Conservation surgery for recurrent carcinoma of the glottic larynx

Laryngectomy-free survival after salvage partial laryngectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Radiotherapy (RT) is widely used for early glottic cancer. Patients failing this treatment are referred to surgical management of their disease. Salvage partial laryngectomy (SPL) has the advantage of preserving laryngeal function with total laryngectomy (TL) remaining as a last resort. The purpose of this study was to determine the efficacy of SPL in preventing total laryngectomy, following failed RT, for early glottic cancer.

METHODS

A meta-analysis of all published English literature was performed. All publications that included patients undergoing SPL were reviewed according to the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) reporting guidelines. The search strategy identified 154 relevant articles. A total of 15 retrospective studies that included 323 suitable patients were subsequently analyzed in this meta-analysis. The main outcome measure was the rate of laryngectomy-free survival (LFS) following SPL. The indications for salvage TL (i.e., disease recurrence and poorly functional larynxes) as well as subgroup analyses for open and trans-oral SPLs were also calculated.

RESULTS

The overall rate of LFS following SPL was 81.2% (fixed effects model range: 75.7-86.8%). Salvage TL following SPL were performed in 96.8% due to disease recurrence and in 3.2% to poorly functional larynxes. A subgroup analysis showed a 90.4% LFS after open SPL and 78.6% following trans-oral SPL.

CONCLUSION

A high rate of successful salvage partial laryngectomies, regardless of surgical technique, is to be anticipated in well-selected patients after RT failure.

Early glottic cancer recurrence: A critical review on its current management

INTRODUCTION

Recurrent early glottic cancer (rEGC) poses several issues in terms of timely diagnosis, correct re-staging, and treatment. We want to critically review the latest evidence about rEGC considering its epidemiology, biology, diagnostic challenges, and treatment strategies.

METHODS

A systematic search of the literature using PubMed from 1990 to October 31, 2020 was performed.

RESULTS

There are many different treatment options available (open surgery, transoral mini-invasive surgery, radiotherapy), and many factors related to the patient's status and previous treatments must be considered when planning the best management strategy for rEGC. While its overall prognosis remains satisfactory, it is of the utmost importance to appreciate all the clinical implications derived from the choice of the initial therapeutic modality, and from a correct primary and recurrent staging.

CONCLUSION

The balance between oncological and voice and swallowing functions represents the fundamental principle underlying rEGC management. Future studies should focus on molecular profiling of rEGC, and on the results of the emerging radiation delivery techniques and mini-invasive procedures.

The high stakes of head and neck surgery following radiation and chemotherapy - An assessment of complications and survival

OBJECTIVES

To investigate variables that predict medical and surgical complications in patients undergoing salvage surgery after primary organ-preserving therapy for head and neck cancer and to investigate the effect of complications on 5-year overall survival.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective study was conducted on patients undergoing salvage surgery after primary organ-preserving therapy for head and neck cancer at a tertiary institution from 2006 to 2011. Multivariable regression analysis was used to assess association between independent variables and medical and surgical complications. A Kaplan-Meier survival curve was plotted to assess effect of surgical and medical complications on 5-year overall survival.

RESULTS

One hundred thirty-six patients undergoing salvage surgery after primary organ-preservation surgery met inclusion criteria. Surgical complications occurred in 68/136 (50.0%) of patients. After adjusting for confounders, young age and history of hypothyroidism were significant predictors of surgical complications (p < 0.05). Medical complications occurred in 37/136 (27.2%) of patients. After adjusting for confounders, older age and history of hepatic disease were significant predictors of having a medical complication (p < 0.05). Patients with no complications had better overall survival than patients with medical complications (p = 0.009). There was no difference in overall survival between patients without complications and patients with surgical complications only (p = 0.259).

CONCLUSION

Risk factors for medical and surgical complications include history of hypothyroidism, liver disease, and age. Survival outcomes are not affected by surgical complications but are significantly affected by medical complications highlighting the importance of personalized patient care and medical co-management.

Oncologic and functional outcomes of salvage supracricoid partial laryngectomy

BACKGROUND

Supracricoid partial laryngectomy (SCL) can have a positive impact on patients' quality of life by circumventing dysphagia and voice problems resulting from creation of a permanent stoma after conventional total laryngectomy (TL) surgery.

