Topographical reliability of mesio-temporal sources of interictal spikes in temporal lobe epilepsy

Localizing hidden Interictal Epileptiform Discharges with simultaneous intracerebral and scalp high-density EEG recordings

BACKGROUND

Scalp EEG is one of the main tools in the clinical evaluation of epilepsy. In some cases intracranial Interictal Epileptiform Discharges (IEDs) are not visible from the scalp. Recent studies have shown the feasibility of revealing them in the EEG if their timings are extracted from simultaneous intracranial recordings, but their potential for the localization of the epileptogenic zone is not yet well defined.

NEW METHOD

We recorded simultaneous high-density EEG (HD-EEG) and stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) during interictal periods in 8 patients affected by drug-resistant focal epilepsy. We identified IEDs in the SEEG and systematically analyzed the time-locked signals on the EEG by means of evoked potentials, topographical analysis and Electrical Source Imaging (ESI). The dataset has been standardized and is being publicly shared.

RESULTS

Our results showed that IEDs that were not clearly visible at single-trials could be uncovered by averaging, in line with previous reports. They also showed that their topographical voltage distributions matched the position of the SEEG electrode where IEDs had been identified, and that ESI techniques can reconstruct it with an accuracy of ∼2 cm. Finally, the present dataset provides a reference to test the accuracy of different methods and parameters.

COMPARISON WITH EXISTING METHODS

Our study is the first to systematically compare ESI methods on simultaneously recorded IEDs, and to share a public resource with in-vivo data for their evaluation.

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous HD-EEG and SEEG recordings can unveil hidden IEDs whose origins can be reconstructed using topographical and ESI analyses, but results depend on the selected methods and parameters.

The network is more important than the node: stereo-EEG evidence of neurocognitive networks in epilepsy

Introduction

Neuropsychological assessment forms an integral part of the presurgical evaluation for patients with medically refractory focal epilepsy. Our understanding of cognitive impairment in epilepsy is based on seminal lesional studies that have demonstrated important structure-function relationships within the brain. However, a growing body of literature demonstrating heterogeneity in the cognitive profiles of patients with focal epilepsy (e.g., temporal lobe epilepsy; TLE) has led researchers to speculate that cognition may be impacted by regions outside the seizure onset zone, such as those involved in the interictal or "irritative" network.

Methods

Neuropsychological data from 48 patients who underwent stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) monitoring between 2012 and 2023 were reviewed. Patients were categorized based on the site of seizure onset, as well as their irritative network, to determine the impact of wider network activity on cognition. Neuropsychological data were compared with normative standards (i.e., z = 0), and between groups.

Results

There were very few distinguishing cognitive features between patients when categorized based purely on the seizure onset zone (i.e., frontal lobe vs. temporal lobe epilepsy). In contrast, patients with localized irritative networks (i.e., frontal or temporal interictal epileptiform discharges [IEDs]) demonstrated more circumscribed profiles of impairment compared with those demonstrating wider irritative networks (i.e., frontotemporal IEDs). Furthermore, the directionality of propagation within the irritative network was found to influence the manifestations of cognitive impairment.

Discussion

The findings suggest that neuropsychological assessment is sensitive to network activity beyond the site of seizure onset. As such, an overly focal interpretation may not accurately reflect the distribution of the underlying pathology. This has important implications for presurgical work-up in epilepsy, as well as subsequent surgical outcomes.

Semiology, EEG, and neuroimaging findings in temporal lobe epilepsies

Temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) is the most common type of focal epilepsy. First descriptions of TLE date back in time and detailed portraits of epileptic seizures of temporal origin can be found in early medical reports as well as in the works of various artists and dramatists. Depending on the seizure onset zone, several subtypes of TLE have been identified, each one associated with peculiar ictal semiology. TLE can result from multiple etiological causes, ranging from genetic to lesional ones. While the diagnosis of TLE relies on detailed analysis of clinical as well as electroencephalographic (EEG) features, the lesions responsible for seizure generation can be highlighted by multiple brain imaging modalities or, in selected cases, by genetic investigations. TLE is the most common cause of refractory epilepsy and despite the great advances in diagnostic tools, no lesion is found in around one-third of patients. Surgical treatment is a safe and effective option, requiring presurgical investigations to accurately identify the seizure onset zone (SOZ). In selected cases, presurgical investigations need intracerebral investigations (such as stereoelectroencephalography) or dedicated metabolic imaging techniques (interictal PET and ictal SPECT) to correctly identify the brain structures to be removed.

Automated electrical source imaging with scalp EEG to define the insular irritative zone: Comparison with simultaneous intracranial EEG

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the accuracy of automatedinterictallow-density electrical source imaging (LD-ESI) to define the insular irritative zone (IZ) by comparing the simultaneous interictal ESI localization with the SEEG interictal activity.

METHODS

Long-term simultaneous scalp electroencephalography (EEG) and stereo-EEG (SEEG) with at least one depth electrode exploring the operculo-insular region(s) were analyzed. Automated interictal ESI was performed on the scalp EEG using standardized low-resolution brain electromagnetic tomography (sLORETA) and individual head models. A two-step analysis was performed: i) sublobar concordance betweencluster-based ESI localization and SEEG-based IZ; ii) time-locked ESI-/SEEG analysis. Diagnostic accuracy values were calculated using SEEG as reference standard. Subgroup analysis wascarried out, based onthe involvement of insular contacts in the seizure onset and patterns of insular interictal activity.

RESULTS

Thirty patients were included in the study. ESI showed an overall accuracy of 53% (C.I. 29-76%). Sensitivity and specificity were calculated as 53% (C.I. 29-76%), 55% (C.I. 23-83%) respectively. Higher accuracy was found in patients with frequent and dominant interictal insular spikes.

CONCLUSIONS

LD-ESI defines with good accuracy the insular implication in the IZ, which is not possible with classical interictalscalpEEG interpretation.

SIGNIFICANCE

Automated LD-ESI may be a valuable additional tool to characterize the epileptogenic zone in epilepsies with suspected insular involvement.

Frequency-specific network activity predicts bradykinesia severity in Parkinson's disease

OBJECTIVE

Bradykinesia has been associated with beta and gamma band interactions in the basal ganglia-thalamo-cortical circuit in Parkinson's disease. In this present cross-sectional study, we aimed to search for neural networks with electroencephalography whose frequency-specific actions may predict bradykinesia.

METHODS

Twenty Parkinsonian patients treated with bilateral subthalamic stimulation were first prescreened while we selected four levels of contralateral stimulation (0: OFF, 1-3: decreasing symptoms to ON state) individually, based on kinematics. In the screening period, we performed 64-channel electroencephalography measurements simultaneously with electromyography and motion detection during a resting state, finger tapping, hand grasping tasks, and pronation-supination of the arm, with the four levels of contralateral stimulation. We analyzed spectral power at the low (13-20 Hz) and high (21-30 Hz) beta frequency bands and low (31-60 Hz) and high (61-100 Hz) gamma frequency bands using the dynamic imaging of coherent sources. Structural equation modelling estimated causal relationships between the slope of changes in network beta and gamma activities and the slope of changes in bradykinesia measures.

RESULTS

Activity in different subnetworks, including predominantly the primary motor and premotor cortex, the subthalamic nucleus predicted the slopes in amplitude and speed while switching between stimulation levels. These subnetwork dynamics on their preferred frequencies predicted distinct types and parameters of the movement only on the contralateral side.

DISCUSSION

Concurrent subnetworks affected in bradykinesia and their activity changes in the different frequency bands are specific to the type and parameters of the movement; and the primary motor and premotor cortex are common nodes.

Increased delta power as a scalp marker of epileptic activity: a simultaneous scalp and intracranial electroencephalography study

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The purpose was to evaluate whether intracranial interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs) that are not visible on the scalp are associated with changes in the frequency spectrum on scalp electroencephalograms (EEGs).

