Messenger RNA for the 73,000-dalton poly(A)-binding protein occurs as translationally repressed mRNP in duck reticulocytes

Is RNA the working genome in eukaryotes ? The 60 year evolution of a conceptual challenge

About 80 years ago, in 1943, after a century of biochemical and genetic research, DNA was established as the carrier of genetic information. At the onset of Molecular Biology around 1960, the genome of living organisms embodied 3 basic, still unknown paradigms: its composition, organisation and expression. Between 1980 and 1990, its replication was understood, and ideas about its 3D-organisation were suggested and finally confirmed by 2010. The basic mechanisms of gene expression in higher organisms, the synthesis of precursor RNAs and their processing into functional RNAs, were also discovered about 60 years ago in 1961/62. However, some aspects were then, and are still now debated, although the latest results in post-genomic research have confirmed the basic principles. When my history-essay was published in 2003, describing the discovery of RNA processing 40 years earlier, the main facts were not yet generally confirmed or acknowledged. The processing of pre-rRNA to 28 S and 18 S rRNA was clearly demonstrated, confirmed by others and generally accepted as a fact. However, the "giant" size of pre-mRNA 10-100 kb-long and pervasive DNA transcription were still to be confirmed by post-genomic methods. It was found, surprisingly, that up to 90% of DNA is transcribed in the life cycle of eukaryotic organisms thus showing that pervasive transcription was the general rule. In this essay, we shall take a journey through the 60-year history of evolving paradigms of gene expression which followed the emergence of Molecular Biology, and we will also evoke some of the "folklore" in research throughout this period. Most important was the growing recognition that although the genome is encoded in DNA, the Working Genome in eukaryotic organisms is RNA.

Feedback inhibition of poly(A)-binding protein mRNA translation. A possible mechanism of translation arrest by stalled 40 S ribosomal subunits

An adenine-rich cis element at the 5'-untranslated region (UTR) of Pabp1 mRNA is able to inhibit translation of its own mRNA. Similar inhibition of translation of a reporter beta-galactosidase mRNA is observed when the adenine-rich auto regulatory sequence (ARS) is placed within the 5'-UTR of this mRNA. For this translational control the distance of the ARS from the 5' cap is not important. However, it determines the number of 40 S ribosomal subunits bound to the translationally arrested mRNA. Inhibition of mRNA translation by this regulatory sequence occurs at the step of joining of the 60 S ribosomal subunit to the pre-initiation complex. Translational arrest of the ARS containing mRNA in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate cell-free system in the presence of exogenous Pabp1 protects the 5'-flanking region of the ARS from nuclease digestion. This protection depends on the binding of the 40 S ribosomal subunit to the mRNA. The size and the sequence of the nucleotide-protected fragment depends on the location of the ARS within the 5'-UTR. When the ARS is located at a distance of about 78 nucleotides from the 5' cap, a 40-nucleotide long region adjacent to the ARS is protected. On the other hand, when the ARS is moved further away from the 5' cap to a distance of approximately 267 nucleotides, a 100-nucleotide-long region adjacent to the ARS is protected from nuclease digestion. Nuclease protection is attributed to the presence of one or more stalled 40 S ribosomal subunits near the Pabp1-bound ARS.

The expression of poly(A)-binding protein gene is translationally regulated in a growth-dependent fashion through a 5'-terminal oligopyrimidine tract motif

Poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) is an important regulator of gene expression that has been implicated in control of translation initiation. Here we report the isolation and the initial structural and functional characterization of the human PABP gene. Delineation of the promoter region revealed that it directs the initiation of transcription at consecutive C residues within a stretch of pyrimidines. A study of the translational behavior of the corresponding mRNA demonstrates that it is translationally repressed upon growth arrest of cultured mouse fibroblasts and translationally activated in regenerating rat liver. Furthermore, transfection experiments show that the first 32 nucleotides of PABP mRNA are sufficient to confer growth-dependent translational control on a heterologous mRNA. Substitution of the C residue at the cap site by purines abolishes the translational control of the chimeric mRNA. These features have established PABP mRNA as a new member of the terminal oligopyrimidine tract mRNA family. Members of this family are known to encode for components of the translational apparatus and to contain an oligopyrimidine tract at the 5' terminus (5'TOP). This motif mediates their translational control in a growth-dependent manner.

