Flux ratios and pump stoichiometries at sites II and III in liver mitochondria. Effect of slips and leaks

Theoretical and Experimental Study of the Interaction of Protonophore Uncouplers and Decoupling Agents with Functionally Active Mitochondria

The purpose of this work was to quantitatively characterize the effectiveness of oxidative phosphorylation uncouplers and decoupling agents in functionally active mitochondria, taking into account their content in the hydrophobic region of the inner membrane of these organelles. When conducting theoretical studies, it is accepted that uncouplers and decouplers occupy part of the volume of mitochondria to exhibit their activity, which is defined as the effective volume. The following quantities characterizing the action of these reagents are considered: (1) concentrations of reagents that cause double stimulation of mitochondrial respiration in state 4 (C 200 ); (2) effective distribution coefficient (E MW ) - the ratio of the amount of reagents in the effective volume of mitochondria and the water volume; (3) the relative amount of reagents associated with the effective volume of mitochondria (U M / U T ); (4) specific activity of reagents localized in the effective volume of mitochondria (A M ). We have developed methods for determining these values, based on an analysis of the dependence of the rate of mitochondrial respiration on the concentration of uncouplers and decoupling agents at two different concentrations of mitochondrial protein in the incubation medium. During experimental studies, we compared the effects of the classical protonophore uncouplers 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP) and сarbonyl cyanide 4-(trifluoromethoxy)phenylhydrazone (FCCP), the natural uncouplers lauric and palmitic acids, and the natural decouplers α,ω-tetradecanedioic (TDA) and α,ω-hexadecanedioic (HDA) acids that differ both in the structure of the molecule and in the degree of solubility in lipids. Using the developed methods, we have clarified the dependence of the degree of activity of these uncouplers and decoupling agents on the distribution of their molecules between the effective volume of mitochondria and the water volume.

Comparative study of free respiration in liver mitochondria during oxidation of various electron donors and under conditions of shutdown of complex III of the respiratory chain

The present work shows that the rate of free respiration of liver mitochondria (in the absence of ATP synthesis (state 4) during the oxidation of succinate is 1.7 times higher than during the oxidation of glutamate with malate. In turn, in the case of oxidation of ferrocyanide with ascorbate, this value is 3.1 times greater than in the case of succinate oxidation. A similar pattern is also observed upon stimulation of free respiration by low concentrations (5 and 10 μM) of the protonophore uncoupler 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP). It is found that the passive leakage rate of protons in state 4 is the same if the H⁺/O ratios are 10, 6, and 2 upon the oxidation of glutamate with malate, succinate, and ferrocyanide with ascorbate, respectively. At these values of the H⁺/O ratio, low concentrations of DNP stimulate passive proton leakage equally during the oxidation of these respiration substrates. In the case of succinate oxidation, bypassing complex III by N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine (TMPD) to the maximum degree, as well as switching this complex completely to idle mode by α,ω-hexadecanedioic acid (HDA) cause a 3-fold stimulation of respiration in state 4. We conclude that at mitochondrial free respiration the values of the H⁺/2e^- ratio for complexes I, III, and IV of the respiratory chain are 4, 4, and 2, respectively. It is assumed that the free respiration of mitochondria is carried out by simple diffusion of protons through the inner membrane, and the rate of this diffusion depends on the total number of protons released by the complexes of the electron transport chain into the intermembrane space.

Physiological uncoupling of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation. Studies in different yeast species

Under non-phosphorylating conditions a high proton transmembrane gradient inhibits the rate of oxygen consumption mediated by the mitochondrial respiratory chain (state IV). Slow electron transit leads to production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) capable of participating in deleterious side reactions. In order to avoid overproducing ROS, mitochondria maintain a high rate of O(2) consumption by activating different exquisitely controlled uncoupling pathways. Different yeast species possess one or more uncoupling systems that work through one of two possible mechanisms: i) Proton sinks and ii) Non-pumping redox enzymes. Proton sinks are exemplified by mitochondrial unspecific channels (MUC) and by uncoupling proteins (UCP). Saccharomyces. cerevisiae and Debaryomyces hansenii express highly regulated MUCs. Also, a UCP was described in Yarrowia lipolytica which promotes uncoupled O(2) consumption. Non-pumping alternative oxido-reductases may substitute for a pump, as in S. cerevisiae or may coexist with a complete set of pumps as in the branched respiratory chains from Y. lipolytica or D. hansenii. In addition, pumps may suffer intrinsic uncoupling (slipping). Promising models for study are unicellular parasites which can turn off their aerobic metabolism completely. The variety of energy dissipating systems in eukaryote species is probably designed to control ROS production in the different environments where each species lives.

