Sexual and reproductive health concerns of women with epilepsy beginning in adolescence and young adulthood

Knowledge, Attitudes, and Decision-Making About Reproductive Health and Epilepsy: A Survey of Health Care Providers and Women With Epilepsy

Background and Objectives

Cisgender women with epilepsy (WWE) have distinct reproductive health needs. It is unknown to what extent WWE and their health care providers (HCPs) are aware of recent research advances regarding the reproductive health of WWE. This study aimed to survey US health care providers and WWE about their knowledge, attitudes, and decision-making pertaining to reproductive health; their awareness of key findings from recent relevant research; and whether learning of these findings would change their decision-making.

Methods

A market research firm conducted an online survey of US health care providers and WWE using a proprietary nationally representative panel. Eligible HCPs included physicians and advance practice providers in neurology, obstetrics-gynecology, and primary care, who treat WWE. Eligible WWE were 18-45 years old and reported an epilepsy diagnosis and taking antiseizure medication. Data were analyzed through descriptive statistics and logistic regression.

Results

Four hundred one HCPs and 199 WWE completed the full survey. Among HCPs, 38% reported being very or extremely comfortable treating pregnant WWE. Seventy-nine percent of HCPs reported that recent relevant research findings were new to them, with 65% reporting that the findings seemed plausible and 49% reporting that the findings would probably or definitely change their management of pregnancy for WWE.Thirty percent of WWE reported that pregnancy is very or extremely safe for WWE, while 50% reported that it is somewhat safe, and 21% not at all or not very safe. Ninety-one percent of WWE reported that research findings were new to them, 37% reported that the findings seemed plausible, and 64% reported that the findings would probably or definitely influence their reproductive decision-making.

Discussion

Survey findings suggest suboptimal awareness of recent research advances pertaining to the reproductive health of WWE among WWE and their HCPs. Findings also suggest that dissemination and implementation of such findings may be impactful on the medical decision-making of both HCPs and WWE. Findings may guide future initiatives to ensure prompt dissemination and implementation of research advances in epilepsy and reproductive health.

Whole-cycle management of women with epilepsy of child-bearing age: ontology construction and application

BACKGROUND

The effective management of epilepsy in women of child-bearing age necessitates a concerted effort from multidisciplinary teams. Nevertheless, there exists an inadequacy in the seamless exchange of knowledge among healthcare providers within this context. Consequently, it is imperative to enhance the availability of informatics resources and the development of decision support tools to address this issue comprehensively.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The development of the Women with Epilepsy of Child-Bearing Age Ontology (WWECA) adhered to established ontology construction principles. The ontology's scope and universal terminology were initially established by the development team and subsequently subjected to external evaluation through a rapid Delphi consensus exercise involving domain experts. Additional entities and attribute annotation data were sourced from authoritative guideline documents and specialized terminology databases within the respective field. Furthermore, the ontology has played a pivotal role in steering the creation of an online question-and-answer system, which is actively employed and assessed by a diverse group of multidisciplinary healthcare providers.

RESULTS

WWECA successfully integrated a total of 609 entities encompassing various facets related to the diagnosis and medication for women of child-bearing age afflicted with epilepsy. The ontology exhibited a maximum depth of 8 within its hierarchical structure. Each of these entities featured three fundamental attributes, namely Chinese labels, definitions, and synonyms. The evaluation of WWECA involved 35 experts from 10 different hospitals across China, resulting in a favorable consensus among the experts. Furthermore, the ontology-driven online question and answer system underwent evaluation by a panel of 10 experts, including neurologists, obstetricians, and gynecologists. This evaluation yielded an average rating of 4.2, signifying a positive reception and endorsement of the system's utility and effectiveness.

CONCLUSIONS

Our ontology and the associated online question and answer system hold the potential to serve as a scalable assistant for healthcare providers engaged in the management of women with epilepsy (WWE). In the future, this developmental framework has the potential for broader application in the context of long-term management of more intricate chronic health conditions.

Survey of an online system for information to women with epilepsy of childbearing age and management during pregnancy: A 3-year evaluation

OBJECTIVE

We developed an online tool for women with epilepsy consisting of two modules: one with information on pregnancy-related issues (information module) and one for reminders about blood test and communication about dose changes (pregnancy module). Our aim was to assess perceived value, user-friendliness and improvement of patient knowledge in users.

METHODS

The system was launched in 2019 and patients invited by epilepsy nurses were asked to participate in a survey 1 month after the invitation for the information module, and 1 month postnatally for the pregnancy module.

