Stability of poliovirus RNA in cell-free translation systems utilizing two initiation sites

Involvement of a Nonstructural Protein in Poliovirus Capsid Assembly

Virus capsid proteins must perform a number of roles. These include self-assembly and maintaining stability under challenging environmental conditions, while retaining the conformational flexibility necessary to uncoat and deliver the viral genome into a host cell. Fulfilling these roles could place conflicting constraints on the innate abilities encoded within the protein sequences. In a previous study, we identified a number of mutations within the capsid-coding sequence of poliovirus (PV) that were established in the population during selection for greater thermostability by sequential treatment at progressively higher temperatures. Two mutations in the VP1 protein acquired at an early stage were maintained throughout this selection procedure. One of these mutations prevented virion assembly when introduced into a wild-type (wt) infectious clone. Here we show, by sequencing beyond the capsid-coding region of the heat-selected virions, that two mutations had arisen within the coding region of the 2A protease. Both mutations were maintained throughout the selection process. Introduction of these mutations into a wt infectious clone by site-directed mutagenesis considerably reduced replication. However, they permitted a low level of assembly of infectious virions containing the otherwise lethal mutation in VP1. The 2Apro mutations were further shown to slow the kinetics of viral polyprotein processing, and we suggest that this delay improves the correct folding of the mutant capsid precursor protein to permit virion assembly.IMPORTANCE RNA viruses, including poliovirus, evolve rapidly due to the error-prone nature of the polymerase enzymes involved in genome replication. Fixation of advantageous mutations may require the acquisition of complementary mutations which can act in concert to achieve a favorable phenotype. This study highlights a compensatory role of a nonstructural regulatory protein, 2Apro, for an otherwise lethal mutation of the structural VP1 protein to facilitate increased thermal resistance. Studying how viruses respond to selection pressures is important for understanding mechanisms which underpin emergence of resistance and could be applied to the future development of antiviral agents and vaccines.

The in vitro RNA synthesizing activity of the isolated arterivirus replication/transcription complex is dependent on a host factor

The cytoplasmic replication of positive-stranded RNA viruses is associated with characteristic, virus-induced membrane structures that are derived from host cell organelles. We used the prototype arterivirus, equine arteritis virus (EAV), to gain insight into the structure and function of the replication/transcription complex (RTC) of nidoviruses. RTCs were isolated from EAV-infected cells, and their activity was studied using a newly developed in vitro assay for viral RNA synthesis, which reproduced the synthesis of both viral genome and subgenomic mRNAs. A detailed characterization of this system and its reaction products is described. RTCs isolated from cytoplasmic extracts by differential centrifugation were inactive unless supplemented with a cytosolic host protein factor, which, according to subsequent size fractionation analysis, has a molecular mass in the range of 59-70 kDa. This host factor was found to be present in a wide variety of eukaryotes. Several EAV replicase subunits cosedimented with newly made viral RNA in a heavy membrane fraction that contained all RNA-dependent RNA polymerase activity. This fraction contained the characteristic double membrane vesicles (DMVs) that were previously implicated in EAV RNA synthesis and could be immunolabeled for EAV nonstructural proteins (nsps). Replicase subunits directly involved in viral RNA synthesis (nsp9 and nsp10) or DMV formation (nsp2 and nsp3) exclusively cosedimented with the active RTC. Subgenomic mRNAs appeared to be released from the complex, whereas newly made genomic RNA remained more tightly associated. Taken together, our data strongly support a link between DMVs and the RNA-synthesizing machinery of arteriviruses.

Rethinking some mechanisms invoked to explain translational regulation in eukaryotes

Real progress in understanding translational regulatory mechanisms lags behind the claims of progress. Novel mechanisms were proclaimed in recent months for some important regulatory proteins from Drosophila (e.g. Bruno, Sex-lethal, Reaper), but the evidence is thin. Many flaws in the design and interpretation of new experiments can be traced to older experiments which came to be accepted, not because the evidence was overwhelming, but because the ideas were appealing. Two of these classic examples of translational regulation are discussed before taking up the newer findings. One paradigm concerns regulation of 15-lipoxygenase production during reticulocyte maturation. The mechanism postulated for 15-lipoxygenase was pieced together in vitro and has never been linked in a meaningful way to what happens naturally in reticulocytes; nevertheless, these experiments have guided (or misguided) thinking about how sequences near the 3' end of an mRNA might regulate translation. The second paradigm concerns the regulation of cyclin B1 translation in Xenopus oocytes by a protein called Maskin, which purportedly interacts with initiation factors. A third topic discussed in some detail concerns the idea that in eukaryotes, as in prokaryotes, initiation of translation might involve base-pairing between mRNA and ribosomal RNA. Recent experiments undertaken to test this idea in yeast are far from conclusive. Many of the experimental defects brought to light in this review are simple-absence of controls, reliance on indirect tests, failure to test a new test system before using it; these things are fixable. Special problems are posed by the practice of using internal ribosome entry sequences (IRESs) as tools to figure out how translation might be regulated by other components. Unanswered questions about the IRESs themselves have to be resolved before they can be used confidently as tools.