Control of OXPHOS efficiency by complex I in brain mitochondria

In the present work we have analysed the efficiency (P/O ratio) of energy production by oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) in rat brain, liver and heart mitochondria. This study has revealed tissue-specific differences in the mean values of P/O ratios and ATP production rates. A marked dependence of the P/O ratio on the respiration rates has been observed with complex I (NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase), but not with complex II (succinate dehydrogenase) respiratory substrates. The physiological impact of the P/O variations with complex I substrates has been further confirmed by extending the analysis to brain mitochondria from three independent groups of animals utilized to study the effects of dietary treatments on the age-related changes of OXPHOS. The general site-specificity of the rate-dependent P/O variability indicates that the decoupling, i.e. decreased coupling between electron transfer and proton pumping, is likely to be mostly due to slip of mitochondrial complex I. These findings suggest an additional mechanism for the pivotal role played by the energy-conserving respiratory complex I in the physiological and adaptive plasticity of mitochondrial OXPHOS.

P/O ratios of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation

Mitochondrial mechanistic P/O ratios are still in question. The major studies since 1937 are summarized and various systematic errors are discussed. Values of about 2.5 with NADH-linked substrates and 1.5 with succinate are consistent with most reports after apparent contradictions are explained. Variability of coupling may occur under some conditions but is generally not significant. The fractional values result from the coupling ratios of proton transport. An additional revision of P/O ratios may be required because of a report of the structure of ATP synthase (D. Stock, A.G.W. Leslie, J.E. Walker, Science 286 (1999) 1700-1705) which suggests that the H+/ATP ratio is 10/3, rather than 3, consistent with P/O ratios of 2.3 with NADH and 1.4 with succinate, values that are also possible.

Mitochondrial respiratory chain adjustment to cellular energy demand

Because adaptation to physiological changes in cellular energy demand is a crucial imperative for life, mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation is tightly controlled by ATP consumption. Nevertheless, the mechanisms permitting such large variations in ATP synthesis capacity, as well as the consequence on the overall efficiency of oxidative phosphorylation, are not known. By investigating several physiological models in vivo in rats (hyper- and hypothyroidism, polyunsaturated fatty acid deficiency, and chronic ethanol intoxication) we found that the increase in hepatocyte respiration (from 9.8 to 22.7 nmol of O(2)/min/mg dry cells) was tightly correlated with total mitochondrial cytochrome content, expressed both per mg dry cells or per mg mitochondrial protein. Moreover, this increase in total cytochrome content was accompanied by an increase in the respective proportion of cytochrome oxidase; while total cytochrome content increased 2-fold (from 0.341 +/- 0.021 to 0.821 +/- 0.024 nmol/mg protein), cytochrome oxidase increased 10-fold (from 0.020 +/- 0.002 to 0.224 +/- 0.006 nmol/mg protein). This modification was associated with a decrease in the overall efficiency of the respiratory chain. Since cytochrome oxidase is well recognized for slippage between redox reactions and proton pumping, we suggest that this dramatic increase in cytochrome oxidase is responsible for the decrease in the overall efficiency of respiratory chain and, in turn, of ATP synthesis yield, linked to the adaptive increase in oxidative phosphorylation capacity.

