Nuclear magnetic resonance titration curves of histidine ring protons. Ribonuclease S-peptide and S-proteins

Quantitative measurement of the solvent accessibility of histidine imidazole groups in proteins

We report a method for expressing the solvent accessibility of histidine imidazole groups in proteins. The method is based on measuring the rate of the hydrogen exchange (HX) reaction of the imidazole C(ε1)-hydrogen. The rate profile of the HX reaction as a function of pH gives a sigmoidal curve, which reaches the maximal rate constant (k(max)) on the alkaline side of the sigmoidal curve. To quantitatively describe the solvent accessibility of imidazole groups in proteins, it is necessary to compare the k(max) of the imidazole groups with their intrinsic k(max) ((i)k(max)), the maximal rate constants for the given imidazole groups when they are fully exposed to the bulk solvent. However, the mechanism of the HX reaction suggests that the (i)k(max) of an imidazole group differs depending on its pK(a), and no systematic study has been conducted to clarify how the (i)k(max) is affected by pK(a). We therefore investigated the relationship between (i)k(max) and pK(a) using four imidazole derivatives at three different temperatures. The experimentally determined pK(a)-specific (i)k(max) values allowed us to derive a general formula to estimate the (i)k(max) value of any given imidazole group exhibiting a specific pK(a) at a specific temperature. Using the formula, the protection factors (PF), the ratio of (i)k(max) to k(max), of five imidazole groups in dihydrofolate reductase were obtained and used to express the magnitude of their solvent accessibility. In this definition, the smaller the PF value, the higher the solvent accessibility, and a value of 1 indicates full exposure to the bulk solvent. The solvent accessibility expressed by the PF values agreed well with the solvent accessible surface areas obtained from the X-ray diffraction data.

Thermal aggregation of ribonuclease A. A contribution to the understanding of the role of 3D domain swapping in protein aggregation

By lyophilizing RNase A from 40% acetic acid solutions, two dimeric aggregates, the "minor" and "major" dimers (named here N-dimer and C-dimer, respectively), form by 3D domain swapping at a ratio of 1:4. Trimeric and tetrameric aggregates are also obtained. The two dimers and the higher oligomers also form without a lyophilization step. By keeping RNase A dissolved at a high concentration (generally 200 mg/ml) in various media at temperatures ranging from 23 to 70 degrees C for times varying from a few minutes to 2 h, various oligomers, in particular the two dimeric conformers, formed in quite different amounts, often inverting their relative quantities depending on the more or less severe unfolding conditions. When unfolding mainly concerned the N terminus of the protein, richer in hydrophilic residues, the N-dimer, formed by 3D domain swapping of the N-terminal alpha-helix of each monomer, prevailed over the C-dimer. Under more vigorous denaturing conditions, where also the C terminus of RNase A, richer in hydrophobic amino acids, unfolded, the C-dimer, formed by 3D domain swapping of the C-terminal beta-strand, prevailed over the other, possibly because of the induction to aggregation promoted by the hydrophobic residues present in the C termini of the two monomers.

15N- and 1H-NMR investigations of the active-site amino acids in semisynthetic RNase S' and RNase A

Extensive 15N-NMR investigations of active-site amino acids were made possible by the solid-phase synthesis of the N-terminal pentadecapeptide of RNase A with selectively 15N-enriched amino acids. On complexation with S-protein a fully active RNase S' complex was obtained. The 15N resonances of the side chains of lysine-7 (N epsilon), glutamine-11 (N gamma), and histidine-12 (N pi, tau) were studied in the free synthetic peptide, in the RNase S' complex and in the nucleotide complexes RNase S' with 2'CMP, 3'CMP, and 5'AMP. The analysis of the 15N-1H couplings, the 15N line broadenings due to proton exchange, and the chemical shift values showed that, while the imidazole ring is directly involved in the peptide-protein interaction, the side chains of Lys-7 and Gln-11 do not contribute to this interaction. In the nucleotide complexes the resonances of His-12 and Gln-11 are shifted downfield. In the 2'CMP complex a doublet for the N tau signal of His-12 indicates a stable H bond between this nitrogen and the phosphate group of nucleotide. The other nucleotide influence the resonances of the imidazole group much less, possibly due to a slightly different orientation of the phosphate group. The downfield shift of the Gln-11 resonance indicates an interaction between the carbonyl oxygen of the amide group and the phosphate moiety of the nucleotide. The only observable effect of nucleotide complexation on the Lys-7 signal is line broadening due to reduced proton exchange. For comparison with the 15N-NMR titration curves of His-12 in RNase S' the 1H-NMR titration curves of RNase A were also recorded. Both shape and pK values were very similar for the 15N and the 1H titration curves. An extensive analysis of the protonation equilibria with several fitting models showed that a mutual interaction of the imidazole groups of the active-site histidines results in flat titration curves. The Hill plots of all resonances of the imidazole rings, including the 15N resonances, show a small inflection in the pH range 5.8-6.4. Since the existence of a diimidazole system is most likely in this pH range, the inflection could be interpreted as a disturbance of the mutual electrostatic interaction of the active-site histidines by a partial H-bond formation between the imidazole groups.

