A simpler, less expensive technique for delayed primary closure of fasciotomies

Effectiveness and safety of an innovative silicone extender in suture reinforcement or dermatotraction: a retrospective study

OBJECTIVE

Multiple techniques are available for closing skin defects, such as skin grafts, flaps and tissue expansion. The tissue extender MID SEW (MID, France) was developed to achieve dermatotraction or suture reinforcement. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness and safety of this innovative silicone extender for large surgical wounds.

METHOD

A single-centre retrospective and observational study on an unselected consecutive cohort of patients treated with a tissue extender was conducted. Indications, initial and final wound surfaces, and adverse events (AEs) were retrieved from electronic medical records. The main outcome measure was the time to complete wound closure.

RESULTS

We identified 50 patients from July 2017 to December 2018. Patients underwent cutaneous tumour-wide excision (n=44), or pilonidal disease surgical treatment (n=6). The average initial wound area was 53.3±42.4cm2. Healing was complete, without secondary dehiscence, within the first seven days after device withdrawal for 41 patients (82%). At least one AE was experienced by eight patients (16%) during the study period: five inflammation; five wound dehiscence; two skin necrosis; and one pain.

CONCLUSION

This case series suggests that the tissue extender may be effective and safe in its dermatotraction and suture reinforcement indications in the treatment of large wounds after wide excision of skin cancer or treatment of pilonidal disease.

DECLARATION OF INTEREST

This work was supported in part by the Hospices Civils de Lyon, France and in part by the University Claude Bernard Lyon 1, France. OB co-owns the patent on the MID SEW system. The authors have no other conflicts of interest to declare.

Principles of Fasciotomy Closure After Compartment Syndrome Release

Acute compartment syndrome is a surgical emergency in the extremities resulting from increased compartmental pressure, requiring immediate fasciotomy to resolve muscular compromise. As the mainstay treatment, fasciotomies involve substantial skin incisions and are thus prone to complications such as skin necrosis, wound infection, and permanent disability. Multidisciplinary care instituted at the time of fasciotomy can facilitate timely closure and minimize the complication profile. Several approaches are available to enhance outcomes of fasciotomy wounds, and a comprehensive knowledge of these options affords the treating surgeon greater flexibility and confidence in optimal management. Common techniques include early primary closure, gradual approximation, skin grafting, and negative pressure therapy. There is currently no consensus on the best method of closure. The purpose of this study was to review fasciotomy wound management from the time of initial release to final closure. Highlights include preparation for closing these wounds; the various techniques for fasciotomy closure, including adjunct options; evaluation of timing and staging; and injury-specific features, such as fracture management, limited subcutaneous tissues, and hand fasciotomies. Combining the perspectives of orthopaedic and plastic surgery, this review evaluates the benefits of multiple closure methods and highlights the importance of planning closure at the time of release.

Primary Closure of Wide Fasciotomy and Surgical Wounds Using Rubber Band-Assisted External Tissue Expansion: A Simple, Safe, and Cost-effective Technique

BACKGROUND

Although decompressive fasciotomy is a limb-saving procedure in the setting of acute compartment syndrome, it leaves a large wound defect with tissue edema and skin retraction that can preclude primary closure. Numerous techniques have been described to address the challenge of closing fasciotomy wounds. This study reports our experience with fasciotomy closure using rubber bands (RBs) for external tissue expansion.

METHODS

Patients were informed about RB closure and split-thickness skin graft options. Only patients who opted for RB closure and had wounds that could not be approximated using the pinch test underwent the procedure. Starting from the apex and progressively advancing, the RBs were applied to the skin edges at 3 to 4 mm intervals using staples. The RBs were advanced by twisting back-and-forth to create a criss-cross pattern. One week after application, fasciotomy wounds were closed primarily or underwent further RB application, based on clinical assessment of adequacy of skin advancement, compartment tension, and perfusion. Review of a prospectively maintained database was performed, including demographics, comorbidities, etiology, wound and operative details, hospital stay, and complications.

