O2-specific regulation of the ferrous heme-based sensor kinase FixL from Sinorhizobium meliloti and its aberrant inactivation in the ferric form

Regulatory Switching by Concerted Motions on the Microsecond Time Scale of the Oxygen Sensor Protein FixL

Signal transduction proteins perceive external stimuli in their sensor module and regulate the biological activities of the effector module, allowing cellular adaptation in response to environmental changes. FixL is a dimeric heme protein kinase that senses the oxygen level in plant root nodules to regulate the transcription of nitrogen fixation genes via the phosphorylation of its cognate transcriptional activator. Dissociation of oxygen from the heme induces conformational changes in the protein, converting it from the inactive form for phosphorylation to the active form. However, how FixL undergoes conformational change to regulate kinase activity upon oxygen dissociation remains poorly understood. Here we report time-resolved ultraviolet resonance Raman spectra showing conformational changes for FixL from Sinorhizobium meliloti. We observed spectral changes with a time constant of about 3 μs, which were oxygen-specific. Furthermore, we found that the conformational changes in the sensor and kinase domains are coupled, enabling allosteric control of kinase activity. Our results demonstrate that concerted structural changes on the microsecond time scale serve as the regulatory switch in FixL.

The role of nitrite and nitric oxide under low oxygen conditions in plants

Plant tissues, particularly roots, can be subjected to periods of hypoxia due to environmental circumstances. Plants have developed various adaptations in response to hypoxic stress and these have been described extensively. Less well-appreciated is the body of evidence demonstrating that scavenging of nitric oxide (NO) and the reduction of nitrate/nitrite regulate important mechanisms that contribute to tolerance to hypoxia. Although ethylene controls hyponasty and aerenchyma formation, NO production apparently regulates hypoxic ethylene biosynthesis. In the hypoxic mitochondrion, cytochrome c oxidase, which is a major source of NO, also is inhibited by NO, thereby reducing the respiratory rate and enhancing local oxygen concentrations. Nitrite can maintain ATP generation under hypoxia by coupling its reduction to the translocation of protons from the inner side of mitochondria and generating an electrochemical gradient. This reaction can be further coupled to a reaction whereby nonsymbiotic haemoglobin oxidizes NO to nitrate. In addition to these functions, nitrite has been reported to influence mitochondrial structure and supercomplex formation, as well as playing a role in oxygen sensing via the N-end rule pathway. These studies establish that nitrite and NO perform multiple functions during plant hypoxia and suggest that further research into the underlying mechanisms is warranted.

Haem-based sensors: a still growing old superfamily

The haem-based sensors are chimeric multi-domain proteins responsible for the cellular adaptive responses to environmental changes. The signal transduction is mediated by the sensing capability of the haem-binding domain, which transmits a usable signal to the cognate transmitter domain, responsible for providing the adequate answer. Four major families of haem-based sensors can be recognized, depending on the nature of the haem-binding domain: (i) the haem-binding PAS domain, (ii) the CO-sensitive carbon monoxide oxidation activator, (iii) the haem NO-binding domain, and (iv) the globin-coupled sensors. The functional classification of the haem-binding sensors is based on the activity of the transmitter domain and, traditionally, comprises: (i) sensors with aerotactic function; (ii) sensors with gene-regulating function; and (iii) sensors with unknown function. We have implemented this classification with newly identified proteins, that is, the Streptomyces avermitilis and Frankia sp. that present a C-terminal-truncated globin fused to an N-terminal cofactor-free monooxygenase, the structural-related class of non-haem globins in Bacillus subtilis, Moorella thermoacetica, and Bacillus anthracis, and a haemerythrin-coupled diguanylate cyclase in Vibrio cholerae. This review summarizes the structures, the functions, and the structure-function relationships known to date on this broad protein family. We also propose unresolved questions and new possible research approaches.

The Dos family of globin-related sensors using PAS domains to accommodate haem acting as the active site for sensing external signals

Sensor proteins play crucial roles in maintaining homeostasis of cells by sensing changes in extra- and intracellular chemical and physical conditions to trigger biological responses. It has recently become clear that gas molecules function as signalling molecules in these biological regulatory systems responsible for transcription, chemotaxis, synthesis/hydrolysis of nucleotide second messengers, and other complex physiological processes. Haem-containing sensor proteins are widely used to sense gas molecules because haem can bind gas molecules reversibly. Ligand binding to the haem in the sensor proteins triggers conformational changes around the haem, which results in their functional regulation. Spectroscopic and crystallographic studies are essential to understand how these sensor proteins function in these biological regulatory systems. In this chapter, I discuss structural and functional relationships of haem-containing PAS and PAS-related families of the sensor proteins.