AIMS/OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to investigate the oncologic and functional outcomes of salvage SCL for recurrent laryngeal carcinoma.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Forty-five patients that underwent salvage surgery for recurrent laryngeal carcinoma between January 2004 and May 2015 after initial treatment failure were included in this retrospective study.

RESULTS

Overall survival and disease free survival were non-significantly higher in the salvage SCL group (n = 14) than in the salvage TL group (n = 31) (87.5 versus 56.5%, 53.4 versus 41.9%). Multivariate analyses showed only positive resection margin to be significantly associated with survival and recurrence (HR 9.974, p = .007, and HR 9.196, p = .002, respectively). In the salvage SCL group, 92.8% achieved successful decannulation and all patients returned to an oral diet. All patients in the salvage TL group sustained a permanent stoma and conversation was possible only through esophageal voice or a voice prosthesis. 74.2% of patients in the group were able to tolerate an oral diet.

CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE

Salvage SCL showed comparable oncologic outcomes and favorable functional outcomes relative to the classic salvage TL. This study could provide a sufficient basis of SCL as salvage treatment for recurrent laryngeal carcinoma in selected patients.

Staged laryngeal reconstruction with a prefabricated flap for radiation recurrent glottic carcinoma

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Although salvage total laryngectomy remains the definitive approach to recurrent/persistent glottic cancer following failed radiation therapy for favorable early-stage disease, it comes at the price of a permanent laryngostome and an impact on quality of life. We describe a three-stage method of laryngeal reconstruction for salvage partial laryngectomy to address the unique challenges of operating on radiation recurrent/persistent cancer.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a single-surgeon retrospective case series of patients who underwent a three-stage laryngeal reconstruction for salvage partial laryngectomy.

METHODS

We performed a comprehensive review of the clinical, pathologic, and radiologic files of all patients who underwent a three-stage laryngeal reconstruction for salvage partial laryngectomy.

RESULTS

Seven male patients underwent a three-stage laryngeal reconstruction following open partial salvage laryngectomy. The average follow-up time since salvage surgery was 55 months. All patients were without evidence of recurrence and demonstrated satisfactory functional outcomes.

CONCLUSION

Staged reconstruction provides a more controlled assessment of wound healing and valuable pathologic information regarding the specific disease virulence and adequacy of the margins.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4. Laryngoscope, 126:1061-1070, 2016.

Clinical Analysis of 74 Cases of Laryngeal Cancer who Underwent Frontolateral Partial Vertical Laryngectomy-Usefulness of Salvage Surgery after Failure of a Full Course of Radiotherapy-

This study was designed to analyze the surgical (postoperative course, mortality, morbidity), oncological (local control, survival rate) and functional (maximum phonation time: MPT) results of frontolateral partial vertical laryngectomy (FLPVL), in order to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of salvage FLPVL after a full course of radiotherapy (FRT). A retrospective analysis of the results in the 74 patients (of whom 61 had previously received FRT) was undertaken. The median follow up was 68 months (range 12-290 months). No significant influence of the prior FRT was noted on the deglutition, respiration, or duration of hospitalization. The frequency of complications after discharge, but not of that during hospitalization was significantly higher in the prior FRT group. Speech (MPT) was significantly shorter (poor effect) in the prior FRT group with standard extirpation. Recurrence developed in 8 patients: in the larynx only in 7 cases, and in both the larynx and neck in the remaining one case. One patient with control of the primary showed relapse in the neck and lung. Subsequent surgery was successful in salvaging 5 of the 8 cases with local failure. One died refusing TL, and two because of uncontrolled neck recurrence. Hence, the overall laryngeal preservation rate following salvage FLPVL was 85% (52/61). Salvage FLPVL results in good tumor control and incompletely satisfactory functional results and may be recognized as a safe procedure.

Endoscopic CO2 laser surgery for early glottic cancer in patients who are candidates for radiotherapy: results of a prospective nonrandomized study

BACKGROUND

Treatment of early glottic malignancies is controversial, particularly if postoperative endoscopy shows minimal/no residual disease.

