Stringent and growth control of rRNA synthesis in Escherichia coli are both mediated by ppGpp

Amino acids can deplete ATP and impair nitric oxide detoxification by Escherichia coli

Nitric oxide (·NO) is a prevalent antimicrobial that is known to damage iron-containing enzymes in amino acid (AA) biosynthesis pathways. With Escherichia coli, ·NO is detoxified in aerobic environments by Hmp, which is an enzyme that is synthesized de novo in response to ·NO. With this knowledgebase, it is expected that the availability of AAs in the extracellular environment would enhance ·NO detoxification, because AAs would foster translation of Hmp. However, we observed that ·NO detoxification by E. coli was far slower in populations grown and treated in the presence of AAs (AA+) in comparison to those grown and stressed in the absence of AAs (AA-). Further experiments revealed that AA+ populations had difficulty translating proteins under ·NO stress, and that ·NO activated the stringent response in AA+ populations. Additional work revealed significant ATP depletion in ·NO-stressed AA+ cultures that far exceeded that of ·NO-stressed AA- populations. Transcription, translation, and RelA were not found to be significant contributors to the ATP depletion observed, whereas AA import was implicated as a significant ATP consumption pathway. Alleviating ATP depletion while maintaining access to AAs partially restored ·NO detoxification, which suggested that ATP depletion contributed to the translational difficulties observed in ·NO-stressed AA+ populations. These data reveal an unexpected interaction within the ·NO response network of E. coli that stimulates a stringent response by RelA in conditions where AAs are plentiful.

Cellular perception of growth rate and the mechanistic origin of bacterial growth law

Many cellular activities in bacteria are organized according to their growth rate. The notion that ppGpp measures the cell’s growth rate is well accepted in the field of bacterial physiology. However, despite decades of interrogation and the identification of multiple molecular interactions that connects ppGpp to some aspects of cell growth, we lack a system-level, quantitative picture of how this alleged “measurement” is performed. Through quantitative experiments, we show that the ppGpp pool responds inversely to the rate of translational elongation in Escherichia coli. Together with its roles in inhibiting ribosome biogenesis and activity, ppGpp closes a key regulatory circuit that enables the cell to perceive and control the rate of its growth across conditions. The celebrated linear growth law relating the ribosome content and growth rate emerges as a consequence of keeping a supply of ribosome reserves while maintaining elongation rate in slow growth conditions. Further analysis suggests the elongation rate itself is detected by sensing the ratio of dwelling and translocating ribosomes, a strategy employed to collapse the complex, high-dimensional dynamics of the molecular processes underlying cell growth to perceive the physiological state of the whole.

ppGpp is a bacterial cell size regulator

Growth and division are central to cell size. Bacteria achieve size homeostasis by dividing when growth has added a constant size since birth, termed the adder principle, by unknown mechanisms.^1,2 Growth is well known to be regulated by guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), which controls diverse processes from ribosome production to metabolic enzyme activity and replication initiation and whose absence or excess can induce stress, filamentation, and small growth-arrested cells.^3-6 These observations raise unresolved questions about the relation between ppGpp and size homeostasis mechanisms during normal exponential growth. Here, to untangle effects of ppGpp and nutrients, we gained control of cellular ppGpp by inducing the synthesis and hydrolysis enzymes RelA and Mesh1. We found that ppGpp not only exerts control over the growth rate but also over cell division and thus the steady state cell size. In response to changes in ppGpp level, the added size already establishes its new constant value while the growth rate still adjusts, aided by accelerated or delayed divisions. Moreover, the magnitude of the added size and resulting steady-state birth size correlate consistently with the ppGpp level, rather than with the growth rate, which results in cells of different size that grow equally fast. Our findings suggest that ppGpp serves as a key regulator that coordinates cell size and growth control.

Calibrating the Bacterial Growth Rate Speedometer: A Re-evaluation of the Relationship Between Basal ppGpp, Growth, and RNA Synthesis in Escherichia coli

The molecule guanosine tetraphophosphate (ppGpp) is most commonly considered an alarmone produced during acute stress. However, ppGpp is also present at low concentrations during steady-state growth. Whether ppGpp controls the same cellular targets at both low and high concentrations remains an open question and is vital for understanding growth rate regulation. It is widely assumed that basal ppGpp concentrations vary inversely with growth rate, and that the main function of basal ppGpp is to regulate transcription of ribosomal RNA in response to environmental conditions. Unfortunately, studies to confirm this relationship and to define regulatory targets of basal ppGpp are limited by difficulties in quantifying basal ppGpp. In this Perspective we compare reported concentrations of basal ppGpp in E. coli and quantify ppGpp within several strains using a recently developed analytical method. We find that although the inverse correlation between ppGpp and growth rate is robust across strains and analytical methods, absolute ppGpp concentrations do not absolutely determine RNA synthesis rates. In addition, we investigated the consequences of two separate RNA polymerase mutations that each individually reduce (but do not abolish) sensitivity to ppGpp and find that the relationship between ppGpp, growth rate, and RNA content of single-site mutants remains unaffected. Both literature and our new data suggest that environmental conditions may be communicated to RNA polymerase via an additional regulator. We conclude that basal ppGpp is one of potentially several agents controlling ribosome abundance and DNA replication initiation, but that evidence for additional roles in controlling macromolecular synthesis requires further study.

Bacterial stress defense: the crucial role of ribosome speed

In nature, bacteria are constantly adapting to various stressful conditions. Timely activation of stress response programs is crucial for bacteria to smoothly survive under stressful conditions. Stress response, demanding the de novo synthesis of many defense proteins, is generally activated at the transcriptional level by specific regulators. However, the effect of the global protein translational status on stress response has been largely overlooked. The translational capacity is limited by the number of translating ribosomes and the translational elongation rate. Recent work has shown that certain environmental stressors (e.g. oxidative stress) could severely compromise the stress response progress of bacteria by causing either slow-down or even complete stalling of the translational elongation process. The maintenance of ribosome elongation rate, being crucial for timely synthesis of stress defense proteins, becomes the physiological bottleneck that limits the survival of bacteria in some stressful conditions. Here, we briefly summarize some recent progress on the translational status of bacteria under two distinct stress conditions, nutrient deprivation and oxidative stress. We further discuss several important open questions on the translational regulation of bacteria during stress. The ribosome translation should be investigated in parallel with traditional transcriptional regulation in order to gain a better understanding on bacterial stress defense.

Global analysis of the impact of linezolid onto virulence factor production in S. aureus USA300

The translation inhibitor linezolid is an antibiotic of last resort against Gram-positive pathogens including methicillin resistant strains of the nosocomial pathogen Staphylococcus aureus. Linezolid is reported to inhibit production of extracellular virulence factors, but the molecular cause is unknown. To elucidate the physiological response of S. aureus to linezolid in general and the inhibition of virulence factor synthesis in particular a holistic study was performed. Linezolid was added to exponentially growing S. aureus cells and the linezolid stress response was analyzed with transcriptomics and quantitative proteomics methods. In addition, scanning and transmission electron microscopy experiments as well as fluorescence microscopy analyses of the cellular DNA and membrane were performed. As previously observed in studies on other translation inhibitors, S. aureus adapts its protein biosynthesis machinery to the reduced translation efficiency. For example the synthesis of ribosomal proteins was induced. Also unexpected results like a decline in the amount of extracellular and membrane proteins were obtained. In addition, cell shape and size changed after linezolid stress and cell division was diminished. Finally, the chromosome was condensed after linezolid stress and lost contact to the membrane. These morphological changes cannot be explained by established theories. A new hypothesis is discussed, which suggests that the reduced amount of membrane and extracellular proteins and observed defects in cell division are due to the disintegration of transertion complexes by linezolid.

