Location of an extrinsic label in the primary and tertiary structure of bacteriorhodopsin

Location of the cyclohexene ring of the chromophore of bacteriorhodopsin by neutron diffraction with selectively deuterated retinal

We report on the location of the cyclohexene ring of the retinylidene chromophore of bacteriorhodopsin projected onto the plane of the membrane. For this purpose, partially deuterated retinal was synthesized containing 11 deuterons at the following positions of the cyclohexene ring: one at C-2, two at C-4, three at C-16, three at C-17, and two at C-18. The partially deuterated retinal was incorporated biosynthetically during growth of the bacteria by using the mutant JW5, which is deficient in the synthesis of retinal. Undeuterated samples were prepared in the same way. Characterization by x-ray diffraction and absorption spectroscopy showed that these samples are identical to native purple membranes as judged by these criteria. A Fourier difference map was calculated from the differences in in-plane diffraction intensities between the deuterated and undeuterated dark-adapted membrane samples. Model calculations showed that the observed difference density had the amplitude expected for a label containing 11 deuterons. At 8.7 A resolution, the map shows one major peak with the center of mass of the deuterated ring in the interior of the molecule between helices 3, 4, 5, and 6. Based on this result and on our previous work on the location of the middle of the polyene chain, we conclude that the COOH-terminal helix G, to which retinal is attached at lysine-216, is either helix 2 or helix 6.

Location of chemically modified lysine 41 in the structure of bacteriorhodopsin by neutron diffraction

Purple membranes were prepared in which bacteriorhodopsin was labeled at lysine 41 with phenylisothiocyanate (PITC) and with perdeuterated PITC. The in-plane position of this small label containing only five deuterons was determined from the differences between the neutron diffraction intensities of the two samples. At 8.7-A resolution the Fourier difference map revealed a well-defined site between helices 3 and 4. This position was confirmed by a refinement procedure in reciprocal space. Model calculations showed that the observed difference density had the right amplitude for the label. Thus it is possible to locate a small group in a large protein structure by replacing as few as five hydrogens by deuterium. The observed location of PITC restricts the number of possibilities for the assignment of helix B in the sequence (to which lysine 41 is attached) to one of the seven helices of the structure. Taking into account the size of the label and the length of the lysine side chain our result excludes helices 1, 2, and 7 as candidates for B.

Recollections of the electron crystallographic heavy atom derivative search of purple membrane: the quest for EM structure determination

The use of multiple isomorphous replacement in protein electron crystallography for phase determination has been systematically studied only for purple membrane, even though the use of heavy atoms or heavy atom clusters has been used on many occasions in electron microscopy for locating domains or subunits in protein assemblies. The background behind the structure determination of bacteriorhodopsin, the protein component of purple membranes, is summarized and an evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of using isomorphous replacement in electron crystallography is discussed.

X-ray diffraction studies of bacteriorhodopsin. Determination of the positions of mercury label at several engineered cysteine residues

The single cysteine-containing bacteriorhodopsin mutants F27C, L100C, T170C, F171C and I222C were labeled with p-chloromercuribenzoic acid, which specifically reacts with sulfhydryl groups. These cysteines should be located at the cytoplasmic ends of the transmembrane helices A, C, F or G. We determined the positions of the bound mercury atoms by X-ray diffraction of purple membrane films, with better than 1 A accuracy. The determined mercury positions were compared with the structural model from cryoelectron microscopy (N. Grigorieff, T. A. Ceska, K. H. Downing, J. M. Baldwin and R. Henderson, J. Mol. Biol. 259, 393-421, 1996). Given that the distance between the mercury and the C alpha atom of the cysteine in the xy plane must be shorter than 4.5 A and that the mercury atom is located at the delta position, the positions obtained for the mercury labels agree with their expected positions from the structural model. The present results give a rationale for detecting structural changes upon illumination as shifts occur in the mercury label position.

Two-dimensional crystallization of Escherichia coli-expressed bacteriorhodopsin and its D96N variant: high resolution structural studies in projection

