Characterization of the GTPase reaction of elongation factor Tu. Determination of the stereochemical course in the presence of antibiotic X5108

Mechanism of the intrinsic arginine finger in heterotrimeric G proteins

Heterotrimeric G proteins are crucial molecular switches that maintain a large number of physiological processes in cells. The signal is encoded into surface alterations of the Gα subunit that carries GTP in its active state and GDP in its inactive state. The ability of the Gα subunit to hydrolyze GTP is essential for signal termination. Regulator of G protein signaling (RGS) proteins accelerates this process. A key player in this catalyzed reaction is an arginine residue, Arg178 in Gα_i1, which is already an intrinsic part of the catalytic center in Gα in contrast to small GTPases, at which the corresponding GTPase-activating protein (GAP) provides the arginine "finger." We applied time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy in combination with isotopic labeling and site-directed mutagenesis to reveal the molecular mechanism, especially of the role of Arg178 in the intrinsic Gα_i1 mechanism and the RGS4-catalyzed mechanism. Complementary biomolecular simulations (molecular mechanics with molecular dynamics and coupled quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics) were performed. Our findings show that Arg178 is bound to γ-GTP for the intrinsic Gα_i1 mechanism and pushed toward a bidentate α-γ-GTP coordination for the Gα_i1·RGS4 mechanism. This movement induces a charge shift toward β-GTP, increases the planarity of γ-GTP, and thereby catalyzes the hydrolysis.

Identification of a second GTP-bound magnesium ion in archaeal initiation factor 2

Eukaryotic and archaeal translation initiation processes involve a heterotrimeric GTPase e/aIF2 crucial for accuracy of start codon selection. In eukaryotes, the GTPase activity of eIF2 is assisted by a GTPase-activating protein (GAP), eIF5. In archaea, orthologs of eIF5 are not found and aIF2 GTPase activity is thought to be non-assisted. However, no in vitro GTPase activity of the archaeal factor has been reported to date. Here, we show that aIF2 significantly hydrolyses GTP in vitro. Within aIF2γ, H97, corresponding to the catalytic histidine found in other translational GTPases, and D19, from the GKT loop, both participate in this activity. Several high-resolution crystal structures were determined to get insight into GTP hydrolysis by aIF2γ. In particular, a crystal structure of the H97A mutant was obtained in the presence of non-hydrolyzed GTP. This structure reveals the presence of a second magnesium ion bound to GTP and D19. Quantum chemical/molecular mechanical simulations support the idea that the second magnesium ion may assist GTP hydrolysis by helping to neutralize the developing negative charge in the transition state. These results are discussed in light of the absence of an identified GAP in archaea to assist GTP hydrolysis on aIF2.

The busiest of all ribosomal assistants: elongation factor Tu

During translation, the nucleic acid language employed by genes is translated into the amino acid language used by proteins. The translator is the ribosome, while the dictionary employed is known as the genetic code. The genetic information is presented to the ribosome in the form of a mRNA, and tRNAs connect the two languages. Translation takes place in three steps: initiation, elongation, and termination. After a protein has been synthesized, the components of the translation apparatus are recycled. During each phase of translation, the ribosome collaborates with specific translation factors, which secure a proper balance between speed and fidelity. Notably, initiation, termination, and ribosomal recycling occur only once per protein produced during normal translation, while the elongation step is repeated a large number of times, corresponding to the number of amino acids constituting the protein of interest. In bacteria, elongation factor Tu plays a central role during the selection of the correct amino acids throughout the elongation phase of translation. Elongation factor Tu is the main subject of this review.

The mechanism for activation of GTP hydrolysis on the ribosome

Protein synthesis requires several guanosine triphosphatase (GTPase) factors, including elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), which delivers aminoacyl-transfer RNAs (tRNAs) to the ribosome. To understand how the ribosome triggers GTP hydrolysis in translational GTPases, we have determined the crystal structure of EF-Tu and aminoacyl-tRNA bound to the ribosome with a GTP analog, to 3.2 angstrom resolution. EF-Tu is in its active conformation, the switch I loop is ordered, and the catalytic histidine is coordinating the nucleophilic water in position for inline attack on the γ-phosphate of GTP. This activated conformation is due to a critical and conserved interaction of the histidine with A2662 of the sarcin-ricin loop of the 23S ribosomal RNA. The structure suggests a universal mechanism for GTPase activation and hydrolysis in translational GTPases on the ribosome.

