Empirical analysis of RNA robustness and evolution using high-throughput sequencing of ribozyme reactions

RNA sequence to structure analysis from comprehensive pairwise mutagenesis of multiple self-cleaving ribozymes

Self-cleaving ribozymes are RNA molecules that catalyze the cleavage of their own phosphodiester backbones. These ribozymes are found in all domains of life and are also a tool for biotechnical and synthetic biology applications. Self-cleaving ribozymes are also an important model of sequence-to-function relationships for RNA because their small size simplifies synthesis of genetic variants and self-cleaving activity is an accessible readout of the functional consequence of the mutation. Here, we used a high-throughput experimental approach to determine the relative activity for every possible single and double mutant of five self-cleaving ribozymes. From this data, we comprehensively identified non-additive effects between pairs of mutations (epistasis) for all five ribozymes. We analyzed how changes in activity and trends in epistasis map to the ribozyme structures. The variety of structures studied provided opportunities to observe several examples of common structural elements, and the data was collected under identical experimental conditions to enable direct comparison. Heatmap-based visualization of the data revealed patterns indicating structural features of the ribozymes including paired regions, unpaired loops, non-canonical structures, and tertiary structural contacts. The data also revealed signatures of functionally critical nucleotides involved in catalysis. The results demonstrate that the data sets provide structural information similar to chemical or enzymatic probing experiments, but with additional quantitative functional information. The large-scale data sets can be used for models predicting structure and function and for efforts to engineer self-cleaving ribozymes.

Experimental Resurrection of Ancestral Mammalian CPEB3 Ribozymes Reveals Deep Functional Conservation

Self-cleaving ribozymes are genetic elements found in all domains of life, but their evolution remains poorly understood. A ribozyme located in the second intron of the cytoplasmic polyadenylation binding protein 3 gene (CPEB3) shows high sequence conservation in mammals, but little is known about the functional conservation of self-cleaving ribozyme activity across the mammalian tree of life or during the course of mammalian evolution. Here, we use a phylogenetic approach to design a mutational library and a deep sequencing assay to evaluate the in vitro self-cleavage activity of numerous extant and resurrected CPEB3 ribozymes that span over 100 My of mammalian evolution. We found that the predicted sequence at the divergence of placentals and marsupials is highly active, and this activity has been conserved in most lineages. A reduction in ribozyme activity appears to have occurred multiple different times throughout the mammalian tree of life. The in vitro activity data allow an evaluation of the predicted mutational pathways leading to extant ribozyme as well as the mutational landscape surrounding these ribozymes. The results demonstrate that in addition to sequence conservation, the self-cleavage activity of the CPEB3 ribozyme has persisted over millions of years of mammalian evolution.

Phased nucleotide inserts for sequencing low-diversity RNA samples from in vitro selection experiments

In vitro selection combined with high-throughput sequencing is a powerful experimental approach with broad application in the engineering and characterization of RNA molecules. Diverse pools of starting sequences used for selection are often flanked by fixed sequences used as primer binding sites. These low diversity regions often lead to data loss from complications with Illumina image processing algorithms. A common method to alleviate this problem is the addition of fragmented bacteriophage PhiX genome, which improves sequence quality but sacrifices a portion of usable sequencing reads. An alternative approach is to insert nucleotides of variable length and composition ("phased inserts") at the beginning of each molecule when adding sequencing adaptors. This approach preserves read depth but reduces the length of each read. Here, we test the ability of phased inserts to replace PhiX in a low-diversity sample generated for a high-throughput sequencing based ribozyme activity screen. We designed a pool of 4096 RNA sequence variants of the self-cleaving twister ribozyme from Oryza sativa For each unique sequence, we determined the fraction of ribozyme cleaved during in vitro transcription via deep sequencing on an Illumina MiSeq. We found that libraries with the phased inserts produced high-quality sequence data without the addition of PhiX. We found good agreement between previously published data on twister ribozyme variants and our data produced with phased inserts even when PhiX was omitted. We conclude that phased inserts can be implemented following in vitro selection experiments to reduce or eliminate the use of PhiX and maximize read depth.