Exchange behavior of the H-bonded amide protons in the 3 to 13 helix of ribonuclease S

The preceding article shows that there are eight highly protected amide protons in the S-peptide moiety of RNAase S at pH 5, 0 degrees C. The residues with protected NH protons are 7 to 13, whose amide protons are H-bonded in the 3 to 13 alpha-helix, and Asp 14, whose NH proton is H-bonded to the CO group of Val47. We describe here the exchange behavior of these eight protected protons as a function of pH. Exchange rates of the individual NH protons are measured by 1H nuclear magnetic resonance in D2O. A procedure is used for specifically labeling with 1H only these eight NH protons. The resonance assignments of the eight protons are made chiefly by partial exchange, through correlating the resonance intensities in spectra taken when the peptide is bound and when it is dissociated from S-protein in 3.5 M-urea-d4, in D2O, pH 2.3, -4 degrees C. The two remaining assignments are made and some other assignments are checked by measurements of the nuclear Overhauser effect between adjacent NH protons of the alpha-helix. There is a transition in exchange behavior between pH 3, where the helix is weakly protected against exchange, and pH 5 where the helix is much more stable. At pH 3.1, 20 degrees C, exchange rates are uniform within the helix within a factor of two, after correction for different intrinsic exchange rates. The degree of protection within the helix is only 10 to 20-fold at this pH. At pH 5.1, 20 degrees C, the helix is more stable by two orders of magnitude and exchange occurs preferentially from the N-terminal end. At both pH values the NH proton of Asp 14, which is just outside the helix, is less protected by an order of magnitude than the adjacent NH protons inside the helix. Opening of the helix can be observed below pH 3.7 by changes in chemical shifts of the NH protons in the helix. At pH 2.4 the changes are 25% of those expected for complete opening. Helix opening is a fast reaction on the n.m.r. time scale (tau much less than 1 ms) unlike the generalized unfolding of RNAase S which is a slow reaction. Dissociation of S-peptide from S-protein in native RNAase S at pH 3.0 also is a slow reaction. Opening of the helix below pH 3.7 is a two-state reaction, as judged by comparing chemical shifts with exchange rates. The exchange rates at pH 3.1 are predicted correctly from the changes in chemical shift by assuming that helix opening is a two-state reaction. At pH values above 3.7, the nature of the helix opening reaction changes. These results indicate that at least one partially unfolded state of RNAase S is populated in the low pH unfolding transition.

Effects of neutral salts on the circular dichroism spectra of ribonuclease A and ribonuclease S

The circular dichroism (CD) spectra of ribonuclease A, ribonuclease S, and N-acetyltyrosineamide were recorded as a function of pH in the presence of various concentrations of inorganic salts. Above pH 9.0 salting-in of tyrosine residues increases their intramolecular associations. This association enhances the contribution from these residues to the CD spectrum leading to an apparent titration curve that is shifted toward lower pH. The data indicate that unfolding of ribonuclease A and S by inorganic salts does not begin with disrupting existing electrostatic interactions. But, as the unfolding process progresses, disruption of electrostatic interactions may take place. This is consistent with our previous calorimetric studies which suggest that unfolding of ribonuclease A by salts proceeds initially by energetically favorable solvation of the folded protein. An increase in ellipiticity at 275 nm of partially unfolded protein in salt was observed as the pH was changed from 7.0 to 4.0. This observation may suggest that the isothermal unfolding of the protein by salts at low pH proceeds through an intermediate step which involves histidine residues and causes a conformational change in the tyrosine's asymmetric environment.

