Intragenic suppressors reveal long distance interactions between inactivating and reactivating amino acid replacements generating three-dimensional constraints in the structure of mitochondrial cytochrome b

Mitochondrial complex III defects contribute to inefficient respiration and ATP synthesis in the myocardium of Trypanosoma cruzi-infected mice

In this study, we conducted a thorough analysis of mitochondrial bioenergetic function as well as the biochemical and molecular factors that are deregulated and contribute to compromised adenosine triphosphate (ATP) production in the myocardium during Trypanosoma cruzi infection. We show that ADP-stimulated state 3 respiration and ATP synthesis supported by pyruvate/malate (provides electrons to complex I) and succinate (provides electrons to complex II) substrates were significantly decreased in left ventricular tissue and isolated cardiac mitochondria of infected mice. The decreased mitochondrial ATP synthesis in infected murine hearts was not a result of uncoupling between the electron-transport chain and oxidative phosphorylation and decreased availability of the intermediary metabolites (e.g., NADH). The observed decline in the activities of complex-I, -IV, and -V was not physiologically relevant and did not contribute to compromised respiration and ATP synthesis in infected myocardium. Instead, complex III activity was decreased above the threshold level and contributed to respiratory-chain inefficiency and the resulting decline in mitochondrial ATP synthesis in infected myocardium. The loss in complex III activity occurred as a consequence of cytochrome b depletion. Treatment of infected mice with phenyl-alpha-tert-butyl nitrone (PBN, antioxidant) was beneficial in preserving the mtDNA-encoded cytochrome b expression, and subsequently resulted in improved complex III activity, mitochondrial respiration, and ATP production in infected myocardium. Overall, we provide novel data on the mechanism(s) involved in cardiac bioenergetic inefficiency during T. cruzi infection.

An empirical test of the concomitantly variable codon hypothesis

A central assumption of models of molecular evolution, that each site in a sequence evolves independently of all other sites, lacks empirical support. We investigated the extent to which sites evolve codependently in triosephosphate isomerase (TIM), a ubiquitous glycolytic enzyme conserved in both structure and function. Codependencies among sites, or concomitantly variable codons (covarions), are evident from the reduced function and misfolding of hybrid TIM proteins. Although they exist, we find covarions are relatively rare, and closely related proteins are unlikely to have developed them. However, the potential for covarions increases with genetic distance so that highly divergent proteins may have evolved codependencies between many sites. The evolution of covarions undermines a key assumption in phylogenetics and calls into question our ability to disentangle ancient relationships among major taxonomic groups.

A “Petite Obligate” Mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Within the mitochondrial F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase, the nucleus-encoded delta-F(1) subunit plays a critical role in coupling the enzyme proton translocating and ATP synthesis activities. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, deletion of the delta subunit gene (Deltadelta) was shown to result in a massive destabilization of the mitochondrial genome (mitochondrial DNA; mtDNA) in the form of 100% rho(-)/rho degrees petites (i.e. cells missing a large portion (>50%) of the mtDNA (rho(-)) or totally devoid of mtDNA (rho degrees )). Previous work has suggested that the absence of complete mtDNA (rho(+)) in Deltadelta yeast is a consequence of an uncoupling of the ATP synthase in the form of a passive proton transport through the enzyme (i.e. not coupled to ATP synthesis). However, it was unclear why or how this ATP synthase defect destabilized the mtDNA. We investigated this question using a nonrespiratory gene (ARG8(m)) inserted into the mtDNA. We first show that retention of functional mtDNA is lethal to Deltadelta yeast. We further show that combined with a nuclear mutation (Deltaatp4) preventing the ATP synthase proton channel assembly, a lack of delta subunit fails to destabilize the mtDNA, and rho(+) Deltadelta cells become viable. We conclude that Deltadelta yeast cannot survive when it has the ability to synthesize the ATP synthase proton channel. Accordingly, the rho(-)/rho degrees mutation can be viewed as a rescuing event, because this mutation prevents the synthesis of the two mtDNA-encoded subunits (Atp6p and Atp9p) forming the core of this channel. This is the first report of what we have called a "petite obligate" mutant of S. cerevisiae.

Analysis of suppressor mutation reveals long distance interactions in the bc(1) complex of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Four totally conserved glycines are involved in the packing of the two cytochrome b hemes, b(L) and b(H), of the bc(1) complex. The conserved glycine 131 is involved in the packing of heme b(L) and is separated by only 3 A from this heme in the bc(1) complex structure. The cytochrome b respiratory deficient mutant G131S is affected in the assembly of the bc(1) complex. An intragenic suppressor mutation was obtained at position 260, in the ef loop, where a glycine was replaced by an alanine. This respiratory competent revertant exhibited a low bc(1) complex activity and was affected in the electron transfer at the Q(P) site. The k(min) for the substrate DBH(2) was diminished by an order of magnitude and EPR spectra showed a partially empty Q(P) site. However, the binding of the Q(P) site inhibitors stigmatellin and myxothiazol remained unchanged in the suppressor strain. Optical spectroscopy revealed that heme b(L) is red shifted by 0.8 nm and that the E(m) of heme b(L) was slightly increased (+20 mV) in the revertant strain as compared to wild type strain values. Addition of a methyl group at position 260 is thus sufficient to allow the assembly of the bc(1) complex and the insertion of heme b(L) despite the presence of the serine at position 131. Surprisingly, reversion at position 260 was located 13 A away from the original mutation and revealed a long distance interaction in the yeast bc(1) complex.