How do heme-protein sensors exclude oxygen? Lessons learned from cytochrome c', Nostoc puntiforme heme nitric oxide/oxygen-binding domain, and soluble guanylyl cyclase

SIGNIFICANCE

Ligand selectivity for dioxygen (O(2)), carbon monoxide (CO), and nitric oxide (NO) is critical for signal transduction and is tailored specifically for each heme-protein sensor. Key NO sensors, such as soluble guanylyl cyclase (sGC), specifically recognized low levels of NO and achieve a total O(2) exclusion. Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain the O(2) insensitivity, including lack of a hydrogen bond donor and negative electrostatic fields to selectively destabilize bound O(2), distal steric hindrance of all bound ligands to the heme iron, and restriction of in-plane movements of the iron atom.

RECENT ADVANCES

Crystallographic structures of the gas sensors, Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis heme-nitric oxide/oxygen-binding domain (Tt H-NOX(1)) or Nostoc puntiforme (Ns) H-NOX, and measurements of O(2) binding to site-specific mutants of Tt H-NOX and the truncated β subunit of sGC suggest the need for a H-bonding donor to facilitate O(2) binding.

CRITICAL ISSUES

However, the O(2) insensitivity of full length sGC with a site-specific replacement of isoleucine by a tyrosine on residue 145 and the very slow autooxidation of Ns H-NOX and cytochrome c' suggest that more complex mechanisms have evolved to exclude O(2) but retain high affinity NO binding. A combined graphical analysis of ligand binding data for libraries of heme sensors, globins, and model heme shows that the NO sensors dramatically inhibit the formation of six-coordinated NO, CO, and O(2) complexes by direct distal steric hindrance (cyt c'), proximal constraints of in-plane iron movement (sGC), or combinations of both following a sliding scale rule. High affinity NO binding in H-NOX proteins is achieved by multiple NO binding steps that produce a high affinity five-coordinate NO complex, a mechanism that also prevents NO dioxygenation.

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

Knowledge advanced by further extensive test of this "sliding scale rule" hypothesis should be valuable in guiding novel designs for heme based sensors.

Ligand binding to the Fe(III)-protoporphyrin IX complex of phosphodiesterase from Escherichia coli (Ec DOS) markedly enhances catalysis of cyclic di-GMP: roles of Met95, Arg97, and Phe113 of the putative heme distal side in catalytic regulation and ligand binding

Phosphodiesterase (Ec DOS) from Escherichia coli is a gas-sensor enzyme in which binding of gas molecules, such as O(2), CO, and NO, to the Fe(II)-protoporphyrin IX complex in the sensor domain stimulates phosphodiesterase activity toward cyclic-di-GMP. In this study, we report that external axial ligands, such as cyanide or imidazole, bind to Fe(III)-protoporphyrin IX in the sensor domain and induce a 10- to 11-fold increase (from 8.1 up to 86 min(-1)) in catalysis, which is more substantial than that (6.3 to 7.2-fold) observed for other gas-stimulated Fe(II) heme-bound enzymes. Catalytic activity (50 min(-1)) of the heme-free mutant, H77A, was comparable to that of the ligand-stimulated enzymes. Accordingly, we propose that the heme at the sensor domain inhibits catalysis and that ligand binding to the heme iron complex releases this catalytic suppression. Furthermore, mutations of Met95, Arg97, and Phe113 at the putative heme distal side suppressed the ligand effects on catalysis. The rate constants (19,000 x 10(-5) microM(-1)min(-1)) for cyanide binding to the M95A and M95L mutants of the full-length enzyme were 633-fold higher than that to wild-type Ec DOS (30 x 10(-5) microM(-1)min(-1)). The absorption spectrum of the F113Y mutant suggests that the Tyr O(-) group directly coordinates to the Fe(III) complex and that the cyanide binding rate to the mutant is very slow, compared with those of the wild-type and other mutant proteins. We observed a similar trend in the binding behavior of imidazole to full-length mutant enzymes. Therefore, while Met95 and Phe113 are not direct axial ligands for the Fe(III) complex, catalytic, spectroscopic, and ligand binding evidence suggests that these residues are located in the vicinity of the heme.

