Head-up tilt testing potentiated with low-dose sublingual isosorbide dinitrate: a simplified time-saving approach for the evaluation of unexplained syncope

Head-up tilt testing for diagnosing vasovagal syncope: a meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

A systematic evaluation focused on sensitivity and specificity of head-up tilt testing (HUT) for diagnosing vasovagal syncope has not been previously performed. We conducted a meta-analysis of studies comparing HUT outcome between patients with syncope of unknown origin and control subjects without previous syncope.

METHODS

We searched Pubmed and Embase databases for all English-only articles concerning case-control studies estimating the diagnostic yield of HUT, and selected 55 articles, published before March 2012, including 4361 patients and 1791 controls. The influence of age, test duration, tilt angle, and nitroglycerine or isoproterenol stimulation on tilt testing outcome was analyzed.

RESULTS

Head-up tilt testing demonstrated to have a good overall ability to discriminate between symptomatic patients and asymptomatic controls with an area under the summary receiver-operating characteristics curve of 0.84 and an adjusted diagnostic odds ratio of 12.15 (p<0.001). A significant inverse relationship between sensitivity and specificity of tilt testing for each study was observed (p<0.001). At multivariate analysis, advancing age and a 60° tilt angle showed a significant effect in reducing sensitivity and increasing specificity of the test. Nitroglycerine significantly raised tilt testing sensitivity by maintaining a similar specificity in comparison to isoproterenol.

CONCLUSIONS

The results from this meta-analysis show the high overall performance of HUT for diagnosing vasovagal syncope. Our findings provide useful information for evaluating clinical and instrumental parameters together with pharmacological stressors influencing HUT accuracy. This could allow the drawing of tilt testing protocols tailored on the diagnostic needs of each patient with unexplained syncope.

An increased endothelial-independent vasodilation is the hallmark of the neurally mediated syncope

BACKGROUND

The neurally mediated syncope (NMS) is sustained by complex cardiac and vascular reflexes, acting on and amplified by central autonomic loops, resulting in bradycardia and hypotension.

HYPOTHESIS

Our aim was to assess whether the pathophysiology of NMS is also related to an abnormal peripheral vasoreactivity.

METHODS

We evaluated by ultrasound the flow-mediated vasodilation (FMD) and the nitrate-mediated dilation (NMD) in 17 patients with NMS, induced by drug-free tilt test in 6 subjects and by nitrate-potentiated tilt test in the other 11 cases; the syncope was classified as vasodepressive (VD) in 8 cases, cardioinhibitory (CI) in 7, and mixed in 2.

RESULTS

The FMD was not different from controls (10.2 ± 4.5 vs 11.4 ± 3.9, P = ns), with normal recovery times; the NMD was greater in fainting subjects than in controls (26.7 ± 7.3 vs 19.0 ± 3.6, P < 0.05), with higher values in VD than in CI syncope (31.1 ± 7.0 vs 23.1 ± 5.0, P = ns); compared to controls, subjects with NMS showed normal recovery times after FMD but longer recovery times after nitrate administration (13.0 ± 5.6 vs 6.3 ± 0.7 minutes, P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The evaluation of endothelial function supports evidence that NMS is characterized by a marked and sustained endothelial-independent vasodilation, in the presence of a normal FMD; vascular hyperreactivity in response to nitrate administration is particularly overt in vasodepressive syncope and can explain the high rate of responses to nitrate administration during tilt test.

Head Up Tilt Testing: An Appraisal of Its Current Role in the Management of Patients with Syncope

Head up tilt testing (HTT) is now commonly used to investigate otherwise unexplained syncope and presyncope. This test has been used for over 20 years primarily to diagnose neurally mediated syncope, but HTT's exact role in the diagnostic process remains uncertain. Recognized limitations include poor reproducibility, lack of prognostic role, and insufficient randomized studies to guide therapeutic choice. In this review, we describe the indications and methods recommended by present guidelines on utilizing HTT. In addition, present criticisms and limitations of this test, along with future perspectives, are outlined.

Head-up tilt table testing in syncope: safety and efficiency of isosorbide versus isoproterenol in pediatric population

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to compare the diagnostic value and safety of sublingual isosorbid dinitrate (ISDN) with intravenous isoproterenol (ISOP) during head-up tilt table testing (HUTT) in pediatric patients with suspected neurocardiogenic syncope.

