

Both indicators of structural SES were independently linked to stigma (p = 0.002). For "SI district", we identified a non-linear relationship with patients from the most deprived quartile feeling less stigmatized compared to those in the second (p < 0.001) or least deprived quartile (p = 0.009). Furthermore, more restrictions of daily life (p < 0.001), unfavorable income (p = 0.009) and seizure freedom in the past 6 months (p = 0.05) were related to increased stigma. A lower "SI neighborhood" was associated with higher stigma (p = 0.002).

Conclusion

Strategies to reduce epilepsy-related stigma need to consider the sociostructural living environment on different regional levels. Unfavorable relations with the immediate living environment may be directly targeted in patient-centered interventions. Non-linear associations with the structural SES of broader regional levels should be considered in public education programs. Further research is needed to examine possible underlying mechanisms and gain insight into the generalizability of our findings to other populations.

Epilepsy Care in Transgender Patients

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The goal of this review is to outline the main considerations when treating transgender patients with epilepsy. Points to be addressed include the gender affirming hormone therapy regimens and how they interact with anti-seizure medications and seizure control, as well as common co-morbidities in the transgender epilepsy population.

RECENT FINDINGS

Gender affirming hormone therapy (GAHT) may affect seizure control directly, due to proconvulsant or anticonvulsant properties. GAHT may interact with anti-seizure medications; most notably, estrogen will decrease serum concentration of lamotrigine. Enzyme-inducing anti-seizure medications may decrease hormone levels, potentially interfering with goals of GAHT. Transgender epilepsy patients are at risk for co-morbidities such as decreased bone mineral density and depression. There are minimal direct studies on treatment or outcomes in the transgender epilepsy population. Providers must be knowledgeable about the bi-directional interactions between gender affirming hormone therapy and anti-seizure medications, as well as direct hormonal influences on seizure control. Future research should directly evaluate outcomes in transgender epilepsy patients with regard to seizure control, success of hormone therapy, and management of co-morbidities, to further educate providers and patients how to best manage their healthcare.