METHODS

Simultaneous scalp high-density EEG and intracranial EEG recordings were recorded in nine patients undergoing pre-surgical invasive recordings for pharmaco-resistant temporal lobe epilepsy. Epochs with hippocampal IED visible on intracranial EEG (ic-IED) but not on scalp EEG were selected, as well as control epochs without ic-IED. Welch's power spectral density was computed for each scalp electrode and for each subject; the power spectral density was further averaged across the canonical frequency bands and compared between the two conditions with and without ic-IED. For each patient the peak frequency in the delta band (the significantly strongest frequency band in all patients) was determined during periods of ic-IED. The five electrodes showing strongest power at the peak frequency were also determined.

RESULTS

It was found that intracranial IEDs are associated with an increase in delta power on scalp EEGs, in particular at a frequency ≥1.4 Hz. Electrodes showing slow frequency power changes associated with IEDs were consistent with the hemispheric lateralization of IEDs. Electrodes with maximum power of slow activity were not limited to temporal regions but also involved frontal (bilateral or unilateral) regions.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with a clinical picture suggestive of temporal lobe epilepsy, the presence of delta slowing ≥1.4 Hz in anterior temporal regions can represent a scalp marker of hippocampal IEDs. To our best knowledge this is the first study that demonstrates the co-occurrence of ic-IED and increased delta power.

Do Spike Domain Analysis Interictally Correlate With the Ictal Patterns in Temporal Lobe Epilepsy?

PURPOSE

To study if one can conceptualize the scalp ictal onset pattern through analysis of interictal spike domain analysis in temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE).

METHODS

Seventy-four patients with unilateral mesial temporal sclerosis (MTS) were categorized into "type A" interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs) with negativity over infero-lateral scalp electrodes over temporal region and contralateral central region showing positivity; all IEDs other than type A were categorized as type B. The ictal electrographic patterns was termed "focal" when confined to side of MTS, was "regional" when lateralized to the ipsilateral hemisphere; "diffuse" if nonlateralized/localized; and ictal onset contralateral to MTS termed as "discordant."

RESULTS

A total of 377 seizures and 5,476 spikes were studied. These were divided into four types: (1) type A IEDs ipsilateral to MTS (44 patients), (2) type A IEDs bitemporally (16 patients), (3) type A IEDs contralaterally (7 patients) and type B IEDs ipsilaterally, and (4) bilateral type B IEDs (7 patients). The ictal pattern was either focal or regional in 51 of 60 patients (85%) with type A IEDs; it was "diffuse" in 9 patients (15%). Diffuse ictal onset was seen in 12 of 14 (86%) with either ipsilateral/bitemporal type B IEDs. Ictal onset on the opposite hemisphere was noted in 2 (14%).

CONCLUSIONS

Type A IEDs signify a focal ictal onset and type B IEDs suggest a diffuse ictal onset in patients with MTS on one side.

SIGNIFICANCE

Interictal spike domain analysis helps predicting ictal patterns in temporal lobe epilepsy.

Fast periodic visual stimulation to highlight the relationship between human intracerebral recordings and scalp electroencephalography

Despite being of primary importance for fundamental research and clinical studies, the relationship between local neural population activity and scalp electroencephalography (EEG) in humans remains largely unknown. Here we report simultaneous scalp and intracerebral EEG responses to face stimuli in a unique epileptic patient implanted with 27 intracerebral recording contacts in the right occipitotemporal cortex. The patient was shown images of faces appearing at a frequency of 6 Hz, which elicits neural responses at this exact frequency. Response quantification at this frequency allowed to objectively relate the neural activity measured inside and outside the brain. The patient exhibited typical 6 Hz responses on the scalp at the right occipitotemporal sites. Moreover, there was a clear spatial correspondence between these scalp responses and intracerebral signals in the right lateral inferior occipital gyrus, both in amplitude and in phase. Nevertheless, the signal measured on the scalp and inside the brain at nearby locations showed a 10-fold difference in amplitude due to electrical insulation from the head. To further quantify the relationship between the scalp and intracerebral recordings, we used an approach correlating time-varying signals at the stimulation frequency across scalp and intracerebral channels. This analysis revealed a focused and right-lateralized correspondence between the scalp and intracerebral recordings that were specific to the face stimulation is more broadly distributed in various control situations. These results demonstrate the interest of a frequency tagging approach in characterizing the electrical propagation from brain sources to scalp EEG sensors and in identifying the cortical sources of brain functions from these recordings.

Magnetoencephalography resting state connectivity patterns as indicatives of surgical outcome in epilepsy patients

OBJECTIVE

Focal epilepsy is a disorder affecting several brain networks; however, epilepsy surgery usually targets a restricted region, the so-called epileptic focus. There is a growing interest in embedding resting state (RS) connectivity analysis into pre-surgical workup.

APPROACH

In this retrospective study, we analyzed Magnetoencephalography (MEG) long-range RS functional connectivity patterns in patients with drug-resistant focal epilepsy. MEG recorded prior to surgery from seven seizure-free (Engel Ia) and five non seizure-free (Engel III or IV) patients were analyzed (minimum 2-years post-surgical follow-up). MEG segments without any detectable epileptic activity were source localized using wavelet-based Maximum Entropy on the Mean method. Amplitude envelope correlation in the theta (4-8 Hz), alpha (8-13 Hz), and beta (13-26 Hz) bands were used for assessing connectivity.

MAIN RESULTS

For seizure-free patients, we found an isolated epileptic network characterized by weaker connections between the brain region where interictal epileptic discharges (IED) are generated and the rest of the cortex, when compared to connectivity between the corresponding contralateral homologous region and the rest of the cortex. Contrarily, non seizure-free patients exhibited a widespread RS epileptic network characterized by stronger connectivity between the IED generator and the rest of the cortex, in comparison to the contralateral region and the cortex. Differences between the two seizure outcome groups concerned mainly distant long-range connections and were found in the alpha-band.

SIGNIFICANCE

Importantly, these connectivity patterns suggest specific mechanisms describing the underlying organization of the epileptic network and were detectable at the individual patient level, supporting the prospect use of MEG connectivity patterns in epilepsy to predict post-surgical seizure outcome.

Deep brain activities can be detected with magnetoencephalography

The hippocampus and amygdala are key brain structures of the medial temporal lobe, involved in cognitive and emotional processes as well as pathological states such as epilepsy. Despite their importance, it is still unclear whether their  neural activity can be recorded non-invasively. Here, using simultaneous intracerebral and magnetoencephalography (MEG) recordings in patients with focal drug-resistant epilepsy, we demonstrate a direct contribution of amygdala and hippocampal activity to surface MEG recordings. In particular, a method of blind source separation, independent component analysis, enabled activity arising from large neocortical networks to be disentangled from that of deeper structures, whose amplitude at the surface was small but significant. This finding is highly relevant for our understanding of hippocampal and amygdala brain activity as it implies that their activity could potentially be measured non-invasively.

Focal epilepsies and focal disorders

Electroencephalographic (EEG) investigations are crucial in the diagnosis and management of patients with focal epilepsies. EEG may reveal different interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs: abnormal spikes, sharp waves). The EEG visibility of a spike depends on the surface area of cortex involved (>10cm²) and the brain localization of cortical generators. Regions generating IEDs (defining the "irritative zone") are not necessarily equivalent to the seizure onset zone. Focal seizures are dynamic processes originating from one or several brain regions (that generate fast oscillations and are called the epileptogenic zone) before spreading to other structures (that generate lower frequency oscillations and are called the propagation zone). Several factors limit the expression of seizures on scalp EEG, such as the area involved, degree of synchronization, and depth of the cortical generators. Different scalp EEG seizure onset patterns may be observed: fast discharge, background flattening, rhythmic spikes, sinusoidal discharge, or sharp activity. However, to a large extent EEG changes are linked to seizure propagation. Finally, in the context of presurgical evaluation, the combination of interictal and ictal EEG features is crucial to provide an optimal hypothesis concerning the epileptogenic zone.