Effects of mutations in mitochondrial cytochrome b in yeast and man. Deficiency, compensation and disease

The mitochondrial cytochrome bc(1) complex is a key protonmotive component of eukaryotic respiratory chains. The mitochondrially encoded cytochrome b forms, with cytochrome c(1) and the iron--sulfur protein, the catalytic core of this multimeric enzyme. Mutations of cytochrome b have been reported in association with human diseases. In the highly homologous yeast cytochrome b, several mutations that impair the respiratory function, and reversions that correct the defect, have been described. In this paper, we re-examine the mutations in the light of the atomic structure of the complex, and discuss the possible effect, at enzyme level, of the human cytochrome b mutations and the correcting effect of the reversions.

Screening of an intragenic second-site suppressor of purine-cytosine permease from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Possible role of Ser272 in the base translocation process

The purine-cytosine permease from Saccharomyces cerevisiae mediates the active transport through the plasma membrane of adenine, hypoxanthine, guanine and cytosine using the proton electrochemical potential difference as an energy source. Analysis of the activity of strains mutated in a hydrophilic segment (371-377) of the polypeptidic chain has shown the involvement of this segment in the maintenance of the active three-dimensional structure of the carrier. In an attempt to identify permease domains that could interact functionally and/or physically with this segment, we looked for second-site mutations that could suppress the effects of amino acid changes in this region. This paper describes a positive screen that has allowed the isolation of one suppressor from a permease mutant displaying the N374I change (fcy2-20 allele), a substitution that induces a dramatic decrease in the affinity of the carrier for adenine, cytosine and hypoxanthine. The second-site mutation corresponds to the replacement of the Ser272 residue by Leu. Its suppressive effect is shown to be a partial restoration of the binding of cytosine and hypoxanthine to the permease. To test whether this second-site mutation is specific for the fcy2-20 allele, two double mutants were constructed (Fcy2pT213I, S272L and Fcy2pS272L, N377G). Results obtained with these two double mutants showed that the suppressive effect of S272 L replacement was not specific for the original N374I change. To understand the general effect of this amino acid replacement for the three distinct double mutants, a strain overexpressing Fcy2pS272I, was constructed. Kinetic analysis of this strain showed that, by itself, the S272 L change induced an improvement in the base-binding step that could account for its global suppressive effect. Moreover, S272 L induced a decrease in the turnover of the permease, thus showing the involvement of S272 in the translocation process. Taking into account the topological model of the permease proposed here, this Ser residue is probably located in a transmembrane amphipathic alpha-helix (TM5). The location and the observed decrease in the turnover of the carrier observed with the S272 L change lead us to propose that S272 could be part of a hydrophilic pore involved in the translocation of the base and/or the proton.

A point mutation in the mitochondrial cytochrome b gene obviates the requirement for the nuclear encoded core protein 2 subunit in the cytochrome bc1 complex in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

A yeast mutant (cor2-45) in which approximately half of the C terminus of core protein 2 of the cytochrome bc1 complex is lacking due to a frameshift mutation that introduces a stop at codon 197 in the COR2 gene fails to assemble the cytochrome bc1 complex and does not grow on non-fermentable carbon sources that require respiration. The loss of respiration is more severe with this frameshift mutation than with the complete deletion of the COR2 gene, suggesting deleterious effects of the truncated core 2 protein. A search for extragenic suppressors of the nuclear cor2-45 mutation resulted (in addition to the expected nuclear suppressors) in the isolation of a suppressor mutation in the mitochondrial DNA that replaces serine 223 by proline in cytochrome b. Assembly of the cytochrome bc1 complex and the respiratory deficient phenotype of the cor2-45 mutant are restored by the proline for serine replacement in cytochrome b. Surprisingly, this amino acid replacement in cytochrome b corrects not only the phenotype resulting from the cor2-45 frameshift mutation, but it also obviates the need for core protein 2 in the cytochrome bc1 complex since it alleviates the respiratory deficiency resulting from the complete deletion of the COR2 gene. This is the first report of a homoplasmic missense point mutation of the mitochondrial DNA acting as a functional suppressor of a mutation located in a nuclear gene and the first demonstration that the supernumerary core protein 2 subunit is not essential for the electron transfer and energy transducing functions of the mitochondrial cytochrome bc1 complex.

