Stimulation of lac Transcription by Guanosine 5′-Diphosphate 2′(or 3′)-Diphosphate and Transfer Ribonucleic Acid

Mechanism of regulation of transcription initiation by ppGpp. I. Effects of ppGpp on transcription initiation in vivo and in vitro

To determine the role of ppGpp in both negative and positive regulation of transcription initiation during exponential growth in Escherichia coli, we examined transcription in vivo and in vitro from the growth-rate-dependent rRNA promoter rrnB P1 and from the inversely growth-rate-dependent amino acid biosynthesis/transport promoters PargI, PhisG, PlysC, PpheA, PthrABC, and PlivJ. rrnB P1 promoter activity was slightly higher at all growth-rates in strains unable to synthesize ppGpp (deltarelAdeltaspoT) than in wild-type strains. Consistent with this observation and with the large decrease in rRNA transcription during the stringent response (when ppGpp levels are much higher), ppGpp inhibited transcription from rrnB P1 in vitro. In contrast, amino acid promoter activity was considerably lower in deltarelAdeltaspoT strains than in wild-type strains, but ppGpp had no effect on amino acid promoter activity in vitro. Detailed kinetic analysis in vitro indicated that open complexes at amino acid promoters formed much more slowly and were much longer-lived than rrnB P1 open complexes. ppGpp did not increase the rates of association with, or escape from, amino acid promoters in vitro, consistent with its failure to stimulate transcription directly. In contrast, ppGpp decreased the half-lives of open complexes at all promoters, whether the half-life was seconds (rrnB P1) or hours (amino acid promoters). The results described here and in the accompanying paper indicate that ppGpp directly inhibits transcription, but only from promoters like rrnB P1 that make short-lived open complexes. The results indicate that stimulation of amino acid promoters occurs indirectly. The accompanying paper evaluates potential models for positive control of amino acid promoters by ppGpp that might explain the requirement of ppGpp for amino acid prototrophy.

Mechanism of regulation of transcription initiation by ppGpp. II. Models for positive control based on properties of RNAP mutants and competition for RNAP

Strains containing ppGpp, a nucleotide whose synthesis is dependent on the RelA and SpoT proteins of Escherichia coli, display slightly lower rRNA promoter activity and much higher amino acid biosynthesis/transport promoter activity than deltarelAdeltaspoT strains. In the accompanying paper, we show that ppGpp directly inhibits rRNA promoter activity in vitro by decreasing the lifetime of the rrn P1 open complex. However, ppGpp does not stimulate amino acid promoter activity in vitro. We show here that RNA polymerase (RNAP) mutants, selected to confer prototrophy to deltarelAdeltaspoT strains, mimic the effects of ppGpp on wild-type RNAP. Based on the positions of the mutant residues that confer prototrophy in the structure of core RNAP, we suggest molecular models for how the mutants, and by analogy ppGpp, generally decrease the lifetime of open complexes. We show that amino acid promoters require higher concentrations of RNAP for function in vitro and in vivo than control promoters, and are more sensitive to competition for RNAP in vivo than control promoters. Furthermore, we show that the requirement of an amino acid promoter for ppGpp in vivo can be alleviated by increasing its rate-limiting RNAP-binding step. Our data are consistent with a previously proposed passive model in which ppGpp inhibits stable RNA synthesis directly by reducing the lifetime of the rrn P1 open complex, liberating enough RNAP to stimulate transcription from amino acid promoters. Our data also place considerable constraints on models invoking hypothetical factors that might increase amino acid promoter activity in a ppGpp-dependent fashion.

The study of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate-mediated transcription regulation in vitro using a coupled transcription-translation system

The effects of the "alarmone" guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp) on regulation of the Salmonella typhimurium histindine operon and the Escherichia coli tRNA(leu) operon were analyzed in vitro using a DNA-dependent transcription-translation system, S-30. The expression of the hisG promoter is positively regulated by ppGpp, whereas that of the leuV promoter (of tRNA(1eu)) is negatively regulated by ppGpp. In an attempt to understand the global regulatory mechanism of ppGpp control, interrelationship between ppGpp-dependent activation and repression of gene expression was examined using these promoters as models. It has been traditionally supposed that the ppGpp-dependent regulation, at least for the activation, is by a passive mode of control: the activation of gene expression by ppGpp is a consequence of the repression of stable RNA gene expression in the condition of RNA polymerase limiting. To test this model, the ppGpp-dependent regulations of both an activable promoter (hisGp) and a repressible promoter (leuVp) were determined in vitro simultaneously using a mixed template setup. The rationale for this exercise was to see whether the ppGpp-dependent activation and repression are inversely correlated in the in vitro condition in which RNA polymerase is limiting. No correlation was observed. It was concluded that the ppGpp-dependent activation is independent of the repression. Moreover, it was proposed that ppGpp-dependent activation and repression are mediated by titratable factors, each of which operate independently.

Effect of the RelA gene on the synthesis of individual proteins in vivo

We have shown that the relA gene can affect the rates of synthesis of many nonribosomal proteins in E. coli. We used rel+ and relA strains that contain a temperature-sensitive valyl tRNA synthetase. Upon transfer from a permissive temperature (30degreesC) to a semi-resitrictive one (36.5degreesC), these strains continue to grow, although undergoing a partial deprivation of valyl tRNA, In the rel+ strain, the concentration of ppGpp increases immediately, and the accumulation of RNA ceases abruptly but temporarily. In contrast, in the relA strain, the concentration of ppGpp falls, whereas the rate of accumulation of RNA increases. As judged by gel electrophoresis, the rates at which individual polypeptides are synthesized by the strains after their transfer to 36.5degreesC depend to a large extent upon the allelic state of the relA gene. In both strains, the concentration of ppGpp changes soon enough to have altered the synthesis of some of the proteins by affecting the transcription of their genes.

Specificity of the stimulation of in vitro ribonucleic acid synthesis by guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate

The in vitro synthesis of ribonucleic acid (RNA) by S-30 extracts of Escherichia coli K-12 is stimulated from two-to fourfold by 0.16 mM to 0.32 mM guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp) when either gammacI857St68h80 deoxyribonucleic acid (gammah80 DNA), gammah80dilv DNA or gammah80dlac DNA are employed as templates. Hybridization analysis of the 3H-RNA product transcribed from gammah80dilv DNA in the presence of ppGpp indicates that both bacteriophage- and bacterial-specific transcription is stimulated to an equivalent degree. In the absence of cyclic 3'-5'-adenosine monophosphate (cyclic AMP), correct lac-specifci RNA synthesis from gammah80dlac DNA is not stimulated by 0.32 mM ppGpp although total RNA synthesis is increased nearly twofold. In the presence of 0.5 mM cyclic AMP, correct lacspecific RNA synthesis is stimulated preferentially by ppGpp. These data suggest that ppGpp is capable of stimulating in vitro transcription in both a general and selective manner.