HPV molecular assays: defining analytical and clinical performance characteristics for cervical cytology specimens

Comparison of four different human papillomavirus genotyping methods in cervical samples: Addressing method-specific advantages and limitations

Since human papillomavirus (HPV) is recognized as the causative agent of cervical cancer and associated with anogenital non-cervical and oropharyngeal cancers, the characterization of the HPV types circulating in different geographic regions is an important tool in screening and prevention. In this context, this study compared four methodologies for HPV detection and genotyping: real-time PCR (Cobas® HPV test), nested PCR followed by conventional Sanger sequencing, reverse hybridization (High + Low PapillomaStrip® kit) and next-generation sequencing (NGS) at an Illumina HiSeq2500 platform. Cervical samples from patients followed at the Family Health Strategy from Juiz de Fora, Minas Gerais, Brazil, were collected and subjected to the real-time PCR. Of those, 114 were included in this study according to the results obtained with the real-time PCR, considered herein as the gold standard method. For the 110 samples tested by at least one methodology in addition to real-time PCR, NGS showed the lowest concordance rates of HPV and high-risk HPV identification compared to the other three methods (67-75 %). Real-time PCR and Sanger sequencing showed the highest rates of concordance (97-100 %). All methods differed in their sensitivity and specificity. HPV genotyping contributes to individual risk stratification, therapeutic decisions, epidemiological studies and vaccine development, supporting approaches in prevention, healthcare and management of HPV infection.

Evaluation of the SureX HPV genotyping test for the detection of high-risk HPV in cervical cancer screening

BACKGROUND

The SureX HPV genotyping test (SureX HPV test), which targets the human papillomavirus (HPV) E6/E7 genes was compared with the Cobas 4800 and Venus HPV tests for detecting 14 high-risk HPV (HR-HPV) types in clinical referral and follow-up patients to evaluate its value for cervical cancer screening.

METHODS

Two different populations were enrolled in the study. The first population comprised 185 cases and was used for comparing the SureX HPV test (Health, China) with the Cobas 4800 test (Roche, USA). The second population comprised 290 cases and was used for comparing the SureX HPV test (Health, China) with the Venus HPV test (Zhijiang, China). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) sequencing was performed for further confirmation of discordant results.

RESULTS

In the first population, the overall agreement rate was 95.6% for 14 high-risk HPV types. Eight discordant cases were confirmed by PCR sequencing, which showed that the agreement rates were 75.0% between the SureX HPV test and PCR sequencing and 25.0% between the Cobas 4800 test and PCR sequencing (P < 0.01). In the second population, the overall agreement rate was 95.5%. Thirteen discordant cases were confirmed by PCR sequencing, which showed that the agreement rates were 76.9% between the SureX HPV test and PCR sequencing and 23.1% between the Venus HPV test and PCR sequencing (P < 0.01). With cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 2+ (CIN2+) as the reference standard, the sensitivity values of the SureX HPV test and the Venus HPV test were 93.5% and 92.0%, (P > 0.05), while the specificity values were 43.3% and 46.7%, respectively (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The SureX HPV test had good consistency with both the Cobas 4800 and Venus HPV tests for 14 HR-HPV types. In addition, it avoided some false negatives and false positives. Therefore, the SureX HPV test can be used for cervical cancer screening.

Molecular Pap Smear: Validation of HPV Genotype and Host Methylation Profiles of ADCY8, CDH8, and ZNF582 as a Predictor of Cervical Cytopathology

Primary high-risk Human Papillomavirus (hrHPV) screening has recently become an accepted standalone or co-test with conventional cytology. Unfortunately, hrHPV singularly lacks specificity for cytopathological grade. However, mechanisms and markers of evolving virus-host interactions at the epigenome level may be harnessed as a better predictor of carcinogenesis. This study aimed to validate and expand the clinical performance of a multiparametric biomarker panel, referred to as the "Molecular Pap smear" based, on HPV genotype and ADCY8, CDH8 and ZNF582 CpG-methylation as a predictive classifier of cervical cytology. This prospective, cross-sectional study used an independent cohort of residual liquid-based cytology for HPV genotyping and epigenetic analysis. Extracted DNA underwent parallel PCR using 3 primer sets for HPV DNA amplification. HPV-infected samples were genotyped by Sanger sequencing. Promoter methylation levels of 3 tumor suppressor genes were quantified by bisulfite-pyrosequencing of genomic DNA on the newest high-resolution PyroMark Q48 platform. Logistic model performance was compared, and model parameters were used to predict and classify binary cytological outcomes. A total of 883 samples were analyzed. HPV DNA positivity correlated with worsening grade: 125/237 (53%) NILM; 136/235 (58%) ASCUS; 222/229 (97%) LSIL; and 157/182 (86%) HSIL samples. The proportion of carcinogenic HPV-types in PCR-positive sequenceable samples correlated with worsening grade: NILM 34/98 (35%); ASCUS 50/113 (44%); LSIL 92/214 (43%); HSIL 129/152 (85%). Additionally, ADCY8, CDH8, and ZNF582 methylation levels increased in direct correlation with worsening grade. Overall, the multi-marker modeling parameters predicted binarized cytological outcomes better than HPV-type alone with significantly higher area under the receiver operator curve (AUC)s, respectively: NILM vs. > NILM (AUC 0.728 vs. 0.709); NILM/ASCUS vs. LSIL/HSIL (AUC 0.805 vs. 0.776); and Collapse