Negative control of the poly(A)-binding protein mRNA translation is mediated by the adenine-rich region of its 5'-untranslated region

Translation of the mRNA for the poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) may be autoregulated by the binding of PABP to the A-rich segment of its 5'-untranslated region (UTR). To test this hypothesis, we examined the effect of different fragments of the 5'-UTR from human PABP cDNA on the translation of the beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) reporter gene. Presence of the A-rich sequence from the 5'-UTR of PABP mRNA inhibited expression of the chimeric beta-Gal gene in transfected HeLa cells. The differences in expression of beta-Gal polypeptide was due to the translational repression of beta-Gal mRNA containing the A-rich 5'-UTR of PABP mRNA. The A-rich region of the 5'-UTR located within nucleotides 58-146 of PABP mRNA was sufficient to mediate translational control of this mRNA expression. We also examined the effect of overexpression of PABP mRNA in HeLa cells. The ectopic PABP mRNA without the A-rich 5'-UTR region was translated efficiently, whereas the translation of the endogenous PABP mRNA was substantially inhibited in the transfected cells. In contrast, the ectopic PABP mRNA containing the A-rich 5'-UTR region did not show similar effect on the translation of the endogenous PABP mRNA in these cells. These results suggest that feedback control of mRNA translation is involved in regulating PABP expression in HeLa cells.

Translational control of poly(A)-binding protein expression

Poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) is important for translation of eukaryotic mRNA and may be involved in shortening of its poly(A) tract. In many eukaryotic cells, this mRNA is inefficiently translated. The 5' untranslated region (UTR) of PABP mRNA has several adenine-rich regions which may serve as the PABP-binding sites to control its translation by a feed-back mechanism. This postulate was tested by using in vitro transcribed PABP mRNA and a rabbit reticulocyte lysate cell-free system. Results of our studies show that removal of the putative PABP-binding sites from the 5' UTR of this mRNA enhances its translation in the rabbit reticulocyte cell-free system. Furthermore, in vitro translation of the full-length PABP mRNA was inhibited by addition of purified PABP to the cell-free system. In contrast, translation of truncated mRNA lacking the putative PABP-binding sites at the 5' UTR was not inhibited by exogenous PABP. We have also tested the ability of purified PABP to bind to the 5' UTR of PABP mRNA using ultraviolet-mediated covalent cross-linking of RNA and proteins in vitro. Our results show that exogenous PABP binds to the 5' UTR of its full-length mRNA. Furthermore, incubation of PABP mRNA in rabbit reticulocyte lysate also led to binding of the endogenous PABP within the first 223 nucleotides of the 5' UTR. The adenine-rich regions are located within this segment of PABP mRNA. Following incubation of PABP mRNA in the reticulocyte lysate cell-free system under conditions of mRNA translation, the polysomal and non-translated free mRNA fractions were separated by centrifugation. Analysis of free and polysomal mRNA-protein (mRNP) complexes following ultraviolet-induced cross-linking showed that the free mRNP population was preferentially enriched in PABP. Results of our studies, therefore, suggest that PABP mRNA translation may be repressed by a unique feed-back mechanism.

