Elevated sulfatide excretion in compound heterozygotes of metachromatic leukodystrophy and ASA-pseudodeficiency allele

The natural history and burden of illness of metachromatic leukodystrophy: a systematic literature review

BACKGROUND

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD; OMIM 250100 and 249900) is a rare lysosomal storage disease caused by deficient arylsulfatase A activity, leading to accumulation of sulfatides in the nervous system. This systematic literature review aimed to explore the effect of MLD on the lives of patients.

METHODS

The Ovid platform was used to search Embase, MEDLINE, and the Cochrane Library for articles related to the natural history, clinical outcomes, and burden of illness of MLD; congress and hand searches were performed using 'metachromatic leukodystrophy' as a keyword. Of the 531 publications identified, 120 were included for data extraction following screening. A subset of findings from studies relating to MLD natural history and burden of illness (n = 108) are presented here.

RESULTS

The mean age at symptom onset was generally 16-18 months for late-infantile MLD and 6-10 years for juvenile MLD. Age at diagnosis and time to diagnosis varied widely. Typically, patients with late-infantile MLD presented predominantly with motor symptoms and developmental delay; patients with juvenile MLD presented with motor, cognitive, and behavioral symptoms; and patients with adult MLD presented with cognitive symptoms and psychiatric and mood disorders. Patients with late-infantile MLD had more rapid decline of motor function over time and lower survival than patients with juvenile MLD. Commonly reported comorbidities/complications included ataxia, epilepsy, gallbladder abnormalities, incontinence, neuropathy, and seizures.

CONCLUSIONS

Epidemiology of MLD by geographic regions, quantitative cognitive data, data on the differences between early- and late-juvenile MLD, and humanistic or economic outcomes were limited. Further studies on clinical, humanistic (i.e., quality of life), and economic outcomes are needed to help inform healthcare decisions for patients with MLD.

Newborn screening in metachromatic leukodystrophy - European consensus-based recommendations on clinical management

INTRODUCTION

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is a rare autosomal recessive lysosomal storage disorder resulting from arylsulfatase A enzyme deficiency, leading to toxic sulfatide accumulation. As a result affected individuals exhibit progressive neurodegeneration. Treatments such as hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) and gene therapy are effective when administered pre-symptomatically. Newborn screening (NBS) for MLD has recently been shown to be technically feasible and is indicated because of available treatment options. However, there is a lack of guidance on how to monitor and manage identified cases. This study aims to establish consensus among international experts in MLD and patient advocates on clinical management for NBS-identified MLD cases.

METHODS

A real-time Delphi procedure using eDELPHI software with 22 experts in MLD was performed. Questions, based on a literature review and workshops, were answered during a seven-week period. Three levels of consensus were defined: A) 100%, B) 75-99%, and C) 50-74% or >75% but >25% neutral votes. Recommendations were categorized by agreement level, from strongly recommended to suggested. Patient advocates participated in discussions and were involved in the final consensus.

RESULTS

The study presents 57 statements guiding clinical management of NBS-identified MLD patients. Key recommendations include timely communication by MLD experts with identified families, treating early-onset MLD with gene therapy and late-onset MLD with HSCT, as well as pre-treatment monitoring schemes. Specific knowledge gaps were identified, urging prioritized research for future evidence-based guidelines.

DISCUSSION

Consensus-based recommendations for NBS in MLD will enhance harmonized management and facilitate integration in national screening programs. Structured data collection and monitoring of screening programs are crucial for evidence generation and future guideline development. Involving patient representatives in the development of recommendations seems essential for NBS programs.

Extremely low arylsulfatase A enzyme activity does not necessarily cause symptoms: A long-term follow-up and review of the literature

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is an autosomal recessive lysosomal storage disease caused by deficiency of arylsulfatase A (ARSA). Heterozygous carriers of disease-causing variants and individuals harbouring pseudodeficiency alleles in the ARSA gene exhibit reduced ARSA activity. In the context of these genotypes, low ARSA activity has been suggested to lead to an atypical form of MLD or other neurological abnormalities, but data are limited. The aim of our study was to analyse the impact of low ARSA activity in two subjects who are heterozygous for the ARSA pseudodeficiency allele and a disease-causing variant. Biochemical testing included ARSA activity measurements and urinary sulfatide analysis. Biochemical data of a large cohort of MLD patients, heterozygotes, pseudodeficient individuals and healthy controls were analysed. MRI was performed at 3T using T1- and T2-weighted sequences and MR spectroscopy. We present two long-term follow-ups who are heterozygous for the ARSA pseudodeficiency allele and a disease-causing variant in the ARSA gene in cis. The two related index cases exhibit markedly reduced ARSA activity compared to controls and heterozygous carriers. The neurological evaluation and MRI do not reveal any abnormalities. Our data underline that extremely low enzyme activity due to a pseudodeficiency allele and a disease-causing variant in the ARSA gene even in cis does not lead to clinical symptoms or pre-symptomatic MRI changes suspicious for MLD. The review of literature corroborates that any association of low ARSA activity with disease features remains questionable. It seems important to combine the measurement of ARSA activity with elevated sulfatide as well as genetic testing, as done in current newborn screening approaches. Heterozygosity for metachromatic leukodystrophy and an arylsulfatase A pseudodeficiency allele does not cause neurological or neuropsychiatric features.