Ribosome-induced changes in elongation factor Tu conformation control GTP hydrolysis

In translation, elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) molecules deliver aminoacyl-tRNAs to the mRNA-programmed ribosome. The GTPase activity of EF-Tu is triggered by ribosome-induced conformational changes of the factor that play a pivotal role in the selection of the cognate aminoacyl-tRNAs. We present a 6.7-A cryo-electron microscopy map of the aminoacyl-tRNA x EF-Tu x GDP x kirromycin-bound Escherichia coli ribosome, together with an atomic model of the complex obtained through molecular dynamics flexible fitting. The model reveals the conformational changes in the conserved GTPase switch regions of EF-Tu that trigger hydrolysis of GTP, along with key interactions, including those between the sarcin-ricin loop and the P loop of EF-Tu, and between the effector loop of EF-Tu and a conserved region of the 16S rRNA. Our data suggest that GTP hydrolysis on EF-Tu is controlled through a hydrophobic gate mechanism.

Functional interactions between the G' subdomain of bacterial translation factor EF-G and ribosomal protein L7/L12

Protein L7/L12 of the bacterial ribosome plays an important role in activating the GTP hydrolytic activity of elongation factor G (EF-G), which promotes ribosomal translocation during protein synthesis. Previously, we cross-linked L7/L12 from two residues (209 and 231) flanking alpha-helix AG' in the G' subdomain of Escherichia coli EF-G. Here we report kinetic studies on the functional effects of mutating three neighboring glutamic acid residues (224, 228, and 231) to lysine, either singly or in combination. Two single mutations (E224K and E228K), both within helix AG', caused large defects in GTP hydrolysis and smaller defects in ribosomal translocation. Removal of L7/L12 from the ribosome strongly reduced the activities of wild type EF-G but had no effect on the activities of the E224K and E228K mutants. Together, these results provide evidence for functionally important interactions between helix AG' of EF-G and L7/L12 of the ribosome.

Oxygen chiral phosphate esters

During the past four years, methods have been reported for the syntheses and configurational analyses of virtually any phosphate mono- and diester chiral by virtue of oxygen isotope substitution, and these techniques have already been applied to an impressive number of enzymic and chemical reactions. At present, no experimental information is available that contradicts the simplest interpretations that have been applied to the results obtained for enzymic reactions: inversion of configuration indicating a direct displacement of the leaving group by the attacking group, and retention of configuration implying the formation of a phosphorylated or nucleotidylated enzyme intermediate. However, it does seem necessary to further investigate the mechanisms of at least some of the reactions discussed in this review to ensure that the simplest interpretation is correct. For example, the caveat we have raised about the interpretation of inversions of configurations in phosphohydrolase reactions is chemically reasonable, and these reactions should be reexamined to evaluate the importance of covalent catalysis by carboxylate groups. However, for the vast majority of the enzymic reactions that have been investigated, the stereochemical approach to ascertaining whether catalysis involves the formation of covalent intermediates remains the simplest and most direct method.

Ribosome as a molecular machine

General principles of structure and function of the ribosome are surveyed, and the translating ribosome is regarded as a molecular conveying machine. Two coupled conveying processes, the passing of compact tRNA globules and the drawing of linear mRNA chain through intraribosomal channel, are considered driven by discrete acts of translocation during translation. Instead of mechanical transmission mechanisms and power-stroke 'motors', thermal motion and chemically induced changes in affinities of ribosomal binding sites for their ligands (tRNAs, mRNA, elongation factors) are proposed to underlie all the directional movements within the ribosomal complex. The GTP-dependent catalysis of conformational transitions by elongation factors during translation is also discussed.

Structure of Gialpha1.GppNHp, autoinhibition in a galpha protein-substrate complex

The structure of the G protein Gialpha1 complexed with the nonhydrolyzable GTP analog guanosine-5'-(betagamma-imino)triphosphate (GppNHp) has been determined at a resolution of 1.5 A. In the active site of Gialpha1. GppNHp, a water molecule is hydrogen bonded to the side chain of Glu43 and to an oxygen atom of the gamma-phosphate group. The side chain of the essential catalytic residue Gln204 assumes a conformation which is distinctly different from that observed in complexes with either guanosine 5'-O-3-thiotriphosphate or the transition state analog GDP.AlF4-. Hydrogen bonding and steric interactions position Gln204 such that it interacts with a presumptive nucleophilic water molecule, but cannot interact with the pentacoordinate transition state. Gln204 must be released from this auto-inhibited state to participate in catalysis. RGS proteins may accelerate the rate of GTP hydrolysis by G protein alpha subunits, in part, by inserting an amino acid side chain into the site occupied by Gln204, thereby destabilizing the auto-inhibited state of Galpha.