Key Words

• DNA methylation
• carcinogenesis
• epigenetic modification
• evolution
• host-pathogen interactions
• human papillomavirus infection
• pap smear
• pyrosequencing

Collapse

MESH Headings Collapse

Grants Collapse

Affiliation(s)

Jane Shen-Gunther Gynecologic Oncology & Clinical Investigation, Department of Clinical Investigation, Brooke Army Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, TX, United States Department of Molecular Medicine, Cancer Therapy and Research Center, University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio, San Antonio, TX, United States
Qingqing Xia Department of Clinical Investigation, Brooke Army Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, TX, United States
Winfred Stacey Department of Clinical Investigation, Brooke Army Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, TX, United States
Heisy B. Asusta Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Brooke Army Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, TX, United States

Collapse

Abundance of HPV L1 Intra-Genotype Variants With Capsid Epitopic Modifications Found Within Low- and High-Grade Pap Smears With Potential Implications for Vaccinology

Background: The aim of this study was to explore the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) genotype composition and intra-genotype variants within individual samples of low- and high-grade cervical cytology by deep sequencing. Clinical, cytological, sequencing, and functional/structural data were forged into an integrated variant profiling pipeline for the detection of potentially vaccine-resistant genotypes or variants.

Methods: Low- and high-grade intraepithelial lesion (LSIL and HSIL) cytology samples with +HPV were subjected to amplicon (L1 gene fragment) sequencing by dideoxy (Sanger) and deep methods. Taxonomic, abundance, diversity, and phylogenetic analyses were conducted to determine HPV genotypes/sub-lineages, relative abundance, species diversity and phylogenetic distances within and between samples. Variant detection and functional analysis of translated L1 amino acid sequences determined structural variations of interest.

Results: Pure and mixed HPV infections were common among LSIL (n = 6) and HSIL (n = 6) samples. Taxonomic profiling revealed loss of species richness and gain of dominance by carcinogenic genotypes in HSIL samples. Phylogenetic analysis showed excellent correlation between HPV-type specific genetic distances and carcinogenic potential. For combined LSIL/HSIL samples (n = 12), 11 HPV genotypes and 417 mutations were detected: 375 single-nucleotide variants (SNV), 29 insertion/deletion (indel), 12 multi-nucleotide variants (MNV), and 1 replacement variant. The proportion of nonsynonymous mutations was lower for HSIL (0.38) than for LSIL samples (0.51) (p < 0.05). HPV variant analysis pinpointed nucleotide-level mutations and amino acid-level structural modifications.

Conclusion: HPV L1 intra-host and intra-genotype variants are abundant in LSIL and HSIL samples with potential functional/structural consequences. An integrated multi-omics approach to variant analysis may provide a sensitive and practical means of detecting changes in HPV evolution and dynamics within individuals or populations.

Deep sequencing of HPV E6/E7 genes reveals loss of genotypic diversity and gain of clonal dominance in high-grade intraepithelial lesions of the cervix

BACKGROUND

Human papillomavirus (HPV) is the carcinogen of almost all invasive cervical cancer and a major cause of oral and other anogenital malignancies. HPV genotyping by dideoxy (Sanger) sequencing is currently the reference method of choice for clinical diagnostics. However, for samples with multiple HPV infections, genotype identification is singular and occasionally imprecise or indeterminable due to overlapping chromatograms. Our aim was to explore and compare HPV metagenomes in abnormal cervical cytology by deep sequencing for correlation with disease states.