Poliovirus translation initiation: differential effects of directed and selected mutations in the 5' noncoding region of viral RNAs

We have analyzed the translational defects of a number of mutations in the 5' noncoding region of poliovirus type 1 RNA. These mutations fall into three categories: (1) two mutations which resulted in temperature sensitive (ts) viruses, (2) the second-site mutations responsible for the reversion of the two ts viruses, and (3) mutations which were lethal to virus production. RNAs containing either of the ts mutations translated in vitro at levels significantly lower than wild-type levels. RNAs containing the respective second-site reversions had corrected these translational defects to levels corresponding to their viral growth potentials. Unlike in vitro translation of wild-type poliovirus RNA, translation of the RNAs which gave rise to ts mutant viruses was not stimulated by the addition of an S10 fraction from an uninfected HeLa cell extract to a rabbit reticulocyte lysate (RRL). In vitro translation of the mutant RNAs (corresponding to the ts viruses) in a RRL was stimulated by factors present in a ribosomal salt wash (RSW) from a HeLa extract, although the levels of stimulation were only half those seen for wild-type. These results suggest that the stimulatory factors present in the RSW have a decreased affinity for the mutant RNA templates but can, to some extent interact, with such RNAs if provided in high enough concentration. The in vitro translation of RNAs containing either of the lethal mutations was not stimulated by factors present in the S10 or the RSW. Taken together, our data suggest a correlation between the ability of a genetically altered RNA to respond to translation stimulatory factors in vitro and the ability of that mutation to be recovered in infectious virus. In addition, we have identified the in vivo-selected reversion of translational defects for two different ts viruses.

Translation deficiency of the Sabin type 3 poliovirus genome: association with an attenuating mutation C472----U

Previous studies have shown that the genome of Sabin type 3 poliovaccine strain (P3/Leon 12a1b) possesses a diminished translation efficiency as compared to genomes of closely related neurovirulent strains, the neurovirulent progenitor (P3/Leon/37), or a revertant (P3/119/70) of the vaccine (Y.V. Svitkin, S.V. Maslova, and V.I. Agol, 1985, Virology 147, 243-252). Here we attempted to evaluate the contribution of each mutation in the genome of the vaccine to this translation deficiency. Recombinants between P3/Leon 12a1b and P3/Leon/37 or P3/119/70 were constructed in vitro and their RNAs were translated in a cell-free system derived from Krebs-2 cells. The results show that of 10 nucleotide differences between the genomes of P3/Leon 12a1b and P3/Leon/37 9 have minor or no effect on translation and that the only mutation of significance is C472----U which is known to reduce the neurovirulence of the virus. Reversion from uridine to cytosine at position 472 in type 3 poliovaccine upon replication in the human gut resulted in an increase of both translation efficiency of polio RNAs and neurovirulence of corresponding strains. The data provide evidence for a common nucleotide sequence regulatory element for protein synthesis of the virus and its neurovirulence. In vitro translation assays may therefore prove to be useful for detection of attenuating mutations in the 5' noncoding region of poliovirus genome. The apparent involvement of the translation mechanism in the expression of neurovirulent or attenuated phenotype of poliovirus is briefly discussed.

Modulation of the expression of poliovirus proteins in reticulocyte lysates

The translation of poliovirus RNA into specific viral proteins in mRNA-dependent reticulocyte lysates (MDLs) was found to be highly dependent on individual lysate preparations. Under optimal conditions, the first polypeptide detected was always P3-1b (formerly NCVP 1b), the product of the 3' portion of the poliovirus genome; the formation of P1-1a (formerly NCVP 1a) followed as shown by time-course and pulse-chase experiments. However, some lysates synthesized little or no P1-1a despite their ability to synthesize P3-1b and to translate normally other cellular and viral mRNAs. When an MDL competent in synthesizing P1-1a was diluted ca. twofold, while maintaining optimal concentrations of salts, tRNA, DTT, creatine phosphate, and amino acids, P1-1a formation was virtually eliminated, while the synthesis of P3-1b, presumably as a consequence of a more downstream initiation, was maintained. The synthesis of P1-1a in a diluted MDL was restored, and P3-1b synthesis suppressed, by the addition of a S10 fraction prepared from uninfected or virus-infected HeLa cells. Nuclease treatment and dialysis of the S10 fraction did not inhibit its activity. These findings indicate that individual MDLs either possess limiting quantities of, or occasionally are deficient in, a factor(s) that promotes the utilization of the presumed 5' proximal initiation site (the AUG at nucleotide position 781-783) and that a homologous factor(s) exists in HeLa cells. The implication of these findings for the strategy of poliovirus replication is discussed.

In vitro translation of poliovirus RNA: utilization of internal initiation sites in reticulocyte lysate

The translation of poliovirus RNA in rabbit reticulocyte lysate was examined. Translation of poliovirus RNA in this cell-free system resulted in an electrophoretic profile of poliovirus-specific proteins distinct from that observed in vivo or after translation in poliovirus-infected HeLa cell extract. A group of proteins derived from the P3 region of the polyprotein was identified by immunoprecipitation, time course, and N-formyl-[35S]methionine labeling studies to be the product of the initiation of protein synthesis at an internal site(s) located within the 3'-proximal RNA sequences. Utilization of this internal initiation site(s) on poliovirus RNA was abolished when reticulocyte lysate was supplemented with poliovirus-infected HeLa cell extract. Authentic P1-1a was also synthesized in reticulocyte lysate, indicating that correct 5'-proximal initiation of translation occurs in that system. We conclude that the deficiency of a component(s) of the reticulocyte lysate necessary for 5'-proximal initiation of poliovirus protein synthesis resulted in the ability of ribosomes to initiate translation on internal sequences. This aberrant initiation could be corrected by factors present in the HeLa cell extract. Apparently, under certain conditions, ribosomes are capable of recognizing internal sequences as authentic initiation sites.