Complementing global measures of RNA folding with local reports of backbone solvent accessibility by time resolved hydroxyl radical footprinting

Chemical Generation of Hydroxyl Radical for Oxidative 'Footprinting'

BACKGROUND

For almost four decades, hydroxyl radical chemically generated by Fenton chemistry has been a mainstay for the oxidative 'footprinting' of macromolecules.

OBJECTIVE

In this article, we start by reviewing the application of chemical generation of hydroxyl radical to the development of oxidative footprinting of DNA and RNA and the subsequent application of the method to oxidative footprinting of proteins. We next discuss a novel strategy for generating hydroxyl radicals by Fenton chemistry that immobilizes catalytic iron on a solid surface (Pyrite Shrink Wrap laminate) for the application of nucleic acid and protein footprinting.

METHOD

Pyrite Shrink-Wrap Laminate is fabricated by depositing pyrite (Fe-S2, aka 'fool's gold') nanocrystals onto thermolabile plastic (Shrinky Dink). The laminate can be thermoformed into a microtiter plate format into which samples are deposited for oxidation.

RESULTS

We demonstrate the utility of the Pyrite Shrink-Wrap Laminate for the chemical generation of hydroxyl radicals by mapping the surface of the T-cell co-stimulatory protein Programmed Death - 1 (PD-1) and the interface of the complex with its ligand PD-L1.

CONCLUSION

We have developed and validated an affordable and reliable benchtop method of hydroxyl radical generation that will broaden the application of protein oxidative footprinting. Due to the minimal equipment required to implement this method, it should be easily adaptable by many laboratories with access to mass spectrometry.

Mechanistic Studies on RNA Strand Scission from a C2'-Radical

The C2'-carbon-hydrogen bond in ribonucleotides is significantly weaker than other carbohydrate carbon-hydrogen bonds in RNA or DNA. Independent generation of the C2'-uridine radical (1) in RNA oligonucleotides via Norrish type I photocleavage of a ketone-substituted nucleotide yields direct strand breaks via cleavage of the β-phosphate. The reactivity of 1 in different sequences and under a variety of conditions suggests that the rate constant for strand scission is significantly greater than 10⁶ s^-1 at pH 7.2. The initially formed C2'-radical (1) is not trapped under a variety of conditions, consistent with computational studies ( Chem.-Eur. J. 2009 , 15 , 2394 ) that suggest that the barrier to strand scission is very low and that synchronous proton transfer from the 2'-hydroxyl to the departing phosphate group facilitates cleavage. The C2'-radical could be a significant contributor to RNA strand scission by the hydroxyl radical, particularly under anaerobic conditions where 1 can be produced from nucleobase radicals.

Reactivity of Nucleic Acid Radicals

Nucleic acid oxidation plays a vital role in the etiology and treatment of diseases, as well as aging. Reagents that oxidize nucleic acids are also useful probes of the biopolymers' structure and folding. Radiation scientists have contributed greatly to our understanding of nucleic acid oxidation using a variety of techniques. During the past two decades organic chemists have applied the tools of synthetic and mechanistic chemistry to independently generate and study the reactive intermediates produced by ionizing radiation and other nucleic acid damaging agents. This approach has facilitated resolving mechanistic controversies and lead to the discovery of new reactive processes.

Drawing and editing the secondary structure(s) of RNA

Secondary structure diagrams are essential, in RNA biology, to communicate functional hypotheses and summarize structural data, and communicate them visually as drafts or finalized publication-ready figures. While many tools are currently available to automate the production of such diagrams, their capacities are usually partial, making it hard for a user to decide which to use in a given context. In this chapter, we guide the reader through the steps involved in the production of expressive publication-quality illustrations featuring the RNA secondary structure. We present major existing representations and layouts, and give precise instructions to produce them using available free software, including jViz.RNA, the PseudoViewer, RILogo, R-chie, RNAplot, R2R, and VARNA. We describe the file formats and structural descriptions accepted by popular RNA visualization tools. We also provide command lines and Python scripts to ease the user's access to advanced features. Finally, we discuss and illustrate alternative approaches to visualize the secondary structure in the presence of probing data, pseudoknots, RNA-RNA interactions, and comparative data.