Nutrient transitions are a source of persisters in Escherichia coli biofilms

Chronic and recurrent infections have been attributed to persisters in biofilms, and despite this importance, the mechanisms of persister formation in biofilms remain unclear. The plethora of biofilm characteristics that could give rise to persisters, including slower growth, quorum signaling, oxidative stress, and nutrient heterogeneity, have complicated efforts to delineate formation pathways that generate persisters during biofilm development. Here we sought to specifically determine whether nutrient transitions, which are a common metabolic stress encountered within surface-attached communities, stimulate persister formation in biofilms and if so, to then identify the pathway. To accomplish this, we established an experimental methodology where nutrient availability to biofilm cells could be controlled exogenously, and then used that method to discover that diauxic carbon source transitions stimulated persister formation in Escherichia coli biofilms. Previously, we found that carbon source transitions stimulate persister formation in planktonic E. coli cultures, through a pathway that involved ppGpp and nucleoid-associated proteins, and therefore, tested the functionality of that pathway in biofilms. Biofilm persister formation was also found to be dependent on ppGpp and nucleoid-associated proteins, but the importance of specific proteins and enzymes between biofilm and planktonic lifestyles was significantly different. Data presented here support the increasingly appreciated role of ppGpp as a central mediator of bacterial persistence and demonstrate that nutrient transitions can be a source of persisters in biofilms.

6S RNA: recent answers--future questions

6S RNA is a non-coding RNA, found in almost all phylogenetic branches of bacteria. Through its conserved secondary structure, resembling open DNA promoters, it binds to RNA polymerase and interferes with transcription at many promoters. That way, it functions as transcriptional regulator facilitating adaptation to stationary phase conditions. Strikingly, 6S RNA acts as template for the synthesis of small RNAs (pRNA), which trigger the disintegration of the inhibitory RNA polymerase-6S RNA complex releasing 6S RNA-dependent repression. The regulatory implications of 6S RNAs vary among different bacterial species depending on the lifestyle and specific growth conditions that they have to face. The influence of 6S RNA can be seen on many different processes including stationary growth, sporulation, light adaptation or intracellular growth of pathogenic bacteria. Recent structural and functional studies have yielded details of the interaction between E. coli 6S RNA and RNA polymerase. Genome-wide transcriptome analyses provided insight into the functional diversity of 6S RNAs. Moreover, the mechanism and physiological consequences of pRNA synthesis have been explored in several systems. A major function of 6S RNA as a guardian regulating the economic use of cellular resources under limiting conditions and stress emerges as a common perception from numerous recent studies.

Metabolic control of persister formation in Escherichia coli

Bacterial persisters are phenotypic variants that form from the action of stress response pathways triggering toxin-mediated antibiotic tolerance. Although persisters form during normal growth from native stresses, the pathways responsible for this phenomenon remain elusive. Here we have discovered that carbon source transitions stimulate the formation of fluoroquinolone persisters in Escherichia coli. Further, through a combination of genetic, biochemical, and flow cytometric assays in conjunction with a mathematical model, we have reconstructed a molecular-level persister formation pathway from initial stress (glucose exhaustion) to the activation of a metabolic toxin-antitoxin (TA) module (the ppGpp biochemical network) resulting in inhibition of DNA gyrase activity, the primary target of fluoroquinolones. This pathway spans from initial stress to antibiotic target and demonstrates that TA behavior can be exhibited by a metabolite-enzyme interaction (ppGpp-SpoT), in contrast to classical TA systems that involve only protein and/or RNA.

Differential regulation by ppGpp versus pppGpp in Escherichia coli

Both ppGpp and pppGpp are thought to function collectively as second messengers for many complex cellular responses to nutritional stress throughout biology. There are few indications that their regulatory effects might be different; however, this question has been largely unexplored for lack of an ability to experimentally manipulate the relative abundance of ppGpp and pppGpp. Here, we achieve preferential accumulation of either ppGpp or pppGpp with Escherichia coli strains through induction of different Streptococcal (p)ppGpp synthetase fragments. In addition, expression of E. coli GppA, a pppGpp 5′-gamma phosphate hydrolase that converts pppGpp to ppGpp, is manipulated to fine tune differential accumulation of ppGpp and pppGpp. In vivo and in vitro experiments show that pppGpp is less potent than ppGpp with respect to regulation of growth rate, RNA/DNA ratios, ribosomal RNA P1 promoter transcription inhibition, threonine operon promoter activation and RpoS induction. To provide further insights into regulation by (p)ppGpp, we have also determined crystal structures of E. coli RNA polymerase-σ⁷⁰ holoenzyme with ppGpp and pppGpp. We find that both nucleotides bind to a site at the interface between β′ and ω subunits.

Bacterial persistence and toxin-antitoxin loci

Bacterial persistence is caused by the presence of rare, slowly growing bacteria among populations of rapidly growing cells. The slowly growing bacteria are tolerant of antibiotics and other environmental insults, whereas their isogenic, rapidly growing siblings are sensitive. Recent research has shown that persistence of the model organism Escherichia coli depends on toxin-antitoxin (TA) loci. Deletion of type II TA loci reduces the level of persistence significantly. Lon protease but no other known ATP-dependent proteases is required for persistence. Polyphosphate and (p)ppGpp also are required for persistence. These observations led to the proposal of a simple and testable model that explains the persistence of E. coli. It is now important to challenge this model and to test whether the persistence of pathogenic bacteria also depends on TA loci.

Stringent response of Escherichia coli: revisiting the bibliome using literature mining

Background

Understanding the mechanisms responsible for cellular responses depends on the systematic collection and analysis of information on the main biological concepts involved. Indeed, the identification of biologically relevant concepts in free text, namely genes, tRNAs, mRNAs, gene products and small molecules, is crucial to capture the structure and functioning of different responses.

Results

In this work, we review literature reports on the study of the stringent response in Escherichia coli. Rather than undertaking the development of a highly specialised literature mining approach, we investigate the suitability of concept recognition and statistical analysis of concept occurrence as means to highlight the concepts that are most likely to be biologically engaged during this response. The co-occurrence analysis of core concepts in this stringent response, i.e. the (p)ppGpp nucleotides with gene products was also inspected and suggest that besides the enzymes RelA and SpoT that control the basal levels of (p)ppGpp nucleotides, many other proteins have a key role in this response. Functional enrichment analysis revealed that basic cellular processes such as metabolism, transcriptional and translational regulation are central, but other stress-associated responses might be elicited during the stringent response. In addition, the identification of less annotated concepts revealed that some (p)ppGpp-induced functional activities are still overlooked in most reviews.

Conclusions

In this paper we applied a literature mining approach that offers a more comprehensive analysis of the stringent response in E. coli. The compilation of relevant biological entities to this stress response and the assessment of their functional roles provided a more systematic understanding of this cellular response. Overlooked regulatory entities, such as transcriptional regulators, were found to play a role in this stress response. Moreover, the involvement of other stress-associated concepts demonstrates the complexity of this cellular response.

Growth rate regulation in Escherichia coli

Growth rate regulation in bacteria has been an important issue in bacterial physiology for the past 50 years. This review, using Escherichia coli as a paradigm, summarizes the mechanisms for the regulation of rRNA synthesis in the context of systems biology, particularly, in the context of genome-wide competition for limited RNA polymerase (RNAP) in the cell under different growth conditions including nutrient starvation. The specific location of the seven rrn operons in the chromosome and the unique properties of the rrn promoters contribute to growth rate regulation. The length of the rrn transcripts, coupled with gene dosage effects, influence the distribution of RNAP on the chromosome in response to growth rate. Regulation of rRNA synthesis depends on multiple factors that affect the structure of the nucleoid and the allocation of RNAP for global gene expression. The magic spot ppGpp, which acts with DksA synergistically, is a key effector in both the growth rate regulation and the stringent response induced by nutrient starvation, mainly because the ppGpp level changes in response to environmental cues. It regulates rRNA synthesis via a cascade of events including both transcription initiation and elongation, and can be explained by an RNAP redistribution (allocation) model.

