Release of transcript and template during transcription termination at the trp operon attenuator

Head-on and co-directional RNA polymerase collisions orchestrate bidirectional transcription termination

Genomic DNA is a crowded track where motor proteins frequently collide. It remains underexplored whether these collisions carry physiological function. In this work, we develop a single-molecule assay to visualize the trafficking of individual E. coli RNA polymerases (RNAPs) on DNA. Based on transcriptomic data, we hypothesize that RNAP collisions drive bidirectional transcription termination of convergent gene pairs. Single-molecule results show that the head-on collision between two converging RNAPs is necessary to prevent transcriptional readthrough but insufficient to release the RNAPs from the DNA. Remarkably, co-directional collision of a trailing RNAP into the head-on collided complex dramatically increases the termination efficiency. Furthermore, stem-loop structures formed in the nascent RNA are required for collisions to occur at well-defined positions between convergent genes. These findings suggest that physical collisions between RNAPs furnish a mechanism for transcription termination and that programmed genomic conflicts can be exploited to co-regulate the expression of multiple genes.

Trigger loop dynamics can explain stimulation of intrinsic termination by bacterial RNA polymerase without terminator hairpin contact

In bacteria, intrinsic termination signals cause disassembly of the highly stable elongating transcription complex (EC) over windows of two to three nucleotides after kilobases of RNA synthesis. Intrinsic termination is caused by the formation of a nascent RNA hairpin adjacent to a weak RNA-DNA hybrid within RNA polymerase (RNAP). Although the contributions of RNA and DNA sequences to termination are largely understood, the roles of conformational changes in RNAP are less well described. The polymorphous trigger loop (TL), which folds into the trigger helices to promote nucleotide addition, also is proposed to drive termination by folding into the trigger helices and contacting the terminator hairpin after invasion of the hairpin in the RNAP main cleft [Epshtein V, Cardinale CJ, Ruckenstein AE, Borukhov S, Nudler E (2007) Mol Cell 28:991-1001]. To investigate the contribution of the TL to intrinsic termination, we developed a kinetic assay that distinguishes effects of TL alterations on the rate at which ECs terminate from effects of the TL on the nucleotide addition rate that indirectly affect termination efficiency by altering the time window in which termination can occur. We confirmed that the TL stimulates termination rate, but found that stabilizing either the folded or unfolded TL conformation decreased termination rate. We propose that conformational fluctuations of the TL (TL dynamics), not TL-hairpin contact, aid termination by increasing EC conformational diversity and thus access to favorable termination pathways. We also report that the TL and the TL sequence insertion (SI3) increase overall termination efficiency by stimulating pausing, which increases the flux of ECs into the termination pathway.

Bacterial transcription terminators: the RNA 3'-end chronicles

The process of transcription termination is essential to proper expression of bacterial genes and, in many cases, to the regulation of bacterial gene expression. Two types of bacterial transcriptional terminators are known to control gene expression. Intrinsic terminators dissociate transcription complexes without the assistance of auxiliary factors. Rho-dependent terminators are sites of dissociation mediated by an RNA helicase called Rho. Despite decades of study, the molecular mechanisms of both intrinsic and Rho-dependent termination remain uncertain in key details. Most knowledge is based on the study of a small number of model terminators. The extent of sequence diversity among functional terminators and the extent of mechanistic variation as a function of sequence diversity are largely unknown. In this review, we consider the current state of knowledge about bacterial termination mechanisms and the relationship between terminator sequence and steps in the termination mechanism.

Ribosomal protein S1 promotes transcriptional cycling

Prokaryotic RNA polymerases are capable of efficient, continuous synthesis of RNA in vivo, yet purified polymerase-DNA model systems for RNA synthesis typically produce only a limited number of catalytic turnovers. Here, we report that the ribosomal protein S1--which plays critical roles in translation initiation and elongation in Escherichia coli and is believed to stabilize mRNA on the ribosome--is a potent activator of transcriptional cycling in vitro. Deletion of the two C-terminal RNA-binding modules--out of a total of six loosely homologous RNA-binding modules present in S1--resulted in a near-loss of the ability of S1 to enhance transcription, whereas disruption of the very last C-terminal RNA-binding module had only a mild effect. We propose that, in vivo, cooperative interaction of multiple RNA-binding modules in S1 may enhance the transcript release from RNA polymerase, alleviating its inhibitory effect and enabling the core enzyme for continuous reinitiation of transcription.