Comprehensive clinical, biochemical, radiological and genetic analysis of 28 Turkish cases with suspected metachromatic leukodystrophy and their relatives

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is a glycosphingolipid storage disease caused by deficiency of the lysosomal enzyme arylsulfatase A (ASA) or its activator protein saposin B. MLD can affect all age groups in severity varying from a severe fatal form to milder adult onset forms. Diagnosis is usually made by measuring leukocyte ASA activity. However, this test can give false negative or false positive laboratory results due to pseudodeficiency of ASA and saposin B deficiency, respectively. Therefore, we aimed to evaluate patients with suspected MLD in a Turkish population by comprehensive clinical, biochemical, radiological, and genetic analyses for molecular and phenotypic characterization. We analyzed 28 suspected MLD patients and 41 relatives from 24 families. ASA activity was found to be decreased in 21 of 28 patients. Sixteen patients were diagnosed as MLD (11 late infantile, 2 juvenile and 3 adult types), 2 MSD, 2 pseudodeficiency (PD) and the remaining 8 patients were diagnosed as having other leukodystrophies. Enzyme analysis showed that the age of onset of MLD did not correlate with residual ASA activity. Sequence analysis showed 11 mutations in ARSA, of which 4 were novel (p.Trp195GlyfsTer5, p.Gly298Asp, p.Arg301Leu, and p.Gly311Asp), and 2 mutations in SUMF1 causing multiple sulfatase deficiency, and confirmed the diagnosis of MLD in 2 presymptomatic relatives. All individuals with confirmed mutations had low ASA activity and urinary sulfatide excretion. Intra- and inter-familial variability was high for the same ARSA missense genotypes, indicating the contribution of other factors to disease expression. Imaging findings were evaluated through a modified brain MRI scoring system which indicated patients with protein-truncating mutations had more severe MRI findings and late-infantile disease onset. MRI findings were not specific for the diagnosis. Anti-sulfatide IgM was similar to control subjects, and IgG, elevated in multiple sulfatase deficiency. In conclusion, the knowledge on the biochemical, clinical and genetic basis of MLD was expanded, a modified diagnostic laboratory algorithm for MLD based on integrated evaluation of ASA activity, urinary sulfatide excretion and genetic tests was devised.

Contribution of tandem mass spectrometry to the diagnosis of lysosomal storage disorders

Tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) is a highly sensitive and specific technique. Thanks to the development of triple quadrupole analyzers, it is becoming more widely used in laboratories working in the field of inborn errors of metabolism. We review here the state of the art of this technique applied to the diagnosis of lysosomal storage disorders (LSDs) and how MS/MS has changed the diagnostic rationale in recent years. This fine technology brings more sensitive, specific, and reliable methods than the previous biochemical ones for the analysis of urinary glycosaminoglycans, oligosaccharides, and sialic acid. In sphingolipidoses, the quantification of urinary sphingolipids (globotriaosylceramide, sulfatides) is possible. The measurement of new plasmatic biomarkers such as oxysterols, bile acids, and lysosphingolipids allows the screening of many sphingolipidoses and related disorders (Niemann-Pick type C), replacing tedious biochemical techniques. Applied to amniotic fluid, a more reliable prenatal diagnosis or screening of LSDs is now available for fetuses presenting with antenatal manifestations. Applied to enzyme measurements, it allows high throughput assays for the screening of large populations, even newborn screening. The advent of this new method can modify the diagnostic rationale behind LSDs.

A homozygote for the c.459+1G>A mutation in the ARSA gene presents with cerebellar ataxia as the only first clinical sign of metachromatic leukodystrophy

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is a rare lysosomal disorder caused by deficient activity of arylsulfatase A or the lack of saposin B, which results in the accumulation of sulfatide in the oligodendrocytes and in the Schwann cells. Three main clinical types of MLD can be distinguished according to the age of onset and the dynamics of clinical outcome: late infantile, juvenile, and adult. We report on a case of late infantile MLD presenting with cerebellar ataxia as the only first clinical sign preceding even changes in white matter visible in MR imaging. The diagnosis was made on the basis of successive MRI, characteristic of demyelination, which developed in the course of the disease, and on the results of the following biochemical and molecular analyses. Very low residual activity of arylsulfatase A was demonstrated in blood leukocytes and the patient was a homozygote for a common mutation c.459+1G>A in the ARSA gene. Since cerebellar ataxia is a relatively common but unspecific neurological symptom in toddlers, it is recommended that MLD be considered as part of the differential diagnosis even if the initial neuroimaging studies are normal and ataxia is the only clinical symptom of the disease.

