The relative locations of intramembrane fluorescent probes and of the cytosol hemoglobin in erythrocytes, studied by transverse resonance energy transfer

Carlos Gutiérrez-Merino: Synergy of Theory and Experimentation in Biological Membrane Research

Professor Carlos Gutiérrez-Merino, a prominent scientist working in the complex realm of biological membranes, has made significant theoretical and experimental contributions to the field. Contemporaneous with the development of the fluid-mosaic model of Singer and Nicolson, the Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) approach has become an invaluable tool for studying molecular interactions in membranes, providing structural insights on a scale of 1-10 nm and remaining important alongside evolving perspectives on membrane structures. In the last few decades, Gutiérrez-Merino's work has covered multiple facets in the field of FRET, with his contributions producing significant advances in quantitative membrane biology. His more recent experimental work expanded the ground concepts of FRET to high-resolution cell imaging. Commencing in the late 1980s, a series of collaborations between Gutiérrez-Merino and the authors involved research visits and joint investigations focused on the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor and its relation to membrane lipids, fostering a lasting friendship.

Effects of dimyristoylphosphatidylethanol and ethanol on thickness of neuronal membrane lipid bilayers

The aim of this study was to provide a basis for examining the molecular mechanism for the pharmacological action of ethanol. Energy transfer between the surface fluorescent probe 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid and hydrophobic fluorescent probe 1,3-di(1-pyrenyl)propane was used to examine the effect of both dimyristoylphosphatidylethanol (DMPEt) and ethanol on the thickness (D) of the synaptosomal plasma membrane vesicles (SPMV) isolated from the bovine cerebral cortex. The thickness (D) of the intact SPMV was 1.044 +/- 0.008 (arbitrary units, n=5) at 37 degrees C (pH 7.4). Both DMPEt and ethanol decreased the thickness of the SPMV lipid bilayer in a dose-dependent manner with a significant decrease in thickness observed at 5 microM and 25 mM, respectively. It was assumed that both ethanol and DMPEt cause interdigitation in the SPMV lipid bilayers. The effects of ethanol on the neuronal membranes were attributed to its direct and indirect actions. The indirect action of ethanol refers to the action of phosphatidylethanol, which is an ethanol abnormal metabolite, on the neuronal membranes. The decrease in membrane thickness by both DMPEt and ethanol might be responsible for some, but not all of its anesthetic actions.

Use of fluorescence to determine the effects of cholesterol on lipid behavior in sphingomyelin liposomes and erythrocyte membranes

The purpose of this study was to generate the equivalent of a cholesterol/temperature phase map for a biological membrane using fluorescence spectroscopy. The pseudo-phase map was created using human erythrocytes treated with various concentrations of methyl-beta-cyclodextrin to remove defined amounts of cholesterol and a trio of fluorescent probes that assess different membrane properties (laurdan, diphenylhexatriene, and merocyanine 540). Parallel experiments with two-photon microscopy suggested that changes in cellular cholesterol content affected the entire membrane rather than being localized to specific macroscopic domains. The various regions of the composite erythrocyte pseudo-phase map were interpreted using analogous data acquired from multilamellar vesicles that served as simplified models of cholesterol-dependent phases. The vesicles consisted of various concentrations of cholesterol (0 to 50 mol%) with either palmitoyl sphingomyelin, 1:1 dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine and dioleoylphosphatidylcholine, or phospholipid mixtures intended to simulate either the inner or outer leaflet of erythrocyte membranes. Four distinguishable regions were observed in sphingomyelin phase maps corresponding to the traditional solid-ordered and liquid-disordered phases and two types of liquid-ordered behavior. Physical properties were less diverse in the mixed phospholipid vesicles, as expected, based on previous studies. Erythrocytes displayed five regions of different combinations of membrane properties along the phase map. Some of the observations identified similarities between the cells and liquid-ordered behavior observed in the various types of liposomes as well as some interesting differences.