METHODS

In a prospective nonrandomized study, we performed endoscopic laser surgery with curative intent in 59 patients with early glottic carcinoma presenting for radiotherapy after diagnosis elsewhere by random biopsy or cordal stripping. We analyzed outcomes and residual cancer in the specimen.

RESULTS

Clinical staging elsewhere did not correspond to (usually underestimated) the pathologic stage in 60.7%. In 22%, no tumor was identified on pathologic examination. After 35.3 months (mean), 93.2% were alive with no evidence of disease. Local control was achieved in 98.3% of the patients, and 13.5% of the patients required radiotherapy. The larynx was conserved in 98.3%.

CONCLUSIONS

Biopsy/stripping are best abandoned for persistent glottic lesions. A single laser endoscopic procedure provides reliable staging and definitive treatment in most cases using fewer resources. Biopsied patients presenting for treatment should be offered laser surgery as an alternative to radiotherapy.

Options for salvage after failed initial treatment of anterior vocal commissure squamous carcinoma

Persistence or recurrent cancer in the anterior commissure (AC) after primary radiotherapy may remain localized to its pretreatment anatomical site. If so, endoscopic CO(2) laser excision, in experienced hands, may achieve complete tumor excision and result in cure for many patients. Occasionally, second and third recurrences may be similarly salvaged by further endoscopic surgery. The use of the vertical hemilaryngectomy is an alternative treatment for similar localized lesions, with a higher first time surgical tumor eradication rate, but with a more protracted hospitalization and a less satisfactory voice and swallowing outcome. In both types of such surgical salvage, CT scanning must demonstrate no evidence of cartilage invasion or destruction. When there is evidence of minimal thyroid cartilage invasion, then the supracricoid partial laryngectomy is an alternative conservation option, and is likely to result in a cure, with the retention of a voicing larynx without a stoma. When the tumor has increased in size from the original pretreatment dimension and/or site, then imaging must be used to identify possible cartilage invasion, in which case the likelihood of tumor eradication by endoscopic or external vertical partial laryngectomy is highly unlikely. The indications for the routine use of total laryngectomy for the treatment of recurrent or persistent cancer involving the AC must be reviewed; there is current evidence that cure can be achieved by a less radical procedure. However, total laryngectomy may remain the only treatment option for advanced or aggressive first time recurrence, or in patients who develop subsequent recurrence following previous less aggressive surgery (endoscopic or external).

Salvage Conservation Laryngeal Surgery after Irradiation Failure for Early Laryngeal Cancer

OBJECTIVES

One third of recurrences after radiotherapy for early laryngeal cancer remain localized. Salvage conservation laryngeal surgery, with total laryngectomy held as reserve, is a surgical management option that is arguably underused. The aim of this review is to report the oncologic and functional results of salvage conservation laryngeal surgery, using the external or the endolaryngeal laser approach.

STUDY DESIGN

Review article.

METHODS

A computerized literature search of the Medline database from 1985 to 2005 was performed using the following search strategy: laryngeal neoplasm/AND salvage therapy/. Studies with a sample size less than 10 and an average follow-up of less than 24 months were excluded from analysis. The oncologic outcome, functional outcome, length of hospitalization, and the frequency of complications were recorded.

RESULTS

The average reported local control rate for recurrent early glottic cancer after radiotherapy salvaged by using the external or the endolaryngeal laser approach is 77% and 65%, respectively. The average reported overall local control rate, including cases that subsequently required total laryngectomy, is 90% and 83%, respectively. The endolaryngeal approach when compared with the extralaryngeal approach does have the advantage of reduced complications, lesser requirement for tracheostomy and nasogastric feeding, and shortened hospitalization time.

CONCLUSIONS

Conservation laryngeal surgery is a safe and effective treatment for recurrent localized disease after radiotherapy for early stage glottic cancer. Local control may be achieved without the sacrifice of laryngeal function, and total laryngectomy may be held in reserve as the ultimate option for salvage without compromising ultimate survival significantly.