Regulation of translation by specific protein/mRNA interactions

This review will focus on cases of specific translational control by protein/RNA interactions in the 5'- or 3'-UTR of eukaryote mRNA where either the cis-acting RNA determinant or the trans-acting protein (or preferably both) have been identified with fair certainty. Examples of messages that are regulated by 5' motifs, which are proposed to occlude ribosome binding when bound by their specific factors, include ferritin and ribosomal protein mRNAs and the autoregulated thymidylate synthase and poly(A)-binding mRNAs. However, it has become increasingly evident recently that 3' UTR determinants and their specific binding proteins also regulate translation efficiency either directly, or indirectly via an influence on the polyadenylation status of the mRNA. It is still unclear how events at the 3' end of mRNA influence ribosome binding. Most, if not all, of the mRNAs known to be regulated by 3' UTR motifs are subject to regulation during early development or during differentiation such as several spermatocyte and oocyte mRNAs and erythroid lipoxygenase mRNA. To date, in all cases where translation is controlled directly by specific protein/mRNA interactions, the protein seems to act as a negative regulator, a translational repressor, whose binding to the specific site on the mRNA results in inhibition of initiation. The only cases of translational activation known so far concern internal initiation of translation of picornaviral RNAs, but this topic is beyond the scope of this review.

Dexamethasone stimulates rRNA gene transcription in rat myoblasts

The glucocorticoid analogue, dexamethasone, stimulated RNA synthesis more than two-fold in rat L6 myoblasts, without affecting the rate of cell proliferation. Treatment of myoblasts for 24 h with 10(-7) M dexamethasone resulted in a 30% increase in the cellular RNA level. More than a two-fold stimulation of pre-rRNA gene transcription by dexamethasone, as measured in isolated nuclei and by cell-free transcription, was accompanied by a corresponding increase in pre-rRNA levels. Co-incubation of myoblasts with cycloheximide and dexamethasone did not affect the enhanced pre-rRNA gene transcription demonstrating that de novo protein synthesis was unnecessary to manifest the dexamethasone effect on rDNA transcription. Support for this conclusion is provided by the finding that the levels of UBF1 and UBF2, rDNA upstream binding transcription factors, remain unchanged. The glucocorticoid antagonist RU38486 [11 beta-(4-dimethylaminophenyl)17 beta-hydroxy-17 alpha-(prop-1-ynyl)estra- 4,9-dien-3-one] inhibited the dexamethasone-stimulated rRNA gene transcription suggesting that the glucocorticoid receptor is involved in the response mechanism.

Translational repression of EF-1 alpha mRNA in vitro

In this report we show that when 10,000 x g supernatant extracts of growth arrested murine erythroleukemia (MEL) cells are incubated there is a rapid conversion of essentially all mRNAs to non-translating messenger ribonucleoprotein (RNP) particles. Most of these RNPs are readily translated in an initiation-dependent manner when added to a nuclease-treated rabbit reticulocyte lysate. A notable exception is the RNP containing eucaryotic elongation factor 1 alpha (EF-1 alpha) mRNA. The mRNA for poly(A)-binding protein behaved similarly to EF-1 alpha. Previous work has demonstrated that the translation of both these mRNAs are repressed in vivo when the growth of a number of different mammalian cells is arrested [Slobin L. I. and Jordan, P. (1984) Eur J. Biochem. 145, 1984; Thomas, G. and Thomas, G. (1986) J. Cell Biol. 103, 1986]. Translational activity of EF-1 alpha mRNA could be restored by treating RNP particles with 0.5 M KCl, provided that the RNPs were separated from salt wash by chromatography on oligo(dT)-cellulose. Addition of the salt wash to total MEL cell mRNA significantly and selectively inhibited EF-1 alpha mRNA translation, suggesting that a component of the salt wash acts as a trans-acting translational repressor of EF-1 alpha mRNA.

Alteration of translation and stability of mRNA for the poly(A)-binding protein during myogenesis

