Serrated adenoma of the colorectum: colonoscopic and histologic features

A Retrospective Analysis of Colorectal Serrated Lesions from 2005 to 2014 in a Single Center: Importance of the Establishment of Diagnostic Patterns

Background

Serrated colorectal lesions are increasingly recognized as an important process in the development of colorectal cancer. Endoscopic and histological diagnosis may be difficult, and knowledge of the serrated lesions is important for the establishment of strategies for treating colorectal lesions. We aimed to analyze serrated lesions diagnosed at a single center and evaluate if there was an increase in their identification over the years.

Design and Setting

A retrospective analysis of colonoscopy reports was performed at a specialized center from 2005 to 2014.

Methods

Colonoscopy reports about any resected endoscopic lesions were reviewed and subjected to histological diagnosis from 2005 to 2014. Then, serrated lesions were evaluated based on morphological characterization, location, size, occurrence of synchronous lesions, and the patient's history of colorectal cancer and polyps.

Results

A total of 2126 colonoscopy examination reports were reviewed, and 3494 lesions were analyzed. On histopathological examination, 1089 (31.2%) were classified as hyperplastic polyps, 22 (0.6%) as sessile serrated adenomas, and 21 (0.6%) as traditional serrated adenomas. There was an increase in the number of cases of sessile and traditional serrated adenomas diagnosed after 2010. Before 2010, two cases of sessile serrated adenomas and seven cases of traditional serrated adenomas were diagnosed; after 2010, 20 cases of sessile serrated adenoma and 14 cases of traditional serrated adenomas were diagnosed.

Conclusion

There was an increase in the diagnosis of sessile serrated adenomas over the years, which can be attributed to better accuracy in colonoscopy and histological classification.

Subtypes of the Type II Pit Pattern Reflect Distinct Molecular Subclasses in the Serrated Neoplastic Pathway

BACKGROUND

Colorectal serrated lesions (SLs) are important premalignant lesions whose clinical and biological features are not fully understood.

AIMS

We aimed to establish accurate colonoscopic diagnosis and treatment of SLs through evaluation of associations among the morphological, pathological, and molecular characteristics of SLs.

METHODS

A total of 388 premalignant and 18 malignant colorectal lesions were studied. Using magnifying colonoscopy, microsurface structures were assessed based on Kudo's pit pattern classification system, and the Type II pit pattern was subcategorized into classical Type II, Type II-Open (Type II-O) and Type II-Long (Type II-L). BRAF/KRAS mutations and DNA methylation of CpG island methylator phenotype (CIMP) markers (MINT1, - 2, - 12, - 31, p16, and MLH1) were analyzed through pyrosequencing.

RESULTS

Type II-O was tightly associated with sessile serrated adenoma/polyps (SSA/Ps) with BRAF mutation and CIMP-high. Most lesions with simple Type II or Type II-L were hyperplastic polyps, while mixtures of Type II or Type II-L plus more advanced pit patterns (III/IV) were characteristic of traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs). Type II-positive TSAs frequently exhibited BRAF mutation and CIMP-low, while Type II-L-positive TSAs were tightly associated with KRAS mutation and CIMP-low. Analysis of lesions containing both premalignant and cancerous components suggested Type II-L-positive TSAs may develop into KRAS-mutated/CIMP-low/microsatellite stable cancers, while Type II-O-positive SSA/Ps develop into BRAF-mutated/CIMP-high/microsatellite unstable cancers.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that Type II subtypes reflect distinct molecular subclasses in the serrated neoplasia pathway and that they could be useful hallmarks for identifying SLs at high risk of developing into CRC.

Optical biopsy of sessile serrated adenomas: do these lesions resemble hyperplastic polyps under narrow-band imaging?

BACKGROUND

Serrated colorectal lesions include hyperplastic polyps (HPs) and sessile serrated adenomas (SSAs). Optical biopsy could misclassify SSAs as unimportant if they resemble HPs.

OBJECTIVE

To explore the narrow-band imaging (NBI) features of SSAs. We hypothesized that SSAs resemble HPs under NBI.

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of data from our prospective study of NBI in routine practice.

SETTING

Single specialty group.

PATIENTS

Patients undergoing colonoscopy.