Effects of Chlorpromazine·HCl on the Structural Parameters of Bovine Brain Membranes

Fluorescence probes located in different membrane regions were used to evaluate the effects of chlorpromazine .HCl on structural parameters (transbilayer lateral mobility, annular lipid fluidity, protein distribution, and lipid bilayer thickness) of synaptosomal plasma membrane vesicles (SPMVs) isolated from bovine cerebral cortex. The experimental procedure was based on the selective quenching of 1,3-di(1-pyrenyl)propane (Py-3-Py) by trinitrophenyl groups, radiationless energy transfer from the tryptophan of membrane proteins to Py-3-Py, and energy transfer from Py-3-Py monomers to 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid (ANS). In this study, chlorpromazine .HCl decreased the lateral mobility of Py-3-Py in a concentration dependent-manner, showed a greater ordering effect on the inner monolayer than on the outer monolayer, decreased annular lipid fluidity in a dose dependent-manner, and contracted the membrane lipid bilayer. Furthermore, the drug was found to have a clustering effect on membrane proteins.

Effects of dopamine HCl on structural parameters of bovine brain membranes

Fluorescence probes located in different membrane regions were used to evaluate the effect of dopamine.HCl on the structural parameters (transbilayer lateral mobility, annular lipid fluidity, protein distribution, and thickness of the lipid bilayer) of synaptosomal plasma membrane vesicles (SPMV), which were obtained from the bovine cerebral cortex. An experimental procedure was used based on selective quenching of 1,3-di(1-pyrenyl)propane (Py-3-Py) by trinitrophenyl groups, and radiationless energy transfer from the tryptophan of membrane proteins to Py-3-Py and energy transfer from Py-3-Py monomers to 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid (ANS) was also utilized. Dopamine.HCl increased both the bulk lateral mobility and annular lipid fluidity, and it had a greater fluidizing effect on the inner monolayer than on the outer monolayer. Furthermore, the drug had a clustering effect on membrane proteins.

Resonance energy transfer study of hemoglobin complexes with model phospholipid membranes

By examining the resonance energy transfer between fluorescent probes, embedded in the lipid bilayer (4-(dimethylaminostyryl)-1-methylpiridine, 4-(dimethylaminostyryl)-1-dodecylpiridine, N,N'-bishexamethylenrhodamine, rhodamine 6G) as donors, and the heme group of hemoglobin as acceptor, the structure of the protein complexes with the model membranes composed of phosphatidylcholine and cardiolipin was characterized. Quantitative interpretation of the experimental data was performed in terms of the model of energy transfer in two-dimensional systems, using a set of parameters including the distance of closest approach between donor and acceptor, the vertical separation of donor planes, the acceptor distance from the donor plane and the orientation factor. The limits for the heme distance from the lipid bilayer center and the depth of the protein penetration in the membrane interior were estimated. The results obtained suggest that the depth of hemoglobin insertion into liposomal membranes decreases upon increasing CL content in the lipid bilayer.

Resonance energy transfer study of hemoglobin and cytochrome c complexes with lipids

The complexes of hemoglobin and cytochrome c with liposomes composed of phosphatidylcholine and its mixtures with cardiolipin and cholesterol have been studied by monitoring resonance energy transfer between fluorescent probe 3-methoxybenzanthrone as donor and heme groups of the proteins as acceptors. By analyzing experimental data within the framework of the model of energy transfer in two-dimensional systems, the limits of the range of possible heme positions with respect to lipid bilayer have been assessed. The distance of heme group of hemoglobin from the membrane center was found to increase in the presence of cardiolipin or cholesterol. The results obtained for cytochrome c complexes with cardiolipin-containing model membranes suggest the existence of preferential protein orientation relative to the lipid bilayer, and provide evidence for the protein penetration in the membrane interior.

Theory for establishing proximity relations in biological membranes by excitation energy transfer measurements