Antagonistic regulation of dgkA and plsB genes of phospholipid synthesis by multiple stress responses in Escherichia coli

Phospholipid homeostasis of the bacterial membrane is maintained by biochemical regulation of the synthesis enzymes depending on the environment. However, genes encoding phospholipid synthesis enzymes might also be regulated during stress responses, in order for the bacteria to adapt their growth to changing environments. While few studies have addressed this question, global analyses show that specific genes are activated by alternative Sigma factors, and that phospholipid synthesis genes are co-ordinately regulated during stringent response. In Escherichia coli, the genes coding for glycerol-3-phosphate acyltransferase and diacylglycerol kinase (plsB and dgkA) are found next to each other in divergent orientations, suggesting a co-ordinated regulation. We investigated their regulation and found that these two genes are inversely regulated by a diversity of stress responses. plsB activation by σE is concomitant with a reduced DgkA amount. A second proximal promoter for plsB expression is responsible for basal plsB expression and is inhibited during stringent response. Finally, dgkA is activated by the two-component regulator BasR, linking dgkA function of phospholipid recycling to LPS modifications. In E. coli, PlsB and DgkA are key enzymes in the phospholipid synthesis pathway. Our results show that their expression is a crucial point of integration for different stress signals.

Transcription regulation of the Escherichia coli pcnB gene coding for poly(A) polymerase I: roles of ppGpp, DksA and sigma factors

Poly(A) polymerase I (PAP I), encoded by the pcnB gene, is a major enzyme responsible for RNA polyadenylation in Escherichia coli, a process involved in the global control of gene expression in this bacterium through influencing the rate of transcript degradation. Recent studies have suggested a complicated regulation of pcnB expression, including a complex promoter region, a control at the level of translation initiation and dependence on bacterial growth rate. In this report, studies on transcription regulation of the pcnB gene are described. Results of in vivo and in vitro experiments indicated that (a) there are three σ⁷⁰-dependent (p1, pB, and p2) and two σ^S-dependent (pS1 and pS2) promoters of the pcnB gene, (b) guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) and DksA directly inhibit transcription from pB, pS1 and pS2, and (c) pB activity is drastically impaired at the stationary phase of growth. These results indicate that regulation of the pcnB gene transcription is a complex process, which involves several factors acting to ensure precise control of PAP I production. Moreover, inhibition of activities of pS1 and pS2 by ppGpp and DksA suggests that regulation of transcription from promoters requiring alternative σ factors by these effectors of the stringent response might occur according to both passive and active models.

(p)ppGpp inhibits polynucleotide phosphorylase from streptomyces but not from Escherichia coli and increases the stability of bulk mRNA in Streptomyces coelicolor

ppGpp regulates gene expression in a variety of bacteria and in plants. We proposed previously that ppGpp or its precursor, pppGpp [referred to collectively as (p)ppGpp], or both might regulate the activity of the enzyme polynucleotide phosphorylase in Streptomyces species. We have examined the effects of (p)ppGpp on the polymerization and phosphorolysis activities of PNPase from Streptomyces coelicolor, Streptomyces antibioticus, and Escherichia coli. We have shown that (p)ppGpp inhibits the activities of both Streptomyces PNPases but not the E. coli enzyme. The inhibition kinetics for polymerization using the Streptomyces enzymes are of the mixed noncompetitive type, suggesting that (p)ppGpp binds to a region other than the active site of the enzyme. ppGpp also inhibited the phosphorolysis of a model RNA substrate derived from the rpsO-pnp operon of S. coelicolor. We have shown further that the chemical stability of mRNA increases during the stationary phase in S. coelicolor and that induction of a plasmid-borne copy of relA in a relA-null mutant increases the chemical stability of bulk mRNA as well. We speculate that the observed inhibition in vitro may reflect a role of ppGpp in the regulation of antibiotic production in vivo.

Depletion of the non-coding regulatory 6S RNA in E. coli causes a surprising reduction in the expression of the translation machinery

BACKGROUND

6S RNA from E. coli is known to bind to RNA polymerase interfering with transcription initiation. Because 6S RNA concentrations are maximal at stationary phase and binding occurs preferentially to the holoenzyme associated with sigma(70) (Esigma(70)) it is believed that 6S RNA supports adjustment to stationary phase transcription. Previous studies have also suggested that inhibition is specific for sigma(70)-dependent promoters characterized by a weak -35 recognition motif or extended -10 promoters. There are many exceptions to this precept, showing that other types of promoters, including stationary phase-specific (sigma(38)-dependent) promoters are inhibited.

RESULTS

To solve this apparent ambiguity and to better understand the role of 6S RNA in stationary phase transition we have performed a genome-wide transcriptional analysis of wild-type and 6S RNA deficient cells growing to mid-log or early stationary phase. We found 245 genes at the exponential growth phase and 273 genes at the early stationary phase to be > or = 1.5-fold differentially expressed. Up- and down-regulated genes include many transcriptional regulators, stress-related proteins, transporters and several enzymes involved in purine metabolism. As the most striking result during stationary phase, however, we obtained in the 6S RNA deficient strain a concerted expression reduction of genes constituting the translational apparatus. In accordance, primer extension analysis showed that transcription of ribosomal RNAs, representing the key molecules for ribosome biogenesis, is also significantly reduced under the same conditions. Consistent with this finding biochemical analysis of the 6S RNA deficient strain indicates that the lack of 6S RNA is apparently compensated by an increase of the basal ppGpp concentration, known to affect growth adaptation and ribosome biogenesis.

CONCLUSIONS

The analysis demonstrated that the effect of 6S RNA on transcription is not strictly confined to sigma(70)-dependent promoters. Moreover, the results indicate that 6S RNA is embedded in stationary phase adaptation, which is governed by the capacity of the translational machinery.

Staphylococcus aureus ClpC ATPase is a late growth phase effector of metabolism and persistence

Staphylococcus aureus Clp ATPases (molecular chaperones) alter normal physiological functions including an aconitase-mediated effect on post-stationary growth, acetate catabolism, and entry into death phase (Chatterjee et al., J. Bacteriol. 2005, 187, 4488-4496). In the present study, the global function of ClpC in physiology, metabolism, and late-stationary phase survival was examined using DNA microarrays and 2-D PAGE followed by MALDI-TOF MS. The results suggest that ClpC is involved in regulating the expression of genes and/or proteins of gluconeogenesis, the pentose-phosphate pathway, pyruvate metabolism, the electron transport chain, nucleotide metabolism, oxidative stress, metal ion homeostasis, stringent response, and programmed cell death. Thus, one major function of ClpC is balancing late growth phase carbon metabolism. Furthermore, these changes in carbon metabolism result in alterations of the intracellular concentration of free NADH, the amount of cell-associated iron, and fatty acid metabolism. This study provides strong evidence for ClpC as a critical factor in staphylococcal energy metabolism, stress regulation, and late-stationary phase survival; therefore, these data provide important insight into the adaptation of S. aureus toward a persister state in chronic infections.