INTERVENTION

Colonoscopy.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

Polyp histology prediction by community gastroenterologists. Features of SSAs versus HPs and adenomas by using the Narrow-Band Imaging International Colorectal Endoscopic (NICE) Classification.

RESULTS

Among 2388 lesions, 141 were diagnosed on pathology as SSAs, 465 as HPs, and 1546 as adenomas. Each individual NICE feature of HPs was found in 38% to 42% of SSAs, 66% to 67% of HPs, and 15% to 20% of adenomas (P < .001 for each). Each individual NICE feature of adenomas was found in 57% to 62% of SSAs, 33% to 34% of HPs, and 80% to 84% of adenomas (P < .001 for each). Compared with HPs, SSAs were less likely (odds ratio [OR] 0.74; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.69-0.79) and adenomas were even less likely (OR 0.62; 95% CI, 0.59-0.64) to have all 3 NICE features of HPs. SSAs >5 mm were more likely than smaller SSAs to have all 3 NICE features of adenomas. SSA location did not predict NBI features. Analyses restricted to high-confidence lesions showed similar results.

LIMITATIONS

The endoscopists were not NBI experts.

CONCLUSION

Community gastroenterologists observed a profile of NICE features among SSAs that was intermediate to the profiles observed for HPs and adenomas. These results require confirmation by NBI experts.

Traditional serrated adenoma of the colorectum: clinicopathologic implications and endoscopic findings of the precursor lesions

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the clinicopathologic and endoscopic features of precursor lesions associated with traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs).

METHODS

Mutation studies for BRAF, KRAS, PIK3CA, and EGFR and immunohistochemical staining for Ki-67 were performed on 107 TSAs from 104 patients.

RESULTS

Nondysplastic hyperplastic polyp (HP) or sessile serrated adenoma/polyp (SSA/P) precursor lesions were found in 56 (52.3%) TSAs, among which 32 (57.1%) cases showed a flat-elevated lesion with a type II pit pattern during endoscopy. TSAs with an SSA/P precursor lesion were usually found in the proximal colon, while TSAs with an HP or with no precursor lesion were mainly located in the distal colon and rectum (P < .001). TSAs with a precursor lesion showed a lower frequency of conventional epithelial dysplasia and KRAS mutation as well as a higher frequency of BRAF mutation compared with those with no precursor lesion (P = .002, P < .001, and P < .001, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

A significant proportion of HP or SSA/P precursor lesions accompanied by TSAs can be detected by endoscopy based on both their flat-elevated growth and type II pit patterns. The heterogeneity of TSAs in terms of clinicopathologic and molecular features correlated with the status or type of precursor lesions.

Endoscopic features of colorectal serrated lesions using image-enhanced endoscopy with pathological analysis

OBJECTIVE

To clarify of the features of sessile serrated adenoma/polyp (SSA/P) observed with image-enhanced endoscopy using immunohistochemical staining.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-five hyperplastic polyps (HP) and 46 SSA/P were studied with autofluorescence imaging (AFI) and magnifying endoscopy with narrow-band imaging (ME-NBI). AFI color change, capillary dilatation, existence of a mucous layer on the tumor surface, and pit dilatation under ME-NBI were examined retrospectively. Immunohistochemical staining was performed with the proliferation-associated antigen MIB-1 (Ki-67).

RESULTS

Using AFI, a magenta color was observed in 32% of HP and 44% of SSA/P. With NBI observation, capillary dilatation was observed in 4% of HP and 11% of SSA/P, a mucous cap was observed in 60% of HP and 94% of SSA/P, and pit dilatation was observed in 28% of HP and 80% of SSA/P. When magenta color, capillary dilatation, mucous cap, and pit dilatation were used for the differential diagnosis of SSA/P from HP, the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were 43, 68, and 52% for AFI, respectively, 10, 96, and, 41% for capillary dilatation, respectively, 94, 40, and 75% for mucous cap, respectively, and 80, 72, and 78% for pit dilatation, respectively. Compared with HP, MIB-1-positive cells were more frequently distributed in the gland's intermediate zone in SSA/P.

CONCLUSION

The biological malignant potential of SSA/P could be higher compared with HP as suggested by the MIB-1 stain. Therefore, endoscopic differentiation of SSA/P from HP is important, and the findings of a mucous cap and dilatated pit might be helpful for the differentiation of SSA/P from HP.

