Small flat adenomas appear to have little clinical importance in Western countries

Positive Predictive Value for Colorectal Lesions at CT Colonography: Analysis of Factors Impacting Results in a Large Screening Cohort

OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study is to evaluate factors affecting the positive predictive value (PPV) for detecting colorectal lesions at CT colonography (CTC), using optical colonoscopy (OC) as the reference standard for concordance. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Consecutive CTC studies from a single screening program interpreted as positive for at least one detected colorectal lesion 6 mm or larger and sent for subsequent OC were analyzed according to per-polyp and per-patient results. Univariable and multivariable analysis of multiple input factors was performed. RESULTS. Of 1650 studies (median patient age, 59.7 years; 877 men and 773 women) with 2688 total CTC-detected lesions 6 mm or larger, the overall PPVs were 88.8% (2386/2688) by polyp and 90.8% (1499/1650) by patient. The by-polyp PPV was significantly higher for polypoid (91.2%; 1793/1965) versus flat or nonpolypoid (79.4%; 459/578) lesions (p < 0.0001). Overall per-patient PPVs were 72.3% (1193/1650) for any neoplasia 6 mm or larger and 38.8% (641/1650) for advanced neoplasia. PPVs for advanced neoplasia increased by CTC Reporting and Data System category: 5.8% (45/781) for C2, 67.1% (511/762) for C3, and 79.4% (85/107) for C4. PPVs for cancer also increased by CTC Reporting and Data System category: 0% (0/781) for C2, 2.2% (17/762) for C3, and 52.3% (56/107) for C4. On multivariable regression analysis, polyp morphologic type (flat vs polypoid) and diagnostic confidence were the strongest predictors of CTC-OC concordance. CTC PPV results are somewhat underestimated because 28.8% (87/302) of CTC-OC-discordant results were categorized as likely OC false-negatives at consensus review. CONCLUSION. Concordance between CTC and OC is high for relevant colorectal polyps and masses. Unlike stool-based tests that provide only a binary positive or negative result, CTC can specify the nature of the positive findings, resulting in much greater specificity and risk stratification for patient management decisions.

CT colonography for the detection of nonpolypoid adenomas: sensitivity assessed with restricted national CT colonography trial criteria

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence of nonpolypoid adenomas and the sensitivity of CT colonography (CTC) in their detection by use of the restricted criteria of height-to-width ratio<50% and height elevation≤3 mm.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In the National CT Colonography Trial (American College of Radiology Imaging Network protocol 6664), a cohort of 2531 participants without symptoms underwent CTC and screening colonoscopy. The CTC examinations were interpreted with both 2D and 3D techniques. Nonpolypoid adenomatous polyps identified with CTC or colonoscopy were retrospectively reviewed to determine which polyps met the restricted criteria. The prevalence of nonpolypoid adenomas and the prospective sensitivity of CTC were determined. Descriptive statistics were used to report the prevalence, size, and histologic features. The sensitivities (with 95% CIs) for nonpolypoid and polypoid lesions were compared by two-sided Z test for independent binomial proportions.

RESULTS

The retrospective review confirmed 21 nonpolypoid adenomas, yielding a prevalence of 0.83% (21 of 2531 participants). Eight (38.1%) were advanced adenomas, many (50% [4/8]) only because of large size (≥10 mm). The overall per polyp sensitivity of CTC (combined 2D and 3D interpretation) for detecting nonpolypoid adenomas≥5 mm (n=21) was 0.76; ≥6 mm (n=16), 0.75; and ≥10 mm (n=5), 0.80. These values were not statistically different from the sensitivity of detecting polypoid adenomas (p>0.37).

CONCLUSION

In this large screening population, nonpolypoid adenomas had a very low prevalence (<1%), and advanced pathologic features were uncommon in polyps<10 mm in diameter. Most nonpolypoid adenomas are technically visible at CTC. The prospective sensitivity is similar to that for polypoid adenomas when the interpretation combines both 2D and 3D review.

Carpet lesions detected at CT colonography: clinical, imaging, and pathologic features

PURPOSE

To describe carpet lesions (laterally spreading tumors ≥ 3 cm) detected at computed tomographic (CT) colonography, including their clinical, imaging, and pathologic features.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The imaging reports for 9152 consecutive adults undergoing initial CT colonography at a tertiary center were reviewed in this HIPAA-compliant, institutional review board-approved retrospective study to identify all potential carpet lesions detected at CT colonography. Carpet lesions were defined as morphologically flat, laterally spreading tumors 3 cm or larger. For those patients with neoplastic carpet lesions, CT colonography studies were analyzed to determine maximal lesion width and height, oral contrast material coating, segmental location, and computer-aided detection (CAD) findings. Demographic data and details of clinical treatment in these patients were reviewed.

