Validation of color Doppler measurements of minimum patent ductus arteriosus diameters: significance for coil embolization

Echocardiographic Versus Angiographic Assessment of Patent Arterial Duct in Percutaneous Closure: Towards X-ray Free Duct Occlusion?

Device selection and procedural guidance for percutaneous ductal closure strongly rely upon angiographic and echocardiographic imaging. Current literature recognises 2D echocardiography as an essential tool for diagnosis and assessment but does not define a consistent methodology to optimise ductal measurement. There is little research comparing echocardiography with gold standard angiography for ductal measurement. Proving 2D echocardiographic ductal measurement to be equivalent to angiography could pave the way for its use as the primary modality in image guidance for percutaneous closure of the ductus. This was a retrospective study of 100 consecutive paediatric patients who underwent percutaneous ductal closure. Echocardiographic images were studied to determine ductal (a) morphology (b) dimensions (length, aortic ampulla, pulmonary end, minimum diameter) (c) size of device that would be appropriate for closure. These data were compared to corresponding measurements generated by angiographic images. Inter and intra-observer ratings were calculated to assess levels of agreement. There were significant differences between the imaging methods in classifying the morphological sub-type and ductal measurements (p < 0.005), except for length which was not found to be significantly different between modalities. Prediction of device selection from angiographic images showed excellent agreement (weighted k = 0.81). Predictions based on echocardiographic images showed a poor level of agreement (weighted k = 0.14). We found poor correlation between echocardiography and angiography for measurement, morphological assessment and device selection. Based on our findings, percutaneous arterial duct occlusion without angiographic guidance in this age group cannot be advocated.

Estimation of patent ductus arteriosus diameters by colour Doppler echocardiography in children

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether accurate estimation of the diameter of the patent ductus arteriosus can be obtained by colour Doppler echocardiography.

METHODS

The minimum and maximum diameters of the patent ductus arteriosus were measured by colour Doppler echocardiography and compared with its angiographic size.

RESULTS

We studied 40 patients, aged between 4 months and 18 years. The measured pulmonary side diameter in echocardiography was 33.6% larger than that in angiography, and the aortic side was 7.8% smaller. We found a correlation between the measurements of the minimum and maximum size of the patent ductus arteriosus (r = 48.8 and 52.6) by colour Doppler echocardiography and angiographic findings, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Colour Doppler echocardiography significantly overestimates the minimum size of the patent ductus arteriosus; therefore, reconsideration of the respective size is suggested.

Clinical and echocardiographic diagnosis of patent ductus arteriosus in premature neonates

The ductus arteriosus frequently fails to close in premature neonates. Considerable difference in opinion exists around what signifies a hemodynamically significant patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) and how reliable clinical signs are in determining the degree of the left-to-right shunting. Although reliance on clinical signs alone could delay the diagnosis of a PDA, there is insufficient evidence to suggest that early treatment improves outcome. Echocardiography is often used as the gold standard for diagnosing a PDA. A combination of echocardiographic measurements may assist in the early diagnosis of a PDA with a hemodynamically significant degree of left-to-right shunting, especially in extremely premature babies, where closure can be significantly delayed. Decision to treat PDA should be based on a combination of clinical signs and echocardiographic parameters. Monitoring B-type natriuretic peptide may be useful in the diagnosing neonates with symptomatic PDA.

Comprehensive assessment of patent ductus arteriosus by echocardiography before transcatheter closure

BACKGROUND

Anatomic type and angiographic measurements of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) are used to determine the suitability of transcatheter closure (TCC). The purpose of this study is to evaluate whether these PDA features can be obtained by 2-dimensional echocardiography (2DE).

METHODS

We retrospectively compared PDA measurements and type from 36 patients submitted to TCC between November 1995 and October 2000.

RESULTS

The patient age ranged between 2 months to 10.5 years (median = 1.2 years). A significant correlation was found between measurements of PDA minimal diameter (R(2) = 0.88) and diameter at aortic ostium (R(2) = 0.72); whereas a poor correlation existed between measurements of the ampulla length. The 2DE and angiographic PDA classification were concordant in 31 of 36 (86%) patients.

CONCLUSION

Our data support the use of 2DE measurements of PDA minimal diameter and PDA diameter at the aortic end to assess suitability for TCC. In the majority of cases, PDA type can be diagnosed by 2DE.