G protein mechanisms: insights from structural analysis

This review is concerned with the structures and mechanisms of a superfamily of regulatory GTP hydrolases (G proteins). G proteins include Ras and its close homologs, translation elongation factors, and heterotrimeric G proteins. These proteins share a common structural core, exemplified by that of p21ras (Ras), and significant sequence identity, suggesting a common evolutionary origin. Three-dimensional structures of members of the G protein superfamily are considered in light of other biochemical findings about the function of these proteins. Relationships among G protein structures are discussed, and factors contributing to their low intrinsic rate of GTP hydrolysis are considered. Comparison of GTP- and GDP-bound conformations of G proteins reveals how specific contacts between the gamma-phosphate of GTP and the switch II region stabilize potential effector-binding sites and how GTP hydrolysis results in collapse (or reordering) of these surfaces. A GTPase-activating protein probably binds to and stabilizes the conformation of its cognate G protein that recognizes the transition state for hydrolysis, and may insert a catalytic residue into the G protein active site. Inhibitors of nucleotide release, such as the beta gamma subunit of a heterotrimeric G protein, bind selectively to and stabilize the GDP-bound state. Release factors, such as the translation elongation factor, Ts, also recognize the switch regions and destabilize the Mg(2+)-binding site, thereby promoting GDP release. G protein-coupled receptors are expected to operate by a somewhat different mechanism, given that the GDP-bound form of many G protein alpha subunits does not contain bound Mg2+.

Structure of the GDP-Pi complex of Gly203-->Ala gialpha1: a mimic of the ternary product complex of galpha-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis

BACKGROUND

G proteins play a vital role in transmembrane signalling events. In their inactive form G proteins exist as heterotrimers consisting of an alpha subunit, complexed with GDP and a dimer of betagamma subunits. Upon stimulation by receptors, G protein alpha subunits exchange GDP for GTP and dissociate from betagamma . Thus activated, alphasubunits stimulate or inhibit downstream effectors. The duration of the activated state corresponds to the single turnover rate of GTP hydrolysis, which is typically in the range of seconds. In Gialpha1, the Gly203-->Ala mutation reduces the affinity of the substrate for Mg2+, inhibits a key conformational step that occurs upon GTP binding and consequently inhibits the release of betagamma subunits from the GTP complex. The structure of the Gly203-->Ala mutant of Gialpha1 (G203AGialpha1) bound to the slowly hydrolyzing analog of GTP (GTPgammaS) has been determined in order to elucidate the structural changes that take place during hydrolysis.

RESULTS

We have determined the three dimensional structure of a Gly203-->Ala mutant of Gialpha1 at 2.6 A resolution. Although crystals were grown in the presence of GTPgammaS and Mg2+, the catalytic site contains a molecule of GDP and a phosphate ion, but no Mg2+. The phosphate ion is bound to a site near that occupied by the gamma-phosphate of GTPgammaS in the activated wild-type alpha subunit. A region of the protein, termed the Switch II helix, twists and bends to adopt a conformation that is radically different from that observed in other Gialpha1 subunit complexes.

CONCLUSIONS

Under the conditions of crystallization, the Gly203-->Ala mutation appears to stabilize a conformation that may be similar, although perhaps not identical, to the transient ternary product complex of Gialpha1-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis. The rearrangement of the Switch II helix avoids a potential steric conflict caused by the mutation. However, it appears that dissociation of the gamma-phosphate from the pentacoordinate intermediate also requires a conformational change in Switch II. Thus, a conformational rearrangement of the Switch II helix may be required in Galpha-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis.