Serrated polyposis syndrome and the role of serrated polyps in colorectal cancer development

SUMMARY Serrated polyposis syndrome is characterized by the presence of multiple colorectal serrated polyps and is associated with an increased colorectal cancer risk. The mixture of distinct precursor lesion types and malignancies in serrated polyposis syndrome provides a unique model to study the recently proposed serrated neoplasia pathway. This pathway involves the progression of serrated polyps, that is, hyperplastic polyps, sessile serrated adenoma/polyps and/or traditional serrated adenomas, to colorectal cancer. The early genetic events of this route, as currently identified, are BRAF or KRAS mutations and an enhanced CPG island methylation status of multiple genes. There is evidence to suggest that a proportion of sporadic colorectal cancers originate from serrated polyps, which encompass molecular sequences of events such as hypermethylation of different genes and BRAF mutations. This review discusses the characteristics and clinical relevance of serrated polyps and provides an overview of the clinical aspects and treatment of serrated polyposis syndrome.

Endoscopic and surgical management of serrated colonic polyps

BACKGROUND

Serrated polyps are an inhomogeneous group of lesions that harbour precursors of colorectal cancer. Current research has been directed at further defining the histopathological characteristics of these lesions, but definitive treatment recommendations are unclear. The aim was to review the current literature regarding classification, molecular genetics and natural history of these lesions in order to propose a treatment algorithm for surgeons to consider.

METHODS

The PubMed database was searched using the following search terms: serrated polyp, serrated adenoma, hyperplastic polyp, hyperplastic polyposis, adenoma, endoscopy, surgery, guidelines. Papers published between 1980 and 2010 were selected.

RESULTS

Sixty papers met the selection criteria. Most authors agree that recommendations regarding endoscopic or surgical management should be based on the polyp's neoplastic potential. Polyps greater than 5 mm should be biopsied to determine their histology so that intervention can be directed accurately. Narrow-band imaging or chromoendoscopy may facilitate the detection and assessment of extent of lesions. Complete endoscopic removal of sessile serrated adenomas in the left or right colon is recommended. Follow-up colonoscopy is recommended in 2-6 months if endoscopic removal is incomplete. If the lesion cannot be entirely removed endoscopically, segmental colectomy is strongly recommended owing to the malignant potential of these polyps. Left-sided lesions are more likely to be pedunculated, making them more amenable to successful endoscopic removal.

CONCLUSION

Even though the neoplastic potential of certain subtypes of serrated polyp is heavily supported, further studies are needed to make definitive endoscopic and surgical recommendations.

Endoscopic discrimination of sessile serrated adenomas from other serrated lesions

Sessile serrated adenoma (SSA) is a proposed precursor of colorectal carcinogenesis. This study aimed to analyze the potential of endoscopy to discriminate SSA from other serrated lesions, specifically traditional serrated adenoma (TSA) and hyperplastic polyp (HP). Of 145 serrated lesions, 111 sessile serrated lesions including 32 TSAs, 25 SSAs and 54 HPs were analyzed for size, color, location and morphologic features using conventional endoscopy and magnifying chromoendoscopy. SSA was preferentially located in the right colon, whereas TSA and HP were located in the left colon. The sizes of SSA and TSA were larger than those of HP. The lesion color was indistinguishable among TSA, SSA and HP. Macroscopically, a pinecone-like or two-tier raised appearance were found more frequently in TSA than in SAA and HP. Under magnified chromoendoscopic observation, the stellar III(L) pit pattern and fern-like appearance were observed more frequently in TSA than in SAA and HP. In conclusion, endoscopic discrimination between SSA and other sessile serrated lesions based on morphological features was difficult. However, size and location of the lesions facilitated diagnosis.

Clinicopathological and molecular features of colorectal serrated neoplasias with different mucosal crypt patterns

OBJECTIVES

Endoscopic examination shows that serrated neoplasias (SNs), such as serrated adenomas and sessile serrated adenomas, exhibit different mucosal crypt patterns. However, it remains unclear whether advanced serrated polyps with different mucosal crypt patterns have different clinicopathological or molecular features.