RESULTS

Seventeen consecutive patients with 25 wounds (22 fasciotomy and 3 other surgical wounds) were treated using the RB technique. Average wound length and width measured 15.7 cm (range, 5-32 cm) and 5.2 cm (range, 1-12 cm), respectively. Locations of wounds included forearm (n = 12, 48.0%), leg (n = 7, 28.0%), hand (n = 4, 16.0%), elbow (n = 1, 4.0%), and hip (n = 1, 4.0%). Eighteen of 25 wounds (72.0%) were closed primarily after 1 RB application. Additional RB application was required for 5 wounds to achieve primary closure. Between stages, patients were discharged home if they did not have other conditions requiring in-hospital stay. No complications were observed, and no revision surgeries were required. Patient satisfaction was 100%, and all indicated that they would choose the RB technique over skin grafting.

CONCLUSIONS

The modified RB technique is a simple, safe, and cost-effective alternative for treating fasciotomy and other surgical defects resulting in high patient satisfaction and good cosmetic outcome, without the need for split-thickness skin graft or flap coverage.

Optimising Wound Closure Following a Fasciotomy: A narrative review

Compartment syndrome is a surgical emergency that could be resolved by a fasciotomy. However, performing substantial skin incisions may lead to life-threatening complications. This narrative review aimed to present the available methods of wound closure and preferential factors for using each technique. Viable and non-infected wounds were most often treated by gradual approximation techniques, such as the simple or modified shoelace technique, the prepositioned intracutaneous suture or several commercially-available mechanical devices. In addition, applying negative pressure therapy was found to be feasible, particularly when combined with approximation techniques. Skin grafting was reserved for severely-dehiscent wounds while other non-invasive approaches were considered for other subsets of patients with inadvisable surgical interventions. Treatment decision should be made in view of the patient’s condition, ease of application, availability of resources, cost of treatment and aesthetic outcomes.

Delayed Primary Closure of Traumatic Tension Wounds Using Plastic Straps and Kirschner Wires

Tension of the wound edges should be overcome with precise surgical planning, which is recognized as one of the major contributors to local complications by compromising circulation of the wound edges. In this article, it was aimed to present the clinical results of a surgical technique, in which the plastic straps and Kirschner wires are used for delayed primary closure of traumatic tension wounds. Depending on the assessment of the wound localization, wound dimension, and mobility of adjacent soft tissue, the technique was performed in 9 patients with a male to female ratio of 8:1. Gunshot injury was the leading cause (n = 5), and in most cases, the wounds were located at the lower extremities (n = 6). The mean time between performing the technique and closing the wound primarily and the mean hospitalization time were 4.8 ± 1.1 and 13.5 ± 3.9 days, respectively. In each case, wound closure and healing were achieved successfully without any serious complications. The presented technique provides advantages of using a low cost as well as a very simple equipment, improved and reliable stability during tightening process due to self-locking feature of the plastic straps, no donor site morbidity, short operating time with low rate of post-operative complications, and short hospitalization time. We recommend using this invaluable technique reliably for the treatment of traumatic tension wounds. However, further studies are needed for better evaluation of cosmetic and functional outcomes of the presented technique.

Fasciotomy closure techniques

We evaluated the risks and success rates of the three major techniques for compartment syndrome fasciotomy closure by reviewing all literature published to date. Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, we systematically evaluated the Medline (PubMed) database until July 2015, utilizing the Boolean search sting "compartment syndrome OR fasciotomy closure." Two authors independently assessed all studies published in the literature to ensure validity of extracted data. The data was compiled into an electronic spreadsheet, and the wound closure rate with each technique was assessed utilizing a proportion random model effect. Success was defined as all wounds that could be closed without skin grafting, amputation, or death. The highest success rate was observed for dynamic dermatotraction and gradual suture approximation, whereas vacuum-assisted closure had the lowest complication rate.

Closure of large wounds using rubber bands in rabbits

OBJECTIVE

to verify the effectiveness of the rubber elastic band in the treatment of large wounds of the body wall of rabbits by means of traction of its edges.

METHODS

we studied 30 New Zealand rabbits, divided into three groups (n=10): Group 1- healing by secondary intention; Group 2- removal and eutopic repositioning of skin as full thickness skin graft; Group 3- Approximation of wound edges with elastic rubber band. In all animals, we removed a segment of the back skin and subcutaneous tissue down to the fascia, in accordance with an acrylic mold of 8 cm long by 12 cm wide. All animals were observed for 21 days.