RESULTS

By November 2022, the system had been used by 96 individuals out of 100 invited in the pregnancy module, in a total of 114 pregnancies. One hundred and eleven women had been invited to the information module, and 70 of these accessed it. The survey received 96 answers (44 information, 52 pregnancy). User-friendliness was rated as good or very good by a little over half of the users; 55% in the information module and 52% in the pregnancy module. Among pregnant women, 83% found the TDM part useful and most would prefer a similar system in future pregnancies. Sixty-four percent of users of the information module and 48% of the pregnancy module found that the system had increased their knowledge. Two knowledge questions were answered correctly by a significantly higher proportion of those that had accessed the online information.

SIGNIFICANCE

There was great demand for online communication during pregnancy and our experiences of implementation can hopefully assist digitalization of epilepsy care elsewhere. Online information also seems to increase knowledge about pregnancy-related issues, but our invitation-only method of inclusion was not effective for widespread dissemination. Patient-initiated access with optional epilepsy-team contact if questions arise could be an alternative.

PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY

We have performed a survey of users of a new Internet-based tool for information to women of childbearing age and communication about dose changes during pregnancy. Users were overall satisfied with the tool and answered some knowledge questions more accurately after accessing the information.

Preferences and experiences of parents/guardians of youth with epilepsy and intellectual disability on reproductive health counseling

OBJECTIVE

To explore the experiences and preferences of parents/guardians of adolescents and young adults (AYA) of childbearing potential with co-occurring epilepsy and intellectual disability (ID) regarding counseling by neurologists on sexual and reproductive health (SRH) topics such as pregnancy, contraception, menstruation, and folic acid supplementation.

METHODS

We conducted semi-structured interviews with parents/guardians of AYAs (12-28 years old) of childbearing potential with co-occurring epilepsy and ID, recruited from a tertiary-care children's hospital. We confirmed the diagnoses of epilepsy and ID with the patient's neurologist and parent/guardian. All degrees of ID (e.g. mild/moderate/severe) were eligible. We audio-recorded and transcribed interviews. Two coders performed qualitative thematic analysis.

RESULTS

Twenty-five parents/guardians completed interviews. Themes included: (1) Parents/guardians believe their child to be immune from sexual abuse due to their supervision, yet desire counseling about abuse recognition and prevention, which they also report not occurring (2) A common opinion was that counseling on menstruation was more relevant to their child's life than counseling about pregnancy-related topics (3) Parents/guardians reported a lack of counseling on pregnancy-related topics such as folic acid supplementation and teratogenesis and generally also reported some degree of interest in hearing about these topics from neurologists (4) Parents/guardians also reported a lack of counseling on drug interactions between contraception and ASMs, and were highly interested in learning more about this topic (5) Parents/guardians want neurologists to initiate annual comprehensive SRH counseling at puberty about most topics, but report that they often initiate SRH discussions themselves.

CONCLUSION

Parents/guardians of AYAs with epilepsy and ID prefer more frequent, neurologist-initiated, comprehensive conversations surrounding SRH particularly emphasizing menstruation and sexual abuse recognition/prevention. Findings may inform professional and patient education and health systems interventions including development of discussion guides and/or decision aides to improve SRH care for AYAs with epilepsy and ID.

Co-production of online educational resources for adolescent and young adult females with epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

To develop online patient education materials about epilepsy for adolescent and young adult females with epilepsy through co-production in partnership with patients, parents or caregivers, and multi-disciplinary healthcare providers who care for this population.

METHODS

We recruited participants from Western/Central Pennsylvania, comprised of females with epilepsy ages 18-26 or parents of children with epilepsy ages 12-26. Healthcare providers who participated in the study were recruited nationally from disciplines of pediatric epilepsy, adult epilepsy, women's neurology, and adolescent medicine. We held three series of meetings to create the online materials from July to August 2021.

RESULTS

Five adolescent and young adult females with epilepsy (ages 18-26, median age 22) and two parents of children with epilepsy were recruited and participated in meetings. The physician group was comprised of two adolescent medicine physicians, one adult neurologist with a specialization in women's neurology, one adult epileptologist, and one pediatric epileptologist. All participants were female. Several sets of meetings were held, which involved the creation of an empathy map to evaluate the needs and desires of our participants, topic list development, and specific content and formatting recommendations. After these meetings, content was created for the online materials and published on the Center for Young Women's Health (CYWH) website.

CONCLUSION

Our team utilized co-production with a diverse group of partners to create educational materials that met the interests of adolescent and young adult females with epilepsy. This is a structured and reproducible methodology that could inform future educational intervention development in epilepsy.

Investigation of illness perception and pregnancy avoidance in sexually active women with epilepsy

AIM

The aim of the study was to examine the perception of illness and avoidance of pregnancy in sexually active women with epilepsy.

