Disruption of an ATP-dependent isomerization of the recA protein by mutation of histidine 163

RecA-mediated cleavage of lambda cI repressor accepts repressor dimers: probable role of prolyl cis-trans isomerization and catalytic involvement of H163, K177, and K232 of RecA

The lambda cI repressor is found to be cleaved in the presence of activated RecA in its DNA-bound dimeric form at a rate similar to that in the absence of operator DNA in contrast to previous studies inferring repressor monomer as a preferred substrate. Though activated RecA does not possess any measurable isomerase activity against a standard peptide substrate, prolyl isomerase inhibitors cyclosporin A and rapamycin do inhibit RecA-mediated cleavage. Histidine and lysine to a smaller extent, are shown to cleave cI repressor in a non-enzymatic fashion whereas arginine and glutamate do not. When activated RecA filament is covalently modified by using an excess of diethyl pyrocarbonate or maleic anhydride, RecA-mediated cleavage of cI repressor is inhibited. Combining our chemical modification data with model building and earlier mutagenesis data, it is argued that H163, K177, and K232 in RecA are crucial residues involved in cI repressor cleavage by combining with the catalytic Ser149 and K192 in the repressor. It is suggested by model building that subunits n, n+4, and n+5 in the RecA filament contribute one loop each for holding the C-terminal domain of the repressor during cleavage within the RecA helical groove, explaining why its ADP-form is inactive and its ATP-form is active regarding repressor cleavage.

Single molecule analysis of a red fluorescent RecA protein reveals a defect in nucleoprotein filament nucleation that relates to its reduced biological functions

Fluorescent fusion proteins are exceedingly useful for monitoring protein localization in situ or visualizing protein behavior at the single molecule level. Unfortunately, some proteins are rendered inactive by the fusion. To circumvent this problem, we fused a hyperactive RecA protein (RecA803 protein) to monomeric red fluorescent protein (mRFP1) to produce a functional protein (RecA-RFP) that is suitable for in vivo and in vitro analysis. In vivo, the RecA-RFP partially restores UV resistance, conjugational recombination, and SOS induction to recA(-) cells. In vitro, the purified RecA-RFP protein forms a nucleoprotein filament whose k(cat) for single-stranded DNA-dependent ATPase activity is reduced approximately 3-fold relative to wild-type protein, and which is largely inhibited by single-stranded DNA-binding protein. However, RecA protein is also a dATPase; dATP supports RecA-RFP nucleoprotein filament formation in the presence of single-stranded DNA-binding protein. Furthermore, as for the wild-type protein, the activities of RecA-RFP are further enhanced by shifting the pH to 6.2. As a consequence, RecA-RFP is proficient for DNA strand exchange with dATP or at lower pH. Finally, using single molecule visualization, RecA-RFP was seen to assemble into a continuous filament on duplex DNA, and to extend the DNA approximately 1.7-fold. Consistent with its attenuated activities, RecA-RFP nucleates onto double-stranded DNA approximately 3-fold more slowly than the wild-type protein, but still requires approximately 3 monomers to form the rate-limited nucleus needed for filament assembly. Thus, RecA-RFP reveals that its attenuated biological functions correlate with a reduced frequency of nucleoprotein filament nucleation at the single molecule level.

Molecular Design and Functional Organization of the RecA Protein

The bacterial RecA protein participates in a remarkably diverse set of functions, all of which are involved in the maintenance of genomic integrity. RecA is a central component in both the catalysis of recombinational DNA repair and the regulation of the cellular SOS response. Despite the mechanistic differences of its functions, all require formation of an active RecA/ATP/DNA complex. RecA is a classic allosterically regulated enzyme, and ATP binding results in a dramatic increase in DNA binding affinity and a cooperative assembly of RecA subunits to form an ordered, helical nucleoprotein filament. The molecular events that underlie this ATP-induced structural transition are becoming increasingly clear. This review focuses on descriptions of our current understanding of the molecular design and allosteric regulation of RecA. We present a comprehensive list of all published recA mutants and use the results of various genetic and biochemical studies, together with available structural information, to develop ideas regarding the design of RecA functional domains and their catalytic organization.