The molecular basis for the natural resistance of the cytochrome bc1 complex from strobilurin-producing basidiomycetes to center Qp inhibitors

Mitochondria from the strobilurin A producing basidiomycetes Strobilurus tenacellus and Mycena galopoda exhibit natural resistance to (E)-beta-methoxyacrylate inhibitors of the ubiquinol oxidation center(center Qp) of the cytochrome bc1 complex. Isolated cytochrome bc1 complex from S. tenacellus was found to be highly similar to that of Saccharomyces cerevisiae with respect to subunit composition, as well as spectral characteristics and midpoint potentials of the heme centers. To understand the molecular basis of natural resistance, we determined the exon/intron organization and deduced the sequences of cytochromes b from S. tenacellus, M. galopoda and a third basidiomycete, Mycena viridimarginata, which produces no strobilurin A. Comparative sequence analysis of two regions of cytochrome b known to contribute to the formation of center Qp suggested that the generally lower sensitivity of all three basidiomycetes was due to the replacement of a small amino acid residue in position 127 by isoleucine. For M. galopoda replacement of Gly143 by alanine and Gly153 by serine, for S. tenacellus replacement of a small residue in position 254 by glutamine and Asn261 by aspartate was found to be the likely causes for resistance to (E)-beta-methoxyacrylates. The latter exchange is also found in Schizosaccharomyces pombe, which we found also to be naturally resistant to (E)-beta-methoxyacrylates.

Structure-function relationships of the mitochondrial bc1 complex in temperature-sensitive mutants of the cytochrome b gene, impaired in the catalytic center N

Seven new structures of cytochrome b have been recently identified by isolating and sequencing revertants from cytochrome b respiratory deficient mutants (Coppée, J. Y., Brasseur, G., Brivet-Chevillotte, P., and Colson, A. M. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 4221-4226). These mutations are located in the center N domain (QN). All the revertants exhibited a modified heme b562 maximum, confirming that part of the NH2-terminal region is in the vicinity of the extramembranous loop between helices IV-V and heme b562. Based on measurements performed on the maximal activities occurring in each segment of the respiratory chain, the decrease observed in the NADH oxidase activities of several revertants was correlated with some bc1 complex activity impairments; this may also explain why a moderate decrease in bc1 complex activity does not limit the succinate oxidase activity. The decrease in the rate of reduction of cytochrome b via the center N pathway is responsible for the impairment of the bc1 complex activity of these revertants. The three double-mutated revertants (S206L/N208K or -Y; S206L/W30C) are temperature-sensitive in vivo, and their mitochondria like that of the original mutant S206L are thermosensitive in vitro. Isolating the W30C mutation does not yield a thermosensitive phenotype: the replacement of serine 206 by leucine is therefore responsible for the thermoinstability of these strains; this temperature sensitivity is reinforced by additional mutations N208K or N208Y, and not by W30C. These data suggest that serine 206 and asparagine 208 are involved in the thermostability of the protein. When bc1 complex activity is lost after incubating mitochondria at a nonpermissive temperature (37 degrees C), heme b is still present, but can no longer be reduced by physiological substrate. The progressive loss of bc1 complex activity seems to be initially linked to a change in the tertiary structure of cytochrome b, which occurs drastically at center N and much more slowly at center P, as shown by kinetic study on the two cytochrome b redox pathways.

Decoupling of the bc1 complex in S. cerevisiae; point mutations affecting the cytochrome b gene bring new information about the structural aspect of the proton translocation

Four mutations in the mitochondrial cytochrome b of S. cerevisiae have been characterized with respect to growth capacities, catalytic properties, ATP/2e- ratio, and transmembrane potential. The respiratory-deficient mutant G137E and the three pseudo-wild type revertants E137 + I147F, E137 + C133S, and E137 + N256K were described previously (Tron and Lemesle-Meunier, 1990; Di Rago et al., 1990a). The mutant G137E is unable to grow on respiratory substrates but its electron transfer activity is partly conserved and totally inhibited by antimycin A. The secondary mutations restore the respiratory growth at variable degree, with a phosphorylation efficiency of 12-42% as regards the parental wild type strain, and result in a slight increase in the various electron transfer activities at the level of the whole respiratory chain. The catalytic efficiency for ubiquinol was slightly (G137E) or not affected (E137 + I147F, E137 + C133S, and E137 + N256K) in these mutants. Mutation G137E induces a decrease in the ATP/2e- ratio (50% of the W.T. value) and transmembrane potential (60% of the W.T. value) at the bc1 level, whereas the energetic capacity of the cytochrome oxidase is conserved. Secondary mutations I147F, C133S, and N256K partly restore the ATP/2e- ratio and the transmembrane potential at the bc1 complex level. The results suggest that a partial decoupling of the bc1 complex is induced by the cytochrome b point mutation G137E. In the framework of the protonmotive Q cycle, this decoupling can be explained by the existence of a proton wire connecting centers P and N in the wild type bc1 complex which may be amplified or uncovered by the G137E mutation when the bc1 complex is functioning.

