Lateral heterogeneity of photosystems in thylakoid membranes studied by Brownian dynamics simulations

Pigment-protein complexes are organized into stable microdomains in cyanobacterial thylakoids

Thylakoids are the place of the light-photosynthetic reactions. To gain maximal efficiency, these reactions are conditional to proper pigment-pigment and protein-protein interactions. In higher plants thylakoids, the interactions lead to a lateral asymmetry in localization of protein complexes (i.e. granal/stromal thylakoids) that have been defined as a domain-like structures characteristic by different biochemical composition and function (Albertsson P-Å. 2001,Trends Plant Science 6: 349-354). We explored this complex organization of thylakoid pigment-proteins at single cell level in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. Our 3D confocal images captured heterogeneous distribution of all main photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes (PPCs), Photosystem I (fluorescently tagged by YFP), Photosystem II and Phycobilisomes. The acquired images depicted cyanobacterial thylakoid membrane as a stable, mosaic-like structure formed by microdomains (MDs). These microcompartments are of sub-micrometer in sizes (~0.5-1.5 μm), typical by particular PPCs ratios and importantly without full segregation of observed complexes. The most prevailing MD is represented by MD with high Photosystem I content which allows also partial separation of Photosystems like in higher plants thylakoids. We assume that MDs stability (in minutes) provides optimal conditions for efficient excitation/electron transfer. The cyanobacterial MDs thus define thylakoid membrane organization as a system controlled by co-localization of three main PPCs leading to formation of thylakoid membrane mosaic. This organization might represent evolutional and functional precursor for the granal/stromal spatial heterogeneity in photosystems that is typical for higher plant thylakoids.

A Rationale for Mesoscopic Domain Formation in Biomembranes

Cell plasma membranes display a dramatically rich structural complexity characterized by functional sub-wavelength domains with specific lipid and protein composition. Under favorable experimental conditions, patterned morphologies can also be observed in vitro on model systems such as supported membranes or lipid vesicles. Lipid mixtures separating in liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered phases below a demixing temperature play a pivotal role in this context. Protein-protein and protein-lipid interactions also contribute to membrane shaping by promoting small domains or clusters. Such phase separations displaying characteristic length-scales falling in-between the nanoscopic, molecular scale on the one hand and the macroscopic scale on the other hand, are named mesophases in soft condensed matter physics. In this review, we propose a classification of the diverse mechanisms leading to mesophase separation in biomembranes. We distinguish between mechanisms relying upon equilibrium thermodynamics and those involving out-of-equilibrium mechanisms, notably active membrane recycling. In equilibrium, we especially focus on the many mechanisms that dwell on an up-down symmetry breaking between the upper and lower bilayer leaflets. Symmetry breaking is an ubiquitous mechanism in condensed matter physics at the heart of several important phenomena. In the present case, it can be either spontaneous (domain buckling) or explicit, i.e., due to an external cause (global or local vesicle bending properties). Whenever possible, theoretical predictions and simulation results are confronted to experiments on model systems or living cells, which enables us to identify the most realistic mechanisms from a biological perspective.

Pea PSII-LHCII supercomplexes form pairs by making connections across the stromal gap

In higher plant thylakoids, the heterogeneous distribution of photosynthetic protein complexes is a determinant for the formation of grana, stacks of membrane discs that are densely populated with Photosystem II (PSII) and its light harvesting complex (LHCII). PSII associates with LHCII to form the PSII-LHCII supercomplex, a crucial component for solar energy conversion. Here, we report a biochemical, structural and functional characterization of pairs of PSII-LHCII supercomplexes, which were isolated under physiologically-relevant cation concentrations. Using single-particle cryo-electron microscopy, we determined the three-dimensional structure of paired C2S2M PSII-LHCII supercomplexes at 14 Å resolution. The two supercomplexes interact on their stromal sides through a specific overlap between apposing LHCII trimers and via physical connections that span the stromal gap, one of which is likely formed by interactions between the N-terminal loops of two Lhcb4 monomeric LHCII subunits. Fast chlorophyll fluorescence induction analysis showed that paired PSII-LHCII supercomplexes are energetically coupled. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed that additional flexible physical connections may form between the apposing LHCII trimers of paired PSII-LHCII supercomplexes in appressed thylakoid membranes. Our findings provide new insights into how interactions between pairs of PSII-LHCII supercomplexes can link adjacent thylakoids to mediate the stacking of grana membranes.

