Minimal DNA requirement for topoisomerase II-mediated cleavage in vitro

Toward discovering new anti-cancer agents targeting topoisomerase IIα: a facile screening strategy adaptable to high throughput platform

Topoisomerases are a family of vital enzymes capable of resolving topological problems in DNA during various genetic processes. Topoisomerase poisons, blocking reunion of cleaved DNA strands and stabilizing enzyme-mediated DNA cleavage complex, are clinically important antineoplastic and anti-microbial agents. However, the rapid rise of drug resistance that impedes the therapeutic efficacy of these life-saving drugs makes the discovering of new lead compounds ever more urgent. We report here a facile high throughput screening system for agents targeting human topoisomerase IIα (Top2α). The assay is based on the measurement of fluorescence anisotropy of a 29 bp fluorophore-labeled oligonucleotide duplex. Since drug-stabilized Top2α-bound DNA has a higher anisotropy compared with free DNA, this assay can work if one can use a dissociating agent to specifically disrupt the enzyme/DNA binary complexes but not the drug-stabilized ternary complexes. Here we demonstrate that NaClO₄, a chaotropic agent, serves a critical role in our screening method to differentiate the drug-stabilized enzyme/DNA complexes from those that are not. With this strategy we screened a chemical library of 100,000 compounds and obtained 54 positive hits. We characterized three of them on this list and demonstrated their effects on the Top2α–mediated reactions. Our results suggest that this new screening strategy can be useful in discovering additional candidates of anti-cancer agents.

The use of divalent metal ions by type II topoisomerases

Type II topoisomerases are essential enzymes that regulate DNA under- and overwinding and remove knots and tangles from the genetic material. In order to carry out their critical physiological functions, these enzymes utilize a double-stranded DNA passage mechanism that requires them to generate a transient double-stranded break. Consequently, while necessary for cell survival, type II topoisomerases also have the capacity to fragment the genome. This feature of the prokaryotic and eukaryotic enzymes, respectively, is exploited to treat a variety of bacterial infections and cancers in humans. All type II topoisomerases require divalent metal ions for catalytic function. These metal ions function in two separate active sites and are necessary for the ATPase and DNA cleavage/ligation activities of the enzymes. ATPase activity is required for the strand passage process and utilizes the metal-dependent binding and hydrolysis of ATP to drive structural rearrangements in the protein. Both the DNA cleavage and ligation activities of type II topoisomerases require divalent metal ions and appear to utilize a novel variant of the canonical two-metal-ion phosphotransferase/hydrolase mechanism to facilitate these reactions. This article will focus primarily on eukaryotic type II topoisomerases and the roles of metal ions in the catalytic functions of these enzymes.

Analysis of the eukaryotic topoisomerase II DNA gate: a single-molecule FRET and structural perspective

Type II DNA topoisomerases (topos) are essential and ubiquitous enzymes that perform important intracellular roles in chromosome condensation and segregation, and in regulating DNA supercoiling. Eukaryotic topo II, a type II topoisomerase, is a homodimeric enzyme that solves topological entanglement problems by using the energy from ATP hydrolysis to pass one segment of DNA through another by way of a reversible, enzyme-bridged double-stranded break. This DNA break is linked to the protein by a phosphodiester bond between the active site tyrosine of each subunit and backbone phosphate of DNA. The opening and closing of the DNA gate, a critical step for strand passage during the catalytic cycle, is coupled to this enzymatic cleavage/religation of the backbone. This reversible DNA cleavage reaction is the target of a number of anticancer drugs, which can elicit DNA damage by affecting the cleavage/religation equilibrium. Because of its clinical importance, many studies have sought to determine the manner in which topo II interacts with DNA. Here we highlight recent single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer and crystallographic studies that have provided new insight into the dynamics and structure of the topo II DNA gate.