Second messenger signalling governs Escherichia coli biofilm induction upon ribosomal stress

Biofilms are communities of surface-attached, matrix-embedded microbial cells that can resist antimicrobial chemotherapy and contribute to persistent infections. Using an Escherichia coli biofilm model we found that exposure of bacteria to subinhibitory concentrations of ribosome-targeting antibiotics leads to strong biofilm induction. We present evidence that this effect is elicited by the ribosome in response to translational stress. Biofilm induction involves upregulation of the polysaccharide adhesin poly-beta-1,6-N-acetyl-glucosamine (poly-GlcNAc) and two components of the poly-GlcNAc biosynthesis machinery, PgaA and PgaD. Poly-GlcNAc control depends on the bacterial signalling molecules guanosine-bis 3', 5'(diphosphate) (ppGpp) and bis-(3'-5')-cyclic di-GMP (c-di-GMP). Treatment with translation inhibitors causes a ppGpp hydrolase (SpoT)-mediated reduction of ppGpp levels, resulting in specific derepression of PgaA. Maximal induction of PgaD and poly-GlcNAc synthesis requires the production of c-di-GMP by the dedicated diguanylate cyclase YdeH. Our results identify a novel regulatory mechanism that relies on ppGpp signalling to relay information about ribosomal performance to the Pga machinery, thereby inducing adhesin production and biofilm formation. Based on the important synergistic roles of ppGpp and c-di-GMP in this process, we suggest that interference with bacterial second messenger signalling might represent an effective means for biofilm control during chronic infections.

Feedback control of ribosome synthesis in Escherichia coli is dependent on eight critical amino acids

When bacteria growing in minimal medium are supplied with exogenous amino acids, they respond by increasing the synthesis of ribosomes; this leads to more protein synthesis capacity and faster growth. To examine how amino acids control the synthesis of ribosomes, two strategies were used. First, single amino acids were added to bacteria growing in minimal medium and their effect on the relative strength of the rrnB P1 promoter was determined. The addition of any one of eight amino acids (alanine, glutamine, and glutamic acid, isoleucine, leucine, methionine, serine, valine) increased the strength of the P1 promoter by 1.25- to 2.0-fold with no appreciable effect on transcription from an isolated rrn P2 promoter or on the bacterial growth rate. The effects of adding combinations of these critical amino acids were partially additive. When any one of the other amino acids was added, no discernable stimulation in relative P1 expression or growth was observed. In the second strategy, all amino acids were present in the growth medium, but the carbon source was altered to change the growth rate. In this case the relative strength of the P1 promoter was always constant and maximal. We suggest that addition of any of the eight critical amino acids reduces the ppGpp synthesis activity of the spoT gene product; the lower ppGpp levels, in turn, increase the strength of the rrn P1 promoters. It is suggested that these amino acids are involved in a feedback chain of reactions that control the rate of ribosome function by adjusting the rate of ribosome synthesis.

The seven E. coli ribosomal RNA operon upstream regulatory regions differ in structure and transcription factor binding efficiencies

Ribosomal RNAs in E. coli are transcribed from seven operons, which are highly conserved in their organization and sequence. However, the upstream regulatory DNA regions differ considerably, suggesting differences in regulation. We have therefore analyzed the conformation of all seven DNA elements located upstream of the major E. coli rRNA P1 promoters. As judged by temperature-dependent gel electrophoresis with isolated DNA fragments comprising the individual P1 promoters and the complete upstream regulatory regions, all seven rRNA upstream sequences are intrinsically curved. The degree of intrinsic curvature was highest for the rrnB and rrnD fragments and less pronounced for the rrnA and rrnE operons. Comparison of the experimentally determined differences in curvature with programs for the prediction of DNA conformation revealed a generally high degree of conformity. Moreover, the analysis showed that the center of curvature is located at about the same position in all fragments. The different upstream regions were analyzed for their capacity to bind the transcription factors FIS and H-NS, which are known as antagonists in the regulation of rRNA synthesis. Gel retardation experiments revealed that both proteins interact with the upstream promoter regions of all seven rDNA fragments, with the affinities of the different DNA fragments for FIS and H-NS and the structure of the resulting complexes deviating considerably. FIS binding was non-cooperative, and at comparable protein concentrations the occupancy of the different DNA fragments varied between two and four binding sites. In contrast, H-NS was shown to bind cooperatively and intermediate states of occupancy could not be resolved for each fragment. The different gel electrophoretic mobilities of the individual DNA/protein complexes indicate variable structures and topologies of the upstream activating sequence regulatory complexes. Our results are highly suggestive of differential regulation of the individual rRNA operons.

Control of rRNA synthesis in Escherichia coli: a systems biology approach

The first part of this review contains an overview of the various contributions and models relating to the control of rRNA synthesis reported over the last 45 years. The second part describes a systems biology approach to identify the factors and effectors that control the interactions between RNA polymerase and rRNA (rrn) promoters of Escherichia coli bacteria during exponential growth in different media. This analysis is based on measurements of absolute rrn promoter activities as transcripts per minute per promoter in bacterial strains either deficient or proficient in the synthesis of the factor Fis and/or the effector ppGpp. These absolute promoter activities are evaluated in terms of rrn promoter strength (V(max)/K(m)) and free RNA polymerase concentrations. Three major conclusions emerge from this evaluation. First, the rrn promoters are not saturated with RNA polymerase. As a consequence, changes in the concentration of free RNA polymerase contribute to changes in rrn promoter activities. Second, rrn P2 promoter strength is not specifically regulated during exponential growth at different rates; its activity changes only when the concentration of free RNA polymerase changes. Third, the effector ppGpp reduces the strength of the rrn P1 promoter both directly and indirectly by reducing synthesis of the stimulating factor Fis. This control of rrn P1 promoter strength forms part of a larger feedback loop that adjusts the synthesis of ribosomes to the availability of amino acids via amino acid-dependent control of ppGpp accumulation.

Essential steps in the ppGpp-dependent regulation of bacterial ribosomal RNA promoters can be explained by substrate competition

Transcription of stable RNA genes is known to be dramatically reduced in the presence of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), the mediator of the stringent response. Using in vitro transcription systems with ribosomal RNA P1 promoters, we have analyzed which step of the initiation cycle is inhibited by the effector ppGpp. We show that formation of the ternary transcription initiation complex consisting of RNA polymerase holoenzyme, the promoter DNA, and the first initiating nucleotide triphosphate is the major step at which ppGpp exerts its regulation. Neither primary binding of RNA polymerase to the promoter nor isomerization to the open binary complexes or the subsequent promoter clearance steps contributes notably to the observed inhibition. The effect of ppGpp-dependent inhibition in the formation of the ternary transcription initiation complex could be mimicked by nucleotide derivatives known to bind to the RNA polymerase active center. Using these model compounds, almost identical inhibition characteristics were observed as seen with ppGpp. The results support the previously published model, which suggests that ppGpp-dependent inhibition is based on competition between the inhibitor molecules and NTP substrates for access to the active center of RNA polymerase.

Underproduction of sigma 70 mimics a stringent response. A proteome approach

When Escherichia coli cells enter stationary phase due to carbon starvation the synthesis of ribosomal proteins is rapidly repressed. In a DeltarelA DeltaspoT mutant, defective in the production of the alarmone guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), this regulation of the levels of the protein synthesizing system is abolished. Using a proteomic approach we demonstrate that the production of the vast majority of detected E. coli proteins are decontrolled during carbon starvation in the DeltarelA DeltaspoT strain and that the starved cells behave as if they were growing exponentially. In addition we show that the inhibition of ribosome synthesis by the stringent response can be qualitatively mimicked by artificially lowering the levels of the housekeeping sigma factor, sigma(70). In other words, genes encoding the protein-synthesizing system are especially sensitive to reduced availability of sigma(70) programmed RNA polymerase. This effect is not dependent on ppGpp since lowering the levels of sigma(70) gives a similar but less pronounced effect in a ppGpp(0) strain. The data is discussed in view of the models advocating for a passive control of gene expression during stringency based on alterations in RNA polymerase availability.