RESULTS

two animals of groups 1 and 2 had wound abscess. In Group 2, there was partial or total graft loss in 90% of animals. The complete closure of the wounds was observed in four animals of Group 1, six of Group 2 and eight of Group 3. There was no difference between the scar resistance values of groups 2 and 3, which were higher than those in Group 1. The scars of the three groups were characterized by the presence of mature connective tissue mixed with blood vessels and inflammatory infiltration, predominantly polymorphonuclear.

CONCLUSION

the tensile strength of the wound edges with rubber elastic band is as efficient as the skin graft to treat rabbits' large body wounds.

How to Close a Limb Fasciotomy Wound

Early fasciotomy is the gold standard of prevention and treatment of compartment syndrome; however, the resulting wounds may significantly increase morbidity. To address the challenge of timely and safe closure of fasciotomy wounds, numerous methods have been described. A thorough search of medical databases PubMed/MEDLINE, ScienceDirect, SCOPUS, EMBASE, and Google Scholar was conducted for articles published between 1976 and 2013 using the search terms “limb fasciotomy wound closure,” “open wound management,” “skin stretching,” and “fasciotomy complications.” A total of 49 articles on technique descriptions, case reports of 2 or more patients, and of complications and comparative studies regarding limb fasciotomy wound closure were included. Details of the duration of treatment, advantages and disadvantages, direct cost, and complications were data extracted for each technique from the 49 studies included in this overview. Thorough knowledge of available techniques and their comparative advantages is essential for their clinical implementation, careful selection of patients, management of possible complications, decreased morbidity, and hospital recovery time and is also crucial for optimization of functional and aesthetic outcomes.

Wound closure of leg fasciotomy: comparison of vacuum-assisted closure versus shoelace technique. A randomised study

BACKGROUND

Fasciotomies, though essential for the prevention and management of compartment syndromes, may increase morbidity and prolong hospitalisation. Two widely applied methods of delayed primary closure are compared in leg fasciotomy wounds.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Two groups, each of 25 patients with leg fasciotomies due to fractures and soft tissue injuries, who were randomly assigned to be treated either by vacuum assisted closure (VAC®, n=42 wounds, group V) or by the shoelace technique (n=40 wounds, group S), were evaluated in this study. Wound length, time to definite closure, complications, need for additional interventions and daily treatment costs were data collected and statistically assessed.

RESULTS

Wound closure time was significantly higher in group V compared to group S (p=0.001; 95% CI of the difference, 1.8-6.3 days). Five group V patients required split thickness skin grafts. In six group S patients, the vessel loops had to be replaced. The mean daily cost of negative pressure therapy alone was 135 euro (range 117-144 euro), whilst the mean daily cost of treatment for the shoelace technique was 14 euro ranging from 8 to 18 euro (p=<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Both VAC® and the shoelace technique are safe, reliable and effective methods for closure of leg fasciotomy wounds. VAC® requires longer time to definite wound closure and is far more expensive than the shoelace technique, especially when additional skin grafting is required.

Acute compartment syndrome: obtaining diagnosis, providing treatment, and minimizing medicolegal risk

Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) is a surgical emergency. Diagnosis depends on a high clinical suspicion and an understanding of risk factors, pathophysiology and subtle physical exam findings. The typical high risk scenario for ACS is a male patient younger than 35 years of age, involved in a high energy sport or roadway collision, resulting in a tibial shaft fracture. He will go on to develop acute compartment syndrome of the leg in less than 10 hours and require emergent fasciotomy. Diagnosis of ACS in this patient is primarily a clinical one but can be confirmed with invasive intracompartmental pressure monitoring or non-invasive near infrared spectroscopy (NIRS). Delaying the diagnosis will likely result in some degree of permanent disability and places the surgeon at high risk for litigation. This article reviews the salient features of acute compartment syndrome that should be understood by all orthopaedic residents and surgeons.

