The ineffective loading process of the embryo transfer catheter alters implantation and pregnancy rates

Steps forward in embryo transfer technique: a retrospective study comparing direct versus afterload catheters at different time frames

PURPOSE

To assess whether embryo transfer (ET) technique can influence the clinical pregnancy rate (CPR) and its correlation with the embryo transfer difficulty.

DESIGN

This single center retrospective cohort analysis of fresh and frozen single blastocyst transfers performed between January 2016 and December 2021 included fresh and frozen single blastocyst transfers performed during the study timeframe. Direct technique was the only one used from January 2016 to September 2017. From September 2017 to March 2019, the choice between the two techniques was given by randomization, due to a clinical trial recruitment. From April 2019, only the afterload technique was used. Preimplantation genetic testing cycles and gamete donation procedures and cycles performed with external gametes or embryos were excluded. CPR was the primary outcome, while difficult transfer rate the secondary one. Univariate and multivariate logistic regressions were performed.

RESULTS

During the period, 8,189 transfers were performed. CPR of the afterload group resulted significantly higher compared to the direct group (44.69% versus 41.65%, OR 1.13, 95% CI 1.02-1.25, p = 0.017) and the rate of difficult transfers two-thirds lower (9.06% versus 26.85%, OR 0.27, 95% CI 0.24-0.31, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Our study demonstrated that CPR is significantly affected by the ET technique. In particular, with the afterload protocol, both CPR and easy transfer rates increased.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

http://clinicaltrials.gov registration number: NCT05364528, retrospectively registered on 3rd of May 2022.

Evidence and consensus on technical aspects of embryo transfer

BACKGROUND

Ultrasound-guided embryo transfer (US-GET) is a widely performed procedure, but standards for the best practice are not available.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

This document aims to provide an overview of technical aspects of US-GET after considering the published data and including the preparation for the embryo transfer (ET) procedure, the actual procedure, the post-procedure care, associated pathologies, complications and risks, quality assurance and practitioners’ performance.

SEARCH METHODS

A literature search for evidence on key aspects of the ET procedure was carried out from database inception to November 2021. Selected papers (n = 359) relevant to the topic were analysed by the authors. The following key points were considered in the papers: whether ultrasound (US) practice standards were explained, to what extent the ET technique was described and whether complications or incidents and how to prevent such events were reported. In the end, 89 papers could be used to support the recommendations in this document, which focused on transabdominal US-GET.

OUTCOMES

The relevant papers found in the literature search were included in the current document and described according to the topic in three main sections: requirements and preparations prior to ET, the ET procedure, and training and competence for ET. Recommendations are provided on preparations prior to ET, equipment and materials, ET technique, possible risks and complications, training and competence. Specific aspects of the laboratory procedures are covered, in particular the different loading techniques and their potential impact on the final outcomes. Potential future developments and research priorities regarding the ET technique are also outlined.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

Many topics were not covered in the literature review and some recommendations were based on expert opinions and are not necessarily evidence based.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

ET is the last procedural step in an ART treatment and is a crucial step toward achieving a pregnancy and live birth. The current paper set out to bring together the recent developments considering all aspects of ET, especially emphasizing US quality imaging. There are still many questions needing answers, and these can be subject of future research.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

No funding. ADA has received royalties from CRC Press and personal honorarium from Cook, Ferring and Cooper Surgical. The other co-authors have no conflicts of interest to declare that are relevant to the content of this article.

Optimizing embryological aspects of oocyte retrieval, oocyte denudation, and embryo loading for transfer: a state of the art review

Oocyte retrieval, oocyte denudation, and embryo transfer are crucial processes during assisted reproduction (ART). Air quality in the ART laboratory, temperature, pH of the media used and the time interval between oocyte retrieval and insemination are all critical factors. Anesthesia is required for oocyte retrieval, however evidence regarding the potential impact of different methods (general anesthesia, conscious sedation, and local anesthesia) on the clinical outcomes is unclear. The optimal timing of oocyte denudation following retrieval has not been established. Regarding the mechanical denudation process, there is a lack of evidence to demonstrate the safest minimum inner diameter of denuding pipettes used to complete the removal of granulosa cells surrounding the oocytes. During embryo transfer, many clinics worldwide flush the catheter before embryo loading, in an attempt to potentially rinse off any toxic agents; however, there is insufficient evidence to show that flushing the embryo transfer catheter before loading increases the success of ART outcome. Considering the serious gaps in knowledge in ART practice, the aim of this review is to provide an updated overview of the current knowledge regarding the various steps and techniques involved in oocyte retrieval, oocyte denudation, and embryo loading for transfer.