Surface charge dynamics in photosynthetic membranes and the structural consequences

The strict stacking of plant photosynthetic membranes into granal structures plays a vital role in energy conversion. The molecular forces that lead to grana stacking, however, are poorly understood. Here we evaluate the interplay between repulsive electrostatic (F_el) and attractive van der Waals (F_vdWaals) forces in grana stacking. In contrast to previous reports, we find that the physicochemical balance between attractive and repulsive forces fully explains grana stacking. Extending the force balance analysis to lateral interactions within the oxygen-evolving photosystem II (PSII)-light harvesting complex II (LHCII) supercomplex reveals that supercomplex stability is very sensitive to F_el changes. F_el is highly dynamic, increasing up to 1.7-fold on addition of negative charges by phosphorylation of grana-hosted proteins. We show that this leads to specific destabilization of the supercomplex, and that changes in F_el have contrasting effects on vertical stacking and lateral intramembrane organization. This enables discrete biological control of these central structural features.

Where Biology Meets Physics--A Converging View on Membrane Microdomain Dynamics

For several decades, the phenomenon of membrane component segregation into microdomains has been a well-known and highly debated subject, and varying concepts including the raft hypothesis, the fence-and-picket model, hydrophobic-mismatch, and specific protein-protein interactions have been offered as explanations. Here, we review the level of insight into the molecular architecture of membrane domains one is capable of obtaining through biological experimentation. Using SNARE proteins as a paradigm, comprehensive data suggest that several dozens of molecules crowd together into almost circular spots smaller than 100 nm. Such clusters are highly dynamical as they constantly capture and lose molecules. The organization has a strong influence on the functional availability of proteins and likely provides a molecular scaffold for more complex protein networks. Despite this high level of insight, fundamental open questions remain, applying not only to SNARE protein domains but more generally to all types of membrane domains. In this context, we explain the view of physical models and how they are beneficial in advancing our concept of micropatterning. While biological models generally remain qualitative and descriptive, physics aims towards making them quantitative and providing reproducible numbers, in order to discriminate between different mechanisms which have been proposed to account for experimental observations. Despite the fundamental differences in biological and physical approaches as far as cell membrane microdomains are concerned, we are able to show that convergence on common points of views is in reach.

Surface electric charge of thylakoid membranes from genetically modified tobacco plants under freezing stress

In the present study we characterize for the first time electrokinetic and light scattering properties of thylakoids from freezing-tolerant tobacco plants, transformed to accumulate osmoprotectants (proline: AtP5Cs, VacP5Cs; fructan: SacB; glycine betaine: codA). Tobacco plants of wild type (WT) and transformed variants were cultivated at 2°C (cold acclimated) and -2°C (freezing stressed). "Lower salt" thylakoids (I=0.0006) of WT and SacB plants exhibited a decrease in electrophoretic mobility (EPM) after (2°C) treatment. AtP5Cs thylakoids (22°C) show a substantial increase in negative electrical charge (σ) upon illumination. We observed that "low salt"SacB thylakoids at 22°C and 2°C increased the σ on their membrane surfaces during the process of acclimation. WT (22°C) and AtP5Cs thylakoids (2°C) in "low salt" media (I=0.0156) showed a substantial increase in surface electrical charge upon illumination. Cold acclimation on WT and freezing stress on transformed plants resulted in a decrease in aggregation of thylakoids at both ionic strengths. There was a large enhancement in the relaxation capacity of reverse photosynthetic reactions in codA and SacB tobacco after freezing stress. Maximal intensity of the delayed light emission following low temperature stimuli was decreased, revealing a path for tobacco transformants to improve their cold stress tolerance. Here, we suggest the EPM value as an indicator for stability of thylakoids undergone genetic transformation.

Clusters of proteins in biomembranes: insights into the roles of interaction potential shapes and of protein diversity

It has recently been proposed that proteins embedded in lipidic biomembranes can spontaneously self-organize into stable small clusters, or membrane nanodomains, due to the competition between short-range attractive and longer-range repulsive forces between proteins, specific to these systems. In this paper, we carry on our investigation, by Monte Carlo simulations, of different aspects of cluster phases of proteins in biomembranes. First, we compare different long-range potentials (including notably three-body terms) to demonstrate that the existence of cluster phases should be quite generic. Furthermore, a real membrane contains hundreds of different protein species that are far from being randomly distributed in these nanodomains. We take this protein diversity into account by modulating protein-protein interaction potentials both at short and longer range. We confirm theoretical predictions in terms of biological cluster specialization by deciphering how clusters recruit only a few protein species. In this respect, we highlight that cluster phases can turn out to be an advantage at the biological level, for example by enhancing the cell response to external stimuli.