METHODS

This study was completed with 82 women with epilepsy who were sexually active and who were admitted to the neurology clinic and outpatient clinic between June and September 2022. The descriptive information form, Brief Illness Perception Questionnaire (IPQ-B), and Pregnancy Avoidance Scale (PAS) were used to collect the data.

RESULTS

The mean age of the patients in the study was 32.96 ± 5.92 years and the mean disease duration was 11.19 ± 7.46 years. Among the patients, 75.6% had previous pregnancies, 70.7% did not have miscarriage or abortion, 69.5% previously gave birth, 61% used a contraceptive method (condom, intrauterine device (IUD), pills, etc.) in their last sexual intercourse, 52.4% had good communication with their spouses, 20% had two children, 51.2% had three or more seizures, and 86.6% used antiseizure medications (ASMs). The mean PAS score of the patients was 2.31 ± 1.14 and the mean IPQ-B score was 35.10 ± 13.16. The regression analysis found that the perception of illness was a significant positive predictor of avoidance of pregnancy and explained 17% of it.

CONCLUSION

Women with epilepsy avoided pregnancy and had negative illness perceptions. Moreover, negative illness perception increased pregnancy avoidance in women with epilepsy.

Sexual and Reproductive Health Counseling: The Sooner the Better

Sexual and Reproductive Health Concerns of Women With Epilepsy Beginning in Adolescence and Young Adulthood

Kirkpatrick L, Harrison E, Borrero S, et al. Epilepsy & Behavior. 2021;125:108439. doi:10.1016/j.yebeh.2021.108439.

Background:

Women with epilepsy (WWE) have potentially unique concerns regarding their sexual and reproductive health (SRH). Prior studies of WWE have focused narrowly on pregnancy and preconception experiences, and have not addressed concerns of nulliparous adolescent and young adult women not actively seeking pregnancy.

Methods:

We conducted individual semi-structured interviews with WWE 18-45 years of age. We sampled to maximize diversity of age and parity, and intentionally included many adolescent and young adult nulliparous women not actively planning pregnancy. Interviews broadly addressed participants’ SRH concerns and experiences. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed. Two coders performed qualitative analysis using thematic analysis with deductive and inductive approaches.

Results:

Twenty WWE (median age 23 years, range 18-43 years) completed interviews. Twelve were nulliparous, six had children, one had a history of miscarriage only, and two were currently pregnant. WWE’s narratives revealed significant concerns about family planning and reproductive health in the context of epilepsy, including: 1) seizures endangering pregnancies and children 2) teratogenic effects of antiseizure medication, 3) heritability of epilepsy, 4) antiseizure medication and epilepsy impacting fertility, and 5) interactions between antiseizure medication and contraception.

Conclusion:

WWE, including nulliparous adolescent and young adult women who are not actively planning pregnancy, have significant concerns about how their epilepsy interacts with SRH. SRH counseling for WWE should begin during adolescence and be incorporated into the transition process from pediatric to adult healthcare. Insights from WWE may aid in the creation of relevant patient-facing educational resources as well as provider-facing training and tools to meaningfully support the reproductive decision-making of WWE throughout their childbearing years.

Gender differences in concerns about planning to have children and child-rearing among patients with epilepsy: A prospective, multicenter study with 477 patients from Germany

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the concerns and worries about planning to have children and being a parent as a person with epilepsy and investigate gender differences in these perceptions.

METHODS

The Epi2020 study was a large multicenter study focusing on different healthcare aspects of adult patients with epilepsy in Germany. In addition to basic clinical and demographic characteristics, patients were asked to answer a questionnaire regarding their plan to have children, if they had children, and concerns about their children's health. Data were analyzed to detect differences between men and women with epilepsy according to age group.

RESULTS

In total, 477 patients with epilepsy with a mean age of 40.5 years (SD = 15.5, range: 18-83 years) participated in this study; 280 (58.7%) were female and 197 (41.3%) were male. Both women and men frequently reported concerns and worries about having children: In the age group below 45 years of age, 72.5% of women and 58.2% of men described being worried to some extent that their children may also suffer from epilepsy (p = .006). Furthermore, 67.3% of women and 54.2% of men below the age of 45 years reported being worried that their children may be disabled (p = .003). Women were more likely to have family members who are reluctant to support their desire to have children (p = .048).

CONCLUSION

Women with epilepsy of childbearing age are significantly more likely to report major concerns that their children might be disabled or also have epilepsy than men with epilepsy and, therefore, express more concerns about choosing to have a child. However, men also report frequent concerns and worries, and this should be addressed not only on request but should be included in the provision of general information on epilepsy.