Shortening of RNA:DNA hybrid in the elongation complex of RNA polymerase is a prerequisite for transcription termination

Passage of E. coli RNA polymerase through an intrinsic transcription terminator, which encodes an RNA hairpin followed by a stretch of uridine residues, results in quick dissociation of the elongation complex. We show that folding of the hairpin disrupts the three upstream base pairs of the 8 bp RNA:DNA hybrid, a major stability determinant in the complex. Shortening the weak rU:dA hybrid from 8 nt to 5 nt causes dissociation of the complex. During termination, the hairpin does not directly compete for base pairing with the 8 bp hybrid. Thus, melting of the hybrid seems to result from spatial restrictions in RNA polymerase that couple the hairpin formation with the disruption of the hybrid immediately downstream from the stem. Our results suggest that a similar mechanism disrupts elongation complexes of yeast RNA polymerase II in vitro.

Transcription termination: primary intermediates and secondary adducts

In living organisms, stable elongation complexes of RNA polymerase dissociate at specific template positions in a process of transcription termination. It has been suggested that the dissociation is not the immediate cause of termination but is preceded by catalytic inactivation of the elongation complex. In vitro reducing ionic strength can be used to stabilize very unstable and catalytically inactive complex at the point of termination; the previous biochemical characterization of this complex has led to important conclusions regarding termination mechanism. Here we analyze in detail the complexes formed between DNA template, nascent RNA, and Escherichia coli RNA polymerase during transcription through the tR2 terminator of bacteriophage lambda. At low ionic strength, the majority of elongation complexes fall apart upon reaching the terminator. Released RNA and DNA efficiently rebind RNA polymerase (RNAP) and form binary RNAP.RNA and RNAP.DNA complexes, which are indistinguishable from binary complexes obtained by direct mixing of the purified nucleic acids and the enzyme. A small fraction of elongation complexes that reach termination point escapes dissociation because RNA polymerase has backtracked from the terminator to an upstream DNA position. Thus, transcription elongation to a terminator site produces no termination intermediates that withstand dissociation in the time scale appropriate for biochemical studies.

Nonequilibrium mechanism of transcription termination from observations of single RNA polymerase molecules

Cessation of transcription at specific terminator DNA sequences is used by viruses, bacteria, and eukaryotes to regulate the expression of downstream genes, but the mechanisms of transcription termination are poorly characterized. To elucidate the kinetic mechanism of termination at the intrinsic terminators of enteric bacteria, we observed, by using single-molecule light microscopy techniques, the behavior of surface-immobilized Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) molecules in vitro. An RNAP molecule remains at a canonical intrinsic terminator for approximately 64 s before releasing DNA, implying the formation of an elongation-incompetent (paused) intermediate by transcription complexes that terminate but not by those that read through the terminator. Analysis of pause lifetimes establishes a complete minimal mechanism of termination in which paused intermediate formation is both necessary and sufficient to induce release of RNAP at the terminator. The data suggest that intrinsic terminators function by a nonequilibrium process in which terminator effectiveness is determined by the relative rates of nucleotide addition and paused state entry by the transcription complex.

Transcription termination in Escherichia coli. Measurement of the rate of enzyme release from Rho-independent terminators

The termination/release phase of transcription must involve at least three major steps: cessation of elongation; release of the transcript; and release of the RNA polymerase. We have devised a novel method for measuring the rate of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase release during transcription termination. The method is based on a kinetic analysis of the rate of RNA synthesis during steady-state transcription. Using this method with defined transcription units, we have found that RNA polymerase release occurs rapidly from several rho-independent terminators. Enzyme release from the T7 early terminator occurs within 13(+/- 3) seconds of the cessation of elongation. Neither nusA protein nor supercoiling of the DNA template affects the rate of enzyme release. However, addition of excess sigma factor significantly increases the rate of enzyme recycling during the steady state. Since added sigma factor does not alter the rates of initiation and elongation by E. coli RNA polymerase holoenzyme, it appears that sigma factor stimulates one or more steps in the termination/release process and reduces the rate of enzyme release to a few seconds. We present evidence that suggests sigma may be directly involved in catalyzing release of the core RNA polymerase from the DNA template during transcription termination. The rapid rates of enzyme release we measure make it difficult to be certain of the exact pathway of events that occur in the termination/release phase of transcription. The most plausible pathway involves initial release of the RNA transcript followed by release of core RNA polymerase from the DNA. Studies on the properties of core polymerase-RNA complexes indicate that core polymerase and the RNA transcript probably do not dissociate as a complex from the terminator. Furthermore, these core-RNA complexes are too stable to represent significant intermediates in the termination/release pathway, at least in the early steps of the reaction.