Resistance of isolated pulmonary mitochondria during in vitro anoxia/reoxygenation

The aim of the study was to investigate the effect of in vitro anoxia/reoxygenation on the oxidative phosphorylation of isolated lung mitochondria. Mitochondria were isolated after harvesting from fresh pig lungs flushed with Euro-Collins solution. Mitochondrial respiratory parameters were determined in isolated mitochondria before anoxia (control), after 5-45 min anoxia followed by 5 min reoxygenation, and after 25 or 40 min of in vitro incubation in order to follow the in vitro aging of mitochondria during respiratory assays. Respiratory parameters measured after anoxia/reoxygenation did not show any oxidative phosphorylation dysfunction, indicating a high resistance of pulmonary mitochondria to in vitro anoxia/reoxygenation (up to 45 min anoxia). These results indicate that mitochondria are not directly responsible of their oxidative phosphorylation damage observed after in vivo ischemia (K. Willet et al., Transplantation 69 (2000) 582) but are a target of others cellular injuries leading to mitochondrial dysfunction in vivo.

Proton re-uptake partitioning between uncoupling protein and ATP synthase during benzohydroxamic acid-resistant state 3 respiration in tomato fruit mitochondria

The yield of oxidative phosphorylation in isolated tomato fruit mitochondria depleted of free fatty acids remains constant when respiratory rates are decreased by a factor of 3 by the addition of n-butyl malonate. This constancy makes the determination of the contribution of the linoleic acid-induced energy-dissipating pathway by the ADP/O method possible. No decrease in membrane potential is observed in state 3 respiration with increasing concentration of n-butyl malonate, indicating that the rate of ATP synthesis is steeply dependent on membrane potential. Linoleic acid decreases the yield of oxidative phosphorylation in a concentration-dependent manner by a pure protonophoric process like that in the presence of FCCP. ADP/O measurements allow calculation of the part of respiration leading to ATP synthesis and the part of respiration sustained by the dissipative H(+) re-uptake induced by linoleic acid. Respiration sustained by this energy-dissipating process remains constant at a given LA concentration until more than 50% inhibition of state 3 respiration by n-butyl malonate is achieved. The energy dissipative contribution to oxygen consumption is proposed to be equal to the protonophoric activity of plant uncoupling protein divided by the intrinsic H(+)/O of the cytochrome pathway. It increases with linoleic acid concentration, taking place at the expense of ADP phosphorylation without an increase in the respiration.

A cooperative model for protonmotive heme-copper oxidases. The role of heme a in the proton pump of cytochrome c oxidase

Oxido-reductions of metal centers in cytochrome c oxidase are linked to pK shifts of acidic groups in the enzyme (redox Bohr effects). The linkage at heme a results in proton uptake from the inner space upon reduction and proton release in the external space upon oxidation of the metal. The relationship of this process to the features of the proton pump in cytochrome c oxidase and its atomic structure revealed by X-ray crystallography to 2.8-2.3 A resolution is examined. A mechanism for the proton pump of cytochrome c oxidase, based on cooperative coupling at heme a, is proposed.

The yield of oxidative phosphorylation is controlled both by force and flux

Dissipation of energy during oxidative phosphorylation may be due to two distinct mechanisms: passive permeability to protons and/or cations (leak) or decrease in the efficiency of some proton pumps (slip). Whatever the mechanism involved, it is admitted that the wastage depends on the protonmotive force. However, the most relevant question in physiology is to determine whether other factors contribute or not to this efficiency. By comparing phosphorylating (high respiratory flux) or non phosphorylating (low respiratory flux) states at similar protonmotive force, we have shown that the wastage is higher in phosphorylating than in non-phosphorylating conditions. This strongly argues for the fact that the flux of oxidative phosphorylation is an important parameter in the control of the yield of this major energetic pathway.

Factors affecting the H+/e- stoichiometry in mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase: influence of the rate of electron flow and transmembrane delta pH