Expression of spoT in Borrelia burgdorferi during serum starvation

Borrelia burgdorferi, the causative agent of Lyme disease, is transmitted by the tick Ixodes scapularis. A 2.9-kb fragment containing a putative spoT gene was isolated from B. burgdorferi genomic DNA by PCR amplification and cloned into a pBAD24 vector. The cloned gene complemented Escherichia coli mutant strain CF1693, which contains deletions of both the relA and spoT genes. The spoT gene in E. coli encodes a bifunctional enzyme capable of synthesizing and degrading (p)ppGpp, which mediates the stringent response during carbon source starvation. B. burgdorferi has been reported to have a stress response to serum starvation. Thin-layer chromatography was used to detect (p)ppGpp extracted from H(3)(32)PO(4)-labeled B. burgdorferi cells starved for serum in RPMI. B. burgdorferi spoT gene expression was characterized during fatty acid starvation. Northern analysis of spoT revealed detectable message at 2.5 min of starvation in RPMI. Expression of spoT during serum starvation increased approximately 6-fold during the 30 min that starvation conditions were maintained. Further, expression of spoT decreased when serum was added to serum-starved cells. Reverse transcriptase PCR (RT-PCR) was used to detect spoT mRNA from approximately 10(6) cells starved for serum in RPMI for 2.5 to 30 min or incubated in tick saliva for 15 min. Northern blot analysis suggests that spoT transcript was approximately 900 nucleotides in length. RT-PCR amplification of the transcript using several sets of primers confirmed this finding. Additionally, a truncated clone containing only the first 950 bp of the 2,001-bp spoT open reading frame was able to complement E. coli CF1693. The data suggest that B. burgdorferi exhibits a stringent response to serum starvation and during incubation in tick saliva.

Kinetic properties of rrn promoters in Escherichia coli

How do bacteria adapt and optimize their growth in response to different environments? The answer to this question is intimately related to the control of ribosome bio-synthesis. During the last decades numerous proposals have been made to explain this control but none has been definitive. To readdress the problem, we have used measurements of rRNA synthesis rates and rrn gene dosages in E. coli to find the absolute transcription rates of the average rrn operon (transcripts per min per operon) at different growth rates. By combining these rates with lacZ expression data from rRNA promoter-lacZ fusions, the abolute activities of the isolated rrnB P1 and P2 promoters were determined as functions of the growth rate in the presence and absence of Fis and of the effector ppGpp. The promoter activity data were analyzed to obtain the relative concentrations of free RNA polymerase, [R(f)], and the ratio of the Michaelis-Menten parameters, V(max)/K(m) (promoter strength), that characterize the promoter-RNA polymerase interaction. The results indicate that changes in the basal concentration of ppGpp can account for all growth-medium dependent regulation of the rrn P1 promoter strength. The P1 promoter strength was maximal when Fis was present and the level of ppGpp was undetectable during growth in rich media or in ppGpp-deficient strains; this maximal strength was 3-fold reduced when Fis was removed and the level of ppGpp remained undetectable. At ppGpp levels above 55 pmol per cell mass unit (OD(460)) during growth in poor media, the P1 promoter strength was minimal and not affected by the presence or absence of fis. The half-maximal value occurred at 20 pmol ppGpp/OD(460) and corresponds to an intracellular concentration of about 50 microM. In connection with previously published data, the results suggest that ppGpp reduces the P1 promoter strength directly, by binding RNA polymerase, and indirectly, by inhibiting the synthesis of Fis.

Regulation of sigma factor competition by the alarmone ppGpp

Many regulons controlled by alternative sigma factors, including sigma(S) and sigma(32), are poorly induced in cells lacking the alarmone ppGpp. We show that ppGpp is not absolutely required for the activity of sigma(S)-dependent promoters because underproduction of sigma(70), specific mutations in rpoD (rpoD40 and rpoD35), or overproduction of Rsd (anti-sigma(70)) restored expression from sigma(S)-dependent promoters in vivo in the absence of ppGpp accumulation. An in vitro transcription/competition assay with reconstituted RNA polymerase showed that addition of ppGpp reduces the ability of wild-type sigma(70) to compete with sigma(32) for core binding and the mutant sigma(70) proteins, encoded by rpoD40 and rpoD35, compete less efficiently than wild-type sigma(70). Similarly, an in vivo competition assay showed that the ability of both sigma(32) and sigma(S) to compete with sigma(70) is diminished in cells lacking ppGpp. Consistently, the fraction of sigma(S) and sigma(32) bound to core was drastically reduced in ppGpp-deficient cells. Thus, the stringent response encompasses a mechanism that alters the relative competitiveness of sigma factors in accordance with cellular demands during physiological stress.

Comparison of DeltarelA strains of Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium suggests a role for ppGpp in attenuation regulation of branched-chain amino acid biosynthesis

The growth recovery of Escherichia coli K-12 and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium DeltarelA mutants were compared after nutritional downshifts requiring derepression of the branched-chain amino acid pathways. Because wild-type E. coli K-12 and S. enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2 strains are defective in the expression of the genes encoding the branch point acetohydroxy acid synthetase II (ilvGM) and III (ilvIH) isozymes, respectively, DeltarelA derivatives corrected for these mutations were also examined. Results indicate that reduced expression of the known global regulatory factors involved in branched-chain amino acid biosynthesis cannot completely explain the observed growth recovery defects of the DeltarelA strains. In the E. coli K-12 MG1655 DeltarelA background, correction of the preexisting rph-1 allele which causes pyrimidine limitations resulted in complete loss of growth recovery. S. enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2 DeltarelA strains were fully complemented by elevated basal ppGpp levels in an S. enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2 DeltarelA spoT1 mutant or in a strain harboring an RNA polymerase mutation conferring a reduced RNA chain elongation rate. The results are best explained by a dependence on the basal levels of ppGpp, which are determined by relA-dependent changes in tRNA synthesis resulting from amino acid starvations. Expression of the branched-chain amino acid operons is suggested to require changes in the RNA chain elongation rate of the RNA polymerase, which can be achieved either by elevation of the basal ppGpp levels or, in the case of the E. coli K-12 MG1655 strain, through pyrimidine limitations which partially compensate for reduced ppGpp levels. Roles for ppGpp in branched-chain amino acid biosynthesis are discussed in terms of effects on the synthesis of known global regulatory proteins and current models for the control of global RNA synthesis by ppGpp.

The study of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate-mediated transcription regulation in vitro using a coupled transcription-translation system

The effects of the "alarmone" guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp) on regulation of the Salmonella typhimurium histindine operon and the Escherichia coli tRNA(leu) operon were analyzed in vitro using a DNA-dependent transcription-translation system, S-30. The expression of the hisG promoter is positively regulated by ppGpp, whereas that of the leuV promoter (of tRNA(1eu)) is negatively regulated by ppGpp. In an attempt to understand the global regulatory mechanism of ppGpp control, interrelationship between ppGpp-dependent activation and repression of gene expression was examined using these promoters as models. It has been traditionally supposed that the ppGpp-dependent regulation, at least for the activation, is by a passive mode of control: the activation of gene expression by ppGpp is a consequence of the repression of stable RNA gene expression in the condition of RNA polymerase limiting. To test this model, the ppGpp-dependent regulations of both an activable promoter (hisGp) and a repressible promoter (leuVp) were determined in vitro simultaneously using a mixed template setup. The rationale for this exercise was to see whether the ppGpp-dependent activation and repression are inversely correlated in the in vitro condition in which RNA polymerase is limiting. No correlation was observed. It was concluded that the ppGpp-dependent activation is independent of the repression. Moreover, it was proposed that ppGpp-dependent activation and repression are mediated by titratable factors, each of which operate independently.

