Metabolic autopsy with next generation sequencing in sudden unexpected death in infancy: Postmortem diagnosis of fatty acid oxidation disorders

Dried Blood Spot Postmortem Metabolic Autopsy With Genotype Validation for Sudden Unexpected Deaths in Infancy and Childhood in Hong Kong

Background Inborn errors of metabolism (IEM) are collectively rare but potentially preventable causes of sudden unexpected death (SUD) in infancy or childhood, and metabolic autopsy serves as the final tool for establishing the diagnosis. We conducted a retrospective review of the metabolic and molecular autopsy on SUD and characterized the biochemical and genetic findings. Methodology A retrospective review of postmortem metabolic investigations (dried blood spot acylcarnitines and amino acid analysis, urine metabolic profiling where available, and next-generation sequencing on a panel of 75 IEM genes) performed for infants and children who presented with SUD between October 2016 and December 2021 with inconclusive autopsy findings or autopsy features suspicious of underlying IEM in our locality was conducted. Clinical and autopsy findings were reviewed for each case. Results A total of 43 infants and children aged between zero days to 10 years at the time of death were referred to the authors' laboratories throughout the study period. One positive case of multiple acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency was diagnosed. Postmortem reference intervals for dried blood spot amino acids and acylcarnitines profile were established based on the results from the remaining patients. Conclusions Our study confirmed the importance of metabolic autopsy and the advantages of incorporating biochemical and genetic testing in this setting.

Carnitine-acylcarnitine translocase deficiency: a case report with autopsy

Fatty acid oxidation defects are a heterogeneous group of disorders related to the mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation pathway. Carnitine acylcarnitine translocase (CACT) is an enzyme responsible for the unidirectional transport of acylcarnitine across the inner mitochondrial membrane. This enzyme plays a crucial role in the oxidation of fatty acids. The autopsy pathology of the CACT deficiency is described in only a few cases. We describe the autopsy pathology of a child with CACT deficiency dominantly in the form of microvesicular steatosis of the hepatocytes, renal proximal tubular epithelia, cardiac myocytes, and rhabdomyocytes. The diagnosis was further confirmed on whole exome sequencing with compound heterozygous variants in the exon 1 (c.82G>T, p.Gly28Cys; likely pathogenic) and exon 5 (c.535G>A, p.Asp179Asn; uncertain significance) of the SLC25A20 gene. This case elucidates the histopathology of the liver and the detailed autopsy of a case of CACT deficiency from India.

Molecular autopsy for sudden death in Japan

Japan has various death investigation systems; however, external examinations, postmortem computed tomography, macroscopic examinations, and microscopic examinations are performed regardless of the system used. These examinations can reveal morphological abnormalities, whereas the cause of death in cases with non-morphological abnormalities can be detected through additional examinations. Molecular autopsy and postmortem genetic analyses are important additional examinations. They are capable of detecting inherited arrhythmias or inherited metabolic diseases, which are representative non-morphological disorders that cause sudden death, especially in infants and young people. In this review, we introduce molecular autopsy reports from Japan and describe our experience with representative cases. The relationships between drug-related deaths and genetic variants are also reviewed. Based on the presented information, molecular autopsy is expected to be used as routine examinations in death investigations because they can provide information to save new lives.

Postmortem Genetic Testing in Sudden Unexpected Death: A Narrative Review

Sudden unexpected death (SUD) is one of the challenging situations encountered in forensic medicine. As a rule, a comprehensive forensic assessment is performed to identify the cause of death in such cases; however, the absence of findings suggestive of a cause, i.e., a negative autopsy, warrants further investigation such as a molecular autopsy. In this review, we aim to highlight the genetic causes of SUD, tools used in a molecular autopsy, and the role of screening in surviving relatives. As per several guidelines, the most preferred samples for DNA extraction are whole blood and fresh frozen tissues. Furthermore, Sanger sequencing and next-generation sequencing are the technologies that are used for genetic analysis; the latter overcomes the former's drawbacks in terms of cost-effectiveness, time consumption, and the ability to sequence the whole exome. SUD have diverse etiologies; we can generally classify them into cardiac and non-cardiac causes. Regarding cardiac causes, many conditions having an underlying genetic basis are included, such as channelopathies and cardiomyopathies. Regarding non-cardiac causes of SUD, the main etiologies are epilepsy and metabolic disorders. Nevertheless, it has been proposed that there is a genetic overlap between channelopathies, especially long QT syndromes and epilepsy. Additionally, fatty acid oxidation disorders are major metabolic conditions that are caused by certain genetic mutations that can lead to SUD in infancy. Since many SUD causes have an underlying genetic mutation, it is important to understand the genetic variations not only to recognize the cause of death but also to undertake further preventive measures for surviving relatives. In conclusion, a molecular autopsy has a major role in the forensic examination of cases of SUD.