METHODS

One hundred thirty-six consecutive pediatric patients complaining of presyncope or syncope were submitted to HUTT for the first time. Those who did not develop syncope or presyncope during passive HUTT for 20 minutes underwent repeated HUTT with either 1.25 to 2.5 mg sublingual ISDN or intravenous ISOP (1-3 mug/min) for 20 minutes. There were 54 boys and 82 girls, aged 10 to 18 years with an average of 15.5 +/- 2.4 years and a median of 16 years. Among the patients with cardioinhibition or mixed responses, the severity of the bradyarrhythmia was scored 1 to 3 (restoration of effective rhythm within 10 seconds, 10-20 seconds, and >20 seconds while back to supine position, respectively).

RESULTS

During the passive period, 24 (17.6%) of 136 patients had a positive response to HUTT. Syncope was observed in another 44 patients during either ISDN or ISOP period (14/58 [24.1%] and 30/54 [55.5%] with ISDN vs ISOP, respectively, P < .05). The time to symptoms was shorter with both ISDN and ISOP compared with passive period (6.5 +/- 2.9, 6.3 +/- 5.9, and 10.3 +/- 4.4, minutes, respectively, P < .05). The severity score for cardioinhibition response was significantly higher with ISDN compared with the passive period and ISOP (2 +/- 0.8, 1.25 +/- 0.45, and 1.26 +/- 0.45, respectively, P < .01).

CONCLUSIONS

Sublingual ISDN is less sensitive and less safe compared to intravenous ISOP in assessing pediatric age patients with suspected neurocardiogenic syncope and with a negative result in tilt test without provocation. The simplicity of ISDN use should be weighed against the risk of longer symptoms with ISDN.

'Front-loaded' head-up tilt table testing: validation of a rapid first line nitrate-provoked tilt protocol for the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope

Head-up tilt testing is the investigation of choice in the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope. The test is time consuming and labour intensive, with conventional tilt testing taking up to 45 min. We compared a shortened 'front-loaded' 20-min glyceryl trinitrate-provoked head-up tilt (FLGTN-HUT) with the standard 40-min passive tilt (HUT) as first line investigations in patients with unexplained syncope and asymptomatic controls. In the study, 149 consecutive patients with unexplained syncope and 83 asymptomatic controls were enrolled. Subjects were randomly assigned to FLGTN-HUT (800 mcg, metred spray) or HUT, then the opposite tilt-test 1 week later. Seventeen (11.4%) patients had diagnostic haemodynamic changes and symptom reproduction during HUT and 54 (36.2%) during FLGTN-HUT. A total of 24.8% more patients had a positive test with FLGTN-HUT than with passive HUT (95% CI: 16.3%, 33.4%). Nine (10.8%) controls had significant haemodynamic changes during HUT and 23 (27.7%) during GTN provocation. Seven controls had haemodynamic changes on both HUT and FLGTN-HUT testing. The controls group had 16.8% more significant haemodynamic changes with FLGTN-HUT than with HUT (95% CI: 0.06, 27.4). The front-loaded GTN protocol provided a higher diagnostic rate than passive tilt testing, and provides a rapid alternative to conventional methods, though false positivity rates are higher.

Predictive models of syncope causes in an outpatient clinic

The investigation of unexplained syncope remains a challenging clinical problem. In the present study we sought to evaluate the diagnostic value of a standardized work-up focusing on non invasive tests in patients with unexplained syncope referred to a syncope clinic, and whether certain combinations of clinical parameters are characteristic of rhythmic and reflex causes of syncope.

METHODS AND RESULTS

317 consecutive patients underwent a standardized work-up including a 12-lead ECG, physical examination, detailed history with screening for syncope-related symptoms using a structured questionnaire followed by carotid sinus massage (CSM), and head-up tilt test. Invasive testings including an electrophysiological study and implantation of a loop recorder were only performed in those with structural heart disease or traumatic syncope. Our work-up identified an etiology in 81% of the patients. Importantly, three quarters of the causes were established non invasively combining head-up tilt test, CSM and hyperventilation testing. Invasive tests yielded an additional 7% of diagnoses. Logistic analysis identified age and number of significant prodromes as the only predictive factors of rhythmic syncope. The same two factors, in addition to the duration of the ECG P-wave, were also predictive of vasovagal and psychogenic syncope. These factors, optimally combined in predictive models, showed a high negative and a modest positive predictive value.

CONCLUSION

A standardized work-up focusing on non invasive tests allows to establish more than three quarters of syncope causes. Predictive models based on simple clinical parameters may help to distinguish between rhythmic and other causes of syncope.