METHODS

We classified the mucosal crypt patterns of 86 SNs into three types (hyperplastic, adenomatous, and mixed pattern) and evaluated their clinicopathological and molecular features.

RESULTS

We found significant differences in the proliferative activity status between SNs with mixed/adenomatous patterns and those with the hyperplastic patterns. SNs with the hyperplastic pattern were frequently located in the proximal colon and had a macroscopically superficial appearance, whereas SNs with the adenomatous pattern were often located in the distal colon and had a protruding appearance. Furthermore, a significant difference was observed in the frequency of the CpG island methylator phenotype (CIMP), involving the methylation of two or more CIMP-related genes (MINT1, MINT2, MINT31, p16, and MLH1), between SNs with the hyperplastic pattern and those with the mixed/adenomatous patterns (18/32 (56%) vs. 8/28 (29%) or 7/26 (27%); P=0.0309 or P=0.0249, respectively). Moreover, the prevalence of KRAS mutations was significantly higher in SNs with the adenomatous pattern than in those with the hyperplastic pattern (7/26 (27%) vs. 1/32 (3%); P=0.0173). In comparison with other patterns, the mixed pattern was detected more frequently in mixed serrated polyps (MSPs), which contain separate histological components. Some MSPs exhibited concordant molecular alterations among the different histological components.

CONCLUSIONS

The clinicopathological and molecular features of SNs correlated strongly with their mucosal crypt patterns, which were observed using chromoendoscopy.

Clinical features and molecular alterations of traditional serrated adenoma in sporadic colorectal carcinogenesis

OBJECTIVE

To compare clinical features and molecular alterations between traditional serrated adenomas (TSA) & serrated carcinomas (SCa) and traditional adenomas (TA) & carcinomas (Ca) of the colorectum and to verify a traditional serrated pathway of sporadic colorectal carcinogenesis.

METHODS

One thousand two hundred slides of colorectal polyps obtained from 1160 patients were collected and reviewed to define TSA and clinical and pathological features were analyzed and compared with TA. DNA was extracted from specimens of TSA, TA, SCa and Ca, v-raf murine sarcoma viral oncogene homolog B (BRAF) V600E mutation and microsatellite instability (MSI) (assay for BAT25 and BAT26) were analyzed.

RESULTS

Overall 29 TSA were confirmed (2.5%), and there was an age difference between patients with TSA and TA (56.0 vs 62.7, P<0.05). Compared with TA, TSA was located more often in the rectosigmoid colon (TSA 62.1% vs TA 35.2%, P<0.05), but occurred less in the descending colon (TSA 0% vs TA 25.35%, P=0.0068). No difference was found in terms of gender and the size or pedicles of polyps (P>0.05). The BRAF V600E mutation was detected in 36.3% of SCa and 26.7% of TSA patients, but it was not detected in TA and Ca patients; MSI-H was noticed in 23% of SCa, 33.3% of TSA, 5.3% of Ca and 0% of TA patients, respectively (P<0.05).

CONCLUSION

There might be a traditional serrated pathway of sporadic colorectal carcinogenesis that is different from the conventional adenoma to carcinoma carcinogenesis pathway in the colorectum.

The clinical significance of serrated polyps

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is a heterogeneous disorder than arises via multiple distinct pathways, such as the serrated pathway, in which serrated polyps (including variants of hyperplastic polyps) are the precursor lesions. Approximately 15-20% of all CRCs arise via the serrated pathway, and these serrated carcinomas are clinically, morphologically, and molecularly distinct from conventional CRCs. The prevention of serrated carcinomas represents an important clinical challenge. Gastroenterologists need to recognize and remove potential precursor lesions and implement a post-polypectomy surveillance program when appropriate. This article focuses on the characteristics and significance of clinically relevant serrated polyps and addresses implications for CRC prevention practices.

Serrated adenoma: a distinct form of non-polypoid colorectal neoplasia?