Evidence-based source modeling of nociceptive cortical responses: A direct comparison of scalp and intracranial activity in humans

BACKGROUND

Source modeling of EEG traditionally relies on interplay between physiological hypotheses and mathematical estimates. We propose to optimize the process by using evidence gathered from brain imaging and intracortical recordings.

METHODS

We recorded laser-evoked potentials in 18 healthy participants, using high-density EEG. Brain sources were modeled during the first second poststimulus, constraining their initial position to regions where nociceptive-related activity has been ascertained by intracranial EEG. These comprised the two posterior operculo-insular regions, primary sensorimotor, posterior parietal, anterior cingulate/supplementary motor (ACC/SMA), bilateral frontal/anterior insular, and posterior cingulate (PCC) cortices.

RESULTS

The model yielded an average goodness of fit of 91% for individual and 95.8% for grand-average data. When compared with intracranial recordings from 27 human subjects, no significant difference in peak latencies was observed between modeled and intracranial data for 5 of the 6 assessable regions. Morphological match was excellent for operculo-insular, frontal, ACC/SMA and PCC regions (cross-correlation > 0.7) and fair for sensori-motor and posterior parietal cortex (c-c ∼ 0.5).

CONCLUSIONS

Multiple overlapping activities evoked by nociceptive input can be disentangled from high-density scalp EEG guided by intracranial data. Modeled sources accurately described the timing and morphology of most activities recorded with intracranial electrodes, including those coinciding with the emergence of stimulus awareness. Hum Brain Mapp 38:6083-6095, 2017. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Localizing value of electrical source imaging: Frontal lobe, malformations of cortical development and negative MRI related epilepsies are the best candidates

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to prospectively assess the anatomical concordance of electric source localizations of interictal discharges with the epileptogenic zone (EZ) estimated by stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) according to different subgroups: the type of epilepsy, the presence of a structural MRI lesion, the aetiology and the depth of the EZ.

METHODS

In a prospective multicentric observational study, we enrolled 85 consecutive patients undergoing pre-surgical SEEG investigation for focal drug-resistant epilepsy. Electric source imaging (ESI) was performed before SEEG. Source localizations were obtained from dipolar and distributed source methods. Anatomical concordance between ESI and EZ was defined according to 36 predefined sublobar regions. ESI was interpreted blinded to- and subsequently compared with SEEG estimated EZ.

RESULTS

74 patients were finally analyzed. 38 patients had temporal and 36 extra-temporal lobe epilepsy. MRI was positive in 52. 41 patients had malformation of cortical development (MCD), 33 had another or an unknown aetiology. EZ was medial in 27, lateral in 13, and medio-lateral in 34. In the overall cohort, ESI completely or partly localized the EZ in 85%: full concordance in 13 cases and partial concordance in 50 cases. The rate of ESI full concordance with EZ was significantly higher in (i) frontal lobe epilepsy (46%; p = 0.05), (ii) cases of negative MRI (36%; p = 0.01) and (iii) MCD (27%; p = 0.03). The rate of ESI full concordance with EZ was not statistically different according to the depth of the EZ.

SIGNIFICANCE

We prospectively demonstrated that ESI more accurately estimated the EZ in subgroups of patients who are often the most difficult cases in epilepsy surgery: frontal lobe epilepsy, negative MRI and the presence of MCD.

Correlation of invasive EEG and scalp EEG

Ever since the implementation of invasive EEG recordings in the clinical setting, it has been perceived that a considerable proportion of epileptic discharges present at a cortical level are missed by routine scalp EEG recordings. Several in vitro, in vivo, and simulation studies have been performed in the past decades aiming to clarify the interrelations of cortical sources with their scalp and invasive EEG correlates. The amplitude ratio of cortical potentials to their scalp EEG correlates, the extent of the cortical area involved in the discharge, as well as the localization of the cortical source and its geometry have been each independently linked to the recording of the cortical discharge with scalp electrodes. The need to elucidate these interrelations has been particularly imperative in the field of epilepsy surgery with its rapidly growing EEG-based localization technologies. Simultaneous multiscale EEG recordings with scalp, subdural and/or depth electrodes, applied in presurgical epilepsy workup, offer an excellent opportunity to shed some light to this fundamental issue. Whereas past studies have considered predominantly neocortical sources in the context of temporal lobe epilepsy, current investigations have included deep sources, as in mesial temporal epilepsy, as well as extratemporal sources. Novel computational tools may serve to provide surrogates for the shortcomings of EEG recording methodology and facilitate further developments in modern electrophysiology.

The role of blood vessels in high-resolution volume conductor head modeling of EEG

Reconstruction of the electrical sources of human EEG activity at high spatio-temporal accuracy is an important aim in neuroscience and neurological diagnostics. Over the last decades, numerous studies have demonstrated that realistic modeling of head anatomy improves the accuracy of source reconstruction of EEG signals. For example, including a cerebro-spinal fluid compartment and the anisotropy of white matter electrical conductivity were both shown to significantly reduce modeling errors. Here, we for the first time quantify the role of detailed reconstructions of the cerebral blood vessels in volume conductor head modeling for EEG. To study the role of the highly arborized cerebral blood vessels, we created a submillimeter head model based on ultra-high-field-strength (7T) structural MRI datasets. Blood vessels (arteries and emissary/intraosseous veins) were segmented using Frangi multi-scale vesselness filtering. The final head model consisted of a geometry-adapted cubic mesh with over 17×10(6) nodes. We solved the forward model using a finite-element-method (FEM) transfer matrix approach, which allowed reducing computation times substantially and quantified the importance of the blood vessel compartment by computing forward and inverse errors resulting from ignoring the blood vessels. Our results show that ignoring emissary veins piercing the skull leads to focal localization errors of approx. 5 to 15mm. Large errors (>2cm) were observed due to the carotid arteries and the dense arterial vasculature in areas such as in the insula or in the medial temporal lobe. Thus, in such predisposed areas, errors caused by neglecting blood vessels can reach similar magnitudes as those previously reported for neglecting white matter anisotropy, the CSF or the dura - structures which are generally considered important components of realistic EEG head models. Our findings thus imply that including a realistic blood vessel compartment in EEG head models will be helpful to improve the accuracy of EEG source analyses particularly when high accuracies in brain areas with dense vasculature are required.

Electrical source imaging of interictal spikes using multiple sparse volumetric priors for presurgical epileptogenic focus localization

Electrical source imaging of interictal spikes observed in EEG recordings of patients with refractory epilepsy provides useful information to localize the epileptogenic focus during the presurgical evaluation. However, the selection of the time points or time epochs of the spikes in order to estimate the origin of the activity remains a challenge. In this study, we consider a Bayesian EEG source imaging technique for distributed sources, i.e. the multiple volumetric sparse priors (MSVP) approach. The approach allows to estimate the time courses of the intensity of the sources corresponding with a specific time epoch of the spike. Based on presurgical averaged interictal spikes in six patients who were successfully treated with surgery, we estimated the time courses of the source intensities for three different time epochs: (i) an epoch starting 50 ms before the spike peak and ending at 50% of the spike peak during the rising phase of the spike, (ii) an epoch starting 50 ms before the spike peak and ending at the spike peak and (iii) an epoch containing the full spike time period starting 50 ms before the spike peak and ending 230 ms after the spike peak. To identify the primary source of the spike activity, the source with the maximum energy from 50 ms before the spike peak till 50% of the spike peak was subsequently selected for each of the time windows. For comparison, the activity at the spike peaks and at 50% of the peaks was localized using the LORETA inversion technique and an ECD approach. Both patient-specific spherical forward models and patient-specific 5-layered finite difference models were considered to evaluate the influence of the forward model. Based on the resected zones in each of the patients, extracted from post-operative MR images, we compared the distances to the resection border of the estimated activity. Using the spherical models, the distances to the resection border for the MSVP approach and each of the different time epochs were in the same range as the LORETA and ECD techniques. We found distances smaller than 23 mm, with robust results for all the patients. For the finite difference models, we found that the distances to the resection border for the MSVP inversions of the full spike time epochs were generally smaller compared to the MSVP inversions of the time epochs before the spike peak. The results also suggest that the inversions using the finite difference models resulted in slightly smaller distances to the resection border compared to the spherical models. The results we obtained are promising because the MSVP approach allows to study the network of the estimated source-intensities and allows to characterize the spatial extent of the underlying sources.