In a previous publication (Shaklai et al., 1977a) the present author developed a theory for evaluating proximity relations and surface densities sigma in biological membranes by measurements of excitation energy transfer from a donor attached to a specific site of a membrane protein and an acceptor attached to a specific carbon on a membrane lipid. It was assumed that the protein and lipid are randomly distributed in the plane of the membrane and that the donor and acceptor groups are confined to different planes in the membrane separated by a distance Rp. In this article several aspects of the theory presented in the previous paper are clarified, especially noting that the previous theoretical expressions for the time-dependent and steady state fluorescence intensities assumed that the labeled protein molecule is cylindrically symmetric with the symmetry axis perpendicular to the plane of the membrane and that the donor is positioned on the symmetry axis of the protein. This assumption is also implicitly or explicitly made in subsequent formulations by other investigators. In this article we generalize the theory to include the case where the donor is not on the symmetry axis of the labeled protein. Equations for calculating the time-dependent and steady state fluorescence intensities for this more general case are presented, and methods for applying these theoretical expressions to the analysis of steady state fluorescence intensity data and evaluation of proximity parameters are discussed. It is also shown in this article that the linear relation l/lo = 1 + Kq sigma previously derived for simple analysis of excitation transfer data for the condition rc/Ro 1 can be modified to apply to almost all practical ranges of rc/Ro without much affecting its simplicity in the analysis of experimental data.

Effects of ethanol on structural parameters of rat brain membranes: relationship to genetic differences in ethanol sensitivity

Fluorescent probes located in different membrane regions were used to evaluate effects of ethanol (50 and 100 mM) on structural parameters (protein distribution, fluidity of total and annular lipid, and thickness of the bilayer) of synaptic plasma membranes (SPMs) from brain cortex of High-Alcohol Sensitivity (HAS) and Low-Alcohol Sensitivity (LAS) rats. An experimental procedure based on radiationless energy transfer from tryptophan of membrane proteins to pyrene, 1,3-bis-(1-pyrene)propane(pyr-C3-pyr), or 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH), as well as pyr-C3-pyr monomer-eximer formation and DPH polarization, and energy transfer from pyrene monomers to 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid (ANSA) was utilized. The efficiency of energy transfer from tryptophan to pyrene was sensitive to protein clustering induced in SPMs by concanavalin A. Efficiency of energy transfer from pyrene monomers to ANSA was different for vesicles of dimyristoyl phosphatidyl choline, dipalmitoyl phosphatidyl choline, and distearoyl phosphatidyl choline, consistent with differences in the thickness of these lipid bilayers. Without ethanol, there were no significant differences between the structural parameters of SPMs from HAS and from LAS rats. Addition of ethanol (50 mM) changed protein distribution (increased clustering) only in membranes from HAS rats and had no effect on the structure of membranes from LAS rats. A larger concentration of ethanol (100 mM) changed the fluidity of annular and total lipid in both lines of rats, but changed protein distribution and decreased thickness of the membranes from HAS rats with no effect on these parameters in SPMs from LAS animals.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Fluidity of intact erythrocyte membranes. Correction for fluorescence energy transfer from diphenylhexatriene to hemoglobin

Membranes of intact erythrocytes were labeled by the fluorescent probe 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH) using an improved labeling procedure described previously (Plásek, J. and Jarolím, P. (1987) Gen. Physiol. Biophys. 6, 425-437). The relationship between the steady-state DPH fluorescence anisotropy r and the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration (MCHC) was studied. Fluorescence anisotropy increased with increasing MCHC. A linear dependence of r = 0.0026 (MCHC) + 0.113 was obtained which enabled us to measure the fluidity of intact red cell membranes. Without this correction for fluorescence quenching by hemoglobin, incorrect conclusions about membrane fluidity could be made. This fact is demonstrated in a group of pyruvate kinase deficient patients compared with a group of healthy blood donors.

Tryptophan imaging of membrane proteins

A theoretical analysis of resonance energy transfer between protein tryptophan and the n-(9-anthroyloxy) (AO) fatty acid probes has been carried out to evaluate its potential use in determining the tryptophan distribution in membrane proteins. The Förster theory for two-dimensional energy transfer was formulated to calculate multiple donor (tryptophan) transfer efficiencies to ensembles of AO probes at different depths in the bilayer. The variation of transfer efficiency with AO probe depth is found to be a sensitive function of tryptophan position and the protein radius but not the dipole-dipole orientation factor or the decay heterogeneity of the donor. For single tryptophan-containing proteins the model predicts that the tryptophan position can be determined with a precision of about 2 A. Although for multiple tryptophans there is appreciable deterioration in resolution, it is still possible to determine the essential features of the distribution such as its first two moments. The positions determined by this method are the projections of the tryptophan positions on a plane perpendicular to the membrane surface, since the probes distribute uniformly around the protein. To analyze the data, a Monte Carlo approach has been developed to search for tryptophan distributions compatible with the observed efficiencies and to display the results in terms of a tryptophan density map. It is shown that even for cases in which little is known about the quantum yield distribution, significant information can be determined about the tryptophan spatial distribution.