Shoelace wound closure for the management of fracture-related fasciotomy wounds

Background. Compartment syndrome is a serious complication that might occur following fractures. The treatment of choice is emergent fasciotomy of all the involved muscle compartments to lower the compartment pressure. The classic management of fasciotomy wounds was split thickness skin graft. Patients and Methods. Seventeen patients with fracture-related compartment syndrome were managed by fasciotomy in the Orthopaedic Casualty Unit of our university hospital. The fractures included four femoral fractures and 13 fractures of the tibia and fibula. Results. All fasciotomy wounds healed eventually. Wound closure occurred from the corners inward. The skin closure was obtained at an overall average of 4.2 tightening sessions (range 3-7). Fracture healing occurred at an average of 15.4 weeks (range 12 to 22 weeks). No major complications were encountered in this series. Conclusion. Closure of fasciotomy wounds by dermatotraction could be performed in a staged fashion, using inexpensive equipment readily available in any standard operating room, until skin was approximated enough to heal either through delayed primary closure or secondary healing.

The use of a silicon sheet for gradual wound closure after fasciotomy

We present a silicon sheet for temporary wound covering and gradual wound closure after open fasciotomy. Fasciotomy was performed in a total of 70 limbs with compartment syndrome (CS). The main etiology of CS was predominantly vascular. All patients were treated with a silicon sheet to cover the soft tissue defect and gradually reapproximate the skin margins. In 53% of the patients, a delayed final wound closure was achieved after a mean of 11.9 days. This method allows final closure of fasciotomy wounds without scar contractures, marginal necrosis, infection, or significant pain.

Vessel loop closure technique in open fractures and other complex wounds in the foot and ankle

A gaping wound of the foot and ankle can be difficult to close. In cases in which wound margin mobility is suitable, the use of a vessel loop, or loops, to provide sufficient tension for wound margin reapproximation can be a useful adjunct to the surgical management of wounds that would otherwise be very difficult to close without the use of a skin graft or flap coverage. In this report, we describe the use of a vessel loop, or loops, for reapproximation of the margins of gaping wounds of the foot or ankle.

Comparison of fasciotomy wound closures using traditional dressing changes and the vacuum-assisted closure device

Fasciotomy wounds can be a major contributor to length of stay for patients as well as a difficult reconstructive challenge. Once the compartment pressure has been relieved and stabilized, the wound should be closed as quickly and early as possible to avoid later complications. Skin grafting can lead to morbidity and scarring at both the donor and fasciotomy site. Primary closure results in a more functional and esthetic outcome with less morbidity for the patient, but can often be difficult to achieve secondary to edema, skin retraction, and skin edge necrosis. Our objective was to examine fasciotomy wound outcomes, including time to definitive closure, comparing traditional wet-to-dry dressings, and the vacuum-assisted closure (VAC) device. This retrospective chart review included a consecutive series of patients over a 10-year period. This series included 458 patients who underwent 804 fasciotomies. Of these fasciotomy wounds, 438 received exclusively VAC. dressings, 270 received only normal saline wet-to-dry dressings, and 96 were treated with a combination of both. Of the sample, 408 patients were treated with exclusively VAC therapy or wet-to-dry dressings and 50 patients were treated with a combination of both. In comparing all wounds, there was a statistically significant higher rate of primary closure using the VAC versus traditional wet-to-dry dressings (P < 0.05 for lower extremities and P < 0.03 for upper extremities). The time to primary closure of wounds was shorter in the VAC. group in comparison with the non-VAC group. This study has shown that the use of the VAC for fasciotomy wound closure results in a higher rate of primary closure versus traditional wet-to-dry dressings. In addition, the time to primary closure of wounds or time to skin grafting is shorter when the VAC was employed. The VAC used in the described settings decreases hospitalization time, allows for earlier rehabilitation, and ultimately leads to increased patient satisfaction.

The use of an innovative device for wound closure after upper extremity fasciotomy

INTRODUCTION

The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the Silver Bullet Wound Closure Device (SBWCD, Boehringer Laboratories, Norristown, PA), a new device for delayed primary closure of fasciotomy wounds.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review was performed over a period of 36 months of all patients with an upper extremity fasciotomy that could not be closed primarily. Cases that underwent fasciotomy closure with the SBWCD were separated from the patients that had a split thickness skin graft (STSG).

RESULTS

Seven patients had their wound closed with the SBWCD within 10 days (mean of 7.4 days). The seven patients that underwent STSG had their wound closed in an average of 8.4 days. The average number of days between the day of the fasciotomy incision and the date of the placement of the SBWCD was 1.9 days. STSGs were placed on the fasciotomy wounds on an average of 10.3 days after the date of the fasciotomy incision. We found that the SBWCD allowed for starting to approximate the edges of the fasciotomy wound at an earlier time when compare to STSG (2.1 vs 10.3 days).