Mechanistic analysis of the observed linear free energy relationships in p21ras and related systems

Previous studies of the GTPase reaction catalyzed by p21ras have indicated that the logarithm of the observed reaction rate and the pKa of the bound GTP are correlated by the Brønsted relationship log(kcat) = beta pKa + A. While most of the Ras mutants display a Brønsted slope beta of 2.1, a small set of oncogenic mutants exhibit a beta of > > 1. On the other hand, it was found that the corresponding Brønsted slope for the GTPase reaction of p21ras in the presence of GTPase Activating Protein (GAP) is about beta = 4.9. The present work explores the basis for such linear free energy relationships (LFERs) in general and applies these concepts to p21ras and related systems. It is demonstrated that the optimal way to analyze LFER is by using Marcus type parabolas that represent the reactant, intermediate, and product state of the reaction in a relevant energy diagram. The observed LFER is used to analyze the actual free energy surface and reaction path of the intrinsic GTPase reaction in p21ras. From this, a model reaction profile can be constructed that explains how a LFER can arise and also how the different observed Brønsted coefficients can be rationalized. This analysis is augmented by solvent isotope effect studies. It is pointed out that the overall activation barrier reflects the energy of the proton transfer (PT) step, although this step does not include the actual transition state of the hydrolysis reaction. The proposed GTP as a base mechanism is compared to a recently proposed reaction scheme where Gln61 serves as a proton shuttle in a concerted mechanism. It is shown by unique energy considerations that the concerted mechanism is unlikely. Other alternative mechanisms are also considered, and their consistency with the observed LFER and other factors is discussed. Finally, we analyze the observed LFER for the GTPase reaction of p21ras in the presence of GAP and discuss its relevance for the mechanism of GAP activation.

Relevance of histidine-84 in the elongation factor Tu GTPase activity and in poly(Phe) synthesis: its substitution by glutamine and alanine

Substitution of His-84 (-->Gln and -->Ala), a residue of the switch II region of E. coli elongation factor (EF) Tu, hardly affected the binding of GTP or GDP. The activity in poly(Phe) synthesis and GTP hydrolysis of EF-Tu H84Q were both reduced to about 35%, as compared to EF-Tu wt, whereas EF-Tu H84A was inactive in poly(Phe) synthesis but still showed a 10% residual GTPase activity. Phe-tRNAPhe exerted a similar inhibitory effect on the GTPase activity of EF-Tu wt and EF-Tu H84Q while abolishing that of EF-Tu H84A. Ribosomes enhanced the GTPase activity of EF-Tu H84Q, but not that of EF-Tu H84A, on which they even seemed to exert an inhibitory effect. The one-round GTP hydrolysis associated with the EF-TuH84Q-dependent binding of Phe-tRNAPhe to poly(U)-programmed ribosomes was less efficient than with EF-Tu wt. Kirromycin stimulated the GTPase activities of both mutants less than EF-Tu wt. The results of this work do not support a catalytic role of His-84 in the intrinsic GTPase of EF-Tu, but they emphasize the importance of its side-chain for polypeptide synthesis and GTP hydrolysis.

Site-directed mutagenesis of Thermus thermophilus elongation factor Tu. Replacement of His85, Asp81 and Arg300

His85 in Thermus thermophilus elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) was replaced by glutamine, leucine and glycine residues, leading to [H85Q]EF-Tu, [H85L] EF-Tu and [H85G]EF-Tu, respectively. Asp81 was replaced by alanine leading to [D81A]EF-Tu, and replacement of Arg300 provided [R300I]EF-Tu. Glycine in position 85 of domain I induces a protease-sensitive site in domain II and causes complete protein degradation in vivo. A similar effect was observed when Asp81 was replaced by alanine or Arg300 by isoleucine. Degradation is probably due to disturbed interactions between the domains of EF-Tu.GTP, inducing a protease-sensitive cleavage site in domain II. [H85Q]EF-Tu, which can be effectively overproduced in Escherichia coli, is slower in poly(U)-dependent poly(Phe) synthesis, has lower affinity to aminoacyl-tRNA but shows only a slightly reduced rate of intrinsic GTP hydrolysis compared to the native protein. The GTPase of this protein variant is not efficiently stimulated by aminoacyl-tRNA and ribosomes. The slow GTPase of [H85Q]EF-Tu increases the fidelity of translation as measured by leucine incorporation into poly(Phe) in in vitro poly(U)-dependent ribosomal translation. Replacement of His85 in T. thermophilus EF-Tu by leucine completely deactivates the GTPase activity but does not substantially influence the aminoacyl-tRNA binding. [H85L]EF-Tu is inactive in poly(U)-dependent poly(Phe)-synthesis. The rate of nucleotide dissociation is highest for [H85L]EF-Tu, followed by [H85Q]EF-Tu and native T. thermophilus EF-Tu. Mutation of His85, a residue which is not directly involved in the nucleotide binding, thus influences the interaction of EF-Tu domains, nucleotide binding and the efficiency and rate of GTPase activity.