Usefulness and safety of shortened head-up tilt testing potentiated with sublingual glyceryl trinitrate in older patients with recurrent unexplained syncope

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the sensitivity and tolerability of shortened, glyceryl trinitrate (GTN)-potentiated, head-up tilt test (HUT) in patients older and younger than 65 with unexplained syncope and to compare the specificity of GTN-potentiated HUT (GTN-HUT) in older and younger controls.

DESIGN

Methodological study.

SETTING

Syncope units in secondary and tertiary hospitals.

PARTICIPANTS

Three hundred twenty-four consecutive patients with unexplained syncope (100 aged > or =65 (mean age +/- standard deviation 73 +/- 6; 35 men) and 224 aged <65 (41 +/- 15; 111 men)) and 64 controls (29 aged > or =65 (73 +/- 6; 13 men) and 35 aged <65 (42 +/- 13; 16 men)).

INTERVENTION

Patients and controls were tilted upright to 60 degrees for 20 minutes. If syncope did not occur, sublingual GTN (400 microg) was administered and 60 degrees HUT was continued for 15 minutes. Responses were classified as positive, negative, or exaggerated (slow decrease in blood pressure with a slight decrease in heart rate after GTN).

MEASUREMENTS

Electrocardiogram and arterial pressure were monitored continuously.

RESULTS

GTN-HUT was positive in 60% and 66% (NS), negative in 29% and 33% (NS), and exaggerated in 11% and 1% (P <.001) of older and younger patients, respectively. In older and younger controls, the GTN-HUT was negative in 70% and 86% and exaggerated in 28% and 9% of cases, respectively, (P <.05). The overall specificity (considering as negative also the exaggerated responses) was 97% in older and 94% in younger subjects. No patient or control experienced serious side effects.

CONCLUSION

The shortened GTN-HUT provides satisfactory positivity rate and specificity in older patients. This test may be considered as a diagnostic tool in assessing recurrent unexplained syncope in older patients.

[Head-up tilt test potentiated with nitroglycerin. What is the optimal duration of the test after administration of the drug?]

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

Numerous variations of the head-up tilt-table test potentiated with nitrates have been reported. After the administration of nitroglycerin, between 10 and 25 min of continued tilting have been recommended. The aim of this study was to assess the optimal duration of the pharmacological phase of the head-up tilt-table test potentiated with sublingual administration of nitroglycerin spray (NTG-TT).

METHOD

The records of 498 consecutive NTG-TT were reviewed. Our protocol consisted of a 20-min drug-free phase at a 60o angle. If syncope does not develop, 400 microgram of sublingual nitroglycerin spray is administered and the patient continues to be tilted for a further 25 min. The test results and time to a positive response were analyzed.

RESULTS

The result of NTG-TT was positive in 288 procedures, most of them after nitroglycerin administration (255, 88.5%). The mean time to a positive response was 10.7 6.7 and 5.0 2.4 min during the control and pharmacological phases respectively. Most positive responses were concentrated in the 3 to 5 min after drug administration. The time to syncope after nitroglycerin administration was over 10 min in 9 patients and 15 min in only 2 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The duration of the pharmacological phase of NTG-TT using the described protocol can be reduced to 15 min without loss of sensitivity. A further reduction to 10 min would decrease the rate of positive responses by a small amount and might be considered clinically acceptable.

Permanent cardiac pacing versus medical treatment for the prevention of recurrent vasovagal syncope: a multicenter, randomized, controlled trial

BACKGROUND

This clinical investigation was performed to compare the effects of permanent dual-chamber cardiac pacing with pharmacological therapy in patients with recurrent vasovagal syncope.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Patients from 14 centers were randomized to receive either a DDD pacemaker provided with rate-drop response function or the beta-blocker atenolol at the dosage of 100 mg once a day. Inclusion criteria were age >35 years, >/=3 syncopal spells in the preceding 2 years, and positive response to tilt table testing with syncope occurring in association with relative bradycardia. The primary outcome was the first recurrence of syncope after randomization. Enrollment was started in December 1997, and the first formal interim analysis was performed on July 30, 2000. By that time, 93 patients (38 men and 55 women; mean age, 58.1+/-14.3 years) had been enrolled and randomized, although follow-up data were available for all patients (46 patients in the pacemaker arm, 47 patients in the pharmacological arm). The interim analysis showed a significant effect in favor of permanent cardiac pacing (recurrence of syncope in 2 patients [4.3%] after a median of 390 days) compared with medical treatment (recurrence of syncope in 12 patients [25.5%] after a median of 135 days; OR, 0.133; 95% CI, 0.028 to 0.632; P=0.004). Consequently, enrollment and follow-up were terminated.