RESULTS

Low- and high-grade intraepithelial lesion (LSIL and HSIL) cytology samples were DNA extracted for PCR-amplification of the HPV E6/E7 genes. HPV+ samples were sequenced by dideoxy and deep methods. Deep sequencing revealed ~60% of all samples (n = 72) were multi-HPV infected. Among LSIL samples (n = 43), 27 different genotypes were found. The 3 dominant (most abundant) genotypes were: HPV-39, 11/43 (26%); -16, 9/43 (21%); and -35, 4/43 (9%). Among HSIL (n = 29), 17 HPV genotypes were identified; the 3 dominant genotypes were: HPV-16, 21/29 (72%); -35, 4/29 (14%); and -39, 3/29 (10%). Phylogenetically, type-specific E6/E7 genetic distances correlated with carcinogenic potential. Species diversity analysis between LSIL and HSIL revealed loss of HPV diversity and domination by HPV-16 in HSIL samples.

CONCLUSIONS

Deep sequencing resolves HPV genotype composition within multi-infected cervical cytology. Biodiversity analysis reveals loss of diversity and gain of dominance by carcinogenic genotypes in high-grade cytology. Metagenomic profiles may therefore serve as a biomarker of disease severity and a population surveillance tool for emerging genotypes.

Molecular Pap smear: HPV genotype and DNA methylation of ADCY8, CDH8, and ZNF582 as an integrated biomarker for high-grade cervical cytology

BACKGROUND

The Pap smear has remained the foundation for cervical cancer screening for over 70 years. With advancements in molecular diagnostics, primary high-risk human papillomavirus (hrHPV) screening has recently become an accepted stand-alone or co-test with conventional cytology. However, both diagnostic tests have distinct limitations. The aim of this study was to determine the association between HPV genotypes and cellular epigenetic modifications in three grades of cervical cytology for screening biomarker discovery.

METHODS

This prospective, cross-sectional study used residual liquid-based cytology samples for HPV genotyping and epigenetic analysis. Extracted DNA was subjected to parallel polymerase chain reactions using three primer sets (MY09/11, FAP59/64, E6-E7 F/B) for HPV DNA amplification. HPV+ samples were genotyped by DNA sequencing. Promoter methylation of four candidate tumor suppressor genes (adenylate cyclase 8 (ADCY8), cadherin 8, type 2 (CDH8), MGMT, and zinc finger protein 582 (ZNF582)) out of 48 genes screened was quantified by bisulfite-pyrosequencing of genomic DNA. Independent validation of methylation profiles was performed by analyzing data from cervical cancer cell lines and clinical samples from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA).

RESULTS

Two hundred seventy-seven quality cytology samples were analyzed. HPV was detected in 31/100 (31 %) negative for intraepithelial lesion or malignancy (NILM), 95/100 (95 %) low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (LSIL), and 71/77 (92 %) high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) samples. The proportion of IARC-defined carcinogenic HPV types in sequenced samples correlated with worsening grade: NILM 7/29 (24 %), LSIL 53/92 (58 %), and HSIL 65/70 (93 %). Promoter methylation of ADCY8, CDH8, and ZNF582 was measured in 170 samples: NILM (N = 33), LSIL (N = 70), and HSIL (N = 67) also correlated with worsening grade. Similar hypermethylation patterns were found in cancer cell lines and TCGA samples. The combination of four biomarkers, i.e., HPV genotype and three-gene promoter methylation, predicted HSIL (AUC 0.89) better than HPV alone (AUC 0.74) by logistic regression and probabilistic modeling.

CONCLUSIONS

HPV genotype and DNA methylation of ADCY8, CDH8, and ZNF582 are correlated with cytological grade. Collectively, these biomarkers may serve as a molecular classifier of Pap smears.

Human papillomavirus genotype distribution and E6/E7 oncogene expression in Turkish women with cervical cytological findings

BACKGROUND

Infection with certain human papillomavirus (HPV) genotypes is the most important risk factor related with cervical cancer. The objective of the present study was to investigate the prevalence of HPV infection, the distribution of HPV genotypes and HPV E6/E7 oncogene mRNA expression in Turkish women with different cervical cytological findings in Mersin province, Southern Turkey.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 476 cytological samples belonging to women with normal and abnormal cervical Pap smears were enrolled in the study. For the detection and genotyping assay, a PCR/direct cycle sequencing approach was used. E6/E7 mRNA expression of HPV-16, 18, 31, 33, and 45 was determined by type-specific real-time NASBA assay (NucliSENS EasyQ(®)HPV v1.1).