Conservation laryngeal surgery versus total laryngectomy for radiation failure in laryngeal cancer

BACKGROUND

Total laryngectomy is the standard of care for surgical salvage of radiation failure in laryngeal cancer. However, the role of conservation laryngeal surgery in this setting remains unclear. The objective was to compare the efficacy of conservation versus total laryngectomy for salvage of radiation failure in patients who initially presented with T1 or T2 squamous cancer of the larynx.

METHODS

A 21-year retrospective analysis of patients who received surgery at a single comprehensive cancer center after definitive radiation therapy is reported. At recurrence, the patients were reevaluated and then underwent a total laryngectomy or, if possible, a conservation laryngeal procedure. The charts of 105 patients who failed radiation treatment for primary laryngeal cancer and who subsequently underwent surgical salvage were reviewed for this study. Eighty-nine were male (84.8%). The mean age was 60.3 years. The median follow-up time after surgery was 69.4 months. Most patients with recurrence after radiotherapy required total laryngectomy (69.5%; 73/105). Conservation laryngeal surgery was performed for 32 patients (31.5%). Concomitant neck dissections were performed on 45 patients (45.5%).

RESULTS

In 14 patients, local or regional recurrence developed after salvage surgery: 9 patients after total laryngectomy (12.3%; 9/73), and 5 patients (15.6%; 5/32) after conservation laryngeal surgery. This difference was not statistically significant, nor was there a difference in disease-free interval for the two procedures (p = .634, by log-rank test). Distant metastasis developed in 13 patients. Most developed in the setting of local and/or regional recurrence, but distant metastasis occurred as the only site of failure in 6 of the patients who had undergone total laryngectomy but in 1 of the conservation surgery patients treated for a supraglottic laryngeal cancer. The overall mortality for patients who underwent total laryngectomy was also higher: 73.74% (54/73) versus 59.4% (19/32) for patients who underwent a conservation approach (p = .011 by log-rank test).

CONCLUSIONS

Although conservation laryngeal surgery was possible in a few patients with local failure after radiotherapy, conservation laryngeal surgery is an oncologically sound alternative to total laryngectomy for these patients.

Perichondrial flap to prevent chondritis and cartilage necrosis in salvage vertical partial laryngectomy for recurrent glottic carcinoma after irradiation: a new procedure

CONCLUSION

We conclude that our new closure method using the posterior- and inferior-based perichondrial flap may diminish the chance of development of chondritis in salvage vertical partial laryngectomized patients with recurrent glottic cancer.

OBJECTIVE

Post-radiation laryngeal chondritis with resultant cartilage necrosis is one of the most dreaded complications of radiotherapy treatment of glottic carcinoma. In the case of salvage vertical partial laryngectomy, the risk of its development may be increased. We introduce a new posterior- and inferior-based perichondrial flap procedure to prevent postoperative chondritis after salvage vertical partial laryngectomy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The perichondrium is incised along the midline and upper border of the thyroid cartilage, but not along the inferior border, unlike the conventional method. Then, the posterior- and inferior-based perichondrial flap, along with the cricothyroid muscle fascia, is elevated from the midline. For closure of the pharyngeal lumen, the outer perichondrium of the lesion side is sutured to the inner perichondrium of the contralateral side to protect the larynx from pharyngeal secretion. The utility of this procedure is reviewed retrospectively in 10 patients with locally persistent or recurrent squamous cell carcinoma of the vocal cord after failed laryngeal radiation therapy between 1994 and 2001.

RESULTS

None of our patients developed chondritis postoperatively. The interval between the operation and removal of the tracheostomy tube ranged from 8 to 23 days (mean 12 days). Patients were able to swallow without aspiration within 7-22 days of the operation (mean 10 days). Discharge from hospital was possible after a mean recovery period of 11 postoperative days.