Separation of phosphoprotein isotypes having the same number of phosphate groups using phosphate-affinity SDS-PAGE

Herein, we demonstrate the separation of phosphoprotein isotypes having the same number of phosphate groups using phosphate-affinity SDS-PAGE. The phosphate-affinity site is a polyacrylamide-bound Phos-tag that enables the mobility shift detection of phosphoproteins from their nonphosphorylated counterparts. As the first practical example of the separation, we characterized the monophosphorylated Tau isotypes by each of three tyrosine kinases, c-Abl, MET, and Fyn. Each monophosphoisotype phosphorylated at the Tyr-394, Tyr-197, or Tyr-18 was detected as three distinct migration bands. As a further application, we extended this technique to the mobility shift analysis of His and Asp phosphoisotypes in the Sinorhizobium meliloti FixL/FixJ two-component system. FixL is autophosphorylated at the His-285 with ATP, and the phosphate group is transferred to the Asp-54 of FixJ and subsequently removed by the FixL phosphatase activity. Using this method, we first performed simultaneous detection of the phosphorylated and nonphosphorylated isotypes of FixL and FixJ generated in their phosphotransfer reaction in vitro. As a result, a monophosphoisotype of FixL containing the phosphorylated His residue was confirmed. As for FixJ, on the other hand, two monophosphoisotypes were detected as two distinct migration bands. One is a well-known isotype phosphorylated at the Asp-54. The other is a novel isotype phosphorylated at the His-84.

Critical role of the heme axial ligand, Met95, in locking catalysis of the phosphodiesterase from Escherichia coli (Ec DOS) toward Cyclic diGMP

Heme-regulated phosphodiesterase from Escherichia coli (Ec DOS) is a gas-sensor enzyme that hydrolyzes cyclic dinucleotide-GMP, and it is activated by O(2) or CO binding to the Fe(II) heme. In contrast to other well known heme-regulated gas-sensor enzymes or proteins, Ec DOS is not specific for a single gas ligand. Because Arg(97) in the heme distal side in Ec DOS interacts with the O(2) molecule and Met(95) serves as the axial ligand on the distal side of the Fe(II) heme-bound PAS domain of Ec DOS, we explored the effect of mutating these residues on the activity and gas specificity of Ec DOS. We found that R97A, R97I, and R97E mutations do not significantly affect regulation of the phosphodiesterase activities of the Fe(II)-CO and Fe(II)-NO complexes. The phosphodiesterase activities of the Fe(II)-O(2) complexes of the mutants could not be detected due to rapid autoxidation and/or low affinity for O(2). In contrast, the activities even of the gas-free M95A and M95L mutants were similar to that of the gas-activated wild-type enzyme. Interestingly, the activity of the M95H mutant was partially activated by O(2), CO, and NO. Spectroscopic analysis indicated that the Fe(II) heme is in the 5-coordinated high-spin state in the M95A and M95L mutants but that in the M95H mutant, like wild-type Ec DOS, it is in the 6-coordinated low-spin state. These results suggest that Met(95) coordination to the Fe(II) heme is critical for locking the system and that global structural changes around Met(95) caused by the binding of the external ligands or mutations at Met(95) releases the catalytic lock and activates catalysis.

Insights into heme-based O2 sensing from structure-function relationships in the FixL proteins

FixL proteins are bacterial heme-containing signal transduction proteins responsible for sensing the O(2) concentration in the organism's environment. In Sinorhizobium meliloti FixL is a protein histidine kinase that, together with its response regulator FixJ, constitute an oxygen-sensitive switch for regulation of the organism's nitrogen fixation and microaerobic respiration genes. The O(2) sensitivity of the switch is such that it transitions during the process of symbiosis in alfalfa roots. Bradyrhizobium japonicum FixL similarly regulates microaerobic and anaerobic respiration genes during symbiosis in soybean roots. FixLs responds to low oxygen concentrations with increased autophosphorylation activity of their kinase domains. The phosphorylated FixL provides a phosphoryl group to FixJ within a FixLJ complex. The phosphorylated FixJs are transcriptionally active toward their target genes. The FixL kinase domain is inhibited when the heme in FixL is oxygenated. Kinetic and thermodynamic studies of ligand binding to both ferrous and ferric FixLs have shown a generally low affinity for ligands relative to myoglobins. These relatively low ligand affinities are attributable almost completely to diminished rates of ligand binding. The heme and its environment in liganded and unliganded FixLs have been characterized by UV-visible spectroscopy, resonance Raman spectroscopy, EXAFS, and X-ray crystallography. These studies have revealed that in the purified proteins, the heme is converted from a six-coordinate low spin state to a five-coordinate high spin state upon O(2) release. Comparisons of spectroscopic and structural characteristics of deoxyFixL with oxyFixL, met-FixL-CN, FixL-CO, and FixL-NO complexes indicate that distal affects in the heme pocket are, at least in part, responsible for communicating the ligation state of the heme to the kinase domain. The mechanisms by which ligand binding events are communicated from the heme to the kinase domain involves propagation and/or amplification of the ligation-coupled conformational transitions of the heme and its immediate protein environment. More recently, time-resolved experiments examining the nonequilibrium, ligand-coupled dynamics initiated by O(2), CO, and NO photolysis from the corresponding FixL complexes have begun to shed light on the landscape of the switching coordinate. Current thinking and understanding of the mechanism for signal transduction in the FixLJ systems are discussed in the context of these physical investigations.