RESULTS

Eighteen carpet lesions in 18 patients (0.2%; mean age, 67.1 years; eight men, 10 women) were identified and were subsequently confirmed at colonoscopy and pathologic examination among 20 potential flat masses (≥3 cm) prospectively identified at CT colonography (there were two nonneoplastic rectal false-positive findings). No additional neoplastic carpet lesions were found in the cohort undergoing colonoscopy after CT colonography and/or surgery (there were no false-negatives). Mean lesion width was 46.5 mm (range, 30-80 mm); mean lesion height was 7.9 mm (range, 4-14 mm). Surface retention of oral contrast material was noted in all 18 cases. All but two lesions were located in the distal rectosigmoid or proximal right colon. At CAD, 17 (94.4%) lesions were detected (mean, 6.2 CAD marks per lesion). Sixteen lesions (88.9%) demonstrated advanced histologic features, including a villous component (n = 11), high-grade dysplasia (n = 4), and invasive cancer (n = 5). Sixteen patients (88.9%) required surgical treatment for complete excision.

CONCLUSION

CT colonography can effectively depict carpet lesions. Common features in this series included older patient age, rectal or cecal location, surface coating with oral contrast material, multiple CAD hits, advanced yet typically benign histologic features, and surgical treatment.

Flat colon polyps: what should radiologists know?

With the recent publication of international computed tomography (CT) colonography standards, which aim to improve quality of examinations, this review informs radiologists about the significance of flat polyps (adenomas and hyperplastic polyps) in colorectal cancer pathways. We describe flat polyp classification systems and propose how flat polyps should be reported to ensure patient management strategies are based on polyp morphology as well as size. Indeed, consistency when describing flat polyps is of increasing importance given the strengthening links between CT colonography and endoscopy.

Flat (nonpolypoid) colorectal lesions identified at CT colonography in a U.S. screening population

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to investigate the clinical importance and height definition of flat (nonpolypoid) colorectal lesions detected on screening computed tomographic colonography (CTC).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Results from prospective screening CTC in 5107 consecutive asymptomatic adults (mean age, 56.9 years) at a single center were analyzed. All detected colorectal lesions > or = 6 mm were prospectively categorized as polypoid or flat (nonpolypoid). The maximal height of all flat lesions was measured to assess the suggested 3-mm threshold definition.

RESULTS

Of 954 polyps measuring > or = 6 mm identified on screening CTC, 125 lesions (13.1%) in 106 adults were prospectively categorized as flat, with a mean size of 12.7 mm (range, 6-80 mm), including 73 lesions 6 to 9 mm, 42 lesions 10 to 29 mm, and 10 lesions > or = 3 cm (carpet lesions). For polyps between 6 and 30 mm in size, flat lesions were less likely than polypoid lesions to be neoplastic (25.0% vs 60.3%, P < .001), histologically advanced (5.4% vs 12.1%, P = .07) or malignant (0% vs 0.5%, P = NS). Two of 10 carpet lesions (20%) were malignant, compared to 50% of polypoid masses > or = 3 cm. Of nine flat lesions seen only on colonoscopy (false-negatives on CTC), two were neoplastic (tubular adenomas), and none was histologically advanced. For all flat lesions between 6 and 30 mm, the maximal height averaged 2.2 mm and was < or =3 mm in 86.1%, including 93.2% of small 6-mm to 9-mm flat lesions.

CONCLUSION

In a US screening population, flat colorectal lesions detected on CTC demonstrated less aggressive histologic features compared to polypoid lesions. Excluding carpet lesions, a maximal height of 3 mm appears to be a reasonable definition.

Flat colorectal neoplasms and the impact of the revised Vienna Classification on their reporting: a case-control study in UK and Japanese patients

OBJECTIVE

The prevalence and interpretation of flat colorectal neoplasms in the East or West remain highly variable. Several factors may contribute to this variability including differences in reporting techniques between Japanese and Western histopathologists when lesions are classified. The aims of this study were (i) to determine the frequency and characteristics of flat colorectal neoplasms in British and Japanese patients, (ii) to examine whether histopathological discrepancies exist between Western and Japanese-trained pathologists applying conventional classification methods and (iii) to determine the impact of the revised Vienna Classification on any differences observed.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

One hundred and forty-four patients in the United Kingdom with neoplastic lesions prospectively identified by a colonoscopist, fully-trained in Japan, were age and gender-matched with 144 Japanese patients with neoplastic lesions detected by the same colonoscopist. Two British and two Japanese pathologists were independently asked to assess all neoplasms using both conventional and revised Vienna Classification methods.

