Large Bielschowsky head-tilt phenomenon and inconspicuous vertical deviation in the diagnostic positions in congenital superior oblique palsy

How Lingering Fusional Adaptation Influences the Bielschowsky Head Tilt Test in Superior Oblique Paresis

Background The lack of a positive Bielschowsky head tilt test (BHTT) is commonly seen as an indicator that superior oblique paresis (SOP) is not present. This study investigated the influence of fusion on the BHTT in unilateral SOP.

Patients/Methods and Material We analyzed vertical fusional vergence using our eye-tracking haploscope and the value of BHTT difference (BHTTD) in 11 patients who were diagnosed with congenital unilateral SOP and able to fuse.

Results Patients used one of three different mechanisms of vertical vergence to achieve fusion. The three fusional mechanisms were associated with a significantly different BHTTD (p < 0.05). Seven of the eleven patients used vertical recti-mediated fusion and had a mean BHTTD ± SD of 21.7 ± 6.3 prism diopters (PD). Three of these patients whom we measured after a patch test for at least 30 min showed a decreased BHTTD (12.7 ± 3.8 PD). Three of the eleven patients used a mixed (oblique/rectus) fusional mechanism and had a mean BHTTD ± SD of 9.3 ± 8.6 PD. Of these patients, the one whom we measured after patching showed an increase of 11 PD in BHTTD. The remaining patient used oblique muscle-mediated fusion and had a BHTTD of only 3 PD that increased to 21 PD after patching. One explanation for this BHTT behavior in the latter patient involves lingering vergence adaptation of the “paretic” superior oblique muscle (SOM) and contralateral inferior oblique muscle, which makes these muscles more effective when activated, as is the case on ipsilateral head tilt (part of the ocular counter-roll mechanism), lessening the expected increase in hyperdeviation. Similarly, in our patients with mixed fusion, the vergence-adapted “paretic” SOM and contralateral superior rectus muscle are activated on ipsilateral and contralateral tilt, respectively, lessening the hyperdeviation in both directions. In the other seven patients, however, the vergence-adapted ipsilateral inferior rectus muscle and contralateral superior rectus muscle are activated on contralateral tilt, accentuating the BHTTD.

Conclusion Depending upon the specific muscles used for vertical fusion, the BHTTD is decreased or increased. The presence of a large BHTTD points to lingering or persisting fusional tonus involving the vertical rectus muscles. The lack of a positive BHTT does not rule out the diagnosis of SOP, but rather may be caused by lingering or persevering fusional tonus involving the oblique muscles. Performing the BHTT after a patch test for a minimum of 30 minutes may be necessary to reveal the BHTTD, supporting the diagnosis of SOP.

The distinctive vertical heterophoria of dyslexics

In this study, we looked for the presence of vertical heterophoria (VH) in 42 dyslexic children (22 males and 20 females) aged 118.5±12.9 months who were compared with a control group of 22 nondyslexic children (eleven males and eleven females) aged 112±9.8 months. Dyslexics presented a low-level (always <1 prism diopter) VH combined with torsion. This oculomotor feature clearly separates the dyslexic group from the normal readers group. It is independent of the type of dyslexia. The essential feature of this VH is a lability that appears during specific stimulation of sensory receptors involved in postural regulation. This lability is demonstrated using a vertical Maddox test conducted under very specific conditions in which postural sensors are successively stimulated in a predetermined order. A quantitative variation in this VH may be seen during the Bielchowsky Head Tilt Test, which reveals hypertonia of the lower or upper oblique muscles. Vertical orthophoria can be achieved by placing low-power prisms asymmetrically within the direction of action of the superior or inferior oblique muscles. The selection of power and axis is not only guided by elements of the eye examination but also from observation of postural muscle tone. All these elements suggest that the VH could be of postural origin and somehow related to the vertical action of the oblique muscles. VH and torsion are not harmful per se. There is no statistical relationship between their level and the various parameters used to assess the reading skills of dyslexic children. VH and torsion could be a clinical marker of global proprioceptive dysfunction responsible for high-level multisensory disturbances secondary to poor spatial localization of visual and auditory information. This dysfunction might also explain the motor disorders concomitant to dyslexia.

Phenotype-phenotype and genotype-phenotype correlations in patients with idiopathic superior oblique muscle palsy

Idiopathic superior oblique muscle palsy presents, as quantitative phenotypes, vertical deviation and cyclodeviation in eye alignment on clinical testing, and superior oblique muscle hypoplasia on imaging. We determined ARIX and PHOX2B polymorphisms as genotypes, and analyzed phenotype-phenotype and genotype-phenotype correlations in 37 patients with idiopathic superior oblique muscle palsy. Vertical deviations were measured at upright position of the head and head tilt for 30° to either side, and angles of objective excyclodeviations were determined by image analysis on fundus photographs. Cross-sectional areas of the superior oblique muscle near the eye globe-optic nerve junction were measured by image analysis on coronal sections of magnetic resonance imaging to calculate the paretic-side/normal-side ratios. Among the phenotypes, the increase in vertical deviations elicited by head tilt to the paretic side, the decrease in vertical deviations elicited by head tilt to the normal side and the difference of angles of objective excyclodeviations between the paretic side and normal side were significantly correlated inversely with the paretic-side/normal-side ratios of the cross-sectional areas of the muscle (r=-0.43 with P=0.0084, r=-0.34 with P=0.038, and r=-0.43 with P=0.009, respectively, n=37, Pearson's correlation test). Fifteen patients with ARIX and/or PHOX2B polymorphisms had significantly greater paretic-side/normal-side ratios of the muscle compared with 20 patients without the polymorphisms (P=0.017, n=35, Mann-Whitney U-test). The patients with ARIX and/or PHOX2B polymorphisms had less hypoplastic superior oblique muscles.

Dissociated vertical deviation in patients with intermittent exotropia

PURPOSE

To determine whether the age of strabismus onset and the degree of stereopsis are related to the development of dissociated vertical deviation (DVD) in patients with intermittent exotropia and to describe the characteristics of DVD in patients with intermittent exotropia and DVD.

METHODS

Retrospective record review of patients with (1) intermittent exotropia with DVD; (2) infantile esotropia with DVD; and (3) intermittent exotropia without DVD. Age of strabismus onset, stereopsis, strabismus measurements, and the response of DVD to the Bielschowsky head-tilt test were compared among the three groups.

RESULTS

Fifty-two children with intermittent exotropia and DVD were identified. In patients with intermittent exotropia with DVD and intermittent exotropia without DVD group, the mean age of strabismus onset was 12.7 months and 28.9 months, respectively (p = 0.03), and mean stereopsis was 147 arcsec and 65 arcsec (p = 0.02). In patients with intermittent exotropia with DVD and infantile esotropia with DVD, the mean amount of DVD was 9.7(Delta) and 17.2(Delta), respectively (p < 0.01). Bielschowsky head-tilt test showed an increase of DVD on ipsilateral head tilt in 91% and 63.3%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Intermittent exotropia with DVD is characterized by earlier onset of strabismus and worse stereopsis, suggesting that these factors may be related to the development of DVD in patients with intermittent exotropia. Unlike DVD in infantile esotropia, DVD in intermittent exotropia was smaller in amount and demonstrated a more uniform response to the Bielschowsky head-tilt test.