Crystal structure of active elongation factor Tu reveals major domain rearrangements

The crystal structure of intact elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) from Thermus thermophilus has been determined and refined at an effective resolution of 1.7 A, with incorporation of data extending to 1.45 A. The effector region, including interaction sites for the ribosome and for transfer RNA, is well defined. Molecular mechanisms are proposed for transduction and amplification of the signal induced by GTP binding as well as for the intrinsic and effector-enhanced GTPase activity of EF-Tu. Comparison of the structure with that of EF-Tu-GDP reveals major mutual rearrangements of the three domains of the molecule.

Structural differences between a ras oncogene protein and the normal protein

One of the most commonly found transforming ras oncogenes in human tumours has a valine codon replacing the glycine codon at position 12 of the normal c-Ha-ras gene. To understand the structural reasons behind cell transformation arising from this single amino acid substitution, we have determined the crystal structure of the GDP-bound form of the mutant protein, p21(Val-12), encoded by this oncogene. We report here the overall structure of p21(Val-12) at 2.2 A resolution and compare it with the structure of the normal c-Ha-ras protein. One of the major differences is that the loop of the transforming ras protein that binds the beta-phosphate of the guanine nucleotide is enlarged. Such a change in the 'catalytic site' conformation could explain the reduced GTPase activity of the mutant, which keeps the protein in the GTP bound 'signal on' state for a prolonged period time, ultimately causing cell transformation.

Mechanism of ribosomal translocation. Translocation limits the rate of Escherichia coli elongation factor G-promoted GTP hydrolysis

The pre-steady-state kinetics of GTP hydrolysis catalysed by elongation factor G and ribosomes from Escherichia coli has been investigated by the method of quenched-flow. The GTPase activities either uncoupled from or coupled to the ribosomal translocation process were characterized under various experimental conditions. A burst of GTP hydrolysis, with a kapp value greater than 30 s-1 (20 degrees C) was observed with poly(U)-programmed vacant ribosomes, either in the presence or absence of fusidic acid. The burst was followed by a slow GTP turnover reaction, which disappears in the presence of fusidic acid. E. coli tRNAPhe, but not N-acetylphenylalanyl-tRNAPhe (N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe), stimulates the GTPase when bound in the P site. If the A site of poly(U)-programmed ribosomes, carrying tRNAPhe in the P site, is occupied by N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe, the burst of Pi discharge is replaced by a slow GTP hydrolysis. Since, under these conditions, N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe is translocated from the A to the P site, this GTP hydrolysis very probably represents a GTPase coupled to the translocation reaction.

Electron-paramagnetic-resonance studies of manganese(II) complexes with elongation factor Tu from Bacillus stearothermophilus. Observation of a GTP hydrolysis intermediate state complex

Changes in the coordination of Mn2+ to nucleotide, water and protein at the active site of elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) have been studied by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. From the time dependence of the Mn2+ spectrum after addition of GTP to EF-Tu X Mn, it was apparent that three complexes with different EPR linewidths could be detected. Using additional information from the kinetics of 32Pi production and release from EF-Tu X Mn X [gamma-32P]GTP these were identified as EF-Tu X Mn X GTP (linewidth 4.2 mT), EF-Tu X Mn X GDP X Pi (1.20 mT) and EF-Tu X Mn X GDP (1.29 mT). The linewidth for EF-Tu X Mn was 1.51 mT. The rate constant for GTP cleavage on EF-Tu was 0.01 min-1 at 24 C, for Pi release from the EF-Tu X GDP X Pi complex 0.0033 min-1. The corresponding rate constants in the presence of Mg2+ were 0.003 min-1 and 0.0065 min-1. The rate constant for reversal of the cleavage step was found to be much smaller than that for the rate of Pi release (and consequently much smaller than in the forward direction), as shown by 31P-NMR experiments on the incorporation of 18O into Pi from GTP hydrolyzed in the presence of H2 18O. EPR experiments using specifically 17O-labelled GTPs demonstrated an interaction of Mn2+ with the beta-phosphate in both the EF-Tu X GDP X Pi and EF-Tu X GDP complexes. Inorganic phosphate in the EF-Tu X GDP X Pi complex was found not to interact with the metal ion. From EPR experiments in H2 17O, it was concluded that the most probable number of water molecules in the different complexes was 4 (EF-Tu X Mn), 5 (EF-Tu X Mn X GDP X Pi) and 3 (EF-Tu X Mn X GDP), with 2, 0 and 2 metal-protein interactions respectively.