A fine tuning of embryo loading technique by eliminating the air bubble in the outer sheath of embryo catheter among women undergoing IVF treatment

OBJECTIVES

The role of air bubbles in bracketing the embryo-containing medium in inner catheter during embryo transfer (ET) has already been established. However, the role of air bubbles in outer catheter (OC) during implantation is yet to be determined. This study aimed to compare the implantation rates between women who have undergone ET with or without ASP (Vitrolife^®; Sweden), a medium use for oocyte retrieval and rinsing in OC embryo catheter. The purpose of introducing the ASP medium to the OC was to eliminate air bubbles in that space during implantation.

METHODS

A total of 312 women were randomly divided into two groups with 156 participants each group. In Group A, ASP medium was used during ET, whereas in Group B, no ASP medium was utilized. Positive implantation was defined as serum beta-hCG level >5 mIU/mL taken on the 7th day following ET.

RESULTS

The average age of the majority of the participants was 30-39 years and had at least 4-5 years of subfertility. The unexplained subfertility was the prominent cause of ET failure in both groups. In most of the participants in both groups, ET was done using fresh embryo cycles with good to excellent embryo grades. After the ASP medium was manipulated in the OC in both groups, the positive implantation rate was not different in both groups (p>0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The elimination of air bubbles in OC by using the ASP medium during ET did not confer an additional benefit nor exert a negative impact on implantation rate.

Increased implantation rate after intrauterine infusion of a small volume of human chorionic gonadotropin at the time of embryo transfer: a randomized, double-blind controlled study

PURPOSE

Intrauterine human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) infusion at the time of embryo transfer (ET) has resulted in controversial results. We evaluated the effects of intrauterine infusion of a small volume of hCG at the time of ET in fresh and frozen-thawed cycles.

METHODS

Infertile women scheduled for ET with either fresh or frozen-thawed cycles were enrolled and randomized into two groups (n = 100 each): an hCG group, who received 500 IU of hCG in 10 µL culture medium infused into the uterine cavity using a soft catheter 4 min before ET; and a control group, who received 10 µL of culture medium alone by the same technique. The primary outcome was the implantation rate. The secondary outcomes were clinical pregnancy and live birth rate.

RESULTS

Two hundred infertile women aged 18-43 years, undergoing fresh or frozen-thawed ET were enrolled, regardless of any previous transfer cycles. The implantation rate was significantly higher in the hCG group compared with the control group (28.8% vs. 18.2%, p = 0.030). The clinical pregnancy rates were similar in both groups (42% vs. 30%, p = 0.077). The live birth rates were also similar (29% and 23% in the hCG and control group, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Intrauterine infusion of a small volume of hCG at the time of ET can significantly improve the implantation rate, while the clinical pregnancy rate may only be improved in younger patients (aged < 40 years). This technique may thus be of benefit to patients undergoing clinical infertility treatment.

Numerical simulation of embryo transfer: how the viscosity of transferred medium affects the transport of embryos

Background

Embryo transfer (ET) is a key step of assisted reproductive procedures, where the transferred medium containing the embryos is injected into the uterine cavity through a transcervical catheter and blended with intrauterine fluid in the uterine cavity. This procedure determines the delivery sites of embryos in the uterine cavity and has crucial impact on the implantation. Due to practical restrictions and ethical issues, it is often difficult to perform an in vivo study in humans to examine factors that affect the motions and delivery of embryos during ET. Alternatively, mathematical modeling is a powerful tool to that end.

Results

A computational model is developed to simulate the intrauterine mixing flow and track the embryo motions. Two important factors affecting the intrauterine flow are studied via this model: the viscosity of the transferred medium and the injection speed. Numerical results show that the dispersion pattern and the final delivery sites of the embryos are significantly influenced by the viscosity of the transferred medium. Specially, increasing the transferred medium viscosity close to that of the uterine fluid can enhance the probability that the embryos are delivered close to the fundus and keep them from being dragged backward to the cervix during catheter withdrawal. In addition, a slow injection speed can lower the driving force on the embryo during ET, which can prevent the embryo from being injured.

Conclusions

Based on our study, the practice of using a transferred medium with similar viscosity to that of the uterine fluid and a slow injection speed is recommended for real embryo transfer procedures in clinic.

Low versus high volume of culture medium during embryo transfer: a randomized clinical trial

PURPOSE

The aim of this prospective randomized control trial was to evaluate if the use of two different volumes (20-25 vs 40-45 μl) of media used for embryo transfer affects the clinical outcomes in fresh in vitro fertilization (IVF) cycles.