Highly ordered two-dimensional (2-D) crystals of Escherichia coli-expressed bacteriorhodopsin analog (e-bR) and its D96N variant (e-D96N) reconstituted in Halobacterium halobium lipids have been obtained by starting with the opsin protein purified in the denaturing detergent sodium dodecyl sulfate. These crystals embedded in glucose show electron diffraction in projection to better than 3.0 A at room temperature. This is the first instance that expressed bR or a variant has been crystallized in 2-D arrays showing such high order. The crystal lattice is homologous to that in wild-type bR (w-bR) in purple membranes (PM) and permit high resolution analyses of the structure of the functionally impaired D96N variant. The e-bR crystal is isomorphous to that in PM with an overall averaged fractional change of 12.7% (26-3.6-A resolution) in the projection structure factors. The projection difference Fourier map e-bR-PM at 3.6-A resolution indicates small conformational changes equivalent to movement of approximately < 7 C-atoms distributed within and in the neighborhood of the protein envelope. This result shows that relative to w-bR there are no global structural rearrangements in e-bR at this 3.6 A resolution level. The e-D96N crystal is isomorphous to the e-bR crystal with a smaller (9.2%) overall averaged fractional change in the structure factors. The significant structural differences between e-D96N and e-bR are concentrated at high resolution (5-3.6 A); however, these changes are small as quantified from the 3.6 A resolution e-D96N-e-bR Fourier difference map. The difference map showed no statistically significant peaks or valleys within 5 A in projection from the site of D96 substitution on helix C. Elsewhere within the protein envelope the integrated measure of peaks or valleys was < approximately 3 C-atom equivalents. Thus, our results show that for the isosteric substitution of Asp96 by Asn, the molecular conformation of bR in its ground state is essentially unaltered. Therefore, the known effect of D96N on the slowed M412 decay is not due to ground-state structural perturbations.

Conformation of proline residues in bacteriorhodopsin

Proline, noted as a hydrophilic residue with helix-breaking potential, nevertheless occurs widely in putatively alpha-helical transmembrane segments of many transport proteins. Ligand-activated or enzyme-assisted trans/cis isomerization of an X-proline peptide bond (where X = any amino acid)--a dynamic, reversible event which could alter the orientation of a transmembrane alpha-helix--may provide the molecular basis for a protein channel regulatory process. Further elucidation of such a function requires knowledge of the isomeric status of the X-Pro bonds in native conformations of membrane proteins. We have used 13C nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to examine the conformation of intramembranous X-Pro peptide bonds in biosynthetically-labelled samples of a model transport protein, bacteriorhodopsin (bR) (purple membrane). Spectra of 13C-Tyr-carbonyl labelled bR (in the solvent system CHCl3:CD3OD (1:1) + 0.1 M LiClO4) first established that all 11 bR Tyr residues were sufficiently mobile for their resonances to be detected and resolved, independent of their domain location within the bR sequence. By taking advantage of the known diagnostic chemical shifts of the isomers of Pro-C gamma carbon resonances, spectra of bR labelled with 13C gamma-Pro were then used to demonstrate that all 11 bR X-Pro peptide bonds--including those within the protein's membrane domain (Pro50, Pro91, Pro186)--are in the trans conformation in resting state bR.

Analysis of high-resolution electron diffraction patterns from purple membrane labelled with heavy-atoms

Progress in the structure determination of bacteriorhodopsin, the protein component of purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium has been limited by the lack of three-dimensional phase information between 6 and 3 A resolution. By analogy with X-ray methods, it is possible that heavy-atom labelling of the membrane crystal may provide heavy-atom derivatives that can be used for phasing by the multiple isomorphous replacement method. This paper describes the screening of heavy-atom compounds as potential derivatives, and the evaluation of the data collected from these heavy-atom-labelled membranes. Improvements in the methods for collecting electron diffraction data and analysing and merging the data are presented. Diffraction patterns of purple membrane samples were taken at -120 degrees C to minimize radiation damage. About 30 heavy-atom compounds were tested for use as potential derivatives. The diffraction patterns from labelled membranes were analysed by examining 6.5 A difference Fourier maps. Two heavy-atom compounds were selected for three-dimensional data collection at 3 A resolution. In addition, a full set of native data at -120 degrees C was collected to 2.7 A resolution. The intensity merging, heavy-atom derivative evaluation, heavy-atom refinement and the calculation of phases are presented. Phases are compared to those determined by electron microscope imaging, and limitations of the method are discussed. It is concluded that, with the present accuracy of data collection and the present magnitude of delta F/F available for the derivatives, the phasing power is too small. The phases that are obtained are not sufficiently accurate to provide a reliably interpretable map. It may be possible, however, to use the heavy-atom derivative data in difference Fourier calculations in which the presence of a peak would confirm the phases calculated from a model or obtained by electron microscope imaging.