Anion binding and pH-dependent electrostatic effects in ribonuclease

The solvent-accessibility-modified, Tanford-Kirkwood, discrete charge model for electrostatic effects is applied to both ribonuclease A and ribonuclease S. The behavior of individual titratable sites and the pH-dependent free energy of denaturation are correctly predicted. The use of the solvent-accessibility factor in reducing charge-site interactions introduces a higher Coulombic shielding for solvent-exposed sites. This shielding is interpreted as a higher local strength or alternatively a higher effective dielectric constant. Specific anion binding sites are determined by locating areas of high positive electrostatic potential at the protein solvent interface. The potential and thus the anion affinity of a given site are calculated and shown to vary with the pH-dependent charge array. pH-dependent anion binding constants are calculated for the ribonuclease S active site. These binding constants and the predicted response of the active-site histidine pK1/2 values to anion binding are shown to agree with experimental determinations.

Conformation of ribonuclease S-protein

Ribonuclease S-protein exhibits a pH-dependent conformational transition between folded and unfolded states, and some unfolded S-protein persists up to pH 8. The histidine C2 proton resonance of the unfolded species was erroneously assigned by Bradbury et al. to histidine residue 119 of the folded species.

Local interactions as a structure determinant for protein molecules: III

Investigation of the known protein structures has led to the generalization that the native folding permits each sidechain to select those nearest-neighbors which maximize stabilization from van der Waals interactions. With regard to secondary structure: 1. Helical and beta regions exhibit characteristic patterns of short-range contacts (residue numbers k and k + t with [t] less than or equal to 4) due to the geometries of these secondary structures. However, these are not strictly obligatory, and preferred short-range contacts which would result in unfavorable van der Waals interactions are replaced by favorable long-range contacts. 2. The generalization mentioned at the outset holds for individual proteins, both for short-range and long-range contacts, and without regard for the type or amount of secondary structure present. 3. These observations imply that van der Waals interactions arising from short-range contacts partially determine secondary structure, and this is demonstrated by tests based upon assignment of regions of secondary structure in the known proteins. The principle of optimizing van der Waals stabilization from long-range contacts is applied to predict the structure of the complex formed by the S-peptide and S-protein of ribonuclease-S. The formation of favorable pairs is found to be more important than the total number of intermolecular contacts, and 40 to 50% of this stabilization is contributed by two residues of the S-peptide, Phe-8 and Met-13.

Nuclear-magnetic-resonance study of the histidine residues of S-peptide and S-protein and kinetics of 1H-2H exchange of ribonuclease A

1H NMR spectroscopy at 100 MHz was used to determine the first-order rate constants for the 1H-2H exchange of the H-2 histidine resonances of RNase-A in 2H2O at 35 degrees C and pH meter readings of 7, 9, 10 and 10.5. Prolonged exposure in 2H2O at 35 degrees C and pH meter reading 11 caused irreversible denaturation of RN-ase-A. The rate constants at pH 7 and 9 agreed reasonably well with those obtained in 1H-3H exchange experiments by Ohe, J., Matsuo, H., Sakiyama, F. and Narita, K. [J. Biochem, (Tokyo) 75, 1197-1200 (1974)]. The rate data obtained by various authors is summarised and the reasons for the poor agreement between the data is discussed. The first-order rate constant for the exchange of His-48 increases rapidly from near zero at pH 9 (due to its inaccessibility to solvent) with increase of pH to 10.5 The corresponding values for His-119 show a decrease and those for His-12 a small increase over the same pH range. These changes are attributed to a conformational change in the hinge region of RNase-A (probably due to the titration of Tyr-25) which allows His-48 to become accessible to solvent. 1H NMR spectra of S-protein and S-peptide, and of material partially deuterated at the C-2 positions of the histidine residues confirm the reassignment of the histidine resonances of RNase-A [Bradbury, J. H. & Teh, J. S. (1975) Chem. Commun., 936-937]. The chemical shifts of the C-2 and C-4 protons of histidine-12 of S-peptide are followed as a function of pH and a pK' value of 6.75 is obtained. The reassignment of the three C-2 histidine resonances of S-protein is confirmed by partial deuteration studies. The pK' values obtained from titration of the H-2 resonances of His-48, His-105 and His-119 are 5.3, 6.5 and 6.0, respectively. The S-protein is less stable to acid than RNase-A since the former, but not the latter, shows evidence of reversible denaturation at pH 3 and 26 degrees C. His-48 in S-protein titrates normally and has a lower pK than in RN-ase-A probably because of the absence of Asp-14, which in RN-ase-A forms a a hydrogen bond with His-48 and causes it to be inaccessible to solvent, at pH values below 9.