•

A Bayesian ESI technique is evaluated to localize interictal spike activity.

•

Averaged spikes in six patients were used that were seizure free after surgery.

•

We compared the technique with the LORETA an ECD technique.

•

We evaluated both spherical and 5-layered finite difference forward models.

•

Our approach is potentially useful to delineate the irritative zone.

Combined EEG/MEG can outperform single modality EEG or MEG source reconstruction in presurgical epilepsy diagnosis

We investigated two important means for improving source reconstruction in presurgical epilepsy diagnosis. The first investigation is about the optimal choice of the number of epileptic spikes in averaging to (1) sufficiently reduce the noise bias for an accurate determination of the center of gravity of the epileptic activity and (2) still get an estimation of the extent of the irritative zone. The second study focuses on the differences in single modality EEG (80-electrodes) or MEG (275-gradiometers) and especially on the benefits of combined EEG/MEG (EMEG) source analysis. Both investigations were validated with simultaneous stereo-EEG (sEEG) (167-contacts) and low-density EEG (ldEEG) (21-electrodes). To account for the different sensitivity profiles of EEG and MEG, we constructed a six-compartment finite element head model with anisotropic white matter conductivity, and calibrated the skull conductivity via somatosensory evoked responses. Our results show that, unlike single modality EEG or MEG, combined EMEG uses the complementary information of both modalities and thereby allows accurate source reconstructions also at early instants in time (epileptic spike onset), i.e., time points with low SNR, which are not yet subject to propagation and thus supposed to be closer to the origin of the epileptic activity. EMEG is furthermore able to reveal the propagation pathway at later time points in agreement with sEEG, while EEG or MEG alone reconstructed only parts of it. Subaveraging provides important and accurate information about both the center of gravity and the extent of the epileptogenic tissue that neither single nor grand-averaged spike localizations can supply.

[French guidelines on electroencephalogram]

Electroencephalography allows the functional analysis of electrical brain cortical activity and is the gold standard for analyzing electrophysiological processes involved in epilepsy but also in several other dysfunctions of the central nervous system. Morphological imaging yields complementary data, yet it cannot replace the essential functional analysis tool that is EEG. Furthermore, EEG has the great advantage of being non-invasive, easy to perform and allows control tests when follow-up is necessary, even at the patient's bedside. Faced with the advances in knowledge, techniques and indications, the Société de Neurophysiologie Clinique de Langue Française (SNCLF) and the Ligue Française Contre l'Épilepsie (LFCE) found it necessary to provide an update on EEG recommendations. This article will review the methodology applied to this work, refine the various topics detailed in the following chapters. It will go over the summary of recommendations for each of these chapters and underline proposals for writing an EEG report. Some questions could not be answered by the review of the literature; in those cases, an expert advice was given by the working and reading groups in addition to the guidelines.

Representation and propagation of epileptic activity in absences and generalized photoparoxysmal responses

Although functional imaging studies described networks associated with generalized epileptic activity, propagation patterns within these networks are not clear. In this study, electroencephalogram (EEG)-based coherent source imaging dynamic imaging of coherent sources (DICS) was applied to different types of generalized epileptiform discharges, namely absence seizures (10 patients) and photoparoxysmal responses (PPR) (eight patients) to describe the representation and propagation of these discharges in the brain. The results of electrical source imaging were compared to EEG-functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) which had been obtained from the same data sets of simultaneous EEG and fMRI recordings. Similar networks were described by DICS and fMRI: (1) absence seizures were associated with thalamic involvement in all patients. Concordant results were also found for brain areas of the default mode network and the occipital cortex. (2) Both DICS and fMRI identified the occipital, parietal, and the frontal cortex in a network associated with PPR. (3) However, only when PPR preceded a generalized tonic-clonic seizure, the thalamus was involved in the generation of PPR as shown by both imaging techniques. Partial directed coherence suggested that during absences, the thalamus acts as a pacemaker while PPR could be explained by a cortical propagation from the occipital cortex via the parietal cortex to the frontal cortex. In conclusion, the electrical source imaging is not only able to describe similar neuronal networks as revealed by fMRI, including deep sources of neuronal activity such as the thalamus, but also demonstrates interactions interactions within these networks and sheds light on pathogenetic mechanisms of absence seizures and PPR.

EEG-fMRI validation studies in comparison with icEEG: a review

Simultaneous EEG-fMRI is a non-invasive investigation technique developed to localize the generators of interictal epileptiform discharges (IED) in patients with epilepsy. Although the value of EEG-fMRI in epilepsy presurgical evaluation is being assessed clinically, its utility is still controversial. In this review, we considered EEG-fMRI applications in epilepsy presurgical evaluation with a focus on validation studies that compared the results of EEG-fMRI with those of the current "gold standard" intracranial EEG (icEEG) in order to assess its utility of seizure focus localization and the possibility for EEG-fMRI to reduce the need for invasive techniques such as icEEG. Since the advances of EEG-fMRI partially rely on the maturation of its data analysis, we also reviewed the methodological developments in EEG-fMRI analysis. It is possible that combining with other neuroimaging modalities such as MEG/MSI and ESI, EEG-fMRI may play a greater role in epilepsy presurgical evaluation.

EEG and MEG in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy: where do the spikes really come from?

OBJECTIVE

There is persistent debate as to whether or not EEG and MEG recordings in patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE) can detect mesial temporal interictal epileptiform discharges (spikes), and this issue is particularly relevant for source localization studies. With the aim of providing direct evidence pertinent to this debate we present detailed examples of the intracranial sources of spikes recorded with EEG and MEG in MTLE.

METHODS

Spikes recorded in five different patients with MTLE during intracranial EEG (n=2), intraoperative electrocorticography (ECOG; n=1), combined scalp-intracranial EEG (n=2) and combined EEG-MEG (n=1) were analyzed and the intracranial sources of the spike foci were matched with their corresponding extracranial EEG and/or MEG fields. EEG and MEG dipole source localization was performed on six independent spike foci identified in one representative patient with bilateral MTLE.

RESULTS

Spikes with an electrical field maximal at F7/8, F9/10≥T3/4 were generated in the anterolateral temporal neocortex. The absence of coincident spiking at mesial locations indicated that these were not propagated from or to the hippocampus. Spikes with an electrical field maximal at T3/4≥T9/10 were generated in the lateral temporal neocortex and likewise did not involve the hippocampus. Individual spikes generated in the mesiobasal temporal neocortex, including the fusiform gyrus, were difficult to detect with EEG (low amplitude diphasic waves most apparent after spike averaging at T3/4, T9/10≥T5/6, P9/10) and only slightly more identifiable with MEG. Spikes generated within and confined to the mesial temporal structures, as confirmed by intracranial recordings, could not be detected with EEG or MEG. Notably, such spikes could not be detected even at intracranial recording sites on the lateral surface of the temporal lobe.

CONCLUSIONS

We present detailed evidence in a small case series showing that typical anterior temporal spikes recorded with EEG and MEG in MTLE arose from the anterolateral temporal neocortex and were neither propagated from nor to the hippocampus. Mid temporal EEG spikes were localized to the lateral temporal neocortex. Intracranially detected mesial temporal spikes were not detected with EEG or MEG.

SIGNIFICANCE

The spikes recorded with EEG and MEG in MTLE are localized to neocortical foci, and not to the mesial temporal structures. Current noninvasive EEG and MEG source localization studies cannot accurately identify true mesial temporal spikes.

Clinical utility of current-generation dipole modelling of scalp EEG

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the clinical utility of current-generation dipole modelling of scalp EEG in focal epilepsies seen commonly in clinical practice.