Until recently, 2 major forms of colorectal polyp were recognized: the adenoma and the hyperplastic polyp. Adenomas were known to represent a precursor to colorectal cancer, whereas hyperplastic polyps were viewed as nonneoplastic, having no potential for progression to malignancy. We now recognize, however, that the lesions diagnosed as hyperplastic polyps in the past represent a heterogeneous group of polyps, some of which truly are hyperplastic, and others that truly have a significant risk for transformation to colorectal cancer. These polyps have a characteristic serrated architecture, and include not only hyperplastic polyps but also the recently recognized serrated adenomas. Serrated adenomas occur in 2 forms: the traditional serrated adenoma, which is usually a polypoid lesion endoscopically, and the sessile serrated adenoma, a flat or slightly raised, usually right-sided lesion. Serrated adenomas of both types show characteristic molecular alterations not commonly seen in traditional colorectal adenomas, and probably progress to colorectal cancer by means of a different pathway, the so-called serrated neoplasia pathway. The morphologic features of serrated colorectal lesions, the molecular alterations that characterize them, and their role in colorectal cancer development are discussed.

Serrated adenomas

Serrated adenomas are categorized as sessile serrated adenomas (SSAs) and traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs). SSAs are more prevalent in the proximal colon and lack classic dysplasia, whereas TSAs are more prevalent in the rectosigmoid and have cytologic dysplasia. Serrated adenomas may progress to colorectal adenocarcinoma through diverse molecular alterations. Colonoscopy is the only test for the early detection of serrated adenomas that allows inspection of the entire colon and same-session biopsy sampling or polypectomy, if necessary. If an endoscopic biopsy at the right colon reveals SSA without cytologic dysplasia or biopsy at the rectosigmoid reveals SSA or TSA, those polyps should be excised or surgically resected as necessary. Postpolypectomy surveillance for removed SSAs without dysplasia and TSAs must be performed at 5- and 3-year intervals, respectively, with colonoscopy to prevent recurrence and progression to colorectal adenocarcinoma.

Hyperplastic polyposis syndrome: a pilot study for the differentiation of polyps by using high-resolution endoscopy, autofluorescence imaging, and narrow-band imaging

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic differentiation and removal of potentially premalignant sessile serrated adenomas (SSAs) may be important steps in preventing the development of colorectal cancer in hyperplastic polyposis syndrome (HPS).

OBJECTIVE

To assess the value of high-resolution endoscopy, autofluorescence imaging (AFI), and narrow-band imaging (NBI) for differentiating polyps in HPS.

DESIGN

A prospective polyp series.

SETTING

Single tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS AND INTERVENTIONS

Seven patients with HPS underwent colonoscopy with endoscopic trimodal imaging, which incorporates high-resolution endoscopy, AFI, and NBI in 1 system. All detected polyps were analyzed with AFI for color and with NBI for Kudo pit pattern and vascular pattern intensity.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

The accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity of AFI and NBI in differentiating detected polyps were determined by using histology as the criterion standard.

RESULTS

A total of 19 hyperplastic polyps (HPs), 32 SSAs, and 15 adenomas were detected. For differentiating SSAs from HPs, AFI color, Kudo pit pattern, and vascular pattern intensity resulted in a diagnostic accuracy of 55%, 55%, and 52%, respectively. For differentiating adenomas from HPs, the accuracy was 65%, 94%, and 90%, respectively. Macroscopically, the combination of a size of 3 mm or larger and a proximal location resulted in the highest accuracy (76%) for differentiating SSAs from HPs.

LIMITATION

Small sample size.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic differentiation between HPs and SSAs by using endoscopic trimodal imaging proved unsatisfactory. Differentiation of adenomas from HPs was possible with NBI but not with AFI.

Serrated Adenoma of Gastric Antrum: Alteration of Mucin Expression Profile and its Role in Carcinogenesis

Serrated adenomas usually occur in colon, the gastric localization is extremely rare. These polyps have their own carcinogenetic pathway with microsatellite instability. In this report, we present a serrated adenoma localized in gastric antrum with four control endoscopies and biopsies. Immunohistochemical panel of MUC1, MUC2, MUC5AC, and MUC6 was applied to the biopsies. Serrated component, MUC 2 expression increased but goblet cells and MUC5AC expression decreased in follow-up biopsies. This lesion probably was originated from a stem cell that had the potential of differentiation in gastric and intestinal way. This might result an incomplete metaplasia for both colon and stomach. Such lesions which originate from either colon or gastric mucosa may be precancerous and their carcinogenetic pathway may not represent its original organ.