RESULTS

Of the 476 samples, 106 (22.3%) were found to be positive for HPV DNA by PCR. The presence of HPV was significantly more common (p<0.001) in HSIL (6/8, 75%) when compared with LSIL (6/14, 42.9%), ASC-US (22/74, 29.7%) and normal cytology (72/380, 18.9%). The most prevalent genotypes were, in descending order of frequency, HPV genotype 66 (22.6%), 16 (20.8%), 6 (14.2%), 31 (11.3%), 53 (5.7%), and 83 (4.7%). HPV E6/E7 oncogene mRNA positivity (12/476, 2.5%) was lower than DNA positivity (38/476, 7.9%).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data present a wide distribution of HPV genotypes in the analyzed population. HPV genotypes 66, 16, 6, 31, 53 and 83 were the predominant types and most of them were potential carcinogenic types. Because of the differences between HPV E6/E7 mRNA and DNA positivity, further studies are required to test the role of mRNA testing in the triage of women with abnormal cervical cytology or follow up of HPV DNA positive and cytology negative. These epidemiological data will be important to determine the future impact of vaccination on HPV infected women in our region.

Association of human papillomavirus and Chlamydia trachomatis with intraepithelial alterations in cervix samples

The influence of different infectious agents and their association with human papillomavirus (HPV) in cervical carcinogenesis have not been completely elucidated. This study describes the association between cytological changes in cervical epithelium and the detection of the most relevant aetiological agents of sexually transmitted diseases. Samples collected from 169 patients were evaluated by conventional cytology followed by molecular analysis to detect HPV DNA, Chlamydia trachomatis, herpes simplex virus 1 and 2,Neisseria gonorrhoeae, Mycoplasma genitalium, Trichomonas vaginalis, andTreponema pallidum, besides genotyping for most common high-risk HPV. An association between cytological lesions and different behavioural habits such as smoking and sedentariness was observed. Intraepithelial lesions were also associated with HPV and C. trachomatis detection. An association was also found between both simple and multiple genotype infection and cytological changes. The investigation of HPV and C. trachomatisproved its importance and may be considered in the future for including in screening programs, since these factors are linked to the early diagnosis of patients with precursor lesions of cervical cancer.

Genotyping human papillomaviruses: development and evaluation of a comprehensive DNA microarray

GOALS

To define the analytical and clinical performance of a human papillomavirus (HPV) custom-designed microarray targeting the HPV L1 gene for viral genotyping.

METHODS

Microarray probes were designed by cataloging the genome sequence of all 120 known HPV types to generate tiling probes using eArray® software against the unique L1 capsid gene segments targeted by MY09/11 and FAP59/64 primers. The microarray (1 slide×8 arrays×60K features) synthesized in situ by inkjet printing was tested using synthetic type-specific HPV DNA and existing HPV DNA from cervical cytology. The synthetic HPV L1 segments (genotypes 6, 11, 16, 18, 31, 33, 35, 45, 53, 58, 66, 73, 83) were manufactured from sequences stored in the NCBI taxonomy database. Using the hybridization patterns of the synthetic HPV DNA as the Support Vector Machine classifier, HPV DNA from patient samples were genotyped and compared to antecedent DNA sequencing/BLAST® results for concordance.

RESULTS

16 cytology-derived HPV DNA samples and 13 synthetic type-specific HPV DNA samples were tested singly, in duplicate, or in combination on 40 arrays. The synthetic HPV DNA hybridization patterns were found to be uniquely distinctive to serve well as a classifier of unknown HPV-containing specimens. For the 16HPV DNA+ samples classified, 15 were concordant with DNA sequencing results. In 6/16 (38%) samples, the microarray hybridization pattern revealed ≥2 concurrent HPV infections.

CONCLUSION

The novel "HPV Array" was sensitive and specific for detecting single and multiple infections. This proof-of-principle project demonstrated the accuracy and advantages of microarray technology for HPV genotyping.

Simultaneous detection and differentiation of human papillomavirus genotypes 6, 11, 16 and 18 by AllGlo quadruplex quantitative PCR

Background

Human papillomaviruses (HPV) are classified into high-risk HPV and low-risk HPV. The most common high-risk HPV types in cervical cancer are HPV 16 and 18, and the most common low-risk types causing genital warts are HPV 6 and HPV 11. In this study, applying novel AllGlo fluorescent probes, we established a quadruplex quantitative PCR method to simultaneously detect and differentiate HPV 6, 11, 16 and 18 in a single tube.

Methods

The specificity, the sensitivity, the detection limit, the reproducibility and the standard curve of this method were examined. Finally, clinical samples that had been tested previously by TaqMan PCR and HPV GenoArray (GA) test were used to verify the accuracy and sensitivity of the method.