Hairpin structures formed by alpha satellite DNA of human centromeres are cleaved by human topoisomerase IIalpha

Although centromere function has been conserved through evolution, apparently no interspecies consensus DNA sequence exists. Instead, centromere DNA may be interconnected through the formation of certain DNA structures creating topological binding sites for centromeric proteins. DNA topoisomerase II is a protein, which is located at centromeres, and enzymatic topoisomerase II activity correlates with centromere activity in human cells. It is therefore possible that topoisomerase II recognizes and interacts with the alpha satellite DNA of human centromeres through an interaction with potential DNA structures formed solely at active centromeres. In the present study, human topoisomerase IIα-mediated cleavage at centromeric DNA sequences was examined in vitro. The investigation has revealed that the enzyme recognizes and cleaves a specific hairpin structure formed by alpha satellite DNA. The topoisomerase introduces a single-stranded break at the hairpin loop in a reaction, where DNA ligation is partly uncoupled from the cleavage reaction. A mutational analysis has revealed, which features of the hairpin are required for topoisomerease IIα-mediated cleavage. Based on this a model is discussed, where topoisomerase II interacts with two hairpins as a mediator of centromere cohesion.

Using 3'-bridging phosphorothiolates to isolate the forward DNA cleavage reaction of human topoisomerase IIalpha

The ability to cleave DNA is critical to the cellular and pharmacological functions of human type II topoisomerases. However, the low level of cleavage at equilibrium and the tight coupling of the cleavage and ligation reactions make it difficult to characterize the mechanism by which these enzymes cut DNA. Therefore, to establish a system that isolates topoisomerase II-mediated DNA scission from ligation, oligonucleotide substrates were developed that contained a 3'-bridging phosphorothiolate at the scissile bond. Scission of these substrates generates a 3'-terminal -SH moiety that is a poor nucleophile relative to the normal 3'-terminal -OH group. Consequently, topoisomerase II cannot efficiently ligate phosphorothiolate substrates once they are cleaved. The characteristics of topoisomerase IIalpha-mediated cleavage of phosphorothiolate oligonucleotides were identical to those seen with wild-type substrates, except that no ligation was observed. This unidirectional accumulation of cleavage complexes provided critical information regarding coordination of the protomer subunits of topoisomerase IIalpha and the mechanism of action of topoisomerase II poisons. Results indicate that the two enzyme subunits are partially coordinated and that cleavage at one scissile bond increases the degree of cleavage at the other. Furthermore, anticancer drugs such as etoposide and amsacrine that strongly inhibit topoisomerase II-mediated DNA ligation have little effect on the forward scission reaction. In contrast, abasic sites that increase levels of cleavage complexes without affecting ligation stimulate the forward rate of scission. Phosphorothiolate substrates provide significant advantages over traditional "suicide substrates" and should be valuable for future studies on DNA scission and the topoisomerase II-DNA cleavage complex.

Single-molecule measurements of the opening and closing of the DNA gate by eukaryotic topoisomerase II

Type II DNA topoisomerases are essential and ubiquitous enzymes that perform important functions in chromosome condensation and segregation and in regulating intracellular DNA supercoiling. Topoisomerases carry out these DNA transactions by passing one segment of DNA through the other by using a reversible, enzyme-bridged double strand break. The transient enzyme/DNA adduct is mediated by a phosphodiester bond between the active-site tyrosine and a backbone phosphate of DNA. The opening and closing of the DNA gate, a critical step for strand passage during the catalytic cycle, is coupled to this cleavage/religation. We designed a unique oligonucleotide substrate with a pair of fluorophores straddling the topoisomerase II cleavage site, allowing the use of FRET to monitor the opening of the DNA gate. The DNA substrate undergoes an enzyme-mediated transition between a closed and open state in the presence of ATP, similar to the overall topoisomerase II catalyzed reaction. Single-molecule fluorescence microscopy measurements demonstrate that the transition has comparable rate constants for both the opening and closing reaction during steady-state ATP hydrolysis, with an apparent equilibrium constant near unity. In the presence of AMPPNP, a reduction in FRET occurs, suggesting an opening or partial opening of the DNA gate. However, the single-molecule experiments indicate that the open and closed states do not interconvert at a measurable rate.