METHODS

In total, 236 patients were randomized in two groups, i.e., "low volume" group (n = 118) transferring the embryos with 20-25 μl of medium and "high volume" group (n = 118) transferring the embryos with 40-45 μl of medium. The clinical pregnancy, implantation, and ongoing pregnancy rates were compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

No statistically significant differences were observed in clinical pregnancy (46.8 vs 54.3%, p = 0.27), implantation (23.7 vs 27.8%, p = 0.30), and ongoing pregnancy (33.3 vs 40.0%, p = 0.31) rates between low and high volume group, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Higher volume of culture medium to load the embryo into the catheter during embryo transfer does not influence the clinical outcome in fresh IVF cycles.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT03350646.

How do laboratory embryo transfer techniques affect IVF outcomes? A review of current literature

Over the last few years, many studies have focused on embryo selection methods, whereas little attention has been given to the standardization of the procedure of embryo transfer. In this review, several parameters of the embryo transfer procedure are examined, such as the: (i) culture medium volume and loading technique; (ii) syringe and catheters used for embryo transfer; (iii) viscosity and composition of the embryo transfer medium; (iv) environment of embryo culture; (v) timing of embryo transfer; (vi) and standardization of the embryo transfer techniques. The aim of this manuscript is to review these factors and compare the existing embryo transfer techniques and highlight the need for better embryo transfer standardization.

The effect of embryo catheter loading technique on the live birth rate

Objective

Embryo loading (EL) is a major step in embryo transfer (ET) and affect on the success of in vitro fertilization (IVF). This study aimed to compare the effect of two different EL techniques on the rates of pregnancy and delivery in IVF/ET cycles.

Methods

207 fresh ET and 194 Frozen-thawed ET (FET) cycles were included in this retrospective study. Two groups (A and B) were defined based on the EL technique used. In group A, the entire catheter was flushed with Ham's F-10 medium. The embryos were then drawn into the catheter using one air bracket. In group B, 70 µL of air was aspirated into the syringe and the catheter was flushed using Ham's F10 medium. The medium, air, embryos, air, and finally another layer of medium were then sequentially drawn into the catheter. The main outcome measures were the pregnancy and delivery rates.

Results

The groups did not differ with respect to the etiology of infertility, the source of spermatozoa, the quality of the embryos, the type of EL catheter, and the ease of transfer. The pregnancy rate was similar between two groups. In fresh ET cycles, a higher delivery rate was observed in group B than it group A (78.1% vs. 60%, p=0.1). In FET cycles, the rate of delivery was significantly higher in group B than in group A to a nonsignificant extent (88.9% vs. 58.8%, p=0.06).

Conclusion

EL techniques did not have a significant impact on the delivery rate in either fresh or FET cycles.

Embryo catheter loading and embryo culture techniques: results of a worldwide Web-based survey

PURPOSE

To identify trends in embryo catheter loading and embryo culture techniques performed worldwide.

METHODS

A retrospective evaluation using the results of a web-based survey, (IVF Worldwide ( www.IVF-worldwide.com ), was performed.

RESULTS

Responses from 265 centers in 71 countries were obtained. Most centers (97 %) preferred a catheter with its orifice on top, with only 3 % preferring a catheter with the orifice on its side; 41 % preferred a catheter marked for clear ultrasound view. The most commonly-reported methods of embryo loading were medium-air-embryo-air-medium (42 %), medium in catheter with embryo at end (20 %) and medium-air-embryo (15 %). In 68 % of centers the final volume of the catheter was up to 0.3 ml, with only 19 % using 0.3-0.5 ml and 1 % using 0.5-0.7 ml. Using reduced oxygen concentrations for embryo culture was divided between those who used it in combination with the two-gas system (34 %) and those who did not use it at all (39 %); 24 % reported using a three-gas system. Most clinics using reduced oxygen concentrations used it throughout the entire culture period. Half of centers (51 %) reported using reduced oxygen concentrations for the entire IVF population while 6 % reserved it only for blastocyst transfer. The use of sequential media was highly dominant with 40 % reporting its use.

Impact of different embryo loading techniques on pregnancy rates in in vitro fertlization/embryo transfer cycles

BACKGROUND

Embryo transfer (ET) technique is one of the important factors of in vitro fertlization success. Among the different steps in ET technique, less attention has been given to embryo loading (EL). The aim was to compare the impact of two different techniques of EL on pregnancy rate in IVF/ET cycles.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this retrospective study, 144 and 170 patients were placed in groups A and B, respectively. In Group A, the embryos were drawn directly into the ET catheter from culture microdrop under the oil. In Group B, the embryos were transferred from culture microdrop into G2 medium in center-well dish. Then, the embryos were drawn into the catheter and finally transferred into the uterus. Both groups were adjusted for other parameters based on the EL technique. The main outcome measure was pregnancy rate.