Recombinant PAS-heme domains of oxygen sensing proteins: high level production and physical characterization

Details of a high-level recombinant production method for the heme-PAS domains of heme oxygen sensing proteins from Sinorhizobium meliloti (Sm) (formerly Rhizobium meliloti, Rm), Bradyrhizobium japonicum (Bj), and Escherichia coli (Ec) are described. Using a newly proposed, concise, and unambiguous naming system (also described here) these proteins are: SmFixLH(128-264), BjFixLH(140-270), and EcDosH(1-147). In addition, high-level production of BjFixL(140-505), the soluble full-length protein containing both heme (oxygen sensing) and kinase (catalytic) domains is described. Using an IPTG-inducible pET/BL21 expression system and a rapid, two-column purification has resulted in increased yields of 3- to 17-fold over literature values. The recombinant proteins are highly pure as judged by SDS-PAGE, MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry, and a UV-visible purity index. To our knowledge, this work includes the first mass spectrometry analysis of any PAS-heme protein and provides high-resolution confirmation of each protein's identity. These production and characterization improvements make possible future spectroscopic and dynamics studies designed to elucidate the intramolecular/interdomain signal that follows heme-domain oxygen dissociation.

CO-sensing mechanisms

Carbon monoxide (CO) has long been known to have dramatic physiological effects on organisms ranging from bacteria to humans, but recently there have a number of suggestions that organisms might have specific sensors for CO. This article reviews the current evidence for a variety of proteins with demonstrated or potential CO-sensing ability. Particular emphasis is placed on the molecular description of CooA, a heme-containing CO sensor from Rhodospirillum rubrum, since its biological role as a CO sensor is clear and we have substantial insight into the basis of its sensing ability.

The C-terminal receiver domain of the Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae FixL protein is required for free-living microaerobic induction of the fnrN promoter

The Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae VF39 FixL protein belongs to a distinct group of hybrid regulatory sensor proteins that bear a covalently linked C-terminal receiver domain. FixL has an unorthodox histidine kinase domain, which is shared with many other hybrid regulators. The purified FixL protein had autophosphorylation activity. A truncated protein, lacking the receiver domain, had a much-reduced autophosphorylation activity. However, this truncated protein still efficiently phosphorylated the purified receiver domain in trans. This indicates that, in the full-length FixL protein, the conserved histidine residue in the kinase domain is phosphorylated only transiently and that most of the phosphoryl label accumulates in the C-terminal receiver domain. Gene-fusion studies showed that the fixL gene is required for free-living microaerobic induction of the fnrN promoter. The presence of a functional fixK gene is not required. An R. leguminosarum strain lacking fixL could not be complemented with a truncated copy of the gene lacking the receiver domain. This indicates that the C-terminal receiver domain is an intermediate in the signal transduction pathway that links oxygen limitation to induction of the fnrN promoter in R. leguminosarum bv. viciae VF39.

ADP reduces the oxygen-binding affinity of a sensory histidine kinase, FixL: the possibility of an enhanced reciprocating kinase reaction

The rhizobial FixL/FixJ system, a paradigm of heme-based oxygen sensors, belongs to the ubiquitous two-component signal transduction system. Oxygen-free (deoxy) FixL is autophosphorylated at an invariant histidine residue by using ATP and catalyzes the concomitant phosphoryl transfer to FixJ, but oxygen binding to the FixL heme moiety inactivates the kinase activity. Here we demonstrate that ADP acts as an allosteric effector, reducing the oxygen-binding affinity of the sensor domain in FixL when it is produced from ATP in the kinase reaction. The addition of ADP to a solution of purified wild-type FixL resulted in an approximately 4- to 5-fold decrease in oxygen-binding affinity in the presence of FixJ. In contrast, phosphorylation-deficient mutants, in which the well conserved ATP-binding catalytic site of the kinase domain is impaired, showed no such allosteric effect. This discovery casts light on the significance of homodimerization of two-component histidine kinases; ADP, generated in the phosphorylation reaction in one subunit of the homodimer, enhances the histidine kinase activity of the other, analogous to a two-cylinder reciprocating engine by reducing the ligand-binding affinity.