Transcription-modulated repair in Escherichia coli evident with UV-induced mutation spectra in supF

We have determined several mutation spectra with the supF sequence after UV mutagenesis in Escherichia coli. The cells were either mfd(+) or mfd(-) and grown in defined or complex medium. The tRNA supF gene was expressed from the plasmid pZ189 or pLS1D (similar to pLS189, a variant of pZ189, but with a tac promoter for supF). Most of the mutations with either plasmid could be attributed to possible targeting photoproducts at dipyrimidine sites in the transcribed (TS) or non-transcribed (NTS) DNA strand with differential characteristics relevant to the repair process "mutation frequency decline" (MFD): (1) with pZ189, targeting sites in TS were favored over sites in NTS in all conditions except after an explicit MFD incubation with mfd(+) cells, when there was a majority in NTS; (2) with pLS1D (tac promoter), there was always a marked bias for targeting sites in TS and this was not altered by an MFD incubation; and (3) with pLS1D, spectra with mfd(-) cells vis-à-vis wild-type indicated a notable shift in the position of a hot-spot (both targeting sites in TS) and an increase in deletion mutations. The results support the Selby-Sancar idea that transcription-coupled nucleotide excision repair (TCR) at tRNA genes accounts for MFD and can be inhibited by rapid transcription. During interference of TCR by rapid transcription, however, the presence or absence of functional Mfd protein (transcription-repair coupling factor) can still influence the pattern of mutation, e.g. alter the position of a hot-spot in pLS1D. Only when a tRNA promoter is modulated by an MFD condition is transcription at a rate conducive to TCR. There were several deletion mutations with pLS1D between direct repeats (not present in pZ189) and a model for their production by UV damage is suggested. The spectra with pZ189 in E. coli had similarities with those published for UV mutagenesis in human cells, e.g. mutations at positions approximately 124 and 156.

Activities of constitutive promoters in Escherichia coli

The in vivo activities of seven constitutive promoters in Escherichia coli have been determined as functions of growth rate in wild-type relA+ spoT+ strains with normal levels of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) and in ppGpp-deficient DeltarelADeltaspoT derivatives. The promoters include (i) the spc ribosomal protein operon promotor Pspc; (ii) the beta-lactamase gene promotor Pblaof plasmid pBR322; (iii) the PLpromoter of phage lambda; (iv) and (v) the replication control promoters PRNAIand PRNAIIof plasmid pBR322; and (vi) and (vii) the P1 and P2 promoters of the rrnB ribosomal RNA operon. Each strain carried an operon fusion consisting of one of the respective promoter regions linked to lacZ and recombined into the chromosome at the mal locus of a lac deletion strain. The amount of 5'-terminal lacZ mRNA and of beta-galactosidase activity expressed from these promoters were determined by standard hybridization or enzyme activity assays, respectively. In addition, DNA, RNA and protein measurements were used to obtain information about gene dosage, rRNA synthesis and translation rates. By combining lacZ mRNA hybridization data with gene dosage and rRNA synthesis data, the absolute activity of the different promoters, in transcripts/minute per promoter, was determined. In ppGpp-proficient (relA+ spoT+) strains, the respective activities of rrnB P1 and P2 increased 40 and fivefold with increasing growth rate between 0.7 and 3.0 doublings/hour. The activities of Pspc, PL, Pbla, and PRNAIincreased two- to threefold and reached a maximum at growth rates above 2.0 doublings/hour. In contrast, PRNAIIactivity decreased threefold over this range of growth rates. In ppGpp-deficient (DeltarelA DeltaspoT) bacterial strains, the activities of rrnB P1 and P2 promoters both increased about twofold between 1.6 and 3.0 doublings/hour, whereas the activities of Pspc, PL, Pbla, and PRNAI, and PRNAIIwere about constant. To explain these observations, we suggest that the cellular concentration of free RNA polymerase increases with increasing growth rate; for saturation the P1 and P2 rRNA promoters require a high RNA polymerase concentration that is approached only at the highest growth rates, whereas the other promoters are saturated at lower polymerase concentrations achieved at intermediate growth rates. In addition, the data indicate that the respective rrnB P1 and PRNAIIpromoters were under negative and positive control by ppGpp. This caused a reduced activity of rrnB P1 and an increased activity of PRNAIIduring slow growth in wild-type (relA+ spoT+) relative to ppGpp-deficient (DeltarelA DeltaspoT) bacterial strains.

Co-ordination of legionella pneumophila virulence with entry into stationary phase by ppGpp

Legionella pneumophila survives in aquatic environments, but replicates within amoebae or the alveolar macrophages of immunocompromised individuals. Here, the signal transduction pathway that co-ordinates L. pneumophila virulence expression in response to amino acid depletion was investigated. To facilitate kinetic and genetic studies, a phenotypic reporter of virulence was engineered by fusing flaA promoter sequences to a gene encoding green fluorescent protein. When subjected to amino acid depletion, L. pneumophila accumulated ppGpp and converted from a replicative to a virulent state, as judged by motility and sodium sensitivity. ppGpp appeared to initiate this response, as L. pneumophila induced to express the Escherichia coli RelA ppGpp synthetase independently of nutrient depletion accumulated ppGpp, exited the exponential growth phase and expressed flaAgfp, motility, sodium sensitivity, cytotoxicity and infectivity, five traits correlated with virulence. Although coincident with the stationary phase, L. pneumophila virulence expression appeared to require an additional factor: mutant Lp120 accumulated ppGpp and acquired two stationary phase traits but none of six virulence phenotypes analysed. We propose that, when nutrients are limiting, ppGpp acts as an alarmone, triggering the expression of multiple traits that enable L. pneumophila to escape its spent host, to survive and disperse in the environment and to re-establish a protected intracellular replication niche.

Effects of the Escherichia coli DNA-binding protein H-NS on rRNA synthesis in vivo

The Escherichia coli DNA-binding protein H-NS is known to interact specifically with the upstream region of ribosomal RNA transcription units, where it causes transcriptional repression in vitro. Here, we present results demonstrating the effect of H-NS on rRNA transcription in vivo. rRNA synthesis rates were compared in cells that differ in the expression of functional H-NS or FIS molecules. We could show that in the absence of H-NS derepression of rRNA synthesis occurs at low growth rates. During the cell cycle H-NS is responsible for the rapid shut-off of rRNA synthesis at the end of the exponential phase. As it is known for FIS-dependent activation, the inhibitory function of H-NS is specific for P1, the first of the tandem rRNA promoters. The effect of H-NS on rRNA synthesis was further assessed under stress conditions. While under osmotic upshift the reduction in rRNA synthesis is clearly H-NS-dependent, no such influence could be detected at cold shock. Determination of the cellular ppGpp concentrations revealed that H-NS does not mediate its function via alterations in the synthesis of the global effector ppGpp.

Effects of nutrition and growth rate on Lrp levels in Escherichia coli

Lrp (leucine-responsive regulatory protein) activates some Escherichia coli operons that function in anabolism and represses others involved in catabolism (for a review, see J. M. Calvo and R. G. Matthews, Microbiol. Rev. 58:466-490, 1994). This overall pattern suggests that Lrp may help cells adapt to changes in the nutritional environment. Here, we tested the idea that the nutritional richness of the medium determines the amount of Lrp in cells. Lrp was measured directly by Western blotting (immunoblotting) in cells grown in a chemically defined rich medium or in a minimal medium. In addition, transcription from the lrp promoter was assessed with a lacZ reporter gene. The results with these two different measurements were nearly the same, indicating that under the conditions employed, beta-galactosidase measurements can accurately reflect Lrp levels. For cells in a minimal medium, Lrp levels were consistently lowest during the logarithmic phase of growth, but overall, there was not much variation in levels as a function of growth phase (1.3-fold difference between highest and lowest values). However, for cells in a rich medium, Lrp levels dropped 3- to 4-fold during the lag phase, remained constant during the log phase, and then rose to starting levels upon entry into the stationary phase. When cells in the log phase were compared, Lrp levels were 3- to 4-fold higher in cells growing in a minimal medium than those in a rich medium. The levels of lrp expression were the same or slightly higher in strains containing mutations in rpoS, cya, or crp compared with wild-type strains, suggesting that neither RpoS nor the cyclic AMP (cAMP) receptor protein-cAMP complex is required for expression. On the other hand, lrp expression was severely restricted in cells that could not make ppGpp because of mutations in relA and spoT. The reduced expression of lrp during logarithmic growth in a rich medium may be due to low ppGpp levels under these conditions. The repressive effects of rich medium and the stimulatory effects of ppGpp were also observed with a construct having only a minimal lrp promoter (-57 to +21). The results of other experiments suggest that Lrp levels vary inversely with the growth rate of cells instead of being determined by some component of the medium.