The regulation of synthesis of various factors involved in mRNA translation during differentiation of muscle cells was examined. The steady-state levels of mRNAs coding for eukaryotic initiation factor (eIF) 2 alpha, 2 beta and elongation factor (eEF)-1 alpha were measured in both proliferating rat L6 myoblast and differentiated myotubes. The steady-state levels of these mRNAs were not altered during myogenesis. Furthermore, the distribution of these mRNAs between repressed and translated populations remained unchanged. Recent studies suggest a role for poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) in translation initiation. Therefore, we also examined the expression of PABP mRNA during myogenesis. The PABP mRNA was less abundant in myotubes compared to myoblasts. However, the synthesis of PABP remained unchanged. In myoblasts, approximately 50-60% of the total mRNA was associated with polyribosomes, whereas in myotubes more than 80% of the mRNA was associated with polyribosomes. These results, therefore, suggest that the PABP mRNA was more efficiently translated in differentiated myotubes than in the proliferating myoblasts. Measurement of the stability and transcription of PABP mRNA showed that, while transcription was not affected during myogenesis, the stability of the mRNA was reduced in differentiated cells. The t1/2 of PABP mRNA in myoblasts was 13 h compared to 7.5 h in myotubes. This observation suggests that the reduced steady-state level of PABP mRNA in myotube were largely due to the change in stability of this mRNA during myogenesis.

Identification of proteins associating with poly(A)-binding-protein mRNA

Synthesis of poly(A)-binding protein is regulated at the translational level. We have investigated the binding of proteins to this mRNA on the premise that the protein(s) of the mRNP complex may be involved in regulating the expression of the mRNA. We found the first 243 nucleotides of the 5' untranslated region to contain sequences essential for RNP formation. A large, single-stranded bulge structure encompassing stretches rich in adenine nucleotides and a potential stem-loop domain appear to be the primary sites for protein binding. Removal of the 243-nucleotide segment results in a drastic reduction in protein binding and a concomitant increase in translational efficiency in vitro. We suggest that proteins binding to this region, including poly(A)-binding protein itself, may be essential for regulating translation of this mRNA.

Distribution and activity of alternatively spliced Alzheimer amyloid peptide precursor and scrapie PrP mRNAs on rat brain polysomes

Mammalian brains contain low levels of the Alzheimer amyloid precursor variants (AAPPs) and the normal form of the scrapie agent protease-resistant protein (PrPc); however, their mRNAs are readily detectable. To understand these discrepancies we have investigated some aspects of the translational regulation of these mRNAs. An accurate blot-hybridization procedure was developed to measure absolute amounts of mRNA. Rat brain contains the following mRNA levels (ng/g tissue) AAPP(695), 170; AAPP(751/770), 63; PrPc, 144; actin, 615; glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (G3PDH), 359; ferritin, 148. The method was also used to determine the distribution of mRNAs between translationally active polysomes and translationally inactive ribonucleoprotein protein particles (mRNPs). More than 90% of G3PDH and actin mRNAs were associated with polysomal RNA; whereas, ferritin light chain mRNA was predominantly (90%) in mRNP RNA. The degree of cross-contamination of mRNPs with polysomes was less than 10%. Probes specific for the scrapie PrP protein and the AAPP(695) splice junction revealed that 70% of these mRNAs were associated with polysomes. One-half of AAPP(751/770) mRNAs (which comprise 20-30% of all AAPP mRNA in brain) were found in polysomes. We conclude therefore that both scrapie and AAPP mRNAs are subject to translational regulation in rat brain. Evidence from in vitro translational experiments confirm the message distribution determined by blot hybridization and corroborate the hypothesis that AAPP is subject to partial post-transcriptional regulation. Nevertheless, the low tissue levels of AAPP and PrPc must result primarily from their relatively rapid turnover.

A unified matrix hypothesis of DNA-directed morphogenesis, protodynamism and growth control

A theoretical concept is proposed, in order to explain some enigmatic aspects of cellular and molecular biology of eukaryotic organisms. Among these are the C-value paradox of DNA redundancy, the correlation of DNA content and cell size, the disruption of genes at DNA level, the "Chromosome field" data of Lima de Faria (Hereditas 93:1, 1980), the "quantal mitosis" proposition of Holtzer et al. (Curr. Top. Dev. Biol. 7:229 1972), the inheritance of morphological patterns, the relations of DNA and chromosome organisation to cellular structure and function, the molecular basis of speciation, etc. The basic proposition of the "Unified Matrix Hypothesis" is that the nuclear DNA has a direct morphogenic function, in addition to its coding function in protein synthesis. This additional genetic information is thought to be largely contained in the non-protein coding transcribed DNA, and in the untranscribed part of the genome.