Characterization of DNA strand transfer promoted by Mycobacterium smegmatis RecA reveals functional diversity with Mycobacterium tuberculosis RecA

The RecA-like proteins constitute a group of DNA strand transfer proteins ubiquitous in eubacteria, eukarya, and archaea. However, the functional relationship among RecA proteins is poorly understood. For instance, Mycobacterium tuberculosis RecA is synthesized as a large precursor, which undergoes an unusual protein-splicing reaction to generate an active form. Whereas the precursor was inactive, the active form promoted DNA strand transfer less efficiently compared to EcRecA. Furthermore, gene disruption studies have indicated that the frequencies of allele exchange are relatively lower in Mycobacterium tuberculosis compared to Mycobacterium smegmatis. The mechanistic basis and the factors that contribute to differences in allele exchange remain to be understood. Here, we show that the extent of DNA strand transfer promoted by the M. smegmatis RecA in vitro differs significantly from that of M. tuberculosis RecA. Importantly, M. smegmatis RecA by itself was unable to promote strand transfer, but cognate or noncognate SSBs rendered it efficient even when added prior to RecA. In the presence of SSB, MsRecA or MtRecA catalyzed strand transfer between ssDNA and varying lengths of linear duplex DNA with distinctly different pH profiles. The factors that were able to suppress the formation of DNA networks greatly stimulated strand transfer reactions promoted by MsRecA or MtRecA. Although the rate and pH profiles of dATP hydrolysis catalyzed by MtRecA and MsRecA were similar, only MsRecA was able to couple dATP hydrolysis to DNA strand transfer. Together, these results provide insights into the functional diversity in DNA strand transfer promoted by RecA proteins of pathogenic and nonpathogenic species of mycobacteria.

Enhanced monomer-monomer interactions can suppress the recombination deficiency of the recA142 allele

The RecA142 protein, in which valine is substituted for isoleucine-225, is defective for genetic recombination in vivo and for DNA strand exchange activity in vitro under conventional growth and reaction conditions respectively. However, we show that mildly acidic conditions restore both the in vitro DNA strand exchange activity and the in vivo function of RecA142 protein, suggesting that recombination function can be restored by a slight change in protein structure elicited by protonation. Indeed, we identified an intragenic suppressor of the recombination deficiency of the recA142 allele. This suppressor mutation is a substitution of leucine for glutamine at position 124. Based on the three-dimensional structure, the Q-124L substitution is predicted to make a new monomer-monomer contact with residue phenylalanine-21 of the adjacent RecA monomer. The Q-124L mutation is not allele specific, because it also suppresses the recombination deficiency of a recA deletion (Delta9), lacking nine amino acids at the amino-terminus, presumably by reinforcing the monomer-monomer interactions that are attenuated by the Delta9 deletion. Expression of RecA(Q-124L) protein is toxic to Escherichia coli, presumably because of enhanced affinity for DNA. We speculate as to how enhanced monomer-monomer interactions and acidic pH conditions can restore the recombination activity of some defective recA alleles.

Quantitative analysis of the kinetics of end-dependent disassembly of RecA filaments from ssDNA

On linear single-stranded DNA, RecA filaments assemble and disassemble in the 5' to 3' direction. Monomers (or other units) associate at one end and dissociate from the other. ATP hydrolysis occurs throughout the filament. Dissociation can result when ATP is hydrolyzed by the monomer at the disassembly end. We have developed a comprehensive model for the end-dependent filament disassembly process. The model accounts not only for disassembly, but also for the limited reassembly that occurs as DNA is vacated by disassembling filaments. The overall process can be monitored quantitatively by following the resulting decline in DNA-dependent ATP hydrolysis. The rate of disassembly is highly pH dependent, being negligible at pH 6 and reaching a maximum at pH values above 7. 5. The rate of disassembly is not significantly affected by the concentration of free RecA protein within the experimental uncertainty. For filaments on single-stranded DNA, the monomer kcat for ATP hydrolysis is 30 min-1, and disassembly proceeds at a maximum rate of 60-70 monomers per minute per filament end. The latter rate is that predicted if the ATP hydrolytic cycles of adjacent monomers are not coupled in any way.