A study is presented of the factors affecting the H+/e- stoichiometry of the proton pump of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase, isolated and reconstituted in phospholipid vesicles (COV). Under level flow conditions, i.e., in the absence of a transmembrane delta muH+, the H+/e- ratio, obtained from spectrophotometric measurements of the initial rates of electron flow and H+ release specifically elicited by cytochrome c, varied from around 0 to 1, depending on the actual rate of electron flow through the oxidase. At steady state the H+/e- ratio for the oxidase was specifically depressed by the transmembrane delta pH. The study of the H+/e- ratio of the pump was complemented by an analysis of the redox pattern of cytochrome c, CuA, and heme a. From both sets of results and recent structural data from other groups, it is concluded that the dependence of the H+/e- ratio on the rate of electron flow through the oxidase and transmembrane delta pH is associated with the possible occurrence of two electron transfer pathways in cytochrome c oxidase, a coupled one (cyt c-->CuA-->heme a-->heme a3-CuB) and a decoupled one (cyt c-->CuA-->heme a3-CuB). The contributions of the two pathways, differently affected by kinetics and thermodynamic factors, will determine the actual H+/e- ratio of the pump. A possible role of heme a in the proton pump and the physiological implication of the variable H+/e- ratio in the oxidase are discussed.

The effect of the lipid peroxidation product 4-hydroxynonenal and of its metabolite 4-hydroxynonenoic acid on respiration of rat kidney cortex mitochondria

In rat kidney cortex mitochondria, 4-hydroxynonenal inhibits state 3 respiration as well as uncoupled respiration at micromolar concentrations. The inhibition is more distinct for NAD-linked than for FAD-linked respiration. 4-Hydroxynonenal increases the state 4 respiration. It is assumed that 4-hydroxynonenal behaves like a decoupling agent. 4-Hydroxynonenal augments the inhibitory effect of 2,4-dinitrophenol observed at superoptimal concentrations. 4-Hydroxynonenal is metabolised by renal mitochondria, and 4-hydroxynonenoic acid is one of the metabolites generated. This metabolite is without effect on respiration at concentrations up to 50 microM. Therefore, the effect of 4-hydroxynonenal on respiration is not mediated by this fatty acid derivative formed during respiratory measurements.

The nature of uncoupling by n-hexane, 1-hexanethiol and 1-hexanol in rat liver mitochondria

We have analyzed the effects of n-hexane, 1-hexanethiol, and 1-hexanol on the coupled respiration of rat liver mitochondria. Incubation of mitochondria with n-hexane, 1-hexanethiol and 1-hexanol resulted in a stimulation, at low concentrations, and an inhibition, at high concentrations, of the state 4 mitochondrial respiration. Three criteria, all based on the comparison with the effect of DNP, have been used to establish whether the stimulation of respiration, at low concentrations of n-hexane, 1-hexanethiol, and 1-hexanol, depends on protonophoric mechanisms. First, the quantitative relationship between the extents of respiratory stimulation and membrane potential depression: a strong decrease of membrane potential was induced by increasing concentrations of DNP and a negligible depression by increasing concentrations of n-hexane or 1-hexanethiol. Only a slight decrease was induced by 1-hexanol. Second, the quantitative relationship between the extents of respiratory stimulation and of proton conductance increase: at equivalent rates of respiration, the enhancement of the proton conductance induced by DNP was very marked, by n-hexane and 1-hexanethiol practically negligible, and by 1-hexanol much smaller than that induced by DNP. Third, in titrations with redox inhibitors of the proton pumps, the pattern of the relationship between proton pump conductance and membrane potential was markedly different from protonophoric and non-protonophoric uncouplers: almost linear in the case of DNP, highly non-linear in the case of n-hexane, 1-hexanethiol and 1-hexanol. These three criteria support the view that n-hexane, 1-hexanethiol, and partially 1-hexanol, uncouple mitochondrial respiration by a non-protonophoric mechanism.

Proton/electron stoichiometry of mitochondrial bc1 complex. Influence of pH and transmembrane delta pH

The effect of pH and transmembrane delta pH on the efficiency of the proton pump of the mitochondrial bc1 complex both in situ and in the reconstituted state was studied. In both cases the H+/e- ratio for vectorial proton translocation by the bc1 complex respiring at the steady state, under conditions in which the transmembrane pH difference (delta pH) represents the only component of the proton motive force (delta p), was significantly lower than that measured under level flow conditions. The latter amounts, at neutral pH, to 1 (2 including the scalar H+ release). In the reconstituted system steady-state delta pH was modulated by changing the intravesicular buffer as well as the intra/extra-liposomal pH. Under these conditions the H+/e- ratio varied inversely with the delta pH. The data presented show that delta pH exerts a critical control on the proton pump of the bc1 complex. Increasing the external pH above neutrality caused a decrease of the level flow H+/e- ratio. This effect is explained in terms of proton/electron linkage in b cytochromes.