Role of the evolutionarily conserved cytochrome b tryptophan 142 in the ubiquinol oxidation catalyzed by the bc1 complex in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Trp-142 is a highly conserved residue of the cytochrome b subunit in the bc1 complexes. To study the importance of this residue in the quinol oxidation catalyzed by the bc1 complex, we characterized four yeast mutants with arginine, lysine, threonine, and serine at position 142. The mutant W142R was isolated previously as a respiration-deficient mutant unable to grow on non-fermentable carbon sources (Lemesle-Meunier, D., Brivet-Chevillotte, P., di Rago, J.-P, Slonimski, P.P., Bruel, C., Tron, T., and Forget, N. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 15626-15632). The mutants W142K, W142T, and W142S were obtained here as respiration-sufficient revertants from mutant W142R. Mutant W142R exhibited a decreased complex II turnover both in the presence and absence of antimycin A; this suggests that the structural effect of W142R in the bc1 complex probably interferes with the correct assembly of the succinate-ubiquinone reductase complex. The mutations resulted in a parallel decrease in turnover number and apparent Km, with the result that there was no significant change in the second-order rate constant for ubiquinol oxidation. Mutants W142K and W142T exhibited some resistance toward myxothiazol, whereas mutant W142R showed increased sensitivity. The cytochrome cc1 reduction kinetics were found to be severely affected in mutants W142R, W142K, and W142T. The respiratory activities and the amounts of reduced cytochrome b measured during steady state suggest that the W142S mutation also modified the quinol-cytochrome c1 electron transfer pathway. The cytochrome b reduction kinetics through center P were affected when Trp-142 was replaced with arginine or lysine, but not when it was replaced with threonine or serine. Of the four amino acids tested at position 142, only arginine resulted in a decrease in cytochrome b reduction through center N. These findings are discussed in terms of the structure and function of the quinol oxidation site and seem to indicate that Trp-142 is not critical to the kinetic interaction of ubiquinol with the reductase, but plays an important role in the electron transfer reactions that intervene between ubiquinol oxidation and cytochrome c1 reduction.

Characterization of mutations in the mitochondrial cytochrome b gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae affecting the quinone reductase site (QN)

The revertant [G33A]cytochrome b recently isolated from the [G33D]cytochrome b mutant [Coppée, J. Y., Tokutake, N., Marc, D., di Rago, J.-P., Miyoshi, H. & Colson, A.-M. (1994) FEBS Lett. 339, 1-6] exhibits cross resistance to center-N inhibitors 2-heptyl-4-hydroxyquinoline N-oxide (HQNO) and funiculosin and a spectral shift in the cytochrome b562 heme. This indicates that the conserved G33 residue is in the vicinity of this heme, and thus agrees with the previous suggestion that glycine may play a role in the helix packing around the hemes. The [S206L]cytochrome b and [M221K]cytochrome b respiratory-growth-deficient mutants [Lemesle-Meunier, D., Brivet-Chevillotte, P., di Rago, J. P., Slonimski, P. P., Bruel, C., Tron, T. & Forget, N. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 15,626-15,632], which synthesize cytochrome b and retain little or no bc1 complex activity, show no change in the reduction kinetics of cytochrome b via center P, which suggests that the oxidizing site is functional. Impairment of both the reduction and oxidation of heme b562 at the ubiquinone reduction center of the mitochondrial ubiquinone-cytochrome-c oxidoreductase site is, therefore, responsible for the deficient catalytic activity and respiratory growth in these strains.

A model of antimycin A binding based on structure-activity studies of synthetic antimycin A analogues

The structural factors of antimycin A molecule required for inhibitory action were studied using newly synthesized antimycin A derivatives with bovine heart submitochondrial particles, in order to probe the interaction between antimycin A and its binding site. In particular, we focused upon the roles of the amide bond bridge, which connects the salicylic acid and dilactone ring moieties, and the 3-formylamino group in the salicylic acid moiety. The lack of formation of an intramolecular hydrogen-bond between phenolic OH and amide carbonyl groups resulted in a remarkable loss of the activity (by four orders of magnitude), indicating that this hydrogen-bond is essential for the inhibition. This result suggested that both the phenolic OH and the carbonyl groups form a hydrogen-bond with some residues at a fixed conformation. In addition, the inhibitory potency was remarkably decreased by N-methylation of the amide bond moiety, indicating that the NH group might function in hydrogen-bond interaction with the binding site. The N-methylation of 3-formylamino group also resulted in a decrease in the activity, probably due to a loss of the rotational freedom of this functional group. Molecular orbital calculation studies with respect to the conformation of the 3-formylamino group indicated that this group takes an active conformation when the formyl carbonyl projects to the opposite side of the phenolic OH group. Based upon a series of structure-activity studies of synthetic antimycin A analogues, we propose a tentative model for antimycin A binding in its binding cavity.

Sequence analysis of three deficient mutants of cytochrome oxidase subunit I of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and their revertants

Three respiratory-deficient mutants of cytochrome oxidase subunit I in the yeast mitochondrion have been sequenced. They are located in, or near, transmembrane segment VI, the catalytic core of the enzyme. Respiratory-competent revertants have been selected and studied. The mutant V244M was found to revert at the same site in valine (wild-type), isoleucine or threonine. The revertants of the mutant G251R were of three types: glycine (wild-type), serine and threonine at position 251. A search for second-site mutations was carried out but none were found. Among 60 revertants tested, the mutant K265M was found to revert only to the wild-type allele.