CONCLUSIONS

DDD pacing with rate-drop response function is more effective than beta-blockade for the prevention of syncopal recurrences in highly symptomatic vasovagal fainters with relative bradycardia during tilt-induced syncope.

Specificity and total positive rate of head-up tilt testing potentiated with sublingual nitroglycerin in older patients with unexplained syncope

The aim of this study was to assess the specificity and total positive rate of head-up tilt testing (HUTT) potentiated with sublingual nitroglycerin in detecting the vasovagal origin of unexplained syncope in the elderly, since the diagnostic value of this non-invasive test has not yet been proven in this age group. In a period of 3 years, 128 elderly patients (mean age 71.6+/-5.1 years, 50% males) with syncope of unknown origin, and 101 control subjects matched for age and gender were tilted upright to 60 degrees for 45 minutes. If syncope did not occur, sublingual nitroglycerin (0.4 mg) was administered, and observation was continued for 20 minutes. The positive response was defined as the reproduction of syncope or pre-syncope according to VASIS definition. During the unmedicated phase, syncope occurred in 26 patients (20.3%) and in no members of the control group. After nitroglycerin, 53 patients (41.4%) and 2 control subjects (2%) displayed syncope. The total positive rate of the test was 61.8% with a specificity of 98.0%. In conclusion, HUTT potentiated with sublingual nitroglycerin provides an adequate specificity and total positive rate in old patients with unexplained syncope; therefore it can be proposed as a useful diagnostic tool to detect the vasovagal origin of syncope not only in middle but also in advanced age.

Spectral and cross-spectral autoregressive analysis of cardiovascular variables in subjects with different degrees of orthostatic tolerance

The mechanisms leading to vasovagal syncope are still unclear. A simple discriminating test for the identification of syncope-prone subjects is not presently available. Fifty-two subjects had a stepwise orthostatic test with 60 degrees tilt and -20 and -40 mm Hg lower-body negative pressure before the appearance of impending syncope symptoms. Spectral and cross-spectral analyses of heart period and systolic pressure time series were performed to estimate the power of the high-frequency (approximately equals 0.25 Hz) and low-frequency (approximately equals 0.1 Hz) oscillations, the coherence between heart period and systolic pressure, and the mean low-frequency and high-frequency central frequency, phase shift, and transfer function at maximal coherence. According to time to presyncope, the 52 subjects were divided into two groups: 25 with normal orthostatic tolerance, and 27 with poor orthostatic tolerance. In the supine positions, the mean central low-frequency was significantly lower in poor-tolerance group than in normal-tolerance group, discriminating poor from normal orthostatic tolerance with 80% specificity and 83% sensitivity, and was significantly correlated to time to presyncope. In the 2 to 3 minutes preceding syncope, subjects with poor orthostatic tolerance had less tachycardia, lower low-frequency power of systolic pressure, higher respiratory frequency, and a less negative phase shift in high-frequency range. In presyncope, sympathetic activation is reduced in subjects with poor orthostatic tolerance. In addition, the higher breathing frequency and the smaller negativity of phase shift in high-frequency range, which may indicate an inadequate engagement of the baroreflex, suggest a causal role of respiration in the development of syncope. Supine central values of low frequency may be proposed as a valuable clinical index of orthostatic intolerance.

Comparison of diagnostic accuracy of sublingual nitroglycerin test and low-dose isoproterenol test in patients with unexplained syncope