METHODS

Scalp EEG recordings from 10 patients with focal epilepsy, five with Benign Focal Epilepsy of Childhood (BFEC) and five with Mesial Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (MTLE), were used for interictal spike dipole modelling using Scan 4.3 and CURRY 5.0. Optimum modelling parameters for EEG source localisation (ESL) were sought by the step-wise application of various volume conductor (forward) and dipole (inverse) models. Best-fit ESL solutions (highest explained forward-fit to measured data variance) were used to characterise best-fit forward and inverse models, regularisation effect, additional electrode effect, single-to-single spike and single-to-averaged spike variability, and intra- and inter-operator concordance. Inter-parameter relationships were examined. Computation times and interface problems were recorded.

RESULTS

For both BFEC and MTLE, the best-fit forward model was the finite element method interpolated (FEMi) model, while the best-fit single dipole models were the rotating non-regularised and the moving regularised models. When combined, these forward-inverse models appeared to offer clinically meaningful ESL results when referenced to an averaged cortex overlay, best-fit dipoles localising to the central fissure region in BFEC and to the basolateral temporal region in MTLE. Single-to-single spike and single-to-averaged spike measures of concordance for dipole location and orientation were stronger for BFEC versus MTLE. The use of an additional pair of inferior temporal electrodes in MTLE directed best-fit dipoles towards the basomesial temporal region. Inverse correlations were noted between unexplained variance (RD) and dipole strength (Amp), RD and signal to noise ratio (SNR), and SNR and confidence ellipsoid (CE) volume. Intra- and inter-operator levels of agreement were relatively robust for dipole location and orientation. Technical problems were infrequent and modelling operations were performed within 5min.

CONCLUSIONS

The optimal forward-inverse single dipole modelling set-up for BFEC and MTLE interictal spike analysis is the FEMi model using the combination of rotating non-regularised and moving regularised dipoles. Dipole modelling of single spikes characterises best-fit dipole location and orientation more reliably in BFEC than in MTLE for which spike averaging is recommended.

SIGNIFICANCE

The clinical utility of dipole modelling in two common forms of focal epilepsy strengthens the case for its place in the routine clinical work-up of patients with localisation-related epilepsy syndromes.

Combined spike-related functional MRI and multiple source analysis in the non-invasive spike localization of benign rolandic epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

To localize the irritative zone in children by combined spike-related fMRI and EEG multiple source analysis (MSA) in children with benign rolandic epilepsy.

METHODS

Interictal spikes were averaged and localized using MSA, and source locations were displayed in the anatomical 3D-MRI in 11 patients (5-12 yrs, median 10). Interictal spikes were additionally recorded during the fMRI acquisition (EEG-fMRI), and the fMRI sequences were correlated off-line with the EEG spikes.

RESULTS

MSA revealed an initial central dipole in all patients, including the face or hand area. A second dipolar source was mostly consistent with propagated activity. BOLD activations from EEG-fMRI, consistent with the locations of the initial dipoles, were found in four patients. We found additional large areas of BOLD activations in 3 of these subjects extending into the sylvian fissure and the insula. These were identified as propagated activity by MSA using the short time differences in the source waveforms.

CONCLUSIONS

MSA provided reliable localization of the spike onset zone in all children with benign rolandic epilepsy. Using the combination of EEG-fMRI and MSA we were able to discriminate the spike onset zone from propagated epileptiform source activity, using the spatial resolution of the EEG-fMRI technique and the temporal resolution of the MSA. However, the sensitivity of the EEG-fMRI technique was low and further improvements of the technique are warranted.

SIGNIFICANCE

This study shows that a combination of EEG-fMRI and MSA may be a powerful tool to describe the irritative zone of patients with idiopathic focal epilepsies. Clinical studies in patients with non-idiopathic focal epilepsies may clarify whether both techniques can be used as complementary clinical tools to localize the onset of interictal epileptic activity in focal epilepsies.

Analysis of EEG–fMRI data in focal epilepsy based on automated spike classification and Signal Space Projection

Simultaneous acquisition of EEG and fMRI data enables the investigation of the hemodynamic correlates of interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs) during the resting state in patients with epilepsy. This paper addresses two issues: (1) the semi-automation of IED classification in statistical modelling for fMRI analysis and (2) the improvement of IED detection to increase experimental fMRI efficiency. For patients with multiple IED generators, sensitivity to IED-correlated BOLD signal changes can be improved when the fMRI analysis model distinguishes between IEDs of differing morphology and field. In an attempt to reduce the subjectivity of visual IED classification, we implemented a semi-automated system, based on the spatio-temporal clustering of EEG events. We illustrate the technique's usefulness using EEG-fMRI data from a subject with focal epilepsy in whom 202 IEDs were visually identified and then clustered semi-automatically into four clusters. Each cluster of IEDs was modelled separately for the purpose of fMRI analysis. This revealed IED-correlated BOLD activations in distinct regions corresponding to three different IED categories. In a second step, Signal Space Projection (SSP) was used to project the scalp EEG onto the dipoles corresponding to each IED cluster. This resulted in 123 previously unrecognised IEDs, the inclusion of which, in the General Linear Model (GLM), increased the experimental efficiency as reflected by significant BOLD activations. We have also shown that the detection of extra IEDs is robust in the face of fluctuations in the set of visually detected IEDs. We conclude that automated IED classification can result in more objective fMRI models of IEDs and significantly increased sensitivity.

EEG Source Imaging in Pediatric Epilepsy Surgery: A New Perspective in Presurgical Workup

PURPOSE

Epilepsy is a relatively frequent disease in children, with considerable impact on cognitive and social life. Successful epilepsy surgery depends on unambiguous focus identification and requires a comprehensive presurgical workup, including several neuroimaging techniques [magnetic resonance imaging, positron emission tomography (PET), and single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT)]. These may be difficult to apply in younger or developmentally delayed children or both, requiring sedation, and hence, a significant workforce. Modern electric source imaging (ESI) provides accurate epileptic source-localization information in most patients, with minimal patient discomfort or need for cooperation. The purpose of the present study was to determine the usefulness of ESI in pediatric EEG recordings performed with routine electrode arrays.

METHODS

Preoperative EEGs recorded from 19 to 29 scalp electrodes were reviewed, and interictal epileptiform activity was analyzed by using a linear source-imaging procedure (depth-weighted minimum norm) in combination with statistical parametric mapping.

RESULTS

In 27 (90%) of 30 patients, the ESI correctly localized the epileptogenic region. These numbers compare favorably with the results from other imaging techniques in the same patients (PET, 82%; ictal SPECT, 70%). In extratemporal epilepsy, ESI was correct in all cases, and in temporal lobe epilepsy, in 10 of 13 cases. In two temporal lobe patients showing less-accurate ESI results, 128-electrode data could be analyzed, and in both cases, the 128-electrode ESI was correct.

CONCLUSIONS

ESI with standard clinical EEG recordings provides excellent localizing information in pediatric patients, in particular in extratemporal lobe epilepsy. The lower yield in temporal lobe epilepsy seems to be due to undersampling of basal temporal areas with routine scalp recordings.

Source localization of interictal epileptiform discharges: comparison of three different techniques to improve signal to noise ratio

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the localization accuracy of low-resolution electromagnetic tomography (LORETA) for mesial temporal interictal epileptiform discharges (IED) using a new relative averaging (RELAVG) technique for noise reduction.

METHODS

We analyzed 19 patterns of mesial temporal IED recorded simultaneously with scalp and foramen ovale (FO) electrodes in 15 consecutive patients who underwent presurgical assessment for intractable temporal lobe epilepsy. The scalp signals were time-locked to the peak activity in the FO electrode recordings and source modeling was performed using the RELAVG technique. Random noise of various amounts was then applied. The results were compared to intracranial data obtained from the FO electrode recordings and to LORETA source solutions obtained using two other approaches to improve signal to noise ratio (SNR): statistical non-parametric mapping (SNPM) and the commonly applied averaging (AVG) technique.