Multivariate analysis of risk factors for wound infection in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma surgery with opening of mucosa. Study of 260 surgical procedures

The goal of this prospective study was to determine risk factors for wound infections (WI) for patients with head and neck cancer who had undergone surgical procedures with opening of upper aerodigestive tract mucosa in multimodal therapeutic approaches. Two hundred and sixty consecutive surgical procedures were studied at Oscar Lambret Cancer Center over a 36-month period. Twenty-five variables were recorded for each patient. Statistical evaluation used chi2 test analysis (categorical data) and Mann-Whitney test (continuous variables). Multivariate analysis was performed with logistic regression model. The overall rate of WI was 45% (117/260). Univariate analysis indicated that five variables were significantly related to the likelihood of WI: male sex (p = 0.03), previous chemotherapy (p = 0.009), duration of previous hospital stay (p = 0.013), hypopharyngeal location (p = 0.003), post-laryngectomy tracheostoma (p < 0.001). Multivariate analysis identified only one major risk factor for WI: post-laryngectomy tracheostoma (Odd Ratio 1.9 [95% CI 1.3-3]; 33% versus 64%; p = 0.001). Despite antibiotic prophylaxis, WI occurrence is high. This study identified one major risk factor, post-laryngectomy tracheostomy. Long-term curative antibiotherapy must be evaluated in cancer head and neck surgery requiring post-laryngectomy tracheostoma.

Supracricoid Partial Laryngectomies after Failure of Radiation Therapy

BACKGROUND

Conservation of laryngeal function is a key surgical objective in cases of limited recurrence after previously irradiated T1b or T2 glottic carcinoma. Only a few articles have mentioned the use of supracricoid partial laryngectomies (SCPL) to treat recurrent T1/T2 tumors that cannot be managed with vertical partial laryngectomy.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate oncologic and functional results of SCPL in selected cases of T1/T2 glottic carcinoma recurrence after primary irradiation therapy.

METHOD

Between 1986 and 2000, 23 selected patients (T1b, 12 cases; T2, 11 cases) underwent SCPL as salvage treatment: cricohyoidepiglottopexy (CHEP) in 18 cases and cricohyodopexy (CHP) in 5 cases.

RESULTS

The mean cannulation time was 28 (14-90) days. The mean nasogastric feeding tube time for CHP and CHEP was 55 (28-96) days and 21 (9-45) days, respectively. Four (17.4%) patients had major swallowing recovery problems. Three patients died in the postoperative period, one of intercurrent disease and two because of aspiration pneumonia. Six (26.08%) patients relapsed and underwent total laryngectomy. Three were subsequently controlled. The T stage was correlated with the onset of a new recurrence (P = .0258). The surgical margins were not correlated with recurrence (P = .0741). At 3 and 5 years, the global survival rate was 82.9% and 69.04%. The success rate for oncologic control and oncologic control with organ preservation was 74% and 66.6%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

In selected cases of limited recurrence after radiation therapy for T1/T2 vocal cord carcinomas, SCPL can be an alternative to total laryngectomy when partial vertical surgery appears unsuitable.

Can I treat this small larynx lesion with radiation alone? Update on the radiation management of early (T1 and T2) glottic cancer

This article endeavors to explain the advantages and disadvantages of radiotherapy (RT) versus transoral laser excision (TLE)and to suggest when each modality may be employed for optimal treatment of patients with this heterogeneous group of tumors. It compares RT and TLE using the criteria of cure and local control rates, posttreatment voice quality, side effects and morbidity, cost,convenience, and salvage potential.

Carbon dioxide laser salvage surgery after radiotherapy failure in T1 and T2 glottic carcinoma

OBJECTIVES

Recurrent glottic carcinoma after radiotherapy (RT) may be managed by open neck or endoscopic surgery. The impact of endoscopic treatment with CO(2) laser for recurrent glottic carcinoma after RT is reported.

METHODS

We present the oncologic and vocal outcomes of a retrospective study based on a series of 16 patients with rT1 and rT2 glottic carcinoma who were endoscopically managed between February 1995 and December 1999 after RT failure. All patients were males with a mean age of 68.7 years (range, 50 to 87 years). Before RT, the lesions had been staged as T1 N0 in 11 patients and T2 N0 in 5, and after RT as rT1 N0 in 12 and rT2 N0 in 4. According to the European Laryngological Society classification, a total of 9 transmuscular, 3 total, and 4 extended cordectomies were performed. Mean follow-up was 45 months (range, 9 to 79 months).