RESULTS

No significant difference in the frequency of flat neoplasms was found between British and Japanese patients; however, flat neoplasia from Japanese patients tended to contain more advanced pathologies. Discrepancies in histological diagnoses were observed between pathologists but which were reduced with the revised Vienna Classification. Japanese pathologists tended to diagnose higher grades of dysplasia for the same lesion compared to their British counterparts.

CONCLUSIONS

The frequency of flat neoplasms in British and Japanese patients is similar. However, Japanese lesions, especially flat (IIb) and slightly depressed (IIc) neoplasms tend to be more biologically aggressive. The revised Vienna Classification achieves greater consensus.

Microsatellite analysis of sporadic flat and depressed lesions of the colon

Prior studies of molecular and genetic derangements in flat and depressed lesions of the colon have revealed lower frequencies in a number of markers commonly present in exophytic lesions. These and other differences suggest that flat lesions are driven by alternative pathways. We reviewed a database of patients who had undergone endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR) for flat and depressed lesions at the University of Chicago from January 2001 to April 2003. Formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded colonic samples were retrieved from the tissue bank, and five standardized mononucleotide and dinucleotide microsatellite regions were analyzed for instability (MSI) using fluorescently labeled forward primers in nonmultiplex reactions. Sixteen patients were identified with flat or depressed lesions who had adequate tissue specimens available for MSI analysis. Of these specimens, eight were tubular adenomas, three were tubulovillous adenomas, and five were carcinomas in situ. Four of the lesions were microsatellite unstable, each at a single locus, and one lesion showed probable instability at a second locus. Eleven lesions were microsatellite stable. Aberrations in DNA repair mechanisms do not appear to significantly contribute to the molecular derangements underlying sporadic flat or depressed colonic lesions. The molecular bases that underlie the aggressive behavior of sporadic flat and depressed lesions remain to be determined, and further investigation is warranted.

Flat Colorectal Lesions: Colonoscopic Detection Without Dye Spray or Magnification and Clinical Significance

OBJECTIVE

The detection of flat colorectal lesions with possible malignant potential has been described by Japanese endoscopists. This study looks at the detection of flat lesions using standard colonoscopic techniques and examines the clinical significance of these lesions.

METHODS

The records of patients who underwent complete colonoscopy by a single colorectal surgeon in an outpatient setting over a 4-year period were reviewed. The site and number of flat lesions and their histology were noted. Patients with incomplete intubation of the colon were excluded.

RESULTS

A total of 491 patients underwent 593 colonoscopic examinations. There were 236 flat lesions identified in 91 patients: 24% (56/236) were adenomas showing mild or moderate dysplasia, and 63% (148/236) were hyperplastic.

CONCLUSIONS

Flat colorectal lesions are common and can be detected without the aid of dye spray and magnification. One-quarter of these lesions are adenomatous and we recommend routine hot biopsy or polypectomy of these lesions.

Chromoendoscopy of the colon

Chromoendoscopy is a technique that uses tissue stains to better characterize, delineate, or highlight the gastrointestinal mucosa. Chromoendoscopy of the colon has the potential to significantly aid the endoscopist in the recognition and identification of mucosal abnormalities ranging from inflammation to neoplasia.

Flat and depressed colorectal tumours in a southern Swedish population: a prospective chromoendoscopic and histopathological study

BACKGROUND

Flat and depressed colorectal tumours are common in Japan but are very rare or non-existent in Western countries.

AIMS

To study the occurrence of flat colorectal tumours in a southern Swedish population.

METHODS

In this prospective study, 371 consecutive European patients were examined by high resolution video colonoscopy combined with chromoendoscopy. The nature of the lesions was determined by histopathological examination.

RESULTS

A total of 973 tumours were found; 907 (93.2%) were protruding and 66 (6.8%) were flat or depressed. Of the flat/depressed tumours, five (7.7%) were early adenocarcinomas infiltrating the submucosa. Eleven carcinomas (1.2%) were found among protruding tumours. High grade dysplasia was observed in 18% (n=11) of flat/depressed adenomas in contrast with 7.3% (n=65) of protruding adenomas, and occurred in smaller flat/depressed tumours compared with protruding ones (mean diameter 8 mm v 23 mm, respectively). Furthermore, high grade dysplasia was significantly more common in flat elevated tumours with central depression or in depressed adenomas (35.7%; 5/14) than in flat elevated adenomas (12.8%; 6/47).