RESULTS

The RELAVG technique allowed for reasonable mesial temporal localization in 52.6% (10/19) of IED patterns, compared with 73.7% (14/19) using SNPM. The AVG technique provided no strictly mesial temporal solutions. Nine of the IED patterns revealed relative current density quotient changes >10; all of these were accurately localized by RELAVG into mesial temporal structures. Increasing amounts of white and physiological noise had no influence on the accuracy of RELAVG and SNPM solutions, whereas AVG source reconstructions became progressively spurious.

CONCLUSION

The RELAVG technique and SNPM, but not the commonly used AVG technique, allow for reasonable source localization of mesial temporal IED. SNPM is the most accurate but also the most time-consuming noise reduction technique.

SIGNIFICANCE

The RELAVG LORETA technique might provide a simple and fast semi-quantitative alternative for localizing IED with low single to noise ratio.

Dipole Modeling of Epileptic Spikes Can Be Accurate or Misleading

PURPOSE

We investigated the accuracy and potential for serious error when representing cortical generators of epileptic spikes with the common single-dipole model. Spike generators were realistically simulated with cortical areas of different extents.

METHODS

The source was simulated by using a patch that comprised small triangles on the cortical surface, each triangle having an elementary dipole generator with a moment corresponding to real intracerebral fields of spikes. The source-patch covered various clinically important parts of the temporal and frontal lobes, with an area ranging from 6 to 120 cm2. The scalp field was computed for each source-patch by using a realistic head model and was fitted by the single-dipole model to determine the best-fit dipole and the intracerebral distribution of residual variance (RV). Dipole modeling also was performed for the simulated scalp field with additional real EEG background.

RESULTS

The RV after fitting a dipole to the scalp field without noise was at most 1.34%. Scalp spikes arising from sources of 6 cm2 were of small amplitude, and the dipoles estimated for these spikes were inconsistent. Extension of the source area was associated with increase of scalp potential amplitude, only very small increase of RV, and increased consistency of the estimated dipoles. When the source was very large, the dipoles clustered at very misleading locations.

CONCLUSIONS

Pitfalls in dipole source localization are caused by the procedure of fitting the simplistic dipole model to real cortical sources with spatial extent and complex configuration.

A comparative study of different references for EEG spectral mapping: the issue of the neutral reference and the use of the infinity reference

Based on EEG data recorded from 11 subjects with eyes open and the left mastoid (M) reference, three data sets were generated by re-referencing to the conventional linked mastoids (L), average (A) and the new 'infinity' (I) reference provided by the reference electrode standardization technique (REST, Yao 2001 Physiol. Meas. 22 693-711). The EEG power in the alpha frequency band with the four different references was calculated and compared with respect to the total energy and spatial amplitude weight centre (AWC) coordinates, to compare the effects of different references on power mapping in the frequency domain. Compared with the I reference, the AWCs of the EEG with the M reference show significant shifts to the right, frontal and superficial positions, the L reference significant shifts to frontal and superficial positions, and the A reference shifts the AWC significantly to a deeper position. Furthermore, the power maps of the M and L references have larger total power than the I reference, while that of the A reference has the smallest total power. These results confirm that different choices of reference electrodes result in systematic changes in the distribution of EEG frequency power, and in order to reduce the effect of such systematic shifts on the explanation of EEG mappings, a common reference is necessary for EEG research. We recommend the I reference for objective use in cross-laboratory studies and clinical practices, as it is far from all the other electrodes and can act as a neutral reference.

Electric Source Imaging in Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

The objective of this study was to determine the validity of interictal spike (IIS) source localization in temporal lobe epilepsies (TLE) using stereoelectroencephalography as a validating method. Twenty patients with drug-resistant TLE were studied with high-resolution EEG and stereoelectroencephalography. Sixty-four scalp channels, a realistic head model, and different algorithms were used. For each patient, the intracerebral interictal distribution was studied and classified into one of three groups: L (mainly lateral), ML (mediolateral), and M (medial). In group L (three patients), surface IIS were recorded with a high signal-to-noise ratio. Source localizations designated all or part of the intracerebral interictal distribution. In group ML (11 patients), 8 patients had surface IIS, only 5 of which were localizable. High-resolution EEG permitted localization of the more lateral portion and definition of its rostrocaudal extension. A common pattern was identified in three patients with a predominant role of the temporal pole. In group M (six patients), four patients had rare surface IIS, none of which were localizable. Surface EEG does not record IIS limited to medial temporal lobe structures. In TLE with a mediolateral or a lateral interictal distribution, only the lateral component is detectable on surface EEG and accurately localizable by source localization tools.

Controversies in clinical neurophysiology. MEG is superior to EEG in the localization of interictal epileptiform activity: Con

OBJECTIVE

To assess whether MEG is superior to scalp-EEG in the localization of interictal epileptiform activity and to stress the 'con' part in this controversy.

METHODS

Advantages and disadvantages of the two techniques were systematically reviewed.

RESULTS

While MEG and EEG complement each other for the detection of interictal epileptiform discharges, EEG offers the advantage of long-term recording significantly increasing its diagnostic yield which is not feasible with MEG. Localization accuracies of EEG and MEG are comparable once inaccuracies for the solution of the forward problem are eliminated. MEG may be more sensitive for the detection of neocortical spike sources. EEG and MEG source localizations show comparable agreement with invasive electrical recordings, can clarify the spatial relationship between the irritative zone and structural lesions, guide the placement of invasive electrodes and attribute epileptic activity to lobar subcompartments in temporal lobe epilepsy and to a lesser extent in extratemporal epilepsy.

CONCLUSIONS

A clear superiority of MEG over EEG for the localization of interictal epileptiform activity cannot be derived from the studies presently available.

SIGNIFICANCE

The combination of EEG and MEG provides information for the localization of interictal epileptiform activity which cannot be obtained with either technique alone.

Brain generators of laser-evoked potentials: from dipoles to functional significance

In this work we review data on cortical generators of laser-evoked potentials (LEPs) in humans, as inferred from dipolar modelling of scalp EEG/MEG results, as well as from intracranial data recorded with subdural grids or intracortical electrodes. The cortical regions most consistently tagged as sources of scalp LERs are the suprasylvian region (parietal operculum, SII) and the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). Variability in opercular sources across studies appear mainly in the anterior-posterior direction, where sources tend to follow the axis of the Sylvian fissure. As compared with parasylvian activation described in functional pain imaging studies, LEP opercular sources tended to cluster at more superior sites and not to involve the insula. The existence of suprasylvian opercular LEPs has been confirmed by both epicortical (subdural) and intracortical recordings. In dipole-modelling studies, these sources appear to become active less than 150 ms post-stimulus, and remain in action for longer than opercular responses recorded intracortically, thus suggesting that modelled opercular dipoles reflect a "lumped" activation of several sources in the suprasylvian region, including both the operculum and the insula. Participation of SI sources to explain LEP scalp distribution remains controversial, but evidence is emerging that both SI and opercular sources may be concomitantly activated by laser pulses, with very similar time courses. Should these data be confirmed, it would suggest that a parallel processing in SI and SII has remained functional in humans for noxious inputs, whereas hierarchical processing from SI toward SII has emerged for other somatosensory sub-modalities. The ACC has been described as a source of LEPs by virtually all EEG studies so far, with activation times roughly corresponding to scalp P2. Activation is generally confined to area 24 in the caudal ACC, and has been confirmed by subdural and intracortical recordings. The inability of most MEG studies to disclose such ACC activity may be due to the radial orientation of ACC currents relative to scalp. ACC dipole sources have been consistently located between the VAC and VPC lines of Talairach's space, near to the cingulate subsections activated by motor tasks involving control of the hand. Together with the fact that scalp activities at this latency are very sensitive to arousal and attention, this supports the hypothesis that laser-evoked ACC activity may underlie orienting reactions tightly coupled with limb withdrawal (or control of withdrawal). With much less consistency than the above-mentioned areas, posterior parietal, medial temporal and anterior insular regions have been occasionally tagged as possible contributors to LEPs. Dipoles ascribed to medial temporal lobe may be in some cases re-interpreted as being located at or near the insular cortex. This would make sense as the insular region has been shown to respond to thermal pain stimuli in both functional imaging and intracranial EEG studies.