Combining autofluorescence imaging and narrow-band imaging for the differentiation of adenomas from non-neoplastic colonic polyps among experienced and non-experienced endoscopists

OBJECTIVES

Endoscopic tri-modal imaging incorporates high-resolution white-light endoscopy (HR-WLE), narrow-band imaging (NBI), and autofluorescence imaging (AFI). Combining these advanced techniques may improve endoscopic differentiation between adenomas and non-neoplastic polyps. In this study, we aimed to assess the interobserver variability and accuracy of HR-WLE, NBI, and AFI for polyp differentiation and to evaluate the combined use of AFI and NBI.

METHODS

First, still images of 50 polyps (22 adenomas; median 3 mm) were randomly displayed to three experienced and four non-experienced endoscopists. All HR-WLE and NBI images were scored for Kudo classification and AFI images for color. Second, the combined AFI and NBI images were assessed using a newly developed algorithm by six additional non-experienced endoscopists.

RESULTS

The outcomes measured were interobserver agreement and diagnostic accuracy using histopathology as reference standard. Experienced endoscopists had better interobserver agreement for NBI (kappa=0.77) than for AFI (kappa=0.33), whereas non-experienced endoscopists had better agreement for AFI (kappa=0.58) than for NBI (kappa=0.33). The accuracies of HR-WLE, NBI, and AFI among experienced endoscopists were 65, 70, and 74, respectively. Figures among non-experienced endoscopists were 57, 63, and 77. The algorithm was associated with a significantly higher accuracy of 85% among all observers (P<0.023). These figures were confirmed in the second evaluation study.

CONCLUSIONS

Non-experienced endoscopists have better interobserver agreement and accuracy for AFI than for HR-WLE or NBI, indicating that AFI is easier to use for polyp differentiation in non-experienced setting. The newly developed algorithm, combining information of AFI and NBI together, had the highest accuracy and obtained equal results between experienced and non-experienced endoscopists.

Serrated polyps and colorectal cancer: new pathway to malignancy

Until recently, two major forms of colorectal epithelial polyp were recognized: the adenoma and the hyperplastic polyp. Adenomas were perceived to represent the precursor to colorectal cancer, whereas hyperplastic polyps were viewed as innocuous lesions with no potential for progression to malignancy. We now recognize, however, that the lesions formerly classified as hyperplastic actually represent a heterogeneous group of polyps, some of which have a significant risk for neoplastic transformation. These serrated polyps include not only hyperplastic polyps but also traditional serrated adenomas and sessile serrated adenomas. These polyps demonstrate characteristic molecular alterations not commonly seen in colorectal adenomas, and they probably progress to colorectal cancer by means of a new pathway: the serrated neoplasia pathway. The morphologic features of serrated colorectal lesions, the molecular alterations that characterize them, and their role in colorectal cancer development are discussed herein.

Significance of serrated polyps of the colon

The fundamental view that colon adenocarcinomas arise only from conventional adenomas has been challenged by the now recognized hyperplastic polyp-serrated adenoma-adenocarcinoma pathway. This article describes the history of the serrated adenoma (both the traditional serrated adenoma and the sessile serrated adenoma) as well as the histology and endoscopic appearance of these lesions in comparison with hyperplastic polyps and mixed polyps. Although the exact pathway is the subject of ongoing research, compelling histologic associations and molecular phenotypes that define the model of the serrated polyp-carcinoma sequence, including microsatellite instability, BRAF/KRAS mutations, and CpG island methylator phenotype, provide strong evidence that this is a genuine pathway. Management of serrated neoplasia of the colon includes careful colonoscopy, complete removal of colonic polyps, sampling fields of diminutive polyps of the rectosigmoid, and basing surveillance on histology of removed polyps.

Sporadic and syndromic hyperplastic polyps and serrated adenomas of the colon: classification, molecular genetics, natural history, and clinical management

There is now strong evidence for an alternative pathway of colorectal carcinogenesis implicating hyperplastic polyps and serrated adenomas. This article briefly reviews the evidence for this serrated pathway, provides diagnostic criteria for clinically significant hyperplastic polyps and allied serrated polyps, and suggests how this information may be translated into safe, effective guidelines for colonoscopy-based colon cancer prevention. Consideration also is given to the definition and management of hyperplastic polyposis syndrome. The currently proposed management plan for serrated polyps is tentative because of incomplete knowledge of the nature and behavior of these polyps. This article highlights key areas warranting further research.