Mechanistic and phenomenological features of proton pumps in the respiratory chain of mitochondria

Various direct, indirect (kinetic and thermodynamic), and combined mechanisms have been proposed to explain the conversion of redox energy into a transmembrane protonmotive force (delta p) by enzymatic complexes of respiratory chains. The conceptual evolution of these models is examined. The characteristics of thermodynamic coupling between redox transitions of electron carriers and scalar proton transfer in cytochrome c oxidase and its possible involvement in proton pumping is discussed. Other aspects dealt with in this paper are: (i) variability of <--H+/e- stoichiometries, in cytochrome c oxidase and cytochrome c reductase and its mechanistic implications; (ii) possible models by which the reduction of dioxygen to water at the binuclear heme-copper center of protonmotive oxidases can be directly involved in proton pumping. Finally a unifying concept for proton pumping by the redox complexes of respiratory chain is presented.

The causes and functions of mitochondrial proton leak

The non-linear relationship between respiration rate and protonmotive force in isolated mitochondria is explained entirely by delta p-dependent changes in the proton conductance of the mitochondrial inner membrane and is not caused by redox slip in the proton pumps. Mitochondrial proton leak occurs in intact cells and tissues: the futile cycle of proton pumping and proton leak accounts for 26% +/- 7% of the total oxygen consumption rate or 33% +/- 7% of the mitochondrial respiration rate of isolated hepatocytes (mean +/- S.D. for 43 rats); 52% of the oxygen consumption rate of resting perfused muscle and up to 38% of the basal metabolic rate of a rat, suggesting that heat production may be an important function in the proton leak in homeotherms. Together with non-mitochondrial oxygen consumption, it lowers the effective P/O ratio in cells from maximum possible values of 2.33 (palmitate oxidation) or 2.58 (glucose oxidation) to as low as 1.1 in liver or 0.8 in muscle. The effective P/O ratio increases in response to ATP demand; the ability to allow rapid switching of flux from leak to ATP turnover may be an even more important function of the leak reaction than heat production. The mitochondrial proton conductance in isolated mitochondria and in hepatocytes is greatly modulated by thyroid hormones, by phylogeny and by body mass. Usually the reactions of ATP turnover change in parallel so that the coupling ratio is not greatly affected. Changes in proton leak in tissues are brought about in the short term by changes in mitochondrial protonmotive force and in the longer term by changes in the surface area and proton permeability of the mitochondrial inner membrane. Permeability changes are probably caused by changes in the fatty acid composition of the membrane phospholipids.

The effect of respiration on the permeability of the mitochondrial membrane to ions

1. The rates of cation uptake, for either organic cations such as tetrapropylammonium, TPA+, at variable tetraphenylboron concentrations, TPB-, or inorganic cations such as Mn2+, or K+ plus valinomycin, have been measured in mitochondria either respiring, under uncoupler titrations, or non-respiring, under variable K+ diffusion potentials. 2. The flow-force relationship for the respiration-coupled ion fluxes during titrations with uncouplers is almost identical to that obtained for the K(+)-diffusion driven fluxes. Similar results are obtained when TPA+ is replaced with inorganic cations, either monovalent such as K+ (+valinomycin), or divalent such as Mn2+. 3. By applying the Eyring analysis, as developed by Garlid et al. (Garlid, K.D., Beavis, A.D. and Ratkje, S.K. (1989) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 976, 109-121), from the flux-voltage relationships the values for the permeability coefficients and for the energy barriers have been obtained for the transport of the ion pair TPA(+)-TPB-, of Mn2+ and of K+ plus valinomycin, in non-respiring and in respiring, coupled and uncoupled, mitochondria. 4. The findings that the rates of respiration-coupled ion fluxes, at all values of membrane potential, are similar to the rates of the K+ diffusion potential-coupled ion fluxes and the similar pattern of the flux-voltage relationships during the titrations with uncouplers and artificial gradients indicate that the membrane permeability for ions is not modified by respiration.