Structural factors of antimycin A molecule required for inhibitory action

A series of antimycin A analogues was synthesized by modifying the salicylic acid moiety, whereas the portion of the molecule corresponding to the natural dilactone-ring moiety was fixed as di-n-octyl L-glutamate. To probe the structure of the antimycin A binding site, the structural factors of the salicylic acid moiety required for inhibitory action were examined by means of structure-activity studies with intact rat-liver mitochondria and the cytochrome bc1 complex isolated from bovine heart mitochondria. As suggested earlier (Rieske, J.S. (1976) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 456, 195-247), the phenolic OH was very important for inhibition. For the derivatives which do not possess a formylamino group in the 3-position (ortho to the phenolic OH), the inhibitory activity tended to increase as the electron-withdrawing property of the substituent increased, i.e., as the acidity of the phenolic OH group increased. This indicates that the acidity of the phenolic OH is an important factor governing inhibition. While the electron-withdrawing property of the formylamino group itself is rather poor, 3-formylamino derivatives elicited potent activity. The conformation of the 3-formylamino group was also found to be a very important factor in establishing inhibitory activity. In addition, the bulkier the moiety corresponding to the 3-formylamino group, the lower the activity. These results demonstrate that the presence of the 3-formylamino group, and its proper conformation, are needed for a close fitting of antimycin A to its binding domain. Although the inhibitors that lack a 3-formylamino group retained fairly potent activity, their effects on the reduction of cytochromes b and c1 were somewhat different from those of natural antimycin A, indicating that the 3-formylamino group is essential for inhibitor binding to the cytochrome bc1 complex in the same manner as natural antimycin A. It is concluded that both the 3-formylamino group and the phenolic OH of antimycin A make important contributions to specific interactions with the amino acid residues of the cytochrome b.

Analysis of cytochrome-b amino acid residues forming the contact face with the iron-sulfur subunit of ubiquinol:cytochrome-c reductase in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Four mutations in the mitochondrial cytochrome b of Saccharomyces cerevisiae have been characterized with respect to catalytic properties, inhibitor resistance and subunit interaction. The respiratory-deficient mutant [G137E]cytochrome b and the pseudo-wild-type revertant [G137E, N256K]cytochrome b were described previously [di Rago, J.-P., Netter, P. & Slonimski, P. P. (1990) J. Biol. Chem. 265, 3332-3339; di Rago, J.-P., Netter, P. & Slonimski, P. P. (1990) J. Biol. Chem. 265, 15750-15757]. Two new mutants [N256K]cytochrome b and [N256I]cytochrome b were isolated by dissociation of the second-site suppressor from the original target mutation. The mutants [G137E]cytochrome b and [G137E, N256K]cytochrome b exhibited a high resistance against methoxyacrylate inhibitors, whereas the suppressors [N256K]cytochrome b and [N256I]cytochrome b showed only a slight resistance. Remarkably, all mutants exhibited stigmatellin cross-resistance. The electron-transfer activity from the substrate nonylubiquinol to cytochrome c of mitochondrial membranes was diminished in all mutants. The substitution G137-->E decreases Vmax/Km by one order of magnitude, indicating a reduced catalytic efficiency for ubiquinol. The amino acid exchange at position 256 to a positively charged lysine residue or to a hydrophobic isoleucine residue resulted mainly in a diminished specific activity. The iron-sulfur subunit and the 8.5-kDa subunit were detectable in all mutants at normal levels in immunoblots of membrane preparations, indicating proper assembly of the complex. However, after purification, the mutant bc1 complex lacked the iron-sulfur subunit and the 8.5-kDa subunit. In contrast, the iron-sulfur subunit can only be dissociated from the parental bc1 complex by harsh treatment. These data suggest that residues 137 and 256 in cytochrome b are crucial for cytochrome-b/iron-sulfur protein interaction.

Analysis of revertants from respiratory deficient mutants within the center N of cytochrome b in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Four modified cytochrome b's carrying mononucleotide substitutions affecting center N residues were analysed. The mutant carrying a G33D change does not incorporate heme into the apocytochrome b and fails to grow on non-fermentable carbon sources. Out of 85 genetically independent revertants derived from this mutant, 82 were true back-mutants restoring the wild type sequence (D33G). The remaining three replaced the aspartic acid by an alanine (D33A) indicating that small size residues are best tolerated at this position which is consistent with the perfect conservation of the G33 during evolution. This glycine may be of crucial importance for helix packing around the hemes. The replacement of methionine at position 221 by lysine (M221K) produced a non-functional cytochrome b [(1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 15626-15632]. Non-native revertants replacing the lysine 221 by glutamic acid (K221E) or glutamine (K221Q) expressed a selective resistance to antimycin and antimycin derivatives having a modified dilactone ring moiety. Cytochrome b residues in 33 and in 221 seemed to contribute to the quinone reduction (QN) site of the cytochrome bc1 complex. Possible intramolecular interactions between the N-terminal region and the loop connecting helices IV and V of cytochrome b are proposed.