Comparison of malignant potential between serrated adenomas and traditional adenomas

BACKGROUND

Serrated adenoma is a discrete colorectal epithelial neoplastic lesion that can evolve into colorectal cancer. However, the degree of malignant potential has not been firmly established as yet. The purpose of the present paper was to compare the malignant potential and clinicopathological features between serrated and traditional adenomas.

METHODS

A total of 124 serrated adenomas from 116 patients were assessed, and 419 traditional adenomas from 200 were randomly selected. The combination of nuclear dysplasia and serration of > or =20% of crypts was regarded as serrated adenoma. The clinicopathological features of serrated and traditional adenomas were compared, and multivariate analysis performed to confirm whether the malignant potential of serrated adenoma was similar to that of traditional adenoma.

RESULTS

The differences in age, sex, total number of adenomas, and synchronous lesions including adenoma with high-grade dysplasia and carcinoma between subjects with and without serrated adenoma were not significant. Serrated adenomas were more frequently located in the rectum and sigmoid colon (P < 0.001), and the average size of serrated adenomas was greater than that of traditional adenomas (P < 0.05). The incidence of malignant lesions including high-grade dysplasia and carcinoma in serrated adenomas was found to be lower than in traditional adenomas (3.2% vs 9.3%, P < 0.05). In the multivariate analysis, adenoma type and polyp size constituted the risk factors for the incidence of high-grade dysplasia and carcinoma.

CONCLUSIONS

Serrated adenoma is a premalignant lesion, but it has a lower potential for the development of malignancy than traditional adenomas.

Colorectal serrated adenocarcinoma

Colorectal cancer (CRC) ranks among the three most common cancers in terms of both cancer incidence and cancer-related deaths in most Western countries. Serrated adenocarcinoma is a recently described, distinct variant of CRC, accounting for about 7.5% of all CRCs and up to 17.5% of most proximal CRCs. It has been postulated that about 10-15% of sporadic CRCs would have their origin in serrated polyps that harbour a significant malignant potential. These lesions include hyperplastic-type aberrant crypt foci, hyperplastic polyps, sessile serrated adenomas, admixed polyps and serrated adenomas, and constitute the so-called 'serrated pathway', which is distinct from both the conventional adenoma-carcinoma pathway and the mutator pathway of hereditary non-polyposis CRC and is characterized by early involvement of oncogenic BRAF mutations, excess CpG island methylation (CIM) and subsequent low- or high-level DNA microsatellite instability (MSI). Methylation of hMLH1 is likely to explain the increased frequency of high-level MSI (16%) and methylation of MGMT is postulated to explain the low-level MSI (29%) in serrated adenocarcinomas. Reproducible histopathological criteria for serrated adenocarcinoma have recently been established and they have been qualified by DNA expression analysis for 7928 genes, showing clustering of serrated adenocarcinomas into a molecular entity apart from conventional adenocarcinoma, and representing with distinct down-regulation of EPHB2, PTCH and up-regulation of HIF1alpha.

Serrated mucosal lesions of the colorectum

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To examine and clarify the nomenclature and histologic lesions identified as serrated mucosal lesions of the colorectum, including serrated adenomas, sessile serrated polyps (also known as sessile serrated adenomas) and hyperplastic polyps. This is timely given the significant confusion in ascribing a microscopic diagnosis and clinical utility of such a diagnosis.

RECENT FINDINGS

The emergence of sessile serrated polyps (or adenomas) as distinct histomorphologic lesions from serrated adenomas, as well as the appreciation of the possibility of different modes of dysplasia exhibited in serrated lesions.

SUMMARY

Clarification of the microscopic features, nomenclature and biology of serrated lesions are important for accurate histologic diagnosis, and in clinical terms for useful outcomes assessment, recommendations for follow-up and risk stratification.

