Enthalpic and entropic contributions to lipase enantioselectivity

Partially purifiedCarica papayalipase: a versatile biocatalyst for the hydrolytic resolution of (R,S)-2-arylpropionic thioesters in water-saturated organic solvents

With the hydrolytic resolution of (R,S)-naproxen 2,2,2-trifluoroethyl thioesters in water-saturated isooctane as a model system, improvements of the specific lipase activity and thermal stability were found when a crude Carica papaya lipase (CPL) was partially purified and employed as the biocatalyst. The partially purified Carica papaya lipase (PCPL) was furthermore explored as an effective enantioselective biocatalyst for the hydrolytic resolution of (R,S)-profen thioesters in water-saturated organic solvents. The kinetic analysis in water-saturated isooctane indicated that both acyl donor and acyl acceptor have profound influences on the lipase activity, E-value, and enantioselectivity. Inversion of the enantioselectivity from (S)- to (R)-thioester was found for (R,S)-fenoprofen and (R,S)-ketoprofen thioesters that contained a bulky substituent at the meta-position of 2-phenyl moiety of the acyl part. Kinetic constants for the acylation step were furthermore estimated for elucidating the kinetic data and postulating an active site model. The thermodynamic analysis indicated that the enantiomer discrimination was driven by the difference of activation enthalpy (DeltaDeltaH) and that of activation entropy (DeltaDeltaS), yet the latter was dominated for most of the reacting systems. The postulated active site model was supported from the variation of DeltaDeltaH and DeltaDeltaS with the acyl moiety, in which a good linear enthalpy-entropy compensation relationship was also illustrated. A comparison of the performances between Candida rugosa lipase (CRL) and PCPL indicated that PCPL was superior to CRL in terms of the better thermal stability, similar or better lipase activity for the fast-reacting substrate, time-course-stability, and lower enzyme cost.

Tailoring the substrate specificity of secondary alcohol dehydrogenase

Our research with the thermophilic secondary-alcohol dehydrogenase (SADH) from Thermoanaerobacter ethanolicus has provided novel information regarding the physical basis of enzyme substrate specificity and stereospecificity. We demonstrated that oxidation of secondary alcohols catalyzed by T. ethanolicus SADH exhibits temperature-dependent enantiospecificity. In other studies, we found that the structure of co-factor analogs also significantly affects the stereochemistry of the SADH reaction. More recently, we demonstrated that pH can also have a modest effect on SADH enantiospecificity. Organic solvents have also been shown by others to affect the stereochemistry of SADH reactions. We designed and prepared S39T and C295A mutant forms of SADH by site-directed mutagenesis, and we evaluated the effects of the mutations by analysis of the temperature dependence of the enantiomeric ratio (E) for simple chiral alcohols such as 2-butanol. This procedure allows for the determination of the differential Eyring parameters (ΔΔH‡and ΔΔS‡) for the reaction. We demonstrated that this technique is a sensitive method for analysis of the effects of mutation on enzyme stereospecificity. S39T and C295A SADH exhibit significant changes in substrate specificity and stereospecificity consistent with the changes in the volume of the alkyl-binding pockets. Thus, it is possible to alter the substrate specificity and stereospecificity of alcohol dehydrogenase by changing either the reaction medium or the protein structure.Key words: alcohol dehydrogenase, substrate specificity, stereospecificity, temperature dependence, site-directed mutagenesis.

Solvent effect on lipase enantioselectivity. Evidence for the presence of two thermodynamic states

The enantioselectivity of lipase-catalyzed kinetic resolutions has been measured at various temperatures in binary mixtures of solvents. Varying the solvent composition and temperature had a profound effect on the enantiomeric ratio. The values for delta delta H(R-S)(#) and delta delta S(R-S)(#), calculated from the E values measured at various temperatures, were estimated as a function of the solvent composition. By plotting delta delta H(R-S)(#) versus delta delta S(R-S)(#) as a function of the solvent composition, an extreme was observed. The resulting "hairpin-type" enthalpy-entropy compensation plots can be described by assuming the presence of two thermodynamically distinct physical states, displaying different enantioselectivities, that are in equilibrium with one another. Changing the solvent composition results in a change in the equilibrium constant K(eq) for the two states. The intriguing bell-shaped curves of the enantioselectivity versus solvent composition observed for lipase-catalyzed kinetic resolutions can be described assuming a linear correlation for the logarithm of K(eq) and the solvent composition. Thus, a simulation of the two-state model adequately describes the solvent effects found for lipase-catalyzed kinetic resolutions in binary mixtures of solvents and possibly in series of homologous organic solvents.

Directed evolution of enantioselective enzymes for organic chemistry

The production of enantiopure compounds is of steadily increasing importance to the chemical and biotechnological industries. In principal, the application of directed evolution in combination with newly developed screening methods enables the generation of enzymes with improved enantioselectivity. The first and most advanced example relates to a bacterial lipase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. This enzyme was evolved towards a model substrate to yield in a lipase mutant showing > 90% enantiomeric excess as compared to 2% for the wild-type lipase. The creation of enantioselective enzymes by directed evolution will become an important technology in the near future.

Molecular modeling and biocatalysis: explanations, predictions, limitations, and opportunities

Rapid advances in structural biology have revealed the three-dimensional structures of many biocatalysts. Molecular modeling is the tool that links these structures with experimental observations. As a qualitative tool, current modeling methods are extremely useful. They can explain, on a molecular level, unusual features of reactions. They can predict how to increase the selectivity either by substrate modification or by site-directed mutagenesis. Quantitative predictions, for example the degree of enantioselectivity, are still not reliable, however. Modeling is limited also by the availability of three-dimensional structures. Most current modeling involves hydrolases, especially proteases and lipases, but structures for other types of enzymes are starting to appear.