Noninvasive methods for evaluating the localization and propagation of epileptic activity

There are multiple approaches to analyzing the scalp EEG to obtain information on the intracerebral generators of epileptic activity. We review here a few of these methods, as they have been applied in various research projects carried out at the Montreal Neurological Institute. The areas covered include the validation of dipole models of epileptic spikes and of seizure discharges, the EEG microscope of Kobayashi, the analysis of rapid spread of epileptic seizures, and the recently developed method of combining EEG and functional magnetic resonance imaging to obtain activation regions at the time of spikes.

High-resolution source imaging in mesiotemporal lobe epilepsy: a comparison between MEG and simultaneous EEG

Magnetic source imaging is claimed to have a high accuracy in epileptic focus localization and may be a guide for epilepsy surgery. Non-lesional mesiotemporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE), the most common form of epilepsy operated on, has different etiologies, which may affect the choice of surgical approach. The authors compared whole-head magnetoencephalography (MEG) with high-resolution EEG for source identification in MTLE. Nineteen patients with unilateral, nonlesional MTLE underwent a simultaneous 151-channel CTF MEG (CTF Systems, Inc., Port Coquitlam, British Columbia, Canada) and 64-channel EEG recordings with sleep induction. Three independent observers selected spikes from the EEG and MEG recordings separately. Only when there was interobserver agreement (kappa>0.4) on the presence of spikes in recordings were consensus spikes averaged. EEG and MEG equivalent current dipoles (ECD) were then integrated in the head model of the patient reconstructed from MRI. The results were compared with intraoperative electrocorticography findings. Spikes were detected in 32% of MEGs and 42% of EEGs. No patient showed MEG spikes only. Equivalent current dipole modeling correctly localized the source to the temporal lobe in four out of five MEG and three out of eight EEG recordings. MEG localized sources were more superficial and EEG localized sources were deeper. Unfortunately, basal temporal lobe areas were only partially covered by the sensor helmet of the MEG setup. Best correlation between EEG or MEG findings and electrocorticography findings was between horizontal EEG dipole orientation and prominent neocortical spiking; these patients also had a less favorable prognosis. Magnetic source imaging is currently unlikely to alter the surgical management of MTLE. The yield of spikes is too low, and ECD modeling shows only partial correlation with electrocorticography findings. Moreover, the whole-head MEG helmet provides insufficient coverage of the temporal lobe.

MEG and EEG in epilepsy

Both EEG and magnetoencephalogram (MEG), with a time resolution of 1 ms or less, provide unique neurophysiologic data not obtainable by other neuroimaging techniques. MEG has now emerged as a mature clinical technology. While both EEG and MEG can be performed with more than 100 channels, MEG recordings with 100 to 300 channels are more easily done because of the time needed to apply a large number of EEG electrodes. EEG has the advantage of the long-term video EEG recordings, which facilitates extensive temporal sampling across all periods of the sleep/wake cycle. MEG and EEG seem to complement each other for the detection of interictal epileptiform discharges, because some spikes can be recorded only on MEG but not on EEG and vice versa. Most studies indicate that MEG seems to be more sensitive for neocortical spike sources. Both EEG and MEG source localizations show excellent agreement with invasive electrical recordings, clarify the spatial relationship between the irritative zone and structural lesions, and finally, attribute epileptic activity to lobar subcompartments in temporal lobe and to a lesser extent in extratemporal epilepsies. In temporal lobe epilepsy, EEG and MEG can differentiate between patients with mesial, lateral, and diffuse seizure onsets. MEG selectively detects tangential sources. EEG measures both radial and tangential activity, although the radial components dominate the EEG signals at the scalp. Thus, while EEG provides more comprehensive information, it is more complicated to model due to considerable influences of the shape and conductivity of the volume conductor. Dipole localization techniques favor MEG due to the higher accuracy of MEG source localization compared to EEG when using the standard spherical head shape model. However, if special care is taken to address the above issues and enhance the EEG, the localization accuracy of EEG and MEG actually are comparable, although these surface EEG analytic techniques are not typically approved for clinical use in the United States. MEG dipole analysis is approved for clinical use and thus gives information that otherwise usually requires invasive intracranial EEG monitoring. There are only a few dozen whole head MEG units in operation in the world. While EEG is available in every hospital, specialized EEG laboratories capable of source localization techniques are nearly as scarce as MEG facilities. The combined use of whole-head MEG systems and multichannel EEG in conjunction with advanced source modeling techniques is an area of active development and will allow a better noninvasive characterization of the irritative zone in presurgical epilepsy evaluation. Finally, additional information on epilepsy may be gathered by either MEG or EEG analysis of data beyond the usual bandwidths used in clinical practice, namely by analysis of activity at high frequencies and near-DC activity.

Comparison of spike-triggered functional MRI BOLD activation and EEG dipole model localization

We studied six patients with localization-related epilepsy, frequent interictal epileptiform discharges, and positive spike-triggered blood oxygen level-dependent functional MRI (BOLD-fMRI) findings. EEG source analysis solutions based on 64-channel EEG recorded in a separate session outside the scanner were obtained using dipole models and compared to the BOLD localization. The BOLD and structural images were coregistered, allowing the measurement of distances between the generator models and BOLD activation(s) and structural lesion when present. In all cases dipole models could be found that explained a sufficient amount of the data and that were anatomically concordant with the BOLD localization. In the five cases with structural abnormality visible on T1 scans, the BOLD activation overlapped or was in close proximity to the abnormality. The overall mean distance between the main moving dipole and the center of the nearest BOLD activation was 3.5 and 2.2 cm for the negative and positive peaks, respectively, including one case of a deep BOLD activation, in which the distance was 5 cm. In conclusion, the degree of agreement between the BOLD and EEG source localization indicates that the combination of these two noninvasive techniques offers the possibility of advancing the study of the generators of epileptiform electrical activity.

Dipole modeling of scalp electroencephalogram epileptic discharges: correlation with intracerebral fields

OBJECTIVE

In order to evaluate the feasibility of modeling seizures and the reliability of dipole models, we compared source localizations of scalp seizures with the distribution of simultaneous intracerebral electroencephalogram (SEEG).

METHODS

In a first session, only scalp electroencephalogram (EEG) was recorded from 15 patients. We averaged the first detectable ictal activity in two consecutive segments of stable topography and morphology. Spatio-temporal dipole sources were estimated for each segment and projected on 3D-magnetic resonance images. In a second session, SEEG was recorded simultaneously with control scalp electrodes, allowing the identification of ictal patterns similar to those submitted to dipole modeling.

RESULTS

Ictal discharges could be analyzed in only 6 of 15 patients. In the remaining 9, scalp discharges were undetectable or non-reproducible in 6, and solutions were unstable despite an apparently stable discharge in 3. In the 6 patients successfully modeled, dipoles were found in regions where SEEG discharges were present. However, when intracerebral discharges were very focal, there was no corresponding scalp activity. When intracerebral signals were maximal in the mesial temporal regions at the seizure onset, only lateral neocortical dipoles were found. When discharges reached the frontal lobes, we could identify lateral and mesial frontal sources.

CONCLUSIONS

In most seizures, it was not possible to obtain satisfactory dipole models, probably a reflection of the high noise level or widespread generators. When modeling was possible, our results suggested that mesial temporal seizure discharges did not contribute to scalp EEG activity. This activity appears to reflect signals synchronized and distributed over the lateral temporal or frontal neocortex, as well as signals generated in mesial frontal areas.