Tau factor from Escherichia coli mediates accurate and efficient termination of transcription at the bacteriophage T3 early termination site in vitro

The termination signal that limits transcription through the early region of bacteriophage T3 (T3Te) has been cloned and sequenced. The nucleotide sequence of T3Te is identical with that of T7Te, with the exception of a single G to U substitution in the 3' tail of the terminated transcript, and addition of an AC to the loop in the terminator stem-loop, enlarging the loop to six residues. Previous studies of the properties of T3Te have shown that this site is rho independent and is highly efficient for termination in vivo, but is used poorly in vitro during transcription with purified Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. In contrast, the equivalent site in bacteriophage T7 (T7Te) is an efficient termination signal both in vivo and in vitro. However, T3Te becomes an efficient termination site in vitro in the presence of preparations of tau factor. This factor also alters the sites of RNA chain termination found in vitro at T3Te. Transcripts formed in the presence of tau are several nucleotides shorter than those produced with RNA polymerase alone, and have 3' termini that are almost identical with transcripts found in vivo. These latter results are similar to our earlier findings with T7Te, and suggest that other rho independent terminators may act with transcription termination factors in vivo.

Isolation and structural analysis of the Escherichia coli trp leader paused transcription complex

Transcription pausing is a key step in many prokaryotic transcription attenuation mechanisms. Pausing is thought to occur when an RNA hairpin forms near the 3' end of a growing transcript. We report here the isolation of the trp leader paused transcription complex containing a defined 92-nucleotide nascent transcript. Digestion of isolated paused complexes with RNase T1 suggests that the trp leader RNA hairpin designated 1:2 forms in the paused transcription complex. The transcription factor NusA alters the RNase T1 digestion pattern of the 92-nucleotide pause transcript in the complex but not the cleavage patterns of purified pause RNA, suggesting that NusA specifically affects the 1:2 hairpin in the paused transcription complex. The isolated paused transcription complex retains the ability to resume transcription. Kinetic studies on the resumption of elongation suggest that NusA is a non-competitive inhibitor of paused complex release and that the Ks for GTP is around 300 microM. RNA polymerase in the paused transcription complex protects approximately 30 base-pairs on both DNA strands from exonuclease digestion.

nusA protein of Escherichia coli is an efficient transcription termination factor for certain terminator sites

We have studied the factors that affect transcription termination in vitro at the tR2 terminator of bacteriophage lambda and at the T1 terminator of the Escherichia coli rrnB operon. Termination efficiency at both of these sites is enhanced by the E. coli nusA protein, giving final efficiencies of termination in vitro comparable to those estimated in vivo. Transcripts terminated in the presence of nusA protein are all released from the RNA polymerase complex, indicating that a complete termination reaction is involved, rather than simply induction of a long pause at the terminator. The termination factor activity of the nusA protein does not depend on the presence of rho protein and is not detectably enhanced by that factor. Thus, the nusA protein appears to play a pleiotropic role in E. coli transcription, serving as an antitermination factor, RNA polymerase subunit and true termination factor for some terminator sites.

Intermediates in transcription initiation from the E. coli lac UV5 promoter

We have used nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to separate intermediates in transcription initiation that result from action of E. coli RNA polymerase on the lac UV5 promoter. The resolved gel complexes are characterized by DNAase I footprinting, protein subunit content, RNA content, and transcription ability. There are two "open" complexes, whose equilibrium ratio is a function of temperature; they differ in their ability to escape abortive cycling, but not in their DNAase I footprints. We find three "initiated" complexes, containing RNA chains at least 11 nucleotides long, and lacking the sigma subunit of RNA polymerase. These experiments provide a detailed view of the early initiation steps and their thermal regulation at the E. coli lac promoter.