Growth-related expression of a 72,000 molecular weight poly(A)+ mRNA binding protein

In this communication, we have studied a 72,000 mol w (p72) host protein which reacts with a mouse monoclonal antibody (PAb6) directed against antigenic determinants on the Simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen protein that map 5' of 0.42 map units on the viral genome. The p72 protein is an abundant basic (pI greater than 7) cytoplasmic protein found in both SV40-transformed and untransformed parental cells and in cell lines derived from normal human and tumor tissue. By two-dimensional gel analysis and Western blot analysis the p72 protein identified by PAb6 is indistinguishable from the 72,000 mol w protein PABP associated with the poly(A)+ tract of cytoplasmic messenger RNA molecules. In normal human peripheral blood mononuclear cells stimulated to proliferate with the T-cell-specific mitogenic lectin phytohemagglutinin the synthesis and cytoplasmic accumulation of p72 occurs very early during the G0----G1-phase transition. The p72 protein is also expressed in proliferating and differentiated human promyelocytic HL60 cells indicating that the expression of this protein is not strictly limited to cycling cells.

The poly(A)-binding protein facilitates in vitro translation of poly(A)-rich mRNA

To investigate the role of the 73-kDa poly(A)-binding protein in protein synthesis, the effect of the addition of homo-polyribonucleotides on the translation of polyadenylated and non-adenylated mRNA was studied in the rabbit reticulocyte lysate. Poly(A) was found to be the most effective polynucleotide in inhibiting duck-globin mRNA translation, whereas it had no effect on the translation of polyribosomal duck-globin mRNP, or on the endogenous synthesis of the rabbit reticulocyte lysate. The translation of poly(A)-free mRNA was not affected by the addition of poly(A). Furthermore, we found that the inhibiting effect of poly(A) can be reversed by addition of purified poly(A)-binding protein. It is thus likely that the 73-kDa poly(A)-binding protein is an essential factor necessary for poly(A)-rich mRNA translation.

A new type of prosome-like particle, composed of small cytoplasmic RNA and multimers of a 21-kDa protein, inhibits protein synthesis in vitro

A large fraction of the translationally repressed non-globin messenger RNA in duck erythroblasts is present in non-polyribosomal free mRNP structures which sediment in the 30-40-S range ('35 S'). In 0.5 M KCl, they form core complexes which show a pronounced peak at about 32 S containing mRNA and a discrete spherical RNP particle with a diameter of about 12 nm and the typical morphology of a prosome [H.-P. Schmid et al. (1984) EMBO J. 3, 29-34]. Buoyant density measurements and chromatography on oligo(dT)-cellulose indicate that this particle is bound to mRNA; it can be released from the mRNA by treatment of the free mRNP fraction with SDS. This prosome-like particle inhibits the translation of mRNA in vitro. It is composed primarily of multimers of a single 21-kDa protein and at least one species of RNA of about 80-100 nucleotides. It is resistant to dissociation by 2 M CS2SO4 and 1% SDS; the 21-kDa protein is not attacked by proteinase K unless the particle is extracted with phenol prior to treatment with the protease. The small RNA moiety of the particle hybridizes to the poly(A)-rich mRNA derived from the free mRNPs, as well as to polyribosomal mRNA. These data indicate that prosomes may serve to regulate mRNA translation; they show furthermore that prosome-like particles (about 600 kDa mass) may be built of up to 25 molecules of a single specific protein, rather than of the entire set of about 20 prosomal proteins previously identified.