Locations of functional domains in the RecA protein. Overlap of domains and regulation of activities

We review the locations of various functional domains of the RecA protein of Escherichia coli, including how they have been assigned, and discuss the potential regulatory roles of spatial overlap between different domains. RecA is a multifunctional and ubiquitous protein involved both in general genetic recombination and in DNA repair: it regulates the synthesis and activity of DNA repair enzymes (SOS induction) and catalyses homologous recombination and mutagenesis. For these activities RecA interacts with a nucleotide cofactor, single-stranded and double-stranded DNAs, the LexA repressor, UmuD protein, the UmuD'2C complex as well as with RecA itself in forming the catalytically active nucleofilament. Attempts to locate the respective interaction sites have been advanced in order to understand the various functions of RecA. An intriguing question is how these numerous functional sites are contained within this rather small protein (38 kDa). To assess more clearly the roles of the respective sites and to what extent the sites may be interacting with each other, we review and compare the results obtained from various biological, biochemical and physico-chemical approaches. From a three-dimensional model it is concluded that all sites are concentrated to one part of the protein. As a consequence there are significant overlaps between the sites and it is speculated that corresponding interactions may play important roles in regulating RecA activities.

Differential proximity probing of two DNA binding sites in the Escherichia coli recA protein using photo-cross-linking methods

The DNA strand-exchange reaction catalyzed by the Escherichia coli RecA protein occurs between the two DNA binding sites that are functionally distinct. Site I is the site to which a DNA molecule (normally single-stranded DNA) binds first; this first binding makes site II available for additional DNA-binding (normally double- stranded DNA). Photo-cross linking was employed to identify the amino acid residues located close to the bound DNA molecule(s). A ssDNA oligo containing multiple 5-iodouracil residues (IdU) was cross-linked to RecA by irradiation with a XeC1 pulse laser (308 nm), and the cross-linked peptides were purified and sequenced. To differentiate the two DNA binding sites, we used two protocols for making RecA-ssDNA complexes: (1) IdU-containing oligo was mixed with a stoichiometric excess of RecA, a condition which favors the binding of the oligo to site I, and (2) RecA was first allowed to bind to a nonphotoreactive oligo and then chased with the IdU-containing oligo, a condition which favors the binding of the IdU-oligo to site II. We observed that when RecA was in excess (site I probing), cross-linking occurred to Met-164 which is located in the disordered loop 1 of the RecA crystal structure [Story, R.M., Weber, I.T., & Steitz, T.A. (1992) Nature 355, 318-325]. When site II was probed, the majority of cross-linking occurred to Met-202 or Phe-203, located in loop 2. These results support the idea that, as predicted by Story and co-workers (1992), the disordered loops are involved in DNA binding. The results also suggest that the two sites are not only functionally but also physically distinct.

Spectroscopic demonstration of a linkage between the kinetics of NTP hydrolysis and the conformational state of the recA-single-stranded DNA complex

We recently constructed a mutant recA protein in which His-163 was replaced by a tryptophan residue; the [H163W]recA protein is functionally identical to the wild-type protein, and the Trp-163 side chain serves as a reporter group for the conformational transitions of the [H163W]recA-single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) complex. We have now examined the fluorescence properties of the [H163W]recA-ssDNA complex in the presence of a series of alternate nucleoside triphosphate cofactors. Under standard conditions (pH 7.5), ATP (S0.5 = 70 microM) and purine riboside triphosphate (PTP) (S0.5 = 110 microM) effect a 44% decrease in Trp-163 fluorescence and are active as cofactors for the DNA strand exchange reaction. In contrast, ITP (S0.5 = 400 microM) elicits only a 20% decrease in Trp-163 fluorescence (a level identical to that observed with the nucleoside diphosphates ADP, PDP, and IDP) and is inactive as a strand exchange cofactor. If the S0.5 (PTP) is increased to 130 microM (by increasing the pH of the reaction solution), the PTP-mediated quenching of Trp-163 fluorescence decreases to 20%, and PTP becomes inactive as a strand exchange cofactor. These results provide direct evidence for a linkage between the S0.5 value of a nucleoside triphosphate and the conformational state of the recA-ssDNA complex, with an S0.5 of 100-120 microM or lower required for stabilization of the strand exchange-active conformation.