Accurate interpretation of genetic variants in sudden unexpected death in infancy by trio-targeted gene-sequencing panel analysis

In sudden unexpected death in infancy cases, postmortem genetic analysis with next-generation sequencing potentially can extract candidate genes associated with sudden death. However, it is difficult to accurately interpret the clinically significant genetic variants. The study aim was to conduct trio analysis of cases of sudden unexpected death in infancy and their parents to more accurately interpret the clinically significant disease-associated gene variants associated with cause of death. From the TruSight One panel targeting 4813 genes we extracted candidate genetic variants of 66 arrhythmia-, 63 inherited metabolic disease-, 81 mitochondrial disease-, and 6 salt-losing tubulopathy-related genes in 7 cases and determined if they were de novo or parental-derived variants. Thirty-four parental-derived variants and no de novo variants were found, but none appeared to be related to the cause of death. Using trio analysis and an in silico algorithm to analyze all 4813 genes, we identified OBSCN of compound heterozygous and HCCS of hemizygous variants as new candidate genetic variants related to cause of death. Genetic analysis of these deceased infants and their living parents can provide more accurate interpretation of the clinically significant genetic variants than previously possible and help confirm the cause of death.

Circumstances and factors of sleep-related sudden infancy deaths in Japan

Background

Sudden unexpected death in infancy (SUDI) comprises both natural and unnatural causes of death. However, few epidemiological surveys have investigated SUDI in Japan.

Objective

This retrospective study was conducted to investigate the latest trends of circumstances and risk factors of SUDI cases in which collapse occurred during sleep.

Methods

Forensic pathology sections from eight universities participated in the selection of subjects from 2013 to 2018. Data obtained from the checklist form were analyzed based on information at postmortem.

Results

There were 259 SUDI cases consisting of 145 male infants and 114 female infants with a mean birth weight of 2888 ± 553 and 2750 ± 370 g, respectively. Deaths most frequently occurred among infants at 1 month of age (18%). According to population data as the control, the odds ratio (95% confidence interval) of mother’s age ≤19 years was 11.1 (6.9–17.7) compared with ages 30–39. The odds ratio for the fourth- and later born infants was 5.2 (3.4–7.9) compared with the frequency of first-born infants. The most frequent time of day for discovery was between 7 and 8 o’clock, and the time difference from the last seen alive was a mean of 4.1 h. Co-sleeping was recorded for 61%, and the prone position was found for 40% of cases at discovery. Mother’s smoking habit exhibited an odds ratio of 4.5 (2.9–5.8).

Conclusion

This study confirmed the trends that have been observed for sudden infant death syndrome; particularly, very high odds ratios were evident for teenage mothers and later birth order in comparison with those in other developed countries. Neglect was suspected in some cases of the prolonged time to discovery of unreactive infants. To our knowledge, this is the first report of an extensive survey of SUDI during sleep in Japan.

Need for strict clinical management of patients with carnitine palmitoyltransferase II deficiency: Experience with two cases detected by expanded newborn screening

In Japan, carnitine palmitoyltransferase II (CPTII) deficiency has been included as one of the primary target diseases in the expanded newborn mass screening program since 2018. However, many cases of the severe infantile hepatocardiomuscular form of CPTII deficiency showed severe neurodevelopmental delay or sudden death, which indicated that management of CPTII deficiency in the acute phase remains to be studied in detail. Herein, we discuss two cases diagnosed by newborn mass screening. Patient 1 was under strict clinical management from the neonatal period, with >20 admissions in 14 months, while Patient 2 was managed using a relatively relaxed approach, with only 2 admissions in the same period. Patient 1 showed normal development; however, Patient 2 expired at the age of 1 year 2 months. To develop strategies for preventing sudden deaths in patients with CPTII deficiency, this retrospective study focused on detailed clinical management practices and biochemical findings during the acute phase. We also investigated the correlation between conventional biomarkers (such as creatine kinase) and long-chain acylcarnitines. We propose that strict monitoring and immediate medical attention, even in case of slight fever or minor abdominal symptoms, can help prevent sudden death in patients with CPTII deficiency. Considering the higher morbidity rate of such patients, strict and acute management of CPTII deficiency cannot be overemphasized.