Results

The assay has a sensitivity of 10¹ to 10² copies/test and a linear detection range from 10¹ to 10⁸ copies/test. The mean amplification efficiencies for HPV 6, 11, 16, and 18 were 0.97, 1.10, 0.93 and 1.20, respectively, and the mean correlation coefficient (r²) of each standard curve was above 0.99 for plasmid templates ranging from 10³ to 10⁷ copies/test. There was 100% agreement between the AllGlo quadruplex quantitative PCR, HPV GA test and TaqMan uniplex qPCR methods.

Conclusions

AllGlo quadruplex quantitative PCR in a single tube has the advantages of relatively high throughput, good reproducibility, high sensitivity, high specificity, and a wide linear range of detection. The convenient single tube format makes this assay a powerful tool for the studies of mixed infections by multiple pathogens, viral typing and viral load quantification.

A review of methods for detect human Papillomavirus infection

Human Papillomavirus (HPV) is the most common sexually transmitted virus. Worldwide, the most common high-risk (HR)-HPV are -16/18, and approximately 70% of cervical cancers (CC) are due to infection by these genotypes. Persistent infection by HR-HPV is a necessary but not sufficient cause of this cancer, which develops over a long period through precursor lesions, which can be detected by cytological screening. Although this screening has decreased the incidence of CC, HPV-related cervical disease, including premalignant and malignant lesions, continues to be a major burden on health-care systems. Although not completely elucidated, the HPV-driven molecular mechanisms underlying the development of cervical lesions have provided a number of potential biomarkers for both diagnostic and prognostic use in the clinical management of women with HPV-related cervical disease, and these biomarkers can also be used to increase the positive predictive value of current screening methods. In addition, they can provide insights into the biology of HPV-induced cancer and thus lead to the development of nonsurgical therapies. Considering the importance of detecting HPV and related biomarkers, a variety of methods are being developed for these purposes. This review summarizes current knowledge of detection methods for HPV, and related biomarkers that can be used to discriminate lesions with a high risk of progression to CC.

Targeting tyrosine kinases in cancer: the converging roles of cytopathology and molecular pathology in the era of genomic medicine

Because of knowledge gained in the field of cancer biology, clinicians are currently witnessing an explosion of molecular tests as companion diagnostics to targeted therapies against growth factor receptors and their signaling pathways. Such tests are being applied increasingly to cytology specimens as essential components of genomic medicine, because less invasive diagnostic procedures are becoming the norm. The objective of this review was to present an overview of the current and future role of cytopathology in molecular diagnostics, including the adequacy of cytology specimens for such studies. The authors also discuss the critical methodologic aspects of the molecular assays used for the selection of tyrosine kinase treatment for oncology patients.

Frequency and multiplicity of human papillomavirus infection in HIV-1 positive women in Italy

BACKGROUND

Natural history of HPV infection is altered in HIV positive women, with increased risk of cervical dysplasia. Limited data are available about the influence of HPV genotypes and HPV multiple infections on cervical disease in HIV positive women.

OBJECTIVES

We determined HPV genotype prevalence in cervical samples from 553 HIV-infected women attending the gynaecological service at "L. Spallanzani" Hospital. Association of HPV multiple infections with cervical abnormalities was investigated.

STUDY DESIGN

MY09/MY11 consensus primers were used to detect HPV-DNA; HPV typing was performed by RFLP. A commercial array based kit was used to define unresolved RFLP patterns.

RESULTS

HPV was detected in 244/553 (44.1%) patients, correlating with low CD4 counts (p<0.001) and age (p=0.001). Multiple HPV types were observed in 44.4% of cases, more frequently involving HR than LR HPV (OR=12.8, p<0.00001). Multiple HPV infections were associated with low CD4 counts (OR=3.8 in CD4<200 vs CD4≥500 cells/mm(3)). Dyskaryosis was associated with decreased CD4 counts (≥500 vs 200-499 vs <200 cells/mm(3), χ(2) for trend, p=0.001) and with HPV types multiplicity (1 vs 2-3 vs ≥4, χ(2) for trend, p<0.00001). Notably, in 3 H-SIL cases only LR types were detected (HPV62, n=2; HPV81, n=1).

CONCLUSIONS

Multiple HPV infections, often involving HR types, are frequent in HIV-infected women. Association between multiple HPV infection, low CD4 count and cytological abnormalities supports the interplay of virological and immunological factors in cervical cancer pathogenesis. Assessment of multiple HPV infections might gain importance in cervical cancer screening, particularly in patients with predisposing factors like immuno-suppression.