What do diffusion measurements tell us about membrane compartmentalisation? Emergence of the role of interprotein interactions

The techniques of diffusion analysis based on optical microscopy approaches have revealed a great diversity of the dynamic organisation of cell membranes. For a long period, two frameworks have dominated the way of representing the membrane structure: the membrane skeleton fences and the lipid raft models. Progresses in the methods of data analysis have shed light on the features and consequently the possible origin of membrane domains: Inter-protein interactions play a role in confinement. Innovative developments pushing forward the spatiotemporal resolution limits are currently emerging, which are likely to provide in the future a detailed understanding of the intimate functional dynamic organisation of the cell membrane.

Seasonal changes of fatty acid composition and thermotropic behavior of polar lipids from marine macrophytes

Major glyco- and phospholipids as well as betaine lipid 1,2-diacylglycero-O-4'-(N,N,N-tri-methyl)-homoserine (DGTS) were isolated from five species of marine macrophytes harvested in the Sea of Japan in summer and winter at seawater temperatures of 20-23 and 3 degrees C, respectively. GC and DSC analysis of lipids revealed a common increase of ratio between n-3 and n-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) of polar lipids from summer to winter despite their chemotaxonomically different fatty acid (FA) composition. Especially, high level of different n-3 PUFAs was observed in galactolipids in winter. However, the rise in FA unsaturation did not result in the lowering of peak maximum temperature of phase transition of photosynthetic lipids (glycolipids and phosphatidylglycerol (PG)) in contrast to non-photosynthetic ones [phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE)]. Different thermotropic behavior of these lipid groups was accompanied by higher content of n-6 PUFAs from the sum of n-6 and n-3 PUFAs in PC and PE compared with glycolipids and PG in both seasons. Seasonal changes of DSC transitions and FA composition of DGTS studied for the first time were similar to PC and PE. Thermograms of all polar lipids were characterized by complex profiles and located in a wide temperature range between -130 and 80 degrees C, while the most evident phase separation occurred in PGs in both seasons. Polarizing microscopy combined with DSC has shown that the liquid crystal - isotropic melt transitions of polar lipids from marine macrophytes began from 10 to 30 degrees C mostly, which can cause the thermal sensitivity of plants to superoptimal temperatures in their environment.

Thermodynamics of nanocluster phases: a unifying theory

We propose a unifying, analytical theory accounting for the self-organization of colloidal systems in nanocluster or microcluster phases. We predict the distribution of cluster sizes with respect to interaction parameters and colloid concentration. In particular, we anticipate a proportionality regime where the mean cluster size grows proportionally to the concentration, as observed in several experiments. We emphasize the interest in a predictive theory in soft matter, nanotechnologies, and biophysics.

Organization of membrane-associated proteins in lipid bilayers

Lateral organization of proteins in biomembranes is vitally important to membrane functions such as signal transduction, endocytosis, and membrane trafficking. One of the major goals in current biomembrane science is to reveal the microscopic mechanism of membrane-associated protein organization in biomembranes. Here, we investigate the structural organization of membrane-associated proteins in lipid bilayers by combining self-consistent field theory with density functional theory. The present study can simultaneously take into account the entropy effect of lipids, depletion effect of membrane-associated proteins due to the presence of lipid headgroups as well as the effect of interfacial interaction. By varying the volume fraction of lipids, we examine various effects on protein organization, and reveal that a close-packed crystal structure appears at low lipid volume fractions due to interfacial energy and weak depletion effect, whereas a chain structure with branches occurs at high lipid volume fractions mainly due to strong depletion. The present results may provide some theoretical insight into further experiments on organization of membrane proteins.

Cluster phases of membrane proteins

A physical scenario accounting for the existence of size-limited submicrometric domains in cell membranes is proposed. It is based on the numerical investigation of the counterpart, in lipidic membranes where proteins are diffusing, of the recently discovered cluster phases in colloidal suspensions. I demonstrate that the interactions between proteins, namely, short-range attraction and longer-range repulsion, make possible the existence of stable small clusters. The consequences are explored in terms of membrane organization and diffusion properties. The connection with lipid rafts is discussed, and the apparent protein diffusion coefficient as a function of their concentration is analyzed.