Despite the widespread use of head-up tilt testing as a means for diagnosing vasovagal syncope, standardization of test methodology remains a controversial issue. The aim of this study was to compare the diagnostic value of head-up tilt testing potentiated with sublingual nitroglycerin with that of head-up tilt testing potentiated with low-dose isoproterenol. For this purpose, 71 patients with unexplained syncope (mean age 43 years) and 30 asymptomatic controls were studied. All underwent the sublingual nitroglycerin and low-dose isoproterenol tests on separate days in a randomized fashion. The protocol of the 2 tests was similar and consisted of 2 phases. Initially, subjects were tilted at 60 degrees for 20 minutes without medication; then, if syncope did not occur, patients and controls received sublingual nitroglycerin (300 microg) or low-dose intravenous isoproterenol (mean infusion rate 1.3 +/- 0.5 microg/min) and continued to be tilted at 60 degrees for a further 20 minutes. During the sublingual nitroglycerin test, a positive response (syncope associated with sudden hypotension and bradycardia) occurred in 35 patients (49%), a negative response in 36 (51%), and drug intolerance in none (0%). During the low-dose isoproterenol test, these percentages were 41%, 59%, and 6%, respectively. A concordant response was observed in 53 cases (75%). Among controls, 3 subjects (10%) had a positive response to the sublingual nitroglycerin test and 4 (13%) to the low-dose isoproterenol test. It is concluded that sublingual nitroglycerin and low-dose isoproterenol are equivalent tests for evaluating patients with unexplained syncope. The sublingual nitroglycerin test, however, is simpler, better tolerated, and safer than the low-dose isoproterenol test and, thus, more suitable for routine clinical use.

Susceptibility to neuromediated syncope after acute myocardial infarction

BACKGROUND

Syncope after acute myocardial infarction (AMI) is a common clinical problem. It may be hypothesised that remodelling and neurohormonal changes following AMI may predispose to neuromediated syncope.

DESIGN

To address this issue we prospectively evaluated the incidence of positive results of head-up tilt-table testing in 40 patients following AMI and 40 age and sex matched controls without a history of syncope. The mechanisms of tilt-induced changes in autonomic tone were assessed using spectral analysis of heart rate variability. The patients were followed-up for one year.

RESULTS

Positive results of tilt-test occurred in 4 (10%) controls and 13 (33%) AMI patients (P = 0.01). No significant differences in sympathovagal interaction (assessed by a low frequency/high frequency ratio) were detected between the groups before tilting (2. 9 +/- 1.9 vs. 3.1 +/- 2.2; NS). However, dynamic changes of this parameter differed significantly during the first 5 symptomless minutes of the active phase of tilt-test. The ratio increased in the majority of controls (87%) and decreased in the majority of patients (62%) (P < 0.0001). During one year follow-up, syncope or presyncope occurred in 10 (25%) AMI patients but did not occur in any control subject (P < 0.001). The sensitivity, specificity and predictive accuracy of an early tilt-test after AMI for the prediction of syncope or presyncope was 70%, 80% and 78%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Patients after AMI are prone to neuromediated reactions. Sympathetic withdrawal seems to be the most likely mechanism of syncope. The role of tilt testing for identification of patients susceptible to syncope or presyncope after AMI needs further investigation.

Electroencephalographic correlates of vasovagal syncope induced by head-up tilt testing

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

We sought to determine whether the introduction of EEG monitoring during head-up tilt testing could significantly improve the understanding of the cerebral events occurring during tilt-induced vasovagal syncope and the potential danger to the patient of this diagnostic procedure.

METHODS

EEG monitoring was performed during head-up tilt testing in a group of 63 consecutive patients (27 males and 36 females; mean age, 41.5 years) with a history of recurrent syncope of unknown origin despite extensive clinical and laboratory assessment.

RESULTS

Syncope occurred in 27 of 63 patients (42.8%) during head-up tilt testing and was found to be cardioinhibitory in 11 of 27 (40.7%) and vasodepressor in 16 of 27 (59.3%). All patients with a negative response to head-up tilt testing showed no significant EEG modifications. In patients with vasodepressor syncope, a generalized high-amplitude, 4- to 5-Hz (theta range) slowing of EEG activity appeared at the onset of syncope, followed by an increase of brain-wave amplitude with the reduction of frequency at 1.5 to 3 Hz (delta range). The return to the supine position was associated with brain-wave amplitude reduction and frequency increase to 4 to 5 Hz, followed by restoration of a normal EEG pattern and arousal (mean total duration of syncope, 23.2 seconds.). In patients with cardioinhibitory syncope, a generalized high-amplitude EEG slowing in the theta range was noted at the onset of syncope, followed by a brain-wave amplitude increase and slowing in the delta range. A sudden reduction of brain-wave amplitude then ensued, leading to the disappearance of electrocerebral activity ("flat" EEG). The return to the supine position did not allow either the immediate resolution of EEG abnormalities or consciousness recovery, both of which occurred after a further time interval (mean total duration of syncope, 41.4 seconds.).

CONCLUSIONS

EEG monitoring during head-up tilt testing allowed recording and systematic description of electrocerebral abnormalities developing in the course of tilt-induced vasovagal syncope.