Immunological detection of microtubule poison-induced conformational changes in tubulin

Plasma membrane tubulin

The association of tubulin with the plasma membrane comprises multiple levels of penetration into the bilayer: from integral membrane protein, to attachment via palmitoylation, to surface binding, and to microtubules attached by linker proteins to proteins in the membrane. Here we discuss the soundness and weaknesses of the chemical and biochemical evidence marshaled to support these associations, as well as the mechanisms by which tubulin or microtubules may regulate functions at the plasma membrane.

Direct interaction of Bcl-2 proteins with tubulin

A direct interaction between tubulin and several pro-apoptotic and anti-apoptotic members of the Bcl-2 family has been demonstrated by effects on the assembly of microtubules from pure rat brain tubulin. Bcl-2, Bid, and Bad inhibit assembly sub-stoichiometrically, whereas peptides from Bak and Bax promote tubulin polymerization at near stoichiometric concentrations. These opposite effects on microtubule assembly are mutually antagonistic. The BH3 homology domains, common to all members of the family, are involved in the interaction with tubulin but do not themselves affect polymerization. Pelleting experiments with paclitaxel-stabilized microtubules show that Bak is associated with the microtubule pellet, whereas Bid remains primarily with the unpolymerized fraction. These interactions require the presence of the anionic C-termini of alpha- and beta-tubulin as they do not occur with tubulin S in which the C-termini have been removed. While in no way ruling out other pathways, such direct associations are the simplest potential regulatory mechanism for apoptosis resulting from disturbances in microtubule or tubulin function.

Localization of the vinblastine-binding site on beta-tubulin

A fluorescent vinblastine derivative, vinblastine-4'-anthranilate, has been shown to inhibit polymerization of rat brain tubulin (IC50 = 4.8 microM). Binding of the drug to tubulin increases fluorescence intensity, causes a small emission blue shift, and has a quantum yield of 0.037. Fluorescence increases as a function of drug concentration, with a high affinity site and an undetermined number of lower affinity sites. Photolabeling, by exciting the fluorescent drug-tubulin complex at the absorption maximum of anthranilate, yields a covalent adduct confined to beta-tubulin. Its formation is specific in that it is blocked by maytansine or vinblastine. Tryptic hydrolysis identifies a single fluorescent beta-peptide coinciding with residues 175-213. The interactions between various ligands at this central portion of beta-tubulin are discussed.

Molecular mechanism of colchicine action: induced local unfolding of beta-tubulin

Colchicine, the classic antimitotic poison, disrupts cell division by preventing proper assembly of microtubules in the mitotic spindle. Colchicine is known to act by binding to tubulin, the heterodimeric subunit of microtubules. How this binding to tubulin changes the structure of the protein and results in polymerization poisoning has not been characterized. The structural locus of spectroscopically detected conformational changes induced by colchicine is unknown. We report here that colchicine induces the unfolding of a small region in the carboxyl-terminal region of beta-tubulin, around Arg-390. This unfolding is detected by proteolysis with trypsin and chymotrypsin. Chymotrypsin cleaves this region after Phe-389, and trypsin cleaves after Lys-392. The unfolded region appears to be the carboxyl end of an amphipathic helix in the absence of colchicine, and we propose that this unfolding prevents contacts necessary for assembly. Our results suggest that beta-tubulin is exposed on the growing end of the microtubule, which provides a mechanism for coupling GTP hydrolysis to polymerization.

Podophyllotoxin, steganacin and combretastatin: natural products that bind at the colchicine site of tubulin

A large number of antimicrotubule agents are known that bind to tubulin in vitro and disrupt microtubule assembly in vitro and in vivo. Many of these agents bind to the same site on the tubulin molecule, as does colchicine. Of these, the natural products podophyllotoxin, steganacin and combretastatin are the subjects of this review. For each of these, the chemistry and biochemistry are described. Particular attention is given to stereochemical considerations. Biosynthetic pathways for podophyllotoxin and congeners are surveyed. The binding to tubulin and the effects on microtubule assembly and disassembly are described and compared. In addition, structural features important to binding are examined using available analogs. Several features significant for tubulin interaction are common to these compounds and to colchicine. These are described and the implications for tubulin structure are discussed. The manifold results of applying these agents to biological systems are reviewed. These actions include effects that are clearly microtubule mediated and others in which the microtubule role is less obvious. Activity of some of these compounds due to inhibition of DNA topoisomerase is discussed. The range of species in which these compounds occur is examined and in the case of podophyllotoxin is found to be quite broad. In addition, the range of species that are sensitive to the effects of these compounds is discussed.