Energy-transfer study of cytochrome b5 using the anthroyloxy fatty acid membrane probes

Resonance energy transfer was used to study the structure of cytochrome b5 and its nonpolar segment reconstituted into sonicated vesicles of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine. The n-(9-anthroyloxy) (AO) fatty acid probes were added to these vesicles, and energy-transfer measurements were carried out between tryptophan and AO, tryptophan and the heme moiety of cytochrome b5, and AO and heme. Results of these measurements were analyzed by using the methods outlined in the previous paper [Kleinfeld, A. M. (1985) Biochemistry (preceding paper in this issue)]. We find, in agreement with Fleming et al. [Fleming, P. J., Koppel, D. E., Lau, A. L. Y., & Strittmatter, P. (1979) Biochemistry 18, 5458-5464], that the fluorescent tryptophan in both forms of the protein is buried about 20 A from the surface and that most of the fluorescence is associated with a single tryptophan. The results are consistent with the AO probe distance of closest approach to the protein, greater for whole b5 than for the nonpolar peptide. The tryptophan-heme and AO-heme measurements indicate that the heme moiety is about 15 A from the surface of the membrane. The agreement of our results with the previous studies supports the description of tryptophan-AO energy transfer outlined in the preceding paper.

Cytosol-membrane interface of human erythrocytes. A resonance energy transfer study

The resonance energy transfer from donors embedded in the membrane of erythrocytes to the cytosol hemoglobin has been measured by comparing the donors' fluorescence decay in ghosts and in intact cells. A series of n - (9-anthroyloxy) stearic acids (n-AS) (n = 2, 6, 9, 12) and similar probes were used as donors, and their locations within the outer leaflet of the phospholipid bilayer were determined from their average efficiency of energy transfer, <T>. The energy transfer data for several membrane probes were analyzed according to a simple semiempirical model, in which the heme acceptors are assumed to form a semiinfinite continuum beyond a plane, whose normal distance (d) from particular donors may be determined if the heme density in the cytosol boundary layer is known. The hemoglobin concentration in the erythrocytes was varied by suspending the cells in buffers of different ionic strengths. This made it possible to study the ionic strength dependence of the heme concentration averaged over the cell (h(c)), as well as that in the boundary layer (h(b)). Both level off above approximately 600 mosM, as does the ratio h(b)/h(c). By using the maximum heme concentration that can be obtained in osmotically shrunken cells as a limiting value, h(b) is estimated to be 17 mM or less, under physiological conditions; and from the measured <T> for various probes, the distance d was found to range from 40 A for 2-AS to 31 A for 12-AS and 26 A for 9-vinyl anthracene (9-VA). It is concluded that the hydrophobic probe 9-VA is located near the center of the phospholipid bilayer and that the cytosol hemoglobin is in contact with the inner membrane surface, or nearly so. This conclusion is valid for oxy- and deoxy-hemoglobin, and is shown to be independent of several systematic errors that might arise from the simple assumptions of the model used. The steady-state fluorescence anisotropy of the probes was found to decrease as they approach the bilayer's central plane. The methodology developed here may be used to extend studies of cytosol membrane interactions in ghost systems to intact cells, and is useful in the investigation of the morphology of normal and pathological intact erythrocytes.

Hydrogen exchange and the dynamic structure of proteins

In native proteins, buried, labile protons undergo isotope exchange with solvent hydrogens, but the kinetics of exchange are markedly slower than in unfolded polypeptides. This indicates that, whereas buried protein atoms are shielded from solvent, the protein fluctuates around the time average structure and occasionally exposes buried sites to solvent. Generally, hydrogen exchange studies are designed to characterize the nature of the fluctuations between conformational substates, to monitor the shift in conformational equilibria among protein substates due to ligand binding or other factors, or to monitor the major cooperative denaturation transition. In this article, we review the recent reports of hydrogen exchange in proteins, focusing on recent advances in methodology, especially with regard to the implications of the results for the mechanism of hydrogen exchange in folded proteins.