CONCLUSION

Flat and depressed tumours exist in a Western population. Future studies should address whether or not chromoendoscopy with video colonoscopy is necessary in the search for flat colorectal neoplasms.

Prevalence and distinctive biologic features of flat colorectal adenomas in a North American population

BACKGROUND & AIMS

To assess the prevalence of flat and depressed (F&D) colorectal adenomas in the United States, we performed a prospective study of 211 American patients.

METHODS

Dye-assisted colonoscopy was performed in the presence of both an American and a Japanese investigator.

RESULTS

F&D lesions were found in 22.7% of patients, and these were more likely to be adenomatous than polypoid lesions (82% vs. 67%; P = 0.03) and contained more invasive cancer (4.5% vs. 0%; P = 0.04), which also appeared to be at a disproportionately advanced stage. The average size of all F&D advanced lesions (high-grade dysplasia and cancer) was significantly smaller than comparable polypoid lesions (10.75 +/- 2.7 mm vs. 20 +/- 2.9 mm; P < 0.05). F&D adenomas showed significantly stronger fragile histidine triad (FHIT) expression and lower p53 reactivity than similarly sized polypoid adenomas, whereas proliferative and apoptotic indices were similar in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that there is a significant prevalence of colonic F&D colorectal adenomas in this country and that these lesions have significantly different biologic features than polypoid lesions. The clinical and epidemiologic implications of these findings for American patients need to be addressed in further studies.

Potential new endoscopic techniques for the earlier diagnosis of pre-malignancy

Light interacts with tissue in a variety of ways, including absorption, fluorescence, elastic scattering and Raman scattering. These interactions enable a number of promising technologies for endoscopic diagnosis of pre-malignancy, including chromoscopy; fluorescence, scattering and Raman spectroscopies; and optical coherence tomography. Although still in various stages of technical development and clinical trials, these optical diagnostic techniques are demonstrating strong potential to significantly enhance the clinical endoscopist's ability to detect dysplasia in gastrointestinal mucosae.

Small flat umbilicated tumors of the colon: radiographic and pathologic findings

OBJECTIVE

We describe the radiographic and pathologic findings of small flat umbilicated tumors of the colon detected on double-contrast barium enema examinations performed in a Western population.

CONCLUSION

Unlike those reported by Japanese authors, the small flat umbilicated tumors of the colon in our patients were usually hyperplastic polyps, previously called "inverted hyperplastic polyps." Nevertheless, colonoscopy with excisional biopsy is warranted for such tumors detected on double-contrast barium enema examinations because of the small possibility that these tumors represent adenoma or even early adenocarcinoma.

Early colorectal cancer: flat or depressed type

The present review describes the changes in views about the early forms of colorectal cancers. In 1985, a concept of 'flat adenoma' was born in Japan. At around the same time, depressed type early colorectal cancers started to be reported by Japanese colonoscopists. Neither flat adenomas nor depressed lesions have been frequently reported in Western countries, but increasing numbers of such cases are now described. The problem is that flat adenomas and depressed lesions seem to have been confused by many researchers. The biological aggressiveness of these lesions is quite different. The rate of submucosal invasion is very high in depressed lesions, but fairly low in small flat adenomas. Some adenomas may even look depressed at first, but such lesions should not be mistaken for truly depressed lesions. Ignorance or resistance to the concept may inhibit the detection of flat or depressed lesions. Differences of diagnostic criteria between Japanese and Western pathologists may influence the apparent frequency of mucosal cancers, but not that of invasive carcinomas. Many small adenomas do not grow if followed, but depressed lesions grow rapidly and invade the deeper layers and, as a result, may look elevated as a whole. Many cases in previously published papers suggest that small depressed carcinomas of the large intestine may develop without a precursory stage of an adenomatous polyp. At least two carcinogenic pathways, one through adenomatous polyps and one de novo, should be recognized. In addition, the importance of small depressed cancers should be emphasized.

Clinicopathological features of superficial depressed-type colorectal neoplastic lesions

OBJECTIVE

We performed this study to analyze the endoscopic findings, dissecting microscopic features, and p53 immunostaining in superficial depressed-type (depressed) colorectal neoplastic lesions.

METHODS

Dissecting stereomicroscopy was used to ascertain the size and pit pattern of lesions removed by endoscopic snare polypectomy. Immunohistochemical staining of p53 was performed with an antigen retrieval system using a monoclonal antibody to p53.