Microtubule assembly protects the region 28-38 of the beta-tubulin subunit

Polyclonal antibodies have been raised against the peptide 28-38 of the beta-subunit of the tubulin heterodimer in order to study the accessibility of this region in the tubulin heterodimer and in various tubulin assemblies. These antibodies were specific for all beta-tubulin subunits, except for beta'-tubulin isotypes, and did not recognize the alpha-tubulin subunit. The 28-38 region does not play a role in the interaction between the alpha- and beta-subunits since it was accessible to the antibodies on the native heterodimer. The accessibility of the antibodies was not modified by several microtubular poisons. In contrast, in all tubulin assemblies obtained in the presence of microtubular associated proteins, the region 28-38 was not available to the antibodies. These antibodies did not react with microtubules or tubulin spirals assembled either from microtubule proteins or from pure tubulin when these tubulin assemblies were probed in the absence of free tubulin after centrifugation on glass coverslips. In addition, antibodies failed to interact with the microtubule cytoskeleton in cultured Ptk2 cells indicating that the 28-38 region of beta-tubulin is also protected in cellular structures. These observations suggest that the 28-38 region of the beta-tubulin subunit is either located in a zone of interaction between two successive tubulin dimers within a protofilament or hidden by an allosteric conformational change which occurs during tubulin assembly.

Effects of antimitotic agents on tubulin-nucleotide interactions

The interaction of antimitotic drugs with guanine nucleotides in the tubulin-microtubule system is reviewed. Antimitotic agent-tubulin interactions can be covalent, entropic, allosteric or coupled to other equilibria (such as divalent cation binding, alternate polymer formation, or the stabilization of native tubulin structure). Antimitotics bind to tubulin at a few common sites and alter the ability of tubulin to form microtubules. Colchicine and podophyllotoxin compete for a common overlapping binding site but only colchicine induces GTPase activity and large conformational changes in the tubulin heterodimer. The vinca alkaloids, vinblastine and vincristine, the macrocyclic ansa macrolides, maytansine and ansamitocin P-3, and the fungal antimitotic, rhizoxin, share and compete for a different binding site near the exchangeable nucleotide binding site. The macrocyclic heptapeptide, phomopsin A, and the depsipeptide, dolastatin 10, bind to a site adjacent to the vinca alkaloid and nucleotide sites. Colchicine, vinca alkaloids, dolastatin 10 and phomopsin A induce alternate polymer formation (sheets for colchicine, spirals for vinblastine and vincristine and rings for dolastatin 10 and phomopsin A). Maytansine, ansamitocin P-3 and rhizoxin inhibit vinblastine-induced spiral formation. Taxol stoichiometrically induces microtubule formation and, in the presence of GTP, assembly-associated GTP hydrolysis. Analogs of guanine nucleotides also alter polymer morphology. Thus, sites on tubulin for drugs and nucleotides communicate allosterically with the interfaces that form longitudinal and lateral contacts within a microtubule. Microtubule associated proteins (MAPs), divalent cations, and buffer components can alter the surface interactions of tubulin and thus modulate the interactions between antimitotic drugs and guanine nucleotides.

Differential in vitro action of S-12363, a new vinblastine derivative, and of its epimer on microtubule proteins

The action of two epimers of a new vinblastine derivative that differ in their in vivo antitumor activity and their cytotoxicity was studied in vitro in brain microtubule proteins. These two compounds, called S-12363 and S-12362, could not be distinguished from one another or from other active vinca alkaloids by their ability to prevent microtubule assembly. However, they differed strongly both from one another and from vincristine and vinblastine in their ability to induce the formation of tubulin paracrystals and in the stability of the paracrystals following temperature shifts from 0 degree to 37 degrees C and vice versa. The most potent drug, S-12363, induced considerable tubulin aggregation, which was even more pronounced than that observed in the presence of vincristine. Previous results have shown that S-12363, in contrast to vincristine, induces no neurotoxic effects. This observation is in disagreement with a direct relationship between tubulin aggregation and neurotoxicity.