RESULTS

Endoscopic salvage surgery was successful in 14 patients. One of them developed a second recurrence and was definitively cured with an additional endoscopic procedure. Two of the 16 patients had recurrent disease after salvage laser surgery and died due to progression of disease. Ultimate local control with laser alone at 3 years was 87.1%, according to the Kaplan-Meier method. Laryngeal preservation was obtained in all survivors after endoscopic rescue surgery. Voice analysis showed a clear correlation between the amount of vocal cord tissue resected and decrease of the vocal outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

The present series indicates that selected recurrences after primary RT for T1 and T2 glottic carcinoma are eligible for endoscopic salvage surgery with oncologic results comparable to those with open neck procedures but with a lower complication rate and a favorable functional outcome.

Partial laryngectomy after irradiation failure

INTRODUCTION

Radiation therapy is often the first method of treating patients with early cancer of the glottis. There is a substantial failure rate among these patients. Total laryngectomy has usually been the means of treating patients with failure after radiation. In recent decades, partial laryngectomy has been used for salvage in such patients. This article will discuss the use of partial laryngectomy for radiation failure both from the oncologic result as well as the morbidity.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between 1984 and 1995, 27 patients with early-stage laryngeal carcinoma underwent salvage partial laryngectomy after irradiation failure. Vertical laryngectomy was performed in 18 patients (13 with T1 N0 and 5 with T2 N0) and horizontal-supraglottic laryngectomy in 9 patients (3 with T1 N0, 1 with T2 N0, and 5 with T2 N1). The mean follow-up was 4.1 years.

RESULTS

Local control was obtained in 77.7% of patients with glottic lesions (T1: 84.6%; T2: 60%, P = NS) and in 55.5% of patients with supraglottic lesions (T1: 66.6%; T2: 50%; P = NS). There was no regional recurrence in the vertical laryngectomy group, whereas the regional control rate in the horizontal-supraglottic laryngectomy group was 77.7%. Distant control was achieved in 94.4% of patients with glottic disease and in 77.7% of patients with supraglottic disease. The overall survival rate for glottic lesions was 88.8% (T1: 92.3%; T2: 80%; P = NS) versus 66.6% for supraglottic lesions (T1: 100%; T2: 50%; P = NS).

CONCLUSION AND SIGNIFICANCE

Vertical laryngectomy was not associated with an increased complication rate. Morbidity in the horizontal-supraglottic laryngectomy group was higher, but a satisfactory functional outcome was obtained in all cases. Therefore, in early laryngeal cancer (glottic T1-T2, supraglottic T1) partial laryngectomy can be performed with good expectation of cure and satisfactory laryngeal function. In T2 supraglottic lesions, the oncologic results are less satisfactory; further research is required for developing more efficient complimentary or alternative treatments modalities.

Salvage vertical partial laryngectomy for radiation failure in early glottic carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Partial laryngectomy after failure of radiotherapy for early glottic cancer is an accepted surgical salvage procedure. However, there have been only a few studies on recurrent disease or long-term survival.

METHODS

Twenty-one patients who were treated with salvage partial vertical laryngectomy (PVL) following failure of primary radiotherapy were prospectively studied. Median follow up was 69 months (range 24-204 months). Patients were seen at two- monthly intervals for the first 24 months and then 3-4 monthly for 5 years after their partial surgery or until death.

RESULTS

Local control was 71.4% (15/21). Among the six patients who recurred within the larynx, two patients developed a second primary; one on the ipsilateral false cord at 24 months and the other on the contra-lateral vocal cord at 10 years. The no evidence of disease rate following salvage PVL was 95%, 85% and 73% at 12,24 and 36 months, respectively, with a mean disease free interval of 34.9 months (range 7-120). Survival was 90%, 85% and 80% at 12, 24 and 36 months,respectively, with a median survival of 152 months for the group. Three patients died of their disease and four from other causes. Four local recurrences occurred within 32 months. Two developed neck metastases and died of their disease. Four patients were treated successfully with completion laryngectomy. Only one of these died, but this was due to a second primary squamous cell carcinoma in the lung. Three of the four patients with local recurrence shad an extended procedure.

CONCLUSION

Partial vertical laryngectomy is an excellent alternative to total laryngectomy for salvage following failure of -radiation. Although local recurrence occurred more frequently in those patients having an extended partial procedure, this was not statistically different.