Serrated adenoma of the colorectum and the DNA-methylator phenotype

Serrated adenomas (SA) of the colorectum show features intermediate between hyperplastic polyps (HP) and adenomas. HP and SA are related lesions and there is now strong evidence for a 'serrated-polyp pathway' to colorectal cancer (CRC) that is largely independent of the classic adenoma-to-carcinoma sequence. A recently recognized lesion in this pathway is a HP variant characterized by relatively large size, atypical histology and proximal location in the colorectum. This HP variant has been given a variety of names in the literature including 'sessile SA' and 'type I SA'. Because this lesion lacks the traditional cytology of colorectal adenoma and in order to avoid confusion with SA, it is referred to in this review as sessile serrated polyp. SA are characterized by a heterogeneous group of changes at the molecular level, but a high proportion have BRAFmutations and DNA methylation. They may develop in HP or sessile serrated polyps, or may arise de novo. In the serratedpolyp pathway, the advent of genetic instability is likely to be an important rate-limiting step that drives rapid neoplastic evolution. Methylation and inactivation of the DNA repair genes MLH1 and MGMT (O-6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase) have been proposed as critical steps leading to genetic instability. Stretches of DNA rich in the bases guanine and cytosine (CpG islands; where p represents a phosphodiester bond linking adjacent cytosine and guanine bases) that are normally unmethylated may become methylated in malignant human colorectal tumors. Subsets of colorectal cancers with an unusually high number of methylated CpG islands have been described as having the 'CpG-island-methylator phenotype' It is possible that many, if not all, CRCs with the CpG-island-methylator phenotype evolve through the serrated-polyp pathway that would, therefore, explain approximately 20% of all CRCs. The current lack of guidelines for managing serrated polyps may explain the static incidence of proximal CRC, despite the falling incidence rates for left-sided CRC during the same time period.

The risk of metachronous neoplasia in patients with serrated adenoma

Serrated adenomas are the precursors of at least 5.8% of colorectal cancers; otherwise little is known of their clinical significance in comparison with conventional adenomas and hyperplastic polyps. We compared the risk of metachronous lesions in colorectal serrated adenomas, conventional adenomas, and hyperplastic polyps. A consecutive series of patients with colorectal polyps first diagnosed from January 1978 to December 1982 and follow-up specimens to the end of 2000 was reviewed, and 239 polyps fulfilling the selection criteria were chosen as index polyps. The type of polyp seen in follow-up correlated significantly with the type of the initial lesion. Serrated adenomas were estimated to grow faster than conventional adenomas, but the incidence of colorectal cancer did not differ significantly between serrated (2/38 [5%]) and conventional adenomas (2.2%). The results indicate that serrated adenomas are lesions with a significant risk of metachronous serrated adenomas and the development of cancer. We emphasize the need for the proper recognition and management of serrated adenomas.

Clinicopathologic and endoscopic features of colorectal serrated adenoma: differences between polypoid and superficial types

BACKGROUND

Serrated adenoma is a distinct histologic colorectal lesion. There are two macroscopic types: polypoid and superficial. The aim of this study was to clarify clinicopathologic and endoscopic differences between polypoid and superficial serrated adenomas.

METHODS

An analysis was conducted of the clinicopathologic and endoscopic features for 240 polypoid and 127 superficial serrated adenomas examined by colonoscopy, and the surface pit patterns of 114 polypoid and 64 superficial serrated adenomas examined by magnifying videoendoscopy.

RESULTS

The male:female gender ratio for the polypoid serrated adenomas (3.5:1) was significantly higher than that for the superficial serrated adenomas (1.7:1). Superficial serrated adenomas were significantly larger than polypoid serrated adenomas (mean [standard deviation], respectively, 10.1 [7.9] mm vs. 6.3 [4.6] mm). In the distal segments of the colorectum, polypoid serrated adenomas were more common than superficial serrated adenomas. Granulonodular and lobular appearances at endoscopy were significantly more common for polypoid (23.3%) than for superficial serrated adenomas (7.1%). Pit patterns differed between the lesion types: polypoid serrated adenomas had type III(L) or IV pit patterns; all superficial serrated adenomas had the type II pit pattern. The relative frequency of occurrence of high-grade dysplasia and carcinoma in situ among superficial serrated adenomas (25.2%) was significantly greater than that among polypoid serrated adenomas (9.2%). The tubulovillous growth pattern was significantly more common in polypoid tumors (31.5%) than in superficial tumors (0%).

CONCLUSIONS

Polypoid and superficial serrated adenomas have different clinicopathologic characteristics and growth patterns.