Midterm results of mitral valve repair with the Sculptor annuloplasty ring

Mitral Valve Annuloplasty Rings: Review of Literature and Comparison of Functional Outcome and Ventricular Dimensions

In the past decades, more than 40 mitral valve annuloplasty rings of various shapes and consistency were marketed for mitral regurgitation (MR), although the effect of ring type on clinical outcome remains unclear. Our objective was to review the literature and apply a simplification method to make rings of different shapes and rigidity more comparable. We studied relevant literature from MEDLINE and EMBASE databases related to clinical studies as well as animal and finite element models. Annuloplasty rings were clustered into 3 groups as follows: rigid (R), flexible (F), and semirigid (S). Only clinical articles regarding degenerative (DEG) or ischemic/dilated cardiomyopathy (ICM) MR were included and stratified into these groups. A total of 37 rings were clustered into R, F, and S subgroups. Clinical studies with a mean follow-up of less than 1 year and a reported mean etiology of valve incompetence of less than 60% were excluded from the analysis. Forty-one publications were included. Preimplant and postimplant end points were New York Heart Association class, left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF), left ventricular end-systolic dimension (LVESD), and left ventricular end-diastolic dimension (LVEDD). Statistical analysis included paired-samples t test and analysis of variance with post hoc Bonferroni correction. P < 0.05 indicated statistical difference. Mean ± SD follow-up was 38.6 ± 27 and 29.7 ± 13.2 months for DEG and ICM, respectively. In DEG, LVEF remained unchanged, and LVESD decreased in all subgroups. In our analysis, LVEDD decreased only in F and R, and S did not change; however, the 4 individual studies showed a significant decline. In ICM, New York Heart Association class improved in all subgroups, and LVEF increased. Moreover, LVESD and LVEDD decreased only in F and S; R was underpowered (1 study). No statistical difference among R, F, and S in either ICM or DEG could be detected for all end points. Overall, owing to underpowered data sets derived from limited available publications, major statistical differences in clinical outcome between ring types could not be substantiated. Essential end points such as recurrent MR and survival were incomparable. In conclusion, ring morphology and consistency do not seem to play a major clinical role in mitral valve repair based on the present literature. Hence, until demonstrated otherwise, surgeons may choose their ring upon their judgment, tailored to specific patient needs.

Multiple purpose simulator using a natural porcine mitral valve

An in vitro pulsatile simulator with a porcine mitral valve was developed in order to simulate physiologic and diseased mitral valve conditions. Evaluation of these conditions was conducted from a hydrodynamic and annulus behavior point of view. We found it possible to simulate mild "mitral valve prolapse" and to obtain quantitative data related to the condition. The diseased condition produced a 40% greater regurgitant volume than that observed under the normal condition (p < 0.0001). Regarding the leakage volume, the diseased condition exhibited about 2.6 times more leakage than the normal condition. The mitral valve simulator proposed in this study is considered fairly stable with respect to both hemodynamics and the behavior of the annulus, and it is an adequate simulator for modeling various types of normal and diseased mitral valve conditions.

Valve repair in mitral regurgitation complicated by severe annulus calcification

BACKGROUND

Valvuloplasty has significant advantages over valve replacement for mitral regurgitation, but the presence of severe calcification of the mitral valve apparatus has been thought to preclude successful valve reconstruction in general. The purpose of this report is to assess the results of valvuloplasty in patients with severe mitral regurgitation having extensive calcification extending from the mitral annulus to underlying myocardium and parts of the papillary muscles.

METHODS

Thirty-seven adult patients with severe mitral regurgitation and calcification were operated on between April 1990 and January 1998. Twenty-six patients had degenerative disease, 4 had acute bacterial endocarditis, 6 had postrheumatic fever, and 1 patient had Marfan's disease. The valve repair comprised of en bloc decalcification with extensive leaflet debridement and reconstruction of the annulus. Autologous pericardium was used in patch-extended endocardial annuloplasty or leaflet repair. Valve competence was retained after correction of regurgitation by sliding atrioplasty, rotation paracommissural sliding plasty, cusp remodeling, or chordal repair. All patients required a prosthetic annuloplasty.

RESULTS

Follow-up echocardiography at 47 months (range, 3 to 92 months) showed no or only trivial mitral regurgitation in 33 patients; 3 had grade I-II mitral regurgitation and 1 required valve replacement after 3 months. Freedom of reoperation at 1 and 5 years was 94.6%. At last examination, 33 patients were in New York Heart Association functional class I and 3 in class I-II; there has been no mortality and no thromboembolic events.

CONCLUSIONS

Valvuloplasty can be safely and successfully carried out in patients suffering from regurgitation associated with severe calcification of the mitral apparatus. With encouraging beneficial midterm results, we suggest patients with calcified valves should not be excluded from mitral repair.

Flexible posterior mitral annuloplasty: five-year clinical and Doppler echocardiographic results

BACKGROUND

Stabilization of the posterior annulus seems to be a critical factor to achieve a stable mitral valve repair. To assess the benefit of softer mural annuloplasty, we analyzed results obtained with the flexible linear reducer.

METHODS

From 1985 to 1993, 120 patients, with pure mitral regurgitation, mainly degenerative, had a mitral reconstruction. Mean age was 64+/-11 years and 74% of the patients were in New York Heart Association functional class III or IV.

RESULTS

Hospital mortality was 3.3%. Mean follow-up was 56+/-24 months. There were 23 late deaths; 10 valve-related including 7 sudden deaths. Two patients (1.7%) required a reoperation. Doppler echocardiographic studies revealed excellent valve function; 5-year freedom from significant regurgitation was 85.8%+/-5.4%. Mean mitral valve area was 2.76+/-0.77 cm2. Although 105 patients were in class I or II, 23 patients were not functionally improved. Previous myocardial infarction and shorter deceleration time of early filling were risk factors for worsening functional disability.

CONCLUSIONS

This support provides stable repair with excellent clinical and echographic results. Previous myocardial infarction and noncompliant left ventricle negatively influence outcome.