Observations concerning topology and locations of helix ends of membrane proteins of known structure

Hydropathy plots of amino acid sequences reveal the approximate locations of the transbilayer helices of membrane proteins of known structure and are thus used to predict the helices of proteins of unknown structure. Because the three-dimensional structures of membrane proteins are difficult to obtain, it is important to be able to extract as much information as possible from hydropathy plots. We describe an "augmented" hydropathy plot analysis of the three membrane proteins of known structure, which should be useful for the systematic examination and comparison of membrane proteins of unknown structure. The sliding-window analysis utilizes the floating interfacial hydrophobicity scale [IFH(h)] of Jacobs and White (Jacobs, R.E., White, S. H., 1989. Biochemistry 28:3421-3437) and the reverse-turn (RT) frequencies of Levitt (Levitt, M., 1977, Biochemistry 17:4277-4285). The IFH(h) scale allows one to examine the consequences of different assumptions about the average hydrogen bond status (h = 0 to 1) of polar side chains. Hydrophobicity plots of the three proteins show that (i) the intracellular helix-connecting links and chain ends can be distinguished from the extracellular ones and (ii) the main peaks of hydrophobicity are bounded by minor ones which bracket the helix ends. RT frequency plots show that (iii) the centers of helices are usually very close to wide-window minima of average RT frequency and (iv) helices are always bounded by narrow-window maxima of average RT frequency. The analysis suggests that side-chain hydrogen bonding with membrane components during folding may play a key role in insertion.

High sensitivity electron diffraction analysis. A study of divalent cation binding to purple membrane

A sensitive high-resolution electron diffraction assay for change in structure is described and harnessed to analyze the binding of divalent cations to the purple membrane (PM) of Halobacterium halobium. Low-dose electron diffraction patterns are subject to a matched filter algorithm (Spencer, S. A., and A. A. Kossiakoff. 1980. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 13:563-571). to extract accurate values of reflection intensities. This, coupled with a scheme to account for twinning and specimen tilt in the microscope, yields results that are sensitive enough to rapidly quantitate any structure change in PM brought about by site-directed mutagenesis to the level of less than two carbon atoms. Removal of tightly bound divalent cations (mainly Ca2+ and Mg2+) from PM causes a color change to blue and is accompanied by a severely altered photocycle of the protein bacteriohodopsin (bR), a light-driven proton pump. We characterize the structural changes that occur upon association of 3:1 divalent cation to PM, versus membranes rendered purple by addition of excess Na+. High resolution, low dose electron diffraction data obtained from glucose-embedded samples of Pb2+ and Na+ reconstituted PM preparations at room temperature identify several sites with total occupancy of 2.01 +/- 0.05 Pb2+ equivalents. The color transition as a function of ion concentration for Ca2+ or Mg2+ and Pb2+ are strictly comparable. A (Pb2(+)-Na+) PM Fourier difference map in projection was synthesized at 5 A using the averaged data from several nominally untilted patches corrected for twinning and specimen tilt. We find six major sites located on helices 7, 5, 4, 3, 2 (nomenclature of Engelman et al. 1980. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 77:2023-2027) in close association with bR. These partially occupied sites (0.55-0.24 Pb2+ equivalents) represent preferential sites of binding for divalent cations and complements our earlier result by x-ray diffraction (Katre et al. 1986. Biophys. J. 50:277-284).

Tertiary structure of bacteriorhodopsin. Positions and orientations of helices A and B in the structural map determined by neutron diffraction

Positions and rotations of two helices in the tertiary structure of bacteriorhodopsin have been studied by neutron diffraction using reconstituted, hybrid purple membrane samples. Purple membrane was biosynthetically 2H-labeled at non-exchangeable hydrogen positions of leucine and tryptophan residues. Two chymotryptic fragments were purified, encompassing either the first two or the last five of the seven putative transmembrane segments identified in the amino acid sequence of bacteriorhodopsin. The 2H-labeled fragments, diluted to variable extents with the identical, unlabeled fragment, were mixed with their unlabeled counterpart; bacteriorhodopsin was then renatured and reconstituted. The crystalline purple membrane samples thus obtained contained hybrid bacteriorhodopsin molecules in which certain transmembrane segments had been selectively 2H-labeled to various degrees. Neutron diffraction powder patterns were recorded and analyzed both by calculating difference Fourier maps and by model building. The two analyses yielded consistent results. The first and second transmembrane segments in the sequence correspond to helices 1 and 7 of the three-dimensional structure, respectively. Rotational orientations of these two helices were identified using best fits to the observed diffraction intensities. The data also put restrictions on the position of the third transmembrane segment. These observations are discussed in the context of folding models for bacteriorhodopsin, the environment of the retinal Schiff base, and site-directed mutagenesis experiments.