Topoisomerase action on short DNA duplexes reveals requirements for gate and transfer DNA segments

Type II topoisomerases change DNA topology by passage of one DNA duplex (the transfer, T-segment) through a transient double-stranded break in another (the gate, G-segment). Here we monitor the passage between short double-stranded DNA segments within long single-stranded DNA circles that leads to catenation of the circles. To facilitate catenation, the circles were brought into close proximity using a tethering oligonucleotide, which was removed after the reaction was complete. We varied the length and the composition of the reacting DNA segments. The minimal DNA duplex length at which we detected catenation was 50-60 bp for DNA gyrase and 40 bp for topoisomerase IV (Topo IV). For Topo IV, catenation was observed when one, but not both, of the DNA-DNA duplexes was replaced by a DNA-RNA duplex. Topo IV cleaved the DNA-DNA duplex, but not the DNA-RNA duplex implying that the DNA-RNA duplex can be a T-segment but not a G-segment.

Stimulated activity of human topoisomerases IIalpha and IIbeta on RNA-containing substrates

Eukaryotic topoisomerase II is a dimeric nuclear enzyme essential for DNA metabolism and chromosome dynamics. Central to the activities of the enzyme is its ability to introduce transient double-stranded breaks in the DNA helix, where the two subunits of the enzyme become covalently attached to the generated 5'-ends through phosphotyrosine linkages. Here, we demonstrate that human topoisomerases IIalpha and IIbeta are able to cleave ribonucleotide-containing substrates. With suicide substrates, which are partially double-stranded molecules containing a 5'-recessed strand, cleavage of both strands was stimulated approximately 8-fold when a ribonucleotide rather than a deoxyribonucleotide was present at the scissile phosphodiester of the recessed strand. The existence of a ribonucleotide at the same position in a normal duplex substrate also enhanced topoisomerase II-mediated cleavage, although to a lesser extent. The enzyme covalently linked to the 5'-ribonucleotide in the cleavage complex efficiently performed ligation, and ligation occurred equally well to acceptor molecules terminated by either a 3'-ribo- or deoxyribonucleotide. Besides the enhanced topoisomerase II-mediated cleavage of ribonucleotide-containing substrates, cleavage of such substrates could be further stimulated by ATP or antitumor drugs. In conclusion, the observed in vitro activities of the human topoisomerase II isoforms indicate that the enzymes can operate on RNA or RNA-containing substrates and thus might possess an intrinsic RNA topoisomerase activity, as has previously been demonstrated for Escherichia coli topoisomerase III.

In vitro evolution of preferred topoisomerase II DNA cleavage sites

Topoisomerase II is an essential enzyme that is the target for several clinically important anticancer drugs. Although this enzyme must create transient double-stranded breaks in the genetic material in order to carry out its indispensable DNA strand passage reaction, the factors that underlie its nucleotide cleavage specificity remain an enigma. Therefore, to address the critical issue of enzyme specificity, a modified systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) protocol was employed to select/evolve DNA sequences that were preferentially cleaved by Drosophila melanogaster topoisomerase II. Levels of DNA scission rose substantially (from 3 to 20%) over 20 rounds of SELEX. In vitro selection/evolution converged on an alternating purine/pyrmidine sequence that was highly AT-rich (TATATATACATATATATA). The preference for this sequence was more pronounced for Drosophila topoisomerase II over other species and was increased in the presence of DNA cleavage-enhancing anticancer drugs. Enhanced cleavage appeared to be based on higher rates of DNA scission rather than increased binding affinity or decreased religation rates. The preferred sequence for topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cleavage is dramatically overrepresented ( approximately 10,000-fold) in the euchromatic genome of D. melanogaster, implying that it may be a site for the physiological action of this enzyme.