The protonmotive Q cycle in mitochondria and bacteria

The cytochrome bc1 complex is an oligomeric electron transfer enzyme located in the inner membrane of mitochondria and the plasma membrane of bacteria. The cytochrome bc1 complex participates in respiration in eukaryotic cells and also participates in respiration, cyclic photosynthetic electron transfer, denitrification, and nitrogen fixation in a phylogenetically diverse collection of bacteria. In all of these organisms, the cytochrome bc1 complex transfers electrons from ubiquinol to cytochrome c and links this electron transfer to translocation of protons across the membrane in which it resides, thus converting the available free energy of the oxidation-reduction reaction into an electrochemical proton gradient. The mechanism by which the cytochrome bc1 complex achieves this energy transduction is the protonmotive Q cycle. The Q cycle mechanism has been documented by extensive experimentation, and recent investigations have focused on structural features of the three redox subunits of the bc1 complex essential to the protonmotive and electrogenic activities of this membranous enzyme.

Roles in inhibitor recognition and quinol oxidation of the amino acid side chains at positions of cyt b providing resistance to Qo-inhibitors of the bc1 complex from Rhodobacter capsulatus

The substitutions M1401, F144S and L, G152S, T163A and V333A in cytochrome b of the ubiquinol-cytochrome c oxidoreductase (bc1 complex) from Rhodobacter capsulatus provide resistance to the quinol oxidation (Qo) inhibitors myxothiazol, mucidin and stigmatellin. Site-directed mutagenesis with degenerate primers was used to define the role of these positions in inhibitor recognition and quinol oxidation, and a collection of various substitutions at each of these positions was obtained. The effects of these mutations on quinol oxidation, nature and level of inhibitor resistance, prosthetic group incorporation and assembly of the complex were analysed. Most of these mutations, unlike those at position 158 reported earlier, yielded functional bc1 complexes able to support the photosynthetic growth of R. capsulatus. However, they perturbed steady-state quinol oxidation and inhibitor recognition indicating that they are important for the function of the Qo site. In particular, the presence of a methyl group on the beta-carbon (Ile and Val residues) at position 140, the absence of an aromatic ring (Phe, Tyr and Trp residues) at position 144 and the loss of residues with small side chains (Gly and Ala) at position 152 correlated with resistance to myxothiazol. On the other hand, no myxothiazol resistance was observed with the substitutions at positions 163 and 333 suggesting that they affected solely the recognition of stigmatellin. Five substitutions, M140R, F144H and R, G152P and T163R, yielded photosynthesis-deficient mutants with assembled but impaired bc1 complexes. Unexpectedly, two substitutions at position 163 (T to F or P) yielded mutants lacking the three subunits of the bc1 complex indicating that this position affects its assembly or stability in vivo. These findings are discussed in terms of the contributions of these residues to inhibitor recognition and quinol oxidation at the Qo site of the bc1 complex.

The C-terminal domain of yeast cytochrome b is essential for a correct assembly of the mitochondrial cytochrome bc1 complex

Yeast mutants modifying the C-terminal region of mitochondrial cytochrome b were isolated and characterized. A nonsense mutation of the leucine codon 335 (TTA-->TAA), 50 residues before the normal C-terminus, blocks incorporation of heme into the apocytochrome b and prevents growth on non-fermentable substrates. The same defects were observed in a frameshift mutant (after codon 348, TAT-->TATT) in which the last 37 C-terminal residues are predicted to be replaced by a novel sequence of 33 amino acids. Function was regained in the nonsense mutant only by true back mutations restoring a protein of the wild-type sequence. The respiratory capacity was restored to wild-type levels in the frameshift mutant by a variety of single base subtractions located within a window of 24 bases before or after the original +T addition, these pseudo-reversions resulted in single or multiple (up to five) consecutive amino acid replacements between positions 346 and 354 and restored the wild-type sequence from position 355 to 385. These data, combined with hydropathy calculations and sequence comparisons, suggest that the C-terminal domain of cytochrome b forms a transmembrane segment essential for the correct assembly of the cytochrome bc1 complex.

Mitochondrial cytochrome b: evolution and structure of the protein

Cytochrome b is the central redox catalytic subunit of the quinol: cytochrome c or plastocyanin oxidoreductases. It is involved in the binding of the quinone substrate and it is responsible for the transmembrane electron transfer by which redox energy is converted into a protonmotive force. Cytochrome b also contains the sites to which various inhibitors and quinone antagonists bind and, consequently, inhibit the oxidoreductase. Ten partial primary sequences of cytochrome b are presented here and they are compared with sequence data from over 800 species for a detailed analysis of the natural variation in the protein. This sequence information has been used to predict some aspects of the structure of the protein, in particular the folding of the transmembrane helices and the location of the quinone- and heme-binding pockets. We have observed that inhibitor sensitivity varies greatly among species. The comparison of inhibition titrations in combination with the analysis of the primary structures has enabled us to identify amino acid residues in cytochrome b that may be involved in the binding of the inhibitors and, by extrapolation, quinone/quinol. The information on the quinone-binding sites obtained in this way is expected to be both complementary and supplementary to that which will be obtained in the future by mutagenesis and X-ray crystallography.

