Echocardiography can detect cloth cover tears in fully covered Starr-Edwards valves: a long-term clinical and echocardiographic study

Excellent durability of Starr-Edwards ball valves implanted in the aortic and mitral positions for 27 years: report of a rare surgical case

A 59-year-old male who had undergone aortic and mitral valve replacement with Starr-Edwards ball valves 27 years ago was admitted to our hospital for hemolytic anemia and heart failure. Echocardiography revealed prosthetic valve failure with a high-pressure gradient and small effective orifice area. The Starr-Edwards ball valves were successfully replaced with bileaflet mechanical valves. The explanted valves revealed no structural abnormalities.

Use of the Bentall method for replacement of an aortic Starr-Edwards ball valve prosthesis implanted 32 years previously

We report the case of a 54-year-old woman who, 32 years previously, had undergone replacement of the ascending aorta by the inclusion method with a Starr-Edwards ball valve prosthesis and recently underwent aortic root re-reconstruction by the Bentall method. Routine chest radiography revealed dilatation of the mediastinum, and computed tomography revealed an aneurysm of the ascending aorta. At reoperation, although the cloth covering the cage of the Starr-Edwards ball valve prosthesis appeared worn and some pannus formation was seen, the Starr-Edwards ball valve was functioning normally. The aortic root was replaced with a composite graft that consisted of a 23-mm St. Jude bileaflet prosthesis and a 24-mm Hemashield gold graft. The patient was discharged from the hospital in good condition 25 days after surgery.

Long-Term Results of the Cloth-Covered Starr-Edwards Ball Valve

BACKGROUND

Between June 1968 and March 1977, Starr-Edwards cloth-covered ball valves were exclusively implanted, in a total of 74 patients at our institution, on a routine basis.

METHODS

The retrospective postoperative follow-up rate was 84.5%, for up to 36 years in mitral valve patients (982.5 patient-years); and 81.3%, for up to 34 years in aortic valve patients (282.0 patient-years). Among 66 operative survivors, 20 patients required reoperation due to valve-related complications. Mortality and morbidity after valve replacement was reviewed, and excised valves were examined.

RESULTS

Survival rates after 10, 20, and 30 years were 74.6%, 64.1%, and 31.2%, respectively, after mitral valve replacement, and 62.5%, 50.0%, and 43.8%, respectively, after aortic valve replacement. Freedom from all valve-related complications, respectively after 10, 20, and 30 years, was 70.5%, 55.9%, and 46.4% after mitral valve replacement, and 56.2%, 37.5%, and 31.2% after aortic valve replacement. Cloth wear or pannus overgrowth was observed in all excised prostheses. Remarkable orifice tear was observed in mitral valves that were more than 20 years old. Pannus overgrowth on the studs contributed to prosthetic regurgitation in the older valves. Concomitant valve procedures were frequently required for valve-related complications or other aggravated valve lesions in the mitral position during the follow-up period.

CONCLUSIONS

Early diagnosis of valve dysfunction and the decision to reoperate are important to improve the long-term results for surviving patients who have received a cloth-covered Starr-Edwards valve, especially in the mitral position.

Valve dysfunction of the cloth-covered Starr-Edwards ball valve

BACKGROUND

Between June 1968 and March 1977, Starr-Edwards cloth-covered ball valves were used for valve replacement on a routine basis.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Among the 66 operative survivors who underwent an isolated aortic or mitral valve replacement, 20 patients required reoperation 22 times because of valve dysfunction, thromboembolic complication, paravalvular leakage, hemolytic anemia, and/or prosthetic valve endocarditis. Reoperation was performed at a mean of 15.9+/-9.8 years after initial replacement. Excised valves were examined and reoperation after initial operation was reviewed. Operative mortality was 10.0%. Freedom from reoperation for aortic valve replacement and mitral valve replacement was 56.2% at 34 years and 61.0% at 37 years after initial operation, respectively. Cloth wear or pannus formation were observed in all excised prostheses. Orifice cloth was more markedly worn in mitral valves than in aortic valves, particularly in mitral valves of more than 20 years old. Pannus overgrowth contributed to valve regurgitation in the older valves.

CONCLUSIONS

Early diagnosis of valve dysfunction and reoperation are recommended as soon as symptoms appear.

Cloth tears in asymptomatic survivors of aortic valve replacement with Starr-Edwards prostheses: detection by transesophageal echocardiography

Cloth-covered Starr-Edwards valves were withdrawn in the 1970s because of complications of cloth tear. Nevertheless, many patients are still alive with their prosthesis in place. We evaluated the ability of transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) to detect cloth tear in 9 asymptomatic patients operated on with a cloth-covered Starr-Edwards aortic valve at our institution. An echogenic mobile structure attached to the prosthesis, suggestive of a tear, was detected in 5 patients (55%). A tear was diagnosed in a sixth patient when TEE was repeated during follow-up because of neurologic symptoms. In all cases, transthoracic echocardiography failed to detect any abnormality. Two patients had symptoms develop and underwent reoperation; cloth tear was more extensive than suspected by TEE. Cloth tear is a frequent finding that can be detected by TEE in asymptomatic patients with cloth-covered Starr-Edwards aortic prosthesis. TEE is recommended in these patients and reoperation should be considered as soon as symptoms appear.