Determination of 5' and 3' DNA triplex interference boundaries reveals the core DNA binding sequence for topoisomerase II

Previous studies have shown that formation of intermolecular DNA triplexes at sequences that overlap protein binding sites inhibits DNA binding by these proteins. We show that DNA cleavage by eukaryotic topoisomerase II is blocked by triplex formation at sites overlapping and adjacent to the triple binding site. To map precisely the boundaries of triplex interference, we constructed a vector containing enzyme binding sites of different lengths and flanked both 5' and 3' by DNA triplexes. We call this method Triplex Interference Mapping by Binding Element Replacement (TIMBER). Triplex regions within 3 bases 5' or 7 bases 3' of cleavage sites blocked DNA cleavage; triplex formation outside of this region had no effect upon cleavage activity. We conclude that topoisomerase II binding requires unhindered access to the major groove of a duplex DNA binding site in this 10-base region. In addition, the inclusion of topoisomerase II inhibitors yielded the same results for the triplex interference assays despite alterations in DNA cleavage site selection. The statistical analyses of over 500 topoisomerase II cleavage sites (in the presence or absence of inhibitors) suggest a model consistent with the region spanning -3 to +7 (relative to the cleavage site) containing most of the base-specific contacts for topoisomerase II. This triplex interference assay may prove valuable in the characterization of DNA binding sites for other proteins as well, particularly in conjunction with deletion analysis.

Influence of minor groove binders on the eukaryotic topoisomerase II cleavage reaction with 41 base pair model oligonucleotides

This report deals with the cleavage reaction of calf thymus (CT) topoisomerase II with oligonucleotides containing one main cleavage site and adjacent binding sites for minor groove binders. The sequences of the oligonucleotides were derived from a pBR 322 sequence, which contains one main topoisomerase II cleavage site. The cleavage reaction was performed under increasing concentrations of minor groove binders and it showed characteristic inhibition dependences of topoisomerase II to the binding sites and to the binding length of the minor groove binders. The extension of the minor groove binder length on DNA from 4 to 10 base pairs (bp) by netropsin and bis-netropsin, respectively, causes a strong increase of the topoisomerase II cleavage inhibition. The same is observed by the introduction of a second minor groove binder sequence symmetrically positioned around the topoisomerase II main cleavage site. The combination of two different minor groove binders can lead to an increased topoisomerase II inhibition but also to a prevention of total inhibition as shown with chromomycin A3 and distamycin A at concentrations of 0.1 and 0.25 microM, respectively.

Human 170 kDa and 180 kDa topoisomerases II bind preferentially to curved and left-handed linear DNA

The binding activities of the 170 kDa and the 180 kDa human topoisomerases II (topo II alpha and topo II beta) to linear DNA fragments with different degrees of curvature were characterized. In gel retardation experiments it was shown that both forms of the enzyme bind preferentially to a curved 287 bp fragment, forming a detectable stable complex. The affinity for straight DNA fragments of similar length is significantly lower. Both a commercially available topo II alpha, isolated from placenta, and topo II alpha and topo II beta purified from nuclear extracts of the Namalwa lymphoma tissue culture line gave similar results. The effects of double-stranded poly[d(A-T)], poly[d(G-C)], supercoiled plasmid DNA and linear Z-DNA on the topo II-complex with curved DNA were analyzed in competition experiments. The hierarchy of affinities of the 180 kDa topo II beta for these DNAs has the order: linear left-handed DNA > supercoiled DNA > or = curved DNA >> poly[d(A-T)] > poly[d(G-C)]. The 170 kDa topo II alpha binds with similar affinity to curved DNA and linear Z-DNA > or = supercoiled DNA >> linear B-DNA. The data imply that human topoisomerase II binding is more sensitive to DNA secondary structure than to DNA sequence per se. The ability of the enzyme to preferentially recognize a wide variety of sequences in unusual secondary structures suggests a mode of targeting the enzyme in vivo to regions of high negative supercoiling.