Localization of interictal delta and epileptiform EEG activity associated with focal epileptogenic brain lesions

The present study was aimed at investigating the accuracy of electric source reconstruction in the presurgical evaluation of epilepsy patients. Spontaneous EEG activity of 14 patients with focal intracerebral epileptogenic lesions was analyzed by source reconstruction based on high-resolution EEG (64-channel system) and a boundary element method head model accounting for the individual head anatomy. Equivalent dipole modeling was applied to focal delta and interictal epileptiform activity. The localization results were validated quantitatively by comparison with the sites of the structural lesions. In 6 of 9 patients with focal delta activity, the maximum of dipole concentration was closer than 10 mm to the nearest lesion margin and mostly at the border or within pathologically altered cortical tissue. In all 11 patients showing interictal epileptiform activity, the localization results were found in the same lobe as the lesion. In almost half of them, they were closer than 10 mm to the lesion margin. Patients with larger distances (22-36 mm) mostly had hippocampal atrophy or sclerosis. Their dipole locations did not appear in the affected hippocampus, but in the adjacent temporal neocortex. In conclusion, electric source reconstruction applied to both abnormal slow and interictal epileptiform EEG activity seems to be a valuable additional noninvasive component in the multimodal presurgical evaluation of epilepsy patients.

Use of cavernous sinus EEG in the detection of seizure onset and spread in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy

PURPOSE

The study goal was to evaluate the clinical usefulness of intravenous EEG recording by placing wire electrodes in the cavernous sinus (CS) and the superior petrosal sinus (SPS) in patients with intractable temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), with special emphasis on the ictal recording.

METHODS

We placed Seeker Lite-10 guide wire as electrodes in the bilateral CS, SPS, or both to simultaneously record both ictal and interictal EEGs with the scalp EEG in five patients with TLE. In addition, in one patient, we averaged interictal scalp and intravascular EEG time-locked to the epileptiform discharge recorded from the CS/SPS-EEG to further delineate the relationship of the spikes between scalp and intravenous recording.

RESULTS

In four of five patients, clinically useful recording was obtained to determine ictal focus. We recorded habitual seizures in three patients, and the detailed characteristics of ictal epileptiform discharges were shown. The averaged waveform of interictal epileptiform discharges clarified the spike distribution in the scalp EEGs, which was otherwise undetectable in the single trace. All of the patients completed the intravenous EEG monitoring without any neurological or psychological problems.

CONCLUSIONS

The CS/SPS-EEG is a relatively noninvasive method that is useful for the detection of ictal focus and its spreading pattern and thus for the selection of surgical candidate among patients with intractable TLE. Although the number of seizures detected during the short monitoring period may be limited, due to the advantages of its safety and simplicity, it is worth trying for potential surgical candidates before more invasive examinations are applied. A further study with a larger number of patients is needed to estimate its practical risk.

Relationships between the epileptic focus and hand area in central epilepsy: combining dipole models and anatomical landmarks

OBJECT

When considering resection of epileptic generators near the central sulcus, it is essential to define the spatial relationship between the epileptic generator and the primary sensorimotor hand area. In this study, the authors assessed the accuracy of dipole modeling of electroencephalographic spikes and median nerve somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEPs) in defining this relationship preoperatively and noninvasively.

METHODS

Epileptic spikes and SSEPs in patients with focal central area epilepsy were represented by dipole models coregistered onto global magnetic resonance images. In patients who underwent surgery, spike dipoles were also compared with findings of electrocorticography (ECoG) and with the resection area. To improve the accuracy of the dipole models, anatomical landmarks of the hand area were used to assess the error in SSEP dipole location, and this error measure was used to correct the location of spike dipoles. Five patients with central epilepsy were studied, three of whom underwent ECoG-guided surgical resections. The location of SSEP dipoles correlated well with anatomical landmarks of the primary sensory hand area. The relative position of the spike and SSEP dipoles correlated well with the patients' ictal symptoms, ECoG findings, and the location of the epileptic focus (as defined by the resection cavity in patients who became seizure free postoperatively). Corrected spike dipoles were located even closer to the resection cavity.

CONCLUSIONS

The calculation of the relative location of spike and SSEP dipoles is a simple noninvasive method of determining the relationship between the primary hand area and an epileptic focus in the central area. The spatial resolution of this technique can be further improved using easily identifiable anatomical landmarks.

Dipole-source analysis in a realistic head model in patients with focal epilepsy

PURPOSE

By the use of three different head models in EEG dipole analysis, we tried to model the origin of interictal and ictal epileptic activity as precisely as possible. Further, as a control, a second evaluation was made by an independent group to control for interindividual reliability of the dipole source analysis. With the realistic head model (CURRY) considering cortex, skull, and skin segmentation, the spike source was located.

METHODS

In five patients with mesial temporal epileptogenesis, confirmed by successful epilepsy surgery, the spike source was close to the hippocampus, with a mean distance of the dipole source from the hippocampus of 13.6 mm (range, 9-17.2 mm). In one case the ictal EEG also could be analyzed and resulted in a dipole-source localization comparable to the interictal source.

RESULTS

In both head models using either pure cortex segmentation only or a concentric three-shell model, the dipole source was systematically dislocated in a more superior position. Data analysis by a second group with independently chosen EEG samples and identical individual head model resulted in deviations of <5.3 mm. Data analysis using independently selected spikes and independently segmented head models resulted in deviations < or =16.7 mm.

CONCLUSIONS

In four cases of extratemporal epileptogenesis, the origin of interictal epileptiform discharges was localized to the suspected primary epileptogenic zone.

EEG and implanted sources in the brain

Localisation procedures are based on models of the EEG that are relatively simple. The models are based on assumptions and choices of parameters that can be mistaken. Thus, it is crucial to validate the localisation procedures used in EEG. One of the options is to use the data obtained with electrodes that are implanted within the brain of an epileptic patient as part of the pre-surgical evaluation. When one of two neighbouring electrodes is used as a current source and the other as a current sink this can be regarded as a current dipole. The current injected has to be below the threshold for activation of cells. The position of this dipole can be deduced from magnetic resonance or X-ray images. The current dipole gives rise to a potential distribution at the scalp that can be measured by EEG. The measurements can be compared with the potential distribution that is calculated in a forward computation. Another method is to use the measured potential at the scalp to localize the source and to compare the result with the actual position of the dipole. In this paper the measured potential distributions at the scalp due to implanted dipoles were used to evaluate different volume conductor models. Since intracerebral and subdural electrodes were introduced through trephine holes over the fronto-central areas, and the diameter of the holes was rather large, approximately 23 mm, special effort was put into modelling the skull. Two important assumptions could be validated in this study: the electric currents within the head are Ohmic and a dipole can be used to model the induced electric activity of pairs of contacts on subdural electrodes or intra cerebral electrodes.

Reliability of dipole models of epileptic spikes

OBJECTIVE

In order to validate dipole-modeling results, we compared dipole localizations with the distribution of intracerebral potentials occurring simultaneously with scalp EEG paroxysms.

METHODS

Firstly, scalp EEGs were recorded from 11 patients. Dipole sources were estimated on averaged spikes and projected on 3D-MRIs. Secondly, stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) was recorded from implanted electrodes with direct identification onto MRI. Simultaneously with SEEG, control scalp electrodes were pasted where spikes peaked during the first session. SEEG was averaged, triggered by the main peak of scalp spikes.

RESULTS

SEEG activity during scalp spikes always involved several contacts. In 13 of 14 spikes, maximal fields occurred in neocortical regions. In 4 of 5 cases where intracerebral activity was simple, spikes could be modeled by one source. In all cases where intracerebral activity was complex, spikes had to be modeled by several sources. The main dipole source was 11 +/- 4.2 mm from the SEEG contact showing the maximal intracerebral potential. Early and late dipole localization and SEEG fields were concordant in two thirds of cases.

CONCLUSION

Results indicate that in our group of patients scalp spikes reflect activity in large neocortical areas and never activity limited to mesial structures. Dipole locations and time activation were confirmed most often and were more reliable for sources representing the main negative component than for early or late sources.