Biochemical profiling to predict disease severity in metachromatic leukodystrophy

Metachromatic leukodystrophy is a neurodegenerative disease that is characterized by a deficiency of arylsulfatase A, resulting in the accumulation of sulfatide and other lipids in the lysosomal network of affected cells. Accumulation of sulfatide in the nervous system leads to severe impairment of neurological function with a fatal outcome. Prognosis is often poor unless treatment is carried out before the onset of clinical symptoms. Pre-symptomatic detection of affected individuals may be possible with the introduction of newborn screening programs. The ability to accurately predict clinical phenotype and rate of disease progression in asymptomatic individuals will be essential to assist selection of the most appropriate treatment strategy. Biochemical profiling, incorporating the determination of residual enzyme protein/activity using immune-based assays, and metabolite profiling using electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry, was performed on urine and cultured skin fibroblasts from a cohort of patients representing the clinical spectrum of metachromatic leukodystrophy and on unaffected controls. Residual enzyme protein/activity in fibroblasts was able to differentiate unaffected controls, arylsulfatase A pseudo-deficient individuals, pseudo-deficient compound heterozygotes and affected patients. Metachromatic leukodystrophy phenotypes were distinguished by quantification of sulfatide and other secondarily altered lipids in urine and skin fibroblasts; this enabled further differentiation of the late-infantile form of the disorder from the juvenile and adult forms. Prediction of the rate of disease progression for metachromatic leukodystrophy requires a combination of information on genotype, residual arylsulfatase A protein and activity and the measurement of sulfatide and other lipids in urine and cultured skin fibroblasts.

Metachromatic leukodystrophy - mutation analysis provides further evidence of genotype-phenotype correlation

Metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) is a rare lysosomal storage disorder resulting from the inherited deficiency of the arylsulfatase A (ARSA) enzyme. Currently, no valid therapeutic options are available for affected patients. A thorough knowledge of disease progression in its diverse clinical variants, together with the identification of reliable prognostic factors, could be instrumental in accurate patient selection for new upcoming therapeutic opportunities, such as enzyme replacement and gene therapy. The described correlation between genotype and clinical presentation proved helpful in predicting patient's prognosis, only in the minority of MLD patients harboring common mutations. Molecular characterization of a cohort of 26 MLD patients allowed us to identify 18 mutations, excluding the common 0 and R alleles, 10 of which are rare and 8 are novel. By categorizing the rare mutations, we were able to confirm a correlation between ARSA gene mutations, age at onset and patterns of disease progression, not only in those patients bearing common mutations, but also in those carrying rare mutant alleles. Moreover, in the case of absent or delayed molecular diagnosis, or of newly identified mutations, the involvement of peripheral nervous system from disease onset proved to be a sensitive prognostic marker predicting a severe progression.

Synthetic sulfogalactosylceramide (sulfatide) and its use for the mass spectrometric quantitative urinary determination in metachromatic leukodystrophies

3-O-Sulfogalactosylceramides (sulfatides) accumulate in the genetic disease metachromatic leukodystrophy which is due to a defect in the catabolic enzyme, arylsulfatase A. Clinical diagnosis is usually confirmed by in vitro enzymatic deficiency of arylsulfatase A activity. The diagnosis may be complicated because of arylsulfatase A pseudo-deficiencies and another cause of MLD, sphingolipid activator B deficiency. As large quantities of sulfatides can be found in the urine in this disease, sulfatiduria appears as an extremely useful test. As recently enzyme replacement is underway, the quantitative determination, using an internal standard, appears particularly useful as a follow-up. Thus a non-physiological sulfatide was synthesized for this purpose, i.e. 3-O-sulfo-beta-D-C17 galactosylceramide (3-O-Sulfo-D: -Galactosyl-beta1'-->1-N-Heptadecanoyl-D-erythro-Sphingosine). It has been prepared through condensation of an azidosphingosine derivative with a protected D-galactopyranosyltrichloroacetimidate. Reduction of the azide was followed by acylation of a C-17 fatty acid. The key step was achieved by selective sulfation of the desired hydroxyl group on the sugar residue of the galactosylceramide using the stannylene methodology to give a 3'-sulfated beta-galactosyl C-17 ceramide.