Association of messenger RNA with the cytoskeletal framework in rat L6 myogenic cells

The distribution of mRNA between the detergent-soluble and insoluble (cytoskeleton) fractions in rat L6 myoblast and myotube cells was examined. Approximately 85% of cytoplasmic mRNA in both myoblasts and myotubes was found associated with the cytoskeletal framework. The cytoskeleton-bound mRNA was present as polysomes. In contrast, the mRNA of the detergent-soluble fraction was not associated with ribosomes and was thus considered to be the repressed population. The association of mRNA with the cytoskeletal framework was not affected by treatments leading to dissociation of polysomes. Differential distribution of mRNA between the soluble and cytoskeleton-bound fractions was analyzed by in vitro translation. The mRNAs coding for polypeptides of molecular masses 40 kDa and 60 kDa were preferentially enriched in the soluble fraction. The nature of binding between mRNA and the cytoskeletal framework was examined following in vivo cross-linking of RNA and protein by irradiating muscle cells with ultraviolet light. It was observed that this treatment covalently linked RNA and the neighbouring protein moieties without any detectable damage to the cytoskeletal framework, as measured by the distribution of RNAs and proteins between the cytoskeleton and soluble fractions. Analysis of the polypeptide moieties cross-linked to the mRNA have shown that a large number of polypeptides of molecular masses between 15-220 kDa were associated with both cytoskeleton-bound and soluble mRNAs. The polypeptide moieties of these mRNA-protein complexes were not only similar in the cytoskeleton and soluble mRNA-protein complexes but also were similar between myoblasts and myotubes. However, one polypeptide of 165 kDa was preferentially associated with the cytoskeleton-bound mRNA-protein complexes. Interestingly this 165-kDa polypeptide was also preferentially enriched in the total proteins from the cytoskeleton fraction. This result suggests a possible role of the 165-kDa polypeptide in association between mRNA and the cytoskeletal framework. To examine the mechanism of interaction between mRNA and the cytoskeletal framework we have reported here a ghost monolayer transcription system from myotubes. This transcription system was able to synthesize rRNA and mRNA. The mRNA transcribed in vitro was preferentially associated with the cytoskeleton structure present in the ghost monolayer system.

Inhibition of poly(A)-binding protein synthesis in Friend erythroleukemia cells subsequent to heat shock

When Friend erythroleukemia cells (FEC) are incubated at 43 degrees C there is a rapid and nearly complete inhibition of protein synthesis which can be reversed when cells are returned to their normal growing temperature of 37 degrees C. Examination of the recovery of FEC from heat shock indicates that most cellular mRNAs behave as a cohort and return to translation at approximately the same rate. We found a notable exception to this rule in the case of a 78 kDa basic protein (named protein A) whose rate of return to a normal synthetic rate is markedly inhibited subsequent to heat shock. We show that protein A corresponds to the 78 kDa polypeptide commonly found to be associated with the poly(A) tails of mammalian mRNA.

Translational repression of mRNA for eucaryotic elongation factors in Friend erythroleukemia cells

Poly(A)-containing mRNA was prepared from polyribosomes and postpolyribosomal messenger ribonucleoprotein particles (mRNP) from Friend erythroleukemic cells. Both mRNA types were translated in vitro and the 35S-labeled translation products examined by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Among the most abundant untranslated mRNA species was the mRNA coding for eucaryotic elongation factor Tu (eEF-Tu). In addition, the mRNA for eucaryotic elongation factor Ts was also present in Friend cells in untranslated form. Calculations based on translation assays indicate that eEF-Tu represents about 15% of the translation products of RNP mRNA and that approximately 40% of the eEF-Tu synthesized in vitro is encoded by translationally repressed mRNA. This repressed mRNA can be activated by addition of cycloheximide to cell cultures. At the level of 0.1 micrograms/ml, cycloheximide was found to inhibit cellular protein synthesis by about 50% while augmenting the relative rate of eEF-Tu synthesis 1.6-fold. This result suggested that eEF-Tu mRNA might initiate poorly. However, addition of supersaturating levels of mRNA to a reticulocyte lysate augmented eEF-Tu synthesis about twofold, while generally depressing the synthesis of other proteins by about 40%. Thus the storage of large amounts of eEF-Tu mRNA in vivo is unlikely to be due directly to the ineffectiveness of the mRNA in competing for the initiation machinery of the cell. The results presented in this report suggest that the supply of active eEF-Tu in erythroleukemic cells is controlled, at least in part, by a translational mechanism.