What information do inhibitors provide about the structure of the hydroquinone oxidation site of ubihydroquinone: cytochrome c oxidoreductase?

The Q cycle mechanism of the bc1 complex requires two quinone reaction centers, the hydroquinone oxidation (QP) and the quinone reduction (QN) center. These sites can be distinguished by the specific binding of inhibitors to either of them. A substantial body of information about the hydroquinone oxidation site has been provided by the analysis of the binding of QP site inhibitors to the bc1 complex in different redox states and to preparations depleted of lipid or protein components as well as by functional studies with mutant bc1 complexes selected for resistance toward the inhibitors. The reaction site is formed by at least five protein segments of cytochrome b and parts of the iron-sulfur protein. At least two different binding sites for QP site inhibitors could be detected, one for the methoxyacrylate-type inhibitors binding predominantly to cytochrome b, the other for the chromone-type inhibitors and hydroxyquinones binding predominantly to the iron-sulfur protein. The interactions with the protein segments, between different protein segments, and between protein and ligands (substrate, inhibitors) are discussed in detail and a working model of the QP pocket is proposed.

Random mutant generation and its utility in uncovering structural and functional features of cytochrome b in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The generation of random mutations in the mitochondrial cytochrome b gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae has been used as a most fruitful means of identifying subregions that play a key role in the bc1 complex mechanism, best explained by the protonmotive Q cycle originally proposed by Peter Mitchell. Selection for center i and center o inhibitor resistance mutants, in particular, has yielded much information. The combined approaches of genetics and structural predictions have led to a two-dimensional folding model for cytochrome b that is most compatible with current knowledge of the protonmotive Q cycle. A three-dimensional model is emerging from studies of distant reversions of deficient mutants. Finally, interactions between cytochrome b and the other subunits of the bc1 complex, such as the iron-sulfur protein, can be affected by a single amino acid change.

Inhibition of electron transport of rat-liver mitochondria by synthesized antimycin A analogs

A series of antimycin A analogs was synthesized by replacement of a dilactone-ring moiety of natural antimycin A by various alkyl, substituted phenyl, substituted diphenyl ether, or amino acid ester groups. The structure-inhibitory activity relationship was studied with rat-liver mitochondria to identify roles of the dilactone-ring moiety in the inhibitor binding to a Qi reaction center of cytochrome bc1 complex. All derivatives caused further reduction of cytochrome b reduced by succinate and the oxidant-induced reduction, showing that the derivatives inhibited electron transport by interacting with a Qi reaction center. The inhibition tended to increase as the hydrophobicity of the inhibitor increased. The mode of binding of inhibitor molecules to a Qi center, which was reflected in, for example, a sigmoidal titration curve for respiratory inhibition and a time-dependent change in inhibitory activity, varied depending on structure. These results suggested that the role of the dilactone-ring moiety of antimycin A may be not only to support hydrophobic interaction with the binding domain by increasing the hydrophobicity of the molecule, as proposed earlier, but also to regulate close fitting of the salicylic acid moiety to the binding domain.

Cytochrome b of protozoan mitochondria: relationships between function and structure

1. The sensitivity of ubiquinol:cytochrome c reductase to its most powerful inhibitors has been characterized in mitochondria from three ciliate and two trypanosome protozoans and compared with that in mitochondria of animals and plants. 2. Mitochondria of ciliates, particularly those of Tetrahymena pyriformis, are resistant to antimycin. 3. Mitochondria of trypanosomes are quite resistant to stigmatellin, as they exhibit a 40-fold higher titer than that in ciliate or animals mitochondria. 4. Both ciliates and trypanosomes are highly resistant to myxothiazol. 5. Correlations have been drawn between the natural resistance of the protozoan mitochondria to antimycin, stigmatellin and myxothiazol and peculiar features in the structure of their apocytochrome b, on the basis of an accurate alignment of the sequences of this protein.

Point mutation in cytochrome b of yeast ubihydroquinone:cytochrome-c oxidoreductase causing myxothiazol resistance and facilitated dissociation of the iron-sulfur subunit