Mutations c.459+1G>A and p.P426L in the ARSA gene: prevalence in metachromatic leukodystrophy patients from European countries

In this multicentre study, we examined the prevalence of two mutations in the arylsulfatase A (ARSA) gene, i.e., c.459+1G>A and p.P426L, in 384 unrelated European patients presenting with different types of metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD). In total, c.459+1G>A was found 194 times among the 768 investigated ARSA alleles (25%), whereas p.P426L was identified 143 times (18.6%). Thus, these two mutations accounted for 43.8% of investigated MLD alleles. Mutation c.459+1G>A was most frequent in late-infantile MLD patients (40%), while p.P426L was most frequent in adults (42.5%), which is consistent with earlier observations, although p.P426L was also found in a few late-infantile patients (0.9%), and c.459+1G>A was present in some adults (9%). Mutation c.459+1G>A is more frequent in countries situated at the western edges of Europe, i.e., in Great Britain and Portugal, and also in Belgium, Switzerland, and Italy, which is visible as a strand ranging from North to South, and additionally in Czech and Slovak Republics. Mutation p.P426L is most prevalent in countries assembled in a cluster containing the Netherlands, Germany, and Austria. In other Central European countries, the frequency of both c.459+1G>A and p.P426L ranges from 8 to 37.5%. Our study has confirmed that c.459+1G>A and p.P426L are the most frequently found MLD-causing mutations in Europe. The data about their prevalence reflect the population variability in Europe.

Investigations of micro-organic brain damage (MOBD) in heterozygotes of metachromatic leukodystrophy

Potential damage of central and peripheral nervous system expressed as micro-organic brain damage (MOBD) was investigated in 27 unrelated heterozygotes with metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD). Arylsulfatase A (ARSA) was determined in peripheral blood leukocytes and sulfatide excretion was estimated in 24-hour urine collections. Genomic DNA was analyzed for the ARSA pseudodeficiency (PD) allele by a PCR method. Clinical investigations included examination of hyper-reflexia, Babinski reflex, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, Benton test, evoked potentials, and nerve conduction velocity (NCV). In our study, a higher incidence of evident or possible micro-organic brain damage was observed in true MLD/PD and MLD heterozygotes (NO/MLD, where NO means the wild allele) than in controls. On the basis of the Benton test, MOBD was suggested or indicated in 67% of MLD heterozygotes, 50% of MLD/PD heterozygotes, and 26% of controls. In our small group of carriers with MLD and PD mutations, persons NO/MLD(PD) with one wild-type allele did not show MOBD and displayed higher ARSA/beta-galactosidase ratios, unlike true MLD/PD compound heterozygotes who carry MLD-causing mutation in one allele and the ARSA-PD polymorphism in the second. Theoretically, this is a shift from autosomal recessive to autosomal dominant-like inheritance, especially when one cannot exclude the influence of polymorphisms (like ARSA-PD) in the wild allele. Since all psychological tests were age-matched, it can be assumed that the MOBD observed in MLD carriers does not have a progressive character unlike in MLD patients. However, it should be mentioned that MOBD appears to have no overt clinical consequences.

Update on genetic disorders affecting white matter

The classification of diseases affecting white matter has changed dramatically with the use of magnetic resonance imaging. Classical leukodystrophies, such as metachromatic leukodystrophy and Krabbe's disease, account for only a small number of inherited diseases that affect white matter. Magnetic resonance imaging has clarified genetic disorders that result in white matter changes or leukoencephalopathies. The term leukoencephalopathy is used to reflect the broader number of diseases that may cause as either primary or secondary changes in myelin development. This review attempts to categorize white matter disorders into classes such as lipid, myelin protein, organic acids, and defects in energy metabolism, in addition to other causes.

Determination of urinary sulfatides and other lipids by combination of reversed-phase and thin-layer chromatographies

A fast and simple method for determination of sulfatides in the urine of patients with metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD, arylsulfatase A deficiency) has been developed. The procedure consists of two steps: extraction of total urinary lipids by reversed-phase chromatography and their HPTLC separation. Two types of sorbents based on different matrixes were compared, of which the hydroxyethyl methacrylate C-18 type sorbent was found to be superior. Twenty-milliliter aliquots of urine are sufficient for the analysis. The technique is appropriate for simultaneous qualitative identification and semiquantitative densitometric determination and is suitable for routine work. The amount of sulfatides is expressed in relation to sphingomyelin, which copurifies with sulfatides and better reflects the level of membrane lipids in urine than commonly used parameters (creatinine, urine volume, etc.). The ranges were found to be 0.15-0.68 nmol sulfatide/nmol sphingomyelin for control individuals and 3.5-27.2 nmol sulfatide/nmol sphingomyelin for MLD patients. The excretion of sulfatides is pathonognomic for true MLD (due to the accumulation in kidney) and therefore its analysis is important for evaluation of suspected MLD cases including clinically and enzymatically atypical cases. The method is also useful as a complementary analysis for other lipidoses with high excretion of sphingolipids in urine (e.g., Fabry disease).