RESULTS

There were insignificant differences for etiology of infertility, source of sperm, type of stimulation protocol, percent of IVF or intracytoplasmic sperm injection type of ET catheter, cycles with good quality embryos and transferred embryos between two groups. The rate of both chemical and clinical pregnancy was higher in Group B compared to A, but the difference was insignificant (P = 0.09 and P = 0.1, respectively).

CONCLUSION

It seems that there is no difference in the outcome by loading the embryo from microdrop or center-well dish.

Bioengineering Studies of the Embryo Transfer Procedure

Embryo transfer (ET) is the final manual intervention in extracorporeal fertilization in which an embryo is transferred into the uterus by a transcervical catheter. The low rates of embryo implantation within the uterus are attributed, among other factors, to the ET technique, which depends on a multitude of anatomical, physiological, and mechanical aspects. We developed computational and experimental models to simulate ET to examine the contribution of mechanical features to the success of this procedure. The experimental model allowed laboratory simulations of the dispersion of the catheter load as a result of different injection speeds into a tilted uterine model. The mathematical model analyzed potential trajectories of the transferred embryos resulting from the interaction between the injection velocity and the intrauterine flows caused by uterine peristalsis. The simulations revealed the important contribution of mechanical parameters, such as the position of the uterus and the presence of air in the catheter load. The latter was found to increase the potential for the embryo to be near the fundal area during the time limit for implantation. Based on the results of our simulations, we recommended performing ET in a patient-specific position in which the fundus will be the highest point above the horizon and that the load be delivered slowly, that is, not less than 10 s. We also recommended placing the tip of the catheter at the mid cavity to avoid ectopic pregnancy.

A computational parameter study of embryo transfer

Embryo transfer (ET) is the final component of the in vitro fertilization process, and the limiting component to its success rate. The procedure is characterized by considerable technical variations in clinical practice and the effects of these different variations on the overall outcome is little understood. In this article we simulate the embryo transfer procedure based on a 2-dimensional fluid dynamics model and, in a large computational effort, we investigate the sensitivity of embryo placement on an array of procedural parameters. The results support the consensus among practitioners in what is the best choice of procedural factors. Based on the study we propose a set of optimal parameters with which to perform the ET procedure; in addition we suggest a novel technique of volume replacement prior to the catheter withdrawal.

In vitro simulations of embryo transfer in a laboratory model of the uterus

Embryo transfer (ET) is the final manual intervention during which the newly formed embryo is placed within the uterus by a transcervical catheter. The loading of the syringe-catheter complex with the transferred volume consists of the transfer media (which contains the embryos) separated by air spaces on both sides. The dynamics involved in injecting the syringe-catheter complex is not well understood nor has it been investigated to date. We developed an in vitro experimental setup for simulations of ET into a rigid transparent uterine model. The catheter was loaded in sequences of liquid and air as it is in the clinical setting. The transferred liquid was colored with a dye and its dispersion within the uterine cavity was recorded by a video camera. The results demonstrated, for the first time, the importance of having a gas phase in the catheter load. The resulting air bubbles within the uterus were carried upward towards the fundus by buoyant forces, thereby dragging behind them the transferred liquid which contained the embryos. This could be expected to substantially increase the probability for the embryos to be present near the fundal wall at the time window for implantation. There was also evidence of a dependency of the rate of injection upon the catheter load into the uterus: a low speed generated several air bubbles which led to more of the transferred liquid being carried towards the fundal end, thus possibly enhancing the potential for implantation.

Air in the transfer catheter does not affect the success of embryo transfer

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effect on embryo transfer (ET) success of air loaded into the transfer catheter to bracket the embryo-containing medium.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized study.

SETTING

University teaching hospital.

PATIENT(S)

One hundred two consecutive patients undergoing ET after IVF.

INTERVENTION(S)

In group 1 (n = 52), embryos were loaded as follows: 200 microL of air in the syringe, 100-125 microL of air in the proximal part of the catheter, 20-25 microL of medium containing the embryos to be transferred, and 10 microL of air at the tip of the catheter. In group 2 (n = 50), the syringe and the entire catheter were filled with medium and the embryo-containing medium (20-25 microL) was aspirated without being bracketed by air spaces.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Implantation and pregnancy rates.

RESULT(S)

No differences were found between groups 1 and 2 with respect to implantation and pregnancy rates.

CONCLUSION(S)

The air loaded into the transfer catheter to bracket the embryo-containing medium has no negative effect on ET success.