Supracricoid partial laryngectomy as salvage surgery after radiation failure

BACKGROUND

Radiotherapy is often chosen as the definitive treatment for early stage laryngeal carcinoma. Total laryngectomy is the main procedure for failures. Endoscopic treatment of recurrences by CO(2) laser has found limited application. Partial laryngectomy through an external approach has been proposed as salvage surgery, and the vertical partial laryngectomy (VPL) is the most mentioned surgical technique in the literature, although there are, to date, very few reports regarding the use of the supracricoid partial laryngectomy (SCPL) as salvage surgery after radiation failure.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the study is to check the feasibility of SCPL with cricohyoidoepiglottopexy (CHEP) or cricohyoidopexy (CHP) in patients with laryngeal recurrence after radiation failure and to evaluate the oncologic results, morbidity, and functional outcome.

METHODS

Fifteen consecutive patients were treated with salvage intent by SCPL from January 1992 to December 1998. CHEP and CHP were performed in 11 and 4 patients, respectively. Five patients underwent homolateral surgical neck dissection, and one underwent bilateral neck dissection. All patients had a temporary tracheostomy, and two patients required percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) to ensure feeding. Functional rehabilitation started 2 weeks after the operation.

RESULTS

The results have been evaluated in terms of oncologic outcome and functional preservation. Twelve patients are alive with a minimum follow-up of 36 months and 3 patients died after 36 days, 6 and 14 months after surgery, the first and second patient from heart failure and the third from lung metastasis. Respiratory function was recovered in all cases. Oral intake began 12 days after surgery, and in 14 cases satisfactory swallowing was recovered 30 days after surgery. An acceptable quality of the voice was achieved by most patients, and a high rate of local immediate complications was solved in all cases.

CONCLUSIONS

SCPL represents an effective technique as salvage treatment of laryngeal cancer after exclusive radiotherapy; there is a good functional recovery with acceptable morbidity and good oncologic long-term control.

Avaliação dos resultados da cirurgia conservadora do câncer da laringe

OBJETIVO: Avaliar retrospectivamente os resultados de pacientes submetidos a laringectomias parciais por carcinoma epidermóide de laringe no serviço do HMCP. MÉTODOS: Dos doentes estudados, 28 eram do sexo masculino (93,5%) e dois do feminino (6,5%) com idade variável de 42 a 66 anos, com média de 58 anos. Em relação ao procedimento cirúrgico, este foi variável, dependendo do local da extensão tumoral e do estádio. A técnica mais utilizada foi a laringectomia frontolateral em 12 pacientes (40%), seguido pela laringectomia vertical em oito (26,6%), laringectomia supraglótica em quatro (13,3%), laringectomia supracricóidea em quatro (13,3%), laringectomia near-total em um (3,3%) e cordectomia em um (3,3%). RESULTADOS: Na avaliação pós-operatória precoce, três pacientes (10%) apresentaram complicações evidenciadas por fístula faringocutâneas em dois, com boa evolução após tratamento conservador, e pneumotórax no paciente restante com boa evolução após drenagem do tórax. No que se refere à avaliação da deglutição, cinco pacientes (16,6%) apresentaram dificuldade de ingestão oral devido a aspirações recorrentes com tempo variável de 45 a 180 dias (média - 65 dias), o que obrigou a um paciente ser submetido à totalização da laringectomia devido a pneumonias recorrentes. Na avaliação tardia, de seis a 125 meses e média de 29 meses, quatro pacientes (13,3%) apresentaram recidiva locorregional, sendo dois submetidos à laringectomia vertical, um à frontolateral e o restante à supracricóidea. Em todos foram realizadas totalização e/ou radioterapia, e dois evoluíram a óbito pela doença. Vinte e quatro pacientes (84%) apresentaram preservação da voz. CONCLUSÃO: Assim, os autores concluem que a cirurgia conservadora da laringe proporciona bom controle da doença e com sobrevida aceitável, já que 90% dos pacientes estudados estão vivos e sem doença até o final da avaliação. Além disso, apresentam melhor qualidade de vida já que a maioria dos pacientes demonstrou voz e ingestão oral bem satisfatórias.