rRNA transcription and growth rate-dependent regulation of ribosome synthesis in Escherichia coli

The synthesis of ribosomal RNA is the rate-limiting step in ribosome synthesis in bacteria. There are multiple mechanisms that determine the rate of rRNA synthesis. Ribosomal RNA promoter sequences have evolved for exceptional strength and for regulation in response to nutritional conditions and amino acid availability. Strength derives in part from an extended RNA polymerase (RNAP) recognition region involving at least two RNAP subunits, in part from activation by a transcription factor and in part from modification of the transcript by a system that prevents premature termination. Regulation derives from at least two mechanistically distinct systems, growth rate-dependent control and stringent control. The mechanisms contributing to rRNA transcription work together and compensate for one another when individual systems are rendered inoperative.

Transcriptional pausing of RNA polymerase in the presence of guanosine tetraphosphate depends on the promoter and gene sequence

We have studied the response of the effector molecule guanosine 3',5'-bisdiphosphate (ppGpp) on RNA polymerase pausing during in vitro transcription elongation. Pausing was followed during single round extension of stalled ternary complexes excluding possible ppGpp effects on initiation. The ppGpp dependences of early pausing sites within different transcription systems controlled by promoters with known response to enhanced ppGpp levels in vivo were quantitatively characterized. Transcription of stable RNAs and mRNA genes were analyzed. In addition, the in vitro pausing behavior of two promoter variants directing the same sequence but differing in their in vivo ppGpp sensitivity were compared. In the presence of ppGpp we noted a slight general enhancement of specific pauses in all transcription systems. However, genes known to be under stringent or growth rate control in vivo revealed a notably stronger pausing enhancement. The sites of pausing are not changed by the presence of ppGpp but appear to be sequence-specific. The effect of ppGpp on the extent of pausing depends on the particular promoter and closely adjacent sequences that the RNA polymerase has passed during initiation. Pausing enhancement requires the presence of ppGpp during elongation but not during initiation. The results underline the importance of pausing for transcription regulation and offer a plausible explanation for inhibition of stable RNA expression under conditions of elevated concentrations of ppGpp.

The RNA chain elongation rate of the lambda late mRNA is unaffected by high levels of ppGpp in the absence of amino acid starvation

In this study, the effects of high levels of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) on the decay and RNA chain elongation kinetics of the bacteriophage lambda late transcript in Escherichia coli were examined in the absence of amino acid starvation. The accumulation, mRNA decay kinetics, and RNA chain elongation rate of the lambda late mRNA were determined after heat induction of lambdacI857 lysogens in the presence of high levels of ppGpp induced from a RelAalpha fragment-overproducing plasmid. The accumulation kinetics and elongation rate determinations of the late mRNA were made at long times after induction to allow a new steady state of transcriptional activities under conditions of elevated intracellular levels of ppGpp. The results indicate no prolonged or significant effect on either mRNA decay or the RNA chain elongation rate of the late mRNA as a result of elevated ppGpp levels. Surprisingly, the RNA chain elongation rate determinations indicate an RNA polymerase processivity of approximately 90-100 nucleotides/s for the lambda late transcript despite the presence of high levels of ppGpp. The results are discussed in terms of various models for regulation of stable and messenger RNA synthesis in E. coli.

A relA/spoT homologous gene from Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2) controls antibiotic biosynthetic genes

A 0.972-kilobase pair DNA fragment from Streptomyces lividans that induces the production of the blue-pigmented antibiotic actinorhodine in S. lividans when cloned on a multicopy plasmid has led to the isolation of a 4-kilobase pair DNA fragment from Streptomyces coelicolor containing homologous sequence. Computer-assisted analysis of the DNA sequence revealed three putative open reading frames (ORFs), ORF1, ORF2, and ORF3. ORF2 extends beyond the sequenced DNA fragment, and its deduced product shares no similarities with any other known proteins in the data bases. ORF3 is also truncated, and its 41-amino acid C-terminal product is identical to the S. coelicolor adenine phosphoribosyltransferase. The 847-amino acid ORF1 protein, with a predicted molecular mass of 94.2 kDa, strongly resembled the relA and spoT gene products from Escherichia coli and the homologs from Vibrio sp. strain S14, Haemophilus influenzae, Streptococcus equisimilis H46A, and Mycoplasma genitalium. Unlike these proteins, the ORF1 amino acid sequence analysis revealed the presence of a putative ATP/GTP-binding domain. A mutant was generated by deleting most of the ORF1 gene that showed an actinorhodine-nonproducing phenotype, while undecylprodigiosin and the calcium-dependent antibiotic were unaffected. The mutant strain grew at a much lower rate than the wild-type strain, and spore formation was delayed. When the gene was propagated on a low copy number vector, not only was actinorhodine production restored, but actinorhodine and undecylprodigiosin production was enhanced in both the mutant and wild-type and morphological differentiation returned to wild-type characteristics. (p)ppGpp synthetase activity was not detected in purified ribosomes from the ORF1-deleted mutant, while it was restored by complementation of this strain.

Measurement of Growth at Very Low Rates ((mu) >= 0), an Approach To Study the Energy Requirement for the Survival of Alcaligenes eutrophus JMP 134

Alcaligenes eutrophus JMP 134 was grown in a recycling-mode fermenter with 100% biomass retention on 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), phenol, and fructose. The growth pattern obtained given a constant supply of substrates exhibited three phases of linear growth on all three substrates. The transition from phase 1 to phase 2, considered to correspond to the onset of stringent (growth) control as indicated by a significant increase in guanosine 5(prm1)-bisphosphate 3(prm1)-bisphosphate (ppGpp), took place at 0.016 h(sup-1) with 2,4-D and at about 0.02 h(sup-1) with phenol and fructose. In the final phase, phase 4, which was achieved after the growth rate on the respective substrates fell below 0.003 to 0.001 h(sup-1), a constant level of biomass was obtained irrespective of further feeding of substrate at the same rate. The yield coefficients decreased by 70 to 80% from phase 1 to phase 3 and were 0 in phase 4. The stationary substrate concentrations s(infmin) in phase 4, calculated from the kinetic constants of the strain, were 1.23, 0.34, and 0.23 (mu)M for 2,4-D, phenol, and fructose, respectively. These figures characterize the minimum stationary substrate concentrations required in a dynamic system to keep A. eutrophus alive. This is caused by a substrate flux which enables growth at a rate >=0 due to the provision of energy to an extent at least satisfying maintenance requirements. According to the constant feed rates of the substrates and the final and stable biomass concentrations, this maintenance energy amounts to 14.4, 4.0, and 2.4 (mu)mol of ATP (middot) mg of dry mass(sup-1) h(sup-1) for 2,4-D, phenol, and fructose, respectively, after correction for the fraction of living cells. The increased energy expenditure in the case of 2,4-D is discussed with respect to uncoupling.