RESULTS

All depressed neoplastic lesions (submucosal carcinoma, n = 6; high-grade dysplasia, n = 14; and adenoma, n = 30) were small (< 1 cm in diameter) and were detected as a depression with or without a marginal elevation on colonoscopic examination. In the dissecting microscopic study, submucosal carcinomas and lesions of high-grade dysplasia almost exclusively showed irregular small pits, with the exception of four malignant lesions with moderate submucosal invasion in which the pit structure was absent. In contrast, adenomas had either regular small (29/30 lesions) or oval pits (1/30 lesions). Rates of p53 positivity were 100%, 64%, and 7% in depressed submucosal carcinomas, lesions of high-grade dysplasia, and adenomas, respectively, thus the prevalence of p53 positivity was significantly higher in the former two groups than in the adenoma group.

CONCLUSIONS

The high frequency of invasive carcinoma and high-grade dysplasia found in depressed colorectal neoplastic tumors, despite their small size, indicates that these lesions may be a subtype of colorectal tumor with more aggressive malignant potential at an earlier stage.

Rectal cancer after sulindac therapy for a sporadic adenomatous colonic polyp

Like adenomatous polyps in familial adenomatous polyposis, some sporadic colorectal polyps have been reported to regress in response to sulindac administration. However, a rapidly growing invasive rectal cancer developed in one of 15 patients with sulindac-treated sporadic adenomatous colorectal polyps 16 months after sulindac treatment. In this patient, both the adenomatous polyp that responded partially to sulindac and the rectal cancer developing after sulindac therapy showed immunostaining for cyclooxygenase-2. Although short term sulindac therapy seems to be able to cause some adenomatous colorectal polyps to regress, 4 months of sulindac therapy may not reliably prevent colorectal cancer development in these patients.

Differences in the diagnostic criteria used by Japanese and Western pathologists to diagnose colorectal carcinoma

BACKGROUND

In view of the many studies of early stage colorectal carcinoma from Japan, it is essential to know whether the criteria for the histologic diagnosis of colorectal carcinoma are similar in Japan and Western countries.

METHODS

Eight expert pathologists from Japan (4), North America (2), and Europe (2) individually reviewed microscope slides of 20 colorectal lesions from Japanese patients who had undergone endoscopic mucosal resection or surgery because early stage carcinoma and/or adenoma was suspected. The pathologists indicated the pathologic findings on which they based each diagnosis.

RESULTS

For 11 slides that showed adenoma according to the Western pathologists with low grade dysplasia according to at least half of them, the Japanese diagnosed definite carcinoma with or without adenoma in 4 cases and adenoma in 5, and in 2 cases they were equally divided between a diagnosis of adenoma and carcinoma. For five slides showing adenoma with high grade dysplasia according to the Western pathologists, the Japanese diagnosed definite carcinoma with adenoma in three cases and adenoma in one, and in one case they were equally divided between a diagnosis of adenoma and carcinoma. For one case in which the Western pathologists were equally divided between a diagnosis of carcinoma and adenoma with high grade dysplasia, all the Japanese pathologists diagnosed definite carcinoma with or without adenoma. Three slides showed definite carcinoma with or without adenoma, according to both the Western and the Japanese pathologists. The presence of invasion was the most important diagnostic criterion of colorectal carcinoma for the Western pathologists, whereas for the Japanese the nuclear features and glandular structures were more important.

CONCLUSIONS

In Japan, colorectal carcinoma is diagnosed on the basis of nuclear and structural criteria, even in cases considered by Western pathologists to be noninvasive lesions with low grade dysplasia. This diagnostic practice may contribute to the relatively high incidence of early stage colorectal carcinoma reported in Japan as compared with Western countries.

Initial management and follow-up surveillance of patients with colorectal adenomas

The clinical management of patients with adenomas is interesting because of the adenomas' malignant potential, the availability of effective intervention by colonoscopy, and the increasing number of patients having adenomas detected and removed. The current literature on follow-up surveillance is reviewed, and surveillance intervals are suggested based on data from the National Polyp Study. Patients newly diagnosed with three or more adenomas, an adenoma of more than 0.5 cm, or with a family history of colorectal cancer should have surveillance colonoscopy at 3 years following the polypectomy. Surveillance of patients with single, small tubular adenomas can be extended to 5 or more years. Patients with large sessile or malignant adenomas need to have follow-up earlier. Identification and removal of adenomatous polyps have been shown to reduce colorectal cancer incidence.