Characteristics of energy-linked proton translocation in liposome reconstituted bovine cytochrome bc1 complex. Influence of the protonmotive force on the H+/e- stoichiometry

A study is presented on the H+/e- stoichiometry for proton translocation by the isolated cytochrome bc1 complex under level-flow and steady-state conditions. An experimental procedure was used which allows the determination of pure vectorial proton translocation in both conditions in a single experiment. The results obtained indicate an H+/e- ratio of 1 at level-flow and 0.3 at steady-state. The ratios appear to be independent of the rate of electron transfer through the complex. Making use of pyranine-entrapped bc1 vesicles, a respiration-dependent steady-state delta pH value of 0.4 was determined in the presence of valinomycin. This value could be either decreased by subsaturating concentrations of the uncoupler carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP) or increased by introducing bovine serum albumin in the assay mixture. The steady-state H+/e- ratio appeared to be in linear inverse correlation with the delta pH. This indicates that delta pH exerts a control on the proton pump of the bc1 complex at the steady state. The effect of valinomycin-mediated potassium-diffusion potential on electron-transfer and proton-translocation activities is also shown. The experiments presented show that the H+/e- ratio is unaffected, both at level flow and steady state, by an imposed diffusion potential up to around 100 mV. At higher potential values the level-flow H+/e- ratio slightly decreased. Measurements as a function of imposed membrane potential of the rate of electron transfer at level flow and of the rate of the pre-steady-state reduction of b and c1 cytochromes in the complex indicate activation of electron transfer at potential values of 40-50 mV. This activation appears, however, to involve a rate-limiting step which remains normally coupled to proton translocation.

The mechanism of the increase in mitochondrial proton permeability induced by thyroid hormones

Three possible mechanisms by which different levels of thyroid hormones in rats might cause the observed sevenfold change in the apparent proton permeability of the inner membrane of isolated liver mitochondria were investigated. (a) Cytochrome c oxidase was isolated from the livers of hypothyroid, euthyroid and hyperthyroid rats and incorporated into liposomes made with soya phospholipids. There was no difference between the proton current/voltage curves of the three types of vesicles. The hormonal effects, therefore, were not an inherent property of the enzymes, and were not due to different coupling of electron flow through the enzyme to proton transport. (b) The surface area of the mitochondrial inner membrane was shown by three different assays to be greater by a factor of between two and three in mitochondria from hyperthyroid animals than in mitochondria from hypothyroid animals; euthyroid controls were intermediate. This difference in surface area of the inner membrane explains less than half of the difference in apparent proton permeability. (c) The proton permeability of liposomes prepared from phospholipids extracted from mitochondrial inner membranes of hyperthyroid rats was three times greater than the proton permeability of those from hypothyroid rats; euthyroid controls were intermediate. This suggests, first, that the proton permeability of the phospholipid bilayer is an important component of the proton permeability in intact mitochondria and, second, thyroid hormone-induced changes in the bilayer are a major part of the mechanism of increased proton permeability. Such changes may be due to the known differences in fatty acid composition of mitochondrial phospholipids in different thyroid states. Thus we have identified two mechanisms by which thyroid hormone levels in rats change proton flux/mass protein in isolated liver mitochondria: a change in the area of the inner membrane/mass protein and a change in the intrinsic permeability of the phospholipid bilayer.

Activation of respiration and loss of thermodynamic control in hyperthyroidism. Is it due to increased slipping in mitochondrial proton pumps?

T3 administration increases the extent of non-linearity in the flow-force relationship between pump proton conductance and protonmotive force. The effect is present also at the ATPase proton pump. These effects are not accompanied by changes in passive proton conductance. Incubation of mitochondria at 45 degrees C also causes an increased non-linearity, accompanied by a partial increase of proton conductance. It appears that the increase of respiratory activity following T3 administration is due to loss of thermodynamic control within or at the proton pumps, an effect which might be attributed to increased slipping.