Interactions of colchicine with tubulin

Colchicine exerts its biological effects through binding to the soluble tubulin heterodimer, the major component of the microtubule. The colchicine-binding abilities of tubulins from a variety of sources are summarized, and the mechanism of colchicine binding to brain tubulin is explored in depth. The relationship between colchicinoid structure and tubulin binding activity provides insight into the structural features of colchicine responsible for high affinity binding to tubulin and is reviewed for analogs in the colchicine series. The thermodynamic and kinetic aspects of the association are described and evaluated in terms of the binding mechanism. Colchicine binding to tubulin results in unusual alterations in the low energy electronic spectra of colchicine. The spectroscopic features of colchicine bound to tubulin are discussed in terms of the nature of the colchicine-tubulin complex. Attempts to locate the high affinity colchicine binding site on tubulin are presented.

Purified podophyllotoxin (CPH-86) inhibits lymphocyte proliferation but augments macrophage proliferation

Purified podophyllotoxin (CPH-86) is an inhibitor of microtubular aggregation used in the treatment of cancer, psoriasis and rheumatoid arthritis. To better understand its immunopharmacology we examined its effects on human lymphocytes and monocytes and guinea pig macrophages. CPH-86 inhibits mitogen-induced human lymphocyte proliferation and macrophage growth factor-stimulated macrophage proliferation with ID50s of approximately 10(-7) M. The effect of CPH-86 on lymphocytes in conjunction with mitogen is nonlethal, evident during the early but not the late phases of proliferation, and associated with early increases in cyclic AMP levels. In contrast to these obviously inhibitory effects, CPH-86 (10(-7) M) alone induces IL-1 by human monocytes and, with mitogen, it induces IL-2 production by human lymphocytes. It directly stimulates macrophage proliferation and potentiates the effects of low doses of macrophage growth factor to do so. The latter effects may be mediated by colony stimulating factor production. The effects of CPH-86 are not mediated by inhibition of prostaglandin synthesis. The stimulation of monokine and lymphokine production by CPH-86 may represent positive features of its action and may be immunotherapeutic.

Binding to tubulin of an allocolchicine spin probe: interaction with the essential SH groups and other active sites

EPR titration of tubulin with an allocolchicine spin probe showed more than one binding site: one high-affinity binding site (Kd = 8 microM), consistent with the Ki found for competition with colchicine, and one or more low-affinity site(s) (Kd higher than 50 microM). No disturbance of the EPR signal of the tubulin-bound allocolchicine spin probe could be observed at room temperature in the presence of other paramagnetic probes: Mn(II) for the binding site of Mg(II), Co(II) for the Zn(II) binding site and Cr(III)GTP for the binding site of the exchangeable GTP. Labelling of tubulin with both the allocolchicine and a SH-group spin probe also showed lack of interaction. The colchicine-binding site is thus sterically isolated from the binding sites for GTP, Mg(II), Zn(II) and the two essential SH-groups. In the tubulin-colchicin complex, all SH-groups could still be labelled with an excess of the SH-reagent, N-ethylmaleimide. Furthermore, colchicine binding was only minimally influenced by the blocking of the two essential SH-groups. However, the rate constant of the reaction of two equivalents of the SH-reagent, a maleimide spin probe, with the tubulin-colchicine complex was only 50% of the rate constant found with uncomplexed tubulin. As direct steric interaction of the essential SH-groups with the colchicine-binding site can be excluded, we can now definitively decide that binding of colchicine to tubulin induces a conformational change, which affects the accessibility of the most reactive SH-groups.

The phagocytosis of yeast cells by blood monocytes. Effects of therapeutic concentrations of Vinca alkaloids

The role of cytoplasmic microtubules in the phagocytosis of yeast cells by blood monocytes was studied by means of therapeutic concentrations of the Vinca alkaloids vincristine, vinblastine, and vindesine. Phagocytosis was measured in a monolayer of glass-adherent monocytes fed with fluorescein-labelled yeast cells. Phagocytosis was composed of two sequential processes, yeast cell adherence to the monocyte and yeast cell engulfment by the monocyte. Monocyte phagocytosis was significantly inhibited by the Vinca alkaloids, mainly due to inhibition of engulfment but probably also due to inhibition of adherence. Since the Vinca alkaloids are microtubule antagonists it is reasonable to assume that monocyte phagocytosis, both adherence and engulfment, are partially microtubule-dependent processes. It is suggested that Vinca alkaloid inhibition of monocyte phagocytosis is of value in the treatment of type II-III autoimmune disorders, such as idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura and autoimmune haemolytic anaemia.