Independent generation and reactivity of uridin-2'-yl radical

The uridin-2'-yl radical (1) has been proposed as an intermediate during RNA oxidation. However, its reactivity has not been thoroughly studied due to the complex conditions under which it is typically generated. The uridin-2'-yl radical was independently generated from a benzyl ketone (2a) via Norrish type I photocleavage upon irradiation at λmax = 350 nm. Dioxygen and β-mercaptoethanol are unable to compete with loss of uracil from 1 in phosphate buffer. Thiol trapping competes with uracil fragmentation in less polar solvent conditions. This is ascribed mostly to a reduction in the rate constant for uracil elimination in the less polar solvent. Hydrogen atom transfer to 1 from β-mercaptoethanol occurs exclusively from the α-face to produce arabinouridine. Mass balances range from 72 to 95%. Furthermore, the synthesis of 2a is amenable to formation of the requisite phosphoramidite for solid-phase oligonucleotide synthesis. This and the fidelity with which the urdin-2'-yl radical is generated from 2a suggest that this precursor should be useful for studying the radical's reactivity in synthetic oligonucleotides.

Analysis of diffuse K+ and Mg2+ ion binding to a two-base-pair kissing complex by single-molecule mechanical unfolding

The folding and stability of RNA tertiary interactions depend critically on cationic conditions. It is usually difficult, however, to isolate such effects on tertiary interactions from those on the entire RNA. By manipulating conformations of single RNA molecules using optical tweezers, we distinguished individual steps of breaking and forming of a two-base-pair kissing interaction from those of secondary folding. The binding of metal ions to the small tertiary structure appeared to be saturable with an apparent Kd of 160 mM for K(+) and 1.5 mM for Mg(2+). The kissing formation was estimated to be associated with binding of ~2-3 diffuse K(+) or Mg(2+) ions. At their saturated binding, Mg(2+) provided ~3 kcal/mol more stabilizing energy to the structure than K(+). Furthermore, the cations change the unkissing forces significantly more than the kissing ones. For example, the presence of Mg(2+) ions increased the average unkissing force from 21 pN to 44 pN, surprisingly high for breaking merely two base pairs; in contrast, the mean kissing force was changed by only 4.5 pN. Interestingly, the differential salt effects on the transition forces were not caused by different changes in the height of the kinetic barriers but were instead attributed to how different molecular structures respond to the applied force. Our results showed the importance of diffuse cation binding to the stability of tertiary interaction and demonstrated the utility of mechanical unfolding in studying tertiary interactions.

RNA catalysis as a probe for chaperone activity of DEAD-box helicases

DEAD-box proteins are vitally important to cellular processes and make up the largest class of helicases. Many DEAD-box proteins function as RNA chaperones by accelerating structural transitions of RNA, which can result in the resolution of misfolded conformers or conversion between functional structures. While the biological importance of chaperone proteins is clear, their mechanisms are incompletely understood. Here, we illustrate how the catalytic activity of certain RNAs can be used to measure RNA chaperone activity. By measuring the amount of substrate converted to product, the fraction of catalytically active molecules is measured over time, providing a quantitative measure of the formation or loss of native RNA. The assays are described with references to group I and group II introns and their ribozyme derivatives, and examples are included that illustrate potential complications and indicate how catalytic activity measurements can be combined with physical approaches to gain insights into the mechanisms of DEAD-box proteins as RNA chaperones.

Single molecule FRET characterization of large ribozyme folding

A procedure to investigate the folding of group II intron by single molecule Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer (smFRET) using total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM) is described in this chapter. Using our previous studies on the folding and dynamics of a large ribozyme in the presence of metal ions (i.e., Mg(2+) and Ca(2+)) and/or the DEAD-box protein Mss116 as an example, we here describe step-by-step procedures to perform experiments. smFRET allows the investigation of individual molecules, thus, providing kinetic and mechanistic information hidden in ensemble averaged experiments.

A microfluidic device that generates hydroxyl radicals to probe the solvent accessible surface of nucleic acids

We describe a microfluidic device containing a mineral matrix capable of rapidly generating hydroxyl radicals that enables high-resolution structural studies of nucleic acids. Hydroxyl radicals cleave the solvent accessible backbone of DNA and RNA; the cleavage products can be detected with as fine as single nucleotide resolution. Protection from hydroxyl radical cleavage (footprinting) can identify sites of protein binding or the presence of tertiary structure. Here we report preparation of micron sized particles of iron sulfide (pyrite) and fabrication of a microfluidic prototype that together generate enough hydroxyl radicals within 20 ms to cleave DNA sufficiently for a footprinting analysis to be conducted. This prototype enables the development of high-throughput and/or rapid reaction devices with which to probe nucleic acid folding dynamics and ligand binding.