Increased parental anxiety and a benign clinical course: Infants identified with short-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency and isobutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency through newborn screening in Georgia

The long-term consequences and need for therapy in children with short-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (SCADD) or isobutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (IBDD) identified via newborn screening (NBS) remains controversial. Initial clinical descriptions were severe; however, while most cases identified through NBS have remained asymptomatic, clinical concerns have been raised in these populations. It is not clear whether these children are asymptomatic because of the success of NBS, or because the normal clinical course of these disorders is relatively benign. To evaluate these possibilities in our program, we evaluated the clinical outcomes of children with SCADD or IBDD identified by the Georgia NBS compared to the health status of a healthy age-matched control group. We also assessed parental anxiety during a phone interview both subjectively and objectively using the Pediatric Inventory for Parents (PIP), a validated measure of illness-related parental stress. The general health of 52 SCADD and nine IBDD cases from 2007 to 2016 were compared to the general health of unaffected control children obtained through the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) parent listserv. We also collected statements from parents who participated in a phone survey regarding events they experienced during and after their diagnostic process. Overall, the children with SCADD and IBDD had no major health problems. There was no significant difference in cognitive development (p = .207). We identified a slightly higher incidence of reported neonatal hypoglycemia in the SCADD group; two of these occurred in the context of maternal diabetes. All interviewed parents reported extreme anxiety during the diagnostic period and current feelings of uncertainty about their child's future. PIP scores for all six caregivers who responded to that portion of the survey were consistent with some degree of parental stress. The greatest reported stressor was the unknown long-term impact of the illness. All children with SCADD and IBDD had no significant long-term sequelae. The phone interviews revealed substantial parental anxiety about the identification and follow-up of SCADD and IBDD. Based on our findings, the anxiety parents experience may be unwarranted given that we see no disease-associated morbidity or mortality in these children. Consideration should be given to the removal of these conditions from NBS panels, or if that is not possible, clinicians could educate parents on the benign nature of these diagnoses and release them from follow-up without treatment.

Estimating carrier frequencies of newborn screening disorders using a whole-genome reference panel of 3552 Japanese individuals

Incidence rates of Mendelian diseases vary among ethnic groups, and frequencies of variant types of causative genes also vary among human populations. In this study, we examined to what extent we can predict population frequencies of recessive disorders from genomic data, and explored better strategies for variant interpretation and classification. We used a whole-genome reference panel from 3552 general Japanese individuals constructed by the Tohoku Medical Megabank Organization (ToMMo). Focusing on 32 genes for 17 congenital metabolic disorders included in newborn screening (NBS) in Japan, we identified reported and predicted pathogenic variants through variant annotation, interpretation, and multiple ways of classifications. The estimated carrier frequencies were compared with those from the Japanese NBS data based on 1,949,987 newborns from a previous study. The estimated carrier frequency based on genomic data with a recent guideline of variant interpretation for the PAH gene, in which defects cause hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA) and phenylketonuria (PKU), provided a closer estimate to that by the observed incidence than the other methods. In contrast, the estimated carrier frequencies for SLC25A13, which causes citrin deficiency, were much higher compared with the incidence rate. The results varied greatly among the 11 NBS diseases with single responsible genes; the possible reasons for departures from the carrier frequencies by reported incidence rates were discussed. Of note, (1) the number of pathogenic variants increases by including additional lines of evidence, (2) common variants with mild effects also contribute to the actual frequency of patients, and (3) penetrance of each variant remains unclear.

Peri-mortem evaluation of infants who die without a diagnosis: focus on advances in genomic technology

Infants who die within the first weeks to months of life may have genetic disorders, though many die without a confirmed diagnosis. Non-genetic conditions may also be responsible for unexplained infant deaths, and the diagnosis may be reliant upon studies performed in the peri-mortem period. Neonatologists, obstetricians, or pediatricians caring for these children and their families may be unsure of which investigations can and should be performed in the setting of a newborn or infant who is dying or has died. Recent advances in genomic sequencing technology may provide additional diagnostic options, though the interpretation of genetic variants discovered by this technique may be contingent upon clinical phenotype information that is obtained peri-mortem or upon autopsy. We have reviewed the current literature concerning the evaluation of an unexplained neonatal or infantile demise and synthesized a diagnostic approach, with a focus on the contribution of new and emerging genomic technologies.