CONCLUSIONS

We feel that the SBWCD as a one-stage procedure provides a consistent and efficacious way to manage upper extremity fasciotomy wounds while minimizing the morbidity associated with STSG. Elimination of a second-stage procedure reduces hospital costs. Our findings may help to inform surgeons about an available alternative when an upper extremity fasciotomy wound is not amenable to primary closure.

Dynamic Wound Closure for Decompressive Leg Fasciotomy Wounds

Decompressive fasciotomy for preservation of lower extremity function and salvage is an essential technique in trauma. The wounds that result from the standard two incision four-compartment leg fasciotomy are often accompanied by a wide soft tissue opening that in the face of true compartment syndrome are often impossible to close in a delayed primary fashion. We describe a technique using a device that allows for dissipation of the workload across the wound margin allowing for successful delayed primary closure. Consecutive patients who presented to the 28th Combat Support Hospital in Baghdad, Iraq with a diagnosis of compartment syndrome of the leg, impending compartment syndrome of the leg, or compartment syndrome of the leg recently treated with fasciotomies were followed. All patients underwent placement of the Canica dynamic wound closure device (Canica, Almonte, ON, Canada). Eleven consecutive patients treated at a combat support hospital in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom underwent four-compartment fasciotomies for penetrating injuries. There were five patients that underwent a vascular repair [three superficial femoral artery (SFA) injuries and two below knee popliteal artery injuries] and six patients that had orthopedic injuries (three comminuted tibial fractures, two fibula fractures, and one closed pilon fracture). Patients returned to the operating room within 24 hours for washout and wound inspection. Mean initial wound size was 8.1 cm; mean postplacement size was 2.7 cm; average time to closure was 2.6 days. All patients were able to undergo primary wound closure of the medial incision and placement of the Canica device over the lateral incision. Ten of the 11 patients (91%) could be closed in delayed primary fashion after application of the device. In our series of patients with penetrating wartime injuries and compartment syndrome of the leg we have found the use of this dynamic wound closure device to be extremely successful and expedient.

Delayed primary closure of fasciotomy wounds with Wisebands, a skin- and soft tissue-stretch device

BACKGROUND

Fasciotomy incisions for limb compartment syndrome usually cannot be closed primarily. The conventional method of wound closure with split-thickness skin grafting is effective, but it results in an insensate and disfiguring wound and is associated with donor site morbidity. We present our experience in delayed primary closure of fasciotomy wounds with Wisebands (WB), a skin- and soft tissue-stretching device.

PATIENTS

Between 2000 and 2003, we treated 16 patients with extremity fasciotomy wounds for which primary closure was not feasible.

RESULTS

The Wisebands devices achieved controlled stretching of the wound edges, including skin and underlying soft tissue, until primary closure was feasible. Fourteen patients (88%) had successful wound closure, two patients (12%) had minor wound complications that did not necessitate the removal of the device, and two patients had local wound complications (infection, intractable pain) and their devices were removed prematurely. Delayed primary closure was achieved at the initial surgery using intraoperative skin stretching in 3 of the 14 cases (21%). After a 2-year follow-up (1.3-4 years), the treated area showed stable scarring with good aesthetic outcome and no functional deficit.

CONCLUSIONS

The Wisebands device facilitates closure of fasciotomy wounds with low complication rates and good functional and aesthetic outcome. Its application is simple and safe and requires a short learning curve. Nevertheless, appropriate patient selection, intraoperative judgment and close postoperative supervision are essential for optimal results.

Shoelace Technique for Gradual Closure of Fasciotomy Wounds

BACKGROUND

After emergency fasciotomy in acute compartment syndrome, skin graft techniques are usually necessary to cover the wound.

METHODS

The shoelace technique for gradual skin closure was retrospectively analyzed after having been applied in 20 patients with acute compartment syndrome.

RESULTS

With the application of this technique, none of the cases required new surgical interventions to close the wound. Closure was reached in an average time of 8.8 days, with an average hospital stay of 10 days and a low rate of complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Gradual skin closure using the shoelace technique avoids the use of free skin grafts to close the dermotomy-fasciotomy wounds, reducing the need for anesthesia, nursing care, and hospital stays of patients, resulting in lower healthcare costs.