Monitoring equilibrium changes in RNA structure by 'peroxidative' and 'oxidative' hydroxyl radical footprinting

RNA molecules play an essential role in biology. In addition to transmitting genetic information, RNA can fold into unique tertiary structures fulfilling a specific biologic role as regulator, binder or catalyst. Information about tertiary contact formation is essential to understand the function of RNA molecules. Hydroxyl radicals (•OH) are unique probes of the structure of nucleic acids due to their high reactivity and small size. When used as a footprinting probe, hydroxyl radicals map the solvent accessible surface of the phosphodiester backbone of DNA and RNA with as fine as single nucleotide resolution. Hydroxyl radical footprinting can be used to identify the nucleotides within an intermolecular contact surface, e.g. in DNA-protein and RNA-protein complexes. Equilibrium and kinetic transitions can be determined by conducting hydroxyl radical footprinting as a function of a solution variable or time, respectively. A key feature of footprinting is that limited exposure to the probe (e.g., 'single-hit kinetics') results in the uniform sampling of each nucleotide of the polymer. In this video article, we use the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena ribozyme to illustrate RNA sample preparation and the determination of a Mg(II)-mediated folding isotherms. We describe the use of the well known hydroxyl radical footprinting protocol that requires H(2)O(2) (we call this the 'peroxidative' protocol) and a valuable, but not widely known, alternative that uses naturally dissolved O(2)(we call this the 'oxidative' protocol). An overview of the data reduction, transformation and analysis procedures is presented.

Product and mechanistic analysis of the reactivity of a C6-pyrimidine radical in RNA

Nucleobase radicals are the major reactive intermediates produced when hydroxyl radical reacts with nucleic acids. 5,6-Dihydrouridin-6-yl radical (1) was independently generated from a ketone precursor via Norrish Type I photocleavage in a dinucleotide, single-stranded, and double-stranded RNA. This radical is a model of the major hydroxyl radical adduct of uridine. Tandem lesions resulting from addition of the peroxyl radical derived from 1 to the 5'-adjacent nucleotide are observed by ESI-MS. Radical 1 produces direct strand breaks at the 5'-adjacent nucleotide and at the initial site of generation. The preference for cleavage at these two positions depends upon the secondary structure of the RNA and whether O(2) is present or not. Varying the identity of the 5'-adjacent nucleotide has little effect on strand scission. In general, strand scission is significantly more efficient under anaerobic conditions than when O(2) is present. Strand scission is more than twice as efficient in double-stranded RNA than in a single-stranded oligonucleotide under anaerobic conditions. Internucleotidyl strand scission occurs via β-fragmentation following C2'-hydrogen atom abstraction by 1. The subsequently formed olefin cation radical ultimately yields products containing 3'-phosphate or 3'-deoxy-2'-ketouridine termini. These end groups are proposed to result from competing deprotonation pathways. The dependence of strand scission efficiency from 1 on secondary structure under anaerobic conditions suggests that this reactivity may be useful for extracting additional RNA structural information from hydroxyl radical reactions.

Hydroxyl-radical footprinting to probe equilibrium changes in RNA tertiary structure

Hydroxyl-radical footprinting utilizes the ability of a highly reactive species to nonspecifically cleave the solvent accessible regions of a nucleic acid backbone. Thus, changes in a nucleic acids structure can be probed either as a function of time or of a reagent's concentration. When combined with techniques that allow single nucleotide resolution of the resulting fragments, footprinting experiments provide richly detailed information about local changes in tertiary structure of a nucleic acid accompanying its folding or ligand binding. In this chapter, we present two protocols of equilibrium hydroxyl-radical footprinting based on peroxidative and oxidative Fenton chemistry and discuss how to adjust the Fenton reagent concentrations for a specific experimental condition. We also discuss the choice of the techniques to separate the reaction products and specifics of the data analysis for equilibrium footprinting experiments. Protocols addressing the use of peroxidative Fenton chemistry for time-resolved studies have been published [Schlatterer and Brenowitz, 2009. Methods; Shcherbakova and Brenowitz, 2008. Nat. Protoc.3(2), 288-302; Shcherbakova et al., 2006. Nucleic Acids Res.34(6), e48; Shcherbakova et al., 2007. Methods Cell Biol.84, 589-615].