Conservation laryngeal surgery

Conservation laryngeal surgery is an increasingly available alternative for treatment of laryngeal cancer. In addition to the traditional techniques of vertical partial laryngectomy (hemilaryngectomy) and supraglottic laryngectomy, new techniques are now in practice that extend the indications to a far greater number of patients. The carbon dioxide laser is used to resect both glottic and supraglottic cancers. This procedure is best applied to early stage I and stage II cancers. Reports indicate superior functional outcome to open surgical procedures, with shorter hospital duration, less morbidity, and equivalent survival rates. The supracricoid partial laryngectomy is becoming increasingly popular for intermediate extent tumors. This novel procedure allows resection of transglottic tumors and tumors with vocal cord paralysis while preserving the patient's speech and swallowing and avoiding a permanent tracheal stoma.

Primary radiation therapy for early glottic cancer

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Early glottic squamous cell carcinoma can be effectively treated with either radiation or surgical intervention. We evaluated our experience treating early glottic cancer with primary radiation therapy and our vertical hemilaryngectomy (VHL) salvage experience.

STUDY DESIGN/METHODS

Retrospectively, patient records between January 1986 and December 1994 were reviewed and 45 patients with early glottic squamous cell carcinoma who received full-course radiation therapy at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation were identified.

RESULTS

Local control after radiation therapy was 80% overall, 87.5% for T1 lesions, and 75% for T2 lesions. Four patients underwent VHL for salvage after local recurrence; 1 was successfully salvaged with VHL. Five patients underwent total laryngectomy salvage after radiation therapy; all were successful. Only 1 of the 6 patients who were originally candidates for VHL before radiation therapy was successfully salvaged with the larynx preserved.

CONCLUSIONS

Our local control rates using primary radiation therapy are consistent with prior published series, but voice sparing salvage is poor.

Risk factors for wound infection in head and neck cancer surgery: A prospective study

BACKGROUND

The goal of this prospective study is to determine risk factors for wound infections (WI) for patients with head and neck cancer who underwent surgical procedure with opening of upper aerodigestive tract mucosa.

METHODS

One hundred sixty-five consecutive surgical procedures were studied at Oscar Lambret Cancer Center within a 24-month interval. Twenty-five variables were recorded for each patient. Statistical evaluation used Chi2 test analysis (categorical data) and Mann-Whitney test (continuous variables).

RESULTS

The overall rate of WI was 41.8%. Univariate analysis indicated that five variables were significantly related to the likelihood of WI: tumor stage (p =.044), previous chemotherapy (p =.008), duration of preoperative hospital stay (p = 022), permanent tracheostomy (p =.00008), and hypopharyngeal and laryngeal cancers (p =.008).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite antibiotic prophylaxis, WI occurrence is high. These data inform the head and neck surgeon, when a patient is at risk for WI and may help to design future prospective studies.

Partial laryngectomy for recurrent laryngeal carcinoma

From July 1975 to January 1998, 33 patients underwent partial laryngeal resection for residual or recurrent tumour after primary radical radiotherapy. Sixteen patients had T1 tumours on presentation, 14 were T2 and three were T3. Six patients underwent a supraglottic (horizontal) laryngectomy, 24 had a vertical partial laryngectomy, two had an endoscopic laser resection and one had an endoscopic laser resection followed by a vertical partial laryngectomy. The median time interval between radiotherapy and salvage surgery was 10 months (range 2-188 months). The median follow-up period was 41 months (range 12-185 months). There were five major postoperative complications (15%); two patients developed a pharyngeal fistula and three required further surgery for laryngo-tracheal stenosis. Twenty-five patients (76%) retained their larynx with satisfactory speech and swallowing. Eight patients (24%) had to be converted to a total laryngectomy, seven for recurrent disease and one for laryngeal stenosis. Of the eight patents converted, seven had normal swallowing and six developed good tracheo-oesophageal speech. Seven patients (21%) developed recurrent tumour after partial laryngectomy and were subjected to total laryngectomy; six of these seven were salvaged. Only one of the 33 patients died with recurrent tumour, giving an ultimate disease-related survival of 97%. Conservation laryngeal surgery for salvage of selected patients who fail radical radiation therapy is safe, effective, and results in reasonable preservation of laryngeal function.