Cytochrome-c reductase was isolated from Saccharomyces cerevisiae GM50-3C. A tenth subunit was detected with molecular mass 8.5 kDa on SDS/PAGE. Two yeast mutants selected for resistance to myxothiazol, an inhibitor of the Q0 center (Q, ubiquinone) of cytochrome-c reductase, were analysed. The single amino acid substitution in the cytochrome-b subunit, N256Y in the mutant Myx-119 and G137R in the mutant Myx-118, caused a general resistance to all methoxyacrylate inhibitors to about fivefold higher concentrations. The kinetic measurements with the substrate analogue nonylbenzohydroquinone revealed a decrease in the Km by fivefold and of the maximal turnover number by fourfold in the N256Y mutant. The Km of the G137R mutant was not affected and the Vmax was 50% higher. Cytochrome-c reductase was isolated from mutants to allow determination of the Kd values of methoxyacrylate-stilbene and myxothiazol by means of fluorescence-quench and red-shift titration. Changes in the structure of the multisubunit complex due to a single amino acid exchange became obvious during the purification procedure. SDS/PAGE of the purified enzyme revealed that the substitution N256Y in cytochrome b led to a loss of the iron-sulfur protein and the fifth small subunit with no change in the pattern of the remaining eight subunits. The subunit pattern of the G137R mutant was identical to the wild type. This is the first report of a single amino acid exchange in the catalytic subunit of cytochrome b, greatly affecting the iron-sulfur protein, the second important catalytic subunit of the Q0 center. This is a new approach to obtain structural information about the interaction of cytochrome b with the iron-sulfur subunit.

Cytochrome b of fish mitochondria is strongly resistant to funiculosin, a powerful inhibitor of respiration

We report here some unusual properties of ubiquinol: cytochrome c reductase of eel and other fish mitochondria. The turnover rate of the reductase is clearly higher than in mammalian mitochondria and the binding constant for ubiquinone seems to be larger than in other vertebrates. Additionally, the reductase activity of fish mitochondria is resistant to some powerful inhibitors that bind to cytochrome b, in particular to funiculosin. After sequencing most of the gene of eel cytochrome b and comparing the deduced amino acid sequence with that of other fish and animals, we hypothesize that the decreased binding of funiculosin could be due to a few amino acid replacements in the third and fourth transmembrane helix of the protein. In particular, the presence of methionine instead of alanine at position 125 seems to be largely responsible for the strong resistance to funiculosin and also to the partial resistance to myxothiazol in all fish mitochondria. Correlations between some residue substitutions in cytochrome b and the different effects of funiculosin in different species are also considered.

The distribution of charged amino acids in mitochondrial inner-membrane proteins suggests different modes of membrane integration for nuclearly and mitochondrially encoded proteins

We have analyzed the amino acid distribution in seven nuclearly encoded and five mitochondrially encoded inner membrane proteins with experimentally well characterized topologies. The mitochondrially encoded proteins conform to the 'positive inside' rule, i.e. they have many more positively charged residues in their non-translocated as compared to translocated domains. However, most of the nuclearly encoded proteins do not show such a bias but instead have a surprisingly skewed distribution of Glu residues with an almost ten times higher frequency in the intermembrane space than in the matrix domains. These findings suggest that some, but possibly not all, nuclearly encoded inner membrane proteins may insert into the membrane by a mechanism that does not depend on the distribution of positively charged amino acids.

The unusual reversion properties of a mitochondrial mutation in the structural gene of subunit I of cytochrome oxidase of Saccharomyces cerevisiae reveal a probable histidine ligand of the redox center

We have analyzed a mutation in the mitochondrial gene oxi3 coding for subunit I of cytochrome-oxidase in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This mutation replaces one of the seven invariant histidines of the polypeptide (position 378) by a tyrosine, and leads to a respiratory deficient phenotype. A total of 157 revertants, which have recovered the ability to grow on a respiratory substrate, have been selected from this mutant (tyrosine 378). The nature of the reversion has been analysed by a rapid screening procedure and 32 of the revertants have been sequenced. They are all true back-mutations reintroducing the histidine in position 378. This very exceptional situation suggests that this histidine is a ligand of the redox center of cytochrome oxidase.

Inhibition of electron transport of rat liver mitochondria by unnatural (-)-antimycin A3

The inhibition of electron transport by unnatural (-)-antimycin A3 was examined with rat liver mitochondria and compared with that of natural (+)-antimycin A3. (-)-Antimycin A3 inhibited respiration about 1/100th as strongly as natural (+)-antimycin A3. (-)-Antimycin A3 binding to the cytochrome bc1 complex did not seem to induce a conformational change in this proteinous complex. The binding site of (-)-antimycin A3 was probably the same as that of (+)-antimycin A3 (at the Qi center). However, the mode of interaction with the Qi center by (-)-antimycin A3 and (+)-antimycin A3 was somewhat different.

Molecular analysis of revertants from a respiratory-deficient mutant affecting the center o domain of cytochrome b in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

In bc complexes, cytochrome b plays a major role in electron transfer and in proton translocation across the membrane. Several inhibitor-resistant and respiratory-deficient mutants have already been used to study the structure-function relationships of this integral membrane protein. We describe here the selection and the molecular analysis of revertants from a thermo-sensitive mit-mutant of known nucleotide changes. Among 80 independent pseudo-wild type revertants screened by DNA-labelled oligonucleotide hybridization, 33 have been sequenced. Eight suppressor mutations, affecting a region critical for both the function and the binding of center o inhibitors (end of helix C) were identified. Two of them were found to be more resistant to myxothiazol.