Topography of surface-exposed amino acids in the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin determined by proteolysis and micro-sequencing

The topography of membrane-surface-exposed amino acids in the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin (BR) was studied. By limited proteolysis of purple membrane with papain or proteinase K, domains were cleaved, separated by SDS-PAGE, and electroblotted onto polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) membranes. Fragments transferred were sequenced in a gas-phase sequencer. Papain cleavage sites at Gly-65, Gly-72, and Gly-231, previously only deduced from the apparent molecular weight of the digestion fragments, could be confirmed by N-terminal micro-sequencing. By proteinase K, cleavage occurred at Gln-3, Phe-71, Gly-72, Tyr-131, Tyr-133, and Ser-226, i.e., in regions previously suggested to be surface-exposed. Additionally, proteinase-K cleavage sites at Thr-121 and Leu-127 were identified, which are sites predicted to be in the alpha-helical membrane-spanning segment D. Our results, especially that the amino acids Gly-122 to Tyr-133 are protruding into the aqueous environment, place new constraints on the amino-acid folding of BR across the purple membrane. The validity of theoretical prediction methods of the secondary structure and polypeptide folding for membrane proteins is challenged. The results on BR show that micro-sequencing of peptides separated by SDS-PAGE and blotted to PVDF can be successfully applied to the study of membrane proteins.

Atomic force microscopy of purple membranes

The surface structure of purple membranes was imaged using an atomic force probe mounted in a scanning tunnelling microscope. One of the two different membrane surfaces showed protruding, disc-shaped features forming an hexagonal lattice with about 6 nm centre to centre spacing. These are identified as the cytoplasmic surfaces of trimers of bacteriorhodopsin molecules and are correlated with the structural information on bacteriorhodopsin obtained from numerous earlier electron microscope and diffraction studies.

Fluorescent labeling of bacteriorhodopsin: implications for helix connections

Purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium was reacted with dansyl (5-dimethylamino-1-naphthalenyl fluorescent labels that have specificity for different protein side chains of bacteriorhodopsin. Dansyl chloride was found to react primarily with Lys-41. Dansyl hydrazine was coupled, with water-soluble carbodiimide, to Glu-74 and/or Asp-85, which was the major modified site after papain-cleavage of the carboxyl-terminal 17 amino acids. Fluorescence energy transfer was used to probe the proximity of the modified sites to the retinal chromophore of bacteriorhodopsin. The dansyl group on Lys-41 was greater than 2.99 nm from retinal, while the dansyl group on Glu-74/Asp-85 was greater than 2.10 nm from retinal. Information available on the location of retinal in the transmembrane profile and probable surface locations of the fluorescent labels was combined with the energy transfer results to calculate distances projected in the plane of the membrane. The projected distances to retinal were 1.64 nm (Lys-41) and 1.65 nm (Gly-74). These measurements, combined with many other labeling experiments that have been reported, restrict the number of likely helix-connection models to only three: EDCABGF, FEDCBAG and FGEABDC (in the nomenclature of Engelman et al. (1980) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 77, 2023-2027).

Amino acid composition of the membrane and aqueous domains of integral membrane proteins

To identify residues which might impart transport capability to the intramembranous regions of transport proteins, we surveyed available data for the 9991 amino acids contained in the aqueous and intramembranous regions of 24 integral membrane proteins: 10 transport (T) proteins and 14 nontransport (NT) proteins. Statistical comparison of percentage occurrence of each amino acid within T and NT samples provided a measure of "typical" composition of T and NT membrane-spanning regions, and showed that the residues partition into membrane and aqueous domains largely in accord with expectation from hydropathy indices. Comparison of aqueous and membrane domain composition between protein categories revealed a statistically similar distribution of residues in aqueous domains, but significant differences in membrane domains: seven residues (Asn, Asp, Gln, Glu, Phe, Pro, Tyr) were preferred in membrane regions of T proteins, and one (Val) was selectively excluded. Chemical and structural considerations suggested that three of these residues--Asn, Tyr, and Pro--are the most likely functional participants in transport processes.

The opsin family of proteins

Images

Cation binding sites on the projected structure of bacteriorhodopsin

Divalent cations are involved in the function of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) as a light-driven proton pump. If cations are removed from purple membranes they become blue. Divalent cations such as Ca2+ or Pb2+ or trivalent ions, can be stoichiometrically titrated back on to these deionized membranes. The color transitions as a function of ion concentration for Ca2+ or Pb2+ are precisely comparable and indicate that approximately three stoichiometric equivalents of cations are required to effect the color transition (Kimura et al., 1984). We found four main partially occupied binding sites for cations at a stoichiometric ratio of 3 Pb2+/bR. We localized the binding sites for Pb2+ using x-ray diffraction of membranes reconstituted with 1, 2, and 3 equivalents of Pb2+ per bR. The site of highest affinity is located on helix 7. At 2 Pb2+/bR, sites on helix 6 and between helix 2 and 3 are occupied. At 3 Pb2+/bR a fourth site above helix 3 is occupied.