Accessibility to modification of histidine residues of RecA protein upon DNA and cofactor binding

The potential role of histidine residues of RecA protein in binding DNA has been investigated by monitoring their accessibility to diethylpyrocarbonate. In the absence of both DNA and cofactor, only one of two histidine residues is modified by the reagent, indicating that the other residue is buried. However, both histidine residues become accessible after addition of cofactor analog adenosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) (ATP[S]) indicating a change in the organization of the RecA filament and/or a change in the conformation of protein. The diethylpyrocarbonate-modified RecA is found to be able to polymerize just as the unmodified protein. The binding of double-stranded DNA, in the presence of ATP[S], reduces the reactivity of both histidine residues to diethylpyrocarbonate. The binding of single-stranded DNA (with ATP[S]) has a similar, though smaller, protective effect. However, no significant dissociation of either of the complexes as a result of the modification was observed and a RecA molecule which had been modified in the absence of DNA could still bind DNA. A protection of the histidine residues is also effected by high salt concentration which promotes, just as DNA binding, ATPase and coprotease activity in RecA. The protection of histidine residues to diethylpyrocarbonate upon DNA binding probably relates to a conformational change of RecA and may not be any direct effect of shielding by the DNA. Nonetheless, the domains including the histidine residues could be centers of allosteric effects and are concluded to be close to the DNA binding site.

Functional structures of the recA protein found by chimera analysis

We developed a novel genetic method for finding functional regions of a protein by the analysis of chimeras formed between homologous proteins. Sets of chimeric genes were made by intramolecular homologous recombination in a linearized plasmid DNA carrying both recA genes of Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. A recBCsbcA strain of E. coli was used for isolation of plasmids carrying recombinants between these genes. Examination of properties of E. coli strains deleting the recA gene and carrying a plasmid with a chimeric gene shows that chimera formation at certain positions inactivates a RecA function. Frequently, all chimeras with a junction in a certain region of the protein inactivate a function. Rather than a direct effect of the presence of the junction at a particular position, mismatching of the regions both sides of the junction that are derived from the different species is responsible for the inactivation. For a chimeric protein to be functional, certain pairs of sequences in different regions of the protein must derive from the same parent. Four pairs of such sequences were found: two are involved in activities for genetic recombination and for resistance to ultraviolet light irradiation and the others in formation of active oligomers. Regions defined by these sequences are located in the looped regions of the protein. A pair of regions may co-operate to form a functional folded structure.

Effect of nucleotide cofactor structure on recA protein-promoted DNA pairing. 1. Three-strand exchange reaction

The structurally related nucleoside triphosphates, adenosine triphosphate (ATP), purine riboside triphosphate (PTP), inosine triphosphate (ITP), and guanosine triphosphate (GTP), are all hydrolyzed by the recA protein with the same turnover number (17.5 min-1). The S0.5 values for these nucleotides increase progressively in the order ATP (45 microM), PTP (100 microM), ITP (300 microM), and GTP (750 microM). PTP, ITP, and GTP are each competitive inhibitors of recA protein-catalyzed ssDNA-dependent ATP hydrolysis, indicating that these nucleotides all compete for the same catalytic site on the recA protein. Despite these similarities, ATP and PTP function as cofactors for the recA protein-promoted three-strand exchange reaction, whereas ITP and GTP are inactive as cofactors. The strand exchange activity of the various nucleotides correlates directly with their ability to support the isomerization of the recA protein to a strand exchange-active conformational state. The mechanistic deficiency of ITP and GTP appears to arise as a consequence of the hydrolysis of these nucleotides to the corresponding nucleoside diphosphates, IDP and GDP. We speculate the nucleoside triphosphates with S0.5 values greater than 100 microM will be intrinsically unable to sustain the strand exchange-active conformational state of the recA protein during ongoing NTP hydrolysis and will therefore be inactive as cofactors for the strand exchange reaction.

The structure of the E. coli recA protein monomer and polymer

The crystal structure of the recA protein from Escherichia coli at 2.3-A resolution reveals a major domain that binds ADP and probably single- and double-stranded DNA. Two smaller subdomains at the N and C termini protrude from the protein and respectively stabilize a 6(1) helical polymer of protein subunits and interpolymer bundles. This polymer structure closely resembles that of recA/DNA filaments determined by electron microscopy. Mutations in recA protein that enhance coprotease, DNA-binding and/or strand-exchange activity can be explained if the interpolymer interactions in the crystal reflect a regulatory mechanism in vivo.