Deletion and duplication sequences induced in CHO cells by teniposide (VM-26), a topoisomerase II targeting drug, can be explained by the processing of DNA nicks produced by the drug-topoisomerase interaction

Frameshift mutations induced by acridines in bacteriophage T4 have been shown to be due to the ability of these mutagens to cause DNA cleavage by the type II topoisomerase of T4 and the subsequent processing of the 3' ends at DNA nicks by DNA polymerase or its associated 3' exonuclease followed by ligation of the processed end to the original 5' end. An analysis of the ability of nick-processing models is presented here to test the ability of nick processing to account for the DNA sequences of duplications and deletions induced in the aprt gene of CHO cells by teniposide (VM-26) [Han et al. (1993) J. Mol. Biol., 229, 52]. Although teniposide is not an acridine, it induces topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cutting in aprt sequences in vitro and mutagenesis in vivo. Although the previous study noted a correlation between mutation sites and nearby DNA discontinuities induced by the enzyme in vitro, neither the nick-processing model responsible for T4 mutations, nor double-strand break models alone were able to account for most of the mutant sequences. Thus, no single model explained the correlation between teniposide-induced DNA cleavage and mutagenic specificity. This report describes an expanded analysis of the ways that nick-processing models might be related to mutagenesis and demonstrates that a modified nick-processing model provides a biochemical rationale for the mutant specificities. The successful nick-processing model proposes that either 3' ends at nicks are elongated by DNA polymerase and/or that 5' ends of nicks are subject to nuclease activity; 3'-nuclease activity is not implicated. The mutagenesis model for nick-processing of teniposide-induced nicks in CHO cells when compared to the mechanism of nick-processing in bacteriophage T4 at acridine-induced nicks provides a framework for considering whether the differences may be due to cell-specific modes of DNA processing and/or due to the precise characteristics of topoisomerase-DNA intermediates created by teniposide or acridine that lead to mutagenesis.

Mode of action of topoisomerase II-targeting agents at a specific DNA sequence. Uncoupling the DNA binding, cleavage and religation events

Methods of uncoupling the DNA binding, cleavage and religation reactions of topoisomerase II were employed to investigate the influence of topoisomerase II-directed drugs on the individual steps in the enzyme's catalytic cycle. A special DNA substrate containing a major topoisomerase II interaction site, which can be cleaved by the enzyme in the absence of any concomitant religation, was used to examine the effect of topoisomerase II-directed agents upon the DNA cleavage reaction. The experiment demonstrated that the topoisomerase II targeting agent Ro 15-0216 stimulates the DNA cleavage reaction extensively, whereas the traditional topoisomerase II inhibitor, mAMSA, has only a minor effect on this reaction. Topoisomerase II trapped in the cleavage complexes can religate to the 3' hydroxyl end of another DNA strand. Using this religation assay, it was demonstrated that the major effect of mAMSA is an inhibition of the enzyme's religation reaction, whereas Ro 15-0216 has no effect on this reaction. Recently, considerable attention has been given to drugs preventing topoisomerase II from introducing DNA cleavages. In the present paper the initial non-covalent DNA binding reaction of topoisomerase II was investigated under conditions excluding enzyme-mediated DNA cleavage. This demonstrated that the anthracycline, aclarubicin, prevents topoisomerase II from performing its initial non-covalent DNA binding reaction and thereby abolishes the DNA cleavage reaction of the enzyme. The results presented here demonstrate that profound differences exist in the mode of action of different agents targeting topoisomerase II, and that the enzyme can be affected by such agents at both its DNA binding, cleavage and religation subreactions.

Catalytic function of DNA topoisomerase II

Although the genetic code is defined by a linear array of nucleotides, it is the three-dimensional structure of the double helix that regulates most of its cellular functions. Over the past two decades, it has become increasingly clear that aspects of this three-dimensionality which reflect topological relationships within the double helix (i.e., superhelical twisting, knotting, or tangling) influence virtually every facet of nucleic acid physiology. In vivo, DNA topology is modulated by ubiquitous enzymes known as topoisomerases. The type II enzyme is essential to the eukaryotic cell and is required for unlinking daughter chromosomes and maintaining chromosome structure. Moreover, topoisomerase II also has been identified as the primary cellular target for several widely used antineoplastic drugs. Before the physiological functions of topoisomerase II can be effectively dissected or its drug interactions fully exploited, it is imperative to understand the mechanism by which this important enzyme carries out its catalytic cycle.