Effects of different growth conditions on the in vivo activity of the tandem Escherichia coli ribosomal RNA promoters P1 and P2

We have analyzed the relative activities of the Escherichia coli ribosomal RNA promoters P1 and P2 in vivo under different physiological conditions. Promoter efficiencies were determined by quantitative comparison of the transcript-specific primer extension products obtained from total RNA preparations. Cells were analyzed at different stages of the growth cycle, at different growth rates, and under conditions of stringent control. In addition, the rRNA gene dosage was altered by transformation with plasmids containing additional rrnD or rrnB transcription units, or rRNA operons in which one of the tandem promoters (P1) had been deleted. Under conditions of amino acid starvation (stringent control) we observed the expected strong reduction in P1-directed transcription. In contrast to the previous assumption that the P2 promoter is not regulated, we simultaneously noticed a smaller but significant repression of P2-directed transcription. In strains in which the rRNA gene dosage was increased by transformation with plasmids bearing rRNA transcription units, a similar degree of repression was observed. Repression of the P1 promoter activity was increased, however, when cells contained extra rRNA operons with P2 promoters only. As demonstrated under stringent control conditions, changes in the growth cycle also affected the activity of promoters P1 and P2. A greater proportion of P2-derived transcripts was observed when cells changed from exponential to stationary growth or if cultures were grown in minimal medium. Under steady-state, slow growth conditions (minimal medium) we obtained evidence showing that the ratio of P1/P2 transcription products is much lower for cells with extra rrnB as compared to extra rrnD operons or cells lacking extra rRNA operons, implying an operon-specific regulation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effects of the antiterminator BoxA on transcription elongation kinetics and ppGpp inhibition of transcription elongation in Escherichia coli

It has been shown previously that two different mRNA chains (lacZ and infB) are elongated at a rate of approximately 40 nucleotides (nt)/s during steady state growth on minimal medium and that the rate of mRNA chain elongation is inhibited by ppGpp in vivo. On the other hand, it was found that a truncated ribosomal RNA chain was elongated at a rate of approximately 80 nt/s, independent of growth condition (Vogel, U., and Jensen, K. F. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 16236-16241). We reasoned that the different transcriptional behavior of mRNA genes and rRNA operons might be caused by the antiterminator sequences present in the rRNA operons. To test this possibility, we have (a) inserted the minimal antiterminator boxA sequence between the promoter and the lacZ and infB genes and (b) deleted the antiterminator sequences from the rRNA transcription unit and measured transcription elongation rates in vivo on the resulting hybrid genes. We found that insertion of boxA in front of the coding region of lacZ increased the transcription elongation rate from 42 nt/s to 69 nt/s during steady state growth and that it eliminated the ppGpp-dependent decrease in the transcription elongation rate during the stringent response. On the other hand, deletion of the antiterminator sequences from the rRNA operon resulted in a reduced transcription elongation rate, but the elongation rate was still insensitive to changes in the ppGpp pool. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the antiterminator boxA is a primary determinant of the rate of transcription elongation rate.

Guanosine tetraphosphate as a global regulator of bacterial RNA synthesis: a model involving RNA polymerase pausing and queuing

A recently reported comparison of stable RNA (rRNA, tRNA) and mRNA synthesis rates in ppGpp-synthesizing and ppGpp-deficient (delta relA delta spoT) bacteria has suggested that ppGpp inhibits transcription initiation from stable RNA promoters, as well as synthesis of (bulk) mRNA. Inhibition of stable RNA synthesis occurs mainly during slow growth of bacteria when cytoplasmic levels of ppGpp are high. In contrast, inhibition of mRNA occurs mainly during fast growth when ppGpp levels are low, and it is associated with a partial inactivation of RNA polymerase. To explain these observations it has been proposed that ppGpp causes transcriptional pausing and queuing during the synthesis of mRNA. Polymerase queuing requires high rates of transcription initiation in addition to polymerase pausing, and therefore high concentrations of free RNA polymerase. These conditions are found in fast growing bacteria. Furthermore, the RNA polymerase queues lead to a promoter blocking when RNA polymerase molecules stack up from the pause site back to the (mRNA) promoter. This occurs most frequently at pause sites close to the promoter. Blocking of mRNA promoters diverts RNA polymerase to stable RNA promoters. In this manner ppGpp could indirectly stimulate synthesis of stable RNA at high growth rates. In the present work a mathematical analysis, based on the theory of queuing, is presented and applied to the global control of transcription in bacteria. This model predicts the in vivo distribution of RNA polymerase over stable RNA and mRNA genes for both ppGpp-synthesizing and ppGpp-deficient bacteria in response to different environmental conditions. It also shows how small changes in basal ppGpp concentrations can produce large changes in the rate of stable RNA synthesis.

Control of the Escherichia coli rrnB P1 promoter strength by ppGpp

Fusions of the rrnB P1 and P2 promoters, and of the tandem P1-P2 combination, to a wild-type lacZ gene were constructed on plasmids and recombined into the mal region of the bacterial chromosome, close to the normal location and in the normal orientation of rrnB. The upstream activator region (Fis-binding sites) was always present with the P1 promoter, and all constructs contained the box A antitermination site of rRNA genes. Using these constructs, beta-galactosidase specific activities were measured in Escherichia coli strains carrying either both ppGpp synthetases, PSI and PSII (relA+ spoT+), or only PSII (delta relA spoT+), or neither (delta relA delta spoT), using different media supporting growth rates between 0.6 and 2.8 doublings/h at 37 degrees C. The beta-galactosidase activities were used to estimate the relative strength of the rrnB P1 promoter in comparison to the isolated rrnB P2 promoter. Promoter strength (transcripts initiated per min per promoter per free RNA polymerase concentration) was distinguished from promoter activity (transcripts initiated per min per promoter). In ppGpp-synthesizing (wild-type) bacteria, the relative strength of the rrnB P1 promoter increased nearly 10-fold with increasing growth rate from 0.17 to 1.5, but in the ppGpp-less double mutants it decreased by 20% from 1.7 to 1.5. Thus, at low or zero levels of ppGpp, the P1 promoter was 1.5-1.7 times stronger than the isolated P2 promoter. These results indicate that the normal growth rate control of the rrnB P1 promoter strength requires ppGpp, and that the strength is reduced at basal levels of ppGpp found during exponential growth. No additional ppGpp-independent control of the rrnB P1 promoter strength was evident. From the beta-galactosidase data and previously determined values of rRNA gene activities, the activities of the isolated rrnB P1 and P2 promoters, and of the P2 promoter in the tandem combination, were estimated. With increasing growth rate, the activity of the isolated P2 promoter increased 6-fold from 6 to 33 initiations/min, while the activity of the isolated P1 promoter increased 24-fold from 2 to 54 initiations/min. The increasing activity of the isolated P2 promoter is assumed to reflect the increasing RNA polymerase concentration at constant promoter strength, whereas the steeper increase in P1 promoter activity reflects increases in both polymerase concentration and promoter strength. When in tandem with P1, the P2 promoter activity is inferred to decrease as the P1 promoter activity increases.

Evaluation of the E. coli ribosomal rrnB P1 promoter and phage-derived lysis genes for the use in a biological containment system: a concept study

A concept study devised for the development of a biological containment system has been conducted. We show that the lysis genes of different phage origin function in a variety of bacteria. They may therefore be suited for conditional suicide cassettes. Moreover, we tested whether the Escherichia coli rrnB P1 promoter could function as an environmentally responsive element sensing poor growth conditions expected after an accidental release of E. coli production strains from a bioreactor. Mimicking poor nutrient conditions by production of the alarmone guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) with a plasmid encoded ppGpp synthetase I, the rrnB P1 promoter activity was completely turned off. These experiments suggested that the rrnB P1 promoter may be used as an efficient biosensor for altered growth conditions. A concept for a conditional suicide system employing the rrnB P1 promoter and phage-derived lysis genes as key components is discussed.