Modeling 2D and 3D diffusion

Modeling obstructed diffusion is essential to the understanding of diffusion-mediated processes in the crowded cellular environment. Simple Monte Carlo techniques for modeling obstructed random walks are explained and related to Brownian dynamics and more complicated Monte Carlo methods. Random number generation is reviewed in the context of random walk simulations. Programming techniques and event-driven algorithms are discussed as ways to speed simulations.

Changes in the energy distribution in mutant thylakoid membranes of pea with modified pigment content. II. Changes due to magnesium ions concentration

Low-temperature (77K) steady-state chlorophyll fluorescence emission spectra, room temperature fluorescence and light scattering of thylakoid membranes isolated from pea mutants were studied as a function of Mg2+ concentration. The mutants have modified pigment content and altered structural organization of the pigment-protein complexes, distinct surface electric properties and functions. The analysis of the 77K emission spectra revealed that Mg2+-depletion of the medium caused not only an increased energy flow toward photosystem I in all investigated membranes but also changes in the quenching of the fluorescence, most probably by internal conversion. The results indicated that the macroorganization of the photosynthetic apparatus of mutants at supramolecular level (distribution and segregation of two photosystems in thylakoid membranes) and at supermolecular level (stacking of photosystem II supercomplexes) required different Mg ion concentrations. The data confirmed that the segregation of photosystems and the stacking of thylakoid membranes are two distinct phenomena and elucidated some features of their mechanisms. The segregation is initiated by changes in the lateral microorganization of light harvesting complexes II, their migration (repulsion from photosystem I) and subsequent separation of the two photosystems. Most likely 3D aggregation and formation of macrodomains, containing only photosystem II antenna complexes, play a certain precursory role for the increasing degree of the membrane stacking and the energy coupling between the light harvesting complexes II and the core complexes of photosystem II in the frame of photosystem II supercomplexes.

The Folch-Lees proteolipid induces phase coexistence and transverse reorganization of lateral domains in myelin monolayers

Solvent solubilized myelin membranes spread as monomolecular layers at the air-water interface show a heterogeneous pattern at all surface pressures. In order to asses the role of myelin protein and lipid components in the surface structuring we compared the topography, as seen by Brewster angle microscopy (BAM) and epifluorescence microscopy, of monolayers made from mixtures containing all myelin lipids (except gangliosides) and variable proportions of Folch-Lees proteolipid protein (PLP, the major protein component of myelin). The presence of the single PLP, in the absence of the other myelin proteins, can reproduce the surface pattern of the whole myelin extract films in a concentration-dependant manner. Moreover, a threshold mole fraction of PLP is necessary to induce the lipid-protein component reorganization leading to the appearance of a rigid (gray) phase, acting as a surface skeleton, at low surface pressures and of fractal clusters at high surface pressures. The average size of those clusters is also dependent on the PLP content in the monolayer and on the time elapsed from the moment of film spreading, as they apparently result from an irreversible lateral aggregation process. The transverse rearrangement of the monolayer occurring under compression was different in films with the highest and lowest PLP mole fractions tested.

Segregation of the photosystems in higher plant thylakoids and short- and long-term regulation by a mesoscopic approach

In this paper we consider the relationship between the lateral segregation of photosystems I and II in the grana and characteristics of the short- and long-term regulation in thylakoids following the mesoscopic approach. Our study is thermodynamic; it is based on the Flory-Huggins theory for binary mixtures and the McMillan-Mayer theory of heterogeneous solutions. We demonstrate that state transitions promote rearrangement of photosystems by either favoring their mixing after LHCII phosphorylation or enhancing their segregation after LHCII dephosphorylation. This regulation influences the entire system properties locally. We also demonstrate that the variations of the photosystem ratio promote rearrangement of the photosystems preserving their segregation. This regulation influences the entire system properties globally. The studies presented are another indication of the importance of the segregation of the photosystems in the grana thylakoids of higher plants. Segregation of PSIs and PSIIs is a signature of the spinodal decomposition, which is a fine regulatory mechanism, related to both the short- and long-term adaptations of the photosynthetic apparatus in higher plant thylakoids.